Lulu Meservey - Transforming Company Narrative - [Invest Like the Best, EP.389]
What this covers
Lulu Meservey, founder of the communications firm Rostra and a Shopify board member, treats comms as a strategic discipline rather than a publicity chore. Much of her framing comes from counterinsurgency: local elders spread a message more credibly than outsiders, and people trust an organization only if they trust its leader. She argues corporate communications has never had a first-principles playbook, so practitioners imitate predecessors without knowing why it works. She also blames the old media monopoly on reach, when founders had to beg reporters for coverage, for comms' reputation as misery. That history is why she favors going direct.
The middle of the conversation is practical. On launches, she says the most important preparation is picking a knowledgeable, enthusiastic reporter, and that skill lies in choosing one description from a thousand possible ones. A good hook uses a bridge to connect what an audience already cares about to the new idea. She cautions that founders fall prey to the illusion of transparency, assuming outsiders can see what is in their heads. She sorts audiences into those who matter, swing voters, and irredeemables. On fundraising, she contends that mimetic investors respond to a company framed inside a larger story, such as American dynamism or US-China competition.
Crisis handling is the third thread: run tabletop exercises, keep routine work on autopilot, and be wary of lawyers who minimize legal risk at all costs. She also says to apologize only for what you actually did, and to answer false attacks. The more contested material includes her reading of why Paul Graham's "Founder Mode" essay went viral, citing Derek Thompson, and her view that Graydon Carter's formula matters less as media shifts toward opinion.
Meservey argues founders must personally own and speak their story rather than route it through layers of comms middlemen, because each intermediary dilutes the message and accountability is what makes it credible.
- Layered comms chains (CEO to CMO to comms VP to media relations to reporter) distort the founder's original insight
- Founders who visibly own the narrative (Tobi Lütke, Palmer Luckey) build credibility that delegation cannot
- Launches, crises, and fundraising all work better when the founder is the direct, accountable voice
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
A counterinsurgency lesson is to win over local authorities and elders, because they propagate the message more credibly than outsiders, and one authority reaches far more people than many outsiders.
“Going to one person who is considered an authority in a certain community is better than going to 200”
Companies and founders assume the outside world can see what is in their heads, so they skip context and misjudge what will resonate with external audiences.
“It's you assuming that the outside world can know what's in your mind”
Routine tasks must run on autopilot during a crisis, because organizational, operational, and mental capacity should be reserved for the crisis itself.
“everything that you can do on autopilot has to be done on autopilot because all of your organizational, operational and mental capacity has to be spent on dealing with the crisis.”
In counterinsurgency and in crises, the leader's personality is paramount because people trust the organization only if they trust the leader, and followers look to the leader rather than advisers for how to act.
“people aren't looking to your advisers for how to act, they're looking to you for how to act.”
Running tabletop crisis simulations with a senior team reveals small coordination gaps, such as hesitation about whether to wake the boss, that cost time when a real crisis arrives.
“I still do these tabletop war room exercises, the same type of thing that the Marine Corps would do.”
Fundraising goes better when a company is framed inside a larger macro narrative such as American dynamism or US-China competition, so the company becomes the natural explanation if investors accept the worldview.
“if you can describe your thing ... in the context of a macro narrative.”
Lawyers typically optimize for minimizing legal risk at all other costs, which is the wrong objective for a CEO who needs to weigh principles and long-term reputation as well.
“a lot of times, the lawyers are optimizing for one thing, they're optimizing for minimized legal risk at all other costs.”
Political mass movements and company growth share a pattern: people must be made dissatisfied with their current situation until they are ready to change, and every adopter bears a cost that must be outweighed.
“people are dissatisfied with some aspect of their life, and you want to get them to think about that more and more”
A founder should apologize wholeheartedly if they did something wrong, but should not apologize for something they did not do, since insincere apologies do not appease people and are regretted later.
“if you didn't do anything wrong, then by definition, there's nothing to apologize for”
Historically, traditional media held a near monopoly on reach, so founders either had to be wealthy or beg reporters to cover them, an experience that is demeaning and produced poor results, which is why people associate comms with misery.
“Historically, there's been a near monopoly by traditional media.”
Investors are mimetic, copying each other and the signals of peers, so a pitch that gives investors a narrative explaining why an investment matters lets them look good inside their firm.
“investors are pretty mimetic. This is not meant to be a dunk on investors, but it's human nature.”
Communities around a product or group make adoption sticky because belonging becomes part of identity, and rivalries between communities deepen commitment, as Tesla owners illustrate.
“being a member of this thing larger than yourself becomes a part of your identity.”
The PG Founder Mode essay went viral largely because its name was simple and familiar yet novel, and Derek Thompson's research suggests that blending novel and familiar is a formula for virality.
“he talks about blending the novel with the familiar and that being a magic formula.”
Graydon Carter's narrative, conflict, and proprietary information formula suits breaking news, but as media shifts toward opinion and personality it is less necessary.
“The Graydon Carter trifecta is good for news and breaking news.”
Founders must be able to name what in the world would go missing if their company vanished, because failing to answer this makes a company hard to invest in and signals dereliction.
“what is missing in the world today that only you can fill.”
Communication only matters when it has a direction; without clear goals, comms becomes activity that creates an illusion of progress while the company moves nowhere.
“So communication is a vector, not a scaler. It only matters if there's a direction attached to it.”
Choosing the right reporter is the most important launch preparation, because choosing well makes what the founder says in the interview matter much less.
“Reporter selection is probably the number one thing prep.”
Corporate communications has never had an analytical, first-principles playbook grounded in logic, so practitioners imitate predecessors without understanding why their methods work.
“There's never been a real playbook for comms that is analytical, grounded in reasoning and logic and first principles”
An effective hook identifies what a target audience cares about, then uses a gateway or bridge (an API) to connect those concerns to the new idea the founder wants them to understand.
“you need to know their cultural erogenous zones, what they care about and what they think about. Then you need a gateway drug”
K-pop groups hook fans through distinct, complementary personas that create friction and drama, so fans invest in personalities and relationships rather than only songs and dances.
“The different personas glue people because it creates friction and drama and diversity inside of this group.”
Groups with contrasting personas create friction and drama that gives fans many reasons to engage, turning one product into several sources of interest, and this works similarly for brands and startups.
“The different personas glue people because it creates friction and drama and diversity inside of this group. So instead of one thing, you get five things.”
Founders should sort audiences into those who can affect the company's future, haters who are mostly irredeemable, and swing voters who could become allies, giving swing voters disproportionate attention.
“Just like in an election, the swing voters are deserving a disproportionate amount of attention.”
Any product can be described in a thousand ways, and launch skill lies in selecting the single best description, which is where most of the controllable 0.5% of success comes from.
“Every product or company can be described in 1,000 different ways.”
The right reporter is someone knowledgeable and genuinely excited about the space, not someone seeking accountability or metrics, and selection now starts with the individual journalist rather than the outlet.
“start with who are the people who are knowledgeable in this space and love it.”
Failing to answer false attacks damages employee morale and encourages future attackers, because it signals that attacking the company carries no cost, so counterattacks raise the cost of hostility.
“you are unfavorably shaping incentives for other people to attack you in the future”
Founders should build enough basic understanding of every communications function that anyone, including the advisor, could leave and the company could continue, so no one becomes indispensable.
“you should be able to have anybody quit, leave, go to a competitor, and you will be able to keep going”
A founder should only start a company if they hold secret knowledge and a vision that others do not; without something new to bring to the world, they have no business being a founder.
“If that's not true, you have no business starting a company.”
When a founder's message passes through many intermediaries, it gets watered down beyond recognition and loses what made it special.
“There can be too many middlemen such that by the time your message reaches people, it's been watered down beyond recognition”
The correct response to a crisis depends on the ground truth of whether the founder did something wrong, not on social pressure such as who is angry or whether they are being ratioed.
“It starts with the ground truth of did you mess up?”
The first manifesto question is what gives the company a right to exist, given that many companies are already doing similar things, and an answer is needed before investors commit.
“What gives you a right to exist and to take up space on this earth”
Engaging with haters can be useful if you let them attack until they overstep, which helps round up true allies, rather than trying to convert them.
“you might consider letting them attack you until they overstep in order for you to round up your true allies.”
The current media landscape is not traditional media shifting to social media but social media shifting to AI-driven, hyper-personalized content that humans can no longer reliably distinguish from machine output.
“social media transitioning to AI-driven, hyper-personalized, very prolific where you can't tell human-made from AI-made”
Culture barriers exist not only between nationalities but between tech and DC people or finance and heavy industry people, so words must be translated through these cultural membranes to land.
“there's also often a culture barrier between a tech person and a DC person or a finance person and a heavy industry person.”
In a professional company, the CEO's story is relayed through a CMO or VP of comms, then corporate comms, then media relations, then a pitched reporter who already has a similar narrative, and is finally filtered through that publication's readers, producing a contorted version.
“the CEO tells maybe a CMO or a VP of comms, who then tells the person who's in charge of corporate comms”
Rostra selects clients largely on vibes and chemistry, because early-stage companies lack enough data to judge their prospects, and reading the founder in person is the best available signal.
“vibes is the best measurement we have so far about whether things are going to go well.”
Launches matter more today than before because the market is noisier and the bar is higher, and a company that does not define itself quickly will be defined by others.
“It actually matters a little bit more now because there is so much more noise and because the bar has been raised.”
A bland, silent crisis response that avoids legal exposure can shred long-term reputation, causing boycotts, lost trust, and lost hires that cost more than a temporary apology would have.
“that actually could shred your reputation longer term, which could be way more expensive.”
Founders should articulate their principles and values so that investors and partners can judge whether they share a vision of the world, since incompatible visions surface costly conflicts after signing.
“If you believe that you will only succeed in vision A of the world, but I happen to believe vision B, then we're incompatible”
Know your audience has become a truism that people ignore, and it is important because talking to the wrong people is worse than talking to no one, since it costs time and creates unwanted enemies or friends.
“if you're talking to the wrong people, it's worse than talking to nobody”
Mass movements and companies both depend on making joining worth the cost to each person, since joining involves monetary, switching, learning, and social costs such as explaining a career move to family, so the value must exceed these costs.
“Every time somebody joins your movement, joins your company, buys your product, there's a cost to them.”
Communities with rivalries and shared identity make products sticky because leaving would be humiliating or costly, and for startups, making employees members of a movement builds loyalty more than awards do.
“being part of a community makes the thing so much more sticky.”
Rostra avoids founders who want a surrogate to do the public work for them, because the model is to help founders become effective public advocates rather than outsourcing their presence indefinitely.
“Sometimes, founders will use another person like a crutch.”
Companies preparing a launch should write a manifesto, not because the world needs more manifestos but because the exercise forces founders to state what they stand for and value.
“it is good as a forcing mechanism, if nothing else, to write down what you stand for and what you value”
Teeing up allies takes time, and for the Cognition launch it took one to two months to brief and prepare people so they were ready to support the company when it launched.
“in the case of Cognition, it took between a month and two months to brief some people and prep some people”
Founders should play rugby rather than American football, running into tackles and using momentum because play is continuous, rather than avoiding confrontation and losing ground.
“you might run into the tackle because you know that the play isn't going to stop”
If the goal is growing users, the company should care about those users and be willing to upset non-users to please them, since non-users have no real stake in the company's future.
“If I have to make them mad in order to please the users, I will make that choice without hesitation.”
The first ingredient of going direct is that the founder must be willing and eager to take responsibility for the story, leaning into it rather than resenting it.
“it starts with the founder. And they have to have a clear vision and they have to be willing and eager to take on that responsibility.”
The best fundraisers are unapologetically themselves, whatever their persona, and forcing a salesy or charming persona that does not match the founder usually backfires.
“The people who do it best are unapologetically who they are.”
The worst fundraising mistake is trying to become a different person for investors, because founders rarely pull off a new persona, which leaves them with neither their original identity nor a convincing new one.
“you're not hot tea, you're not iced tea, you're just lukewarm tea and you've got nothing and nobody”
Earlier-stage founders at small companies should personally do their own communications, while larger-company founders should delegate execution but keep ownership of the story.
“If you're an earlier founder in a smaller company, you should just straight up do it yourself.”
Pitching your own company directly is self-defeating because your self-interest undermines the pitch throughout, whereas a macro narrative lets investors reason to the company themselves.
“you're so clearly self-interested that, that self-interest is undermining your pitch the whole time you're making it.”
The K-pop industry in South Korea functions as a national industrial manufacturing complex that systematically selects and trains youth through academies and mentors, similar to how Spartans trained fighters.
“It's like a national, industrial, manufacturing complex but for K-pop stars.”
Ramp succeeds because it is clear about what it is and is not, repeats its core promise of saving customers time and money, and aligns all comms to that message, which copycats fail to replicate.
“Ramp knows that they're there to save customers time and money. They say it 10 times a day.”
Meservey's main selling point is being unencumbered by experience in conventional communications, because the more experience someone has in a broken comms industry, the more compromised they may be.
“the more experience you have in it, the more compromised you might be and the harder it is to break away.”
Anduril has a strong comms team, but Palmer Luckey adds personal accountability, personal creativity, and personal risk-taking, including stepping in when he is attacked rather than the company.
“Then there's the Palmer alpha where on top of that, he takes personal accountability”
The standard corporate comms chain, where a CEO's message is relayed to comms staff, pitched to a reporter who already has a similar narrative, and filtered through that reporter's worldview, produces a contorted version, and founders today should not rely on it; traditional press is perhaps 1% of the playbook.
“That's maybe 1% of the playbook.”
For the Devin launch, Lulu estimates that 99% of the outcome came from Cognition building a genuinely great product, with the remaining 1% split evenly between good execution and luck.
“For the Devin launch, 99% was the Cognition guys built Devin.”
A manifesto should explain why only this founder can do the work right now and how the company approaches the problem, convincing stakeholders the plan exists without exposing every trade secret.
“people need to be convinced that the plan exists.”
Founders should put their manifesto into different media, such as writing, video, audio, short posts, memes, and in-person speech, to discover which medium is their strongest.
“see which one is the natural medium for you.”
Rostra's main goal is to change founder culture so that accountability for the message and going direct becomes the default in tech, which it does not earn money from but considers better for tech and the world.
“the thing we want to do is to, number one, change how founders think about, how they communicate to the world.”
People fear downside more than they want upside, so it is more persuasive to say the current state is unacceptable and a better state is close than to say things are fine but could be better.
“people fear downside more than they want upside.”
Steve Jobs knew his reputation and did not prioritize being liked, instead putting excellence first and setting aside hurt feelings to pursue what mattered most.
“making new friends and being liked universally was not one of those priorities. Excellence was one of the priorities.”
Even a strong reporter can be undermined by a weak editor, so founders should check who edits a reporter's work before pitching.
“You might have a great reporter with a not-so-great editor that becomes an unforeseen problem.”
Rostra was named after the Roman speaker's platform built from captured enemy battle rams, the center of political speech and power in Rome, representing a place where ideas and public opinion were shaped.
“A rostra is a speakers platform.”
Misunderstandings in ordinary conversation arise when a person assumes the listener shares context in their head, which is the same cognitive failure that causes companies to miscommunicate with the outside world.
“you say a thing that completes a thought that's in your head, and I'm completely lost.”
Tobi Lütke takes personal responsibility for Shopify's story, including its origin from a janky online snowboard store, and delegates help without abdicating ownership.
“He takes personal responsibility for the story of Shopify.”
The medium and messenger determine whether a message reaches its audience, because different groups get ideas from different places such as Reddit, Joe Rogan, NPR, conferences, or the New York Times.
“You need to reach people where they intellectually hang out.”
Influencers and individuals have become mediums for information alongside social media and generative AI, making personal voice a key channel.
“this is not a technology, but influencers and individuals as mediums.”
Founders should address known weaknesses, or skeletons in the closet, before a crisis arrives, and maintain a crisis plan.
“try to fight the crisis before it happens. If there is dry tinder lying around you, do something about it”
Publication prestige differs from circulation, since USA Today has very high circulation but less prestige than the Financial Times, which has a smaller readership and a higher bar.
“USA TODAY is one of the biggest circulations, but it's not seen as prestigious compared to the Financial Times”
Know your audience has become such a truism that people no longer think about it, and it should be rebranded to become fresh again, though it remains central to communication.
“know your audience is actually a cliché at this point.”
Information overload, breakdown of trust, AI slop, and very persuasive real and fake versions of content together make the current information environment especially hard to navigate.
“It's a combination of information overload, trust breaking down, AI slop, very persuasive real and fake versions of things.”
Part of the work is reading the room in the target audience's current culture, because an idea that was cool two weeks ago can be cringe now, so launch messages need continuous calibration.
“This thing that was cool two weeks ago ... has actually turned cringe in the meantime”
Capturing a special moment creates urgency because the opportunity may not recur, such as a band disbanding or a startup's Series A window closing.
“Capturing something special about this moment creates a sense of urgency.”
If a company is making something different that threatens incumbents, founders will face upset and must decide upfront that the fight is worth it, because they are shaping a better world.
“you need to decide upfront that's worth it and you're willing to fight for your company”
Before starting Rostra, Meservey filled out a YC-style application to test whether her motives were genuine rather than vanity, arguing founders should do the same to be honest with those who join them.
“I actually did the exercise of filling out the application before starting Rostra.”
Founders who are unapologetically themselves, including those with unusual demeanors, succeed when their persona reflects who they really are, because the authenticity itself signals competence.
“He is totally unapologetic for him. Wallets fly out of pockets when he walks by”
In AI, the informal gossip ecosystem is intense enough that without a strong launch, word spreads in a distorted form, forcing companies to spend long periods cleaning up.
“The scuttlebutt in AI is intense. It's the biggest water cooler in the world”
Rostra's leaders are not trying to maximize revenue; they value freedom for its own sake and would turn down large sums to pursue other work, aiming instead to change how founders communicate.
“We're not here to be revenue-maxing.”
Rostra recruits from outside traditional comms, including a former nun, a rabbi, a CIA officer, a White House staffer, a diplomat, founders, and medical doctors, because people who learn quickly can outperform average comms professionals.
“Someone like that who learns can do a better job than the average comms person”
Pitching a reporter at a major outlet like the Wall Street Journal to reach policymakers is roughly 1% of the comms playbook, and founders should not rely on that channel alone.
“That's maybe 1% of the playbook.”
Talented comms professionals are scarce, many founders have never worked with one who fits their energy and will fight for them, and comms has earned a bad reputation as a result.
“the talent density in comms is not awesome.”
Rostra prefers clients where there is a gap between current conditions and a better world if the company succeeds, rather than riding the coattails of already successful companies.
“We like when there's a delta between where the world is now and where the world should be with this company succeeding.”
Lulu and her cofounder Sergey split listening audiences between them, with Sergey acting as a translator for people with different technical styles, so reading the room is done jointly across a wide spectrum of tech.
“he's my autism translator. I will talk to and listen to one set of people more”
Over 90 percent of the founders Meservey talks to think communication is important and also hate doing it, which is why they seek help.
“It's got to be over 90% of the people I talk to.”
Alex at Scale is a founder's founder who gets into the weeds, micromanages in a useful way, and applies the same intensity to comms, including absorbing blame on the company's behalf.
“He has never shied away from taking a bullet on behalf of Scale”
Key knowledge of the AI space is a scuttlebutt-driven environment in which distorted narratives can spread widely.
“the scuttlebutt in AI is intense. It's the biggest water cooler in the world”
For Cognition and SSI, Ashlee Vance was chosen because he is intellectually curious about AI and genuinely loves the subject, so he matches the founders' energy and researches through that lens.
“we chose Ashlee Vance because he is intellectually curious about AI.”
The kindest thing anyone did for Meservey was an older man who thanked her in Norwegian for holding a door and gave her a NOK 10 coin, saying she was a nice girl, which she still remembers decades later.
“he gave me a NOK 10 coin and he handed it into my hand and said, "You're a nice girl."”