Jonathan Neman - Building the Modern Restaurant - [Founder’s Field Guide, EP. 24]
What this covers
Patrick talks with Jonathan Neman, co-founder and CEO of Sweetgreen, which began at Georgetown in 2007 and was heading toward about 160 restaurants by the end of 2021. The conversation opens with origins and supply chain, then gets into restaurant arithmetic. Revenue is trimmed by discounts and fees, food and labor each run near 30 percent, and occupancy near 10, leaving most restaurants a unit-level margin of 10 to 15 percent. Neman argues that labor and rent only look variable and in practice behave like step-change fixed costs. He also describes Sweetgreen's internal operating system, which forecasts demand by SKU, schedules labor, and tells kitchen staff how much to prep.
The middle of the episode concerns delivery and digital. Neman says aggregator commissions of up to 30 percent made sense only while delivery was incremental, and that a platform holding customer data can promote competing or private-label items. He contrasts this with large chains that often own neither their restaurants nor their supply chains. He defends flagships with lower returns on capital, using Nike as the comparison. He also explains how digital ordering lets a menu of 10 to 12 items expand to millions of combinations, and why he treats Food as Content.
The last stretch widens to health and climate. Neman cites US healthcare spending now at twice food spending, says 75 to 85 percent of chronic illness is preventable (a contested figure), and expects continuous glucose monitor data to change what people eat. He ties Sweetgreen's vegetable-heavy menu to carbon neutrality, questions Impossible-style meat on health grounds, and calls Larry Fink's sustainability letter transformational. His stated goal is a "Spotify of food."
Neman argues Sweetgreen wins by owning the full value chain and the direct customer relationship, measuring customer lifetime value rather than single-store returns, because restaurants that cede the customer to marketplaces will lose the value they create.
- Restaurants that franchise or rely on national distributors and marketplaces lack control over supply, operations, and customers, so the platform captures the value.
- Customer-level economics (CAC vs. LTV, ARPU, digital users) justify capital allocation that single-unit ROIC would reject.
- Health and sustainability trends favor a food platform that can personalize, which requires owning the digital relationship.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Restaurants look like variable-cost businesses, but much of labor, rent, and operating costs are fixed, so labor behaves like a step-change variable cost and restaurant gross margins are high, around 70 percent, before those fixed costs.
“I think restaurants look like variable cost businesses, but a lot of the labor is fixed, the rent is fixed, and a lot of your operating costs are fixed.”
The US now spends about twice as much on healthcare as on food, whereas in 1960 it spent three times as much on food as on healthcare.
“Today, we spend twice as much on healthcare as we do on food. In 1960, we spent three times as much on food as healthcare.”
Food is about 25 percent of carbon emissions, making the food sector one of the largest categories of carbon output, and Sweetgreen's model of selling mostly vegetables and no meat is what enables its carbon neutrality commitment.
“I believe it's about 25% of carbon emissions come from food. So, we are one of the biggest categories in terms of carbon output.”
Continuous glucose monitors like Levels pair diabetes-tracking hardware with software showing how exercise, sleep, and diet affect glucose spikes, which drive chronic illness and weight gain, and this information is likely to change what people choose to eat.
“Glucose spikes are what lead to a lot of the chronic illnesses and the weight gain that people try to avoid.”
A typical restaurant's revenue is reduced by discounts and fees, then food costs run about 30 percent, labor about 30 percent, and occupancy about 10 percent, leaving most restaurants at a 10 to 15 percent unit-level margin.
“Then you have your food costs, which typically run about 30%. You've got your labor costs, which typically run another 30%. You got your rent, which for most restaurants will run occupancy around 10%.”
BlackRock CEO Larry Fink's letter stating the asset manager would invest only in companies with sustainability initiatives is transformational because money moves markets, and it is pushing companies toward sustainability through capital incentives and ESG.
“when you have the largest asset manager in the world saying we're only going to invest in companies that have sustainability initiatives. Money moves markets.”
Impossible Foods-style plant-based meat alternatives may solve sustainability but are not great for health, so the better solution is to eat more vegetables, which solves both problems.
“While I do appreciate what they do from a sustainability perspective, that they're not great from a health perspective.”
Sweetgreen evaluates customer acquisition cost, blending organic acquisition driven by location and paid spend, against customer lifetime value, because a single-store ROIC view leads restaurants to misallocate capital by ignoring lifetime value.
“I believe they're not actually allocating capital properly because they're not thinking about the lifetime value of the customer.”
Neman estimates that 75 to 85 percent of the chronic illnesses being treated in the US could have been prevented with simple food and lifestyle changes, and he cites 40 percent obesity and 88 percent metabolic unfitness.
“estimates are between like 75% and 85% of chronic illnesses that we're treating are things that just with simple food and lifestyle changes could have been prevented. 40% of this country is obese.”
When a restaurant uses a marketplace, the platform owns the customer data and can advertise competing items to that customer, potentially earning far higher margins on its own private-label product than the 15 percent commission the restaurant pays.
“Well, they own your data, they own your customer, and you may have a really good deal where they're charging you, let's say, 15% commission. You're selling burgers, and so they learn that that customer loves burgers.”
Delivery marketplaces offer efficient logistics and incremental revenue, but their commissions (up to 30 percent) were justified only when delivery was incremental, and when the platform becomes a competitor, restaurants are dependent on it.
“The big question as you think about these is the idea of incrementality... or sometimes they charge up to 30%, you could pay that because your rent was fixed, your labor was largely fixed”
Delivery is not a very profitable business, and COVID accelerated marketplace delivery by five to ten years, but the substantial profit in the food value chain can be captured by becoming the operator yourself.
“Delivering food is not a very profitable business. COVID has accelerated this by five to 10 years and it's still not really like that profitable. But there is a lot of profit within the food value chain”
A flagship store with a lower return on capital can be worth building because customer-level economics can capture a lift across the whole market, similar to how Nike uses tentpole moments and flagships to lift a region.
“you may decide to build one, say, flagship store that really builds the brand... you may see a lift across the market as you build that market out.”
Fast food only looks cheap; when health costs, lost productivity, and environmental costs are included, a McDonald's meal is arguably the most expensive food one can eat.
“when you eat something like McDonald's, people think it's cheap, but I would argue it's the most expensive thing you can eat, if we were actually calculating the cost appropriately”
Technology has changed how people buy, consume media, and work over the past 20 years but has done little for health, because the body is still a black box and health is personal, so new sensing could radically change individual decisions in five to ten years.
“If you think about our bodies, it's still this black box. What is going on inside?”
Sweetgreen built a digitally native experience early by studying how travel and retail digitized their verticals and what direct-to-consumer relationships enabled, while restaurants had been wary of technology after many failed software promises.
“studied other industries, whether that be travel or retail, and just saw what happens when you digitize a vertical and what you can do with that data”
Large US restaurant companies often do not own their restaurants, supply chains, or direct customer relationships, operating mainly as marketing and branding businesses, whereas Sweetgreen controls the full value chain from seed to customer.
“Large restaurant companies in the United States actually don't own their restaurants. They're really just marketing and branding things in many cases.”
In-store restaurants can run only about 10 to 12 menu items because of consumer choice overload and staff memorization limits, but digital ordering with kitchen software lets Sweetgreen personalize options and expand the menu to millions of combinations.
“You've unlocked the menu from 12 items to millions of items.”
The key question for restaurants is whether they have direct relationships with customers or marketplace relationships, and the restaurant industry's greatest existential risk is that whoever owns the customer extracts more value in the value chain.
“And I think the answer is probably... in my opinion, the greatest existential risks facing our industry, reminiscent of both the retail, Nike versus Amazon, Disney versus Netflix, Four Seasons versus Expedia.”
As technology becomes commoditized, as streaming has, power shifts from convenience to content, so consumers choose Netflix or Sweetgreen for what they want to consume rather than for better software.
“I'm a believer that content is king as technology becomes commoditized. You don't go to Netflix because it has better software, you go there because you want to watch what you want to watch.”
Sweetgreen treats food as content, meaning the story and naming around a dish matter as much as the food itself, and nutrition and sustainability constraints make the product hard but must be made delicious through positioning.
“food is content. Think about it as our content. And when you're designing, when you're creating content, you got to think about both what the actual food is, but also what's the story around the food.”
Sweetgreen's internal operating system forecasts demand by SKU, schedules labor from that forecast, and tells kitchen staff how much product to prep at a given time based on weather, product mix, and time of day, so employees follow instructions rather than guess.
“you're not guessing how much chicken to put in the oven at a certain time, you have an iPad software that we built that said based off the weather and the product mix”
Sweetgreen's vision is to become the Spotify of food, a food plugin that recommends what to eat based on personal health data from any tracker, because health and taste are personal in a way that current recommendation systems fail to address.
“we want to create the Spotify of food. You're able to decide how you want to learn more about yourself with whatever tracker you want to use.”
Restaurants have a low barrier to entry because everyone thinks they know food, and while starting has become easier with new software, scaling a restaurant has become harder, mirroring retail's easy start and hard scale.
“The barrier to entry has gotten even lower, but the complexity to scale has gotten much harder, I think.”
Sweetgreen works with hundreds of regional farmers and in some cases goes to the seed level, choosing seeds and growing methods and paying attention to soil health, because soil drives nutrition and taste, and each new market requires building a local supply chain.
“in many cases go to the seed level with our farmers, thinking about what seeds, the design and where to grow. We pay a lot of attention to the soil health”
Sweetgreen's conversion of customers into its digital ecosystem began with convenience and long lunchtime lines, then moved to CRM loyalty rewards, then to personalization and exclusive content.
“Just Sweetgreen at lunchtime, there'd be lines around the block. That ease of convenience. Two has been CRM loyalty. Parts three is around personalization and expanded content.”
Marketplaces such as Instacart are becoming ad platforms where restaurants and brands pay to play for visibility, which is efficient for driving revenue but may produce short-term sales pops rather than sustainable sales.
“The way that they're actually going to make money, and you've seen this with Instacart as well, is becoming ad platforms. Pay to play.”
Restaurants are valued for their massive total addressable market and the moat created by execution complexity at scale, since each unit is individually low-margin on revenue but can earn high returns on capital when replicated thousands of times.
“Each individual unit is not that profitable on a percent of revenue perspective, but on a return on capital perspective can be very profitable.”
Restaurants must take control of their own digital experience and customer ownership now, because the Netflix-Disney pattern is already happening, and waiting makes it too hard to claw back control from aggregators.
“I do believe that what you saw happen with Netflix is going to happen. It's already happening”
Sweetgreen's founders' lack of restaurant experience was one of their greatest advantages, because they approached the problem from first principles rather than copying how restaurants are normally opened.
“our naivete, our not knowing what we were doing or what we were getting into, I think was one of our greatest advantages”
Raising money is a necessary evil that forces founders to believe in their idea enough to ask many people for checks, and that process sharpens the vision.
“raising money is a necessary evil in a way of going through the gauntlet. You have to believe something so much to have to ask so many people to write you a check. It forces you to almost sharpen your vision”
Sweetgreen rejected the commissary kitchen model, which centrally prepares food for shipment to restaurants, because centralized production sacrifices quality, so it cooks from scratch in every restaurant kitchen.
“What you typically see in those situations is quality sacrifice. Very few people have been able to do that and maintain the level of quality.”
Technology can only take a restaurant so far, and great general managers and head coaches drive results, so Sweetgreen focuses on manager stability, since having a head coach in place for over two years drives both experience and profitability.
“Things for us like head coach stability, having a head coach in place for over two years are things that really drive the experience and profitability.”
Because marketplaces drive short-term sales, Sweetgreen allocates more capital to internal G&A and technology, exclusive content, personalization, CRM, and performance marketing in its own properties, so the Sweetgreen app is the best place to order Sweetgreen.
“There is a lot more capital in the Sweetgreen-owned native experiences, as well as driving both exclusive content, personalization, and CRM, performance-based marketing within our own properties”
Converting customers into a digital ecosystem starts with a product people want, then convenience, then CRM loyalty rewards for interactions, then personalization and exclusive content, because the app can only succeed after the brand and product do.
“If you don't have something that people want, they're not going to download your app as good, as the app is.”
Sweetgreen partnered with chef David Chang on a kelp bowl because kelp is sustainable and sequesters carbon but is not sexy, so the team borrowed Nike-style brand aura to make consumers want it.
“We took a page in a lot of ways out of Nike. How do you build an aura outside of the dish beyond just, Hey, this is a dish with kelp in it.”
Pre-COVID, Sweetgreen's digital penetration was just over 50 percent, far ahead of competitors in the twenties, and today about 80 percent of its business is digital because COVID accelerated restaurant online adoption.
“Pre-COVID, we were running at just over 50%. The competition was, I think best in class, behind us was in the twenties.”
Sweetgreen uses digital-only exclusive menu items, such as influencer bowls from Valkyrie, Harper Waters, and Ally Love, to give consumers reasons to order digitally, and because healthy food is habitual, it turns occasional guests into frequent ones who treat Sweetgreen as a real food utility.
“We see customers using Sweetgreen less as a treat, and a once in a while restaurant, but really more as a utility. I call it a real food utility.”
Around 80 percent of Sweetgreen's business is digital, which gives the company a direct line to customers for personalized content and marketing.
“where 80% of our business today is digital”
Restaurant capital allocation is judged by return on invested capital and payback period, where a two-year payback is best in class and some restaurants take five or more years, so a $1 million store should return about $100,000 or more per year.
“We're going to spend $1 million building a store, it's going to return $100,000X per year. And it's that payback period. If you have payback around... I'd say two years is probably best in class, and it can go up to five-plus years.”
Sweetgreen's founders raised about $350,000 from over 50 individuals during senior year, before building the first restaurant, in what Neman called a Kickstarter before Kickstarter existed.
“We ended up raising about $350,000 from over 50 individuals, kind of a Kickstarter before the Kickstarter existed.”
The best restaurant operators exceed 20 percent unit-level margin, with Chipotle reaching about 25 percent at its peak and Shake Shack in the low 20s, while most restaurants operate at 10 to 15 percent.
“Chipotle is north of 20%. At their peak they were about 25% unit level margins. You see Shake Shack in the low 20s.”
Without knowing how restaurant supply chains worked, the founders went directly to farmers and built farmer relationships, an approach that high-end restaurants did but that Sweetgreen made affordable and accessible.
“we just went to the farmer's market and started meeting people. I think that was something that was probably done at some high-end restaurants, but for us, it was how do we do that and do that in it in a affordable and accessible and convenient way”
With no marketing budget early on, Sweetgreen found word-of-mouth marketing was best achieved through unexpected acts of sweetness, which is why Add the Sweet Touch became a core cultural value of customer obsession and going above and beyond.
“Not having marketing budgets, we realized the best marketing was word of mouth marketing and the best way to do that was just to do something unexpected, that random act of sweetness.”
Neman finds that the leadership principles he uses at work, such as empowerment, ownership, and tolerating failure, apply directly to raising a family, with time and energy allocation replacing capital allocation.
“It's not capital allocation, it's time and energy allocation and all of the things around empowerment and giving them ownership and letting them fail and grow”
Sweetgreen started when Jonathan Neman and his co-founders, as Georgetown seniors, found they could not find a healthy, affordable, convenient, accessible place to eat, and realized the problem was national and global rather than personal.
“we couldn't find a decent, healthy, affordable, convenient, accessible place to eat”
Sweetgreen's first menu item, guacamole greens, established its method of taking familiar, loved foods and giving them a healthy twist, which later menu design made more intentional around sustainability, nutrition, taste, and price.
“taking things that people love and are familiar with and putting a healthy twist on them”
Software partners now allow restaurants to go online almost immediately, replacing the need to build their own digital systems, which is why many restaurants have crossed the 50 percent digital threshold.
“So the Shopify-ication. Now you can go to some really great software partners that can take you online almost immediately”
Sweetgreen uses marketplaces for logistics and customer acquisition and brand awareness, then tries to move those customers into its own digital ecosystem, which it views as a symbiotic arrangement.
“For us, we think about it as customer acquisition and brand awareness, and then hope to move those customers into our own digital ecosystem.”
Obesity treatment cost about $150 billion directly in the US last year, total healthcare spending is about $3.6 trillion, and total food spending is about $1.5 trillion, split almost equally between food at home and food away from home.
“Obesity costs alone, last year directly treating obesity, it was $150 billion in the US. In terms of actual spend on healthcare, I think it's a $3.6 trillion spend on healthcare. Food spend in the United States is $1.5 trillion”
The leasing agent Marcy Simon rejected the founders' four-page business plan as a school project, but her demand for an architect, kitchen engineer, and capital proof pushed them into a real plan.
“She goes, Well, it doesn't really seem real. It doesn't seem like you have the capital for it. It doesn't seem like you have a full plan”
Sweetgreen's first core value is win-win-win, which means conscious capitalism, the belief that a company can be good for society and business at once, with doing good things making more money.
“Our first core value at Sweetgreen is win-win-win. And it's our way of saying conscious capitalism.”
When Sweetgreen partnered with a famous Thai chef in LA for a Thai crispy chicken bowl, it respected the culture and paid him fairly, which the company sees as avoiding cultural appropriation and as part of equitable treatment across farmers, team members, and collaborators.
“We partnered with the most famous Thai chef in LA. It didn't feel like there was any sort of cultural appropriation. We were working with him to respect to the culture and then paying him fairly for it.”
Live the Sweet Life means the intersection of passion and purpose with a growth mindset of curiosity and continuous learning, not the vacation or party meaning people usually assume.
“The idea of the sweet life is the sweet life is where your passion and purpose come together and it's this idea of a growth mindset full of curiosity.”
Music executives John Cohen and Rob Stone, founders of FADER and FADER Magazine, mentored the young founders by helping them create a music festival out of kindness, a debt Neman tries to repay by mentoring others.
“These two gentlemen, John Cohen and Rob Stone, who were the founders of Fader and Fader Magazine”
A carbon tax is probably likely in some form and probably should be implemented if climate change is to be tackled the right way.
“I think a carbon tax is probably likely in some way and probably should be if we're going to tackle this the right way.”
Sweetgreen runs over $3 million in unit volume in roughly 2,000 to 2,500 square foot kitchens across five channels: in-store, pickup, native delivery, third-party marketplace delivery, and Sweetgreen Outpost virtual pickup hotspots.
“We operate over $3 million unit volumes in about 2000, 2500 square feet, across five different channels.”
Apple's healthcare investments and Tim Cook's statements that health will be its greatest contribution to society signal that understanding what happens inside the body will change radically within five to ten years.
“even Tim Cook's statements that their greatest contribution to the society will be around health”
The first 20 years of the internet delivered cheaper, better, and faster services, and personalization is a fourth category that becomes important for restaurants.
“the first 20 years of the internet was cheaper, better, faster, and that will persist of course, but that personalization is a fourth category that becomes really important.”
Sweetgreen counts an order as digital only when placed through its own web or app properties, while line orders paid by credit card are non-digital, although scan-to-pay through its digital wallet maps back to the customer.
“Yes, someone who is on a native digital platform ordering through essentially a Sweetgreen web, or app property, so we can directly communicate with.”
Keith Ferazzi's book Never Eat Alone taught Neman to call strangers and ask for help, and young founders are helped because people root for underdogs.
“I actually read this book called Never Eat Alone by Keith Ferazi. Took it to heart where it was stranger interviews, mentors, just call and ask for help.”
The founders' first location was a 550 square foot former burger shack, and the small space forced them to focus on the experience and on solving healthy fast food rather than on salads specifically.
“Part of it was this constraint of a small space. Again, forced us to really focus on what our experience was going to be.”
Tracking sleep and other health metrics, as with an Oura ring, changes behavior because what is measured gets managed, and Neman credits his tracker with better productivity, happiness, and fewer illnesses.
“And as we know what we measure, we manage. And I feel like I haven't gotten sick since I've had an Oura Ring”
Sweetgreen's two key metrics are the number of digital users and ARPU, average revenue per user measured over a 90-day period.
“One of our key metrics you just touched on was ARPU, is average revenue per user. Once we have a customer, how much do they spend? We look at it in a 90 day period.”
Sweetgreen recently committed to being carbon neutral by 2027, which would make it one of the first food companies to do so.
“We recently announced a commitment to be carbon neutral by 2027. That should make us, if not the first, one of the first food companies to do so.”