Chris Dixon - The Potential of Blockchain Technology - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 221]
What this covers
Patrick interviews Chris Dixon of Andreessen Horowitz, and the conversation moves from first principles to specific protocols. Dixon begins with what a blockchain newly allows: code that makes commitments about its future behavior, guaranteed by network architecture rather than by its authors. Bitcoin's 21 million coin cap is his first example. He also states the costs plainly. Consensus among many untrusted machines imposes a performance penalty that he says never fully disappears. He likens this to the first iPhone's tiny screen and dropped calls, which a flywheel of developers and revenue eventually overcame.
The middle of the episode is a walk through DeFi. Dixon explains MakerDAO and its dollar-pegged stablecoin Dai, the Compound lending protocol, and Uniswap, an automated market maker whose idea came from a Vitalik Buterin blog post and which runs with a team of about ten. He notes that all current lending is overcollateralized, with under-collateralized loans still to come. Other topics include the Bitcoin schism that sent programmability toward Ethereum, Ethereum's planned move to proof of stake, and Uniswap's token airdrop to past users.
The more contested material is political and economic. Dixon contrasts public protocols, which work like streets and parks, with closed platforms that work like theme parks, and he argues that email's openness let anti-spam startups flourish. He calls the limited liability corporation a form that has run its course, and he defends token-based community ownership in its place. He dismisses the money-laundering charge because public ledgers expose transactions. The closing stretch covers DAOs that pool strangers' money to buy an NFT, and he expects NFT spending to concentrate as it does in games, where roughly 0.5 percent of players buy 80 percent of virtual goods.
Dixon argues blockchains are a new computing platform whose core value is programmable, credible commitments that move power and money from platform owners to users and builders, so crypto should be judged as internet infrastructure rather than as finance.
- Blockchains let code make commitments (fixed supply, unchangeable rules, user-held assets) that no company can revoke, unlike platforms that change rules.
- Like the iPhone, blockchain platforms have real weaknesses such as performance and gas fees, but these are expected to be mitigated while new applications emerge.
- Community-owned networks using tokens can align incentives among users, builders, and investors better than corporate structures.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Blockchains take a performance hit versus traditional computers because many untrusted machines must vote on system state through a game-theoretic consensus mechanism every few seconds, and this overhead is structural and will never fully disappear.
“a blockchain inherently by design takes a performance hit versus a non blockchain computer.”
Email, as an open protocol, let anyone build anti-spam solutions, which produced a wave of startups such as Postini and Brightmail that solved spam, whereas closed networks do not get this ecosystem benefit.
“email was a public open protocol. Anyone could build anti-spam solutions.”
In games and creator markets only a tiny share of users pay for most virtual goods, with a typical figure of 0.5 percent of users paying for 80 percent of goods, and Dixon expects NFTs to show the same concentration, which is enough to support a giant industry.
“typical number is 0.5% of the user base pays for 80% of the virtual goods or something.”
Uniswap has no servers and has never gone down because it is software on the Ethereum blockchain, so it will keep running even if its founders disappear, and its volume has reached levels approaching Coinbase and Binance with a team of only about 10 people.
“There's no servers. There's no AWS. ... It's never been down. ... It's approaching Coinbase, Binance levels of volume.”
A consensus mechanism uses game theory so that even if some individual computers act maliciously, the aggregate system stays consistent, analogous to Adam Smith's private vice leading to public virtue.
“It's a little bit like Adam Smith and free markets or something, like private vice leads to public virtue.”
A smart person in 2009 would not have predicted that calling a car would be the killer app of GPS, so new platform applications are hard to forecast and entrepreneurs will find them over time.
“most people would not have had calling a car as the killer app.”
The fundamental new capability of blockchains is that code can make strong commitments about how it will behave in the future, and these commitments are guaranteed by network architecture rather than by the people who built the system.
“Fundamentally what blockchain lets you do is, it lets you write code that can make strong commitments about how it will behave in the future.”
Bitcoin's 21 million coin cap is guaranteed by the network architecture rather than by Satoshi Nakamoto or the developers, which is something no prior digital currency controlled by a company could guarantee, and this is why people believed in it.
“That property of saying there's only going to be 21 million is guaranteed by the blockchain. It is not guaranteed by the creators of Bitcoin.”
Smart contracts can hold money themselves, not as a pointer to a bank balance, and the Compound lending protocol holds roughly $10 billion while running even if its creators disappear.
“I think it's something like $10 billion is held by the code. The people that created Compound could go away tomorrow”
New computing platforms have real early weaknesses, like the first iPhone's tiny screen and dropped cellular connections, but a flywheel of developers, revenue, and reinvestment mitigates them over time.
“So those kinds of shortcomings got taken care of.”
Uniswap is a decentralized exchange built as an automated market maker, where a smart contract prices assets on a demand curve that rises as people buy and falls as they sell, rather than matching bids and asks on an order book, with its idea originating in a Vitalik Buterin blog post.
“Essentially, it's a smart contract that ... Basically, as somebody buys it, the system automatically increases the price a little bit.”
A DAO let strangers pool money through smart contracts and collectively buy a high-value NFT, with tokens representing ownership, and this type of code-enforced collective action resembles a company but can be formed ad hoc.
“A DAO is just a set of smart contracts on Ethereum. So there's no company. But the smart contracts enforce the deal.”
A schism in the Bitcoin community over its vision split the ecosystem: the faction favoring digital gold won within Bitcoin, while those wanting programmability such as NFTs and DeFi moved to Ethereum, which launched in 2015 after being announced in 2014.
“Basically, the people that wanted it to become digital gold won that battle, and the people that wanted it to be more programmable and have divisions of things like NFT and DeFi went over to the Ethereum world.”
Modern video games are free to play and earn revenue by selling virtual goods such as skins and emotes using in-game currency like V-Bucks, and typically about 0.5 percent of players pay for 80 percent of virtual goods.
“typical number is 0.5% of the user base pays for 80% of the virtual goods or something”
Because everything on public blockchains is visible, anyone can measure whether the system is at risk, which Dixon contrasts with 2008 mortgage opacity, and he argues the claim that blockchains aid money laundering is absurd because public ledgers expose transactions.
“You can go measure, is the system at risk? Is this and that? Everything's open, right?”
MakerDAO lets users borrow against overcollateralized crypto assets to mint Dai, a stablecoin pegged to the US dollar with no fiat or bank backing, and it has operated reliably for four years with tens of billions of dollars flowing through it.
“It's now worked for four years very reliably at scale. There's tens of billions of dollars passing through it at all times.”
Public blockchain protocols act like public infrastructure such as streets and parks that enable private businesses, whereas closed platforms like Facebook and Twitter act like theme parks, which leads to spam and bot problems because the single owner must fix everything alone.
“A lot of the Internet now is like a theme park, right? It's Facebook. It's Twitter. It's controlled by one person.”
Public infrastructure such as streets and parks reinforces private enterprise because it generates foot traffic, whereas privately tolled infrastructure deters entrepreneurs, and crypto protocols are a return to public infrastructure that the public can build on without permission.
“The two reinforce each other. The fact that you have a public sidewalk creates street traffic, which then helps the entrepreneur.”
Transformative technologies typically start out looking like toys, such as the early telephone that barely worked and went less than a mile, so the trajectory of improvement must be projected rather than judged by the early form.
“The Next Big Thing Starts Out Looking Like A Toy. ... The early telephone barely worked and went less than a mile.”
The core promise of DeFi lending is disintermediation: removing banks' layers of fees and slow approval processes so that depositors earn near-zero rates while borrowers pay high rates, and demand signals can be used directly to match borrowers and lenders.
“the promise of DeFi in lending is the same promise of the Internet in a lot of other industries, where it's essentially disintermediation.”
All current DeFi lending is overcollateralized against crypto assets, like a house-backed mortgage, while under-collateralized loans and credit scoring are expected to become the next wave but have not yet scaled.
“all of the DeFi lending is over-collateralized.”
Bitcoin is deliberately conservative with an extremely limited programming language for security, while Ethereum has a fully expressive language similar to JavaScript and is switching from proof of work to proof of stake, likely within about twelve months.
“They're switching to proof of stake. This is a dramatic change in the system, and that will happen probably in the next 12 months.”
Uniswap allocated 14% of its governance tokens to addresses that had used the protocol over the prior two years, with about 400 tokens each, worth about $11,000 at the time of the interview, and one Indian computer science class's tuition was paid from the early airdrop value.
“they decided to issue 14% of the tokens to the people that had used the protocol over the last two years.”
The limited liability corporation, developed with 1830s railroads, has run its course because it concentrates wealth and misaligns network owners with participants, and token-based granular rewards can align network participants better.
“I believe it's mostly run its course. It's not really working very well for a whole bunch of reasons, including the fact that you end up with very, very concentrated wealth on these networks.”
The early web succeeded because it was built on open protocols that made implicit commitments to developers, so builders like Google's founders knew the rules could not be changed to demote or tax them, creating a level playing field and a wave of innovation.
“It made implicitly commitments to developers. If you're Google and you wrote Sergei and Larry creating their search engine knew that the protocols they were building on wouldn't change the rules”
Open DeFi protocols can be built on by anyone and cannot be blocked by design, so protocols like Compound and Maker act as composable building blocks, and meta-protocols like Yearn can automatically allocate deposits across them.
“People call it money Lego sometimes. Compound is one Lego. Maker is one Lego.”
The right internet business model balances abundance and scarcity by giving away viral base content and charging for scarce complements, because locking content prevents the viral distribution the internet enables, as Nintendo found when it allowed streaming.
“The right business model on the internet is to find some balance between abundance and scarcity.”
An NFT lets a user truly own a digital good because the blockchain guarantees ownership, so the issuing company cannot change take rates, charge more, or remove the item, unlike virtual goods in video games that fade out when companies change their minds.
“It doesn't matter if the company behind it changes their mind. They can't go and change the take rate or charge you more rent or take it away from you”
Blockchains will not replace Google or AWS; instead, applications will put only the money-holding parts on-chain and use traditional infrastructure for displaying content, making blockchains complementary.
“At the part of the application where you're holding the money, you'd use a blockchain. At the part of the application where you're just displaying images, you don't use a blockchain.”
Kevin Kelly's 1,000 True Fans idea, that creators can sustain themselves by reaching about 1,000 devoted supporters, was suppressed by advertising-driven social networks but is now resurging because of new tools for direct creator-fan payment.
“Now I think we have a real resurgence of Kevin's ideas.”
Ethereum trades performance for high security and resistance to nation-state attacks, while a gaming chain like Flow can be designed to withstand hacker attacks and routine threats, so different workloads will suit different chains connected by trustless bridges.
“Ethereum makes a different set of trade offs. It's trading off performance for higher security.”
Current internet security works like putting gold in a village surrounded by walls and hoping no one breaks in, which has repeatedly failed, while blockchains use encryption-based authentication and are a better security model.
“Everything in the world has been hacked at this point. It's not a good system.”
Dai behaves like a file that can be sent without a service attached, so computers can send dollars to each other and enable machine payments, and it has over $3 billion in issuance and is especially used in countries with hyperinflation.
“Dai is I can send you a dollar. So a computer can send a computer. You can have machine payments.”
Tokens are the native asset class of information networks, and they can align the incentives of users, builders, and owners in ways that corporate structures cannot.
“we finally discovered what, actually, a friend of mine calls the native asset class of information networks. That's what tokens are.”
Programmable blockchains such as Polkadot, Solana, Cosmos, Near, and Avalanche are not Ethereum killers but complementary chains with different trade-offs, and billions of users will need an interoperating fabric where each chain handles different workloads, connected by trustless bridges.
“I don't think they're competing. I think the only way that we're going to have a world with billions of people interacting with blockchain applications every day ... is you're going to have a fabric”
Investors should focus on startups that exploit capabilities new to a platform, because the popular iPhone apps are either old-world services like Facebook and Amazon or new-capability apps like Snapchat and Uber that could not exist before.
“the key, I think, when you're investing is focusing on the things that are novel and new about it.”
Social tokens let a person or community have their own token used for in-network currency, access to exclusive content, and investment, creating a flywheel where investor demand funds creators who then become more successful.
“the idea is to have a token associated with either a person or community associated with a person.”
Free-to-play video games monetize through their own currency and virtual goods rather than selling the base product, and this model will propagate to podcasters, musicians, and other creators, who will issue their own currencies and NFTs alongside free base content.
“I think that model will be replicated throughout the internet.”
DAOs could scale collective action to solve collective action problems such as energy consumption and tragedy-of-the-commons issues with public infrastructure, and the GameStop Reddit episode may be a canary in the coal mine for this capability.
“DAOs are the way to really scale that collective action out”
A DAO is the natural successor to the limited liability company as a capital formation vehicle, because it pools capital, labor, and effort through software, enabling open-source projects and even community-owned hardware such as a mobile phone to be financed and governed.
“No, that's exactly how I think of it. It's how you do it in a modern internet software world.”
Community-owned networks remain compatible with rewarding founders and early investors, just as early real estate developers earned from land they owned as the network around it grew in value, because creators hold tokens in the systems they build.
“It's sort of similar to that. They just own a chunk of the network, of the tokens.”
Demand for computing resources such as bandwidth, CPU, and GPU power has always outstripped supply, so demand for blockchain transactions will continue to exceed capacity even after upgrades like sharding and proof of stake.
“Every good computing resource in the world, in the history, has had demand outstrip supply.”
How the internet is governed and how money and power flow through it are the most important questions about the internet, and the risk is that the network becomes four controlling companies, like television, requiring decades of regulation, unless power is sent to the edges.
“Is it going to be four companies? ... Or is it going to be this internet, is it going to send the power out to the edges?”
Old versions of protocols like Uniswap V1 and V2 keep running forever even after new versions launch, and the creators cannot remove them, so users choose which version to use.
“V2 and V1, they're still out there, and they'll run forever. They can't even remove it if they wanted to.”
Platforms like Apple have a long history of changing rules, take rates, and APIs, and blockchains reverse this because their rules are fixed in code, so 'it can't be evil' replaces 'don't be evil'.
“Instead of don't be evil, it can't be evil. It cannot change the rules.”
Over the next decade most of the most valuable and exciting startups will be blockchain-oriented, just as most were mobile-oriented in the last decade, with a likely split between blockchain and non-blockchain computing similar to desktop versus mobile.
“I believe most of them will be blockchain oriented, the same way that most were mobile-oriented.”
Crypto is cyclical with feedback loops pushing prices both up and down, so an NFT winter is likely at some point, but the long-run secular trend toward creator economics will persist, creating a roughly twenty-year creative renaissance.
“I'm sure there'll be an NFT winter or something at some point.”
DeFi reaches only about a million users, but NFTs are simple and tangible enough to reach around 100 million people, which would feed back into infrastructure investment and attract new entrepreneurs and mainstream adopters.
“DeFi is great and it's really important, but it's still like a million people. ... If we can get something like NFTs, that go to like a hundred million people”
Blockchains and crypto are the most exciting next computing wave, following mainframes, PCs, the commercial internet, and mobile, and should be understood as a computing movement rather than primarily a financial one.
“I believe at its core, it's a computing movement.”
Writers on Substack are earning hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars through paid subscriptions from relatively small but devoted audiences, as illustrated by Glenn Greenwald, whose Substack following is about two orders of magnitude smaller than his Twitter following yet earns substantial income.
“You have a bunch of people who are making real money, many hundreds of thousands, sometimes millions of dollars”
OpenSea has an over $1 billion annual run rate and NBA Top Shot has about $450 million in total sales with roughly 1.3 million accounts of which about 200,000 are active, showing that a small active minority can generate enormous industry revenue.
“It's done 450 million total sales, includes primary and secondary. ... maybe 200,000 or so are active.”
A DAO is a set of smart contracts that functions like a Delaware C-Corp but exists solely in software, where membership confers defined rights and responsibilities that the code enforces.
“building a set of smart contracts that kind of looks like a Delaware C Corp, like a traditional company, but one that exists solely in software.”
Investors and builders prefer predictable rules, so just as capital flows to countries with consistent rule of law rather than those that might privatize assets, developers flock to platforms with predictable, unchangeable rules.
“It's just a basic rule of economics that people are more willing to invest and spend time on and money on platforms or countries”
Bitcoin has performed well as a store of value, increasingly used in hyperinflationary countries, but has not lived up to expectations as a payment mechanism because of high fees and volatility that deter merchants and holders alike.
“I think Bitcoin has not lived up to some expectations in terms of a payment mechanism. It's not used very widely for payments, and that has to do with the fees and I think also the volatility”
The video game industry is roughly $140 billion while music is about $20 billion, and Dixon attributes music's lag to its unchanged lock-everything-down, copyright-based business model despite its high engagement.
“Video games, $140 billion industry. Music is something like 20.”
Blockchains carry no identity by default, so users choose what to reveal, such as a credit score, while still using KYC on exchanges like Coinbase when required.
“there's no identity on a block. You choose to have an identity.”
Many financial institutions and job postings still rely on COBOL, a 50-year-old language, which Dixon cites as evidence that legacy banking infrastructure is outdated.
“They literally are still using COBOL, and I'm not exaggerating.”
Public blockchains expose everything, so privacy remains a very hard unsolved problem, though users can selectively reveal identity or credit information to counterparties.
“It's actually a very hard unsolved problem, is how to make it private.”
The Foundation crypto art platform takes a 10 percent fee and gives the artist 90 percent, which Dixon argues dramatically improves creator economics compared with traditional publishers, and lets creators price different tiers for different fans.
“Foundation takes the small 10% fee, he gets 90%.”
Satoshi Nakamoto is thought to hold a significant portion, roughly 5 percent, of Bitcoin, illustrating that creators and early developers can own stakes in a community-owned network.
“I think it's something like 5% or some significant portion of Bitcoins are owned by Satoshi”
A blockchain such as Ethereum is a computer instantiated by a network of physical machines (miners, soon validators) that creates a virtualized layer with new properties prior computers lacked.
“Ethereum is a computer, it's a computer that happens to be instantiated by running on top of a network.”
The blockchain industry has a shortage of entrepreneurs and developers relative to the amount of money and opportunity, making it a shockingly small community that needs many more builders.
“We have a shortage of entrepreneurs, if any entrepreneur's listening. I've never been in a space where there's so few.”
Music's revenue has lagged video games because the industry has kept a pre-internet model of locking everything down and relying on copyright, and even if NFT drops like Blau's are a bubble, they represent a major business model change.
“The business model essentially is lock everything down and rely on copyright”
Compound is a money market protocol where users lend to or borrow from the protocol, and the code dynamically sets supply, demand, and interest rates without human intermediaries.
“it dynamically sets the supply and demand, the interest rates and things like that. But the code itself does it.”
Steve Jobs said computers would remain like trucks while phones are cars, implying that specialized devices persist alongside new ones, a pattern Dixon expects between blockchain and non-blockchain computing.
“Computers are like trucks. You're always going to have trucks.”
Social networks built on blockchains have moderation and governance encoded from day one in a democratic, open way, which Dixon argues is better than an opaque group of product managers deciding moderation, even though the specific approach may not be ideal.
“I would argue that almost anything is better than an opaque group of product managers in San Francisco making those roles.”
Abstract blockchain concepts are hard to explain, but NFTs and on-chain transaction histories on Etherscan give people tangible objects, making the technology understandable to newcomers and relatives.
“Finally we have something that's really tangible. And now you're on Etherscan, looking at the history of it.”
Holders take out Dai against their crypto to avoid selling assets they believe in, using it either for leveraged trading or as spendable dollars that many crypto merchants accept.
“I know a lot of crypto people who just never want to sell their crypto, and they use the Dai for spending money.”
Ethereum is moving from proof-of-work mining to proof-of-stake, a radical change expected within about 12 months that will address environmental concerns and improve performance and security.
“They're switching to proof of stake. This is a dramatic change in the system, and that will happen probably in the next 12 months.”
Patrick's conversational turn on the broad concept of platform limitations restates a question without adding a claim.
“So every new platform also has limitations.”