Henry Ward - Transforming Private Markets - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 273]
What this covers
Patrick interviews Henry Ward, Carta's CEO, in a conversation that moves from the legal history of private markets to how he runs a company. The history starts with the 1933 Securities Act, which standardized public markets and left private deals bespoke. Ward then explains how price discovery differs in private rounds: whoever issues the first term sheet sets the price, later investors pay the same, and waiting costs nothing, so followers herd. He connects this to Price Setters vs Price Takers and to the argument that venture returns follow a power law, an exposure available only in private markets.
The middle of the episode covers CartaX, which uses a periodic auction with a single clearing price. Ward says Carta paid out $7 billion in secondary liquidity last year, up from $2 billion in 2020. Several of his positions are contested. He wants the accredited investor wealth test replaced with an education qualification. He credits Tiger Global and similar funds with pushing private valuations up. He forecasts that private prices may stay hot while public markets reprice, because venture capital is committed for ten years. He also predicts that a business built on data will fail as data is commoditized.
The last stretch is about management and product. Ward describes the N of 1 vs 1 of N market framework, the Aperture Framework for judging decisions, and Scooter Before Car Product Sequencing. Patrick brings in Gall's Law. Ward also argues that a team reaching the right answer through conflict has failed, and that employees whose experiments fail should get top ratings.
Henry Ward argues private markets lack the infrastructure public markets have, and Carta can build that infrastructure by owning the cap table, entering only markets where it can become the single winner, and layering liquidity and debt on top, which moves compensation toward ownership.
- Private markets are built on paperwork and contract law, not standardized infrastructure, so pricing and liquidity diverge sharply from public markets
- Carta's cap table database creates optionality, and it enters only N of 1 markets where it can dominate
- Solving liquidity and duration enables employee loans and securitization, which would reshape venture economics
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The 1933 Securities Act split securities into registered public offerings and unregistered private ones governed by accredited investor rules, which standardized public markets while leaving private markets bespoke because they had no scale problem.
“It all goes back to the 1933 securities exchange act, where they bifurcated securities that were registered”
Asset managers assume returns are normally distributed and build options and derivatives on that basis, but venture returns follow a power law in which the best companies win it all and most fail, so power-law exposure is only available in private markets.
“Private markets, especially in venture are not normally distributed. They're power law.”
In public markets price is set by the marginal (last) buyer, while in private markets price is set by the first buyer who issues a term sheet, so private prices are not discovered the way public prices are.
“In the private markets it's determined by the first buyer, the buyer that gives you a term sheet.”
Because the lead investor sets the price and later investors get the same price, there is no cost to waiting, which produces herd behavior where followers pile into rounds only after a lead has priced them.
“there's no cost to waiting, because you get the same price that everybody else does”
Product teams should deliver a usable early version, like a skateboard then scooter before a car, because early versions must provide utility, and big companies fail by building the chassis first and spending years on massive projects.
“your job is to build a scooter first and not the chassis.”
Marketplaces begin with a thesis of hidden embedded demand, and the hard part is unlocking supply first, as Airbnb did with spare rooms; the later challenge is raising demand to match supply.
“all marketplaces start with this thesis that there's hidden embedded demand that you can't see”
Companies now go public later or not at all, so employees question joining for a lottery ticket on an IPO that may never happen, and companies respond by offering pre-IPO liquidity.
“Employees are starting to question this idea of, why would I go join this company for a lottery ticket”
In the 2000s and 2010s tech ecosystem, IPO was the only form of liquidity, and early-stage employee selling before an IPO was seen as a vote of no confidence, reflecting a norm that no one gets liquidity until everyone does.
“employees selling before IPO was a vote of no confidence in the company”
Public markets offer near-instant liquidity while private markets have essentially none, and investing in two founders in a garage takes about 30 days, tons of paperwork, and about $20,000 in legal fees.
“And then the private markets, there's zero. And everything's done in paperwork.”
A business model predicated on data will fail, because data was defensible over the last 20 years but will become commoditized, so value must come from what is built on top of the data, especially deep integrations.
“if your business model is predicated on data, you're going to die.”
Patrick cites John Gall's Systems Bible principle that no complex system that works was designed complex from the start; each evolved from a simple system that worked first.
“there's no such thing as a complex system that's just designed complex and implemented.”
The accredited investor rule should be amended from a net worth or income threshold to an education qualification, which would open private markets to around 300 million Americans.
“not a net worth based or financial mean space metric or threshold, but rather an education qualification”
Private valuations usually follow public markets with a three-to-six-month lag, but because venture funds have 10-year committed capital that must be deployed, private markets may stay hot even as public markets reprice.
“there is a real argument that this time is different for private capital.”
Growth and crossover funds like Tiger Global saw that few private bidders versus infinite public buyers created a price gap, and tried to build an index-like fund on late-stage private growth to arbitrage it, which pushed private valuations up.
“they were trying to build an index fund effectively on late stage private growth to arbitrage the difference”
CartaX uses a periodic auction rather than continuous trading: sellers and buyers submit limit orders, and a single clearing price is set that clears the most shares, so everyone trades at the same price.
“This is a periodic auction-based market, not a continuous trading market.”
Carta paid out $7 billion in secondary liquidity to employees last year, up from $2 billion in 2020 and $600 million the year before.
“last year we paid out $7 billion in secondary liquidity to employees.”
The biggest missing piece in private capital markets is debt: lenders cannot price loans without knowing the duration of liquidity, so if CartaX creates systematic liquidity it can solve duration, enabling home and car loans securitized against private stock, which would change venture economics.
“what's missing is debt.”
Private markets offer more alpha than public markets because they have fewer competing buyers and less scrutiny, so overlooked opportunities are easier to find.
“There's less competition from buyers where, as I said, there's seven institutional buyers”
Leaders should never visibly show upset, because once they show it for any reason people stop telling them things, and one moment of visible anger outweighs 99 right moments.
“I can do 99 things right and be cheerful, positive, optimistic and that one time I'm upset about something, that's what everybody will remember.”
Carta was founded as a database of private assets, analogous to the MLS for real estate and the DTC in public markets, so that once every owner's holdings were recorded it could become the central clearinghouse and the base for private liquidity.
“think of it as like the MLS but of private assets”
Decisions should be judged through a chosen aperture, since the same feature can be correct under a customer-satisfaction aperture and wrong under a company-mission aperture, and the executive's job is choosing the aperture rather than ruling on ideas.
“And both are correct answers. The question is which aperture do we want to look through today?”
Private markets lack infrastructure because all financial infrastructure was built for public securities, while private securities remained trapped in contract law and paperwork.
“all the infrastructure had been built for public securities, but nothing for private”
Labor compensation is moving from a payroll era, where workers rent time for money, to an ownership era, where workers get equity in the upside of the companies they build, a shift that has so far been concentrated in tech.
“I think the next era of labor compensation is going to be an ownership one.”
Private markets have many price takers but very few price setters, since few firms know how to price a private company and employees cannot price it either, and attracting active capital is difficult.
“there's many, many price takers. There're very few price setters.”
When choosing which product to build first, ask what gets easier if you wait because of network effects and critical mass, and what gets harder because competitors enter, then sequence accordingly.
“what gets easier and what gets harder to build? And so some things, if we wait, actually get easier”
Companies should give a top performance rating to employees whose experiments failed, because rating failures low makes people avoid risk; Carta is input-based rather than output-based and rates effort in the right way.
“if you give them a two, nobody will ever take risks”
The biggest difference between working for a CEO and for anyone else is that the CEO knows less about the function than the executive, so the executive should tell the CEO what to do.
“it's the first time in your career, you work for someone that knows less than you do.”
A team that reaches the right decision through conflict and upset should count as a failure, since relationship quality matters more than the answer, and friction, though often seen as healthy debate, is failure.
“Friction is failure, and most people think friction is good”
A CEO's executives are the first people in their careers to work for someone who knows less than they do about their function, so Henry asks his C-suite to tell him what to do rather than relying on his own expertise.
“the biggest difference is it's the first time in your career, you work for someone that knows less than you do.”
The venture ecosystem has grown beyond the eight firms on Sand Hill Road, so there are now many emerging managers and founders need help finding investors and investors need help finding companies; intermediation that was once stigmatized as negative selection could now serve as matchmaking.
“Has venture reached the scale where we can actually help investors find companies, help companies find investors and play this matchmaking role”
Companies die in three waves: before product-market fit, during scaling, and at the transition to multi-product platforms, which is where most fail; single-product companies top out at single-digit billions, while 10 to 100 billion requires multi-product expansion.
“Vast majority of companies die there. That's where you get the single digit billion outcomes”
Carta's bottom-up, decision-pushed-down model is chaotic and poor training for becoming a corporate executive but excellent for producing founders; a dozen early employees have left to start companies, which Henry calls the Carta cartel.
“If you want to be an executive, this is a terrible place to learn to be an executive. But if you want to be a founder, this is how you do startups.”
Carta's first business charged $20 per issued stock certificate against FedEx at $30, but the real value turned out to be tracking ownership in the cap table, which is why it moved to a subscription SaaS model in 2016.
“Because what we realized was the real value was not issuing the securities. The real value is tracking it in the cap table.”
Leaders should never visibly show being upset with an employee, because displayed anger makes people stop sharing information, and instead should run a discovery process to find out whether the employee thinks the work was good, bad but defensive, or bad and candid.
“once you show you're upset for any reason, people won't want to tell you things”
Hiring an investment banker to raise money was frowned upon in venture because it signaled weakness, so venture capitalists would not talk to such companies; with venture now at scale, Carta is testing whether it can match investors and companies without that stigma.
“If you hired an investment banker to raise money, venture capitalists wouldn't talk to you.”
On CartaX each company configures its own market rules, including the available float, who can buy and sell, and sale limits, effectively creating its own personal stock market, unlike public markets governed by one SEC rule set.
“In CartaX, we view it as the company gets to set their rules.”
Carta's mission has two parts: make equity on a payroll platform the default for every new job, and then give employees at companies that stay private a way to get liquidity, which is a one-two play over the next 20 years.
“Our mission is twofold. One is to make it so much easier.”
Investors saw the cap table as a wedge into the capital structure rather than a small market, and that wedge gave Carta optionality to sell eight or nine products into the venture ecosystem.
“they saw cap tables as a wedge”
Ideas should be evaluated by whether the time is right for them rather than whether they are good or bad, a framework Henry took from Mark Andreessen and Andreessen Horowitz.
“There's no bad ideas. It's only timing.”
Execution companies with a clear roadmap, like payroll or database firms, develop great executives, while discovery companies without line of sight to a billion-dollar product line, like Carta, develop founders instead.
“The first type of company, I would call an execution company. They know exactly what to do.”
Leaders should trust and let go about 90 percent of the time, and micromanage in the remaining 10 percent when confidence is low, since the process is an apprenticeship; about half the time the intervention succeeds and about half the time it does not.
“I take two sides and 90% of the time, I trust and let people go.”
Employees should escalate problems they have no solution for rather than problems they have already solved, since the unsolved problems are the ones leaders most need to hear and help with.
“One of the old management maxims I hate is don't come to me with a problem without a solution”
An execution company like a payroll firm has line of sight to a billion-dollar revenue market and a defined roadmap, while Carta has no line of sight beyond any single product line and must hack through a foggy jungle, so employees should choose by whether they want to execute a plan or discover a path.
“We're like that company that sort of has a machete and we're hacking our way through a foggy jungle”
Tender offers are version one of private liquidity and work well, while bespoke transactions such as auctions remain slow to adopt, so the industry must work through intermediate versions before private market liquidity matures, and Henry believes it is inevitable that someone will crack it.
“Private market liquidity is inevitable, I do believe that. Somebody is going to crack the code on this.”
Entering N of 1 markets means starting in relatively small markets, since large markets take too long and need scale to dominate, but winning each one creates optionality to move into bigger markets.
“you have to go to relatively small markets because large markets are really hard to become an N of 1 player”
When work is poor, a leader should first find out whether the employee thinks it was good, bad but defensive, or bad and will admit it, because each case calls for a different response, and in the first case the leader may be wrong.
“So it's a discovery process to figure out why the employee thinks they did a good job.”
Henry defines a new market as any arrangement that lets money change hands in a way that has not happened before, and CartaX is an attempt to create such a market for private secondary trading.
“our definition is anything where you've made a way for money to exchange hands that hasn't happened before.”
A scalable go-to-market engine lets a company invent, acquire through M&A or corporate development, and push new products through its distribution channels to customers, which is how Salesforce-level execution is achieved.
“you just look at these startups, you see which one's getting traction and you buy it and you push it through your pipes.”
Carta Total Compensation is a real-time benchmarking product, similar to Radford, built from option grant data across 30,000 customers and salary data from HRIS integrations, allowing it to state what a given engineer level at a Series B company should earn.
“We were getting option grant information from 30,000 customers that we have”
As private markets attract 20 to 50 potential bidders instead of a handful, price discovery will become more efficient and will be automated, since today founders manually run auctions across half a dozen to 10 term sheets from Sand Hill Road.
“if you have 20, 30, 40, 50 potential bidders, you now start to automate this”
Goldman Sachs and JP Morgan are moving into private markets, with JP Morgan buying Global Shares and Goldman running a private markets desk and venture loans, while Carta fills the sub-$100 million capital formation niche that banks will not serve.
“JP Morgan just bought one of our competitors, Global Shares.”
Most of the $7 billion in liquidity came from tender offers after financing rounds, where excess investor demand buys employee secondaries, while bespoke auction transactions have been slower to adopt, and CartaX is working to build the intermediate versions of private liquidity.
“most of that $7 billion number last year comes from”
The best companies will offer liquidity as part of compensation to attract talent, and as more do, competitors will have to follow, which Henry believes is the current inflection point.
“we're getting to an inflection point where the best companies offer liquidity”
Companies should enter only N of 1 markets, where market structure allows one winner, and never 1 of N markets with many competitors, because only N of 1 positions are defensible.
“Our job is to never enter 1 of N markets.”
CartaX currently allows only institutional investors, Henry hopes to admit credit investors within two years, and retail participation within five to ten years, which requires an SEC change to the accredited investor rule.
“in two years, to your question, we'll allow credit investors. And then I hope in five to 10 years”
In five to seven years, employees of private-equity-backed companies will automatically receive equity, as tech workers do now, and this is already starting.
“I think in five years, seven years, if you work for a PE backed company, you will automatically get equity in that company”
Carta's cap table pricing is based on line items rather than seats, so it grows as companies add investors and employees, averaging about 120 percent net dollar retention while individual cohorts show power-law outcomes.
“we average out at roughly 120% net dollar retention”
Carta builds customer success organizations that use an automated customer health score measuring engagement and value, so customers call their success manager before quitting.
“an automated customer health score, and then make sure the CSMs understand the health score”
Long-run public market returns show a power-law pattern in which a small group of winners drives the outcome for the whole market, even though near-term returns look distributed.
“the studies of the public markets that show long term that power law thing exists”
The entertainment industry is moving from a royalty model to an M&A model in which each movie gets its own cap table and is sold to a streamer, with talent such as Zendaya receiving equity in films.
“the entertainment industry is moving from a royalty model to an M&A model”
Carta's products are bought by different executives, for example the general counsel for cap tables, the CFO for 409A, and the head of people for compensation benchmarking, so one relationship can be expanded into others.
“Our cap table product might be bought by the general counsel. Our 409A product might be bought by the CFO”
Chobani's founder gave equity to all employees, including dairy farmers, as an example of equity expanding beyond tech.
“You can see Hamdi at Chobani who gave equity to all of his employees, including the dairy farmers.”
More liquidity is generally good for price discovery in markets, so CartaX's push toward private liquidity seems obvious in hindsight.
“it seems kind of obvious that more liquidity is generally good for price discovery”
CartaX was started too early, and it was Henry's third attempt at a liquidity product after two earlier ones objectively failed; the team stayed together afterward and the failure was framed as heroic effort.
“I started CartaX too early. I would say this is actually the third swing I've taken at creating a liquidity product.”
Leaders should credit employees for their own success, saying congratulations rather than good job, since employees did the work for themselves, not for the CEO.
“I say congratulations because they didn't do it for me, they did it for themselves.”
At about 2,000 employees, Henry's biggest challenge is fighting the inertia of bureaucracy, because standardization and process are necessary for scale but threaten the innovation-garden culture, which he resolves by choosing the appropriate aperture for each part of the company.
“fighting the battles of bureaucracy is my biggest challenge.”
Private market liquidity is inevitable, someone will solve it, and Henry fears that Carta could be close but fail to finish, which would haunt him.
“Private market liquidity is inevitable, I do believe that.”
Marc Andreessen led Carta's Series E, and when Henry asked him to match terms over breakfast he came back that afternoon with a term sheet delivered at Henry's home along with a Lego set for his toddler, a gesture Henry advises every VC to replicate.
“if you have a chance to go to an entrepreneur's home and give them the term sheet, do it.”
CartaX is the first exchange to charge both buyers and sellers commissions to trade and to provide crossing trades as a service.
“we're the first exchange where we're charging buyers and sellers commissions”
An explosion of emerging venture managers, many niche-focused, creates demand for helping investors find companies, since founders ask who to raise from and emerging managers ask for deal referrals.
“there's an explosion of emerging managers happening in the world”
So far CartaX attracts more passive capital than active capital, since the active price-setting investors are sourcing deals elsewhere, which Henry says the company is actively trying to change.
“We attract more passive capital versus the active capital.”
Some CEO customers do not want employees to receive vesting email reminders because it makes them worry about equity or prompts exercise on departure, while Carta's mission to normalize equity argues for sending them, illustrating how aperture choices diverge.
“some of our CEOs that are customers, some of them don't like to give vesting email reminders to employees.”
In late-stage private growth investing only about seven bidders really mattered, including Andreessen Horowitz, Sequoia Growth, D1, and Tiger Global, while public markets have effectively unlimited buyers.
“there were like seven people that really mattered.”
Early-stage Carta employees who left to found startups form a group Henry calls the Carta cartel, numbering about a dozen, which he sees as evidence that the company breeds founders.
“We have the Carta cartel, we affectionately call it, early stage employees that have left to do startups, and there's a dozen of them already.”
Carta currently runs about 20 liquidity events a month to unlock supply and create liquidity on company cap tables.
“We run 20 liquidity events a month these days”