Devon Zuegel: How To Create A New Town - [Invest Like the Best, EP.413]
What this covers
Devon Zuegel, founder of the Esmeralda Institute, talks with host Patrick about Esmeralda, a town she is planning in California wine country. It is modeled on the Chautauqua communities she loved growing up, but she wants residents to be peers who build businesses, art, and research rather than a lifelong audience for visiting lecturers. The conversation starts small, with how a friend's distance decides whether you drop by, text first, or plan ahead, and why Manhattan restaurants rush tables while cheaper cities let people linger. It then moves to the practical problems of founding a town.
The financial middle stretch is the most concrete. Zuegel explains the Lender Asymmetric Payoff, which makes debt-financed real estate cautious about novelty. She traces the history through short balloon loans that failed in the Depression and the federal mortgage standards that followed, a reading she presents as contested. New towns return capital over 10 to 20 years, which clashes with typical fund lifespans. She argues that places like Las Catalinas and Serenbe have still out-earned conventional development, and that debt fits better at later, lower-risk stages. Infrastructure costs, mostly buried underground, can decide whether a project survives.
The rest is more contested or more experimental. Zuegel argues that planners overreached into details like hallway width, and that cars let individuals choose space in ways that hollow out walkable cores. She also discusses property taxes as a price signal. On the practical side, she describes entering the community as an organizer before buying land, using a pop-up village to get faster feedback, and holding optional nightly dinners so residents reliably run into one another.
Zuegel argues that environments and their frictions shape human behavior, so building new towns requires designing for coordination, patient capital, and tight feedback loops, and that the barriers to doing so are largely financial and regulatory conventions rather than technical difficulty.
- Proximity, cost of space, and tool friction systematically shape what people do, so environment design is behavior design
- Debt-based real estate finance and 30-year mortgage norms lock in the status quo, while patient equity can earn high returns on new towns
- Community trust, peer-to-peer containers, and short feedback loops (pop-up villages) are how a new town can be validated before concrete is poured
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Lenders receive only fixed interest and bear the full downside of default, so they are inherently cautious and resist borrowers' novel projects, while equity holders share in upside, which is why debt-financed real estate locks in the status quo.
“lenders are inherently cautious. They do not want the borrower to take any interesting risks with that money because they don't get any upside”
Short balloon loans of about five years failed en masse during the Great Depression; in response, the FHA and agencies including Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac created longer mortgages and national eligibility rules that locked in one ideal of the home.
“A lot of people's loans came due just when the Depression hit”
Las Catalinas in Costa Rica preserves 1,000 of its 1,200 acres as rainforest and develops the remaining 200 as a dense, car-free hill town, showing that removing cars allows far more homes and amenities in a given area than conventional American development.
“once you take cars fully out of the equation of a residential neighborhood, suddenly everything can be a lot closer together.”
New towns take 10 to 20 years to return capital, which mismatches the five-to-seven-year life of traditional real estate funds, so patient capital is needed; historical examples were funded by a single wealthy family or a lumber company's long-horizon land holdings.
“Often traditional real estate funds need to return capital in five to seven years. These projects tend to take 10, 15, maybe 20 years”
Railroads and later cars opened previously inaccessible land, creating towns around transportation hubs and American suburbs on the periphery of cities, and each new transport frontier explains why new towns sprout at certain times.
“Cars had a similar effect... The car opened up a new frontier on the outskirts of cities”
Cities are coordination problems in which people trade space against access to amenities, and the car, by opening the periphery, let individuals choose more space, which in aggregate hollows out the walkable core.
“everybody's always making a trade-off between space and access.”
Property taxes that track rising real estate values send a price signal that encourages people to locate in productive areas, while freezing taxes dulls that signal and allows owners to hold valuable land empty at low cost.
“When you freeze property taxes at a much lower level, you end up dulling that price signal.”
How far a friend lives changes how people socialize: same-block neighbors drop by spontaneously, a 10-minute walk prompts texting first, and a 20-minute distance requires advance planning, so proximity is a key lever for social life.
“If you live on the same block, you might knock on their door... if you live 20 minutes away, you're probably going to plan ahead”
Infrastructure such as roads, sewers, and electrical systems is astronomically expensive and largely invisible underground, so people underestimate it, and a 10 percent infrastructure cost overrun could decide whether a town project succeeds or fails.
“If your infrastructure costs end up being 10% more than you expect, that could be the difference between having a successful project versus not.”
High real estate cost makes businesses in expensive cities like Manhattan push customers to turn tables quickly and discourage lingering, whereas low-cost cities tolerate long stays, so the price of space directly shapes social and commercial behavior.
“because that seat is expensive for them”
Environments such as office floor plans, weather, and street layouts fundamentally shape how people think, feel, and behave, so one can deliberately design one's environment to shape oneself in desired ways.
“It came from realizing how much environments shape the way I think, feel, and behave”
There are more people who would prefer to live in a walkable community than there are walkable communities, largely because of the coordination problem created by car-oriented development.
“I do think that there are more people who want to live in a walkable community than there are walkable communities”
Federal agencies such as the FHA, Fannie Mae, and Freddie Mac created standardized mortgage rules, including detailed physical requirements, that centralized decision-making nationwide and removed the evolutionary pressure of free-market experimentation, locking in an ideal of what a home should be.
“It gets rid of a lot of the evolutionary pressures that you would normally get in a more free-market system.”
Short-term balloon mortgages of about five years, which came due during the Great Depression when credit had frozen, left many borrowers unable to refinance and caused widespread home losses.
“a lot of people had taken out short-term, what are called balloon loans, and they were only a few years”
Real estate risk falls as a project moves from raw land to infrastructure to vertical construction and sales, so debt becomes more appropriate at later stages where approvals and demand are clearer.
“the earlier you are in this project, the riskier it is”
Early city planning emerged because dense living produced problems such as cholera in water systems, but over time planners overextended, regulating details like hallway width and house distance from the road that should be left to organic local solutions.
“There would be more issues of cholera in the water system, which would kill a lot of people.”
Purpose-built walkable towns such as Serenbe, Seaside, Trilith, Seabrook, and Las Catalinas have made more money than conventional development, but the payoff takes longer, so the returns are real but illiquid relative to standard fund timelines.
“when people build this way, they do make more money. It does take longer though.”
Reducing friction through tools or places is not always beneficial, because it biases behavior toward whatever is easy, so environment designers should deliberately keep some friction where it guards valuable activity.
“lower friction is not always better because if you create lower frictions through the tools you use or the places you live, you're going to bias your behavior towards low friction stuff.”
Software iteration takes seconds while real estate takes years, so long feedback loops in development mean that flawed site plans or infrastructure can be locked in before anyone learns whether people want them.
“Nothing in real estate takes 20 seconds. Nothing.”
Because real estate is culturally built on debt, projects that avoid leverage must be sufficiently innovative to offset lower returns, and only transformative projects like Chautauqua can clear that hurdle, while partially innovative projects fall flat.
“if you're not going to take on debt, you will hurt your returns. What you're doing better be sufficiently innovative”
A friend designated a quarter-mile circle in San Francisco and invited his network to move there, and within six months it became the center of gravity for their social lives, showing that a simple coordination signal can create a community focal point.
“He said, 'Next time you consider moving, move to this area.' Then we can all live close to each other.”
Nightly community dinners that are optional but always available, modeled on college dining halls, ensure residents reliably bump into friends and interesting people without forcing attendance.
“It's like a dining hall where people come, and you always know that you're going to bump into some friends”
Esmeralda aims to improve on Chautauqua by shifting from lifelong consumption of lectures by visiting experts toward action-oriented building of businesses, art, and research, and by making residents peers who are experts in their own right rather than audiences for stage speakers.
“Chautauqua is much more about lifelong learning than it is about building.”
Rather than arriving as a developer with plans to bulldoze land, the team entered the community first as organizers, building trust through events before purchasing any land, which is necessary to overcome negative reactions to development in California.
“we first come in as community organizers—people who bring people together”
Empowerment is not bestowed by one person; it requires trust that is earned incrementally, and the person being empowered must give the empowerer a reason to extend trust.
“empowerment is something that requires trust, and for someone to empower you, you also have to give them a reason to do so.”
Empowerment requires trust, and it is built reciprocally, so the capacity Zuegel developed early through caring for her younger brother with special needs grew incrementally each time she earned more trust from her parents.
“empowerment is something that requires trust, and for someone to empower you, you also have to give them a reason to do so”
Esmeralda uses fee-simple lots and zero-lot-line homes, which look like townhomes but do not share walls, to keep ownership simple and make the project fit standard mortgage underwriting while remaining innovative.
“There are a lot of tactical decisions like that which allow the project to fit cleanly into a mortgage lender's box”
A plausible but untestable theory holds that California startup culture took root because warm year-round garages offered cheap, usable workspace attached to homes, whereas cold East Coast garages did not, and cheap space enables more physically intensive creativity.
“startups took root in California... because there are garages that are warm enough most of the year”
Building a new town is not a technical breakthrough, since buildings and roads are known engineering, yet new towns are rare because the frontier is perceived as closed, the idea seems abnormal, and the best locations are already taken.
“On some level, it shouldn't be that hard because we know how to build buildings, and we know how to build roads. This is not rocket science.”
Thirty-year lending horizons make lenders even more risk-averse than shorter loans, because a 30-year bet spans enormous social and economic change, which further entrenches the status quo.
“if you're lending money as a bank for 30 years, you are even less risk-taking than any normal lender”
Running Edge Esmeralda as an unconference, where the organizers provide venues and AV but attendees fill the schedule, produced unplanned collaborations such as a solar A-frame campsite built by volunteers who responded to a group text.
“we instead create a container for things to happen... those people end up filling the slots”
A local critic who announced a sign reading 'Don't colonize Healdsburg' became one of the most engaged attendees and then a close helper, illustrating that opposition often stems from misunderstanding and can be converted through direct engagement.
“many people, I think, are much more amenable to conversation and trying to find common ground”
Tools, like physical environments, make some actions easier and so bias behavior toward them, so a person's identity is partly defined by the tools and spaces they use.
“if you have a tool that makes it really easy to do one thing and much harder to do another thing, you're going to tend to do the first thing more.”
Experiencing the walkable lifestyle at Edge Esmeralda converted a skeptical friend who had resisted verbal descriptions, showing that for community real estate, direct experience is more persuasive than explanation.
“the idea of 'show, don't tell.' ... I see why you've been talking about this for so long.”
Investing more upfront in excellent public places costs more on day one but yields higher property value later, because modern developments that build only housing and skip downtowns capture less long-term value than walkable towns with public space.
“people will end up paying way more for it in year five, year ten, than if you churn out another ticky-tacky box.”
Frontier Camp, an unconference for about 120 people, produced real collaborations because putting people together in a context focused on specific work and optimism prompted them to start joint projects that later produced papers.
“people are really seeking out containers in which to live, act, and meet others.”
Proving that a new town model works, creating an existence proof, will inspire other developers and capital to copy it, which is why the project aims to show the model is possible rather than to be dominant.
“Providing an existence proof that this is possible would inspire people to do more.”
Development risk is highest at the raw land stage, before infrastructure and approvals exist, which is also where debt is least desirable because it creates a ticking clock before cash flows begin, so Esmeralda funds land purchases entirely with equity.
“For us, we strongly prefer to fund the land purchase entirely with equity.”
Core public systems such as clean water and transportation networks should be planned in advance, while house color and similar local choices should be left to organic, lower-level decisions, in a federal-style system that pushes decisions down as far as possible.
“You want to have as many decisions pushed to the lowest level as possible”
Devon values expanding human potential as a terminal value because life is finite, and she sees the broadening of possibilities across history as progress that brings her awe.
“My first reaction is it's almost like a terminal value.”
Devon's highly efficient email setup, with hotkeys and a counter, has made responding to email a video game that draws her away from more important work, showing that too-low friction can bias attention toward low-value tasks.
“I've turned my inbox into a video game where I have a counter and points”
Hosting a pop-up village 15 minutes from the site and planning walks of the property lets Esmeralda test site plans and community preferences cheaply before concrete is poured.
“how do we take this huge thing and turn it into smaller bite-sized pieces that we can learn from.”
Publicly discussing one's interests online draws people with shared values to come to you, which is how Devon found developers, architects, and a Dutch street designer, and it works better than cold outreach.
“if you talk about the stuff you find interesting online, enough people will come to you”
Community trust is a long-term process that cannot be demanded on day one; like tending a garden, a developer must plant seeds, show up consistently, and earn trust over time.
“I think it's more like tending a garden than it is like anything else.”
Edge Esmeralda, a 30-day summer pop-up village in Healdsburg, served as a prototype for the permanent town, drawing 1,300 attendees last year and testing ideas like nightly community dinners that are optional but always available.
“Last year, we had 1,300 people attend Edge Esmeralda”
As the number of new-town examples grows, conservative capital becomes more willing to participate, so proof points in the Southeast and Seabrook in Washington State matter for attracting institutional money to California projects.
“As we have more examples, more conservative capital will be interested in participating”
Devon grew up visiting Chautauqua, a roughly 8,000-person town founded about 150 years ago that hosts a nine-week summer season of lectures, performances, and workshops; her husband's question about why there are no more places like it led her to plan a modern Chautauqua-style town in California.
“why aren't there more places like Chautauqua? Why is this the only one?”
Homes in Chautauqua sell for roughly twice as much as comparable homes just outside the town, as seen in Zillow data, which suggested that new town development can be a strong business.
“homes in Chautauqua sell for dramatically more than those outside the town. I think it's twice as much”
Chautauqua, a town of about 8,000 people founded roughly 150 years ago in western New York, runs a nine-week summer season of lectures, workshops, symphony, opera, and theater, functioning like a multigenerational college campus.
“for nine weeks every summer, Chautauqua hosts what they call the season”
Streets are the single most important building block of a city because the way they interface with buildings and public spaces defines the feel of a city.
“I think that streets are the single most important building block in a city.”
An empty, centrally located San Francisco lot held for decades by an owner paying very low property tax exemplifies how Prop 13-style freezes let owners hold land idle while nearby renters pay thousands per month.
“I was walking around San Francisco yesterday and noticed an empty lot.”
People moving to a new town are buying the people they will know as well as the house, so showing prospective residents the types of people attracted to the community helps them imagine their children's friendships and their own place there.
“they're also considering who lives there—someone they'd like to know.”
Seabrook, a town about two and a half hours from Seattle built over 20 years, is a financial success, and Devon uses it to argue that a similar model could work in California because Seattle and San Francisco are more alike than Southeastern markets.
“Seattle and San Francisco have a lot more similarities than Atlanta or Birmingham, Alabama.”
There is no single correct town design; choices depend on the community's purpose, such as an industrial hub, a resort, or a multigenerational or generation-targeted community, so one should build a detailed mental model of specific goals.
“It's not a binary thing either. It depends on what your goals are.”
A wide, fast road next to Healdsburg's plaza creates friction that makes crossing feel not worth the effort, while the narrower streets on the other side are easy to cross, showing how road width shapes which places people visit.
“there's this friction where I'm like, oh, it better be really worth it for me to get to the other side of this road”
Using debt lets a developer need less equity and so earn higher returns if the project succeeds, but it creates default risk and cash-flow pressure, so the equity-versus-debt choice is a trade-off between upside and fragility.
“you might end up with higher returns if things go well because you need less equity to fund the project”
California's Proposition 13, passed in the 1970s, froze property tax increases at a maximum of 2 percent per year, so long-held homes such as those owned by Devon's parents since the early 1980s pay little tax despite large appreciation.
“Proposition 13, which was passed in the 1970s and basically froze property tax increases—at a maximum of 2% a year.”
Dense cities without planning suffered cholera from contaminated water systems, which precipitated the first wave of urban planning.
“There would be more issues of cholera in the water system, which would kill a lot of people.”
Keeping a phone out of sight makes a person forget it exists and stop using it, while keeping it nearby causes checking every few minutes, showing that physical placement alone changes behavior.
“if I have my phone next to me... I'll check it every few minutes to see if I have notifications”
Hand surgeons Dr. Miki and Dr. Buntic treated Devon with respect by including her in decision-making and convening a 12-expert conference about her hand, showing that engaged patient involvement can improve care.
“they treated me with so much respect, particularly encouraging my curiosity and making it so that I was part of the decision-making process”
Devon deliberately studies places at extremes on a dimension, such as Las Catalinas' car-free design, because extremes reveal the limits of a system more quickly than middling examples.
“I really like studying things that are extremes on a particular dimension because I think that you end up learning a lot about the limits of the system.”
Building a town requires hardware (physical real estate and infrastructure) and software (community practices and culture), and because hardware takes years, Esmeralda starts the software side early through a pop-up village.
“On the software side, we've actually gotten things started because it's going to take a while to build all that hardware.”
A widespread feeling that the American frontier is closed, and that the industry has reached an end of history, reduces the appetite for building new towns from scratch.
“there's a sense that the frontier is closed in the United States”
Right now there is basically no institutional capital in California for new towns, and no clean comparables exist there, while the Southeast has a growing community of practice and rising institutional investment.
“Right now, in California, there's basically none.”
Real estate development increasingly feels imposed from above by external capital, which makes local residents react negatively, so projects need local buy-in to succeed.
“a lot of real estate development these days has become something that's imposed from above”
Devon is not anti-car but views cars like horses: a fine hobby with valid applications that should not dictate the shape of entire cities.
“I think of cars the way I think of horses”
Large housing subdivisions built at town scale are not true towns because they lack public spaces and walkable destinations, containing homes without anywhere to walk.
“There are large subdivisions built at the scale of towns, but I would never call those towns”
Michael Nielsen's world tour, including a bamboo forest in Japan and Hiroshima, taught Devon not to become jaded by famous places and to see their historical significance.
“the number one thing I've learned from Michael is to always maintain a sense of wonder”
The intended Esmeralda resident is an adult with a young family whose older parents or grandparents also live nearby, where kids have independence to walk around, there is high community trust, and neighbors share values.
“three, and sometimes even four, generations all in the same home”
Visiting inspirational towns with a group of about 20 for a week simulates living there more fully than a solo trip, because shared community reveals how a place feels to live in.
“when you go somewhere by yourself, you don't fully experience what it's like to live there”
Before buying any land, Esmeralda ran a multimillion-dollar event that brought thousands of people and millions of dollars of business into Sonoma County, building local goodwill before any development commitment.
“We haven't even purchased the land, but we've already run a multimillion-dollar event”
Zuegel joined the Stanford Review because it offered intellectual diversity and challenging ideas, even on taboo topics, which she found missing from the campus's more uniform discourse.
“I liked that there was a diversity of viewpoints and people who would challenge me”
Success for the project means proving the model so Zuegel's team can build many more villages, and inspiring other developers through an existence proof that this type of development is possible, while she personally wants to live there.
“Providing an existence proof that this is possible would inspire people to do more.”
Her husband's question about why Chautauqua is the only place of its kind led Zuegel to realize that the town's origins were not commonly examined, and she then spent about five years researching how such towns come into being.
“why aren't there more places like Chautauqua? Why is this the only one?”
Patrick draws a parallel between the Wynwood Miami story, where police and graffiti artists became collaborators, and Devon's experience converting skeptics into partners.
“the cops and the graffiti artists, once enemies, became collaborators and friends”
Hosting the city managers of Cloverdale and Healdsburg on a panel at Edge let them describe their priorities and gave future residents a sense of local challenges, building relationships with government.
“I invited the city managers of both Cloverdale and Healdsburg”