Julio Vasconcellos & Mate Pencz - Investing in Latin America - [Invest Like the Best, EP.296]
What this covers
Host Patrick talks with Julio Vasconcellos of Canary and Mate Pencz of Atlantico, both investors who were founders first. Julio was Facebook's first Brazil country lead and started Peixe Urbano. Mate co-founded Loft, the Brazilian real estate company. The talk follows Atlantico's annual digital report. It sizes the region by a tech penetration index of about 1.5%, against roughly 50% for the US, 20% for China and 15% for India. Mercado Libre is the only technology company among the region's ten largest by market cap.
The middle stretch is about financial plumbing. Pix reportedly moves around one trillion reais a month about two years after launch. The guests credit a central bank mandate that put a Pix button on every bank's home screen for under $10 million. They forecast synthetic credit cards, installment lending and securitization built on the rail. They also cover Brazil's profitable unsecured personal credit market, which Mate says leaves banks over-earning (a contested claim). Mortgage penetration in Brazil is in the low teens as a share of GDP, against 50 to 60 percent or more in the US. Other threads include small firms that are numerous but unproductive, and informality that traps young workers. Julio links wealth concentration to the region's leftward political turn, and he says crypto's logic is sound but its usage has not yet shown up.
The last part turns to craft. They argue Mexico differs from Brazil more than Texas from California. They discuss the wage gap for engineers, human capital as the binding constraint, and resilience after failure. They also cover Julio's lesson on focus from Peixe Urbano, small funds, and whether Latin American venture returns are as strong as claimed.
Latin America is an early, under-penetrated tech market whose growth rests on digitalization and maturing local talent rather than macro conditions, and Brazil's government-built Pix payment rail shows how state design can seed a platform that private firms then build on.
- Tech penetration is about 1.5% in Latin America versus over 50% in the US, so the catch-up runway is very large
- Digitalization steals share from incumbents regardless of GDP swings, and human capital, not capital, is the binding constraint
- Pix reached enormous volume within two years because the central bank mandated bank adoption and removed the chicken-and-egg problem
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Small businesses are about 80 percent of US businesses, 85 percent in Brazil, and over 90 percent across most of Latin America, but small businesses contribute around 50 percent of US GDP versus only about 25 percent in Latin America, so the region has many more small firms that are far less productive.
“in Latin America, they only contribute about 25%. So there's a lot more of them, but they're a lot less productive.”
Julio's first company, Peixe Urbano, spread across six Latin American countries and four business units from daily deals to restaurant reservations and food delivery, and he concluded that focus on one market and product at a time is critical for entrepreneurs.
“In our case with Peixe Urbano, we were across six different countries all over Latin America. We had different... Four business units”
Mexico differs from Brazil more than Texas differs from California, so treating Latin America as one homogeneous block misses large regional differences in culture, regulation, and internet penetration that matter by business type.
“certainly Mexico differs much more from Brazil than a Texas differs from California”
Fintech is the top category among publicly traded and unicorn businesses in the region, and it is highly regulated and differs substantially by country, so cross-border fintech models face distinct regulatory constraints.
“That category is a highly regulated category and differs very much by country and by region.”
High informality in Latin American work, where many independent workers are unregistered, untaxed, and without benefits, disproportionately hits young people and creates a cycle in which lacking formal jobs prevents building the work history needed for future formal employment.
“You don't build up your curriculum and your work history. And then that prevents you from getting another formal job.”
On a productivity-adjusted basis there is a glaring wage gap between engineers in San Francisco and engineers in Latin America, Eastern Europe, and Africa, which creates a massive arbitrage opportunity for companies willing to hire technical talent across the globe.
“There is today this massive arbitrage opportunity if you're open to hiring engineers or technical talent”
Brazil's personal credit market is one of the largest and most profitable in the world, and Brazilian banks significantly over-earn versus international peers because lending is concentrated in unsecured personal credit rather than collateralized products.
“The banks here are significantly over-earning versus international peers.”
At early stage, paying 10 million versus 20 million matters little if the company becomes a 20 billion dollar outcome, but paying higher prices carries real opportunity cost when investing in companies of that potential.
“whether you paid 10 million bucks or 20 million bucks, doesn't really matter when it's a $20 billion company”
Mortgage penetration in Brazil is in the mid-to-low teens as a percent of GDP, versus roughly 50 to 60 percent or more in the US and Canada and about 20 percent or more in Chile.
“Mortgage penetration in Brazil today hovers in the mid to low teens versus GDP.”
Higher wealth concentration among the top 10 percent or top 1 percent in Latin America than in many other regions helps explain the recent shift toward left-of-center governments and redistributive, social-leaning programs in Mexico, Colombia, and Chile.
“that serves to explain a little bit of why, in recent years, you've had a shift towards more left of center governments”
The logic that crypto is more valuable in Latin America, given hyperinflation and remittance costs, is sound, but the reality has not yet proven out in usage results, though the potential remains.
“It's a great discussion because I do think that the logic is there, but the reality hasn't really proven out yet.”
Among the top 10 companies by market cap in Latin America, Mercado Libre, at roughly a 30-something billion dollar valuation, is the only technology company, while the top US tech giants are each 30 to 70 times larger than Mercado Libre.
“That's the only technology company in the top 10, otherwise it's a very traditional Petrobras and Velez and Walmart and Ambev”
Latin American venture funds have performed in roughly the top quartile of global venture returns, and because few investors compete for strong companies, competition is lower and returns are concentrated in a few players.
“the level of competition is just frankly lower. Not because people are better or worse, but just because there's less of us going after them”
Digitalization of the economy is the main secular driver of company growth in Latin America for the next 10 to 20 years, because most growth comes from taking share from incumbents that have not innovated, so it holds whether GDP grows 3% or shrinks 3%.
“whether GDP grows by 3% or shrinks by 3%, really the vast majority of their growth is coming from stealing share from incumbents”
Adjacencies that are saturated in the US, such as listings, marketplaces, and iBuyer-style services, remain empty in Brazil, so a company like Loft can go first with an iBuyer model, then expand into marketplace and listing businesses, each of which could be a multi-billion dollar opportunity.
“some of the opportunities in Latin America are oftentimes much larger than their peers or their comparables in the United States”
The Brazilian central bank bootstrapped Pix top-down by mandating that all banks and digital payment providers place a prominent Pix button on their home screens, which solved the network chicken-and-egg problem that normally slows new payment rails, for under $10 million of government investment.
“They mandated all the banks and all the digital payments. Said look, you need to have a prominent button on your home screen”
The traits that made Julio a weaker entrepreneur, broad curiosity and spreading attention, became strengths as an investor, because investing requires learning across many contexts while founding requires narrow focus.
“Ironically, almost the opposite of an investor, right? An investor you kind of have to be able to go broad intellectually curious”
Because local investors run small, focused craft funds rather than diversified asset management franchises, there is more at stake in each investment, which Mate believes should theoretically produce superior returns.
“This is really a craft business here. Essentially all of the local investors are highly focused, highly craft centric”
The Brazilian central bank is taking a long view on Pix, aiming to use the rails for securitization and collateralized transactions to lower the cost of credit, not just reduce payment fees or displace cards and cash.
“they're going as far as thinking about securitization, thinking about collateralized transactions, thinking about how to ultimately bring down the cost of credit”
The key ingredient for success in Latin American entrepreneurship is the ability to get back up after failure, which Mate estimates is 80 percent or more of what it takes, combined with iteration and pattern recognition in building tech-enabled organizations.
“It's really about making sure that you can get back up after failure rather than not getting beaten down”
The biggest bottleneck on Latin American tech growth is human capital, specifically people with experience building and scaling technology companies, and this cannot be solved by throwing more money at it because talent requires time to develop through mistakes and new companies.
“that's a bottleneck that you can't solve by just throwing more money at it. You just need time.”
Latin America's tech penetration index is about 1.5%, versus a little over 50% for the US, about 20% for China, and about 15% for India, measured as the total value of public tech companies relative to GDP.
“Latin America's 1.5%.”
Data from China and India suggests that once an ecosystem reaches a dozen or two dozen unicorns, a wave of hundreds more follows, and Mate expects a similar but more muted flywheel in Latin America given slower GDP growth.
“once you've got one or two dozen unicorns in China, you almost have this Cambrian explosion of hundreds of others following”
Brazil's Pix instant payment system is processing roughly one trillion reais, about $200 billion, in payments per month only about two years after launch, making it the largest form of digital payment in Brazil ahead of credit cards, bank transfers, and debit cards.
“we likely now in the last month cross something like a trillion Reals, which is roughly about $200 billion of payments every month”
Because Pix is a programmable, blockchain-like rail built by the government, it could enable synthetic credit cards and installment buy-now-pay-later on top of it, with credit extended on the fly by any competing institution.
“you potentially build synthetic credit card, for example”
Latin America has the highest penetration of creators and influencers on social networks and the greatest influence over the population, yet one of the lowest abilities to monetize that influence anywhere in the world, so NFTs could help creators monetize their work, though this is still early.
“we have the highest level of penetration of creators and influencers on social networks”
In Atlantico's annual survey of graduating students at top Brazilian universities and Brazilians abroad, tech and startups, including big tech, became the top destination for graduates, ahead of banking, consulting, and traditional companies, even after the market downturn.
“the number one destination of the top college students that are graduating, ahead of historic competitors like banking and consulting”
Pix functions as a competing payment rail to Visa and MasterCard that is as efficient and more fraud-resistant, because its transactions are irreversible, and the central bank president has publicly described it this way.
“you now have a competing payment rail to what you had with Visa and MasterCard”
China's tech giants grew to scale inside a huge domestic market, while the same playbook in Latin America is constrained by a much smaller economy, so Latin American tech companies must become global to reach comparable size.
“that same playbook in Latin America is just constrained by the size of the economy, which is much smaller than China's”
Valuations in Latin American startups rose sharply as money flooded in, reaching too high even relative to the US because thinner local markets amplify price swings, and the region likely overcorrected but remained expensive for the past year or two.
“the valuations kind of really skyrocketed. And I do think they went a little too high, even compared to the United States”
Early-stage company building in Brazil is very local and hard to do from abroad, so global funds should partner with local experts, combining local understanding with global scale, as Atlantico has done in co-investing alongside international funds.
“If you're a global fund sitting in an office in New York City or Silicon Valley, it's going to be hard for you to help a company hire ahead of sales”
Atlantico's selective, high-conviction boutique model lets it concentrate support on a few founders and has won every competitive deal since inception, but the risk is picking wrong or missing the next Mercado Libre, Loft, or Nubank.
“since inception we've been able to win every single competitive deal that we've been in”
The Latin American venture funding environment has fewer than half a dozen firms with over $100 million in assets under management, one of them being Atlantico or Canary, compared with roughly several thousand in the United States, a gap of multiple orders of magnitude.
“you were really talking about less than half a dozen firms with over a hundred million dollars of AUM, one of them being ours”
Investors who have operated in emerging markets develop pattern recognition for red tape that US and European investors underestimate, and in Loft's case about a third of employees now come from prior tech experience, a pool that did not exist eight to ten years ago.
“almost about a third of all our employee base is in some shape or form coming from a prior tech experience”
A pro-innovation agenda from Brazil's central bank, including open banking (now called open finance) and instant payments, has been a regulatory tailwind accelerating FinTech innovation alongside infrastructure that already exists.
“this regulatory tailwind mainly driven by the Brazilian central bank that has had this very pro-innovation agenda”
Beyond outsourcing through firms such as Accenture, companies are now hiring Latin American engineers directly, which Mate expects will slowly level the wage gap and feed a local flywheel of wealth, education investment, and reduced inequality over coming years and decades.
“people are going direct and hiring these engineers directly. And hence I think slowly but surely leveling the playing field”
Access to capital, which was a constraint a decade ago, is no longer a binding constraint for Latin American startups, because multiple local and regional funds now have later-vintage funds and dry powder, and international growth investors fund companies from Series A through IPO.
“access to capital used to be a constraint. I don't think it's one today.”
A second generation of Latin American founders, such as those with studies or work abroad, is building with a global mindset, and companies such as Wildlife, which has a split headquarters in São Paulo and San Francisco, and GymPass, with most revenue from the US and Europe, already show global footprints.
“the second generation of... serial entrepreneurs... They come to the table with much more of a global mindset and global ambition.”
Mexico is among the world's leading remittance markets, and remittance costs are prohibitively high for dependent families, so DeFi protocols that transfer money more cheaply and efficiently should take hold, with Mexico's Bitso showing early growth on this opportunity.
“the cost of doing so is so prohibitively expensive or so usurious to those people that depend on the remittance”
The second wave of Latin American fintech focuses on B2B payments and business credit, especially embedded finance and embedded credit combined with software, as opposed to the consumer-focused first wave.
“that's much more focused on B2B and thinking about how businesses pay each other and give each other credit”
Pix is now the most frequently used form of payment on a daily basis in Brazil, tied with cash, so it is eating all payments rather than only digital ones.
“Pix is now the most frequently used form of payments on a daily basis, tied with cash in Brazil.”
Pix took about a quarter as long as India's UPI to reach a billion transactions, despite Brazil having about a sixth of India's population.
“it took Pix about a quarter as long as UPI to reach a billion transactions. And this is in a country of Brazil, which has a sixth of the population of India.”
Companies with revenue in local currency, such as Loft, face a cat-and-mouse dynamic when competing for engineers against global firms that earn in dollars and can pay in dollars, so employers must compete on intangibles rather than compensation alone.
“our revenues, our top line is generated in local currency. Whereas, some of these global firms are earning in dollars”
Latin America has roughly three to four times as many soonicorns as public tech companies, and as these likely go public in the next five years, tech penetration should rise from about 1.5% toward 5% and then into double digits.
“you probably have about three or four times as many companies that are in that unicorn or soonicorn scale”
Vertical software in Latin America can solve an acute need in one vertical and then expand horizontally within it, capturing more value than in more competitive markets like the US or Europe, where the adjacencies are already occupied.
“you can kind of expand horizontally within that vertical and capture a lot more value there”
Latin America has internet penetration higher than China and India and one of the highest digital usage and adoption rates in the world, a region with about 600 million people and about $5 trillion of GDP.
“We have internet penetration that's higher than China and India. I think digital usage and adoption, that's one of the highest in the world.”
Pix lets users register a unique key such as phone number, email, personal ID or random key, attach it to one or more bank accounts or wallets, and pay via QR codes, so payees need only that key.
“you can register to get a unique identifier key... And you can have multiple keys, and you attach it to a single bank account”
Middle-class growth in Brazil and other Latin American countries flattened because of COVID, and the region lost a couple of years of education and recovery, with poorer economies taking longer to bounce back than richer ones.
“with COVID, that's kind of flattened out. And actually we've lost a couple of years”
Five years before the 2022 conversation there were no unicorns in Brazil, and the current generation of unicorns scaled only over the last decade, so the talent pipeline that now staffs startups is very recent.
“five years ago, there were no unicorns in Brazil”
Brazilian unicorns such as Wildlife, a gaming company now among the biggest globally, and GymPass, which earns most of its revenue in the US and Europe, show that regional companies can achieve global footprints.
“GymPass, which is another Brazilian unicorn also that has the majority of its revenues now coming from the US and Europe.”
The first wave of Latin American fintech was B2C, with neobanks, cheaper digital payments, and online investing displacing oligopolistic incumbents that had offered lower-quality, higher-cost services than comparable markets.
“that first wave was really a B2C consumer focused FinTech revolution of the neobanks”
Brazil went through what Julio calls the second-worst recession in history from 2014 to 2017, following the impeachment of the president, which made Brazilian GDP growth more volatile and sideways over the decade than in China or India, and in dollar terms looked even weaker.
“I think it was the second worst recession in history in that period of 2014, through 2017, following the impeachment of the President”
Entrepreneurs who solve problems acutely present in Latin America in a very local way may produce world-class solutions with global product-market fit, so bottom-up thinking is a source of regional leadership.
“think about problems that we have acutely here and solve them in a very local way and in a way that could actually have global product market fit.”
Latin America's population is younger than most developed countries and is at the peak of its demographic boom, so the region is in prime time to capture growth, but the window is beginning to close.
“I think we're hitting that demographic boom, hitting the peak of that. So we're in prime time”
Direct selling through networks such as Natura, long used to reach the bottom of the pyramid, is moving to influencers and social media, creating a model similar to China's social selling that incumbents are developing in ways no one else is doing.
“you're seeing a lot more of how do you do direct selling through influencers and through social media”
Gabriel Security in Rio de Janeiro uses a network of cameras linked by homeowners and AI to protect residents on streets and in homes, a bottoms-up solution to acute local crime that could have global product-market fit.
“They use a network of cameras joined together by a network of homeowners and AI.”
Julio caps his funds at about $100 million and makes roughly one deal every two months, versus two deals every two weeks for US managers in the prior year, and Mate sees this discipline as hardwired into Latin American entrepreneurs' tenacity.
“Julio caps his funds at a hundred million dollars and not more than that. So when folks were doing two deals every two weeks in the US last year, he was doing one deal every two months.”
About half of Latin America's GDP is in Brazil and about a quarter in Mexico, with the remainder spread across a long tail including Colombia, Peru, Chile, and Argentina, making Brazil the main domestic consumption market.
“about half of that GDP is in Brazil”
eCommerce penetration in Brazil is around 6 or 7 percent of retail, far below the high teens in the US, which gives a large runway for online growth.
“I think eCommerce penetration is like 6 or 7% in Brazil, which is much lower than say the US at high teens”
Altruistic mentorship and generational knowledge transfer, such as founders paying forward their time and knowledge, is what made Silicon Valley what it is, and Julio sees the same behavior emerging in Latin America.
“a lot of this kind of altruism and I think generational knowledge transfer is ultimately what made Silicon Valley be the kind of place that it is today”
Remote work is creating a two-way talent flow in which senior leaders move to Latin America, as dLocal and Rappi have done, with Rappi keeping much of its senior leadership in Austin, and foreign workers relocating to Colombia, Brazil, or Mexico with their families.
“it's no longer sort of a one way street of talent from Brazil working for the US or US folks working for Latin America”
Large B2B banks are using Pix as a wedge to offer businesses programmable, instant collection and payment that is quicker and easier than existing systems, which has given those banks significant traction in Brazil.
“we've seen big B2B banks use this as wedge to allow banks to collect and pay in a much quicker, easier programmable and instant manner”
Early proof points of cheaper, Pix-enabled high-value transactions are appearing in Brazil's real estate market, and auto loans show a similar pickup.
“we're starting to see early proof points of that in the real estate market”
If Latin America closes even part of the tech penetration gap to China and India over the next decade, the value created would be measured in the trillions of dollars, an order-of-magnitude increase.
“you're talking about an order of magnitude increase that when you consider how much that's worth, that's measured really in the trillions of dollars”
International investors are taking their foot off the gas in Latin America, but there has been no exodus, and local funds are now more active than foreign investors, which should cool the market to a more adequate level.
“There definitely hasn't been the Exodus that we've seen in the past, the international investors are still here.”
The kindest thing Julio says has been done for him is mentorship and friendship from Andy Ratcliffe, a Benchmark co-founder.
“the opportunity to have Andy Ratcliffe as a mentor for us, as a good friend”