Carl Kawaja - Dealing with Regime Change - [Invest Like the Best, EP.314]
What this covers
Patrick talks with Capital Group portfolio manager Carl Kawaja, a return visit after their 2021 conversation, about how markets have changed since. The conversation moves through sports, linguistics and history as readily as finance. Carl treats the market as a spectrum of favor and disfavor: technology overshot in one direction, and the distribution has drifted back toward the middle without reaching the opposite extreme. Oil and gas serves as a case study. Exploration and production companies were once valued on reserve life and production growth, and are now judged on cash flow and capital returned. Carl also argues that commodity cycles take years to correct, so patience matters.
The range is wide. On Warren Buffett, Carl credits the Apple investment to the product's ecosystem lock-in. He tells the story of Galen Weston recasting bread baking as a transportation business, and of Jens Heyerdahl building Orkla through a long run of positive-NPV decisions across unrelated industries. Patrick brings in The Systems Bible to question Meta's approach, and Carl adds that a product needing $8–10 billion a year to start may be a bad idea.
The more contested material concerns energy: falling renewable costs against weak storage, hydrogen's logistical problems, the Canadian oil sands and the Pathways carbon-capture program, and the claim that electrified cars will matter more than investors realize. Carl describes screening about 2,000 ideas a year through a pattern recognition funnel, warns about pride, and says investors can hold stocks that embody contradictory worldviews.
Kawaja argues the post-2021 shift to costlier capital is a durable regime change that culls speculative projects, so investors should stay open-minded, be patient through slow cycles, accept being right only about 55% of the time, and look for overlooked opportunities in energy and resources rather than chasing AI hype.
- Expensive capital has removed the funding for speculative 'chaff' companies, and this change is unlikely to reverse
- Investing success comes from many small wins ('gorks') and from being right only slightly more than half the time
- Overlooked sectors such as energy, resources and the oil sands may hold more opportunity than popular technology themes
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Commodity and resource cycles take a long time because behavior and market prices take years to correct, so investors must be patient rather than expecting quick reversals.
“these cycles, they take a long time. And it takes a long time for behavior to correct and for the market to correct and you have to be patient.”
Every successful complex system evolves from a simpler system, so complex systems cannot be airdropped in and will not hold, a principle drawn from The Systems Bible that explains why Meta's approach is risky.
“every successful complex system evolves from a simple system to start. You can't airdrop in a complex system, like it just does not work.”
Boiled down to essence, value-based strategies buy companies that are terrible and become less terrible, and incremental improvement from very low levels can produce large returns.
“incredibly terrible to godawful is a huge move.”
For much of Kawaja's career, E&P companies were valued on reserve life and production growth with little regard for the true economics of new wells, but now they are judged on cash flow growth and capital returned to shareholders, a sharp swing back from the growth-at-any-cost extreme.
“Our primary goal is to say we're going to grow our cash flow 27% and we're going to return 20% of it to investors.”
Buffett's Apple investment has been extraordinarily successful, and Kawaja attributes this to Apple's exceptionally strong product, with the iPhone's ecosystem lock-in so powerful that users would pay a lot to stay.
“I would pay a lot of money to stay on the iPhone.”
As money became more expensive, the opportunity cost of funding long-dated projects rose, and cash in T-bills became a more promising alternative to speculative investment.
“It became more expensive to do things because money became more expensive. And the alternatives for sitting on your hands and buying T-bills, all of a sudden got more promising.”
Canadian oil sands are highly polluting but geopolitically stable, and if the Pathways program with roughly $75 billion over 20 years can capture and sequester most emissions, it could cut carbon emissions there by about 90 percent while still supplying energy.
“the goal is that with $75 billion or so in 20 years, they will essentially sequester the majority of the carbon emissions output that they have in the oil sands.”
Pride is a persistent investing risk: as experience and titles accumulate, investors overestimate their accuracy, so they need to remind themselves how often they are wrong and rely on colleagues to challenge them.
“as you get older and you have more experience ... Oh, gosh, I must be right about quite a few things.”
The energy transition is a better area than AI or SaaS for someone seeking deep investing expertise, because the AI theme is well known and not a huge source of alpha while energy is poorly understood.
“I think I would encourage them to spend time on this question of the energy transition more than SaaS or AI.”
Renewable generation costs have fallen dramatically, but progress on storing solar and wind energy is much smaller, and hydrogen, though widely seen as the best storage and transport option, lacks infrastructure and is harder to transport than oil.
“we really have made, in my view, much less progress on the technologies for storing solar and wind.”
The investing environment has changed irreparably and probably for the better, and the speculative excess that rewarded unprofitable, audacious ideas will not return, even though some out-of-favor stocks have rebounded.
“I do think that the environment and the regime has changed irreparably and probably for the better.”
The difference between a minor leaguer and a major leaguer is a few extra hits per season, or gorks, so investing success similarly depends on a handful of unexpected small wins that compound into large outcomes.
“sometimes the margins of victory, the difference between being a minor leaguer and making $80,000 a year ... is really just a couple of those gorks.”
Investors are often only about half right, and success depends on being right a bit more than half the time, which is a realistic and sufficient edge if it is paired with keeping spirits up.
“often in investing, we're not much more than half right.”
Galen Weston reframed bread baking as a transportation business, so the right move was to sell old urban bakeries and build new ones at highway nexus points for efficient distribution.
“baking bread and selling bread, it's not a bakery business, it's a transportation business.”
Succeeding at roughly 30 different businesses through a series of positive-NPV decisions is a different and hard achievement, comparable to inventing the iPhone, and can aggregate to extraordinary success even with failures along the way.
“it's a different thing and a different kind of difficulty to succeed at like 30 different things.”
Good new products usually start small and catch fire organically, so committing $8 billion to $10 billion a year for five years to start something may itself suggest the idea is bad.
“if you're investing $8 billion to $10 billion a year and something to get it started and you do that for five years, it might even just prima facie be a sign that it's a bad idea.”
Deep-value companies trading at low multiples can improve dramatically under a new CEO, so the odds of getting a manager who is seven times better are higher there than at high-quality growth companies that already have strong leaders.
“But with some crummy companies itself who are like 2.5x EBITDA and stock is down to 80%, can you get someone 7x better? Your odds are better.”
Kawaja screens around 2,000 ideas a year and lets most flow past, deepening research only when pattern recognition signals interest, rather than studying 20 names deeply to find three winners.
“Whereas I would say, I'm going to look at 2,000 things this year. When I start sensing, like when my pattern recognition kicks in, that the thing is interesting, I'm going to go deeper on that.”
A decade-old belief that everyone must learn Chinese to succeed proved wrong because Chinese business people learned English, showing that popular expertise bets can be undercut by counter-adaptation.
“it turned out that everyone in Chinese was learning English.”
Investors can own stocks that reflect contradictory worldviews, such as rate-sensitive banks and rate-sensitive SaaS companies, and embrace that uncertainty instead of forcing consistency.
“But you own two things that, in a way, reflects contradictory underlying world views, but you embrace the uncertainty of that and you allow yourself to own both of them.”
Investing is unusually replicable: anyone can copy Warren Buffett's publicly described actions, whereas one cannot replicate Barry Bonds' hitting skill even by knowing exactly what he did.
“the nice thing is if I tell you what Warren Buffett does, you can actually do the exact same thing.”
Jens Heyerdahl turned Norway's Orkla from a small pyrite miner into one of Europe's best-performing stocks from roughly 1982 to 2002 by making a series of positive NPV decisions across uncorrelated industries, including frozen pizza, beer, detergent, hydropower and securities.
“he succeeded by making a series of positive net present value decisions in different industries.”
Market valuation of a sector moves along a spectrum, so sectors swing from extreme favor to extreme disfavor, and after overshooting in technology the distribution has drifted back toward the middle without yet reaching the opposite extreme.
“if the scale ran left to right, it's moved very sharply back to the left having been on the right.”
The magnitude of change from greater electrification of automobiles is larger than the investment community understands, and analysts' question of what happens when electricity is nearly free captures this.
“tremendous change is coming from greater electrification of automobiles, for example. But I don't think the investing community, in general, kind of understands how profound it is.”
Investors need a positive internal narrative that they are right most of the time, because if they believed they were wrong most of the time they would be too discouraged to do the job.
“I think part of succeeding as an investor is convincing yourself that you're right most of the time.”
Investors should sell companies when the original thesis changes or disappointment occurs, rather than holding out, though patience is sometimes warranted.
“when they disappoint her, goodbye. ... sometimes the thesis changes and you got to be brutal and move on.”
Organizations should avoid building too many baskets, meaning stored-up assets or processes, and instead challenge themselves constantly, as exemplified by Shopify's program that deletes meetings from calendars.
“a process of constantly challenging yourself and don't build too many baskets.”
The rush to learn AI resembles the earlier belief that everyone must learn Chinese, which proved less valuable because Chinese businesspeople largely learned English, so crowded expertise may not produce an edge.
“it turned out that everyone in Chinese was learning English.”
The Nantucket whaling industry collapsed after whale guns allowed thousands of whales to be taken annually, showing how technological change can invalidate an industry that once dominated colonial exports.
“Then when they invented whale guns, they started taking out several thousand whales a year, and it kind of decimated the industry.”
The Pirahã orient using external landmarks such as the river rather than body-centered left and right, which Kawaja connects to the humbling idea that one's own frame of reference is not the only sensible one.
“their system of orientation is exocentric as opposed to endocentric.”
Companies like Gopuff and Carvana, which address large markets in unconventional ways, may thrive, but in a shifted regime the next winners could be oil and gas, electric utilities such as PG&E, rather than popular tech names.
“Maybe it will be oil and gas. Maybe it will be electric utilities.”
Unexpected beneficiaries of the regime change could include oil and gas and regulated electric utilities such as PG&E, which would benefit from electric car adoption with a regulated return base.
“Maybe the biggest beneficiary will be PG&E because everyone in California is driving an electric car, and they have a regulated return base.”
Reliance Enterprises' decision to open hundreds, then thousands, of organized retail stores in India with a data-driven concept challenged the view that retailers must start small, and Kawaja says it has been successful despite his initial doubts.
“Boy, has it been successful. They kind of were right.”
Hilda Applbaum deliberately holds stocks that benefit from rising rates alongside stocks that benefit from falling rates, embracing the contradiction to stay flexible and hedge uncertainty about the macro outcome.
“I keep my mind flexible so that I can balance two different things.”
George Weston's holding company was transformed by a new CEO, Dick Currie, who grew Loblaw's grocery business to make more EBITDA in a day than in a year when he joined, pruning weak businesses and making the stock rise as much as 7x in short order.
“the stock did incredibly well under his tenure. I mean, I think it may have gone up as much as 7x in short order.”
During a regime change investors should widen their aperture to consider many more possibilities, while specialized focus is appropriate only when a long wave is clear and certain.
“during regime change to really open your aperture.”
Before the regime change, the further a company was from making money and the crazier its idea, the more its stock rose and the higher its valuation, because audacious ideas excited investors.
“the farther you were from ever making money and the crazier the idea was, the more your stock price went out and the higher valuation you got”
Sports franchise values have produced exceptional returns because the power law of wealth, rising wealth inequality, and the scarcity of professional teams make the asset class structurally valuable.
“the combination of power law of wealth and wealth inequality and scarcity of the number of professional teams has produced this crazy return for the franchise values.”
Because oil sands extraction uses large trucks and shovels to haul sand back for heating, most of the material returns to the same site, so emissions are concentrated enough to capture and sequester rather than dispersed like conventional drilling.
“the nice thing is you basically bring most of the sand back to the same place and you heat it and produce emissions at the same place.”
Kawaja analyzed ten years of his own investing in the New Perspective Fund and found many gorks, outcomes he had not expected that contributed to good results.
“I looked at 10 years of my own investing experience in the fund ... there were so many gorks in there.”
The discounted value of a future CEO's superior performance is a real valuation factor for stocks that does not appear in a standard DCF model.
“Like the discounted future value of the future CEO relative to the current one in growth businesses, that factor is like an inhibitor. ... that's not in a DCF, but it's a very real factor”
Being right about 55 percent of the time is pretty good in investing, and occasional home runs such as Jeff Bezos's 30-home-run framing drive most of the returns.
“being 55% right is pretty good.”
Investors should avoid becoming stubborn and giving up on sectors they have dismissed, because mental flexibility is what lets them reinvest when conditions change, as Buffett did when he bought gold and Japanese trading houses after disparaging them.
“Don't get stubborn. Don't forget about things and give up on things and deem them not worthy of your investing time.”
Investors should position for how the world may evolve five years out because the world surprises you so much, though Kawaja admits he cannot start from a blank sheet every January 1.
“I do think that you plant the seeds for success five years from now today.”
Owning sports franchises was once considered foolish, but over the last 20 years sports investing has been very successful, driven by scarcity of teams and wealth concentration.
“look how incredibly successful sports investing has been in the last 20 years.”
The Piraha language, documented by Daniel Everett, has no numbers beyond one and two, only few or many, no past or future tense, and no color words.
“he proved that the language doesn't have any numbers beyond two. So it's one, two and then few or many”
Berkshire's investments in Japanese trading houses are effectively leveraged commodity bets, since their returns depend mainly on iron ore, coal, gold and oil prices rather than on product innovation or new services.
“They're leveraged commodity investments.”
Kawaja invested in Canadian conglomerate George Weston, where the Loblaw grocery business came to dominate value, and under Galen Weston's later decision to install Dick Currie to transform the holding company, the stock reportedly rose as much as sevenfold.
“I mean, I think it may have gone up as much as 7x in short order.”
Large wipeouts in private companies make it an ideal time to have raised money and to be scanning the field, because the downturn separates durable businesses from speculative ones.
“That's probably an ideal time to have raised some money and be looking at the field, because now we'll separate the wheat from the chaff.”
When Everett taught the Piraha to build deep canoes, they declined to fill them with fish, because they only fish for immediate needs and do not store surplus.
“Is there any reason on earth why we would do that?”
After a mistake, a constructive reset focused on the next action is more useful than harsh self-criticism, a lesson Kawaja drew from tennis instruction and from a conversation with Mats Wilander.
“You always have to reset and just think about the next ball that you're hitting so to have that positive mindset.”
Muhammad Ali's 1966 fight against Cleveland Williams featured the Ali Shuffle, a rapid footwork move that disoriented the opponent in a sport built on feints, retreats and positional advantage, and Ali changed strategy by saying he had different strokes for different folks.
“the Ali Shuffle, which is that move where he would move his legs back and forth very quickly without moving at all.”
Daniel Everett's study of the Pirahã language, which lacks number words beyond two, has past and future tenses, color words and left-right terms, suggests that different languages can produce very different ways of thinking about space, time and the world.
“they don't have a past or a future tense. They only speak in a present tense.”
The Pirahã appear to be happier and less stressed by simple objective measures, yet they have made no technological progress, such as durable baskets, so the trade-off may be between contentment and progress that lives in the future.
“it's like, to me, the trade-off could be between contentment and happiness.”
Carl believes global warming is probably a real phenomenon and that its consequences, if true, could be extreme, and that recent fires and floods make it a serious problem worth focusing on.
“I'm of the belief that it's probable that global warming is a phenomenon.”
Investors benefit from the tennis lesson of resetting after a bad shot rather than self-flagellating, applying the same positive mindset to investing mistakes.
“You always have to reset and just think about the next ball that you're hitting so to have that positive mindset.”
Exposure to non-business sources such as art exhibits and museum visits can generate governance insights, as a Whitney Biennial piece tracing Warren Buffett to every Fortune 500 board member through six degrees informed Kawaja's thinking on boards.
“occasionally, insights come from something else.”
Kawaja believes global warming is probably real and that if it is real and worsening the consequences could be extreme, so investors should focus on it, while expecting that solutions will be nuanced, unconventional and profitable for flexible investors.
“if global warming is real and if it's going to get worse, I think it's a really big problem.”
Kawaja's habit of spending half of family vacations planning the next trip is a failing that the Pirahã avoid by living in the present, and the trade-off between constant future planning and contentment is worth considering.
“I never go on a vacation with our family without spending half the vacation planning the next vacation.”
Unlike most sports where athletes improve, boxing has declined, and boxers from 80 years ago were better than today's boxers, according to The Arc of Boxing.
“in boxing, he argues, people have gotten worse. And he thinks boxers from 80 years ago were better at boxing than boxing today.”
Buffett was brilliantly right on Apple, but across his technology investing he has been right only about half the time, which underscores that even great investors miss frequently.
“obviously, he's been so incredibly, blindingly brilliantly right. ... in his history of technology investing, he's been right about half of the time.”
Large companies such as Amazon, Meta, Alphabet and Wayfair are cutting staff and reducing their flexibility to fund projects whose net present value or path to profitability is uncertain.
“We're seeing a variety of companies, Amazon, Meta, Alphabet, Wayfair, kind of across the board, engage in significant layoffs and reduce their flexibility to sort of fund things where the NPV or the path to profitability is uncertain.”
The reduction in speculative 'chaff' projects is healthy because companies are still planting real crops and investing in innovation, just without indiscriminately throwing ideas at the wind.
“There was too much of that, and it feels very healthy to me.”
Kawaja screens for stocks that were very bad last year, such as long-time Dow laggards, and also for exceptional performers whose success the market may be underestimating, then digs deeper on those.
“I try to see what's been really bad last year.”
On a left-to-right scale of investor priorities, oil and gas has moved sharply back to the left from the right extreme, while technology and e-commerce remain on the far right, though drifting toward the middle.
“it's moved very sharply back to the left having been on the right.”
Kawaja believes Buffett's investment in IBM, made with confidence in CEO Ginni Rometty, was wrong, and Berkshire's internal analysts flagged competitive weakness and disruption in detail.
“respectfully, I feel like he was totally wrong.”
Analysts Dominic Phillips and Gigi Pardasani asked what will happen when the marginal cost of electricity heads toward zero, a question Kawaja endorses as a useful practice for analysts to frame disruptive change.
“They said, What will we do when electricity is free?”
Cricket accounts for roughly 90 to 95 percent of live sports viewing in India and has enormous popularity, so franchise ownership of an Indian cricket team has strong fundamentals.
“I think cricket is something like 90% or 95% of live sports viewing in India”
In one year Orkla sold companies and returned dividends worth roughly 75 to 80 percent of the share price at the start of that year while keeping much the same earnings base, a feat Kawaja admired as magical capital allocation.
“he returned dividends to investors that I think were something like 75% or 80% of the share price at the start of the year.”
Carl has the widest aperture among well-known investors, covering topics from ChatGPT to oil sands to Argentinian bonds to an Italian town, which makes conversations with him refreshing.
“of all the investors I know well, I feel like you always have the most interesting aperture. Like it's always the widest.”
When a company has an exceptional product, such as GLP-1 weight-loss drugs with dramatic results, Kawaja becomes very interested in it, because a great product is a good base for investing.
“if a company has a product that is exceptional, it makes me very interested.”
Energy-related stocks were a source of positive relative return in 2022, and Kawaja's gains came from holding one energy company for about a decade through declines, adding to it as fundamentals improved.
“I owned it, it went down as all other energy things did. It was painful. But I thought that the core thesis was still there, so I hung on to it.”
Energy-related holdings were a source of positive relative return last year, and it was hard to beat the market without energy exposure, since Chevron and Exxon were among the biggest S&P 500 contributors.
“it was hard to do much better than the market last year without having exposure to energy.”
Patrick restated that Kawaja's experimentation summary was fair and asked about its pros and cons.
“Is it fair to summarize that as the cost of experimentation has gone up a lot”