Christina Cacioppo - Building an Enduring Software Company in the Age of AI - [Invest Like the Best, EP.496]
What this covers
Patrick talks with Christina Cacioppo, founder and CEO of Vanta, five years after their first conversation. The discussion starts with how Vanta became a category leader, then turns to rebuilding an established product around AI. Vanta's current design centers on an Agent that brings tasks to the user, proposes actions, and carries them out with permission. Cacioppo says no application she benchmarked has an agent doing more of the work. She also describes the internal resistance: her team kept proposing conventional onboarding wizards until leadership burned the boats and replaced the wizard with an LLM canvas that takes messy files and screenshots.
The economics get the most specific treatment. Vanta absorbs model costs to push more customers into agent workflows, because token-based pricing invites direct comparison with the model provider. She explains why outcome pricing is harder to define than it sounds. She also argues that an 80% growth, 80% margin business should return more cash than a 160% growth, 30% margin one, even though the market pays more for the latter. Smaller points include a skeptical view of application-layer post-training, a critique of FDE economics outside Palantir-sized contracts, and a preference for hiring product knowledge over generic sales skill.
The security section looks ahead to vulnerability chaining, machine-speed patching, and continuous agentic penetration testing, with CrowdStrike better placed for large enterprises. She sizes Vanta's cloud-remediation opportunity against Wiz, and mentions a customer asking for an AI off switch, which Vanta declined to build. The episode ends with an aside on French startups moving to Chinese open models.
Cacioppo argues that in the AI era, software companies must rebuild on agents that act for users rather than assistive features, absorb token costs to win usage, and restore enterprise trust, because the market now values AI-branded growth over durable margins and cash returns.
- Vanta's data foundation (integrations, Trust Graph) and agent-first product let it build faster than AI-native competitors
- Token-based pricing invites direct comparison with model providers, so Vanta eats token costs and pursues outcome pricing later
- Enterprise AI distrust creates demand for verifiable, industrial-grade security and compliance proof
Verifiable metrics and enterprise trust grow more important as AI reshapes buyer budgets and model-dependence concerns.
- AI has raised the priority of modernization for governments and enterprises, so CISOs now seek budgets for enterprise risk programs they would have been denied three years ago, creating a more active buying motion.
“because of the attach to AI, they're much more likely to get that budget today.”
- If security fixes can be applied at machine speed as soon as flaws are found, the need to prioritize vulnerabilities largely disappears, though the transition will be rocky.
“if you're fixing things at machine speed, you don't have to prioritize.”
- A large enterprise asked Vanta to turn off its AI features to pass procurement more easily, and Vanta declined to build an off switch, preferring to spend effort on useful capabilities and trusting that AI features could be enabled after entry.
“it's way easier to get a non-AI tool through procurement and we want your tool.”
- Many French software companies in Paris have switched predominantly to Chinese open models after U.S. model access was restricted for non-Americans, because they judged dependence on American models a business continuity risk.
“We basically all switched to Chinese models when Trump closed Fable off to non-Americans.”
- In B2B markets, trust will be rebuilt through specific data, improvement curves, and contracts that back promises, while consumer trust is driven by vibes that are much harder to repair.
“I would like to see specific things or specific improvement curves or make promises with maybe contracts behind them.”
- Vanta shows candidates and employees its business metrics and strategy, including context on good and bad facts, so that hiring is grounded in data rather than hype, which counters YOLO-style vibes with trustworthy vibes.
“we'll generally show candidates, show everybody everything.”
- As security visibility increases, companies will face more pressure to prove their software is legitimate and industrial-grade to enterprises, governments, regulators, and lawmakers, and Vanta sits between software sellers and buyers as the connecting layer.
“Vanta is the thing that connects both sides of that marketplace.”
- AI has produced an era of extremely high excitement but low trust in technology companies, and showing trustworthiness through verifiable metrics and standards is becoming more important, not less, as buyers, regulators, and auditors demand proof.
“we just don't trust software companies, tech companies the way we used to. And that is getting worse year over year.”
- Vanta's government work shows an appetite for modernization across federal, state, and local governments inside and outside the US, and AI has made modernization an imperative where it used to be a nice-to-have.
“The AI piece has created more FOMO in government officials”
- Cacioppo would not trust big tech companies with her personal emails or chats, preferring that data stay with search and operating system providers than with the AI tools that want it.
“I would rather just Google or just Apple or just insert company here have that information.”
- Cacioppo says Vanta's brand combines vibes with rigorous proof, and that customers and regulators will increasingly require proof rather than marketing trust signals.
“counter the vibes with data and trustworthy vibes versus YOLO vibes.”
Continuous shipping and broad data integrations defend Vanta against fast, AI-enabled copying.
- In software, you are only as good as the last thing you shipped, and AI makes this more true because a competitor can vibe-code a copy of your product in a weekend, so Vanta must keep shipping differentiating features.
“you're really only as good as the last thing you shipped”
- Vanta's go-to-market advantage came partly from memorable marketing, including a billboard and compliance messaging that resonated on r/accounting, which signaled that the product was working.
“Compliance that doesn't suck too much, which got really popular on r/accounting”
- Vanta's investment in integrations with about 400 tools, which it calls the Trust Graph, creates a security data lake broader than other providers' because it covers areas they do not touch, and this data foundation lets Vanta build software and agents faster.
“We call it our Trust Graph. It's really just a security data lake, and that is bigger, broader than any other provider”
- Vanta can expand into cloud misconfiguration remediation for mid-sized customers at around $40,000 to $50,000, a price point Wiz would not reach because Wiz's customers start at multi-thousand-person companies and cost about $150,000.
“Where are they unlikely to go pay $150,000 for Wiz, but very well could pay $40,000 or $50,000 for something suited to them”
AI token pricing hype overstates custom economics, yet margin strain makes pricing leverage decisive.
- Most post-training of models by application companies is done for marketing reasons, mainly to impress investors and customers, because the only real reason to post-train is cost, and quality gains are not the justification.
“the reason to post-train a model is cost. ... There's kind of a marketing reason to do it right now”
- Companies that avoid token pricing by charging credits with a token exchange rate are simply obscuring the underlying token cost, and sophisticated users see through this.
“people try to obscure that by charging credits and having some credit-token exchange rate-y thing”
- Customers are quick to compare an application's token price against the underlying model's price, so marking up Claude tokens four times invites the question of whether the product is four times as good, placing the application in direct competition with the model provider.
“Are you 4x as good as Claude? I don't know. Let me go try it out.”
- The main pitch for post-training a model for a customer is that it signals being a real AI company to customers, and a secondary benefit is form factor for large enterprises that need wall-to-wall deployment with integrations and many approvals.
“You are putting a stake in the ground of being a real AI company. Customers will notice.”
- Token-based pricing, low margins pursued for their own sake, and custom-trained models done for marketing are overhyped trends in the current AI market.
“Token-based pricing, low margins for the sake of having low margins, custom training models for the marketing value.”
- Handing customers a custom model is not yet the right solution because users have not figured out how to use models that way, similar to early mobile apps before pull-to-refresh was invented.
“I don't think anyone actually wants to be handed a model the same way it's hitting a refresh button.”
- Cacioppo says that calling a product an agent or a harness can earn a roughly threefold revenue multiple in the market, though 'agent' often just means AI.
“You get 3x revenue multiple if you say agent. It's like 3x if you say harness.”
- Forward-deployed engineering works at Palantir's eight-figure contracts, but many companies apply FDEs to five- and six-figure contracts where the economics, given roughly 30% gross margins, are upside down and likely unsustainable.
“I think we're using FDEs in a place where there's five- and six-figure contracts, and those economics probably are upside down.”
- The open-source model ecosystem is much less built out than the frontier labs' product and tooling layer, so the hype around open-source models is disconnected from actual application companies, and building an OpenAI-style playbook on open models remains an opportunity.
“the ecosystem around them is so much less built out than the big labs. And that just feels off to me.”
- Vanta is absorbing token costs and accepting lower margins, aiming to move 25% of customers in agent-driven workflows to 75%, because it believes stronger usage will improve retention and that pricing can be resolved after the usage phase.
“We're eating the token cost right now.”
- Everyone wants outcome pricing because it aligns incentives, but defining the unit of work is hard: a ticket closed is an output, not the outcome, and listing many units such as document drafted or account offboarded creates cognitive overhead that customers reject.
“Everyone I talk to wants to get to outcome-output pricing, but it's really not clear how you get there.”
- When a rival founder refused to sell the billboard spot back, Cacioppo offered to double the price and even offered triple, but the rival said it was cash-flow positive, so the spot was lost because it had no pricing leverage.
“we're actually cash flow positive. So I'm an inelastic seller.”
- Vanta's 'Compliance that doesn't SOC 2 much' billboard succeeded because it reflected the brand's wink, but the company lost its prime spot because it had only a placement order rather than a multi-year contract and a rival paid more.
“we did not have a multi-year contract... it was a placement order. They paid more. So they swapped it out underneath us.”
AI reshapes how the company builds, staffs, and hires, favoring product knowledge and firsthand AI fluency.
- Large, eight-year-old codebases exceed the context window agents can handle, so Vanta is modularizing its code so agents can understand and modify smaller parts fully, and onboarding agents resembles onboarding thousands of new engineers.
“it just doesn't have the context window to understand everything and will do silly things.”
- Founders must personally push in this AI era because the rest of the company will not self-organize toward the new reality, so commitment cannot be delegated to the organization.
“the rest of the company will not self-organize to do so.”
- Vanta uses subject-matter experts who previously ran security programs to write task-specific eval frameworks and evaluate those evals, and model swaps are decided mainly on quality rather than cost because decision-action agents use far fewer tokens than coding agents.
“When we think about model swapping, it is mostly quality. It's not cost.”
- Cacioppo rates Vanta's codebase-readiness for AI low, but she believes the fundamentals of company building are unchanged even though the way work is done should look quite different.
“I think the principles are still the same. Everything is hard. People matter.”
- Vanta's recruiting pitch is that engineers ship to 16,000 customers who use agents, get instant feedback, and experiment with fast iteration loops at a stage early enough that new hires can still shape the company.
“You get 16,000 customers using a product, using agents.”
- Ambitious people move to companies they believe are on the right trajectory, so if employees feel their company is not in the right boat they will change boats, making the talent war a real pressure on companies that lose momentum.
“if it feels like they're not in the right boat, they're going to change boats”
- Adopting AI is largely a matter of whether individuals go dive into the tools on their own, and although she once thought non-adopters had separate problems, she now believes some strong people need nudges and that blockers can be identified and addressed.
“something can be blocking them — and you can get people into the muck, even if they don't dive in initially.”
- Cacioppo cares most about ARR and ARR growth and less about valuation multiples, but she watches employee sentiment about growth relative to alternatives because competitors raising every six months at five times prior valuations are real talent threats.
“I care about ARR and ARR growth.”
- Vanta values a person's knowledge of the company, customers, and product over generic vertical skills like sales, and would hire a weaker salesperson who knows the product better, because AI-era go-to-market hiring overweights sales skill.
“I'm at a phase right now where we value that skill set more than the vertical skill set”
- Calling forward-deployed engineering a professional services role would attract a different talent profile, and high-agency Harvard CS graduates are unlikely to join as the fourth or twelfth services hire, so the FDE wrapper will not last even though the work is real.
“if you call it a professional services role, that's a very different talent profile than FDE”
- Leaders must use AI tools personally, understand where models are good and bad, and track changes at least every two weeks, because only firsthand experience lets them assess claims like replacing all SDRs with one agent.
“Do that at least every two weeks because it just changes so quickly.”
Founders should favor authenticity, deliberate practice, and long-term compounding businesses.
- A good talk depends more on how the speaker feels and whether they believe the content than on the facts delivered, because audiences read whether a speaker is going through the motions, and authenticity is the key to good heart.
“Believing in it yourself. Authenticity. One-on-one, on a stage, people are pretty good at reading one another.”
- Cacioppo overcame severe nerves about public speaking by repeated exposure, and she believes a skill improves with deliberate effort even when the person started out poor at it.
“Exposure therapy was helpful on that one. You just do it and you do get better at it.”
- Cacioppo advises founders to live for the fullness of time, believing the valuation confusion will sort itself out and that high-margin compounding businesses win in the long run.
“I think this will all sort itself out and you have to live for the fullness of time.”
Investor expectations and market conditions pressure software companies more than founder skill does.
- Cacioppo says an 80% growth, 80% margin business should return more cash over time than a 160% growth, 30% margin business, yet the market values the latter at three to four times the multiple, which creates cognitive dissonance for founders.
“an 80% growth business with 80% margins will actually be better than... a 160% growth business with 30% margins”
- The last twelve months were the scariest because the market treated established SaaS systems of record as commoditized, with the attitude that a company that built a system of record must now figure out what it does with the data.
“The last 12 months. SaaS apocalypse. You're like, okay, great job building a system of record. You're now screwed.”
- Many investors are AI maximalists who will fund only frontier labs or physical AI such as robotic tractors, leaving little capital for ordinary software companies, which forces those companies to adapt to investor expectations.
“we'll invest in the labs and we'll basically invest in tractors in Iowa. Nothing in between.”
- VC investors face more acute FOMO and echo-chamber pressure than founders, judged on incremental and paper returns, making their trade-offs harder than founders' despite founders' own pressures.
“it feels more echo chambery, more judged on incremental returns and paper returns on the VC side than the company side.”
- Some market structures are so bad that any entrepreneur would hit a wall, and AI has made some previously attractive markets look unattractive, so the market matters more than founder skill, though founders still must push hard in this era.
“The best person in the world can run into that and will still run into a brick wall.”
Vanta's agent brings tasks to users and executes them with permission rather than alerting.
- Vanta has built its product around an agent that brings tasks to the user, proposes actions, and executes them with permission, rather than monitoring and alerting, and Cacioppo claims no AI application she benchmarked is further along in having an agent do most of the work.
“We are constantly going to the set of names you imagine when you think AI applications and generally finding they're not yet where we are, where an agent is doing most of the work.”
- Vanta's agent auto-generates UI on the fly because sometimes a user wants chat and sometimes a visual interface, optimizing around keeping the user in the flow of work with long-running agents rather than fixed SaaS screens.
“Our agent is auto-generating UI on the fly because sometimes you want chat, right? And sometimes you want UI”
- A Vanta agent detects events such as an employee departure without full account offboarding, proposes a custom action, and asks the user to approve it once or always, shifting security work from alerts to delegated execution.
“Someone just left your company and you didn't get them out of all of their accounts. I just wrote a custom agent for you that will go do that.”
- Vanta replaced its traditional onboarding wizard with an LLM canvas where customers drag in messy files and screenshots and the model asks questions, because the team had been defaulting to a familiar wizard out of fear of failing on the new approach.
“we don't think we're allowed to fail on this project. ... Great. We're going to bet that the LLM flow is going to work”
AI reshapes security through chained exploits and agentic penetration testing.
- The future of security for some Vanta segments is continuous agentic penetration testing paired with an automated patcher agent that fixes issues as they are found, though CrowdStrike will do this better for large enterprises.
“For some parts of Vanta, yes. I think we can do that in very compelling ways for the bulk of our customers.”
- Models are persistent enough to chain together many individually low-severity or benign flaws into a meaningful exploit, which undermines traditional prioritization that defers low-severity fixes for 90 days.
“these models are able to chain 17 benign-ish or benign on their own things together and then really find something.”
- Cacioppo sees generative activity in new cybersecurity startups and revenue-technology companies, notes that legacy revtech providers are running PE-style playbooks instead of building AI, and believes robotics is underweighted relative to software.
“Robotics is probably underplayed — somewhat hot and hypey.”
Top talent deserves rising pay, and compensation pressure will keep accelerating.
- Cacioppo does not treat IPO or sale as a bucket-list goal, viewing public listing as a means to an end, because 99% of large independent US software companies are public and the goal is a big standalone company.
“99% of the big independent software companies in the United States are public.”
- A high-context leader who understands the company, customers, and domain, makes reasonable decisions, and iterates quickly on bad ones is worth millions of dollars because of high agency.
“High agency, get shit done... A high-context person who understands the company and the customers”
- Total compensation for Vanta's top person is roughly ten times what that role paid five years earlier, and Cacioppo believes top people should be paid even more because you never pay top people enough relative to their contribution.
“Total comp? It's probably a factor of ten.”
- Investor concern about dilution and stock-based compensation was intense in 2022 and 2023 but has faded, removing the main counterforce to rising talent pay, so compensation is likely to keep accelerating.
“Without that push on dilution, I think people just get paid more and more.”
- Employee tender offers have become a standard expectation, so companies must run them regularly, and if they do not, they must offset the loss with other compensation even if founders personally find tenders unhealthy.
“the game on the field is you're doing a tender every time and you gotta do 'em.”