Michael Simanovsky - A Platform Approach to Real Estate - [Invest Like the Best, EP.344]
What this covers
Patrick O'Shaughnessy talks with Michael Simanovsky, founder of Conversant Capital, a firm that invests across public and private real estate, in equity and credit, and incubates platforms around themes. The conversation moves from how the capital cycle applies to property into how he built his firm, where investors go wrong, and his best and worst decisions. A recurring point is that "real estate" only signals a hard asset. Senior living, data centers, malls, offices, cold storage and ground leases are separate ecosystems, each needing its own read.
The sector tour is specific. On offices, he argues remote work accelerated trends already underway, and that New York's post-crisis absorption came almost entirely from tech users, a claim that invites pushback. Cold storage is framed as resilient and consolidated, and AI-driven data center demand is forecast to rival the public cloud wave. On housing, he uses renter demographics to argue families lack large, amenitized rental options, which is the gap build-to-rent targets. He also covers shrinking regional bank lending, the deleveraged public REITs, and a forecast that supply could improve in 2026 through 2028. The publisher's notes also flag an unexpected enthusiasm for billboards.
The closing stretch is more reflective. He says every institutional asset class, from cell towers to single-family rental, emerged from a crisis, and that the worst mistakes come from forgetting stacked leverage. In public markets he prefers improving returns to high static ones, and he explains his failed 2015 Macy's position. He ends with the question he thinks LPs should keep asking managers.
Simanovsky argues real estate should be analyzed through the capital cycle, using supply trends first, then demand and capital structure, and that the 2023 downturn is a 're-equitization' that creates opportunities for a flexible, platform-based investor.
- Supply declines and capital flight at the bottom of the cycle signal the best entry points, while peak optimism signals danger
- Real estate is a commodity-style sector whose returns are amplified by cyclicality, operating leverage and financial leverage
- Platform incubation with a strong management team lets an investor capture themes that have no existing business model
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The average US renter is about 39, the 35-to-49 single-family cohort grows about twice as fast as population through the end of the 2030s, and 88% of multifamily units are studios or one- or two-bedroom units, leaving families without a large amenitized rental option.
“88% of all multifamily is studios, 1 or 2 bedrooms”
High valuations attract new supply, rising competition eventually drives returns below the cost of capital, consolidation follows, and the cycle bottoms when investors are maximally pessimistic, so the capital cycle is a useful lens for real estate because it is largely a commodity-style sector.
“high valuation of businesses or assets encourage a supply side response as new entrants to the space become excited about the prospect of high returns”
The best time to enter a space is when the supply picture is improving, because returns recover above the cost of capital after competition and consolidation have cleared out capacity, while peak optimism with long duration assumptions is the worst time.
“that, to me, is the best time to think about entering the space, which is an improving supply side picture causes returns to return to a point in excess of the required cost of capital”
Real estate combines cyclicality, operating leverage from fixed-cost assets, and financial leverage from debt financing, so these overlapping effects make the asset class highly sensitive to the cost of capital and amplify downturns.
“you can have cyclicality overlapping with operating leverage overlapping with financial leverage”
At the peak of the capital cycle investors are most optimistic and extend their investment duration to reach required returns, while at the bottom they are maximally pessimistic and demand the shortest possible duration, which is why the bottom is the opportunity.
“at the peak of the capital cycle, investors tend to be the most optimistic and they extend their duration”
The biggest real estate investor mistakes happen when people forget cyclicality, especially when high valuations and high financial leverage were used to justify a target equity return that cannot survive a downturn.
“the biggest mistakes occur when people forget about the cyclicality. It's sort of exacerbated rather by the financial leverage and operating leverage”
In New York City, more than 100 percent of incremental office absorption from the GFC through COVID came from tech or tech-related users, including WeWork, which grew from nothing to several million square feet, meaning the office market depends on one sector.
“over 100% of the incremental absorption from the GFC through the COVID time period was related to tech or tech-related users”
Cold storage demand is resilient because people need to eat whether at home or out, consolidation among the top two US operators, which control roughly 50 to 60 percent of the market, improved contract structures, and revenue fell little during the GFC.
“Cold storage doesn't care if you eat out or eat at home, they just care that you eat”
Many real estate billionaires were built by tax efficiency and long holding periods, since owning assets through the 1990s, 2000s, and 2010s gave owners the ability to withstand volatility and duration, which became a massive competitive advantage.
“there is a ton of tax efficiency in owning real estate and owning it for a long, long periods of time”
Remote work did not cause office weakness; it accelerated trends already underway, since office oversupply in central business districts and suburbs and the inflow of tech demand that ended around 2017 were already reshaping the market.
“work from home simply expedited the fundamentals that were already prevailing”
Public REITs spent the last 12 to 13 years deleveraging, most now sit below 40 percent loan-to-value, and they are the best capitalized real estate owners with bond market access, so the best REIT allocators may earn premium valuations to play offense as fundamentals turn up.
“most REITs have sub 40% loan-to-value based on the implied valuation in the public market”
A significant pullback in capital availability for housing after the GFC created much of the home price appreciation seen since, and the capital cycle logic suggests that no two crises are ever the same.
“you had a significant pullback in capital availability of housing, which is I think, in some ways, created the home price appreciation that we see”
Real estate is not one thing; it comprises many sub-ecosystems such as senior living, data centers, malls, offices, cold storage, and ground leases, and the term real estate merely signals a hard asset while the real opportunity lies in the subtext of each subsector.
“there's something called real estate isn't actually the case. There's so many different sub ecosystems”
Because no new development capital is available today, the supply picture could improve substantially in 2026, 2027, and 2028, creating a better setup for investments made in the current downturn.
“there's no new development capital available today. So when you look into '26 and '27 and '28, the supply picture could get a lot better”
Real estate is highly scalable because ownership is fragmented: Prologis, the largest REIT with about a $115 billion market cap, controls only about 5 percent of US stock after 30-plus years of building, and industrial REITs combined own less than 10 percent of US industrial stock.
“Prologis and all the other industrial REITs combined own less than 10% of the industrial stock in the U.S.”
Build-to-rent combines new, highly amenitized product with an operational focus that looks and feels like multifamily, which is very different from scattered-site single-family rental, and this was the niche the Quinn platform targeted.
“you can bring in brand new product, highly amenitized with an operational focus that looks and feels like multifamily, which is very different than scattered site, single-family rental”
Regional banks, the main source of development and local real estate lending, are pulling back sharply, and over 750 of more than 4,700 US banks, about 16 percent, have commercial real estate concentration above FDIC guidance.
“over 750 of them have CRE concentration issues well in excess of FDIC guidance”
AI-driven data center demand could be at least as large as the public cloud wave, which added about 13 gigawatts globally, with some infrastructure funds citing as much as 38 gigawatts, and industry studies projecting data center needs doubling between 2023 and 2030.
“the opportunity set could be at least as big as the public cloud opportunity, if not larger”
Three abrupt changes characterize the 2023 real estate market: sharply reduced credit availability, a rapid increase in the cost of debt, and meaningfully reduced equity flows into the space.
“three pretty abrupt changes, one, an abrupt change in the availability of credit. Two, an abrupt increase in the cost of that debt capital”
Every incremental real estate asset class that became institutional emerged from a crisis or dislocation: cell towers after the 2001-2002 cable and fiber debt problems, multifamily and REITs after the early 1990s crisis, and single-family rental after 2010-2011.
“every incremental real estate asset class that institutionalizes comes out of some dislocation”
Simanovsky's worst public investment, a 2015 Macy's position based on real estate value, failed because without control of the real estate, deteriorating revenue and earnings matter more than the special-situation value.
“the direction of fundamentals is far more important than the 'special situation' which would be extracting value”
In public markets, the direction of return on invested capital matters more than its static level, because a company moving from 0 or 2 percent to 6 or 8 percent is more attractive than a 14 percent ROIC that stays flat, since the stable high return is already priced into the multiple.
“the direction of return on invested capital is far more important than the static level of ROIC”
Investors get paid when a complex, over-levered, poor-ROIC business is transformed into a simple, transparent one, because public markets will not assign the deserved multiple while the business remains complex.
“you get paid when complexity becomes simplicity”
The most revealing question to ask a real estate investor, as an LP, is what they are doing at various points in the cycle, repeatedly asked over time, to see how their business and investment style evolves and whether their skill is adaptable when conditions change.
“I would just ask them what they're doing at various points in the cycle and I'd repeatedly ask the same question”
In sectors with elevated supply such as multifamily, life sciences, self-storage, and industrial, transaction activity is down more than 50 percent year over year, values are down significantly, interest burdens are up, loan-to-value thresholds are breached, and debt service coverage is strained.
“transaction activity is down more than 50% year-over-year”
Senior living's average age of entry is about 83, and the 80-plus cohort grows rapidly through 2031 as the post-war boomer cohort ages, so the supply built for a 75-plus cohort is mismatched and demand growth is underestimated.
“the average age of entry today is about 83 years old. All of that supply that was built on the back of the outperformance in the post-GFC period, I think, presumed a 75-plus age cohort”
Marinas, cold storage, billboards and cell towers have regulatory supply constraints because communities resist new marinas on lakes or ocean waters, so they resemble the Beverly Hills of real estate subsectors where new supply is scarce.
“there are pockets of marinas that fall into regulatorily supply constrained because folks don't want more marinas on handful lakes or on ocean waters”
When a theme has no existing business model to invest in, Conversant incubates a platform by identifying a theme, finding an exclusive management team, and building a vertically integrated company, rather than buying into a public or private model that does not match the thesis.
“we're building a platform. We're identifying a theme, we're finding a management team. And ultimately, that management team is exclusively working for us”
Not everyone wins from AI data center expansion; the key questions are energy supply, cost, and return on invested capital, and some facilities will be functionally obsolete because of size or energy capacity.
“I don't think it's going to be as simple as everybody wins”
If the GFC was characterized by amend-and-extend, this downturn will be paydown-and-extend, meaning borrowers must pay down loans with fresh capital to get lenders to extend, which means new equity or structured financing will be needed at the asset or company level.
“our view is that this period will be characterized by paydown and extend”
Base rates went from effectively zero five or six quarters before mid-2023 to about 500 basis points, and with spreads widening roughly 100 basis points, a loan that cost 3 to 3.5 percent now costs 8.5 to 9 percent.
“what used to be a 3% or 3.5% loan is an 8.5%, 9% loan”
Distress should be pursued only when the investor is excited to own the asset for a long period, and Simanovsky attributes this rule to a mentor who said do not do distress for the sake of it.
“Don't do distress for the sake of it, do it because you're excited about the opportunity to own the asset for a long period of time”
The platform approach requires identifying a sector or asset type, then backing one high-quality management team with capital and time, since a platform's value depends on that team's track record and ability to execute its playbook at the asset level.
“the only way to do it is with a really quality management team”
Billboards are an attractive subsector because a little under a third of the space has converted to digital, leaving room to keep converting, and geospatial tracking could link advertising exposure to consumption, and the asset quality is strong.
“a little bit less than a third of the space has been converted to digital”
Office buildings have attracted large institutional checks, but once true capex is considered they often fail to earn their cost of capital through the cycle, while data centers face high obsolescence and capital needs and must be assessed by age and adaptability.
“I don't think it actually earns its cost of capital when you actually consider true CapEx”
Data centers are highly capital-intensive and carry more obsolescence risk than most real estate classes on shorter horizons, so older facilities may become functionally obsolete, while AI-adaptable facilities currently face very tight markets.
“They actually have more obsolescence risk than probably any other real estate asset class, at least on a shorter time horizon”
A key risk in senior living is that independent living will merge with age-restricted apartment housing, so the IL stock may not be needed as in the past, and the average entry age could move to 86 or 87, making the investment a few years early.
“independent living is going to merge with a new form of asset, which is age-restricted apartment housing”
The current liquidity shortage creates opportunities in rescue financing, structured corporate capital for companies needing defense or offense, discounted public companies as passive holdings or take-private candidates, and bank loan sales at attractive valuations, concentrated in multifamily, life sciences and industrial.
“lack of liquidity today is driving a handful of opportunities. Number one will be rescue financing”
Simanovsky's investment lens sequences analysis in three steps: first supply, because it is the easiest variable to read and get excited about; second demand; third the best way to participate in the capital structure.
“I think with supply is step one, demand a step two, what's the best way to participate in the capital structure. That's step three”
Single-family rental became an institutional asset class after the 2010-2011 distress, and in 2019 Simanovsky's firm saw a scarce-supply setup, a 35-to-49-year-old renter cohort growing faster than the population, and discounted purchases below replacement cost that justified incubating a build-to-rent platform.
“that 2010, '11 time period, birthed, single-family rental as an institutional asset class”
The platform approach works only when Conversant backs a single high-quality management team that executes the firm's playbook at the asset level, making the firm a vertically integrated strategic owner rather than a financial buyer, which yields deal flow it could not otherwise access.
“the only way to do it is with a really quality management team”
Simanovsky screens platform opportunities for resilience (predictable rental or earnings growth, defensive or countercyclical), scalability (large market and long reinvestment runway), and optionality (ability to grow the platform, improve returns on invested capital, and possibly earn a platform premium as the space institutionalizes).
“It has scalability and it has optionality. And what I mean by resilience is a high-quality, reasonably predictable rental growth stream”
Conversant prioritizes maximizing return opportunity over firm size, so it uses a hybrid fund, co-investments, and a compensation structure that makes investors indifferent between public and private markets, with private real estate roughly nine times the size of public real estate.
“every decision that we've made at this firm is simply about being flexible and making sure that we can maximize the return opportunity, not necessarily maximize the size of the firm”
The current real estate cycle is a re-equitization, in which low rates and FOMO in 2020-2021 drove peak valuations in 2021, and now capital flight, higher debt costs and reduced credit force meaningful asset-level and company-level deleveraging through new equity, forced selling, and recapitalizations.
“we describe it as broadly the re-equitization of real estate”
Simanovsky's main failure modes are getting demand wrong despite correct supply reads, obsolescence making a supply recovery arrive early, and holding too long so the capital cycle repeats, such as a 2026 wave of returning supply.
“We get the capital cycle wrong. We get the supply dynamic generally correct, but the demand were just wrong”
Conversant designed its incentive structure so that everyone is indifferent to investing in public or private markets, seeking only the best return opportunity, which Simanovsky considers the key decision-making framework for building the firm.
“ensure an incentive structure in place to where everyone is indifferent to investing in the public markets or the private markets”
When analyzing a distressed situation, one should focus on what can happen next rather than only current trading value and recovery analysis, because the most valuable opportunities come from companies in transformation.
“when you're looking at a distressed situation, you want to be excited about what can happen next”
Maintenance capital expenditure is not a sweeping rule across real estate; industrial and self-storage have very low maintenance CapEx, so the right approach is to evaluate true free cash flow through a full cycle for each asset.
“let's just look at true free cash flow through a cycle”
In 2016, Simanovsky's firm invested in Caesars bonds after its reorganization plan, seeing that bonds trading at distressed levels could be worth two or three times their price over three to four years because the company had reinvested in rooms and quality during bankruptcy.
“these bonds can be worth two or three times what they're trading at, if we actually look at it over three or four years”
Beyond the capital cycle, public investing should look for company-specific transformation, which can come from jettisoning a bad business, a new management team, or acquiring a misunderstood asset with a special-situation component.
“where is the company-specific transformation occurring”
For single-family rental, the big open question for a long period was whether there was a good operator; consolidation around 2015-2018 by American Homes 4 Rent and Invitation Homes left scattered, heterogeneous homes that still required a best-in-class operator.
“the big question mark for a long period of time was is there a good operator or set of operators around the asset”
Senior living went from a late-1990s supply surge, to distressed takeovers at the century turn, to strong post-GFC performance that drew capital back in 2011, to a 2013-2015 supply wave that peaked in 2015 and ended in Q4 2019; COVID then cut occupancy about 1,000 basis points from roughly 88% to 78%, and labor costs compounded the damage.
“you saw industry occupancy fall 1,000 basis points. So you went from roughly 88% in the month before COVID to about 78% of its trough”
The 2020 investment in Colony Capital, later DigitalBridge, involved four simultaneous changes: a healthcare real estate business, a hospitality business, a mortgage REIT, and an acquisition of DigitalBridge; each business had nonrecourse debt, letting the company exit legacy assets and pivot to an asset-light digital infrastructure manager.
“every single one of those verticals had its own nonrecourse balance sheet”
Malls rationalized after a death-of-retail narrative beginning in 2015, and Class A malls are now more valuable than ever while Class B and C malls lose value, so office may follow the same supply-driven playbook of shifting value to top assets.
“the Class A mall is probably more valuable than it ever has been because Class B and C malls have gotten a lot less interesting and worth less”
The core question for single-family rental in 2010-2011 was whether assets could be bought at a deep discount to replacement cost, with limited new supply and demographic-driven rental growth, so the investment could be fine even as a trade.
“could you price the asset at such a discount to replacement cost?”
On average real estate is a commodity-style sector that benefits from capital cycle analysis, but some subsectors such as irreplaceable or heavily regulated supply-constrained assets may not follow the typical capital cycle.
“on average, I think real estate is a commodity style sector, and it benefits greatly to look at it through the capital cycle lens”
Senior living occupancy has started to mean-revert toward pre-COVID highs while supply is down roughly 80 percent from its early-2010s peak, and the bottom decile of assets may be converted to other uses, creating a setup where supply growth could turn flat or negative.
“supply is down 80% from its highs earlier in the 2010s”
Many great REIT assets had to be recapitalized during the GFC at distressed valuations, causing lots of dilution in 2009 through 2011, which taught REIT investors and managers to lever conservatively.
“they had to be recapped, really distressed valuations causing lots of dilution in 2009, '10, '11”
John Wooden's first practice taught players to put on socks and tie shoes, reflecting the principle that if fundamentals are not right, nothing else can be right.
“they get to practice the first day and he teaches them how to put their socks on”
Conversant incubated Quinn Residences, a private build-to-rent single-family platform owning entire communities across the Southeast, because none of the three large public single-family rental REITs (American Homes 4 Rent, Invitation Homes, Tricon) were a pure play on dedicated build-to-rent communities.
“None of them were pure play on what we were really, really excited about, which was the build-to-rent concept”
As fundamentals potentially turn back up in 2024 and 2025, the best REIT capital allocators are likely to earn premium valuations that let them play offense, compounding NAV growth on top of normal free cash flow per share growth.
“the best capital allocators and REITs are actually going to get premium valuations to let them go play offense”
Large private asset managers such as Blackstone (QTS), DigitalBridge (Switch), and GIP and KKR have taken most public data center opportunities, so public-market access is limited and private pricing is hard to match at the firm's cost of capital.
“all the big private asset managers have taken most of the public opportunities away”
Real estate supply and demand cycles are long, with some assets taking one to three or four years to build before fundamentals deteriorate, and demand cycles can run 10 to 15 years, such as millennials aging into housing.
“it could take a year or three or four years to build an asset before you actually see that deterioration of fundamentals”
Americans earning $60,000 to $100,000 face a shortage of affordable housing, and the most unaffordable housing has ever been with homes above $400,000 at prevailing rates, while households earning several hundred thousand face challenges reaching housing given credit conditions.
“the American that earns on average between $60,000 and $100,000 a year, has a dearth of affordable and available housing”
Senior living operating risk is elevated by difficulty staffing nursing, since labor is the largest cost component and staffing shortages make it harder to deliver a great resident experience.
“nursing staff continues to be harder and harder to make sure that the residents have a great experience”
Typical levered private equity real estate buyers put 65 to 80 percent loan-to-cost on acquired assets, so their returns depend heavily on cost of capital and driving rental growth or operating improvements.
“they'll put 65%, 70%, 80% loan to cost on the asset”
Real estate returns are commonly grouped into core, core plus, value-add and opportunistic tiers, roughly mid-single digit, high single digit, low teens, and equity-like returns on equity, with the tiers moving with the prevailing cost of capital.
“core capital is sort of mid-single digits return on equity, that core plus is high single digits. The value-add is low teens and opportunistic is equity-like returns”
The public REIT index fell 27 percent from its end-2021 peak and serves as a directional proxy for real estate asset values, while leveraged names fell further and core funds faced redemption issues.
“it's down 27% from its peak at the end of 2021”
Private real estate markets are much larger than public ones, roughly 9x, which is why Conversant considers expanding its private capacity over time.
“because the private markets are much, much bigger in real estate than the public markets are, we usually think 9x the size”
Real estate is not a single asset class but many sub-ecosystems, so a flexible mandate makes it one of the most curious investment endeavors because each subsector requires separate analysis of supply, demand and business economics.
“there's something called real estate isn't actually the case. There's so many different sub ecosystems”
Sonny Kalsi told Simanovsky, after a two-plus hour conversation before he left his prior firm, that his success came 70 percent from hustle and forward thinking rather than the big balance sheet behind him, which reframed his confidence to start his own firm.
“I actually think it's the other way, 70-30 in favor of your hustle”
At the bottom of the capital cycle there are banks tired of holding nonperforming loans and private equity firms fatigued after entering in 2016 and 2017, creating sellers motivated to exit, which is where opportunities arise.
“there are banks that are getting tired and selling nonperforming loans, there are fatigued sellers”
Applying John Wooden's maxim be quick but don't hurry, the last few years called for patience, and the coming period calls for impatience because of capital outflow, while acknowledging that the economy or fundamentals could still deteriorate.
“There's a time to be patient and time to be inpatient”
Simanovsky's firm wants to invest in affordable housing but has not found a structure that meets its return expectations, because affordable housing returns tend to be lower than what the firm targets.
“those tend to be lower returns than what we've seen. And we've spent some time with some really interesting folks”
Over the last 15 to 20 years the real estate private equity space has institutionalized substantially, and some of the smartest investors are focused on real estate, with real estate a huge component of the largest private equity firms and asset managers.
“the space has institutionalized so much over the last 15 or 20 years. I think some of the smartest investors I've ever met, focus on real estate”
Sam Zell was the original thinker around real estate platforms because he securitized real estate, making him the first figure Simanovsky would invite to a dinner of real estate investors.
“He was the original thinker around real estate platforms from my lens”
Over a sufficiently long horizon everything is cyclical, so the capital cycle is a useful frame for real estate investing across asset classes.
“on a long enough time horizon, everything is sort of cyclical”
Simanovsky does not know the specifics of Charlie Munger's multifamily portfolio origin, but he understands a persistent neighbor in Los Angeles pushed Munger to acquire multifamily assets decades ago.
“there was a relentless person in his neighborhood in L.A., who kept knocking on his door”