Katherine Boyle - Investing for America - [Invest Like the Best, EP.290]
What this covers
Patrick interviews Katherine Boyle, a general partner at Andreessen Horowitz who came to venture from reporting at The Washington Post and now leads the American Dynamism practice. She traces her interest in technology-driven change to watching a regional newspaper monopoly lose its syndication and advertising models in about five years. From there the conversation covers how she sizes up founders and sectors where government is the customer or the obstacle.
Defense gets the most concrete treatment. Boyle says the Pentagon's procurement system was built in the 1960s and 70s to buy tanks and battleships, which leaves it poorly equipped to buy software. About 40 percent of spend goes to five primes, and tailored line items and lobbying lock in suppliers. She cites the roughly $780 billion NDAA authorization alongside allied budgets. Her claim that consolidation from some 17,000 companies to five raised costs is contested, as is her argument that long-tenured bureaucrats drive much of the regulatory buildup.
The later sections turn to education and housing. She treats pandemic school closures as a spur for parental demand, points to Arizona's ESA program, and argues that college costs rose because of subsidy. She also favors deregulated prefabricated housing. The remaining threads are investing mechanics. Government-facing companies rarely show clean ARR growth at Series A. A government network effect can spread one county's adoption to its neighbors. The factory is the product in hardware. She also notes that roughly half of unicorns have a foreign-born co-founder.
Boyle argues that American Dynamism investments in national-interest sectors such as defense, housing, and education will be driven by technology rather than policy, and that the cultural split between Washington and Silicon Valley, plus decades of accumulated regulation, is the main obstacle.
- Washington runs on zero-sum, short-horizon incentives while Silicon Valley runs on positive-sum, long-horizon ones, so the two struggle to cooperate
- Regulatory accumulation since the 1970s has slowed government relative to the private sector, and procurement structures favor incumbents
- Founders with deep sector history and a serious mission are the best predictors of success, and early-stage investors should back them before revenue appears
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The DOD's procurement system was built in the 1960s and 1970s to acquire tanks and battleships, and now that it needs software it cannot acquire top talent and technology because the system was designed for hardware.
“We used to need battleships. We used to need tanks. We used to need hardware. And we have a procurement system that was set up in the sixties and seventies to acquire from the industrial base tanks battleships.”
About 40 percent of defense procurement spend goes to five companies, the primes, and tailored RFPs and lobbying make it hard for startups to win a share of that spend.
“something like 40% of that sort of procurement spend is spent on five companies that supply the DOD.”
Lobbying matters in defense because a congressional spending line item tailored to a company effectively commits the DOD to that supplier for the long term, making it hard to rebid, so companies seek to become a program of record.
“if you get a line item in a spending bill that is tailor made for you, that ultimately that is saying that you will work with that company in perpetuity.”
The growth of federal regulation since 1971, shown by the increasing page count of the federal register, has compounded over time so that government now moves far more slowly than the private sector, which has accelerated since the 1970s because of technology.
“And it shows all of the different charts of how many pages have been added to the federal registrar since 1971.”
Many deep tech companies spun out of universities fail not because the technology is weak but because founders cannot make the case or raise enough capital to cross the valley of death.
“there's a graveyard of companies with great technologists who've spun out of universities where the technology was great, but they couldn't make the case”
Defense industry consolidation has reduced the number of companies from roughly 17,000 to five dominant firms that receive 40 percent of the defense budget, which Boyle argues has raised costs because competition has disappeared.
“because of the rampant consolidation of going from 17,000 companies to five companies that are getting 40% of the defense budget, that the cost of defense has gone up dramatically”
Bipartisan push to send all children to college, subsidized by government, has made college roughly 10 times more expensive for the current generation than for their parents' generation and left millennials with extreme debt.
“which has made college 10 times more expensive for our generation than our parents' generation, because it is so subsidized.”
Much of the regulatory accumulation is driven by bureaucrats who have spent 20 to 30 years in Washington agencies rather than by democratically elected lawmakers.
“And that's not necessarily lawmakers who are democratically elected, those are bureaucrats who've been in Washington operating in different agencies for 20, 30 years.”
When parents opt out of traditional public schools, the remaining public system can improve because lower enrollment reduces class sizes, as with the move from a class of 40 to a class of 18.
“people opting out of the system often improves the system, the underlying system at hand”
Two years of remote schooling caused parents to see their children's curricula directly, creating demand for education transformation at K-12 and higher-ed levels, which Boyle argues is a major American dynamism category.
“when you go through two years of everything moving online, and then every parent seeing what their children are learning”
Authoritarian regimes such as Russia and China can tell their engineers exactly what to build, which makes it easier for them to get technology than it is for democracies that must persuade people to work with government through procurement processes.
“Russia and China are adversaries have very different views of their countries and their authoritarian regimes that can actually tell their innovators, their engineers, exactly what they want them to do.”
The 19th-century school model emphasized grammar and reading for universal literacy, but the 21st-century economy requires universal STEM education, and parents are turning to alternatives when public schools do not teach higher-level math.
“universal stem education would be something that is 100% necessary going into the 21st century. And that's not something that's happening at public schools across America.”
Roughly 50 percent of unicorn companies valued at over one billion dollars have a foreign-born co-founder, reflecting the US system's success in attracting top international talent.
“something like 50% of companies have a foreign born founder, that is an extraordinary statistics.”
Housing, education, and healthcare are the most regulated and most subsidized sectors with the least competition, which explains why their prices have risen while unregulated technology categories like TVs have fallen.
“It's really housing, education, and healthcare. And when you think they are the most regulated sectors, they're also the most subsidized by government and there's the least competition.”
Housing affordability is the most fundamental human good, and the most promising route is deregulated, prefabricated housing, because the places with the worst shortages are those with the hardest permitting regimes.
“The hard thing about housing is the places that have the hardest time because they are so regulated in terms of permitting are the ones with the dire housing shortages.”
Two years of school closures during COVID changed parental attitudes so that parents will not tolerate continued closures and want alternatives to traditional schooling, which has created grassroots pressure on politicians.
“COVID was the inevitable see change that forced ... I don't think you can come out of two years of school closures worried about continued school closures.”
Boyle's time at the Washington Post exposed her to the rapid collapse of a regional newspaper monopoly, where syndication and advertising models died within about five years, which pushed her to study the technology-driven forces she later saw in Silicon Valley.
“Watching the monopoly just be destroyed within five years by innovation.”
The US NDAA in the most recent passage authorized about 780 billion dollars, and combined with allied countries like the UK, New Zealand, and Australia the total spend exceeds 1.2 to 1.3 trillion dollars annually, before counting new business through the State Department.
“the NDAA is 780 billion dollars I believe in the last NDAA that was passed.”
How a company designs and runs its manufacturing process, including early factory decisions and automation, becomes the product because those decisions compound into greater scale, quality, and replicability across successive factories.
“how you do the process ... the actual process and decisions you make about the system are the resulting product.”
Hardware and government-facing companies take longer to show revenue growth, so the traditional Series A metric of annual recurring revenue growth does not apply, and these companies often become explosive only at Series C or D after they reach government contracts.
“So oftentimes these companies accelerate at series C or at series D and they become explosive competing against no one”
A network effect in government occurs when one county adopts a working product and neighboring counties follow to appear effective to their citizens, so successful government adoption can spread rapidly across regions.
“if one county does something and it's working, all of the other neighboring counties wants to look great too”
Arizona's move to a universal education savings account lets parents opt out of public schools and fund alternative programs, creating a market for suppliers that compete with government education services.
“the state of Arizona going to a universal ESA, education savings account, where now parents can opt-out of the public school system”
The culture of Washington media and electoral politics is zero-sum with short time horizons, while Silicon Valley operates in positive-sum games with long horizons, and this fundamental misunderstanding of each other's culture is a core reason the two ecosystems fail to work together.
“So if you think about Washington media or even electoral culture, it's a zero sum game.”
In categories that are very hard to build in, only one winner is needed, and that winner's success opens the floodgates because the playbook for working with government becomes visible to everyone, producing many fast followers.
“you often see this with categories that are very difficult to build in is you only really need one winner. It opens the floodgates for everyone understanding the playbook.”
The DOD's move-slow culture arises because officials fear being fired for backing the wrong company, which leaves them prioritizing cover and paperwork over speed while adversaries with authoritarian control move faster.
“I don't want to get fired because I invested in the wrong company and now we don't have drones.”
Venture capital will work in government-related categories, because innovation everywhere comes from risk capital and a system where people who can tell a story get capital outside banks, and the real question is why government has not captured these benefits.
“our contrarian view is that it 100% will.”
Startups can enter defense by targeting small pockets of spending that primes will not pursue, using these as proof points before moving up to larger, established categories that have existed for 20 to 30 years.
“starting with those smaller pockets of money that really don't touch the larger players is the way that you get an entry point, a proof point.”
The resurgence of American federalism is technology-enabled because remote work requires only internet infrastructure, so people can move to states whose values and policies they prefer while keeping their jobs, and Boyle argues Starlink will enable this in new ways.
“I believe the resurgence of federalism is real and it is technology enabled. I've made the case that Starlink will enable a new type of federalism”
In defense and other government-facing categories, the best founders are unique historians of their sector who know the problem in depth, unlike consumer founders who often solve a problem they personally experienced.
“they're unique historians of the sector while an enterprise or consumer, you often see young, maybe college dropouts”
Deep government expertise can lead founders to nihilism, the belief that nothing can get done, so the best founders combine sector history with a belief that change is possible.
“expertise in government can lead to sort of nihilism. It can lead to this belief that like, oh, you're never going to get it done.”
Government-facing hardware companies are hard to build from seed through Series B, but after reaching contracts and critical mass they accelerate sharply at Series C or D against incumbents rather than many fast followers, because government adoption has network effects across counties.
“there's a network effect that exists in government that I think a lot of people don't talk about, which is if one county does something and it's working, all of the other neighboring counties wants to look great too”
By story Boyle means not hype but the founder's grasp of the market's history, the ability to explain why technology matters to the customer, and enough seriousness to survive the first three hard years.
“I'm not talking about like hype men or hype women. I mean, I'm talking about really understanding the history”
The best founders in American Dynamism are unique historians of their sector who know the procurement and technical history cold, which lets them see opportunities that outsiders miss and convince customers.
“they're unique historians of the sector while an enterprise or consumer, you often see young, maybe college dropouts”
A firm that cannot compete on history should compete on philosophy, and in hard missions like defense, founders care about mission alignment, which made early defense investors who were laughed at valuable partners.
“if you can't compete on history, compete on philosophy.”
Government-facing companies such as SpaceX, Anduril, and Flock Safety do not face many fast followers because fundraising and hardware barriers are high, unlike software markets where competitors quickly copy successful categories.
“The reason why SpaceX doesn't have fast followers, Anduril doesn't have the same fast followers competing in the same way. Flock certainly doesn't.”
The core trait Boyle looks for in founders is seriousness, defined as a combination of capability and will, a ferocity to run through walls that she believes cannot be quantified but must be present for a mission to be credible.
“I divide it as a unique combination of capability and will where there is just such a ferocity in the founder that they are going to run through walls”
Thousands of people who have worked at SpaceX can leave and build space startups because Elon Musk built the company in public, which taught them how to work with government, the importance of the factory, and the pace required.
“Elon has been building in public. There are now thousands of people who've worked at SpaceX who can leave SpaceX and go build space startups with the playbook”
The best engineering talent no longer goes to traditional defense primes like Lockheed Martin and instead goes to exceptional startups, a trend that has developed over roughly the last 15 years.
“I think there is now an understanding that the best talent does not go to work at Lockheed Martin, that they go to work at exceptional startups.”
The US has a robust prefab housing manufacturing base, but prefab is marketed as a low-income solution, and the opportunity is to design modern prefab homes for middle-class buyers in deregulated states.
“We actually have prefab manufacturing in this country that is very robust. I think there's a marketing challenge around prefab”
Remote work has led people in San Francisco and New York to move to ex-urban areas where building is easier, and this out-migration will pressure high-cost cities to deregulate permitting, enabling technology to make housing construction easier.
“if enough people leave, I do think that there will be changes there”
The risk in early-stage defense investing is highest in the earliest stages, but once companies pass that stage they can compound for much longer because competitors are absent, which makes SpaceX the most valuable private American company.
“once they hit a certain escape velocity, there are no competitors in many ways.”
Rather than asking why venture capital fails in civic categories, the real question is why government-regulated and government-funded sectors have not received technology's benefits, which Boyle attributes more to regulation and to cultural differences than to founders' reluctance.
“I think it has less to do with impetus of founders wanting to work in these sectors. I think it has more to do with this question”
Government's failure to deliver things quickly is mainly a regulatory problem combined with a cultural gap, since the most important obstacle is the accumulated weight of rules rather than the technology itself.
“I would argue that it's much more on the regulatory side, but also this cultural difference”
COVID-era school closures were the inevitable change that made parents reconsider how their children are educated, and they are unlikely to accept continued closures, which is why Boyle is more bullish on K-12 than on higher education.
“I think COVID was the inevitable see change that forced”
Boyle anchors her evaluation of founders on how well they know the market and how well they can explain why the technology matters to the customer, and in government sales a deep historical knowledge that produces customer empathy is what lets a buyer take a bet.
“I always anchored on, how well does this founder know the market? How well can this founder explain why the technology is so important to the customer?”
Investors who want to back defense founders must share their mission, because early defense companies like Anduril faced ridicule and claims of harming society in 2017, and only aligned investors will be trusted by founders.
“you have to be mission aligned with these companies and they have to believe your mission aligned.”
John Gall's Systems Bible argues that the goal of any system is not the purpose it was designed for but keeping itself alive, and Patrick applies this to Congress and government.
“the goal of any system is not the thing it was designed for, but it's actually to keep itself alive.”
Boyle's investing in defense is bottom-up rather than top-down, because founders are the most informed about what the DOD actually needs, and she declines to predict geopolitical needs or dictate what government wants.
“I think in these categories, it's usually the founders who are the most up to speed on actually, this is what the DOD cares about.”
Children learn at different rates and levels, and the best educational environment is small, tutoring-style instruction, which parents have always known but which public scale does not easily provide.
“I think we know the best way to educate kids is in a small environment, a tutoring environment has always been kids learn at very different rates.”
States like Texas, Florida, and Arizona that gain migrants cannot build schools fast enough, so deregulation enabling online learning and small school formats can meet demand faster than traditional construction and five-year funding cycles.
“you can't build schools fast enough to educate kids. So you have to deregulate”
Miami Mayor Francis Suarez used Twitter to evangelize his city to a specific industry, showing that a city can differentiate itself through policy and attract one targeted sector without needing everyone to move.
“I think that mayor Francis Suarez as a perfect example of this as sort of an unknown mayor, was able to get on Twitter”
California's accessory dwelling unit legislation, which allows small backyard homes without extensive permitting, has spurred a wave of housing startups, although many focus on the high end of the market, similar to the Tesla model of building luxury first and descending the cost curve.
“we've seen an influx of housing startups, mostly related to ADU legislation or accessory dwelling unit legislation in California”
The primary return difference in defense investing is extra risk at the earliest stage, because companies attempt untested approaches and may be crushed by incumbents, but companies that survive can compound for much longer than typical software companies.
“The real difference is I'd say in the earliest of stages, you taking on a little bit more risk”
Aerospace and defense were long robust but closed to new entrants; now new space and new defense companies from Silicon Valley are winning contracts and providing working models of how to sell to the DOD.
“now there are winners, now there are examples of how to work with DOD, and we're really bullish there.”
Most progress in housing, education and other regulated sectors will come from technological improvements rather than policy changes, and the investment thesis rests on the belief that technology rather than policy solves core national issues.
“most of the progress that is going to come in these sectors are going to come from technological improvements, not from policy improvements, in our opinion.”
A provision that would have blocked Chinese drone maker DJI from selling to government agencies was struck from the NDAA, and the Financial Times reported DJI and the CCP spent about 4 million dollars over 2018 to 2022 lobbying to stop the ban.
“The Financial Times said it was $4 million over 2018 to 2022 that DJI and the CCP have been able to successfully lobby the US government”
Boyle's firm invests at seed because hardware and government-facing companies go further down the J-curve, often with no revenue at Series A, so evaluation should rest on founder profile and company profile rather than ARR growth.
“Oftentimes they have no revenue. Oftentimes they're still working on V2 of the product”
Being able to afford housing is probably the most fundamental human good and the thing people worry about most, which is why Boyle sees housing as a relevant subcategory of American Dynamism.
“being able to afford housing is probably the most fundamental human good.”
A key function of traditional public school is providing a place where children are watched while parents work, a role that has become essential as the dual-income household became the norm, which makes deregulated alternatives harder to scale.
“the ultimate reason why public education is so important ... is because it operates as a way for oftentimes what has become the norm to income households in America, where everyone is working.”
The places that have the hardest time building housing because of strict permitting are the ones with the most dire shortages, which makes housing a government problem more than a technology problem.
“The hard thing about housing is the places that have the hardest time because they are so regulated in terms of permitting are the ones with the dire housing shortages.”
Culture-war debates that make math something kids need not learn, or that cast math as a bad word, are pushing parents to take higher-level math into their own hands with state-funded alternatives.
“if there is culture wars happening in certain cities where making math something that kids don't necessarily have to learn or making math a bad word, parents are getting upset about that.”
Media consolidated from about a dozen regional newspapers that mattered to a handful, and major outlets now play a tech game, competing for the news cycle through Twitter-style distribution.
“there used to be probably a dozen regional newspapers that mattered, now there's a few, there's a handful.”
Journalists operate like hedge fund managers, judged daily on whether their work goes viral or reaches the front page, which makes them play a repeated zero-sum game where only one person wins.
“journalists actually function more like hedge fund managers and that they have their marks every day.”
Silicon Valley's abundance culture holds that more companies in an ecosystem is good for everyone, which is why the same investors back multiple companies in one space.
“The abundance culture of Silicon Valley is a real thing. The more companies that exist here is actually good for the ecosystem.”
The US has a cultural bias that every kid should go to college, which undervalues trades and manufacturing even though these areas have the most extreme labor shortages.
“which we know are where the most extreme labor shortages are in this country, which we do not celebrate as a culture.”
States are beginning to treat education like healthcare, using education savings accounts that give taxpayer dollars to parents to choose schools, which resembles the health savings account model.
“states get very excited about the prospect of treating education, the same way we treat healthcare. So the ESA movement education, saving account movement, is a really exciting movement because it looks a lot like FSA.”
Parents are increasingly choosing micro schools, homeschooling with shared tutors, or one teacher for five students, because children learn at different rates and parents found this model more economical and controllable during COVID.
“parents were pleasantly surprised by hiring one teacher for five students.”
Adapting Margaret Thatcher's line that Europe is built on history and America on philosophy, Boyle advises that if an investor cannot compete on history, they should compete on philosophy, which matters especially to founders on difficult national-interest missions.
“In all of investing, if you can't compete on history, compete on philosophy.”
Patrick observes that America holds about 5% of world population but about 60% of enterprise value or market cap of companies, suggesting the American system has produced exceptional innovation outcomes.
“it's got, I don't know, 5% of the world population and 60% of the enterprise value or market cap of companies.”
Patrick notes that many defense businesses are old-school physical companies with complex CapEx and different business models, unlike the software companies that dominate Silicon Valley.
“A lot of these businesses are old school in some sense, they're building something physical.”
Small pockets of government, particularly the DOD, are beginning to change because the cost of not moving has become catastrophic, leading to work with fast AI and startup companies.
“the DOD being one of them, where it's become just so catastrophic to not move that there are changes being made”
The kindest thing anyone has done for Boyle is her mother giving up her later years to help raise Boyle's child in a multi-generational household, which Boyle sees as a return to a traditional model.
“my mother committing her Twilight years to help us raise our child.”
The war in Ukraine is accelerating the realization that Russia and China are resurgent adversaries, so the government now understands it must bring Silicon Valley's best talent directly into defense work.
“I would actually say Ukraine is also leading to an acceleration here”
Flock Safety, a hardware-software license plate reader company founded in 2017 in Atlanta, took a long time to build but now operates in all 50 states after starting with homeowners associations, illustrating why early-stage investing in hardware-software hybrids is hard but rewarding.
“They are hardware, software hybrid, small license plate reader, empowered by AI that tracks cars, not people. Founded Atlanta, Georgia, founded in 2017”
Nuclear family structures were bad for society, and multi-generational households, where grandparents help raise children, are a valuable arrangement that modern life has abandoned.
“I am a firm believer in multi-generational living the nuclear family in many ways was actually bad for society.”
Consolidated legacy newspapers like the New York Times and Washington Post remain powerful, but they now compete through tech distribution such as Twitter-driven news-cycle dynamics, which did not exist when Boyle worked at the Post.
“they are playing a tech game. And that was not the case maybe 10, 15 years ago.”
A second-order opportunity in American dynamism is the supplier layer for aerospace and defense, including manufacturing automation, which Hadrian exemplifies.
“there's sort of an underlying sector beyond that, which is suppliers in those categories.”
Startups move from small non-recurring business grants to small-dollar grants that could later be institutionalized by Congress, but this step requires lobbying Congress as well as procurement officers.
“you go from small business grants, which are non-recurring to these other types of small dollar grants”
Immigrants fleeing collapsed or authoritarian states bring a hustle culture and proud attachment to capitalism and the American flag, which Boyle sees as a central feature of the American story and of Miami's energy.
“there's a hustle culture I would say that comes from having left somewhere that is collapsed”
The DOD has made good progress learning how Silicon Valley operates, and Silicon Valley is learning Washington's institutions, so cross-cultural exchange is the path forward.
“I do think the DOD has actually done a very good job of learning how Silicon Valley works.”
Founders in Silicon Valley now want to work with government and are excited about defense categories, a sharp change from when Boyle moved to the Valley almost a decade earlier when that was not the case.
“Silicon Valley wants to work with government. When I moved here almost 10 years ago, it certainly wasn't the case.”
Immigrants such as Chris Power of Hadrian, who came from Australia, show that being embraced by the country and its entrepreneurs is a feature of American defense industrial building that should be celebrated.
“Chris power of Hadrian came from Australia a few years ago.”
Boyle treats moving from journalism to Silicon Valley as a research project, and argues that early-stage venture investing is the best career for someone obsessed with being at the forefront of cultural shift.
“Approached moving to Silicon Valley almost as a research subject of how do I understand what's going on”
Journalism and venture investing are similar because both are driven by truth-seeking and curiosity, and early-stage investing offers a similar way to track cultural shifts and what comes next.
“There's a lot of similarities between investing and between journalism, truth seeking is the cliche obvious thing.”