Frank Blake - Leading By Example - [Invest Like the Best, EP.377]
What this covers
Frank Blake, who ran Home Depot from 2007 to 2014, talks with Patrick about carrying forward the inverted pyramid culture built by founders Kenneth Langone and Bernie Marcus. Most of the conversation is practice rather than theory: how a CEO gets a message through, what he writes and says, and where he puts money and people. Two concrete anecdotes recur. One is the roughly 200 handwritten notes a week Blake sent to employees for specific acts of customer service. The other is a store lunch in Columbus, Ohio, where he learned that 75 to 80 percent of Home Depot store managers lack a college degree.
The range runs from operations to finance. Blake describes halting new store construction, writing off about $0.5 billion of pipeline, and freeing roughly $2 billion for supply chain, online and shareholder returns. He presents the move as partly a signal to the organization, and he says it proved skeptical investors wrong about existing-store productivity, a claim marked as contested. He warns of Organizational Entropy, in which companies drift from solving customer problems to solving their own. He also looks at Delta, which escaped commodity business status by putting operating metrics first on board agendas and paying leaders on Net Promoter Score. He speculates that airlines can build adjacent revenue, such as Wi-Fi access and the AmEx co-brand.
The later stretches turn to people and governance. Blake argues that leaders should hire direct reports for energy and alignment, with technical skill as the entry ticket. He wants directors with steady judgment in a crisis who avoid the Senator From X Problem. His view of dealmaking is that buyers should find the economic engine owners aren't using instead of squeezing the last penny.
Blake argues the inverted pyramid works only if leaders actively fight organizational gravity: information, messages, and resources flow up slowly and the organization resists change, so leaders must deliberately allocate capital and people, listen beyond their bubble, and communicate through concrete stories to keep the company aligned with customers.
- Messages and information must be pulled up through the organization because the organization shapes itself to the CEO's opinions and filters bad news.
- The CEO's two core jobs are allocating capital and people, and the organization is structurally built to resist changes in both.
- Concrete recognition and stories make abstract values like customer service actionable, while memos and banners do not.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Getting productivity from existing stores is economically superior to spending about $2 billion on new capital expenditure, and Home Depot's experience showed the existing base had more productivity than investors expected.
“it proved that there was more productivity in the store. And obviously... you're a lot better off getting productivity from your existing assets than going out and spending $2 billion in new CapEx.”
Halting new store construction completely and clearing the pipeline was more psychological than financial, a signal to the organization that it had to optimize existing stores, and productivity in existing stores then rose, proving investors who doubted it wrong.
“The more dramatic, stopping it completely and clearing out the pipeline was honestly probably more psychological than financial.”
Leaders who assume messages cascade down an organization like gravity are mistaken; the leader must work upward to get messages through, because most employees are not waiting to hear from the CEO and largely do not care what the CEO has to say.
“I'm always amused when I hear leaders talk about messages cascading down through an organization as if gravity were your friend. And gravity is not your friend.”
Great companies start by solving a customer problem, but over time a law of entropy pushes them to solve their own internal problems instead, and the discipline is to keep asking whether you are still solving customers' problems.
“greater organizations always start because they provide a great solution to a customer problem. And then over time, there's some law of entropy that over time companies get more interested in solving their own problems, not their customers' problems.”
The organization wants resource allocation roughly the same as last year and prefers a culture where no one leaves, so it trades off strategic change for protection, and leaders must constantly work against this default.
“The organization wants resources allocated, give or take, the same way they were last year... they'll more than happily do the trade-off that, hey, our culture is such that no one ever leaves.”
Important information is happening several layers below the CEO, and organizations put leaders in a bubble, molding themselves to the leader's opinions and feeding back what the leader wants to hear, so leaders risk never learning what frontline associates or customers are experiencing.
“The organization molds itself to fit your opinions. They feedback what they think you want to hear.”
Most leaders are surprisingly unclear about what they want, and without concrete expression people fill in the blank with their own guesses and usually miss; concrete actions like notes give content to the leader's expectations.
“most leaders are surprisingly not terribly clear about it... otherwise, without that, I'll fill in the blank on what you want and by and large I won't be right.”
Leaders become isolated because organizations are conflict averse, resistant to change within about 5 percent, and control the CEO by filling the schedule and filtering information; this is an organizational behavior rather than individual malice.
“Organizations generally are resistant to change, plus or minus 5%... It's not that people are bad. It's just this is what organizations do.”
CEOs may not need their board day to day, but they desperately need it during a crisis, so they should select directors with mature judgment who stay steady and wise under pressure, not based on age.
“you really probably don't need your Board until you need your Board and then you really need your Board... over index on mature judgement, and that isn't a statement of age”
A leader's general memo or banners declaring customer service a priority accomplish nothing, because employees need concrete expression of what the leader wants before they can rally around it.
“if I say, as I did, 'Customer service is going to be hugely important at Home Depot, and here's my memo on customer service'. All right. I mean, seriously, what has that done? That's done nothing.”
Leaders should select direct reports for their energy and ability to radiate the leader's message through the organization more than for technical competence, which is only the entry ticket to the game.
“you almost need to select for that energy quotient, the ability to radiate out the alignment with the message more than technical competence, not that technical competence is important, it's sort of the entry to the game”
A good deal is not about squeezing the last penny from the counterparty; the buyer should identify how to capture the economic engine of the business that current owners are not exploiting, so both sides see a reasonable deal and small price differences are lost over time.
“deals are not zero sum. The objective of a deal is not to come out thinking I would squeeze the last penny out of the person.”
Home Depot stopped building new stores and wrote off about $0.5 billion from its real estate pipeline, freeing roughly $2 billion of capital for supply chain, online, and shareholder returns, and reducing the business's capital intensity.
“we stopped building new stores. In fact, we took $0.5 billion write-off and cleaned out our entire real estate pipeline... which from the financial capital allocation perspective, freed up $2 billion of capital”
Writing about 200 handwritten notes a week to employees recognizing specific customer service acts made people invest in the leader's success, because people want a piece of the leader and recognition builds reciprocal loyalty.
“every Sunday, I would spend half a day writing about 200 handwritten notes... people want a piece of you as a leader... if you do that, they're much more inclined to be invested in your success.”
Many leaders announce new strategies without tying them to changes in financial or human resources, and when asked how the strategy connects to resource shifts they give vague answers, which signals the strategy will not happen.
“The number of times that you can see people who make a great pronouncement on here's the new direction the company is going in... how is that strategy tied to a change in financial or human resources, and you get not much of an answer.”
Delta escaped commodity status by making operational performance the first agenda item at board meetings, tracking on-time departures, lost bags, and involuntary boardings, and paying leaders on Net Promoter Score.
“The leadership team gets paid on Net Promoter Score... here's on-time, here's on-time departures, on-time arrivals, lost bags, involuntary boarding”
Capital-intensive airlines can build adjacent revenue, such as Delta's free Wi-Fi portal giving access to customers and its AmEx co-brand loyalty relationship, creating value beyond the physical assets and potentially increasing valuation.
“what are the adjacent things that we can do that may not be a SaaS model but that give more leverage to this physical asset... the portal on the Wi-Fi is that the customer connection that can be shared”
A store lunch with Ken Langone and Bernie Marcus in Columbus, Ohio, showed that associates who started in fill-in jobs had built careers and families, and that 75 to 80 percent of Home Depot store managers lack a college degree.
“75% to 80% of our store managers don't have a college degree. These are people who made their own lives.”
A second trade-off is that the team must be fully aligned because it bears the same weight as the leader; CEOs can work around talent but cannot work around someone who is not aligned with the organization's direction.
“You can work around the talent, but you can't work around someone who's not aligned with where you're trying to take the organization.”
Board members should not act as the advocate for their own functional expertise on every issue, which Blake calls being the 'Senator from X'; instead they should broaden their view, because the company should hire experts for specialized roles.
“don't become the Senator from X, try to broaden out in terms of how you cover what the company does.”
The most effective way to communicate a value like customer service is through stories and recognition: bring a specific employee on stage, tell what they did, and repeat it consistently, because audiences then think they can do the same thing.
“the most effective way to communicate is through stories and through recognition and celebration. So it is by saying if what we want is customer service, then it's taking Joe or Jane on the literal or virtual stage”
Issuing a memo or putting up banners announcing customer service as a priority does nothing to change behavior, whereas a specific story about a customer interaction carries emotional meaning that empowers associates.
“if I say, as I did, "Customer service is going to be hugely important at Home Depot, and here's my memo on customer service"... That's done nothing.”
Picking strategic priorities in an inverted organization is straightforward if leaders look to customers at the top of the pyramid, because great companies start by solving a customer problem and the discipline is asking whether they still do.
“the only way it works is if you look to what's at the top of the pyramid, which is your customers”
The CEO's two key jobs are to allocate capital and allocate people correctly, because if these are done right everything else falls into place, while if they are done wrong, a great culture and everything else will not matter.
“to be a successful leader, you've got to allocate capital right, you've got to allocate human resources right. And if you do those two things right, everything else will fall in place.”
Two competing Home Depot and Lowe's stores in Opelousas, Louisiana, revealed that the high-growth store-opening model had overrun real demand, so the investor-modeled growth engine of opening over 200 stores a year was no longer producing good returns on capital.
“does Opelousas, Louisiana need two massive home improvement stores? No... this was genuinely Wile E. Coyote.”
Blake personally wrote about 200 handwritten notes every Sunday, citing specific customer-service examples surfaced from districts and regions, and found that a store associate later asked him to rewrite a note because they doubted he had written it himself.
“every Sunday, I would spend half a day writing about 200 handwritten notes... within a few months of being CEO, I'm walking in a store and an associate comes up to me and says, "You wrote me a really nice note a couple of weeks ago, would you mind writing it to me again?"”
Frank spent half of every Sunday handwriting roughly 200 personal notes to frontline associates who exemplified great customer service, routed up from districts and regions, and the practice produced visible loyalty within months of his becoming CEO.
“every Sunday, I would spend half a day writing about 200 handwritten notes”
At GE, the path to success under Jack Welch was disagreeing with the CEO and being right, and Welch genuinely invited confrontation, using arguments to test how hard subordinates would push back.
“the path to success at GE was going to be disagreeing with the CEO and Chair and being right... And with Jack, it genuinely did.”
Effective directors push CEOs through questions that make the CEO realize a better answer is needed; a board with experienced directors who ask smart questions is like training for the CEO.
“what Ken was great about... was asking a lot of questions and through their questions go, oh, okay, yes. I ought to have a better answer to that”
Frank survived his unlikely CEO start by leaning on a strong team, lead director Ken Langone, and founders, and by studying great leaders plus shareholder-value thinking, and he says he should have started with the team.
“I was very fortunate to have folks like Ken and a really strong Board and a great team. ... I should have started there.”
When COVID collapsed Delta's revenue by about 95 percent, CEO Ed Bastian presented the board a single page of seven bullets that put customers and employees first, then laid out every financial lever, and the company followed through.
“Within a month, 95% of the revenues of the business leave... Ed comes to the Board, and he has a single piece of paper with seven bullet points on it”
Blake aimed for the roughly 400,000 associates on the store floor to give the same answer when asked what the CEO wants, modeling this on the clarity Reagan's administration provided its appointees.
“I want the 400,000 associates on the floor of the store. If somebody goes and says, what does your CEO want, I want them to be able to give the same answer.”
For a message to move up through an organization it must be simple, repeated over and over, compelling to others, and aligned with the organization's self-interest so that each person adopts it as their own.
“the message has to be simple. It has to be repeated over and over again. It has to have something that is compelling to the rest of the organization and compelling to the organization's self-interest”
Leaders avoid isolation by holding skip-level meetings and direct conversations with customers, vendors, and frontline employees, and by making clear that people may disagree with them.
“You need to have the skip-level meetings. You need to be meeting with your customers, your vendors, your frontline people.”
Board members should give candid, relevant, and thoughtful advice, whether one-on-one, in committee, or with the full board, since being candid is the core of the director role.
“be willing to be candid, which either candid one-on-one, candid in the committee or candid around the Board team”
Delta's vision of moving away from a commodity product was sound, but the vision alone is insufficient; Blake argues execution and attention to detail, which Ed Bastian's team sustained, made the difference, and the airline business is more complicated than making table sauce.
“the vision without the execution and without the focus... So the vision is powerful, the execution even more so.”
In any organization, when a leader asks a store manager how things are going, there is only one acceptable answer, that everything is great, so leaders should not rely on such check-ins to learn what is actually happening.
“There is only one right answer to that in any organization. The answer is everything is going great, you are wonderful, please leave.”
The humility in the inverted pyramid is only partial: leadership is a weight-bearing position where the leader must be singularly devoted to the organization's success, because self-regarding leaders cause the organization to fracture under anxiety and a hard job.
“it's humble in one way, but it's not in another. And the way in which it's not humble is the way that the organization is on you. When you're leading an organization, it's a weight-bearing position.”
Reagan's leadership was effective because political appointees always knew what the President stood for; a cabinet member's message that the President wants you to withstand a negative New York Times article shows how clarity cascades through an organization.
“He wants you to be able to take a negative article in The New York Times... you're not here for self-regarding behavior that's going to get you praised”
Bernie Marcus advised Blake when he became CEO that when he told jokes around the leadership table everyone would laugh, so he should remember he is not actually funny, illustrating how deference distorts a leader's feedback.
“He said, "Look, you're going to get into the -- around the table with your leadership team, and you get to tell a joke and everybody is going to laugh, and just remember, you're not funny".”
Great investors like Ken Langone and Anne-Marie Peterson have strong opinions and rapid information processing with high curiosity, yet they can be moved off a view by good arguments, which is a version of Marc Andreessen's strong opinions, lightly held.
“There wasn't lightly help like Marc Andreessen comment, "Strong opinions, lightly help". Those all more than lightly help, and the same with Anne-Marie, but you could move them off that opinion.”
Ed Bastian presented three priorities to the board during succession from Richard Anderson, all aimed at moving Delta away from a commodity product, and he remained consistent on all three.
“Here are the three things we need to do, and they're all pretty much directed towards how do I move this airline away from a commodity product”
Associates at a Columbus, Ohio lunch with Ken Langone and Bernie Marcus credited Home Depot with letting them own homes and send kids to college, and Frank argues the company's advancement pathway is the American dream.
“because of working at Home Depot for 20 years, I now own a house and I have sent my kids to college”
Recognition by a senior leader generates lasting loyalty, illustrated by fans who prize autographs from marginal players because they see those players as future stars.
“if you've got a baseball card autographed by the utility infielder, what happened? Well, I want that person to play, I want that person to be a star”
Directors should not act as investigators hunting for what is going wrong in a company, because doing so wastes everyone's time; such investigations belong outside the boardroom.
“avoid the forensic Board member. Don't view the person who's going, "I know that something is going wrong here, and I'm going to waste everybody's time finding out what's going on". I mean if you want to do that, do that in another room.”
Leadership alignment at scale is achieved through repeated, consistent mechanisms such as notes, stories, and skip-levels rather than one-time announcements or charisma.
“if you do it intentionally and if you do it consistently and if you do it through compelling story within the context of your business, you actually do get the alignment”
George H.W. Bush's personal handwritten notes to his small staff made staffers feel elevated, and Frank later adopted that recognition habit at Home Depot.
“he would spend an hour typing individual notes... you get a note like that, and it just made you walk on air”
Political appointees must accept that doing the right thing may draw negative press, because the mission matters more than self-regarding praise, a lesson Frank took from a Reagan cabinet member's speech.
“you're not here for self-regarding behavior that's going to get you praised in The New York Times”
The two biggest lessons from great leaders are high energy and a willingness to tolerate and actively invite disagreement; most bosses say they want candid input but do not behave that way.
“every boss says that he or she wants to hear the candid opinion from their employees, but that doesn't play out that way around the table.”
David Novak at Yum! took photos with restaurant associates and Blake followed the practice in stores, hanging photos of associates in the CEO's office so visiting families could see them, which created lasting investment.
“he would take photographs with his associates in the restaurants, and I would do it in the stores... I got you and me on a photo on the wall in my office.”
Home Depot's cheer ended with 'let's kick a**' in blue, and the competitive message was embedded in the culture through symbols like Carol Tomé wearing blue suits on earnings day, while customer service remained the first job.
“the Home Depot cheer used to end with, let's kick a**. And the a** was always blue... Carol Tomé... on earnings day, she would always wear blue suits.”
Blake attended dinners with hourly associates in cities he visited almost every week, hearing life stories that he considers the most meaningful part of leading and that he would write about if he ever wrote a book.
“Whenever I'd fly into a city, I'd sit down and I have dinner with hourly associates... If I were to ever write a book, that's the book I would write.”
Blake's transition succeeded because he had prior Home Depot exposure, relied on founders and lead director Ken Langone for centering principles, studied great leaders' approaches, and built a strong team that later produced several CEOs.
“I had a really strong team. My CFO is now running UPS. My Head of Stores is now running Lowe's.”
Small differences in purchase price of about half a year's worth of value are lost over time if the buyer has accurately understood and captured the business's economic engine.
“The small differences of half a year or something on what you pay is going to be lost in time if you've done what drives the economic engine of the business if you've accurately understood them.”
Blake, a lawyer by training, says lawyers make simple things seem complicated to bill for unwinding them, whereas leadership requires doing the reverse: making strategy clear and portable across the organization.
“The leadership stuff is the reverse. You've got to make it clear and portable throughout your organization.”
Delta never involuntarily furloughed an employee during COVID despite losing 95 percent of revenue, and it kept empty middle seats long after other airlines, forgoing cost savings to protect customers.
“They never involuntarily furloughed an employee... Delta was -- maintained an empty middle seat long past the other airlines.”
A Home Depot cashier waived payment for materials when a customer said he was building a coffin for his grandson, and the story is powerful because it shows empowerment to do right by customers in a way a policy statement cannot.
“Don't even think about paying for it”
The inverted pyramid model places the CEO and leadership team at the bottom and customers and frontline employees at the top, a concept that came from Home Depot's founders and that Blake formalized over eight years as CEO.
“it's the CEO and the leadership team are at the bottom of the pyramid, not at the top, and the customer and your frontline employees are at the top of the pyramid”
A major trade-off of the inverted pyramid is that it takes time: leaders can make big reallocations of resources, but the approach requires consistent effort over years, Blake's case being about eight years, rather than a single directive.
“I think one of the things that is a trade-off is it takes time. You can make big changes in allocation of resources... But the nature of things is it's not one directive.”
Blake was an unlikely CEO choice because he was a lawyer who had moved into GE M&A and then Home Depot Supply deal-making, had little known retail reputation, and was seen as a lawyer who did not understand retail.
“Within the retail world, no one knew who Frank Blake was... he's a lawyer. He comes from GE, and he doesn't really know retail.”
Delta moved its capital allocation away from smaller regional jets toward mainline aircraft, so passengers now more often fly a mainline airline, which is part of its strategy against commodity status.
“Delta has moved away from smaller regional jets. So now, while there's still some in service, odds are you're going to get on a regular mainline airline.”
George Bush, when Vice President, spent an hour each morning writing personal handwritten notes to staff, which made recipients feel elevated and who were loyal to him for years.
“he would spend an hour typing individual notes... As a staff person, you get a note like that, and it just made you walk on air.”
Ken Langone, as lead director, called Blake every day during the 2007 housing crisis, offering counsel and encouragement, which Blake considers the kindest thing anyone has done for him.
“While he was my lead director, I got a call from Ken every day... It was raining frogs, and here was this guy every day saying it's okay, it's okay.”
Larry Bossidy bet $10,000 that Frank would not last six months as Home Depot CEO, reflecting how improbable the appointment seemed.
“Larry Bossidy, who hired me at GE, bet $10,000 I wouldn't last 6 months”
Home Depot had been out-competed and losing market share to Lowe's for a while, and the company made gaining share back a major objective.
“We had been out-comped. We have been losing share to Lowe's for a while. And so, it was a big point to start to gain share.”
After retiring, Blake concluded he needed to become more generous, having seen the generosity of Ken Langone, Bernie Marcus, and Arthur Blank.
“because of the example that I saw set by Ken and Bernie and Arthur and others of generosity. One of the things I thought is I need to learn how to be more generous.”
Frank's lead directors Ken Langone, Bonnie Hill, and Greg Brenneman all combined mature judgment with the ability to ask probing questions, which Frank regarded as the model of a useful board.
“I had both Ken and Bonnie Hill and then Greg Brenneman, who are all that way.”
Patrick asked the Home Depot-style closing question, which is procedural framing and not a substantive claim.
“It's a wonderful bridge to my favorite and traditional closing question for you.”