YouTube10m· Feb 2018· cataloged

Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in the workforce & treatment


What this covers

This is a ten-minute excerpt from Jordan Peterson's 2017 Maps of Meaning lecture series, repackaged by the Essential Truth channel. It runs in two loosely connected halves. The first treats video games and one-sided pursuits as a way into how fragments of meaning combine, and why a game tuned to keep a player at the edge of exploration is not a stable way to live. The second turns to treating depression, in particular among guilt-ridden men who resist taking medication. The recording does not identify any questioner, so it is effectively one voice lecturing and answering.

The range is wider than the title suggests. Peterson sketches an evolutionary argument built on the Baldwin effect: as societies stabilize through contracts, conscientiousness pays off and is selected for, which stabilizes society further. He extends this to the spread of a meme and to the survival of religious hero stories, a move the extracted statements flag as contested. A related thread concerns delay of gratification, which he treats as a rational bargain that only makes sense when the future is predictable. He also describes confession and psychotherapy as ways of making past errors conscious so the conscience can guide better. He adds that the conscience is fallible and has to be trained.

The treatment half is the most practical. Peterson separates a terrible life from clinical depression and suggests this muddle partly explains the weak trial evidence for the antidepressant. He compares medication to insulin for diabetes, says a month is enough to judge whether a drug works, and describes spending two years persuading reluctant clients to try one. He still insists that treatment should look across friendships, intimate relationships, work, leisure, substance use, sleep and eating. He also holds that lying damages the nervous system's ability to give reliable signals, so truth and courage are the working virtues for bearing a life he calls inherently tragic.

Sharpest takeaway

Speaker argues that virtue—particularly truth-telling and courage—is the practical foundation for psychological health and navigating life's suffering, while acknowledging that medical interventions like antidepressants can be necessary tools when combined with behavioral change.

  • Lying corrupts your neurological structure and warps your sense of meaning, making it unreliable as a guide
  • Virtue (truth, courage) enables you to bear suffering without becoming corrupt and is deeply practical
  • Antidepressants can be miraculous for people whose lives are otherwise in order, but require multidimensional behavioral analysis alongside medical treatment

The claims · ranked24 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.69

Confession (or psychotherapy) functions as a technique for making conscious the stupid and miserable things you have done, which prevents you from repeating them and allows you to rely more on your conscience as a guide to proper action.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“this is this is partly why people go to confession right which is mud which is like I said a psycho therapeutic technique it's like okay what stupid miserable wretched things did I do this week that's a good thing to to make conscious right because maybe you cannot do the the next week”

0.69

As societies stabilize through contractual relationships, conscientiousness becomes more useful and individuals become more likely to be selected for high conscientiousness, which in turn further stabilizes society—this is an example of a Baldwin effect.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“what happens as you stabilize societies being conscientious conscientious becomes more useful and so then you're going to be selected for as a consequence of being conscientious and that's going to stabilise the society even more these are these are roughly known as Baldwin effects so that's where let's call it a genetic transformation produces a behavioral transformation that transforms the environment so the genetic transformation is more likely to propagate”

0.68

A life is inherently a tragedy, and no one's life is fully fine—this is a universal human condition rather than a pathology.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“sometimes people are depressed their life is just it isn't fine because no one's life is fine everyone's life is a tragedy”

0.63

Medical interventions for depression should be pursued if you are sick, and you should use everything at your disposal including medications, but some antidepressants can be absolutely miraculous, especially for people whose lives are otherwise together.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“ok so the first thing I would say is don't underestimate the utility of medical interventions depression is a catastrophe it carries with it a very high suicide rate and it also levels people out and it's really hard on their families and so and it and it's physiologically extraordinarily damaging and so if you're in a depressive state and it's severe you can try an antidepressant you'll know in a month if it works if it works well”

0.63

Antidepressant use should not be compared to weakness or moral failure; it is pragmatic to use them as a tool just as one would use insulin for diabetes, and the speaker uses this analogy to persuade reluctant clients.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“but you know I say well look man what if you had diabetes you're not gonna take your insulin it's like you got stressed you blew out it your weakest point that's what happens when you get stressed if there's something out there that might help you it's like try it for God's sake you'll know in a month and you just stop if it doesn't work”

0.62

A meme (idea) spreading through a culture can manifest itself genetically: if an idea tilts the culture such that those holding that idea are more likely to be successful, then the meme and the biology will align themselves across time and selection will favor that behavioral/genetic pattern.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“that's that's also how in some sense a meme can be turned into a genetic can manifest itself genetically so if you have an idea that spreads through the culture and it tilts the culture in a certain way such that those who hold that idea are likely to be more successful than the meme and the biology will align themselves across time”

0.59

The conscience is not an unerring guide (illustrated by Pinocchio), and it has to learn through being pushed into new situations and through differentiation, which requires both courage and truth.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“in the pinocchio story is that the conscience was not an unerring guide for Pinocchio it had to learn and so and so it's also partly pushing yourself into new situations and differentiating yourself so that you get wiser and and so it's courage as well as truth”

0.59

A Baldwin effect is a process where behavioral change produces environmental transformation that creates selection pressure for genetic change, enabling rapid evolutionary movements when such feedback loops develop.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“let's call it a genetic transformation produces a behavioral transformation that transforms the environment so the genetic transformation is more likely to propagate you can get unbelievably rapid evolutionary movements when when you get a loop like that developing”

0.59

Sometimes people whose lives are quite well-ordered (with friends, intimate relationships, good careers, and who work hard with minimal self-deception) are still severely depressed, and antidepressants can fix this, which justifies their use.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“sometimes people are depressed their life is just it isn't fine because no one's life is fine everyone's life is a tragedy but sometimes people have their lives in order as much as you could expect anyone to have they have friends they have an intimate relationship they have a career that they like you know they're they're qualified industrious people working hard on what they're doing and and and really playing a minimum number of games with themselves and they're terribly depressed antidepressant man that's sometimes that will just fix it and so hooray”

0.59

Delaying gratification is only a useful strategy if the social structure is stable, because you are making a bargain with the future that everyone will continue acting as they do now; if the future becomes uncertain, people rationally abandon delayed gratification.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“you can only delay you can only delay gratification intelligently though if the social structure is stable right because basically what if you delay gratification you're making a bargain with the potential future and the bargain is everybody's going to keep acting the same way so that the future is the same as the present because otherwise you'll delay gratification and then everything fall apart”

0.56

One can fall prey to pathological senses of meaning by engaging in one-sided pursuits, and the antidote is not to lie—because lying corrupts your neurological structure and prevents your nervous system from reading out reliable internal signals.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“you can get pulled down rabbit holes of all sorts that that are one-sided pursuits of meaning so and it's time something we're actually going to talk about as the later class is unfold the question is how do you stop yourself from falling prey to a pathologist sense of meaning and I think one of the answers to that is don't lie”

0.55

Proper treatment of depression requires multidimensional analysis across behavioral and life domains: social connections, intimate relationships, career/education, meaningful leisure, substance use, and sleep/eating—each domain where behavioral intervention is possible should be addressed alongside medication if warranted.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“now having said that you want to do a multi-dimensional analysis it's like well do you have any friends do you have an intimate relationship or are you pursuing one do you have a reasonable career are you as educated as you are intelligent do you have something useful to do with your time outside of work do you have a drug or alcohol problem are there other behavioral issues like sleep dysregulation and lack of eating that are contributing to the pathology you want to differentiate all of that and wherever you can make a behavioral intervention so much the better”

0.52

Religious stories have propagated themselves partly because as the idea of the hero becomes clearer and manifests itself more clearly in society, more rewards accrue to hero-like behavior, creating positive selection pressures that align behavior with the narrative and create an upward loop.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“that's that's also how in some sense a meme can be turned into a genetic can manifest itself genetically so if you have an idea that spreads through the culture and it tilts the culture in a certain way such that those who hold that idea are likely to be more successful than the meme and the biology will align themselves across time and and well I think you see that happening that's that to some degree that's what's happened as religious stories have propagated themselves as well because as as the idea of the hero becomes clearer so to speak and then it manifests itself more clearly in the society then there's more rewards for doing it then the selection pressures get more positively related to that kind of behavior and the whole thing loops upwards”

0.52

The fundamental virtues are truth and courage, and the answer to 'why be virtuous' is practical: so that you can bear the suffering of life without becoming corrupt.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“there's more beauty courage truth you know the fundamental virtues why be virtuous that's the question and so that you can bear the suffering of life without becoming corrupt right it's practical its practical and there's nothing more practical than that”

0.50

You can determine if an antidepressant is working for you within one month of starting it, and you can stop if it doesn't work—this short-term testability makes it reasonable to try antidepressants without committing to them long-term.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“if you're in a depressive state and it's severe you can try an antidepressant you'll know in a month if it works if it works well”

0.50

You cannot know how to speak the truth, but you can know how not to lie, and you should define lies for yourself (not let others define them) and avoid uttering falsehoods because doing so warps your neurological structure.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“I shouldn't say that because you don't know how to speak the truth but you do know how not to lie and it's a game you're playing with yourself you can define the damn lies no one else has to do that for you you you try not to utter falsehoods because you warp your neurological structure by doing so”

0.48

Clinical evidence for antidepressants appears weak partly because the diagnosis of depression is poorly formulated; it is very different to have a terrible life than to be clinically depressed, and antidepressants can only help so much if your life circumstances are the actual problem.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“so you know when you hear about the clinical evidence in their favor being iffy and that's partly because the diagnosis of depression isn't very well formulated there's it's very different to have a terrible life than to be depressed and antidepressants can only help you so much if you have a terrible life”

0.45

If you rely on your sense of meaning to guide you and you have polluted that mechanism through deception or omission, it will run you right off a cliff—therefore there is a moral element to maintaining the integrity of your guidance mechanism.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“and then your sense of meaning will lead you astray so like one of the reasons for speaking the truth... you warp your neurological structure by doing so and then it will read out pathologically and then if you rely on it to guide you it will run you right off a cliff so that's where there's a moral element to this is if you're going to rely on your sense of meaning make sure that you don't pollute the mechanism”

0.45

The ultimate sense of meaning is composed of the union of fragmentary senses of meaning, which can be overwhelmingly powerful (anger, sexual lust, etc.) and are often deliberately calibrated in video games to keep players on the edge of exploration.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“you could say that the ultimate sense of meaning is composed of the union of fragmentary senses of meaning and the fragmentary sensitive meaning can be overwhelmingly powerful anger sexual lust and and and the sorts of things that you experience wouldn't say when you're playing a video game which are very carefully calibrated to keep you on the on the edge of exploration”

0.45

Many people take antidepressants only after serious consideration, not casually; the speaker spends two years trying to convince depressed clients to try antidepressants because they feel guilty about using an external crutch.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“you know people you hear everyone takes antidepressants you know everyone's taking them just like no one takes those bloody things without serious consideration half the time I spend with my clients who are depressed is often the two years long attempt to get them to tentatively try an antidepressant because they're so guilty that they're relying on an external crutch to sort out their lives that they can't even tolerate it”

0.40

Playing 50 hours of video games per week is not a stable solution for you, your family, or society because it is too one-sided and neglects other important life domains.

normativeestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“50 hours a week probably not unless you're gonna go pro right because there's other things you need to be attending to it's not a stable solution for you your family your society it's too one-sided”

0.37

Depression is a catastrophe that carries a very high suicide rate, levels people out psychologically, is damaging to families, and is physiologically extraordinarily harmful.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“depression is a catastrophe it carries with it a very high suicide rate and it also levels people out and it's really hard on their families and so and it and it's physiologically extraordinarily damaging”

0.32

Sometimes people's lives are so wrecked that they don't even know where to start with behavioral intervention, which complicates treatment planning.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“but sometimes too you're dealing with people whose lives are so wrecked that they don't even know where to start”

0.24

Children who could delay gratification at an early stage showed better outcomes later in life, though this relationship's strength depends on IQ and other controlled variables.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: Video games, guilt-ridden depressed men in… [i8FudntXfR8]

“the kids who could delay gratification at an early stage we're doing quite a bit better later in life now I don't know to what degree that was controlled for IQ because such things matter”