Kirsten Green - Investing in Consumer Change - [Invest Like the Best, EP.301]
What this covers
Patrick talks with Kirsten Green, who founded Forerunner Ventures in 2012, about what she learned from a research effort into modern consumers. She describes a population that has lost its old life script of college, job title, marriage and house, along with the durable communities that religion, long-term employers and neighborhoods once supplied. In her telling, that loss shows up as anxiety, a demand for mentorship, and a search for belonging, which is why she thinks community combined with commerce is promising. Some of her findings cut against assumptions. The person most concerned with environmentally aligned behavior was a busy, lower-income, middle-aged adult rather than a young one, and crypto adoption skewed middle-aged too.
The second half turns to how Forerunner invests. Green says most product businesses are good but not venture-scale, and that venture scale comes from structural shifts. She walks through Dollar Shave Club, which she says she backed for the wholesale-to-retail shift and not for its viral ad. Michael Dubin pitched that shift rather than a razor company. She also discusses Warby Parker turning glasses into an identity statement, and Curated, a three-sided marketplace that brings the in-store expert back online. The Beachhead Entry Point question runs through the discussion, along with the idea that tailwind diligence tends to talk investors out of deals. Green also covers building deal flow deliberately and opening Forerunner's founder network beyond Silicon Valley. She traces commerce from barter to Amazon and back to one-to-one selling, and recalls how Phil Schlein responded to a 2008 failure.
Green argues that consumer change is structural and continuous, so venture investors should find the entry point where a deep consumer need meets a shifting power dynamic, and then judge whether the business can build a repeatable, brand-driven advantage.
- Consumer behavior is shifting structurally, driven by the loss of traditional life paths, a search for purpose, and the digital empowerment of buyers and sellers
- Early-stage success depends on a viable entry point, a founder with unique insight into the customer, and tech capability, not on a grand original idea
- Strong consumer brands deliver a consistent promise across touchpoints, and deal flow must be built deliberately rather than left to luck
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Commerce has cycled from one-to-one barter through markets, corner stores, streets, malls, and Amazon-driven digital warehouses, and now returns to one-to-one selling because connected payments, discovery, and online tools let individual sellers reach the long tail.
“And suddenly, you can be like the single person at the market, but you can be online selling.”
Original ideas are rare, so the key test for early-stage founders is whether their team has a unique advantage, such as deeper insight into a category or user psychology, that lets them execute better than the many other teams pitching similar concepts.
“There are very few super unique ideas.”
The lack of direction people feel can be addressed by communities, peer-group measurement, and tools that guide people through their journey, and combining community with commerce is a promising area for investment.
“Are there ways to help create some measurement against a peer group or some things that sort of bring you along on that journey where people are craving some of that.”
Contrary to the hypothesis that younger generations would lead environmental behavior, the study found the person most concerned about environmentally aligned behavior was a busy middle-aged adult in a lower income bracket, often facing expensive sustainable options.
“the person that was most concerned about behaving in a way that aligned with environmental causes was a middle-aged, busy adult in a lower income bracket”
People used to have a clear life path to follow, such as college, a job with a title, promotion, marriage, and a house, which gave direction and a relative benchmark for self-assessment; its loss now produces anxiety and a demand for mentorship and security.
“There was like a path to follow.”
Warby Parker made glasses a fashion and identity statement, a category where brand previously did not matter, and its balanced aesthetic that many consumers can identify with could let it grow into a durable brand, possibly beyond glasses.
“they really made a statement in the market in a category where nobody else did it, and that's hard to do.”
Michael Dubin did not pitch Dollar Shave Club as a shaving company, which Forerunner would have passed on given entrenched duopoly economics; instead he pitched a fundamental shift in the consumer purchase journey and the repositioning of wholesale and retail that a direct model could exploit.
“Michael Dubin never came in and pitched as a shaving company. I would have passed outright on a shaving company.”
The team first narrows to an area by listening to consumer changes, then applies tailwind and headwind diligence, but this diligence tends to talk the team out of deals, so investors need a true-believer conviction to proceed.
“usually diligence yourself out of something, by the way, but you have to have a little bit of I am just a true believer”
Founders should articulate a value proposition that connects to the bigger idea but start with a narrow entry point, as Dollar Shave Club did by pitching a shift in the purchase journey through razors rather than pitching a shaving company.
“Michael Dubin never came in and pitched as a shaving company.”
Curated is a three-sided marketplace linking brands, experts, and consumers in which human experts recommend products from a brand catalog, consumers buy through the platform, and brands ship directly, with technology selecting the best few experts from thousands.
“That's why I said three-sided marketplace.”
Forerunner's consumer investing starts from observed consumer need and shifting market dynamics, while SaaS and marketplace investors start from a product category playbook, and most consumer product opportunities are good businesses but not venture-scale.
“It's not a venture business. There's a lot of things. The majority of things that fall into like products and services are kind of in that bucket.”
First movers in a structural shift can gain lift-off if they figure out the future business model before competitors, and the rest of the industry then imitates them, although it is unclear whether the outcome is a standalone company or an acquisition.
“And the rest of the industry looked at you and said, I need some of that.”
Curated's three-sided marketplace of brands, experts, and consumers brings back the in-person personal salesperson online, because experts with hands-on knowledge provide credible, practical advice that anonymous Amazon reviews cannot.
“That is the magic of retail has been happening offline forever. There used to be people who really were professional salespeople.”
Most product and service businesses are not venture businesses; venture-scale opportunity arises when there is a big structural shift that lets a company show the industry how the future will look, and such first movers face disadvantages but benefit from less saturated advertising and industry skill gaps.
“There's a bunch of things that people need. There's opportunity for a new product. You can build a nice business. It's not a venture business.”
Forerunner invested in Dollar Shave Club because of the underlying shift between wholesale and retail and a changing male consumer who was self-educating online, not because of its viral YouTube ad.
“This was about the change that was happening and that really underpinned all of those early”
A venture firm cannot build a business on hoping to stumble onto the right deal; it must generate critical mass of companies and pick from them, because deal flow is foundational and repeatable.
“you cannot build a business on that because you're hoping for luck”
A product has a real market tailwind when it either powers a meaningful technology or user shift, or when it makes people's lives or jobs better and they deeply care about it, and Forerunner tries to start with that wind at its back since ventures face many headwinds.
“Are you operating in a path of progress? Because you're going to fight so many headwinds along the way.”
Founders like Emily Weiss of Glossier and Michael Dubin of Dollar Shave Club had insight into the psychology of their users that went beyond surface-level white space analysis, and this psychological advantage is a durable competitive edge.
“They had an insight into the head of their user other founders don't have.”
A good brand delivers on its promise, has a clear directive about the relationship it wants with consumers and community, and delivers that consistently across all or most touchpoints.
“A good brand delivers on its promise.”
After the 2008 failure of a high-profile startup in which Green had invested, mentor Phil Schlein asked detailed questions about what went wrong and offered to co-invest in her next angel deal, reframing the loss as learning that made her stronger.
“Next time you have an angel you want to invest in, I'll angel invest, I'll invest.”
People used to have durable communities through religion, long-term employers, and local neighborhoods, but greater physical, career, and social mobility has removed these anchors, creating a real challenge around belonging.
“People had real communities that they were attached to, whether that was from their religions or whether that was from companies that they worked with for 2 decades”
Forerunner's early network grew organically when good founders referred other good founders, especially after the firm invested in companies others were less excited about, but the firm must now deliberately open its network beyond Silicon Valley to avoid being a closed network business.
“good founders know other good founders. ... I think this can't be a closed network business that we have to be able to open the doors”
Contrary to the perception that a young generation fueled the 2021 crypto boom, the data showed crypto adoption skewed toward middle-aged people who had the traits of early adopters or techy users.
“That also is much more of a middle-aged person.”
Greater information about failing systems and personal shortfalls creates curiosity and felt need, which sparks the expectation that solutions should exist, and this sequence lays the groundwork for new products and services.
“usually, information fuels. It's curiosity or need that fuels it. Information sparks ideas, you start to expect that there should be some way to solve something.”
Marketplace businesses with interlocking services are fundamentally technology projects, and the Faire founders stood out because they recognized that tech was the viability requirement, with product engineering and data combined with small business experience.
“it is a tech project, for sure.”
Forerunner's 2022 consumer study concluded that there is a lot of structural change in how Americans live, and that this change creates both freedom and anxiety because the old linear life path (college, job, marriage, house, kids) has disappeared.
“It's about structural change and how we live our lives.”
Consumer archetypes sit at different points on an evolving continuum of behavior and finances, so a group's position today will change over about five years, and venture investors must find trends that will be on everyone's mind in 5 to 10 years but can already reach critical mass.
“But in 5 years, they're going to get advanced on the spectrum”
When evaluating early-stage businesses, Forerunner first asks whether there is a clear, viable entry point in terms of reach, adoption, and execution, because a business cannot reach its later marketplace or flywheel vision without first getting into the market.
“is there a clear viable entry point.”
Forerunner's early deal flow was built organically when first partner founders such as Bonobos, Birchbox, and Warby Parker became signals and referral sources to other entrepreneurs, and this founder-to-founder referral network is the most reliable source of quality deals.
“And good founders know other good founders.”
Forerunner mentors young investors by working closely together in the room, starting with note-taking and progressing to questions, debate, and partnership, so that both the mentor's and the junior's thinking improve as trust builds.
“let's be in the room together. Let's have conversation and dialogue.”
A scaled business model can be attractive only in some cases; the question is what it takes in time and dollars to reach scale, whether the investment still holds up on the other side, and whether the core activity is inherently repeatable, because a one-and-done business is very hard to make work.
“So very hard to make a business, at least in the framework that we think about or with the ambition we think about, work if it's a one and done.”
Digital connectivity expands access to affinity groups and broader ideas, but it also fragments community, leaving people with a dual experience of online engagement and loneliness offline, which is jarring rather than grounding.
“But then Friday night you're home by yourself, very confusing, very jarring.”
Julie Bornstein of THE YES succeeded because her industry credibility let her gain buy-in from roughly 300 brands at launch, which a newcomer could not have achieved with only two brands.
“she couldn't launch with two brands, she had to launch with 300 brands”
Forerunner's clear stance on what it invests in made it possible to fund founders with no prior Silicon Valley connection or easy access to funding, and it views the industry's closed-network tendency as a problem to counter.
“this can't be a closed network business that we have to be able to open the doors”
Dollar Shave Club succeeded by aligning with a male consumer newly self-aware about personal care, who had been online and was taking shopping into their own hands because Amazon made buying easy, which also drew in people who previously did not shop.
“Alongside a male consumer who is now having self-awareness around the personal care routine because they were online and they were learning about more stuff”
Forerunner's firm-level discipline is to ask how to do fewer things better and to define the areas it wants to be known for, signaling proficiency to founders so that relevant founders self-select into the firm.
“How can we do fewer things better? What are the areas we want to be known for?”
Health and wellness is now a proactive pursuit of physical and mental well-being, unlike a decade ago when people assumed they were covered by health care and only went to the doctor when sick, and this shift is still rolling out to the majority of the population, creating an enormous tailwind for opportunity.
“health and wellness today as opposed to health before”
Forerunner developed six core tenets of brand by combining its own research, expert interviews, and consumer surveys of over 14,000 people across a list of 100 brands, including customers and noncustomers, scored on dimensions such as size and growth.
“we went to over 14,000 people over the course of the study”
Nike is a model for young investors because it started with a running shoe and, through consistent articulation of its ambition across product breadth, distribution, and marketing over 40 years, became a global athletic brand that remains the leader.
“they've done that through incredible articulation of that ambition through a broad product offering”
Forerunner's conviction typically forms when a founder walks in whose superpower matches an opportunity the firm already saw from its fundamental research, so the team recognizes that this founder's advantage can become the business's edge.
“when that founder walked through the door, and we were able to see that superpower strength that was absolutely critical to that business coming into light, other people pursuing it didn't have that”
Curated's expert-matching depends on technology that selects the best three experts from thousands based on a consumer's interests, skill, and experience, which would be impossible with manual handpicking.
“there is technology that is then helping to say these are the 3 best experts”
There is no playbook for consumer investing; frameworks help, but investors must stay open-minded because each company's success pattern does not necessarily transfer to another.
“It's actually a lot of what keeps this business interesting is that there's not a playbook”
Forerunner passed on resale despite strong tailwinds from waste awareness and the appeal of unique secondhand goods, because shipping costs on one-off items make unit economics hard to make work long term.
“there are very specific things that make it challenging on a unit economic basis”
Apple is a company to study because its product journey has been consistent across an ever-broader reach, so that a user can recognize an Apple product or even an Apple show, reflecting strong execution across all cylinders.
“There's something you just know it's an Apple product.”
Online platforms let people reach broader networks, more ideas, and niche affinity groups they could not otherwise access, which can provide belonging, even if the big social platforms fracture the experience.
“finding affinity groups that they wouldn't otherwise know how to access and finding some belonging there.”
The most underappreciated consumer trend is that consumers are savvy and cannot be fooled, so a lasting business requires a real partnership with consumers built on respect while also building a strong business.
“The consumer is really savvy, cannot fool the consumer.”
Consumer products are harder to develop early than enterprise software, because they have many more levers, including product, delivery, and brand messaging, and are more unpredictable than selling to a set of businesses with large contracts.
“Most things in consumer, it's more nuanced and there's many more levers in play”
Asking a person who has suffered a failure detailed questions about what happened, why, and what could be done differently helps them learn and rebuild confidence, which is a simple act anyone can do for others.
“What's nice about that story is something that we can all do for everyone.”
Tools like Shopify do not reverse the scale advantages of Amazon-like players, but add to the competitive field by enabling a new group of small sellers to compete digitally.
“I don't think it's necessarily reversing it as much as it's just adding to the party”
Green's children, who grew up with digital access from the start, lack the novelty effect earlier generations felt, and she believes the fluency may help them integrate online and offline life, though she worries that engagement tricks may rewire developing minds.
“The skeptic in me says the entire online world is full of gaming tricks that play to our mind and it's rewiring our young minds”
Many early-stage consumer products require building all technology from scratch as a first mover, which is inefficient compared with plugging into platforms like Shopify, though first movers benefit from less saturated advertising markets and an industry without the necessary skills.
“we had to build all our own technology. That was not efficient, it's a lot more efficient to plug into Shopify.”
A single investment is not enough to be successful in venture; sustained success requires many building-block investments, consistency, and some timely luck to propel the firm.
“If all you could talk about was one investment you made in your career, that's lucky.”
The hardest lesson in venture is that it is a people business, and the same rapport and closeness with founders that make it rewarding also make it draining during long periods of tough conversations, especially after several years of market change.
“this is a people business, it is.”
Deal flow comes naturally from deliberate curiosity, reading, and choosing whom to talk with, so investors end up investing where they spend their time, though deal flow still requires specific work.
“you almost can't help it. You still have to like specifically work for deal flow”
Consumer relevance and spending are concentrated in transformative life stages, which is why the market focuses on ages 18 to 45, while baby boomers hold a large amount of money but change behavior less.
“there's a ton of money, a ton of money in the baby boomer on the upside. And it's a shifting profile on what's discretionary and nondiscretionary.”
The term direct-to-consumer is a bad label because very few companies are truly direct, and companies with big ambitions must be where the consumer is, which may be direct or through other channels.
“which I think is like a bad word because very few companies are just direct-to-consumer.”
Forerunner overlaid archetype sizes with spending power and the cost of mere existence, separating nondiscretionary from discretionary spending, to understand where purchasing and adoption power actually sits.
“what's nondiscretionary and what's discretionary to really understand, again, where was their purchasing power, adoption power.”
The kindest thing anyone has done for Kirsten Green was her long-term partner's patience and support when she decided to throw herself into founding Forerunner while they had a baby.
“I have an incredible partner who I've been with for several decades.”
Despite concerns about manipulation, technology has made many things better and will continue to do so, so the goal is to help young people make the best of it.
“technology is a huge enabler. It made so many things better, and it's going to continue to make so many things better.”
Forerunner's brand study explicitly tested whether brands can be built and make a statement without a customer-first relationship, comparing impressions from customers and noncustomers.
“can you actually build a brand and make a statement without having had a customer-first relationship.”
When Forerunner launched in 2012, its thesis was that the commerce revolution began with the buyer, because the smartphone let consumers instantly act on purchase recommendations.
“we went with the initial thesis of this revolution of commerce is starting with the buyer”
The phrase customer obsession is overused, so it should be defined concretely as building product, delivery, and messaging holistically around what the customer needs and wants at every level.
“I think you need to go a little further and ask people like what does that mean to them to be customer obsessed”
Whether B2C or B2B, the key is whether the product naturally supports ongoing relationships and whether the pricing and packaging create a repeat dynamic that makes the product better over time, while not overfocusing on business model details that will change.
“is there some way about how you're packaging it or charging for it that makes sense to make it better but also creates the hype repeat dynamic.”
Managing children's technology use is a shared responsibility of parents and schools, comparable to rules on drugs and alcohol, even though technology is a huge enabler that improves many things.
“it becomes a conversation with parents and schools about like what sort of guidelines and rules do you put on technology”
A bold, high-profile company Green had backed through one of roughly eight or nine SPVs went under in 2008 when the team could not rewrite the business plan fast enough during a funding squeeze.
“And 2008 happened. And we got caught in a funding moment. And collectively as a team, we just couldn't figure out how to rewrite the business plan fast enough”
The consumer changes Green observes are structural and meaningful but less ubiquitous than a new OS-level platform like mobile, so they behave as chunkier trends that enable opportunities within specific categories rather than across the whole economy.
“Maybe it's a bit chunkier.”
The study grouped Americans into 12 psychographically driven archetypes rather than by age or income, though the groups still skew by age and finances in practice.
“Here are 12 archetypes, and across the 12 archetypes, we can more or less fit everybody into them.”
The early outcome of Dollar Shave Club in Forerunner's first four or five years was a needle-moving milestone that shifted doubters' perception and made the firm's ideas credible, though one success does not make later decisions automatic.
“one investment does not make anything you ever do again a no-brainer”
Founders have the hardest job, but venture investing is also hard work, and the investor's role in navigating difficult conversations through change is demanding even though it is rewarding.
“Founders have the hardest job. Everybody thinks VCs don't work very hard, but it's a hard job too.”