Dan Rose - How Stunning Founders Operate - [Invest Like the Best, EP.316]
What this covers
Dan Rose, chairman of Coatue Ventures, spent about twenty years at Amazon and Facebook in their early days, and Patrick Oshag has him walk through that front-row view. The conversation opens with the Kindle. Jeff Bezos launched it in 2004 after watching the iPod decimate Amazon's music business, and he gave Steve Kessel the job of killing physical books with a better digital product. Rose describes winning over publishers, whose cost structures were built around print. He went in asking them to digitize books and came out asking for the rights to do it himself, and a demo of the E-ink device convinced them Amazon was serious. The team went back to Bezos about fifteen times before the economics of free cellular delivery barely worked.
From there the talk ranges across Amazon and Facebook. Bezos justified AWS with an electricity analogy. Amazon beat eBay's stronger flywheel partly by putting third-party listings on the same page as its own, over objections from the retail team. At Facebook, Rose found 7,000 new users a day while roughly 30,000 were being turned away. He also recalls the 2006 News Feed backlash, when Zuckerberg held firm because users were returning 10 to 20 times a day. Rose also lays out his Orange Negotiation approach to partnerships.
The last stretch turns personal and institutional. Rose describes a 360 Review from Cheryl Sandberg that changed his trajectory, and the Flow training he started at Facebook. He explains how Coatue combines three investor types, and he contests the idea that early-stage investing is art while public investing is science.
Rose argues that great technology founders win by stubbornly insisting on unrealistic goals, articulating a vision that attracts top talent, and proving over time that their conviction is skill rather than luck, while product-driven companies are steered through detailed product involvement and clear role division between CEO and lieutenants.
- Jeff Bezos forced the Kindle team to make impossible cost and technology trade-offs, and the constraints produced the product's success
- Credible founders must both articulate why their vision matters and be right repeatedly before their stubbornness is seen as skill
- Product-led CEOs should micromanage product while delegating everything else to people who do it better, which the speaker calls highest and best use
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Bezos justified building AWS by analogy to electricity: just as stores once needed their own power grid, websites needed their own data centers, and Amazon should build the compute grid and offer it as a service.
“It used to be the case that in order to own a store, you had to have an electric grid built behind your store.”
Jeff Bezos launched the Kindle digital book platform in 2004 because he saw the iPod decimate Amazon's physical music business and wanted Amazon to disrupt its own books business before someone else did.
“Jeff had seen the iPod come out and decimate our physical music business and had the recognition that the same thing was going to happen to books.”
Facebook launched the News Feed in 2006 despite a privacy backlash that led some to urge reversal, and Zuckerberg held firm because data showed users returned 10 to 20 times a day instead of two or three.
“instead of coming back to Facebook two or three times a day, people were coming back to Facebook 10 or 15 or 20 times a day.”
Opening Facebook beyond college email addresses raised daily new users from 7,000 to 37,000 almost immediately and hundreds of thousands within six months, because each new user made the network more valuable.
“the day we flipped the switch on open registration, all of a sudden, we had 37,000 new users a day.”
In Amazon's early years eBay had the stronger flywheel because its two-sided marketplace drew buyers and sellers into a self-reinforcing loop, and eBay's market cap was five to six times Amazon's during Amazon's struggle in the early 2000s.
“eBay's market cap was five- or six-times Amazon's market cap.”
Book publishers had weak incentives to produce digital books because the entire publishing process converts digital manuscripts into analog print formats, and their cost structures were built around printing and packaging physical books.
“it then gets converted into an analog format before it goes to the printing press, and book publishers don't really have an incentive to publish digital books because their whole cost structure is tied up in printing and packaging of physical books.”
Most negotiations split the difference like an orange, but great partnership negotiators dig deeper to find that one side wants the rind and the other the meat, so both get all of what they want.
“one party is looking for the meat of the orange and the other party, for whatever reason, actually wants the rind.”
When Dan joined Facebook it had 7,000 new users a day while about 30,000 people a day were blocked from signing up, a rejection rate that implies a business turning away four or five times as many customers as it accepted.
“we had 30,000 people a day who were trying to sign up for Facebook who were being told that they couldn't use the service.”
Founders have the right to demand unrealistic things from their teams and be stubborn until the team finds a solution, and when a goal is put in front of people they usually find a way through, though it takes longer and requires creativity.
“they have the right to ask for completely unrealistic things of their team and to be stubborn about those things and wait until they get to the answer that they like”
The idea that early-stage investing is art while public investing is science is a myth, because public-company conversations about founder quality, trend size, and business model are as much judgment-based as early-stage conversations.
“sometimes it's a little bit of a myth that like early stage is all about the art of investing and the public company is all about the science of investing.”
Running a hedge fund requires being a big-picture thinker who wins or loses daily, and that discipline transfers to late-stage private growth investing because the same drivers move private companies that move public ones.
“I think you can apply a lot of those public market insights as an investor into late-stage growth investing”
Bezos removed Steve Kessel from his media business and told him his new job was to kill the physical books business with a digital product so good that people stopped buying physical books, because running both would never motivate him to cannibalize it.
“Your new job is to kill your old business. I want you to put the physical books business out of business by building a digital product that's so good that people don't buy physical books anymore. If you run both, you'll never be motivated to do that.”
To move from a stubborn outsider to a credible founder, a leader must first articulate why their conviction matters in a way that resonates with smart people, and then be proven right repeatedly, because stubbornness that is later validated looks like skill rather than luck.
“you have to articulate why it is that you're so insistent on this thing that you believe is so important.”
When Sheryl Sandberg joined Facebook, she gave Dan a 360 review that showed colleagues saw him as political and self-focused despite his negotiating skill, and that feedback changed his trajectory.
“they think that you are primarily focused on yourself and not on others. And that's a real problem”
The Kindle team returned to Bezos about fifteen times trying to make the economics of free cellular book delivery work, and only barely got there by modeling the trade-offs together.
“And we came back 15 times.”
Dan went to publishers asking them to digitize books but came out asking for the rights to digitize the books themselves, which was better for publishers who avoided the work and for Amazon which needed their permission.
“I went in asking them to publish these books digitally, and I came out asking them to give us the rights to publish the books ourselves.”
Publishers resisted digital books because earlier devices like PalmPilots had failed, and they only became receptive after Dan was allowed to show the e-ink Kindle, which convinced them Amazon was making a serious investment.
“when I showed them the device, they suddenly went, Oh, now I understand why you're being so persistent”
Amazon's existing search-inside-the-book technology was refined to digitize physical books, so many of the Kindle's day-one titles were produced by Amazon rather than publishers, which got the launch over the hump.
“a lot of books that you were able to get on your Kindle on day one weren't produced by the publishers.”
If a founder is a product founder, they must micromanage the product and get into the weeds, because caring about tiny details like pixel placement is part of great product leadership.
“I think when it comes to product, the founder has to micromanage unless they are not a product founder.”
Dan started a two-day Flow training program at Facebook in which senior managers shared personal struggles, believing vulnerability builds deeper bonds that improve business relationships and retention.
“we would take them through uncomfortable exercises where they were vulnerable with each other”
Amazon overcame eBay's network-effect advantage through perseverance and execution, including adding third-party listings on the same page as first-party listings despite internal opposition from the retail team.
“Jeff navigated this very narrow path to being able to out-execute eBay”
Investment firms are often just assemblages of individuals, but Coatue deliberately built institutional building blocks rather than copying corporate processes, because copying them would smother what makes a firm distinctive.
“You can't just say, oh well, let's do all the things that we did in our corporate environment here because that wouldn't work and it would smother”
Bezos forced Amazon to put third-party sellers' listings on the same product page as first-party listings, a controversial move that threatened the retail team's inventory planning because a cheaper third-party offer could take the buy button and blow up inventory forecasts.
“putting third-party listings on the same page as first-party listings, very, very controversial decision at the time, especially among the retail team.”
A complete investment firm needs three investor types, public-market-style growth investors, career venture investors, and operator-turned-investors, and combining them lets a firm cover the full company life cycle.
“I think if you can bring those three pieces together, I think you can really stitch together this full life cycle strategy”
A CEO should focus on the things they are best in the world at and empower others to fill the gaps, because the CEO's time is limited and should go to where they add the most value.
“The founder CEO should focus on the things that they are the best in the world at and the most capable of doing”
The founder CEO should focus on what they are uniquely best at, usually closely tied to product, and empower others to fill the gaps; Marc Benioff's strength is sales and marketing rather than product, and Chris Cox serves as the platonic Chief Product Officer by ensuring Benioff's time goes to the highest-value decisions.
“The founder CEO should focus on the things that they are the best in the world at and the most capable of doing”
When trust is lost, a leader can rebuild it by acknowledging the problem openly, asking colleagues for direct feedback, and having them point out bad behavior in real time, which Dan says turned his situation around.
“the only way for me to break through with people who now don't trust me anymore is to just be vulnerable with them”
Bezos's interview question about whether a candidate considered themselves lucky reveals belief in self, and because startup success requires luck, hiring people who believe they are lucky may increase catching breaks.
“if you believe you're a lucky person, then you're more likely to end up being successful”
Sandberg's management excellence came from caring enough to give hard feedback, because caring means helping people grow and change, not just being a cheerleader.
“caring doesn't just mean being a cheerleader, caring means also giving the hard feedback when it's necessary”
Instead of using its data science platform only to pick winners, Coatue gave the analysis to founders to help run their businesses, because that was more valuable than using it as an investing edge.
“the best thing you can do is hand that data off to your founders and let them use it to run their business.”
Strong cultures encourage debate, but once a decision is made everyone should disagree and commit, and people commit because they trust the leader who has proven capable over time.
“But once the decision has been made, you disagree and commit.”
Earlier e-book devices failed largely because they lacked selection: when readers could not find the book they wanted, they stopped carrying the device, so Bezos set a launch target of 100,000 digital titles against roughly 20,000 e-books existing at the time.
“At the time, there were about 20,000 e-books in the world. And Jeff gave us a goal of launching the Kindle with 100,000 books in a digital format.”
After a disruptive launch, a company should pause before the next major change so the community can absorb it, and Dan convinced Zuckerberg to delay open registration by a week for this reason.
“We need to give our community a chance to absorb and get comfortable before we do the next big shock to the system”
Coatue's founder Philippe Laffont started as a hedge fund in 1999, and Thomas Laffont moved to California to open a West Coast office because companies like Facebook were staying private so long they began to resemble public companies, making public-market analytical skills useful for late-stage growth investing, as with Stripe, which is 13 years old and still private.
“a lot of these private companies like Facebook were staying private for so long that they actually look more like a public company”
To get people to abandon physical books, a new reading device must be better across every dimension, because a trade-off where it is better in some ways but worse in others will not displace the incumbent.
“It can't be better in some ways, but worse in other ways. It has to be better across the board.”
When a product leader describes where the product is going, it immediately aligns the entire organization, so a large strategy framework is unnecessary.
“All you have to do is describe where you're trying to take the product, and it immediately aligns everybody behind what you're trying to do.”
Growth leadership needs deep data science fluency because growth must be data-driven, and at Facebook growth meant improving the product itself, since more users made the experience better for existing users.
“growth wasn't just about growth because that's a good thing. Growth actually meant making the product better.”
After the Sandberg feedback, Rose found that the only way to rebuild trust with colleagues who no longer believed him was to be vulnerable and admit that the hard feedback was difficult to hear, a move he credits with completely turning the situation around.
“the only way for me to break through with people who now don't trust me anymore is to just be vulnerable with them”
Javier Olivan is the ideal growth leader because he understood Facebook's data deeply and treated growth as a way to make the product better, since more users meant better connections and better content for existing users, and his promotion to COO reflects this talent.
“growth wasn't just about growth because that's a good thing. Growth actually meant making the product better.”
Amazon's status as a major distribution channel meant publishers had to keep taking Dan's meetings even while saying no, which let him keep building the relationship.
“they could keep saying no, but they couldn't take the meeting with me because Amazon was a really, really important distribution channel for them.”
Sandberg never missed a weekly one-on-one with any team member and kept her CEO synced the same way, using these recurring meetings to stay aligned and act as the bridge between product, business, and leadership.
“She was religious about her weekly one-on-ones with every single person on our team”
Network effects are very powerful and create a huge moat that is probably the best moat a business can build, though a two-sided marketplace like eBay's shows the same dynamic in a different form, where more buyers attract more sellers and vice versa.
“if you have one, it can create a huge moat, and it's probably the best moat you can build around any business”
Great product visionaries such as Jeff Bezos, Mark Zuckerberg, Steve Jobs, and Bill Gates shared an obsession with details, and Zuckerberg spent five days a week in product reviews asking about tiny design choices.
“He spent five days a week sitting through product reviews.”
Dan's partnership style is to understand the other side's legitimate reasons for resisting, such as the risk to their print cost structure, and then find solutions that address those concerns.
“my personal style of partnering is to really try to understand the other side and understand where they're coming from”
After the review of Dan, Sandberg implemented a company-wide 360-degree review process at Facebook that continues to this day, giving every employee a chance to receive feedback.
“she went on after that experience with me to implement a 360-review process for the entire company, which they still do to this day.”
Many AI startups need an early partnership with a cloud company such as Amazon, Google, or Microsoft to get started, and OpenAI's arrangement with Microsoft shows partnering can be transformational.
“A lot of times, they will need an early partnership to get them started. In many cases, these days, that might look like a partnership with one of the cloud companies”
Talented people choose to work for founders who articulate a compelling vision, and the best founders attract the best people, which is why Peter Thiel told Dan to join Facebook for that reason alone.
“And he said, Simple, they have the best people. And the companies that have the best people are the ones that ultimately win.”
Effective CEO-lieutenant partnerships require that the lieutenant understands both roles and that there is no gap between them, so that when they disagree they commit to the CEO's decision.
“you want to make sure that there is no space between you.”
Sales organizations often feel like second-class citizens in product-driven companies, so a strong sales leader must make the team feel important while accepting that the company may not always follow sales' direction.
“the sales org oftentimes feel like second-class citizens.”
Even without a perfect network effect, a company can build a great company by delivering a product people love, innovating, and attending to small details.
“even if you don't have a perfect network effect, if you build a great product and people love what you're offering”
Dan's experience at Life Mastery taught him that how people communicate and engage is driven by personal issues beneath the surface, and that getting closer to that deeper level builds relationships that enable deeper collaboration.
“we're all human, we all have our own issues that we deal with every day, and how we communicate and how we engage with each other are driven by a lot of that.”
Bezos was impatient and business-oriented, asking what the ultimate business and monetization would be, while Zuckerberg was more patient, less business-oriented, and believed great products would eventually find monetization, as WhatsApp's long road to revenue illustrates.
“a lot of the conversations started with, well, what's the ultimate business here, how do we make money from this?”
Coatue differentiated its early-stage investing by hiring people with operator experience and combining them with professional investors, because seed and Series A markets were crowded.
“how do you differentiate in that market? One of the ideas was to bring in people like me”
In Flow sessions Dan publicly described family illnesses and his son's anxiety to senior staff, and this vulnerability made leaders feel more connected and in one case kept someone from resigning.
“I was actually on my way to resigning from the company. But after this experience, I decided to stay”
Facebook did not do many partnerships early, but by about 2006, when it had around 130 employees, media companies were asking for access to users and to publish content, which made partnerships necessary.
“I joined when we had about 130 employees.”
The next generation of great founders will be defined mostly by the same principles as past generations, though the larger opportunity and scale of markets now make ambitious founders more numerous.
“I personally think it's a lot of the same principles.”
When Rose was choosing among six offers, Peter Thiel advised him to join Facebook because it had the best people, and Rose later concluded that companies with the best people are the ones that ultimately win.
“Simple, they have the best people. And the companies that have the best people are the ones that ultimately win”
Rose believes the next generation of leaders will be shaped by mostly the same principles as the past generation, and his investing job is to find those people early and coach them, with the scale of opportunity today being much larger.
“I personally think it's a lot of the same principles.”
A great Chief Product Officer like Chris Cox protects the CEO's time by filtering product reviews and ensuring complete alignment, disagreeing privately but committing publicly, so that no space exists between CEO and product leader.
“Chris understands that Marc is the CEO, Chris' job is to make sure that when they are reviewing product that they're making the best use of Marc's time”
Bezos gave the Kindle team three extremely difficult goals, selection, an e-ink screen, and over-the-air book delivery, and delayed the launch three or four times until the team found the right formula.
“There were three things that Jeff really charged the team with. All three were going to be extraordinarily difficult.”
The Kindle team bet on e-ink screens, which had no existing devices at the time, because they believed the display was central to making digital books as comfortable to read as physical books.
“At the time, there were no devices with e-ink screens. We took a big bet on e-ink.”
Bezos wanted Kindle books to download over the air with no cable, which pushed the team to pay for cellular connectivity even though the economics initially did not work.
“He wanted it to happen over the air. He didn't want you to have to plug in your Kindle.”
Partnerships suit people who are business-oriented and product-intuitive but dislike the repetitive pace of sales, because partnerships are open-ended and creative, whereas sales suits people who thrive on turning the crank.
“partnerships is great because it's super creative and open-ended.”
Early design partner programs are a good way to prove product-market fit, but partnerships are generally less formulaic than sales and rely more on creative, open-ended approaches.
“I think in partnerships, it's less formulaic.”
Mark Zuckerberg showed the same stubborn conviction as Bezos at age 21, pushing through executive resistance, and Dan expected him to be even more capable by age 30, the age at which Bezos founded Amazon.
“When I joined Facebook, he was 21 years old. Yet he had this in his DNA”
Although big strategic partnerships are open-ended, Facebook's partnership work with millions of media companies required building repeatable motion, which made some partnerships scalable.
“we worked with millions of media companies, and you have to build some motion into that.”
Rose attended a weeklong Life Mastery personal-growth seminar at Harvard after struggling with anxiety, became inspired by the teacher's ideas drawn from Carl Jung and Joseph Campbell, then worked there for about six months, where he discovered he was more drawn to the business mechanics of selling and profit than to philosophy, which led him to business school.
“after six months I was actually much more interested in the business”
Moving from Amazon and Facebook to a less elite environment is hard because those companies were full of people smarter than oneself, and the Coatue culture aims to recreate that intellectually honest debate environment.
“It's very hard to go from working with the smartest and the best people at companies like Amazon and Facebook to anything less than that.”
The best people in partnerships are hybrids of business and product, and many of Facebook's partnership staff later moved into product orgs because their product intuition became visible.
“A lot of the people in my organization at Facebook who worked in partnerships ended up graduating into the product org.”
Coatue should act as a business builder rather than only an investor, which is why it started offering structured equity and other solutions to help founders across the full company life cycle.
“Why can't we just think of ourselves as business builders rather than just investors and add new products”
A new platform must hold the bar of being better than incumbents on all dimensions even while launch dates slip, and Bezos accepted several launch delays to get the magic formula right.
“he delayed the launch date three or four times until he felt like we had the magic formula.”
Miles Grimshaw of Benchmark reportedly argued that a cynical investor might back only database companies and network-effect companies, since those are the enduring and indelible business models.
“he said, if you're really cynical about it, you might just say you kind of only want to back database companies and network effects companies.”
Growth is fundamentally data-driven, and the best growth people identify the few numbers that matter and focus on moving them in the right direction, which is hard because staring at screens of numbers is difficult.
“growth fundamentally has to be data-driven. And it's hard looking at a screen full of numbers.”
Thomas Laffont persuaded Dan to join Coatue instead of starting his own venture by arguing that Dan was a people person who thrived on teams and scale.
“he reminded me that I'm a people person, I get energy from people.”
Rose believes partnership roles reward people who enjoy open-ended creative work rather than repetitive sales, but scalable partnership programs can be created to serve millions of media companies.
“we worked with millions of media companies, and you have to build some motion into that”
Dan sees his role as a venture investor as a coach who helps founders and team members grow, comparing this to Steve Kerr moving from playing position to coaching at the highest level.
“I want to be a coach at the highest level.”
Dan's early reputation was for negotiation and business development, which Sandberg recognized, but colleagues felt he was political and self-focused.
“people really believe and respect your ability as a negotiator, as a business development person”
Dan took a job at Life Mastery after college, planning a graduate-school-like experience, but found he preferred business after six months because he liked how products generate revenue and profit.
“after six months I was actually much more interested in the business.”
Although Marc Benioff is sometimes considered a product leader, he is better described as a sales and marketing genius who turned enterprise software for salespeople into an aspirational company through Dreamforce and Trailblazer.
“I would argue that Marc is a product leader, but if you had to describe him, you'd probably describe him more as a sales and marketing genius.”
Graydon Carter's content rules at Vanity Fair included proprietary information, data or stories that no one else has, which Patrick sees as a key lens for Dan's experiences.
“the one that stands out was proprietary information, some data or stories or information that no one else had that you had.”
The slowdown in the economy has made the environment healthier for founders because it gives them time to process and build sustainable businesses rather than chasing short-term growth.
“It's a different environment. I think it's a healthier environment, frankly, because everything is slowing down a little bit.”
Dan attended a weeklong Life Mastery seminar as a Harvard undergraduate who was successful but anxious, and the seminar's ideas about what drives him led him to abandon a planned law career.
“I was very successful on the outside, but like many of us, I had a lot of anxiety”