Joost van Dreunen – Unlocking Value in Gaming – [Invest Like the Best, EP.210]
What this covers
Patrick interviews Joost van Dreunen, an investor, NYU Stern professor and former SuperData Research CEO, about his book One Up. The conversation runs as a history of how games make money, starting with the early-1980s crash, when a market of about $2 billion fell to roughly a tenth of that. It then moves through Nintendo's rebuilding of the industry in 1984-85 and on to the present. Nintendo's rules are laid out in detail: five titles a year per publisher, two-year exclusivity, a mandatory purchase of 30,000 copies, and a license fee. They sit alongside the razor blade model of subsidized hardware and profitable software.
The middle of the discussion is about who captures what. Van Dreunen breaks down a $60 boxed game, in which the publisher takes about twice the developer's share. He also explains how used game sales powered GameStop while leaving publishers resentful. Steam's growth from a patching tool into a distribution platform comes up, as does the shift of industry power from Japan to the US and now to Chinese firms such as Tencent.
The later sections cover free-to-play. He dates mobile's takeoff to around 2009 rather than the iPhone's launch, and he distinguishes free-to-play from pay-to-win. He also describes how rising acquisition costs pushed designers toward retention and aggressive bottlenecks, and how early reliance on a few "whales" made revenue fragile. Subscriptions like Game Pass, user-generated content, and Twitch round out the picture. The most contested claim is that GameStop and legacy publishers survived mainly because industry growth lifted every company.
Van Dreunen argues that video game industry profits follow business model innovation (subscriptions, free-to-play, user-generated content, advertising, and virtual economies) rather than new technology, and that incumbents who wait on the sidelines lose value to newcomers.
- Nintendo's 1980s platform model and GameStop's used-game and specialty retail model created advantages through business design, not hardware
- Free-to-play mobile monetization, not the iPhone hardware alone, made mobile the largest segment and spurred explosive industry growth
- Incumbent publishers that dismissed digital and free-to-play were outcompeted by digital-native firms such as Tencent, Epic, Roblox, and Supercell
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Mobile gaming took off not with the iPhone's 2007 launch but around 2009, when Apple's app ecosystem enabled free-to-play monetization with no spending ceiling, creating a revenue hockey stick that outpaced console and PC.
“Mobile gaming takes off, not in 2007, it takes off in 2009, and Apple turns the key on free-to-play monetization.”
Free-to-play became sustainable when social layers and network effects were built in, as with League of Legends, where friends, communities, and esports made the game valuable without aggressive microtransactions.
“What makes this all make sense is network effects. As you start building a social layer into these games, that's when things really start to gel.”
Nintendo's 1984-85 entry established the modern games industry model of curating content, building third-party relationships, and controlling quality, and it wrote the blueprint for how the industry operates by restricting titles, requiring exclusivity, and charging license fees.
“Nintendo really wrote that blueprint, they really drafted it in the '80s.”
Nintendo's pooled licensing system, where third parties paid a license fee to market a shared install base, reversed the early disintermediation in which publishers like Activision broke away from manufacturers and kept the profits.
“the idea that you would all pool resources and pay a platform some license fee so that they could collectively market the devices and create an install base... nobody thought of that.”
Used game sales let GameStop resell a blockbuster title about six times on average, generating traffic and roughly a quarter of annual revenue, while publishers received payment only for the first sale and resented the lost revenue.
“In other words, they were then able to resell the same game, six times, on average.”
As user acquisition costs rose in free-to-play, where everyone pays $0 upfront, companies shifted their focus to retention, and the pressure to convert users led designers to add aggressive bottlenecks that squeezed players.
“you realize that it's really about retention as the cost of acquisition goes up in free-to-play”
Nintendo's licensing rules limited each publisher to five titles per year, required two-year exclusivity, required publishers to buy 30,000 copies of their own game for marketing, and charged a license fee, which allowed the platform to control quality and supply.
“you would only be allowed to have five titles on their platform, and would have to be a two year exclusive to their platform”
Digitalization is not merely an extra revenue stream for product businesses but a fundamental shift affecting every part of the conventional supply chain, as the Tower Records and Napster/iTunes example shows when incumbents refused to acknowledge it.
“In a product-based business, it is so tempting to think of digital as a creative revenue saying, 'Oh, it's extra money, that's great.' But really, it's a fundamental shift.”
Subscription models like Game Pass, with about 16 to 17 million subscribers, are attractive because consumers get a buffet of content and public companies earn higher valuations and better capital access from recurring revenue than from transactions.
“everybody loves recurrent revenue on their books, as opposed to transaction-based revenue. The evaluations for those companies are much higher”
The conventional games model is a razor blade business: hardware is sold to subsidize, and margin is made on software sold for the device, a structure that persists today because the hardware is expensive to develop and content drives the profit.
“In that conventional model, you'd have effectively a razor blade business model. So you sell the hardware, but then you make money on the software”
Of a $60 boxed game, the developer receives about 20 percent, the publisher about 40 percent, the platform about 15 percent, the distributor a small share, and the retailer about 20 percent, so the publisher captures roughly twice the developer's share.
“the developer gets 20%, the publisher, 40% of the total, the platform, which should be like a Nintendo, 15%”
Publishers capture about twice the revenue developers receive because they control capital, legal and corporate functions, sales-channel relationships, and platform access, while developers forfeit their ability to invest and depend on publishers for funding.
“Naturally, because they have access to the markets and access to the platform relationships, they are in a position to just capture more of the value than the developers can.”
Valve's Steam platform, launched in the early 2000s to push updates and fix bugs for its own games, expanded to third-party content, enabling PC gaming to regain share and become larger than console today.
“Digitalization then allows PC to regain some of its glory. And so, today, PC is the second-largest category, bigger than console nowadays.”
Free-to-play is not pay-to-win: most monetization sells vanity and aesthetic items, with some games offering modest advantages such as bonus bullets, but paying does not guarantee victory, which runs against the logic of high-budget blockbuster spending.
“So free-to-play does not mean, 'I spent money, therefore, you lose.' It's mostly vanity items and visual and aesthetic upgrades.”
Twitch succeeded because watching others play is a common, organic experience rooted in sibling and friend play, and Amazon's acquisition of Twitch for nearly a billion dollars in 2014 reflected the value of turning this behavior into live programming.
“Twitch then make that something that was online. ... They purchased them in 2013, 14 for like a billion dollars, a little shy of a billion dollars”
The industry's center of power moved from Japanese firms in the 1990s to American companies about ten years ago to mostly Chinese companies such as Tencent and NetEase today, because those firms command IP and capital.
“today the market is no longer governed by Japanese and American companies, it's really to Chinese companies.”
Nintendo sold about 140 million Wii units but only about 14 million Wii U units, yet the Switch restored its position, showing the company can reinvent itself and remain resilient to market cycles.
“The Wii was a huge hit, they sold 140 million units of the Wii. And then the Wii U was the opposite, they sold one-tenth of that, they sold 14 million units”
Apple's 2007 iPhone changed game development by letting developers build one version of a game for a standardized, high-spending device base, instead of building for hundreds of carrier-specific handsets.
“Rather than having to build the same game for 400 different handsets for AT&T, you now have to own make one version of the game”
A platform's user base can produce far more digital assets and content than any conventional creative firm, so a well-designed user-generation model can reduce acquisition costs and deepen retention.
“There's no way that a conventional creative firm could produce the same amount of digital assets and content as its own user base.”
The early 1980s video game market grew explosively to about $2 billion, then collapsed to roughly a tenth of its value (about $200 million in 1983) because too many manufacturers flooded an undifferentiated market with too little quality content.
“So it grew explosively to $2 billion in value in only a few years... So the market then collapsed, and, quite literally, became decimated to like a 10th of its value, to about $200 million in '83.”
In the product model, November and December account for 40 to 50 percent of annual sales, which forces publishers into crowded June conventions like E3 and drives up marketing costs, consolidating the value chain around a few winners.
“November, December, the two months out of the year when they have 40 to 50% of annual sales in a traditional product model.”
Predictions that free-to-play mobile would kill consoles and PCs proved wrong, because all three categories grew together, with console software about $20 billion, PC about $35 billion, and mobile about $85 billion annually.
“It turns out all three of them grow. ... the console business today, off the top of my head, it's about $20 billion in terms of software sales annually. The PC market is $35 billion. Then the remainder, it's about 85 billion, is mobile.”
Standard competitive theory predicts that GameStop and legacy publishers like EA should have been out-competed by now, but they survive because the explosive growth of the industry lifted all boats, so most incumbents persisted in new roles.
“and I think that it has everything to do with the explosive growth of the industry. And so all the boats went up.”
Early free-to-play companies depended heavily on a handful of enormous spenders, sometimes called whales, which made them fragile because losing one big spender could erase half the business, and investors avoided such concentrated revenue.
“some of these companies early on were very dependent on just a handful of ridiculous customers”
Virtual items with collectible value, like Magic: The Gathering's Black Lotus cards or World of Warcraft's Spectral Tigers, show that players will attach real money value to digital assets, and blockchain-based trading could formalize this as a fourth revenue model within two to five years.
“the early shape of crypto-based gaming, where now we have basically a financial system that isn't encumbered by international taxes and exchange rates.”
Digital asset economies with tradable in-game items, similar to Magic: The Gathering or Pokemon cards, are on the horizon in two to five years, enabled by crypto-based financial systems that avoid international taxes and exchange rates.
“So that's still two to five years out.”
Retail management's mental models, built around square-footage metrics, make it hard for them to see digital as a fundamental shift rather than a creative revenue add-on, which is why GameStop stayed the course for a decade.
“If you put it in business school terms, it's the mental inertia of management.”
Free-to-play was perpendicular to how legacy publishers operated, just as television was perpendicular to filmmakers, leading incumbents to dismiss it as blasphemy and allowing digital-native companies like Supercell and Tencent to win.
“Free-to-play comes in perpendicular to how things have been going and functioned up until that point.”
User-generated content platforms like Roblox and Minecraft reduce the need to constantly acquire new users, since players create content for each other, which is more scalable than what any conventional studio could produce.
“There's no way that a conventional creative firm could produce the same amount of digital assets and content as its own user base.”
Legacy publishers waited on mobile, expecting newcomers to fail first, so they moved slowly and let digital-native firms capture most of the value; investors should look for categories where incumbents sit on an opportunity without acting.
“As an investor, I always look for moments where that's happening, where the incumbents are just sort of sitting on something but not acting on it.”
Creativity is not a unique virtue for investors; what matters is whether a creator has a rationalized business model that can capture and repeat a success.
“I don't think being creative is a unique virtue. It's really about, do you have a rationalized model around it”
A business model's competitive advantage comes from how its components work together, not from having a website, mobile game, or custom controller, so the iPhone mattered mainly for its business model rather than its device specs.
“It is because of the way that you do things and combined components of the business that you are better than everybody else”
GameStop designed wide aisles and ramps because its real purchasers were mothers pushing strollers, since teenage boys had little money and mothers controlled the spending, so accessibility was a deliberate customer-focused decision.
“Because they figured out that 14-year-old boys, don't have any money, but Mom has money.”
Live streaming creates a simultaneous shared viewing experience, like watching the World Cup with friends, which YouTube has overlooked and which Twitch provides, making it more than an on-demand video platform.
“live streaming of course has this additional component, which I think YouTube has overlooked for a long time, watching simultaneously with other people.”
PUBG created the battle royale category and charged $30, but Epic's free-to-play Fortnite cloned and improved the model, showing that the company that scales a category can capture value after the pioneer.
“PUBG basically created the category in and of its own right, but it charged 30 bucks and it was really photorealistic”
GameStop's leadership failed to acknowledge the shift to digital distribution, describing digital sales in earnings reports as prepaid game cards rather than a threat, which Van Dreunen attributes to retail managers' mental inertia and dollar-per-square-foot mindset.
“they described digital in their earnings reports as basically prepaid game cards.”
Epic Games and Roblox do not follow the conventional way of making games; by combining games, engines, and platforms, and monetizing user engagement differently, they shift the entire category toward ecosystems of creativity rather than shipped boxes.
“So it's not so much that you have a novel idea and you're successful in your own right, but you shift the category entirely”
GameStop succeeded in used games because it staffed a dedicated team of about 400 people to manage the inventory, valuation, and logistics of previously sold copies, a capability that generalist retailers like Best Buy and Target could not replicate.
“So they have a dedicated team of 400 people, and that's all they do, is the used game sales.”
When newcomers like Roblox make user creativity central, every competitor is forced to answer how it will handle user-based creativity and monetization, so the category shifts entirely.
“every other company is going to be asked, what are you doing about user-based creativity?”
Advertisers seek younger consumers that traditional sports and TV no longer reach, since the average age of baseball and football fans is not declining, so games with huge audiences become a major advertising channel.
“for advertisers to look for younger audiences that are still consumers they can influence in their purchase behavior, sports, and traditional media, aren't really the place to go anymore.”
Conventional publishers like Ubisoft thought mobile had no margin because of its software complexity, and they waited while Apple and newcomers built the category, which let newcomers take most of its value.
“We're just going to have some of the newcomers first break their legs and then we'll step over the dead bodies”
Games now have four ways to make money beyond boxed sales: subscriptions such as Game Pass with 16 to 17 million subscribers, indirect advertising across a 3 billion person audience, user-generated content platforms like Roblox and Minecraft, and tradable digital assets in crypto-based systems.
“And if we purely look at how games make money, I can think of four of them.”
The biggest deciders in games are companies that own intellectual property and capital, which lets them survive market cycles, as Nintendo did after the Wii U's weak sales.
“The big deciders today are the ones that have the IP and the capital.”
Roblox's Series 8 investment valued the company at $29.5 billion, although it was reportedly around $200 million in the hole annually, meaning its economics were unproven even as its ecosystem model was compelling.
“I'd value it at 30 billion, but they are 200 million in the hole annually.”
GameStop differentiated itself from generalist retailers like Walmart and Best Buy by investing in staff knowledgeable enough to outwit customers on game titles, which made the buying experience far better for a fringe category than a generalist store could offer.
“They really invested in their staff to make them differentiated from more general retail stores.”
The iPhone standardized a single game version for a mass audience of premium-device owners and taught users touch interaction, with games such as Angry Birds acting as tutorials for swiping.
“Rather than having to build the same game for 400 different handsets for AT&T, you now have to... make one version”
Film producers initially treated television as crap and offensive, believing its low-resolution, black-and-white form factor could not support the spectacle they produced, an attitude that changed once streaming money made the medium lucrative.
“TV in its early phase was almost offensive to filmmakers. Nowadays, people can't wait to take Netflix money”
The games industry's culture of modest, ego-free creators, unlike Hollywood's red-carpet culture, produces more durable long-term businesses, so investors should evaluate management teams by seniority, execution ability, and the cadence of their ego.
“that absence, I think, of ego in everything that you do... long-term, that is far more interesting than your 15 minutes of fame.”
By the 2000s the market was about 95 percent console and 5 percent PC, because publishers preferred consoles' stable hardware, which avoided building many versions of the same game and mitigated piracy concerns on open PC platforms.
“Around the 2000s, you see basically a market that's 95% console, and 5% PC games.”
Discord, valued at about $7 billion, functions as social connective tissue by integrating voice, video, and play among curated groups, filling a gap between public Twitch and private email.
“I'm not surprised that they were valued at $7 billion last month, because they are effectively a social connective tissue”
miHoYo's free-to-play Genshin Impact resembles Nintendo's Zelda: Breath of the Wild in scope and open-world design, but costs nothing upfront and runs on phones, showing how newcomers outcompete incumbents on accessibility.
“you have a free-to-play Chinese title that looks and feels like Zelda: Breath of the Wild”
Van Dreunen spent the last five years predicting GameStop's end, either through bankruptcy or acquisition by Amazon, because its leadership could not adapt to digital distribution.
“I spent the last five years predicting the end of GameStop, either by way of just bankruptcy or by acquisition by Amazon.”
Video games have long been the entertainment category politicians attacked for violence, which left the games industry on the back foot culturally compared to Hollywood and music.
“politicians would use it to demonize behavior and say, 'Look at all these violence coming from these games,'”
In the early 1980s Nintendo subsidized retailers by letting them take units with no payment due until a unit sold, which helped get the console onto shelves before retailers had faith in demand.
“You don't pay us anything until you actually sell one of them.”
The original Activision was founded by eight former Atari employees who left salaried jobs after building hit titles, reasoning they should capture the profits themselves, and then sold content to other manufacturers.
“back then, Activision was basically eight people that escaped Atari and just went out on their own.”
Used video games do not lose quality with use the way cars do, so they can be traded in and resold repeatedly at high margin, which makes resale a durable profit engine.
“This doesn't really depreciate in quality, right? A game is a game is a game.”
Tower Records, once a dominant music retailer, declined after the CD and then iTunes and Napster because its owners refused to build digital distribution, showing how a physical retailer can be destroyed by failing to adapt.
“Then iTunes and Napster basically murdered that whole business, in collusion with the actual owners, because they refused to acknowledge it.”
In 2021 terms, mobile represents roughly four times the market share of console and twice that of PC, a 4:2:1 mobile-to-PC-to-console ratio.
“if that one is $4 in terms of total market share, then a PC is about $2, and the console is $1. So it's a 4:2:1 between the three.”
Angry Birds succeeded partly because it taught users how to swipe on a touchscreen, a function Apple had reason to highlight because it showed people how to use its new interface.
“a game like Angry Birds, in addition to its brilliant design, and its incredible creative marketing effort, it's also a game that teaches you how to swipe.”
Valve's Team Fortress 2, originally a $30 game, was made free-to-play and monetized through paid cosmetic items like funny hats, which Van Dreunen cites as evidence that free-to-play is the best monetization model because it gives users choice.
“Team Fortress originally was 30 bucks. And then they gave it away for free to play.”
Tencent benefits from many stakes in the industry, including high-priced acquisitions such as Supercell and Riot Games, which give it fingers in many pies.
“the Tencent universe of course benefits greatly from having made a few smart, although high priced acquisition in the form of Supercell, in terms of Riot Games”
Epic Games extended beyond games by selling Unreal Engine to Hollywood, with The Mandalorian shot in Unreal Engine 4, showing that its engine and platform reach outside games.
“Which they then, of course, sell to Hollywood with having the Mandalorian shot in Unreal Engine 4.”
Take-Two operates as a publisher with multiple studios and labels, such as Rockstar (Grand Theft Auto, Red Dead Redemption) and 2K (NBA 2K), mirroring how film and music companies organize genres under one corporate flag.
“If you think of Take-Two Interactive, they will have Rockstar, which is the studio behind Grand Theft Auto”
Behavior in digital environments that once seemed frivolous, such as spending real money on virtual items, will be seen by future generations as meaningful, just as parents failed to see the value of gaming.
“it will have meaning to them in the same way that what we value made no sense to our parents.”
Van Dreunen predicts consumer packaged goods companies will pool money to fund games in specific genres, the game equivalent of sponsored soap operas, because advertisers want the audience that games reach.
“I think you will very soon see the game equivalent of soap series, where you just have a category of CPG companies that are all going to pool their money”
Van Dreunen evaluates people and management teams by their seniority, their ability to get things done, and the cadence of their ego, and argues other entertainment businesses should tone down their ego to focus on their work.
“You just look at the management team and the seniority and their ability to get shit done, but really just the cadence of their ego.”
In the 1980s and 1990s, physical retailers played a key role in marketing and discovery, guiding consumers such as parents buying gifts toward games, and this function eroded only gradually over time.
“So you imagine your mother walking into a retailer in the '80s and '90s going, 'Well, he wants to play a game. It's his birthday. What should I get him?'”
GameStop's early success was based on basic economies of scale and retail presence: it was founded in the early 1980s to sell software, then grew by acquiring competitors, after which Barnes and Noble bought and later spun it off.
“So their success in the very early stages was really dependent on just basic economics. They just could have been selling frozen yogurt for that matter.”
Developers are the creative makers of games, including artists, programmers, and motion-capture performers, and do the work that Hollywood-style production involves.
“Developers are really the makers of the game. So these are the people that have all the creative talent.”
GameStop's Game Informer magazine, an official store-linked publication and reportedly the only surviving gaming magazine, was an early content-driven flywheel that reinforced the store's ecosystem.
“a magazine people might remember, called Game Informer, which was sort of the official GameStop”
Aggressive free-to-play monetization, which turns gameplay into paid bottlenecks, alienates players and gives legacy publishers ammunition to dismiss the model as shallow.
“they start to really squeeze people, which is of course is a turnoff”
GameStop kept stumbling forward because the games market was never scrutinized as closely as music, film, and video, and COVID-19 may have exposed its weaknesses by accelerating direct-from-publisher purchasing through services like Game Pass and EA Play.
“I think COVID has then finally laid bare some of their weaknesses.”
The pandemic boosted direct-to-consumer services like Xbox Game Pass and EA Play, which exposed GameStop's weaknesses, and if GameStop fails, the cause would be the digital shift rather than COVID itself.
“I think COVID has then finally laid bare some of their weaknesses.”
Epic CEO Tim Sweeney, who looks like an unassuming programmer yet is a billionaire with a long-held vision, embodies the games industry's pattern of modest genius operating behind the scenes.
“So if you see a Tim Sweeney, so I met him briefly two years ago, he looks like the programmer that's been sitting in the corner in a windowless office”
A game is a non-depreciating, repeatedly tradable good with high replay value variance, so it is structurally different from commodity retail goods that lose value quickly.
“the replay value of a product-based game tends to be limited, as opposed to say, online games”
The total video game content market grew from about $30 billion in the early 2000s to roughly $150 to $175 billion by 2021, driven by the combined expansion of all three platforms.
“the industry just explodes from $30 billion in the early 2000s to about 150, 175 today.”
Van Dreunen was diagnosed with cancer in 2007 and a Columbia doctor insisted he upgrade insurance and get checked out, an act of care that shaped his later approach to empathy in business and teaching.
“One of the kindest things that anyone's ever done for me was a doctor at Columbia University. So, I was diagnosed in 2007 with cancer.”
Patrick suggests that the pioneers of free-to-play may have felt foolish giving away their product, and that its key distinction from free-to-win is that successful games can be finished without paying.
“I'm sure at the time, the pioneers of this maybe felt like idiots. They're giving away the thing”
Hit games like Fall Guys and Among Us may not sustain their business, since it is unclear whether merchandise or sequels will work, and cloning by newcomers poses a longevity risk.
“Among Us next year? What's the longevity here?”