
Ep47 “Is the U.S. National Debt Sustainable?” with Mohamed El-Erian
What this covers
This is an episode of the All Else Equal series, in which hosts Jonathan Berk and Jules van Binsbergen question former PIMCO CEO Mohamed El-Erian. It starts with measurement. The debt-to-GDP ratio divides a stock measure by a flow measure, and the discussion points to Argentina defaulting at roughly 40% while Japan carries about 250% without default risk. El-Erian then lays out four routes to debt sustainability: growth, austerity, financial repression, and default or restructuring. He ranks growth first, calling it "getting a second job."
The middle of the conversation concerns the United States specifically. El-Erian explains its borrowing advantages through the Cleanest Dirty Shirt idea and the dollar's reserve status. He also warns about "sudden stops" in financing that arrive regardless of a country's own policy. Deficits of 6-7% of GDP with unemployment at or below 4% are called historically unprecedented. Jonathan Burbank notes that the US's unbroken repayment record now sits alongside primary deficits. The group also considers whether bond markets expect the Federal Reserve to step in again, after quantitative easing bought about $9 trillion of bonds and mortgages. They question whether Japan's low rates will last.
The last stretch widens to demographics, geopolitics, and technology. Falling population growth removes a source of GDP growth, and immigration policy is restrictive. El-Erian argues that fragmentation and a shift from deficient demand to deficient supply raise the equilibrium inflation rate to roughly 2.5-3%. He describes the post-war Washington Consensus as giving way to protectionism and industrial policy, and Berk worries that no tested alternative exists. On AI, El-Erian frames an 80/20 split of benefits and harms. He is more hopeful than the hosts about growth over three to five years, while Berk says that outcome depends on policies that raise productivity.
National debt sustainability cannot be evaluated by debt-to-GDP ratio alone; alternative measures like debt-to-wealth, interest-expense-to-GDP, and consideration of growth dynamics reveal the US fiscal position is manageable in the medium term despite high absolute debt levels, though long-term sustainability requires either growth acceleration or fiscal adjustment.
- Debt-to-GDP is a problematic stock-to-flow measure; debt-to-equity (or debt-to-wealth) and interest-expense-to-GDP ratios show relatively stable or flat trends since 1975, contradicting alarm from debt-to-GDP alone
- The US maintains favorable borrowing conditions because it is the 'cleanest dirty shirt' with reserve currency status and deep capital markets, buying time to find paths to fiscal sustainability
- Long-term growth from AI, life sciences, and sustainable energy innovations could improve the denominator of debt ratios, though demographic decline and geopolitical fragmentation present countervailing headwinds
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Debt-to-GDP is a problematic measurement because the numerator (debt) is a stock measure and the denominator (GDP) is a flow measure, whereas standard financial analysis typically uses stock-to-stock or flow-to-flow ratios; this inconsistency can produce misleading conclusions.
“the ratio of Deb to GDP is a very strange ratio because the numerator is a stock measure the level of debt and the denominator is GDP which is a flow measure the amount of domestic product produced in a year and we don't usually measure things by putting stocks over flows so example a company if we want to know the level of debt we'll put debt to assets of the company if if we want to put flows on case then often we'll put interest coverage over say earnings so it's flow to flow and stock to stock”
The US maintains favorable borrowing conditions because it is the 'cleanest dirty shirt'—relatively better positioned economically than other major developed and developing economies—and because the dollar is a reserve currency with deep, liquid capital markets.
“the reason why the US interest rates are so well behaved is that in relative terms the US is what you can think of as your cleanest dirty shirt imagine that you are on a trip you have packed exactly for the dur of the trip your trip is extended what are you going to wear you're going to wear your cleanest dirty... so while the US is not pristin in terms of its economic characteristics it's a lot cleaner than elsewhere so the US will tend to attract funds into the spawn market and after all it is the deepest it is the market where others are are willing to Outsource their savings too”
A sudden stop in financing (abrupt loss of credit market access) can occur for reasons independent of a country's own policies and can cause debt crises even in countries that otherwise appear sustainable, making vulnerability to sudden stops a critical dimension of debt sustainability.
“you can have and we have had a complete sudden stop on financing that has nothing to do with you that has to do with a shock elsewhere in the system and suddenly you cannot refinance your debt and that in itself can cause a debt problem in a big way”
Argentina defaulted at a 40% debt-to-GDP ratio while Japan maintains 250% debt-to-GDP with no default risk, demonstrating that debt-to-GDP alone does not determine default risk; interest rates and debt servicing conditions are critical differentiators.
“one of the big puzzles is why is Argentina default at a 40% debt to GDP ratio whereas Japan has a 250% debt to GP ratio nobody's even thinking about the possibility of Japan defaulting with a clear difference between those two countries are interest rates”
In growing economies, all nominal quantities (national debt, GDP, stock market) constantly hit all-time high records, so the absolute level of debt is less informative than the ratio of debt to some other economically relevant quantity.
“in growing economies all of these numbers will hit alltime high records all the time meaning if we would look at us GDP hits as a total size number as a flow number US GDP constantly hits all-time high numbers and every time we have growth it grows by another one or two% then becomes an even bigger number the same is true for the stock market in a growing economy the stock market will constantly hit new records”
Debt sustainability depends on four main mechanisms: growth (best outcome—'getting a second job'), austerity (counterproductive after a certain point), financial repression (requires deceiving creditors and distorting the system), and default/restructuring (worst outcome); among these, growth is most important because it affects the denominator of debt-to-GDP.
“there's four ways to deal with excessive debt the best ways to grow out of it the equivalent for an individual of getting a second job and paying off the credit cards and being able to maintain the standard of living if you can't do that you can opt for austerity but we have found that after a certain point austerity becomes counterproductive the third is financial repression but that requires you to fool a lot of people for a lot of the time and distort your system and the fourth is an outright restructuring or default”
Population growth and economic growth have had important historical synergies: GDP growth includes growth from population increase, so population decline removes a 'free' source of GDP growth that previously offset debt accumulation.
“historically I do think that population growth and economic growth have had important synergies and first of all GDP itself because it's GDP per capita times capita if you just have population growth you get part of your GDP growth for free right”
The US has never defaulted on its debt, which establishes historical precedent that makes investors willing to lend at favorable rates; however, this precedent is now contingent on the absence of primary deficits, which are currently present.
“if you look historically the US has always in periods of where had borrowed a tremendous amount run primary surpluses and paid it back and I think that's the reason we can still borrow at the rates we are borrowing at because to First approximation we've never defaulted”
The US faces a demographic problem similar to other Western and Eastern countries, with declining population growth reducing potential GDP growth; historically, immigration could solve this, but current immigration policy is restrictive.
“we have a demographic problem on our hands as all Western countries to and actually also Eastern countries and then add to that our current issues with immigration I mean historically I would have said okay big deal America has a demographic problem but we we can easily solve That We're a nation of immigrants the extent to which we walk back on that then you really wonder where's the economic growth going to come from”
Interest rates in Japan may not stay low indefinitely; if they rise substantially during debt rollover, Japan's debt situation could deteriorate significantly, creating a 'sustainability trap' where the sustainability itself depends on interest rates that may not persist.
“suppose that for what whatever reason interest rates in Japan would go up substantially Japan will have to roll over that debt at those new rates and that might lead to a different situation”
Geopolitical fragmentation (the shift from a unified global system to one with regional 'little pipes') is increasing the equilibrium inflation rate because supply chains are becoming less commercial in design and more influenced by national security considerations rather than pure efficiency.
“secondly the jaop politic we talked about is fragmenting the system Supply chains are increasingly becoming less commercial in design they are being influenced by natural security consideration”
The US government faces significant geopolitical challenges requiring large military investments in AI, drones, and advanced weaponry; these investments may be necessary for national security and competitiveness in an AI-driven arms race, though they further complicate the fiscal situation.
“the future of warfare and of international stability from that point of view has changed marketly since the introduction of AI and the use of drones in combination with AI and I do therefore think that the US is in some sense in an arms race with many other countries and the question is can the US win that arms raise”
The positive externalities of transformational technologies tend to be taken for granted and not appreciated fully; people often focus on negative risks without recognizing that current living standards are products of past technological progress.
“we take the positive for granted and we don't realize wait a minute the lives we Le are all result of this”
Why government cannot claim or directly access private sector wealth as a measure of national assets: while wealth-to-debt ratios are theoretically correct, in practice the private sector wealth can 'go away' or relocate to other countries, as has happened in many developing economies, making the calculation unreliable.
“and the argument for not doing that is ultimately the government cannot claim the wealth of the private sector the wealth of the private sector has a way of going away going elsewhere as lots of developing countries have tried so that's why people say yes in theory that's correct but in practice is it really right”
Bond markets have learned from both Japan's experience with managing high debt-to-GDP ratios and the Federal Reserve's quantitative easing (which purchased approximately $9 trillion in government bonds and mortgages), suggesting that central bank support for debt markets is possible and may happen again.
“the Bond markets also learned from Japan Japan went a debt to GDP that was enormous and somehow continued to manage it the market has also learned from quantitative easing the notion that you can have a central bank that comes in and buys up to 9 trillion of government bonds and mortgages”
US fiscal deficits of 6-7% of GDP during periods when unemployment is at 4% or below are historically unprecedented and unthinkable, as economic convention dictates running surpluses ('fixing the roof when it's sunny') during good economic times.
“it would have been Unthinkable for the United States to go 30 straight months with the unemployment rate at 4% or below and yet we have a fiscal deficit of six to 7% of GDP that combination would have been Unthinkable to use John Kennedy's words that ECB president lagard likes to mention you fix the roof when it's sunny when unemployment rate is so low the economy is sunny you're not supposed to run large fiscal deficits”
AI and modern technology create an 80/20 risk-benefit profile: 80% positive applications (productivity, innovation) and 20% negative applications (non-state actor weapons acquisition, enabling terrorism); most innovation-focused actors emphasize the 80% while European regulators are obsessed with managing the 20%.
“these Innovations and especially AI has 80% that's good and 20% that's bad and the 20% that bad certainly includes enabling non-state actors to acquire weapons that otherwise they wouldn't be able to acquire and small drones and the like so typically when you go to those involved in the Innovation they say guys you're looking at 8020 the whole focus is on the 80 we will do good go to Europe and face them with an 8020 they'll be obsessed with the 20”
Historical transformational technologies (steam engine, automobile) were initially criticized for potential harms, but those harms were managed over time through regulation and adaptation; the same learning process will likely apply to AI.
“if you look back and I'm sure you have if you look at the steam engine if you look at the car there was always the that this was going to create harm in this and we've learned over time to get the ad20 right now I'm hoping the same thing”
Japan maintains low interest rates on its 250% debt-to-GDP ratio because historically the country benefited from very low or zero interest rates for approximately 20 years, during which time the debt was rolled over at minimal cost.
“Japan has an incredibly High one of the highest debt to GDP ratios in the world but of course everybody also knows that interest rates are absolutely un precedented low levels for a very long time in Japan now recently they've come up a tiny little bit maybe by a percentage point or so and the interest rates were essentially at zero for a 20y year period before that”
The transition from deficient aggregate demand to deficient aggregate supply is a fundamental shift that increases the equilibrium inflation rate from the 2% central bank target to approximately 2.5-3%, because supply constraints are more durable than demand fluctuations.
“if central banks could revise their inflation targets which are all anchored on 2% they would choose a higher equilibrium inflation rate that they would choose closer to two and a half to three why first thing is because we're no longer living in a world of deficient aggregate demand we're living in a world of deficient aggregate supply”
Berk is less optimistic than El-Erian because he is concerned that unless government puts in place policies to increase productivity (like policy support for AI and technology development), the next generation will face the problems El-Erian warned about
“let me just say that I don't completely share that optimism I agree we are leaving the Next Generation with a problem but unless the government is prepared to think about putting in place policies that are going to increase our I mean it'd be great if AI works out and of course if AI works out we're fine it does seems a little bit too good to be true”
El-Erian is less pessimistic about growth than Burbank and van Binsbergen because he believes there are transformational innovations (AI, life sciences, sustainable energy) and sectoral adjustments (healthcare, defense, food security) that could accelerate growth over a 3-5 year horizon, even if not in the next 12 months.
“I used to be pessimist I must say I'm less so today... there are things that will move the needle in a significant way over a three to five year Horizon... above you've got three massive transformational enabling Innovation... technology and particularly Ai and a different type I'm talking about life sciences and I'm talking about sustainable energy and then from below you have certain sectors that historically have had massive positive externalities that are being forced to adjust think of Health Care think of Defense think of food security”
The economic paradigm that governed post-WWII Western growth—Washington Consensus emphasizing liberalization, deregulation, and fiscal prudence—has been replaced by a new paradigm emphasizing protectionism, industrial policy, and fiscal responsibility (rather than prudence).
“when I grew up life was easy the domestic policy stance was governed by the Washington consensus in order to grow in a sustainable fashion you needed liberalization deregulation and financial prudence today liberalization has been replaced by protectionism and deregulation is being replaced by industrial policy and fiscal Prudence is being replaced by fiscal responsibility”
Only one economic system (the Washington Consensus) has actually worked, and all other systems have failed; the current shift away from those principles is concerning because there is no proven alternative
“only one system works all the other systems fail and that system worked for us very very well there is no other system”
Barring major policy or technology changes, demography will be a significant structural constraint on growth; however, governments and markets may not fully understand the interaction between population dynamics and debt sustainability, but markets themselves appear to understand this dynamic implicitly.
“the big question is to what extent do population Dynamics interact with indust trade Dynamics and that cuts to maybe as economists we don't fully understand what's going on but the market itself understands that Japan is able to keep borrowing at very low interest rates because somehow the market understands these Dynamics”
The ratio of national debt to the value of the residential housing stock has remained relatively flat since 1975, further supporting the view that debt growth is proportional to wealth accumulation.
“if I do the same thing with national thatb to say the value of the residential housing stock you're going to get that the numbers look pretty flat it doesn't look that alarming at all in terms of how much the debt of the United States has increased”
When governments ran large deficits in response to crises (wars), there was a common understanding that the deficits were temporary and would be reversed; currently, pandemic-driven spending increases are understood as justified but without any common understanding that reversal is necessary, creating a permanent higher debt level with continued climbing.
“when we had an explosion in debt and spending and fiscal deficit it was understood that it was justified but that we will need to reverse it over time this time most of the explosion that happened in response to the pandemic were seen to be Justified but there was no common understanding that it needs to be reversed so you settle at the much higher debt level and then you keep on climbing from there”
No country is challenging the US at the core of the global financial system, but countries are building 'little pipes' of alternative payment and settlement infrastructure that fragment the system without replacing it
“what's happening right now is no one is challenging the us at the core of the system but they're building little pipes these little pipes fragment the system but don't completely replace the US”
Herbstein's principle that 'what is unsustainable will prove unsustainable' is qualified by two key considerations: the time frame over which unsustainability manifests, and the need to evaluate sustainability comparatively (relative to other countries) rather than absolutely.
“I also understand the concern that herbstein famously summarized by saying what is unsustainable will prove unsustainable there are two qualifications one is the time frame and the other one is the relative comparison not the absolute one”
The US has run large fiscal deficits despite not being in a traditional war, which is historically unprecedented; the analogy of 'war without war' captures this anomaly, though technically the US is involved in proxy wars.
“I mean let's just say the following that I think what we've seen in the United States in the last few years is something we've never seen before we've seen deficits huge deficits but they all is associated with war it's like we've had a war without the war”
Although there is currently no political path to primary fiscal surpluses in the US, bond markets believe there is sufficient time to find such a path in the future, which is why they are not yet pricing in fiscal risk despite the current deficit dynamics.
“most people in the market would agree with you that as yet there is no path to primary surpluses there is no path to turning the thatb dynamic but they say we have time to find that path so that's the way the markets are thinking right now some feel that that is complacent others feel that that is realistic”
The UK government has adopted growth as an explicit mission, attempting to release constraints (e.g., planning rules, supply) while simultaneously enhancing growth drivers, representing a conscious policy shift toward growth-maximization.
“take the UK government as an example they've been stuck in a low productivity low growth equilibrium and the incoming new government has put growth as a mission and there's two elements to the mission the first that could release the braks take off the constraints on current obstacles to growth for example planning rules and trying to increase the supply s and then there are the future drivers of growth”
Supply chains and supply-side economics have not received sufficient policy attention post-pandemic; this represents a missed opportunity to learn from pandemic-era adaptive capacity and public-private partnerships that proved effective.
“Supply Changers I completely agree and you would have thought after the pandemic they would have said wait a minute look what happened”
El-Erian characterizes the growth trajectory as 'a bumpy journey to a better destination,' contingent on whether governments can navigate the path without pursuing 'irresponsible Sprint for growth' that would cause subsequent collapse.
“I have this notion we're on a very bumpy journey to a better destination as long as we can navigate the journey... yes there is nothing that's going to move the growth needle in a significant way in the next 12 months unless it's irresponsible Sprint for growth that will end up in tears”
US national debt has been on an upward trajectory since Independence, reaching $34 trillion in 2024, representing one of the highest levels ever recorded.
“we're currently hitting a level of $34 trillion in debt and that one of the highest numbers that we've ever seen for you as debt”