Bill Gurley and Philip Rosedale - Back to the Future - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 254]
What this covers
Philip Rosedale, who built Second Life, and Bill Gurley, whose firm Benchmark invested in it, talk with Patrick O'Shaughnessy about what that early virtual world did and did not prove. They begin with its origins and economy. The Linden dollar traded openly against the dollar and euro, and the company held it steady by selling new currency into the market as users arrived. They then turn to what today's metaverse push is repeating. Rosedale separates two ideas bundled in the word: the shift from 2D to 3D, and the shift from a lonely internet to one where people are always present and talking. The second does not require 3D.
Rosedale supplies the technical detail. Conversation feels natural when audio latency is under about 0.2 seconds, and spatial audio would restore the cocktail-party effect that online calls lack. He doubts that community infrastructure built on VR headsets is the right bet, and he thinks AR-style audio overlays may be more practical. He also argues the metaverse must cross both a chasm and the uncanny valley before avatars can stand in for people in a boardroom or classroom.
The second half is about crypto. Gurley frames decentralization as a continuum with technical and governance sides. Rosedale calls crypto the price of distrust, which is still too high to support a virtual world. He says no stable, low-fee currency exists for something as small as paying for a virtual hat. They also discuss Alienable Property and why moving an NFT between games is mostly a wink. Gurley prefers governance, such as subreddit members voting through tokens, and notes that a token's value depends on whether the protocol can collect a rake. He also predicts that any arbitrageable flaw in a virtual economy will be exploited quickly.
Gurley and Rosedale argue that Second Life's experience shows mass metaverse adoption will come from low-friction communication, purpose-driven digital places, and trustworthy governance, not from photorealistic avatar worlds, which appeal mainly to a small group seeking escapism.
- Second Life's avatar-based world reached about a million users and a roughly $650 million annual GDP, but its appeal stayed limited to a small demographic.
- Discord-style communication spaces already aggregate people more effectively than 3D avatar environments, and separating graphics from communication is key.
- Crypto's core unsolved problems are stable low-fee currencies and trust-minimized governance, not the speculative token economy.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Conversation feels natural and fun when audio latency is under about 0.2 seconds, allowing interruption and lively exchange, but above that threshold people experience painful waiting and talk over one another, so latency is a major driver of how people feel about online interactions.
“if it's below two tenths of a second, we get along with each other and we have fun and we interrupt and have a lively conversation.”
Decentralization is a continuum rather than a binary, and systems such as Linux, Android, Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Solana sit at different points, trading off trust, performance, and cost.
“There's a continuum of decentralization. ... they all trade off on these two things Phillip talked about, which is trust versus performance, and cost.”
Digital goods become real and valuable when they are alienable, meaning they can be sold or given to another person without a third party in the middle, a principle that Lawrence Lessig articulated in 2004 and that underlies NFT-style ownership.
“What will make digital goods real is if they are alienable.”
Two people talking at once can only be understood when their voices come from different points in space, so three-dimensional audio enables a cocktail-party effect that allows people to follow multiple conversations, which online audio has lacked.
“if two people talk at the same time, you can't understand them unless their voices come from two different points in space.”
Crypto functions as the price of distrust: a fully distributed system in which no one trusts anyone carries a basic cost that is far from zero and too high to support a virtual world yet.
“I always talked about crypto in some measure as being the price of distrust”
Putting more of a 3D world on a blockchain instead of a database would make it harder to deliver the performance a 3D world requires, so the technical cost of decentralization is a real constraint on virtual worlds.
“putting more things on a blockchain versus a database would only make it more difficult to do what you need to do in a 3D world.”
The metaverse must cross both a chasm and the uncanny valley, because avatars used as game props tolerate low fidelity, but presenting yourself to establish real relationships at a board meeting or classroom requires a fidelity that has not yet been achieved.
“the challenge of the metaverse is that you have both chasm to cross, and the uncanny valley, if you want.”
Governance is the more promising use of crypto: tokenization could let members of a subreddit vote on subscription models, ads, or moderation, combining digital community spaces with decentralized governance.
“could you imagine a subreddit where the members get to make a decision about whether it's a subscription model there or whether ads can run”
If a currency is designed to appreciate, handing participants coins that might rise creates a double incentive, like giving everyone lottery tickets that encourage participation, which could be a powerful on-ramp if liquidity and network effects are achieved.
“The participant gets handed a coin that might go up. It's like you're handing out lottery tickets to everybody.”
The early internet had an obvious utility function, such as email and websites for broadcasting information, creating urgency, while crypto is anchored to big ideas but lacks immediate everyday utility, which makes it polarizing.
“we actually all knew what the internet was for. There was a strong sense of urgency.”
Decentralization has two parts: a technical component, where putting more on a blockchain than a database makes 3D performance harder, and a trust and governance component, which can work better than the technical side.
“The decentralization kind of has two parts, a technical component and a trust governance component”
Because new websites reached about 300,000 per day at the peak of internet growth around 2012, a truly open metaverse at internet scale would require enormous parallel deployment, making a single company building it unlikely and a decentralized architecture more probable.
“the number of new websites that were deployed per day was something like 300,000 a day.”
Building community infrastructure that depends on VR headsets, as Meta's strategy does, is a difficult and unproven theory, so it does not seem like the right direction, while AR-style audio overlays may hold more practical promise.
“trying to build community infrastructure that's dependent on a VR headset, which is part of what Meta strategy is, just doesn't feel like the right direction to me.”
Second Life openly traded the Linden dollar against the dollar and euro at market prices, and the company kept the currency steady by selling new currency into the market as users arrived.
“we increased the money supply by selling new currency into the market so that it remained steady.”
Axie Infinity only exploded in activity after moving to the Ronin sidechain, which is controlled by the company and has lower friction than Ethereum, supporting the idea that a managed, low-friction economy is needed for commerce on top of a platform.
“they didn't explode until they created this Ronan side chain that didn't have the frictions of Ethereum itself.”
Validated authenticity and scarcity increase economic value of digital assets, but moving an NFT item from one platform to another is largely a wink because applicability across games requires a shared framework that is unlikely to emerge.
“I don't think that's a real thing because the likelihood of having applicability there, I mean, I guess that could become some emergent property”
Facebook's top-down plan to build a universal avatar metaverse applies to all people, but the evidence from Second Life and other systems shows that avatar worlds serve a narrow group, creating a large disconnect between what has worked and what is being promised.
“there's a tremendous disconnect between what has worked so far”
Crypto has not yet produced a stable currency with low fees for small everyday payments, so there is no easy way to pay someone for a virtual hat, and this lack of frictionless payment is the core reason crypto cannot yet support Second Life-style commerce.
“we don't yet have a stable currency with low fees. We do not yet have it.”
Virtual role-playing would reach a far larger share of the population under a dystopian scenario, because science fiction such as Snow Crash and Ready Player One depicts dystopian futures in which people shift much of their life online.
“if you have a dystopia, there would obviously be a much larger percentage of the world that would get value out of role-playing in a virtual world.”
Graphical realism does not determine adoption, since Second Life was closer to realism than Minecraft and still lost, and hardware companies promote realism because it sells more devices.
“if being closer to realism mattered, Second Life would've crushed everyone, because it's much closer.”
A governance token's value depends heavily on whether the protocol can collect a fee rake, since a token that only confers governance rights without economic claim would be worth a small fraction of an economic token, illustrated by the Uniswap DAO's option to take up to 5 percent.
“everything from my history of studying finance and economics would say that if you declared you'd never rake the system, governance token, simply the right to kind of control a group or community would be worth a fraction”
Any mispricing or design flaw in a virtual economy that can be arbitraged will be exploited quickly, and the internet has always been an arbitrage machine, so incentive design that creates a windfall for early participants invites risk.
“The internet has from the very beginning and continues to be the ultimate arbitrage machine. And if you make a mistake that someone can get rich off and arbitrage, they will.”
Simple heuristics spread faster and produce more emergent behavior than complex ones because they reach higher participation rates, since more people are comfortable manipulating and contributing to simple systems, which yields complexity such as kids building computers inside Minecraft.
“The simpler heuristics, you get way more emergent behavior out of, because you have a much higher participation rate.”
The term metaverse conflates two separable ideas: the move from 2D to 3D presentation, which improves some information retention, and the move from a lonely single-player internet to one where people are always present and communicating, with the second idea not requiring 3D at all.
“So there's two ideas. 2D to 3D is separable from people being there all the time.”
Second Life kept the Linden dollar pegged to the US dollar by continually issuing new currency into the market as users arrived, and Gurley now thinks that in hindsight they should have let the currency appreciate because the appreciation incentive is a powerful attractor.
“we decided collectively to keep the Linden dollar ratio fixed to the dollar. And that was achieved by actually increasing supply in that case.”
Within Second Life, item values stayed small and stable, with a baseball cap costing about $2 and designer items $20 to $100, because values were driven by real utility rather than speculation, which is why Second Life can be used to study the separation of speculation from utility, unlike today's crypto markets where a profile picture sold for 2.4 million.
“the value of the things in there was entirely or almost entirely in every case, driven by their real utility.”
Minecraft and Roblox outperformed Second Life because their creation primitives were simpler, their audience was children rather than adults, and they had more game-like mechanics, while Second Life was an open-ended creator universe with harder tools.
“their primitives are simpler. And so the creator tools at Second Life, you could do amazing rich things, but they were a little harder to use.”
Unity is a software development kit rather than a finished product, so it cannot by itself produce a metaverse, because a metaverse built from thousands of separately built experiences would not connect into a coherent whole that players or designers want.
“Unity is a software development kit, not a product.”
The metaverse should be forked into an avatar-centric 3D version, which is what Second Life built and what Zuckerberg demonstrates, and a digital place version centered on live audio-first communication, which Gurley believes is far more promising than avatar board meetings.
“One of them, as opposed to 3D, I might say avatar-centric.”
The metaverse needs a simple, broadly accessible public commons where people meet safely before branching into experiences, and the open question is what rules of engagement and degree of decentralization are needed to make such a space workable.
“That place is typically a public place, which is interesting. It's often a place that's broadly accessible. It's safe.”
Virtual-world events like the Travis Scott concert are one-off phenomena that are not replicated, and Second Life saw hundreds of similar examples without them becoming regular, so people extrapolate incorrectly from single events.
“There's the one off thing that's really interesting because it's unique, but then it's not replicated, the opposite of what people are extrapolating.”
In Second Life, the chance that a randomly met user was outside your country was around 60 percent, so the platform had to build a currency that worked across geographies with near-zero transaction fees, since payment tools like Venmo could not settle across borders.
“There was a 60% or more chance if you're in the US, a 60% chance that they were not in your country.”
A safe, broadly accessible public meeting place where people can gather and then branch into activities is still missing on the internet, and Discord is the closest current approximation.
“We don't have that yet. And one of the opportunities, and then, I think Discord is the closest thing to it”
Every hardware and microprocessor company wants to believe that graphical realism matters because it sells more hardware, so their claims about fidelity should be discounted.
“there are many, many reasons why every hardware company, and every microprocessor company, wants to believe it matters”
Most gaming is consumptive, like a ride or TV show, and the platform and game components needed for purposeful, collaborative creation differ fundamentally from consumptive play, so they are unlikely to emerge from the same architecture.
“they're just very different beasts. And so I don't think we can expect to see them spring from new architecture equally.”
Second Life's flat user and transaction numbers for over a decade suggest that a graphically rich virtual world plateaus at a modest audience rather than compounding into a mass platform.
“that number has been the same for more than the last 10 years, since from about 2008 on to now.”
A competitor to Uniswap could declare that its DAO will never take a rake and exist solely for the community, which would be more consistent with crypto's stated narrative and expose a contradiction in token collection.
“Ironically, that's truer to the narrative the crypto religious claim to be making”
Second Life creators were cashing out about $100 million per year, showing that money could be withdrawn from the platform, so centralized control of the currency did not block creator monetization.
“The creators were cashing out 100 million a year last time I had access to the number.”
Gurley agrees that Ethereum's built-in rake mechanism in its incentive structure is philosophically intriguing, but warns that Solana could be cheaper and then be disrupted itself, so the sector may be a race to the bottom where token values fall far below current expectations.
“if Solana eats ETH then all of these tokens are worth far less than we imagine because there's just a race to the bottom.”
Gurley would be more excited by Facebook if it built bottom-up community on top of its existing user base instead of a top-down avatar-driven metaverse that is disconnected from its platform, which he does not expect to succeed.
“I would be way more excited for them if they were doing a bottom up thing on top of that liquidity.”
A digital version of adult social games like spades, charades, and bridge, with audio and maybe video, could take off quickly if the ingredients are right, yet such simple adult group experiences remain surprisingly absent online.
“It's actually quite shocking that we don't have a digital form of those more simplistic type adult games”
Second Life had about a million users at the time of the conversation, a virtual space roughly the size of Los Angeles that functions largely as one connected map, and an economy of about $650 million a year in individual GDP transactions, roughly a billion dollars in total transactions, with those figures flat since about 2008.
“It's about a million people using it. It's a space that's about the size of Los Angeles.”
Discord serves as the starting point where young people meet to coordinate across games and locations, like a modern version of meeting at a boat ramp, and users then move to other experiences, so Discord functions as the community's kickoff point rather than the place of activity itself.
“If they're going to hang out or get together or do something in this 3D universe, they start by meeting in Discord.”
Games use onboarding and tutorials such as basic training to get players committed and produce quick dopamine, while digital places have a built-in purpose from the start, such as a crypto project group, which helps onboard and engage new users faster than open-ended worlds.
“I think purpose can really help onboarding new customers, and getting the engaged.”
Play-to-earn models that distribute scarce fixed virtual assets to whoever devotes the most time are fundamentally different from creator-driven economies like Second Life and may cause real harm to people, so entrepreneurs should be thoughtful about them.
“That may be something which does real harm to people. I think as entrepreneurs, we have a responsibility to be thoughtful about that.”
Audio is the simplest medium with immediate utility for online community, and voice conveys a lot if done right, so audio-first spaces like Clubhouse and Twitter Spaces are a practical next step toward digital togetherness.
“audio, if it's done right, convey a lot.”
The best investment opportunity is the simplest next step in communication, possibly 3D audio, along with the governance rules and centralization decisions needed to make a grown-up, everyday communal space work for all, rather than a graphics-heavy avatar world.
“I think the investment opportunity is to say what is that? What is the very simplest step forward from here”
The simpler the building primitives, the more appealing they are to kids but less suited to adults, because adult uses such as work, dating, and attending shows require high graphical quality, creating a trade-off between accessibility and fidelity.
“the simpler the primitives are, the more appealing they are to kids and not grownups. You've got this interesting trade-off.”
Taking on a new body in a virtual world is an escapist choice that few adults make, and the groups that benefit most are people in authoritarian regimes, disabled people, or people in rural areas without creative communities, so a top-down avatar metaverse appeals to only a small fraction of adults.
“reasons why you would essentially give up your body and take on a new body in a virtual world are very different. And they're certainly not common.”
Second Life spent about 20 million dollars on AML and KYC protocols, which raises the question of whether a token-based economy would remain legal.
“Second Life spent $20 million on those protocols”
Rosedale and Gurley held about eight board meetings with avatars in Second Life before Zoom existed, and Zoom now provides a substitute that is a real competitor to avatar-based work meetings.
“Philip and I have done eight of those board meetings with avatars, and that was pre-Zoom.”
A platform with 500 million users communicating in a digital place would beat a technically superior 3D avatar system without users, because network and participation matter more than immersive technology.
“Boy, I'd bet on the first.”
Second Life reportedly went from zero to around 70 million dollars in revenue in under 18 months, which made the vision look achievable and led Gurley to believe the company would go to the moon before it did not.
“the company went from zero to 70 million in revenue in less than 18 months.”
Organizations increasingly coordinate in real time on Discord around crypto projects, and this type of digital place is more useful for professional collaboration than avatar-based board meetings.
“you see organizations getting together in realtime around like a crypto project”
Crypto's frictionless capitalism is working today, but its governance capabilities, especially easy one-person-one-vote democratic decision-making, have not been developed, though Rosedale believes they could have high impact.
“one of them is working pretty well today ... frictionless capitalism is like what crypto is doing.”
Silicon Valley has a pervasive unwritten norm that when asked for a reasonable amount of time people typically give it, and successful people often pay this forward, so kindness is more common there than Rosedale suggests.
“nine times out of 10, if you ask someone for a reasonable amount of their time, they tend to give it to you.”
Children naturally want to play with identity, trying out being older or different, which drives the appeal of experiences for kids, but this desire largely fades in adulthood, so avatar worlds keep a narrower audience as people age.
“Kids want to play with their identity. For example, they want to grow up, try what it's like to be 20 when they're 12.”
Second Life publicly pledged to make no claim on intellectual property created by users, aiming that no one could stop a person from selling something to another person, which foreshadowed the person-to-person ownership NFTs now enable.
“we made no claim on the intellectual property that people created.”
The internet has not yet delivered a shared room with about 1,000 people in which real-time conversation works, and this scale is a missing capability relative to Discord-style gathering.
“how do I give you a room with 1,000 people?”
Zoom has substantial untapped potential to build additional features on top of its platform for digital connectivity and communication, making it an attractive public-market exposure to the communication side of the metaverse.
“I think Zoom has a shit ton of potential to things they could do on top of where they stand”
A persistent always-open video room, like Rich Barton's BlueJeans room at Zillow, lets people drop in and create serendipitous interaction, and this concept could be used by marketing departments to foster spontaneous collaboration.
“I could imagine the marketing department having a Zoom room that's just live all the time.”
Rosedale finds it hard to recall kind acts in the tech industry and suspects the competitive, unfettered-capitalism culture leaves more kindness outside work, so tech may need to reexamine itself.
“I don't know if there's enough kindness out there in that space.”
Mitch Kapor, Second Life's first investor, repeatedly encouraged Rosedale to keep going when investors did not understand the odd idea, which was a crucial kindness that enabled what Second Life became.
“Mitch Kapor, who was the first investor in Second Life”
NFT projects are building secondary royalty rates into the assets, which Gurley notes as part of how the market is being constructed.
“they are building secondary rates and to several of these NFTs”
Second Life became feasible around 1999, when generalized 3D reached home computers and broadband was becoming something nearly everyone would have within a couple of years.
“3D came to computers in a way that was generalized, right at about 1999.”
Rosedale's origin idea for Second Life was to build a Lego-like set governed by rules of physics, where people could build things together from basic blocks and trade what they made in a shared economy, a concept that predates VR headsets and advanced 3D graphics.
“what if we could build a Lego set that was the rules of physics?”
The core idea that drew Patrick to crypto was that the internet enabled permissionless open exchange of information, and similarly permissionless exchange of value with trustless digital asset ownership could be a foundational building block for the metaverse.
“the internet was about the permissionless open exchange of information. And this is about the same open permissionless exchange of value.”
Distributed crypto communities resemble an evolution of open source governance, so the people studying crypto governance should study open source projects.
“everyone that's learning about crypto should study open source”
Gurley would be more excited by augmented reality that delivers audio or light visual overlays for practical tasks, such as touring a building, than by full 3D immersion, though immersive VR may still deliver value for gaming, meditation, and anxiety treatment.
“I'd be much more excited investing in a AR type thing”
A Second Life user named StarX built a scripted magic wand that generated props matching what avatars said, selling for around $50 and thousands of copies, which Rosedale cites as early evidence that a single creator could earn money from user-made virtual goods.
“he used our scripting language to build this thing called StarX's wand.”
Second Life's breedable and growing virtual pets were an early, popular market, since their growth continued even when owners were offline, anticipating crypto kitties-style collectibles, and that pet market continues to be large in Second Life.
“your chickens would evolve even when you weren't there.”
A wall-sized screen that lets people hear and see another room is feasible for conversation, but walking around while speaking is not yet possible because the microphone must stay close to the mouth, and AirPods do not reconstruct voice well enough for quality 3D audio.
“we've got to keep your mouth close to a microphone. There's a physics problem with that.”
Al Jackson, who ran equity research at Credit Suisse, took a chance on Gurley after a cold call despite Gurley coming from the University of Texas, and that early opportunity had a lasting impact on his career.
“Al took a shot. ... that was super, super impactful to my career.”
Facebook's video demos showing users moving between virtual spaces look awkward, which shows that the graphical part of the experience should be separated from the human communication part.
“They're very awkward. That part doesn't need to be 3D.”
Rebuilding Second Life today would start with the expectation of a smaller audience, using simpler building blocks that are still expressive, so the onboarding is easier and the market larger than today's, though not a replacement for the internet.
“this is going to not be the new internet, but it's going to be something amazing.”
A quote that the metaverse was a warning, not an instruction manual, captures the risk that the sci-fi visions of virtual worlds describe dystopias rather than blueprints.
“the metaverse was a warning, not an instruction manual.”
The typical transaction in Second Life was a couple of dollars, which made micro-scale creator commerce the norm.
“the typical transaction ... is a couple of dollars”
COVID created a real-world scenario in which people had to shift more of their social life online regardless of preference, resembling science fiction scenarios and possibly driving adoption of virtual social spaces.
“We're looking down the barrel of possibility, where we all have to shift more of our social life online, even if we don't like that prospect.”
Gabe Leydon, who ran Machine Zone, reported that AI builders want gaming and metaverse products to distract the masses when AI takes over, a dystopian framing that Patrick says is why the metaverse concept needs definition.
“We're going to need you to distract the masses when the AI takes over.”
Basic technology challenges that blocked Second Life remain just as challenging today and will block any metaverse, even though decentralization ideas are powerful and crypto has not yet settled the question.
“there are basic technology problems that keep all of us from wanting to go into what we're imagining”
Rosedale says the metaverse is still very early, that Roblox currently serves a specific demographic and is a short-term win, and that he does not know how he would build a metaverse ETF.
“it's still quite early. ... I don't really know. I don't know how I would do it.”
Matt Ball has an ETF called Meta, intended as financial exposure to the metaverse concept, and Patrick finds it funny that Ball beat Zuckerberg to the ticker.
“my friend, Matt Ball has a ETF now called Meta, quite funny that he beat Zuck to the meta ticker”