Graham Weaver - Building Alpine - [Invest Like the Best, EP.425]
What this covers
The conversation is a long interview with Graham Weaver, founder of Alpine Investors. It starts with his background in wrestling and rowing and his early business ventures, then turns to Alpine's founding. He is candid about early mistakes: three label-printing deals returned about 1x because he underwrote customers shallowly and backed founders' successors who were not backable. He says Alpine took roughly 21 years to get where it is, with a $100,000 salary and no carry for much of that time.
The middle of the episode is a critique of private equity and an account of Alpine's alternative. Weaver argues that with about 5,500 funds, quality assets sold through banker auctions go to the highest bidder. He says falling rates and multiple expansion flattered returns from 1990 to 2020 and that those tailwinds are over, a forecast he expects median managers to feel. He also argues for MOIC over IRR as a firm's objective function. Alpine instead targets smaller companies below the EBITDA range competitors chase, assembling a playbook by visiting about 20 companies before the first check. He compares the model to a captive search fund, and he describes underwriting about 3x net per deal while relying on outliers for the fund target. His worst deal, a slot-machine business that grew too large for the fund, supplies the lessons on concentration and on backing products he believes in.
The last third moves to people. Weaver describes a new CEO's first 60 days of listening, the skills he teaches at Stanford, and the Nine Lives Exercise, which he uses to help students choose between a safe path and a passion path.
Graham Weaver argues Alpine's edge is installing trained, young operators as CEOs in overlooked, owner-retiring $20M-revenue businesses, so talent development and a repeatable playbook, not deal sourcing or financial engineering, drive its returns.
- Competitive auctions for high-quality assets go to the highest bidder, so Alpine targets businesses where the hard work of management change scares away competition
- Alpine replaces management in nearly 100% of platform companies and treats talent as its alpha source
- Returns above 3x net come from asymmetric outlier deals and long holding periods, not from multiple expansion, which Weaver says is ending
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Alpine's three early label-printing deals returned about 1x because Weaver underwrote the customers too shallowly, missing recession exposure, and underappreciated management quality, backing successors who were not backable.
“I wildly underappreciated how much the management team mattered, and I made that mistake three times before realizing I had made it.”
A new 28-year-old CEO's playbook for the first 60 days is to listen: meet 20 to 30 employees, ask what is working, what is wasted effort, and what the priorities are, which builds trust and surfaces obvious low-hanging fruit.
“On day zero, which is understandable, the first move for the first 60 days is listen.”
Weaver backed founders' successors in his first deals and repeatedly found them unbackable, making the same management mistake three times before recognizing that management quality matters more than he had weighted it.
“I wildly underappreciated how much the management team mattered, and I made that mistake three times before realizing I had made it.”
In today's private equity market with about 5,500 funds, a high-quality business sold through an investment bank process goes to the highest bidder, not necessarily the smartest investor, so winning those auctions is a tough game.
“it doesn't necessarily go to the smartest person, it goes to the highest bidder.”
From 1990 to 2020 the 10-year Treasury yield fell from about 8% to near zero, which forced pensions with 8-9% return assumptions to shift money into private equity, while cheap debt and multiple expansion fueled PE returns.
“they went basically from 8 to 0 over a very steady period of time throughout that.”
A firm's objective function should be net MOIC rather than IRR, because IRR can encourage selling the best companies early to raise the next fund, and the chosen objective cascades into hold periods, investment style, and value creation decisions.
“are you selling your best companies quickly so you can raise the next fund and have higher IRRs or what are you doing?”
With 5,500 PE funds and rising efficiency, the tailwinds of falling rates are over, so median-performing managers who assume bigger future funds will struggle over the next decade, while mega-firms that can raise capital from wealth management channels will gather assets.
“the people who were putting up median returns and felt like they had this God-given right to raise their next fund and it was going to be bigger. I think that's not going to work out very well in the next decade or so.”
Weaver asserts that there was real multiple expansion in PE over his career: firms bought businesses at about 5x EBITDA in 1994 but pay about 13x now.
“I don't care what anyone says, there was multiple expansion. I mean we were buying the same companies in 1994 at five times that we're paying 13 times for now”
Alpine builds a roll-up platform by hiring a CEO and choosing an industry first, then visiting around 20 companies to assemble the best playbook from each one's strengths before writing the first check, with the first deals starting small.
“you learn more in one three-hour management visit than you do in three weeks in a conference room.”
Alpine noticed that every HVAC competitor was chasing the same $5M to $10M EBITDA businesses with strong management, while about 90% of the market sits below that size where owners want to cash out, so Alpine built a system to buy those smaller companies.
“It turns out 90% of the market is below that and management wants to leave and cash out.”
Search fund entrepreneurs often fail at the first step of raising capital and finding a deal because bankers avoid one-time sellers, searchers have a clock ticking, and they lack support once they acquire a company.
“They usually mess up that first part. Investing is a pattern recognition business.”
Weaver's Stanford class teaches granular CEO skills such as hiring, firing, and difficult conversations through role-play, and about a quarter of the course is devoted to helping students find their dream, because students liked the class without pursuing their dreams.
“students love the class, but they weren't doing it.”
Weaver argues that PE leaders who spend their time on deal competition and not on making their firm the place top people want to stay probably sacrifice returns, and he estimates that spending 25% of time on talent would have improved his last firm's returns.
“if they'd spent 25% of their time doing that, they'd probably have the best returns.”
Weaver argues that many PE firms' real objective is to raise the next larger fund, which encourages showing realized returns while compounding weaker assets, and attracts people who want money rather than to build companies.
“you cut your flowers and water your weeds, you show these great realized returns and you're compounding your stuff that's not great.”
Alpine's model resembles a captive search fund, but it removes the searcher's weakest steps by supplying sourcing, industry evaluation and post-close support, so young CEOs skip the front-end deal-building that search funds often fail at.
“They usually mess up that first part. Investing is a pattern recognition business. Bankers don't want to sell to them”
Weaver's key lessons from the slot-machine deal are not to bet the business on a single concentrated position and not to back businesses whose products he does not believe improve the world.
“we never want to bet our business on one.”
Alpine took about 21 years to reach its current success, with Weaver's salary at $100,000 and no carry until the last company sold, and he argues that building takes much longer than people expect.
“My salary was a hundred thousand dollars. That's a fact.”
Weaver's worst deal was a slot-machine software and distribution business where Alpine held about $170M of total investment against a $68M fund, making the position too big to fail and forcing continued support despite ethical concerns about gambling and grey-market competitors.
“We were in a $68 million fund at the time and we had $170 million in the business, including co-invest. So it was just too big to fail.”
In coaching students torn between a safe path and a passion path, the passion path usually wins within about 10 minutes of questioning, but the head talks people out of it, so the work becomes lowering the risk of the passion path.
“In 10 minutes, it's clear that their heart wants to do B, but their head's talking them out of it.”
Alpine believes its alpha comes from talent: it buys industries others overlook, pairs them with an A-level team, and refuses to overpay for A-rated industries.
“the way that we're really going to create alpha is through talent.”
Alpine's best early deals were ones where a partner or someone with raw talent and coachability, who knew nothing about the industry, went in to run the company, and these deals produced the most fun board meetings and strongest outcomes.
“The best deals that we did were always ones where we put in either us or someone just we to go run this business who knew nothing about the industry, but had these raw talent and also coachability”
Alpine underwrites individual deals to about 3x net, roughly 3x to 3.5x gross in five years with no multiple expansion, and reaches the 5x fund target through asymmetric outcomes and extended holds, since underwriting any single deal to 5x would mean never closing a deal.
“If we underwrote an individual deal to 5x, we would never close a deal.”
The most important attributes Alpine looks for in young CEOs are will to win and ownership, grit, emotional intelligence and self-awareness, and a bias for action, with grit rarer than expected and some recruiting schools producing less of it.
“Number two, which is probably one A is grit.”
The nine-lives exercise asks people to list nine possible lives, which makes the pressure of finding one passion manageable, and reveals that people can pursue several of those lives over time, just not at the same time.
“the secret is you can have all nine at some point in your life, just not all at the same time.”
Personal growth consists of learning to hear one's intuition, which Weaver calls an internal LLM containing all past experiences, and then having the courage to act on it, which he considers the highest level of personal growth.
“It's our own LLM. It's taken every experience and every input we've ever had”
Weaver frames investing as choosing between winnable endogenous games and hard exogenous games, and he would spend roughly 25 of 100 units of energy finding a winnable game and 75 on brute-force execution within it, rather than brute-forcing a crowded auction.
“If I have a hundred units of energy, I want to use 25 of those units to go try to find a winnable game to play.”
Early-stage investors should carve out enough personal salary to live reasonably, even at the cost of total upside, because paying yourself allows you to stay in the game long enough for duration to matter.
“So carve out enough that you can live reasonably comfortably, even if that cuts into your total upside or something.”
Alpine's winnable game is buying a roughly $20M-revenue plumbing company whose owner is retiring: the deal math works at about 8x EBITDA purchase, blended to about 5x with the playbook, financed at about 5.5x debt, with the platform trading around 18x, so the hard work is placing the CEO and systems rather than the investment decision.
“you're paying eight times EBITDA with the playbook that you have, you can blend that down to five times EBITDA, you can borrow at five and a half, and your platform is going to trade at 18.”
Alpine measures employee and customer net promoter scores at acquisition and every six months thereafter, treats them as the most important leading indicators of success, and holds CEOs accountable for them.
“the two biggest underappreciated leading indicators of success are the net promoter score of the customers and the net promoter score of the employees.”
Around 2010 Alpine decided to install its own management team in every deal, rebuilding its sourcing engine and brand, because bankers do not sell companies lacking management teams, which made the change brutal.
“let's just put our own team in a hundred percent of the time and we burn the boats.”
Asking 'what would you do if you knew you wouldn't fail' and temporarily setting aside the 'how' surfaces the path a person's soul wants, because the answer often arrives days later once fear is removed.
“My favorite question of all time is: what would you do if you knew you wouldn't fail?”
Alpine's funds typically have at least one outlier deal that dominates returns, so the firm tries to plant seeds with outlier potential by building real companies with strong holdcos, large industries, and time to get the playbook right.
“we tend to have at least one real outlier deal per fund.”
First-time dealmakers should stick to one industry rather than doing deals across several, because learning compounds within an industry, and Weaver's fourth deal succeeded because he had learned from three prior ones in the same industry.
“pick one industry. Don't go do three deals in three different industries”
Visualizing a self 20 years in the future who has succeeded, then asking what advice that person would give, typically yields a clear directive such as going after a specific path or relaxing about outcomes.
“You're meeting your future self 20 years from now... what advice did that future self have for you?”
The Apex platform, started with an approximately $40M-revenue business, grew through internally trained veterans, with Brad Schwartz going from $8M-revenue unit to a $500M division, and is projected to reach about $3B revenue with only about $50M of equity added in total.
“We haven't put any more equity in. They've just been accumulating these small little businesses.”
Successful platforms require heavy early investment in the holdco, such as a $15M holdco expense for young platforms, and Weaver says over-investing early is the right foundation, partially funded by cash flow from acquired businesses.
“Our best companies, we've really over-invested early in those platforms.”
Accessing intuition requires meditation, breathwork and stillness that silences the mind, separating the self from the chattering mind, which Weaver identifies as the core principle of meditation.
“a lot of times it's meditating, breathwork, really being still and quiet and getting out of your mind.”
Weaver says feeling physically good is the variable most highly correlated with having a good day, and that depends on sleep, so he avoids alcohol, caffeine, and sleeping pills and keeps a consistent night routine.
“the most highly correlated thing to having a good day is if I feel good physically, that starts with sleeping well.”
Companies usually already contain the solutions to their problems, so hiring consultants like McKinsey to interview employees and repeat back what they heard is unnecessary; the answers come from talking to your own people and customers.
“The answer's always in the room. You don't have to go hire McKinsey.”
Alan Watts's point that dancing is not about reaching a spot on the dance floor, and that no one rewards the fastest dancer, supports Weaver's view that the journey and growth matter more than arriving early.
“you're not rewarding the fastest dancer.”
Early self-help frameworks taught Weaver three principles: refuse the victim stance and take control, write down goals, and choose only one or two goals while drawing a bright line against the rest.
“you can have any goal you want, but you can't have 20. So you pick the one or two that you're really excited about, and then you have to draw a bright line”
Weaver recalls that Warren Buffett earned about half of his money from two investments, GEICO and the Washington Post, illustrating return asymmetry, though he says the specific year and figure are approximate.
“he'd made half of all of his money on two stocks, Geico and the Washington Post.”
Weaver advises facing whatever one fears because the fear marks where one's work lies, and suggests imagining a 10-years-older self to escape the fog of war when facing a decision.
“There's a great Carl Jung quote: Where your fear is, there is your task.”
Alpine's guiding passion statement is unleashing heroes, based on the belief that new hires are heroes who have not yet had the arena to show it, and that the expectation that people can be great becomes self-fulfilling.
“Our passion statement at Alpine is unleashing heroes.”
Weaver's father built a successful veterinary practice one emergency call at a time over 25 years, a pattern Weaver sees as the template for Alpine: building something far bigger than expected through patient, incremental effort.
“He would say it took way longer than he thought and he built something much bigger than he thought.”
Alpine replaces the IT systems of every acquired company with its own ERP, financial package and business intelligence system, and requires uniform data input so all portfolio data is comparable.
“We rip out their IT systems and we put in a financial package, an ERP system, a business intelligence system.”
Search fund entrepreneurs want to be CEO early, and Alpine's model appeals to that drive by putting them in an established company with a playbook and 25 years of CEO intellectual property rather than making them build a firm for one deal.
“They built it to do one deal.”
Weaver claims that about 70% of people in the U.S. dislike their job or are disengaged from it, and that Alpine's aim is to flip that ratio in its companies.
“70% of people dislike their job or they're disengaged from their job right now, today.”
Weaver's biggest fear is running out of time, which he addresses by being fully present in whatever he is doing rather than overthinking it.
“how long do I have? And am I going to be able to do all the things that I want to do in this lifetime?”
Talking through goals with a coach activates different parts of the brain than thinking or reading alone, so having a coach means more of the brain is lit up during reflection.
“You activate different parts of your brain when you talk than when you think or read.”
Alpine gives first-time CEOs roughly 25 years of accumulated intellectual property on how to lead established businesses, so they start in year 26 rather than year zero, while the firm handles sourcing and industry selection.
“we might as well start you off 25 years in year 26 rather than in year zero.”
Teaching forces Weaver to codify a full year of reflection into a course, and he feels obligated to live the principles he teaches, such as not tolerating B-plus people in key roles, which acts as a mirror on his own life.
“So it's a forcing function that almost makes me download an entire year of reflection into 19 classes”
When raising money with no track record, selling his past deals failed; Weaver's successful pitch focused on his trustworthiness and commitment, consistent with the principle that people buy the salesperson, not the product.
“people buy the salesperson, not the product.”
Most people go through routine days on autopilot, repeating yesterday's patterns, and only step back to ask powerful questions when they make space for reflection with a coach, journal, or friend.
“if you watch most people, they're kind of asleep or unconscious.”
Weaver distinguishes between investor-focused firm leaders who execute deals and CEO-style leaders who build the machine, and says he has done both but now puts Alpine's talent building first.
“Looked at their job as being a deal person trying to close deals.”
Through its first 14 years Alpine had about $400 million under management and a large team, while Weaver earned a $100,000 salary and the firm had no carry because the European waterfall delayed payouts until the best company was sold.
“My salary was a hundred thousand dollars. That's a fact. And we hadn't yet had a carry check because our European waterfall.”
Individuals are starting to access private equity through wealth management platforms, which didn't exist before and is a new source of capital for large firms, though the amounts are still small.
“individuals are starting to be able to go into private equity through their wealth management, which didn't used to be a thing.”
Patrick notes the search fund process forces young operators to build a firm only to abandon it after one deal, meaning they cannot reuse their skills, while Alpine lets them run much larger businesses sooner.
“They built it to do one deal. And you know, the other thing is they can just do something on a way bigger scale.”
Alpine's first CEO-in-training hires could not be placed in portfolio companies because operators saw them as inexperienced and expensive, so Weaver offered a one-year salary reimbursement guarantee, after which the program grew incrementally.
“I said, listen, hire her and if she doesn't work out in a year, I'll reimburse you her salary from the management company.”
Alpine recruits CEOs mainly through word of mouth from successful alumni, and its CEO-in-training program became the most applied-to job at Harvard, Stanford, and Kellogg business schools, which Weaver says short-circuits the search-fund pipeline.
“Alpine was the number one most applied-to job at Harvard Business School, Stanford Business School, Kellogg Business School”
Weaver argues that people who criticize executive coaching usually have never hired a high-quality coach, and that the value of coaching is hard to appreciate without experiencing it.
“I don't think I've ever met anyone who actually hired a very high-quality coach and had anything negative to say about the process.”
The slot-machine investment was saved by anticipating Illinois legalizing slot machines in bars, so Alpine paid bars for placement rights years early and became the largest or second-largest supplier when the law passed, enabling a sale.
“we went around Illinois and made deals with all the bars.”
Alpine schedules time outside the office for imaginative strategic thinking, and Weaver describes this as planting seeds of oak trees that yield shade five years later, which he argues lets a firm build moats if it does so consistently despite urgent work.
“we're planting seeds of oak trees that will yield us shade five years from now.”
Weaver's routine includes waking without an alarm, about eight hours of sleep, at least 15 minutes of meditation, a hard workout, and writing each day the three most important yearly goals and three actions toward them, a habit he has kept since age 12.
“I write out what are the three most important things you're doing this year and what are the three things you're doing today to move toward those things.”
As a teenager Weaver learned that you can have any goal but not 20, so you should pick one or two and draw a bright line, giving yourself permission to ignore the rest, which he says drove his early achievements.
“you can have any goal you want, but you can't have 20. So you pick the one or two that you're really excited about”
Weaver credits his refusal to join a popular, drinking, bullying athlete group at age 12 or 13 as the first time he learned to trust his inner voice, which gave him lasting confidence in following intuition.
“that gave me just so much confidence in listening to that gut from then on.”
Alpine's founders used a recession-era gap of about three years without a fund to do deep strategic thinking with executive coaches, asking why they were doing the business and what would keep them energized.
“We didn't have a fund for a number of years, so we had three years to work on our business and really do some deep thinking.”
Weaver found Wall Street private equity recruiting appealing but the 80-to-100-hour weeks of building financial models were disappointing, convincing him he had far more capacity than his job used.
“Why am I only using 3% of my capacity?”
The 5x fund target originated during the recession, when Alpine used public pension fund data to conclude that consistently delivering 3x net would put a firm among the top performers of all time, and then raised the goal once it kept beating 3x.
“we said, hey, if we could deliver 3x net consistently on every fund, that would put us in the conversation. We've been outperforming that, so we increased our goal a little bit.”
Alpine has about 80 military veterans serving as general managers of its portfolio companies, a talent pool that Weaver credits with phenomenal performance.
“for the military veterans, I think we have 80 military veterans as general managers of that company.”
Irv Grousbeck, the Stanford professor often called the father of search funds, is one of the most influential people in Weaver's life because he remembers conversations, believes in students and gives needed encouragement at difficult moments.
“I would say Irv is one of the most influential people in my life.”
At age 15 Weaver chose to drop about 30 pounds to wrestle at 125 pounds, eating about 900 calories a day, and found that deciding to change his trajectory actually worked, which made him believe in intentional goal pursuit.
“I dropped 30 pounds and I wrestled 125. I was eating 900 calories a day.”
Showing up at 5:30 a.m. for three straight weeks to use rowing machines earned Weaver mentorship from a national-team rower, showing that consistent visible effort can open doors when talent is unproven.
“After I showed up at 5:30 in the morning for three weeks in a row, he's like, 'Okay, this kid really means it.'”
Across the last four funds Alpine has replaced management 100% of the time in platform companies and about 80% of the time in add-on acquisitions, while openly telling sellers they can cash out.
“historically we've the last, I don't know, four funds. We've replaced the management 100% of the time”
Alpine's three guiding goals are to be the top-performing private equity fund in the world as measured by MOIC with a specific target of 5x on every fund, to be the best place for top talent to work, and to use the platform as a force for good.
“One is to be the number one performing private equity fund in the world as measured by MOIC. Our specific goal is 5x on every fund.”
A later label-printing business whose largest customer was Trader Joe's, growing about 15% annually with five-day payment terms, was a home-run deal that Weaver owned for 22 years and paid dividends throughout.
“the biggest customer we had was Trader Joe's, which was just like, the best customer ever.”
Weaver deliberately separates his teaching from Alpine recruiting, never interviewing or giving feedback on students, because Alpine recruits in the fall and the winter class falls after hiring decisions are made.
“I never interview students. I don't even ever give feedback on students when I'm teaching.”
Weaver spends about 25% of his time on portfolio deals and boards to keep hands-on understanding of operations, and about 75% on building Alpine itself.
“I think for me, the right balance is to probably spend around 25% of my time in the action”
Weaver learned from rowing coach Mike Teti that performance is a linear function of hours: row as long as possible slightly below aerobic threshold and goals follow, which he took as a template for achievement.
“Here's the formula. It's really simple. Sit on this machine and row as long as you can, slightly below your aerobic threshold.”
Weaver's Stanford case was about buying companies from his dorm room and failing repeatedly, making him the token failure case in a class of successful alumni, and he says the failure is part of the curriculum's value.
“I think I was the token failure case in the quarter where all these people are three-peat champions”
The kindest thing anyone has done for Weaver was his son Blake and daughter Lily driving 90 minutes to attend his Stanford class during a power outage on their day off.
“no, dad, Lily and I want to come down and watch your class.”