Andrew Sugrue - Investing in Paradigm Shifts - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 224]
What this covers
Patrick O'Shaughnessy talks with Andrew Sugrue, co-founder of Avenir Growth Capital, about how a growth investor decides what is worth owning. The early part follows Sugrue's career and what he took from Julian Robertson. Robertson's fundamentals-based approach lost its edge once others copied it. He also applied First Principles Thinking across consumer, healthcare, and technology, and made most of his money on a handful of ideas. Sugrue turns that last lesson into a Concentrated Best-Ideas Portfolio of eight to ten names.
The middle works through portfolio companies. On Savage X Fenty, he explains why lingerie's long inventory lead times and fit sensitivity kept venture money out and concentrated share in Victoria's Secret. He also explains why direct-to-consumer brands, which expense growth as marketing, can look less profitable than their LTV to CAC implies. He defines contribution margin as the store-level EBITDA equivalent. For Latch, he describes Hardware as Entry Point to a software relationship of ten-plus years, plus an app used about five times a day that reaches renters at move-in through Event-Triggered Customer Acquisition. Drizly gets a briefer look: local network effects shaped by three-tier alcohol distribution.
The more contested claims concern investing itself. Sugrue calls betting on multiple expansion dangerous and questions diffused power-law portfolios that drift away from companies that fail to break out. He describes "bad growth" as selling dollars for 50 to 75 cents until capital markets close. He also uses building density to explain why cleaning costs about $90 in a New York one-bedroom versus $45 to $50 for a hotel turnover.
Sugrue argues that durable value in growth businesses comes from unit-level economics, repeat customer behavior, and privileged customer relationships that compound over time, not from heavy growth spending or hoped-for multiple expansion.
- Savage's 12-month cohort spend beat Victoria's Secret's, showing repeat behavior drives LTV advantage over acquisition spend
- Latch's hardware creates a long software relationship and a free customer-access channel, which is a durable advantage
- Efficient capital markets compete away initially attractive returns, so only sustainable advantages hold value
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Drizly has local network effects where more demand attracts more supply, and that supply attracts alcohol brand advertisers, because alcohol brands cannot sell direct-to-consumer under three-tier distribution and need a measurable conversion endpoint.
“The more demand they have in a specific area, the more they can bring on supply”
When a building has about 200 households, the marginal cost of an additional service is very low, so cleaning costs about $90 for a New York one-bedroom versus $45 to $50 for a hotel room turnover, because cleaners move between units in one place instead of commuting.
“In New York for instance, the average cost to clean a one-bedroom apartment is about $90.”
Unlike retail, where growth costs appear as capex, direct-to-consumer brands expense all growth costs in marketing, so fast-growing DTC businesses can look less profitable than their LTV-to-CAC suggests.
“Here you're expensing all of your growth costs. It's in marketing.”
Lingerie has 6 to 12 month inventory lead times and fit sensitivity, so it needs massive minimum orders and few manufacturers can do it well, making it venture-unfriendly and a barrier to entry that concentrated Victoria's Secret's share.
“You're talking about 6 to 12 month lead times on inventory.”
Initially attractive returns on invested capital get competed away quickly in efficient markets, as contract manufacturers and paid digital acquisition let rivals copy products, so businesses without a sustainable or compounding advantage are not investable.
“those returns quickly get competed away”
Residential tenants move about every 7 years but multifamily tenants move about every 1.5 years, so insurance and similar products must catch customers at move-in, which Latch can do by knowing when move-in happens.
“people are moving every 7 years in the residential world, every 1.5 years in the multi-family world”
Robertson's late 1980s and early 1990s fundamentals-based approach generated strong returns, but those returns were competed away as other investors copied his framework and capital flowed into the strategy.
“More smart people followed his framework. More capital was attracted to that strategy.”
Legacy retailers struggle with paradigm shifts because store leases are a liability, they make it hard to invest in ecommerce, and store-based merchandising and distribution across 1,000 stores is less efficient than centralized fulfillment.
“Leases are a liability. It makes it really hard to invest in innovation in eCommerce capabilities.”
Being the core software relationship for building owners lets Latch reinvest subscription profits into R&D and upsell solutions such as thermostat management, leak detection, and tenant payments.
“you get to reinvest your subscription profit dollars into R&D to solve more and more of your customers' challenges”
A first-principles mindset is a mental model usable across all industries, because it focuses on why a market is structured as it is and how it could change, and Robertson succeeded in consumer, healthcare, and technology by applying consistent frameworks around returns on invested capital and business defensibility.
“it's a mental model that you can use across all industries”
Hardware is a hit-driven business with peaks and valleys, commoditizes quickly, and has 1 to 2 year competitive lead times versus many years for software, so one-time hardware sales are a poor business model on their own.
“hardware is a very bad business model in its own, right? It's a hit-driven business, it's peaks and valleys.”
Enterprise customers deploy a product when it drives returns that substantially exceed their cost of capital, and Latch's top 20 property owners adopted it because the ROI was demonstrable.
“If you can drive great returns to them that dramatically exceed their cost of capital, they'll deploy your solution.”
Many investors bet on multiple expansion or assume multiple compression, which Andrew considers a dangerous way to invest because returns then depend on market sentiment rather than business fundamentals.
“I think a lot of people are betting on multiple expansion or at least assuming multiple compression. And I think that that's a dangerous way to invest.”
Julian Robertson made most of his money on a handful of ideas and treated the rest of his portfolio as mere survival, which Sugrue takes as the reason to run a concentrated portfolio of 8 to 10 best ideas.
“the vast majority of his money was made on a handful of ideas, and the rest was just surviving”
Many venture and growth investors rely on power-law distributions across highly diffused portfolios, staying with companies during good times but moving attention away when companies fail to break out.
“Many folks in our industry are there with you in the good times. And they're focused on other companies when you're not breakout”
Services have elastic demand: households clean once a month because they will spend about $90 a month, not because apartments only get dirty monthly, so reducing cost through density can increase usage frequency.
“So if you can reduce the cost, you can actually increase the frequency that those things are used.”
Companies that know exactly when a customer's trigger event occurs, such as moving into a building, can reach that customer at the moment of need, which is more efficient than broad advertising that must guess the timing.
“You have to catch that person at the time they need it.”
Marketplace businesses may rationally accept a poor return on a specific customer acquisition if the exponential effect of increased liquidity creates compounding advantages, unlike growth without network effects.
“there's an exponential impact that increasing liquidity in a marketplace may have that could make that an attractive dynamic.”
Although Latch looked like commoditized hardware, the firm saw that the hardware wins a software relationship of 10+ years, with about 5 years of software paid upfront, and a built-in consumer relationship through a frequently used app that creates an unfair customer acquisition advantage.
“It was hardware that won you a software relationship of 10+ years. We're at 5+ years, that's paid upfront.”
Direct-to-consumer contribution margin, measured after cost of goods, variable distribution and fulfillment, and marketing, is effectively the four-wall or store-level EBITDA equivalent, and most DTC businesses lack it because they spend all gross profit on acquisition.
“That contribution margin is effectively after marketing is effectively like store-level EBITDA for these businesses.”
Latch's app is required for tenant onboarding and is used about five times a day, which gives Latch a high-frequency channel to offer renter's insurance and internet services at conversion rates that competitors pay heavily to achieve through marketing.
“When you move into a Latch building, you have to download the Latch app, right? That's your onboarding flow.”
Latch's app onboarding flow presents renters with insurance and internet offers, so Latch can reach people at the moment they need those services, avoiding the heavy marketing spend that insurers like Lemonade use.
“When you move into a Latch building, you have to download the Latch app”
In consumer businesses the secret to success is high repeat ordering; trial can be bought or driven by celebrity, but only brands that deliver value, quality, convenience, and selection earn repeat purchases.
“the secret to success in consumer is high repeat ordering”
Bad growth comes from businesses without compounding advantages that spend heavily on digital acquisition, valuing growth above all, and selling dollars for 50 to 75 cents, which collapses when capital markets turn off because they have built nothing of value.
“businesses that value growth above all else and are willing to sell dollars for $0.50 or $0.75.”
The right test for a consumer business is whether each customer cohort is profitable on a unit basis, whether those cohorts have high returns on initial acquisition investment, whether the company can retain them, and whether it can sell additional products over time.
“Doesn't mean on a per order basis, it's on a customer cohort.”
For a direct-to-consumer apparel brand, contribution margin after marketing is effectively like store-level four-wall EBITDA, and Savage's contribution margin is as good as Lululemon's.
“Our contribution margin for Savage is as good as Lululemon.”
Density of demand lets providers offer low-value services like watering plants, turndown, and trash removal, which take 10 to 15 minutes and cannot be justified alone, because labor is already present in the building.
“when you already have labor present in the building, it enables you to do things that solve real consumer needs”
If an investment reaches 30% or more operating margins at the unit level and the entry price implies only 1 to 2 times free cash flow at that state, the investor makes money regardless of whether the market values free cash flow at 20x or 30x, while betting on multiple expansion is dangerous.
“Whether the market values free cash flow at 30x or 20x, it's all gravy.”
Amazon funded an hour-long show because inclusive, socially significant content drives traffic to Amazon Prime, which makes it a low-cost customer acquisition channel for Savage.
“Amazon wouldn't produce it if it wasn't a huge driver of traffic to Amazon Prime.”
Inclusivity is good for business as well as for societal good, since firsts like plus-size, transgender, and male lingerie models generate press that accelerates brand awareness faster than any direct-to-consumer brand Sugrue knows of.
“Not just because of why we did it, which is because it was for societal good, but also because it's good for business.”
Savage uses celebrity in under 10% of creative, relies on over 300 influencers for most marketing spend, and avoids dependence on Facebook and Google, so the brand is defined by community, which Sugrue sees as the future of consumer brands.
“Rihanna is used in less than 10% of our creative. This brand is defined by the community.”
Savage reimagined the Victoria's Secret fashion show as a more inclusive Savage X Fenty show produced with Amazon, which replaced the Victoria's Secret show during New York Fashion Week and generated over 16 billion press impressions.
“It's the most watched fashion show on Amazon Prime.”
Savage's first-order AOV was similar to Victoria's Secret's, but over 12 months a Savage customer spent over $200 versus about $110 for a Victoria's Secret customer, and that incremental lifetime value gave Savage room to outbid rivals on digital acquisition.
“a Victoria's Secret consumer was spending $110. And our consumer was spending over $200.”
Most apparel is a low-quality, fragmented category with low long-term operating margins, but lingerie is an exception because it has high brand affinity and is not a utility purchase.
“Lingerie is one of those. Unlike most categories of apparel”
Robertson recognized that everyone in the industry is smart, so the key difference between successful and unsuccessful investors is hunger, and hiring young, hungry people produced the Tiger Cubs who now control large amounts of capital.
“The key difference between successful and unsuccessful people is really the hunger.”
The firm searches for companies with an unfair advantage in customer acquisition that is not obvious to outsiders, such as a privileged relationship that gives access to customers at near-zero cost.
“what we're constantly looking for is where is there this unfair advantage on customer acquisition that a company may have”
If a brand's customers spend more over their lifetime, it can compete for digital acquisition up to a higher ceiling than rivals, meaning it is more profitable than competitors even while bidding for the same customers.
“we were competing to the last dollar that we would be willing to spend on digital acquisition”
A celebrity can be a powerful growth hack, but only celebrities with authentic, long-standing alignment with the category succeed, and such opportunities are rare.
“But every celebrity is not created equally. Authenticity really matters.”
Although Latch's hardware advantages may commoditize over time, its real goal is building density of its network, which is reinforced by a high ROI for building owners through lower labor costs, fewer lost keys, and higher rents.
“What we really want to build is the density of the network.”
On-demand services and sharing economy behavior have created a need for a new access paradigm, which is provisioning access to the right people at the right times and nothing more, and Latch addresses this last-millimeter entry problem.
“there's a need for a new paradigm around access, which is provisioning the access to the right people at the right times, and nothing but that.”
Latch customers pay for software upfront, on average five years, and because doors stop working without the product, the relationship is highly sticky and creates a locked-in customer base.
“On average, our customers are paying us 5 years upfront for the software. You can't turn off the product because your doors no longer work.”
Portfolio companies share entrepreneurs with a vision of inevitable paradigm shifts from technology, consumer preferences, or regulation, and they are constructively paranoid operators who build barriers to entry while serving customers.
“these are what I would say constructively paranoid operators”
Private investing has no Bloomberg-like universe of companies and is relationship-driven, unlike public markets where anonymous counterparties trade at market prices, and founders choose partners who help with capital allocation rather than only maximizing price.
“there is no Bloomberg for information. There is no mapped universe per se.”
Running 8 to 10 investments per fund lets the firm spend more time with each company and be as contrarian as the entrepreneur, which founders value because the firm rolls up its sleeves and helps with capital allocation.
“We run concentrated 8 to 10 investments per fund, which means we're the only person close to as contrary as the entrepreneur”
Savage was digitally native and built in the cloud for an inevitable future, and its inclusive, Rihanna-defined brand generated viral cultural narratives that built brand awareness faster than any direct-to-consumer brand the firm knew of.
“That is how we've been able to build brand awareness far faster than any direct consumer brand that I'm aware of.”
When approaching a new business, Avenir first seeks to understand the market as it is today, including its size, market share, earnings power, and supply-demand dynamics, and why that structure exists, then asks how technology could reshape it and how the business model could rerate.
“we like to understand the world as it is today, and why is it the case?”
Latch took a stale category of lock hardware sold as a one-time purchase and turned it into an enterprise software business with strong economics, which is why Andrew finds businesses that mask high quality inside old-line industries most exciting.
“a business like Latch, that's taken a relatively stayed category of lock hardware, a one-time sale, and transitioned it into an enterprise software business with some of the best economics.”
A centralized fulfillment model turns inventory faster than having products spread across 1,000 stores, which allows a wider range of sizes and styles and faster replenishment of winning products.
“a centralized fulfillment model is far more attractive than having your products spread out across 1,000 stores because you can turn inventory far faster”
Consumer brands can make creative work scientific by using data such as size histories, customer panels, and PDP image testing, and companies that mask large data advantages will be most successful over time.
“there are far more data sources now available that you can actually make the creative process scientific”
The shared trait across Avenir's portfolio companies is that they ride inevitable structural shifts in technology, consumer preference, or regulation, and are led by founders who see those shifts clearly.
“They see these undeniable, inevitable shifts. These paradigm shifts that are happening in their industry.”
Many direct-to-consumer founders say customer acquisition cost is the new rent, so the productivity of CAC drives success, and contribution margin after COGS, fulfillment, and marketing is the key unit-level measure.
“Many of our friends have coined the term CAC is the new rent.”
Two paradigm shifts hit the lingerie industry: consumers moved from in-store to online shopping, and consumers shifted toward inclusive, body-positive beauty, which Victoria's Secret's size-0, male-centric vision missed.
“two massive paradigm shifts had happened in that industry”
Victoria's Secret was built on a narrow, male-centric vision of beauty as size zero and missed the consumer shift toward inclusivity and body positivity, which contributed to year-over-year same-store sales declining 10% before COVID.
“Victoria's Secret had totally missed the mark on this change in consumer behavior, which is why you saw pre-COVID the sequential year over year 10% negative same-store sales comps.”
Rihanna's long-standing, authentic commitment to inclusive beauty makes her a credible founder-brand, and her ability to reposition the category around inclusivity is what made Savage resonate with customers and was the core of Avenir's investment.
“Rihanna has always been very authentic in this in-market of saying that beauty is inclusive.”
After last-mile logistics, the remaining challenge is the last millimeter of getting into the apartment, which requires density of demand within a building to make the economics of on-demand services attractive.
“It's no longer last mile. It's that last millimeter.”
Lingerie has historically had high brand affinity because it is not a utility purchase but a statement about identity, which keeps it insulated from the commoditization seen in most apparel categories sold on Amazon as private label.
“Lingerie has historically been a category where there's high brand affinity, where there's a high desire to buy branded products.”
Renter's insurance companies spend a disproportionate share of gross profit on customer acquisition because the product is infrequently bought, tied to moves that occur about every 7 years in residential and every 1.5 years in multifamily.
“they spend the disproportionate amount of their gross profit dollars on customer acquisition. Because these are very infrequently consumed products.”
Savage's monthly product drops bring customers back about once a month, so although they buy only four or five times a year, they are engaged enough that the brand does not need to keep re-acquiring them.
“The average customer's coming back once a month to check things. They're only purchasing 4 or 5 times a year”
Avenir positions itself as a lifecycle partner by leading successive rounds, having led Latch's Series B and every financing after, including its public offering anchor, because it wants to own as much of a winner as possible.
“We led Latch's series B and led every subsequent financing, including anchoring their public offering.”
Investors currently value growth highly and overlook fundamentals, while Avenir focuses on unit-level economics where the business need not generate aggregate cash flow but must be highly profitable per unit.
“I'm surprised at how often investors are willing to overlook fundamentals for growth and for momentum.”
Latch's lock hardware combines silicon chips, plastics, and cameras in a way that combusts at lower temperatures than a traditional lock, which matters for multifamily fire codes, and this complexity is why no competitor offers a similar product.
“it combusts at lower temperatures than a traditional hardware-only lock device”
When Avenir first invested in Savage, many people argued that direct-to-consumer was a horrible business model and that the category commoditizes quickly, but Avenir had a differentiated view that the business had a sustainable competitive advantage and could become category-defining.
“Direct to consumer is a horrible business model. Haven't you seen how XYZ category has commoditized so quickly?”
Testing product detail page images on the site can reveal that visually similar images convert at dramatically different rates, so iterative testing beats intuition about creative quality.
“you would look at three different images and say, Those all look the same to me. When you test them on the site, you find that some convert at dramatically different rates”
Well-run apparel businesses like Lululemon operate after store-level EBITDA with about 6% overhead, so a category-defining DTC apparel business should reach 20% or more operating margin.
“These businesses should be 20%+ operating margins in the future.”
Latch can reinvest the roughly 40% of premium value that insurers spend on marketing into lower customer prices, which drives high conversion because it reduces cost to the customer.
“When we can reinvest those 40% of dollars premium value spent on marketing and instead reduce cost to customers, that's a huge conversion opportunity.”
Investors should understand the bear case intimately and take it apart piece by piece, not just articulate the bull case, and this is why the firm welcomes armchair critics with differentiated views.
“not just to be able to articulate the bull case, but to understand intimately the bear case and to take it down piece by piece”
Julian Robertson's hiring of young talent produced a network of Tiger Cubs who now control an extraordinary amount of capital, showing how an investing approach can scale through people trained under one leader.
“the amount of capital that's now controlled by that group of people”
The firm name Avenir is French for future, chosen partly because it is easy to pronounce in English.
“The name of our firm Avenir is French for the future.”
Unconditional love from family provides a level of security that allows people to take risks, such as starting a firm at 27 and accepting the possibility of failure.
“When you have unconditional love, it's a level of security that is irreplaceable. It allows you to take risks.”
Sugrue's drive to succeed began as nervous energy from insecurity while growing up gay in the South, channeled into measurable achievements like school and athletics, and it persisted after he became more accepting of himself.
“I really invested that nervous energy into trying to be successful on quantifiable metrics.”
The founders attracted to the firm are critical thinkers who want their assumptions challenged, so the relationship involves frequent calls about alternatives and trade-offs rather than pitching finished plans, and the investor's understanding of founders' mental models increases conviction and capital deployment.
“the more we are understanding of their mental models, of their decision frameworks, of their motivations, the greater conviction we can have”
Drizly serves as a direct-response advertising endpoint for alcohol brands, so when a 'shop now' button on a Bud Light or Bacardi ad sends users to Drizly, Drizly captures the sale because it has the most users and supply.
“When you click that shop now button, it oftentimes directs you to Drizly.”
Avenir positions itself as a capital allocation partner that helps founders resource their highest-return opportunities, sequence spending, and draw analogies from other companies, because founders are rarely experienced investors themselves.
“We've helped them think about how do we resource the highest return opportunities in front of the business?”
Most apparel businesses are low-quality because the category is highly fragmented with very low long-term operating margins and increasing commoditization, including private-label products on Amazon.
“we had a view that most apparel businesses were low quality businesses. Apparel is a highly fragmented category with very low long-term operating margins.”
Fit matters far more in bras than in tees: a 5% sizing error in a bra is noticed by consumers, whereas a tee can be off by that much unnoticed, so few manufacturers can produce bras well and they require large minimum orders.
“If a bra is 5% too large or too small, I can tell you that the female consumer is going to notice that.”
Savage's community-driven brand generates tremendous Net Promoter Score, higher than Apple's, because it tells customers something about who they are rather than just what they purchase.
“It has higher NPS scores than Apple.”
Sugrue finds the investing job energizing because it lets him meet the most driven people who see the world as it should be and have tactical plans to get there, and this, rather than the job's demands, is what sustains his energy.
“I look forward to my Monday morning rather than dreading it.”
Rihanna changed the way women perceive beauty from a size-0, other-perceived standard to a self-actualizing concept, which has produced customer messages saying they feel beautiful for the first time.
“She's changed the way that women perceive beauty.”
The historical consumer model of creating a brand in the boardroom and pushing it out through marketing has been replaced by data-driven, community-defined brands.
“the historical disposition in consumer was that it was more art than science. It was, create the brand in the boardroom”
The US lingerie category is about a $16 billion market, with more than half captured historically by Victoria's Secret, which peaked at about $7.5 billion in annual sales.
“it's about a $16 billion category in the United States. And historically, more than half of that was captured by Victoria's Secret.”
At Catterton, Sugrue learned to keep the consumer as the north star, focusing on companies that solve a unique customer problem and relentlessly improve that experience, especially in very large end markets being disrupted by new technology, changing preferences, or regulation.
“I really learned the concept of keeping the consumer as your North Star to steal a line from Rich Barton.”
Apparel companies that are easy to picture from their name alone have a persona or identity that gives them a stronger brand, and that identity is a useful heuristic for which apparel businesses are interesting.
“brands have to stand out in a very, very fragmented market”
Latch can sell internet installation at move-in and deliver it cheaper and faster than traditional cable providers, since some categories have lower NPS than the cable industry.
“I think there's a few categories that have lower NPS than the cable industry.”
The average tenant needs access to six different doors in a building, and the old keypad-lock model fails because nobody can remember six codes that must change constantly as tenants move in and out.
“The average tenant needs access to six different doors. The old world of a Schlage lock with a keypad, who's going to remember six different codes?”