David Fialkow - Paint Outside the Lines - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 243]
What this covers
Patrick talks with David Fialkow, co-founder of General Catalyst, philanthropist, and Oscar-winning producer of the documentary Icarus. Fialkow argues that he and his partners lacked investing or technology backgrounds and Ivy League or Goldman Sachs pedigrees, and that this helped because they were not trained to chase gold stars for staying inside the lines. That idea runs into his Four-Filter Founder Screen: love of the product, the ability to sell and tell stories, enough modesty to listen, and a mission that holds under testing. He calls venture the art of luck and money a commodity, so he wants firms to act as builders and to defer to founders' instincts.
The examples are concrete. Jim Koch turning Boston Beer toward Truly illustrates the pivot. Fialkow describes the float in a travel business, which works only while growth continues. He recounts General Catalyst leaving Boston after a lost deal, then expanding by giving regional partners autonomy under one culture. He also admits to bluffing about cloud backup before bringing in partners who knew the field. The Icarus story shows Bryan Fogel's failed doping experiment turning into a Russian state-doping investigation.
Some positions are contested: letting founders sell secondaries, and the claim that tech leaders can influence voting-rights policy through public trust rather than donations. Fialkow also describes convening founders with athletes, filmmakers, and academics, and spending much of his time shielding founders from investors who push a quick sale. Ken Chenault comes up as a CEO who stands apart from his peers.
David Fialkow argues that venture returns come from backing founders who love their product, can pivot without abandoning their mission, and can be trusted through adversity, and that firms should empower founders with empathy, storytelling, and convening rather than capital alone.
- Money is a commodity; the valuable contribution is helping founders build the business through empathy and storytelling
- Founders who love their product pivot the business rather than abandon it, and pivoting is where venture returns come from
- Adversity reveals character, so investors should select for judgment and resolve under pressure rather than written rules
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Boston Beer founder Jim Koch pivoted the company's beer business into Truly, a malt-based flavored seltzer that competed with tequila, reaching a billion dollars in under three years compared with about 40 years for beer, because he kept the product's roots while responding to consumer tastes.
“Zero to a billion. It took him 40 years to get to a billion dollars in beer. And in less than three years, Truly is over a billion dollars.”
The travel business generated roughly two months of float because customers paid upfront while vendors were paid a month after the trip, but that float only works as long as the business keeps growing, since shrinking reverses it.
“that two months of float only works as long as you grow the business, because if you stop growing, then”
When David met Austin McCourt, he bluffed about cloud backup by citing Barracuda, then admitted a year later he did not understand the field. He recognized his knowledge gap and matched McCourt with partners who did.
“I was smart enough, A, to get him the right partner at GC who knew a lot about this stuff and B to know what my role would be with him”
When a business can afford it and the team is strong, letting founders sell some shares in secondaries lets them meet personal financial needs like buying a house, and giving founders money does not cause them to lose their hunger.
“If a business can afford it and the team is great and you're in it in the long haul, the founders take some money out.”
Venture capital returns come largely from pivots, which require founders who can change direction without losing the core vision, and founders who will not pivot leave investors with no path to returns.
“there's no room for a pivot, which is the major part of where venture capital returns come from.”
General Catalyst started in Boston but lost a deal because it was not local, so it moved to Silicon Valley after an advisor warned that a Boston-only firm would be marginal.
“They claimed it was because we weren't local.”
Tech leaders and firms can influence public policy such as voting rights not through political donations, which no longer works, but through the trust that CEOs and the public place in their businesses, which they can use as a carrot instead of a stick.
“Not because we can give money and we can donate to politicians, that doesn't work anymore.”
Venture firms should see themselves as builders and makers rather than steely-eyed investors, because money is a commodity and the real value is helping founders build the business from the bottom up.
“The word investor doesn't work in my mind in the venture business. We're builders. We're makers.”
People trained at Ivy League schools, business school, and Goldman Sachs tend to view risk and failure as painful blemishes on their gold-star record, which makes it harder for them to pivot and learn from mistakes.
“you tend to look at risk as painful. 'I don't want to lose a gold star. I don't want to have a blemish.'”
Great founders are not necessarily charismatic; they are obsessive about something they believe in, so they do not sell investors or customers but simply tell them how they see the product, which others perceive as selling but is actually belief.
“A lot of the founders that we talked about, I would be hard pressed to say that they were charismatic. What I would say is they're obsessive about something that they believe in.”
The founders had no investing or technology background and no Ivy League or Goldman Sachs pedigree, which they viewed as an advantage because they were not conditioned to get gold stars for staying inside the lines.
“We're outsiders, we're total outsiders.”
Adversity does not teach character but reveals it, so investors should select founders who will make the right decisions under pressure through gut instinct rather than relying on written rules or principles.
“adversity does not teach character, it reveals it.”
The documentary Icarus began as Bryan Fogel's plan to dope for a year and film it, but when the doping project failed, the VCs pivoted it into an investigation of Russian state doping through Gregory Rodchenkov, and held on through the film's completion.
“All we did was helping him pivot.”
Investors should continue supporting a founder through setbacks by providing air cover, encouragement, and resources, because the founder's resolve must be maintained when threats and hacking arise.
“We provide him air cover. We provided encouragement and nutrition along the way to keep going.”
The travel company deliberately hired people from outside the travel industry and made teammates as enjoyment-driven as customers, arguing that cheaper trips should come with a better experience, not a worse one.
“We didn't hire anybody from the travel business. We wanted to recreate the experience.”
The firm's core advantage is a mentor mentality that keeps every stakeholder, including investors, team members, and co-investors, aligned around the founder who is running the company, which means resisting co-investors who treat founders poorly.
“The part we've done well is build a mentor mentality. It totally changes the way you deal with investors, founders, your team, board members, co-investors, everything.”
After being unable to compete from Boston, where a lost deal was attributed to not being local, the firm expanded to New York and San Francisco by giving partners full autonomy to run regional businesses with their own pricing, networks, and ecosystems while keeping one culture.
“If people feel you're always checking back with command control, you're dead before you begin. So you're going out there completely deputized.”
Everyone experiences bad things in life, including in marriages, families, friendships, and businesses, so the goal is to be able to ask for help and have people with empathy around you, which builds a common good of mutual support.
“no one's spared. Everybody has bad shit that goes on in their lives”
A large share of the firm's time goes to protecting founders from other investors whose agendas, such as pushing a quick sale, conflict with building value over a long period.
“we find a lot of our time protecting founders from other investors who may have different agendas than us.”
The best venture investments do not come from competitive processes run over Zoom in a few days but emerge from relationships cultivated over the long term.
“the best investments don't come from a competitive process run over Zoom over two days.”
Investors should know what they are good at and what they are not, and when outside expertise is needed, bring in specialists, such as bringing a cloud-computing partner to a cloud backup founder rather than bluffing about expertise.
“Know what you're good at and know what you're not.”
Venture capital is the art of luck, and Fialkow's approach rests on three principles: always defer to the founder or filmmaker and trust their instincts, never give up because failure is defined only by giving up, and surround yourself with extremely positive people while treating founders with empathy.
“always, always, always deferring to your founder or filmmaker and trusting their instincts on things. Number two, never giving up. Failure is only defined by giving up”
Fialkow's filter for founders has four parts: the founder loves the product enough to run through walls, knows how to sell and storytell, has modesty to listen to others, and has a true north mission that holds under testing, and he claims these criteria are very selective.
“There are four things that we get turned on by, in our filter.”
Bringing founders together with athletes, filmmakers, academics, LPs, and other founders creates a cross-pollination of perspectives that helps founders feel less odd, builds a network they can call, and prevents the echo chamber of talking only to people in their own industry.
“that creates safety, that you're not always talking to the same people and you get the same echo chamber.”
The first filter for a great founder is whether they love their product so much that they will do anything to get people to use it, believing the world needs it more than they need oxygen.
“does that founder love their product and is willing to do anything to get Patrick and David to use their product?”
Building a tech company is like hockey in requiring two separate skills, having a creative idea and executing to build the business, and venture investors often fail by being right about the first and neglecting the second.
“Not only do you have to be right about the idea, but you've got to execute and build the business.”
Fialkow cares about business models only when they matter for a specific founder, and otherwise he says investors should bring in specialists rather than bluff, since a swarm of experts helps founders more effectively.
“Why the hell would anybody try to bluff and pretend they know things”
Fialkow and Cutler could not raise outside money for their first venture fund, so the roughly 60 to 70 million dollar fund was mostly their own capital, with a few friends investing because they expected access to co-investment deals rather than expected returns.
“So our first fund was small. 60, 70 million, most of it our own money.”
Many innovators can generate a good idea but fail at execution, so the disconnect between having an idea and building the business is a frequent failure point that venture investors must address by helping with execution.
“what we found is there was a disconnect so often between one and two. One, an innovator's creativity to come up with an idea”
Founders who truly love their product do not treat feedback as proof of failure; they treat their creative instinct as able to pivot the product while keeping it their own, which is the main source of venture returns.
“They never lose track of the fact that this is still their product.”
The partners' success in the travel business came from delegating authority out of inexperience rather than from skilled leadership, and Cutler's critique on a rock in Hawaii revealed weak leadership, project management, and finance skills that they had to confront.
“We were delegating authority because we didn't know any better.”
Convenings lead to concrete relationships: Fialkow introduced a healthcare founder to Tony West, who later joined the board after meeting at a convening, showing that deliberately connecting people produces board-level value rather than coincidence.
“It wasn't a coincidence that I put the two of them together at this community.”
The Icarus team could not promote the evidence of Russian doping because it risked legal harm to the whistleblower, so they had to rely on Sundance's CEO agreeing to screen the film and load it at 3 AM the morning of the premiere.
“We couldn't say we have prima facie evidence of Russian doping. We would have been laughed out of the world or Rodchenkov would have been killed or something.”
General Catalyst brought in former American Express CEO Ken Chenault to help scale and run the firm, not because it needed capital, but because the firm's differentiation depends on empathetic mentorship that scales and building the platform, which the firm had struggled to do internally.
“We did a really transformative thing three years ago, and that we brought in Ken Chenault to help Hemant, Joel and I at the time, really scale and run the firm.”
The firm's culture was myopically focused on the mission of serving founders, which led it to make weaker internal choices about its own people, platform, and scale, and to red-line the business in a way that was good but not scalable.
“sometimes, we probably didn't make the best choices internally on how we were dealing with our own people.”
Getting a job, getting into college, hiring, raising money, selling a business, or convincing anyone to join you all require telling a story, and that story must be authentic or nobody will join the journey.
“You have to tell a story, Patrick, and that story has to be authentic or else nobody will join you in this odyssey.”
Venture firms must now build teams that are diverse in geography, ethnicity, and creativity, which is not only good for responsible innovation but helps founders build businesses aligned with that goal.
“you have to build a diverse team today, the likes of which we've never had to do before in our industry”
Fialkow joined the Boston Beer Company board at Jim Koch's invitation about five years before the recording, helping him through a period of declining sales and a CEO transition.
“I joined the board five years ago of Boston Beer Company, Sam Adams. Why? Because my neighbor is Jim Koch, the founder.”
Fialkow and Joel Cutler built a leading US travel company on the premise that travelers who want sun will go wherever they can afford, so booking at the last minute for half or a third of the price creates a better value proposition.
“Why not wait till the last minute and book it? Who really cares whether you go to Aruba or St. Martin or Antigua?”
The strategy is to be good at collecting great people and knowing when and how to connect them, rather than trying to be an interesting node in the network, because great things come from creating more edges.
“Don't try to be an interesting node in the network. Just create more edges of the network.”
The OneTen program, created by Ken Chenault and Ken Frazier, aims to help Black workers earn a family wage over the next ten years by encouraging employers and recruiters to hire for skills and not require a college degree.
“this program called OneTen, which is this program to provide black leadership and that families can earn a family wage, a million over the next 10 years.”
Fialkow pays forward the kindness he received by building a firm whose core principle is empathy and understanding for the journey of founders, since everyone eventually needs help through adversity.
“make GC a firm that has at its core, the fact that we need to have empathy and understanding for that journey of founders.”
A film or company that fails to pivot is often not truly lost; a founder should reframe a failed plan into a new direction the investor can back, as with the Icarus pivot.
“This one's in the rear view mirror. It didn't work. Let's go.”
A venture investor builds trust by being someone founders feel safe discussing personal matters such as family, spouses, and co-founder tensions, because good judgment combined with safety makes people want to talk to them.
“Be somebody that people want to talk to because you have good judgment, but you're safe.”
The Icarus story illustrates how far people can go doing things the wrong way to achieve a good outcome, which raises the question of whether founders who prioritize a larger purpose can be a counter-pattern investors deploy.
“how far people can go doing things the wrong way to achieve an end or an outcome that we think of as good”
The Vow was followed through to the prosecution of NXIVM leader Keith Raniere because the production's purpose is making films that lead to action and social justice, not merely good films.
“our mission is not making great films, it's making great films that tell you something you need to know that leads to action and social justice.”
Cutler's question on a rock in Hawaii about whether they were A, B, or C entrepreneurs prompted Fialkow to decide they should start a venture fund, reasoning that they would need to be around A-level entrepreneurs.
“If you really want to be around A entrepreneurs, how are you going to do that?”
The firm re-upped with a Series A and additional money after the pivot, and Fogel's persistence produced one of the great documentaries, with the firm's role being air cover, encouragement, and legal help through the US judicial system.
“We gave him a series A. We gave him more money. And what happened next is the guy made one of the greatest films of all time.”
The Icarus Sundance premiere fell on the same day as the 2017 presidential inauguration, which made the film's timing a matter of luck that reduced the attention it could receive.
“the day that the movie premiered at Sundance, the exact day, is the day that Trump gets inaugurated.”
A tech venture firm should give young people large roles early, because not believing in its own young talent sends the wrong message and wastes the best talent in the world.
“We're a tech venture fund. If we don't believe in young people in our own firm, what message does that send?”
Ken Chenault and Bill Campbell are rare mentors who combine emotional intelligence and intuition with the ability to say the right thing in the moment and to help build organizations at scale.
“The only other person I had ever seen do that was Bill Campbell.”
People are loyal to sports teams based on where they live, and this shows that intense belief blinds people to obstacles and makes persuasion feel unnecessary, which is the source of compelling storytelling.
“Nobody could ever be a Yankees fan unless they were born in New York and Boston.”
After selling the travel business, the founders had cash, a large office, and a set of spin-out companies that would become orphans without an organizing structure, which prompted them to start a venture fund to support those founders.
“the only thing that was left was some money that we made and a bunch of these hatched companies that were now going to be orphans”
Investors should treat founders with dignity and let them build a life for themselves, including through liquidity events, rather than assuming they will lose drive.
“Why not treat them with dignity? Let them build a life for themselves.”
Creativity in founders is a renewable resource that must be constantly renewed rather than a single early inspiration, so investors must find ways to underwrite it when there is no business yet.
“Because that's a renewable resource, I've found. It's not just a moment of inspiration early on and then you build for 10 years.”
Fialkow bet a group of business acquaintances one million dollars that he could qualify for and finish the Hawaii Ironman within 90 days, with the money going to the Crohn's and Colitis Foundation if he succeeded, and he did so.
“So I bet these folks a million dollars that I could do the Hawaiian Ironman in 90 days, qualifying and doing it”
Fialkow cites an unsourced rule of thumb that about 40 percent of any investment return is determined by what the market is doing, so even the best company can produce lower returns in a bad market.
“40% of every return is what the market's doing at the time. Some number like that.”
Fialkow's unique energy, attitude, and profile distinguish General Catalyst from many other venture investors, and this personal contribution is a key driver of the firm's success.
“your contribution to GCs success is just that, you just bring this really unique energy and attitude and frankly profiles.”
Gina Raimondo, a former venture capitalist and former governor who became Secretary of Commerce, is a strong example of a leader with venture experience applying it to infrastructure and cyber policy.
“Who better than a governor who was a former VC?”
The kindest thing anyone did for David was his wife Nina Singh believing in him early, when there was little to believe in, and later coaching him to make Icarus and win an Academy Award.
“She believed in me when there wasn't a lot to believe in.”