Mike Maples, Jr. - A Playbook for Startups - [Founder’s Field Guide, EP. 48]
What this covers
Host Patrick talks with Mike Maples, co-founder of Floodgate, in what works as a working manual for founders. Maples lays out a Breakthrough Sequence. It starts with insight development, using backcasting to find a secret about the future. Founders then iterate toward product-market fit through customer development, and only after that turn to growth hacking. He likens the stages to a phase change from gas to liquid to solid, each needing a different team and operating mode. Corporations are marching bands; startup teams are jazz bands.
The examples cover a lot of ground. Brian Chesky listing his apartment on Craigslist stands in for an earned secret. Evan Williams pitched Twttr with no roadmap or revenue model. Clarence Birdseye had to build the freezer aisle and the cold supply chain around frozen food, and the Tesla Roadster is offered as a minimum viable future that people bought for reasons other than being objectively better. Kodak's collapse illustrates an inflection, and AI is described as making predictions cheap. Maples also explains why Justin.TV and Lyft could pivot so far from their first ideas: the underlying insight can survive a wrong product.
The tactical advice is blunt. Pitch with two slides, the second being your secret, and end the meeting if the investor disagrees. Be wary when most VCs like a pitch. Use Going for the No to find desperate customers, and choose early customers for fitness to the future rather than waiting for them to appear. Maples treats risk as pursuit of unbounded upside, and the forecasts that private tech funding will explode and that scalable startups will define the economy are the most contestable claims.
Maples argues that breakthrough startups succeed by creating a forced choice around a secret about the future, built on inflections, a team that can move people to that future, and a willingness to be disliked, rather than by offering incremental improvements or predicting the future.
- Startups must offer a different future rather than an incrementally better version of the status quo, because buyers cannot reconcile an apple and a banana
- Inflections, not predictions, are the source of breakthrough insights, and Floodgate's exit value comes largely from pivots that were right about the insight
- Early customers and early team should be chosen for fitness to the future being built, and founders must shift from zero-to-one improvisation to one-to-X repeatable growth
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Airbnb's earned secret was that Brian Chesky, short of money, put his apartment on Craigslist during a conference and noticed the demand, then reasoned that hotels work on trust and that ratings and photographs could build trust in strangers' homes.
“Brian didn't have much money, wanted to go to a conference in town, put up his apartment and and air mattress on Craigslist”
Clarence Birdseye created the frozen food category not by just inventing a freezing process but by convincing supermarkets to add freezer aisles, transport networks to carry frozen cargo, and inventing freezing and packaging mechanisms.
“He had to convince supermarkets to have a frozen food aisle, freezers in their aisles.”
The hardest recurring difficulty in venture investing is startup failure, where the margin between glory and abject failure is thin, and founders who spent five to ten years on an idea that could not be big enough suffer deeply, while breakthroughs are rare and investors will be wrong as often as right.
“the number one hardship is true breakthroughs are a rare event, and no matter how good you are at picking, you're going to be wrong just as often, if not more often, than right.”
Digital camera fidelity per dollar improved exponentially under a Moore's-law-like dynamic until it was good enough to substitute for film, leaving Kodak unable to reconcile film purchases with smartphone snapshots, which illustrates how an inflection displaces an incumbent.
“the amount of megapixels per dollar and the depth per pixel just kept exponentially improving to a point where now all of a sudden it was better than good enough”
Maples expects the amount of private money going into tech startups before exit to explode, because if the stock market is about 30 trillion dollars and may reach 60 trillion in ten years, the value creation will increasingly come from big tech incumbents and future startups that investors want to own privately.
“I do think that private dollars available to startups are going to radically increase”
The economy is shifting from mass production, mass distribution, and electricity to mass computation, mass connectivity, and algorithms and code, so scalable startups are becoming the defining force in the economy, as seen with Amazon, Tesla, and SpaceX.
“we're shifting from mass production, mass distribution, and electricity animating the economy to mass computation, mass connectivity, and algorithms and code”
Evan Williams proposed Twttr, a micro-blogging service with no roadmap or revenue model, reasoning that if millions wrote blogs and 10 million would write micro-blogs, the burden of proof would shift to skeptics; Maples invested as soon as they took money for it.
“And if 10 million people wrote micro blogs, I think that the burden of proof would be on the people who are negative.”
The value hypothesis asks what a team can uniquely build that people are desperate for, and if people will be desperate for it at scale in the future, the team has an opportunity; the concept draws on Steve Blank and Eric Ries.
“The value hypothesis is a simple question, which is what can we uniquely build that people are desperate for?”
Startup markets do not exist like company markets that can be segmented and sized; a startup market starts at zero, a movement gathers and accelerates, and the market emerges from the movement capturing conventional wisdom.
“A startup market starts at zero and then a movement gathers and the movement accelerates and the market emerges from the movement.”
Maples's early sales tactic, going for the no, involved signaling he would leave a sales meeting so that buyers who genuinely needed the software would pull him back, identifying customers desperate for a solution rather than polite interest.
“I used to do this as an entrepreneur, I called it, 'Going for the no.'”
Category design is not choosing a label such as CRM or ERP but mapping the minimum viable future: all elements the entrepreneur must assemble, the early movers who will adopt it, and what it takes to move them.
“category design is understanding what is that minimum viable future? What are all of the elements of that minimum viable future”
If most VCs like a pitch, Maples becomes worried that it is not controversial enough to be a breakthrough.
“I say, 'If most VCs like it, now I'm worried because it's not controversial enough.'”
A startup starts out dead and must prove it is alive, so it should hire people to take out the most important risks as soon as possible, because if the biggest risk cannot be crushed the company will fail anyway, and if it can be crushed the value created is maximal.
“you want to hire people to take out the most important risks as soon as possible.”
Many founders skip insight development, the first step in a breakthrough sequence, which uses backcasting to identify a secret that leads to a different future; only after that do founders iterate the insight to product-market fit through customer development and then pursue growth hacking.
“And this is the step that a lot of people skip. I call it insight development. In insight development, you use a technique We call backcasting to identify a secret”
Most inflections turn something formerly scarce and expensive into something cheap and abundant, and AI's effect is to make previously difficult and expensive predictions available at commodity prices and distribution.
“most inflections take something that usually in the past was scarce and expensive, and they turn it into something cheap and abundant.”
A VC does not need to know where a trend will go; the job is to recognize a valid insight and distinguish it from an invalid one, which removes the need to predict the future.
“I have the opportunity to not have to know where it's going to go. I just have to have the ability to recognize a valid insight and distinguish it from an insight that's not so valid.”
Taking an early risk that leads to a wrong first product still gives founders a first-mover advantage in the future, because the insight may still be right or need only a 30-degree tweak, and the market learning makes their next pursuit better informed.
“your first product instantiation of the idea may be wrong, but the insight might still be right, or the insight might just need to be tweaked 30 degrees.”
The breakthrough sequence of insight, product, and growth is like a phase change from gas to liquid to solid, so the startup must change its operating mode, team, and value creation at each transition.
“it's almost like you transition from being a gas to a liquid to a solid. You are literally becoming something different when you go from one phase to the next”
Breakthrough founders need co-conspirators more than investors: people who believe the controversial secret, help create the movement and ecosystem, and prioritize product features that flow from the insight rather than conventional customer requests.
“those founders don't need investors. They need co-conspirators, and they need people who believe the secret that they believe”
The first Tesla Roadster was not objectively better than a BMW convertible, yet people bought it for aesthetic reasons because it demonstrated a minimum viable future, and early believers paid to be first in that movement.
“They bought it because it did enough to show minimum viable future, and early believers in that future were willing to part with their money”
Founders should pitch with two slides: first, a simple statement of what they do said as if to a three-year-old; second, their secret about the future, and if the investor disagrees with the secret they should end the meeting, because the rest of the pitch will not make sense without agreement.
“Slide one is, here's what we do. Say it like I'm a three-year-old, like I know nothing.”
When selling early, go for the no: a prospect who is desperate to solve a problem with no alternative, such as a cable operator facing a 3 million subscriber commitment, is more valuable than a prospect who can wait on a roadmap.
“I used to do this as an entrepreneur, I called it, Going for the no.”
Companies such as Justin.tv, Twitter, and Lyft pivoted from original ideas because their founders were the right kind of crazy, and Maples invested based on the insight behind the idea rather than the initial product.
“I told Justin to his face, I think this idea is stupid, but I love the insight that live video on the internet is going to be a thing”
Most people prefer an 80% chance of 5X over a 20% chance of 50X because they treat risk as avoiding failure, but Maples treats risk as something to take in pursuit of an unbounded upside, with each seed round purchasing the chance to decide on an all-in bet.
“But I like to think of risk as something you take. Taking risks means, out there is an unbounded upside opportunity.”
Secrets about the future fall into three types, plausible, possible, and preposterous, and the type determines the team needed, the hiring, the fundraising strategy, the risk profile, and how many inflections must converge.
“some secrets are plausible, some are possible, and some are preposterous, all different types of insights.”
Corporations operate like marching bands with sheet music, dance steps, OKRs, and functional org charts, while startup teams operate like jazz bands that improvise together and do not treat themselves as a traditional team.
“a corporation is like a marching band. They need dance steps, and they need sheet music”
Instead of letting customers find the company, founders should pick customers based on their fitness to the future they are designing and convince them to move, tracking a list of target customers in board meetings and focusing time on them.
“we're not going to try to convince customers to find us and buy from us. We're going to pick our customers based on their fitness to the different future we're designing.”
Maples passed on Airbnb because he failed to extract Brian Chesky's earned secret, the trust-based insight from the early air-mattress experiment, and he now treats passed deals as his own failure to see insight, so he re-interviews founders to uncover the secret.
“Airbnb, which I passed on, I failed to tease out Brian Chesky's earned secret.”
Moving from one-to-X growth requires founders to stop acting like MacGyver or James Bond and instead copy repeatable patterns, adding people and sheet music; founders who do not make this forward pivot often falter after a big venture round.
“one to X is really hard for some founders to transition to because all the stuff that got you to this point isn't going to get you to the next point.”
About 90% of Floodgate's exit profits have come from pivots, so the firm values the potential energy of an insight and the market it leads to rather than the company's current business or actualized market.
“but 90% of our exit profits have come from pivots.”
Floodgate has built about three awesome people networks of super founders and builders who receive the firm's insight frameworks and emotional preparation, and ideally receive checks without pitching other investors, because the firm avoids speed-dating and term-sheet auctions.
“we've created what we affectionately refer to as awesome people networks. Right now we have about three different ones.”
Investors who back demonstrable progress face heavy competition, but investing in insights faces less competition because founders cannot fully explain what the business will become.
“Surprisingly I find when you invest in insights, you don't have as much competition as most people would think, because you can't explain what the business will be.”
Founders should ask whether they want to work with a specific investor for years before collecting term sheets, because a brief pitch round forces a choice between a long-term partner and a term-sheet auction.
“why do you need to go pitch 10 people? Because you're going to get to know them at best for all two hours”
Floodgate has made two kinds of mistakes: falling in love with a powerful inflection-based idea and overlooking a weak team, or admiring a strong team that cannot articulate inflections and thus executes toward a local maximum with an okay but not great outcome.
“I'd say the reverse mistake we've made is the team just seems awesome, and we just can't look past the fact that they didn't articulate good inflections”
Innovative early customers living in the different future act as bellwethers for other customers, so word of mouth spreads, and if they are all your customers, you become predestined to achieve leading share and category leadership.
“they tend to be bellwethers for other customers. Word of mouth spreads that, 'Oh, this is a new thing that's happening.'”
When a startup fails, investors should avoid blaming the founder's capabilities and instead frame the outcome as an invalid experiment, because the idea or timing was wrong, which preserves the founder's confidence to change the future again.
“It's not you that failed. It's the experiment that turned out untrue.”
Inflections such as the falling cost of genome sequencing or AI prediction are an asymmetric weapon that lets an entrepreneur attack an incumbent's present, much as a surfer relies on a wave that the surfer does not generate but must ride.
“all of these things are like the asymmetric weapon that allows the entrepreneur to wage asymmetric warfare on the presence.”
Entrepreneurs who will create breakthrough startups must change the subject, and tiny resource-constrained teams need a force multiplier bigger than themselves, which comes from following inflections.
“Entrepreneurs who are going to create breakthrough startups, they have to change the subject.”
The risk a startup faces determines the hire: a legislation risk needs someone who can directly impact it, a technical risk like rocketry needs top aerospace engineers, and a market or distribution risk for a social network needs a go-to-market expert.
“If the risk is, can we build it in the first place? Like with SpaceX”
Value hacking in zero-to-one product creation resembles improvisation like MacGyver, while growth hacking in one-to-X scaling requires copying a repeatable pattern and instrumenting growth economics like a scientist on Mars.
“value hacking and the early days of product market fit, it's like Earth and growth hacking is like Mars.”
A scalable startup has only one opportunity to succeed, and it succeeds only if it offers people a choice of a different future, because people do not move for incrementally better products and an incumbent-like offering leaves no room to believe the startup can do a better job than a large incumbent.
“People don't want something incrementally better from a startup, because human beings are conditioned to like things.”
When stress testing a team's insight, first ask what change events the team is riding and whether each is a mini inflection, such as a new API release, or a sea-change inflection, such as COVID making telemedicine mainstream.
“Are they little miniature, mini inflections? Like Stripe just launched a new API call last week. Or is it a sea change type of inflection?”
The most valuable help Floodgate offers founders is its insight development frameworks for stress testing ideas, combined with emotional preparation for the rejection and negative press that breakthrough builders face.
“we try to give them our insight development frameworks so they can stress test their ideas.”
Founders should not think of a startup when seeking a great idea, because that orients them toward gaps in today's markets and pain of current customers; instead they should time-travel out of the present using inflections as their secret weapon.
“if you want to have a great startup idea, don't think of a startup. And the reason is that if you think of a startup, you're going to orient yourself in the present.”
At Maples' prior company, the board tracked 30 chosen target customers, aimed to win 10, and ended up winning 12 by spending all effort on those 30 and ignoring other prospects.
“we chose for this year, of which we want to get 10. We wouldn't even talk to any other customers.”
Two markers signal apple-quality opportunities: inflections, which are sea changes that create breakthrough secrets about the future, and teams that assemble in a collaborative structure unlike a typical corporate organization.
“So I'd say that there's really two markers. At a high level, the markers are inflections, which lead to breakthrough secrets about the future.”
Vinod Khosla holds that failure does not matter, only success does, provided the magnitude of the upside is big enough to justify the pursuit.
“Vinod likes to say, failure doesn't matter, only success matters, as long as you're pursuing ideas where the magnitude of the upside is big enough.”
Lyft exemplified an inflection: GPS locators were bundled into smartphones and smartphone adoption was expected to rise from 10% to over 50%, so combining these inflections made it possible to envision Airbnb-style sharing applied to cars.
“GPS locators got bundled in with smartphones. And so another inflection was that smartphone adoption, we believed was going to go from 10% to greater than 50%.”
Founders who follow inflections and develop intuition about unbounded-upside futures must be backed on two counts: the quality of their secret and their team's talent, wherewithal, and grit to make it real.
“I have to bet that the team has the talent and the wherewithal and the grit to make it real.”
Once a company achieves product-market fit, it should build instrumented growth accounting across product, marketing, sales, and upsell economics so it can reliably hit discrete growth objectives.
“we need an instrument those things so that we can guarantee that we'll achieve a very discreet growth objective.”
Bruce Dunlevie encouraged Maples to pitch limited partners for his seed fund idea, and his phone introduction to Phil Horsley of Horsley Bridge led to an investment in Floodgate's second fund, with Horsley among the first believers in seed funds.
“he calls Phil Horsley at Horsley Bridge, probably one of the best known fund of funds on the planet.”
True breakthroughs make people uncomfortable, so the reckless optimism Maples practices means embracing discomfort, while still informing bets with inflections and possible futures rather than taking wild swings blindly.
“true breakthroughs just make people uncomfortable. They have an element of getting out of your comfort zone that you have to embrace.”
When people analogize a new company to many unrelated existing companies, scrambling to fit it into categories, that pattern is a litmus test that the company is creating a genuinely new category.
“the company that they choose to analogize it are all very different from each other.”
Founders should not seek to win over every investor or customer, because being disliked by conventional thinkers is a feature of breakthrough work, not a bug.
“I don't need everybody to like this idea. In fact, it's a feature, not a bug.”
A breakthrough startup should be judged by whether every person who values the advantage of its offering flocks to it, because a choice is only forced when people who cannot reconcile the two offerings must pick one.
“The set of people who value the advantage of apples, a hundred percent of them should flock to your apple.”
Knowing a secret about the future is not enough; a breakthrough requires a team with complementary specialists who take out critical risks, much like a heist crew, and who are willing to disrupt people's comfort to sell them a radically different future.
“It's not enough that you just know that there's money in the Bellagio safe, you have to rob it.”
The growth breakthrough aims at winner-take-all global hegemony in a category of the future and seeks to penetrate it as rapidly as possible.
“what would it look like to achieve winner-take-all, total global hegemony in this category of the future”
After Maples totaled his mother's station wagon in a crash while learning to drive, his father immediately gave him the keys to his one-month-old Mercedes, conveying trust that had a lasting impact.
“So I had to learn how to drive in my dad's one month old Mercedes.”
When Maples asks founders to identify the inflections driving their radically different future, many say the framework is obvious, then fail to name inflections, implying their business is not a breakthrough.
“And a lot of times they'll say, 'Let me get back to you on that.'”
A product breakthrough is recognized when customers demand features faster than the team can build them, so the team is constantly laying track in front of the train while customers argue over features.
“You know when you've got this product breakthrough, when you just feel like you're in a constant state of laying tracks in front of the train”
A founder who arrives with cereal boxes instead of slides and a failed product demo shows how a presentation can hide a strong secret, which investors must still see through.
“he comes to the meeting, he's got cereal boxes, Obama O's and Cap'n McCain Crunch.”
Maples told Justin Kan that he thought the idea was stupid but liked the insight that live internet video would become a thing and would improve with CDNs, and he invested because the founders were the right kind of crazy.
“I think this idea is stupid, but I love the insight that live video on the internet is going to be a thing”
Once a founder decides to move from product-first to growth-first, the decision must be all in, emotionally, strategically, and intellectually, with no looking back, since partial commitment is like a Hertz car's tires exploding when driven backward.
“you have to be all in on going forward, it's like making a forward pivot.”
Lyft began as Zimride, a transportation network for colleges and corporations, but its one-page summary later revealed the larger insight of Airbnb for cars, showing how an early business description can hide the real insight.
“When we invested in Lyft, it started out as Zimride.”
Founders often underestimate their ability to influence the odds of high-risk, high-upside opportunities, because the learning from early market interaction can improve execution toward the real opportunity.
“what often happens is that founders even underestimate their ability to impact the odds of the high risk, high and bounded upside opportunities.”
Floodgate focuses on identifying the mental models that help one recognize what makes a great insight, in the spirit of how Buffett and Munger studied the nature of scalable companies.
“what are the mental models that help you identify what makes a great insight?”
When a great founder's presentation is bad and the investor passes, the investor is at fault, not the founder, because the investor's job is to have better radar for insights and secrets.
“My job is to have a better radar for these insights and secrets. And so it was my failure, not his.”
Maples is currently watching crypto, synthetic biology, AI applied to life sciences, and carbon capture as inflections that could meaningfully change humanity's future, and he finds the commoditization of AI software especially significant for normal startups.
“I'm paying a lot of attention to crypto. I'm paying a lot of attention to synthetic biology or AI applied to... Carbon capture”
A lot of founders receive advice that is conventional, which does not accelerate their path to a breakthrough.
“a lot of founders get a lot of advice, but a lot of the advice is conventional advice. It's not advice that accelerates your path to a breakthrough.”
Todd McKinnon at Okta excelled at the founder-to-growth-executive transition by hiring Adam Aarons as CRO to run sales, and Aarons's recruiting skill filled the slots needed for a predictable growth machine.
“he hired this guy to run sales, their CRO at the time, Adam Aarons, who is a stud.”
Maples's early experience taking apart a Radio Shack calculator with his father, and his later exposure to the IBM PC, shaped his view of technology's leverage and abundance and led him to see computing as a child of the PC revolution.
“And so my dad and I took it apart, and he got a bunch of wires and soldering irons”
Business has two fundamental fields animating the economy: scalable corporations and scalable startups.
“there's two fundamental fields of business that are animating the economy. There are scalable corporations, and then there are scalable startups.”
If founders were asked which stress test Floodgate provided was most useful, they would likely cite its inflection analysis and its startup category design, which Maples believes are next level compared to most investors.
“our understanding of inflections and startup category design are next level compared to most people.”
Patrick's summary that a startup should extrapolate Moore's law five years out and build for that future is essentially right, though Maples emphasized the skill of recognizing valid insights.
“Is that a fair summary of this insight searching?”