
Thomas Hazlett on Apple vs. Google 10/25/2010
What this covers
Russ Roberts talks with Thomas Hazlett of George Mason University, drawing on Hazlett's Financial Times article, about the 2010 rivalry between Apple and Google. The usual story says Steve Jobs is repeating his old mistake. In 1985 Bill Gates urged him to license Apple's graphical operating system, Jobs refused, and the company nearly died in the 1990s. Meanwhile Google's open Android is praised. Hazlett goes back through computing history to complicate this. Microsoft won by taking the horizontal platform slice and partnering with thousands of firms. The industry's break from IBM-style vertical integration came from standardized interfaces, he says, not from antitrust or regulation.
The range is wide. AOL's mailed sign-up disks brought over 40 million households online in 1996, and its walled garden later collapsed as outside content grew. Japan's NTT DoCoMo, by contrast, kept strict content rules and took nine or ten percent of content revenue. Google's search-and-ads business is a two-sided market whose profits finance its fast move into smartphones. Hazlett cites Thomas Sowell on experts despising mass-market products, and treats Apple purchases as consumer signaling, much like cars or clothing.
The more contested turns come later. Hazlett says Hayek never opposed planning, only asked who plans. He calls the end-to-end principle an optical illusion, criticizes network neutrality rules, and denies that the internet was a DARPA blueprint. He also judges the Microsoft antitrust case comically unimportant in hindsight. His regulatory advice is to stick to consumer-welfare antitrust. The conversation closes on app-based access through Facebook and Twitter and what it means for Google.
Hazlett argues that Apple's closed platform and Google's open Android are competing business models whose success depends on unpredictable market dynamics, so casting one as capitalist and the other as anti-capitalist misreads how creative destruction works.
- The standard open-versus-closed framing misses that both firms pursue vertical control or ecosystem strategies that are judged by market outcomes, not ideology.
- Competition between business models is a discovery process, and the winning structure changes over time (Microsoft's licensing, Apple's near-collapse, its later dominance).
- Regulators should be cautious and limit intervention to consumer-welfare antitrust, because micromanaging competitive structures suppresses dynamic efficiency.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
In any mass consumer market, experts in the field despise the mass-market product, as Thomas Sowell observed about photography enthusiasts who hated Kodak not because of its quality but because they thought using it said something bad about them.
“in any mass consumer market the experts in the field despise the mass-market product”
The computer industry's shift from vertically integrated firms like IBM to disintegrated chip makers, box makers, operating systems and application software was a natural market response to the desktop microcomputer, not the result of antitrust or regulation.
“that's not because of antitrust it's not because of regulation it's a very natural process where the you know the economies of the marketplace demanded vertical integration”
In 1996, AOL's sign-up disks, mailed in enormous numbers, brought over 40 million households online quickly, because no technical skill was needed, and AOL became the dominant gateway for mainstream users rather than the browser.
“1996 was called the year of the carpet bombing when they dropped 250 million the sign of disks”
Vertical disintegration was not caused by antitrust or regulation; it occurred naturally when standardized interfaces allowed coordination without common ownership, so the market could create entire ecosystems.
“the technologies grew more powerful you actually got the ability for standardization of interfaces to to to be created and for coordination to exist without ownership”
In 1985 Bill Gates flew to Cupertino and urged Apple to license its graphical user interface operating system to hardware partners like HP and IBM, but Steve Jobs rejected this and kept vertical control, a choice that nearly destroyed Apple in the 1990s.
“he tried to talk Apple and Steve Jobs in particular into basically going the licensing route on the operating system”
Japan's NTT DoCoMo wireless walled garden in 1999-2000 became the most successful mobile data model, with carriers setting strict content rules, handling billing and taking nine or ten percent of content-provider revenues.
“they take you know nine or ten percent of the revenues you know from from the content providers and do all the billing”
People attach emotional and identity meaning to brands like Apple, treating the purchase as a signal of who they are, which is similar to how people use cars, homes and clothing as status signals.
“we use these consumer products to signal you know whether it's where we live the house we buy the car we drive”
Calling Apple anti-capitalist for controlling its ecosystem fails to see creative destruction and competition not just between products but between modes of production, where rival structures compete to offer consumers value through an innovative discovery process.
“it just really fails to see what what Jean Pater and and the great philosophers of capitalism have talked about in terms of creative destruction and the competition not just between products or services but between modes of production”
People use consumer products as social signals about where they live, what they drive, and what they wear, and the incentive structure and old human instincts are the same as they always were, even with new technology.
“we use these consumer products to signal you know whether it's where we live the house we buy the car we drive”
Walled gardens are effective because they give platform builders an incentive to make massive investments in mass-market access, and consumers gain from the easy entry, so new walled gardens keep being created.
“that walled garden was extremely effective and new walled gardens are being created all the time”
Whether an approach succeeds depends on unpredictable gales of creative destruction, and the innovation is unpredictable in any epoch, but part of that innovation is the market structure itself, so Apple's strategy competes with other market structures rather than a fixed ideal.
“part of that innovation is the market structure and so what Apple is doing now is competing of course with other market structures”
Hayek never opposed planning; the real question is who plans, and competition pits islands of control and planning against each other, so Apple's top-down control is a form of planning that competes with Google's approach.
“Hayek was never against planning it's the question of who plans”
The end-to-end principle of an open internet with control only at the edges is an optical illusion: substantial control and integration happen in the network core, and the core incentivizes standardization while pushing innovation to edge applications.
“the idea that networks are open end to end there's only control at the edges of the network that's in some sense an optical illusion there is a lot of control that takes place in the core”
Competition between business models is an innovative discovery process in which rival structures offer consumers value, and the competitive watching of this process is itself fascinating to observe.
“offer consumers value in a very innovative discovery process”
Google's search-plus-ad model is a two-sided market, in which free access for users is paired with selling user attention to advertisers, the same pattern seen earlier in newspapers and broadcasting.
“they have exploited a two-sided model we've seen many of these models before certainly in the newspaper business or the the broadcasting business you build an audience and you sell the audience to advertisers”
Microsoft's decentralized platform strategy of taking on thousands of hardware and software partners allowed it to dominate the PC market, and Microsoft was fanatical about partnering, occupying the profitable horizontal platform slice of the vertical stack.
“they take on thousands of partners in the sense of opening their system to the computers the boxes underneath them”
AOL's walled garden was an effective way to bring tens of millions of households online with easy-to-use sign-up discs and to justify subscription fees, but as outside content grew, AOL had to open access and its walled-garden model collapsed under its own weight.
“the walled garden just collapsed of its own weight”
Google's ability to respond quickly to the smartphone revolution is financed by its very profitable advertising business, which creates incentives to direct resources into new innovations.
“its funding this enormous ability of Google to very quickly respond to you know the smartphone revolution”
The Microsoft antitrust case was comically unimportant in hindsight because it failed to foresee the evolution of Google and Apple, and the 1998 Justice Department suit cited an exclusive deal between Internet Explorer and CBS Sports as an anticompetitive harm.
“it seems so comically unimportant because it did not foresee the evolution of Google and now Apple”
Network neutrality rules that restrict innovation to the edge of the network ignore the significant control, integration and innovation that happens in the network core, such as Google's integration with core networks and Akamai's speed-up services.
“there is a lot of control that takes place in the core and lots of integration that takes place that's not so visible but very productive”
Whether a given strategy wins depends on serendipity, timing, luck and what consumers want, and none of these can be known in advance, so a combination of assets that succeeds in one era can fail in another.
“sometimes it's glorious and sometimes it's disaster as you say depending on the serendipity depending on the timing depending on luck”
The Internet is largely deregulated, and the Internet was not a government blueprint from DARPA, since the modern network of networks emerged from products, chips, software and wireless developed by private firms.
“you really have a largely deregulated environment where economic forces have had very wide play”
Regulators should be circumspect, keep interventions general, limit themselves to antitrust under the consumer welfare standard, and respect dynamic efficiencies, because trying to micromanage the direction of competition destroys the productive experimentation that markets generate.
“the regulator should be very circumspect as to their interventions and they should try to be as general as possible”
The ARPANET/DARPA network contributed useful inputs to modern networks, but the network of networks today was not master-crafted on a Defense Department blueprint, nor designed to withstand nuclear attack.
“they were not master crafted on some blueprint that was developed by the Department of Defense”
Competition for fixed voice came through a vertical, non-neutral structure, showing that healthy capitalism generates business-structure experimentation that does not conform to the 'open architecture' ideal.
“competition is coming to the market through that vertical structure that is highly non neutral”
Google acquired a mobile operating system for reportedly up to $50 million, modified it, and released it as Android, licensing it to hardware makers without a dollar payment while taking its own roughly 30% cut of its application store and imposing terms on partners.
“they reportedly paid up to 50 million dollars for and they tweak that extend and revise and put that out call it Android”
Network neutrality rules that allow only edge innovation would prohibit beneficial integration such as Google's integration with core networks and Akamai's speed-up services, and calling vertical integration sacrilege is a religious belief rather than an economic conclusion.
“any religion that tells you that the you know that that is a that is a sacrilege should be re-examined”
Over 90% of U.S. households could choose between a cable operator and a phone company for fixed voice service, because cable operators carved out reserved capacity on their networks for high-quality voice, which was a vertically integrated and non-neutral arrangement that produced real competition.
“more than ninety percent of US households now get to choose between two fixed operators one the cable company one the phone company”
The internet is largely deregulated, with economic forces playing out widely; the common mistake is to attribute market outcomes to public policy, such as thinking the internet was a government project from DARPA.
“you really have a largely deregulated environment where economic forces have had very wide play”
Google's search engine monetizes internet traffic through an efficient advertising model in which it aggregates millions of small transactions, which is why it is notoriously hungry for new applications that drive search traffic.
“Google has an extremely efficient advertising model and Google is notoriously hungry for new applications that can drive traffic through its search engine”
Google's search-advertising franchise is driven by a two-sided model: it gives away its search engine to users without payment and sells the resulting eyeball traffic to advertisers, with over 90 percent of revenue coming from search despite more than 150 applications.
“they're all dependent on the search essentially all dependent on the search engine for the revenue massive majority of the you know well over 90% of the the revenues are driven by search”
The 1998 Justice Department suit against Microsoft cited an exclusive deal between Internet Explorer and the CBS Sports online site as an anticompetitive practice, which Hazlett finds absurd because CBS Sports was not a dominant player.
“one of the anti-competitive deals was an exclusive between Internet Explorer and the CBS Sports online site”
Apple earns money primarily from selling hardware, extending the device with iPods, iPhones and iPads and then making money on apps and music, while Google is essentially a services and search company with over 90% of its revenues driven by search.
“well over 90% of the the revenues are driven by search”
Apple's vertical control has served it well at different points in time, so what once nearly killed Apple now lets it soar, because market structure is itself part of the innovation that competes.
“what would almost killed Apple 20 or so years ago is now allowing Apple to soar”
The standard view criticizes Apple for running a closed platform and praises Google for openness, but this framing misses the point because both firms are competing business models whose structures are judged by market outcomes.
“the standard view of Google and Apple's business strategies misses the point the standard view is critical of Apple for being a closed system and praises Google for its openness”
Apple is fighting the trend toward vertical disintegration even as it uses competitive suppliers, buying chips and parts from the market while still controlling how the parts are assembled and making sure its own purchases end up in its products.
“Apple is still in many respects fighting that trend now Apple does have a lot less vertical integration”
Criticizing a company's controlling nature as making its products immoral is a bizarre idea, because the same logic would say private property owners should not control their property; Hazlett compares this to his blog where comments are unedited but he retains the right to control the space.
“it's like saying you know in my backyard you should be free to saunter by and eat the hot dogs I'm grilling”
The strongest economic argument against micromanaging is that competitive outcomes are unpredictable, and what looks like a success or failure depends on luck, timing and consumer demand, so regulators cannot identify the winning structure in advance.
“you don't know any of those things in advance”
Apple's current success stems from Steve Jobs's control-freak perfectionism, which produces stunningly great products now, and there is no reason Jobs would not thrive as head of Google, just as Google's leaders would do well at Apple.
“I think that that's related to two jobs as control freak nature and the quality of the products he's generating now”
Framing Apple and Google as good guys versus bad guys is misleading, because they have different strategies and products, and both face image and business-cost problems that come with making money.
“it's really misleading to think of it as the good guys versus the bad guys”
The 'closed versus open' contrast is a misleading spin: when you dig below the surface, Apple controls certain aspects of its environment more than Google does, but Google also exercises control through its terms and conditions, so the contrast is one of degree, not of capitalist versus anti-capitalist.
“to call one open and one closed puts a spin on it that makes some sense there's a certainly a German truth or more in saying Apple is is controlling certain aspects of their environment more than Google might”
Google's Android is not as open as it appears, because Google sets conditions for hardware makers and app developers and takes a revenue cut, so its openness is a strategic choice to gain market share rather than a philosophical commitment.
“Google's idea is just get market share get this stuff out there make it good software make it free”
The browser competition between Netscape Navigator and Microsoft's Internet Explorer drove mass adoption of the web in the 1990s, and the 1998 Justice Department case was largely about whether the browser would control internet traffic.
“there was this battle for dominance through the browser and and that drove massive adoption”
The IBM antitrust case, filed on the last day of the Johnson administration in 1969 and dropped by the Reagan administration in January 1982, lasted about 13 years without reaching a final ruling, and by then IBM had lost its dominance.
“the IBM famous an IBM antitrust case was filed on the last day of the Johnson administration in 1969 and then dropped”
The browser war between Netscape and Internet Explorer drove mass Internet adoption, but America Online's sign-up-disc campaign brought tens of millions of households online, shifting where users actually went.
“there was this battle for dominance through the browser and and that drove massive adoption”
Chris Anderson's Wired article 'The Web Is Dead' argues that users are moving to self-contained platforms like Facebook and Twitter, where they spend time without browsing the open web, which is a 'one-stop shopping' shift.
“the thesis is that clear but you know on the parts of it that makes sense there are more platforms coming at us”
Google's privacy approach was a disaster, with its Buzz launch a few months before this episode being an obvious mistake that the company quickly retraced, and such costs are inevitable for firms making money online.
“Google has made some you know just in hindsight obvious mistakes the approach they had to buzz just a few months ago was a disaster”
Apple's Mac in 1985 was a superior graphical-interface operating system whose strategy, not just its product, was what Microsoft later copied, and Microsoft's Excel spreadsheet, not DOS or Windows, was its first money-maker on the graphical interface.
“the money maker at Microsoft in those early days wasn't it was not the das operating system it was their their first killer application which was the Excel spreadsheet”
Television broadcasting was shaped by a spectrum allocation process that created regulatory interventions which have stayed in place for about 60 years, showing that regulatory decisions tend to be sticky.
“if you look at the television marketplace just for example and how broadcasting you know was created through the spectrum allocation process and you know has been with us well 60 years now”
Google's search engine business was thought unsolvable or unprofitable early on because web search was gamed, returning porn-site links, yet Google built a dominant franchise by innovating on search quality.
“people thought that search was really all solved 12 years ago in Google's started out it wasn't interesting or on the other side that it was never going to be a good business”
Private property and control over one's own platform are consistent with good incentives and outcomes, so people who demand free access to Hazlett's blog comment section misunderstand property rights, as with saunter by and eat the hot dogs in someone's backyard.
“this idea that somehow private property belongs to everybody web belongs to everybody it's a nice idea but it's not consistent with incentives or behavior”
Google's early search design, with a plain page without banners and very fast responses, delivered consumer value and encouraged frequent use, which is the sort of user-centered competition that builds a brand.
“they had a very bear search page they didn't bombard you with banners or lots of options you just had a very simple place to go”
Chris Anderson's Wired claim that the web is dead is misleading, because the trend toward one-stop platforms like Facebook does not threaten Google, which can integrate those platforms through acquisitions and applications like YouTube.
“I think that indeed the article seems to violate the title they say this is this has been going on for a long time”
Many developers in the tech community hold the standard critical view of Apple, but many others love its platform because Apple's vertical coordination pushes the whole ecosystem forward and delivers value to developers.
“many others love the Apple platform they love the coordination that is provided vertically by Apple”
Company leaders' success depends on their personalities, skills, and competitive environment, so Jobs would likely thrive at Google and Google's head would thrive at Apple.
“there's no reason to think Steve Jobs wouldn't thrive as the head of Google”
Apple takes about 30% of revenues generated in its App Store, and the independent developers who sell through it must accept Apple's terms and conditions, which critics read as vertical control.
“Apple takes at last report 30% of the revenues generated in the App Store”
The conventional narrative holds that Apple made a strategic blunder by staying closed, yet Apple survived with Microsoft investment and then came to dominate using the same closed strategy that had nearly failed it.
“the accepted narrative is that Apple made a marketing a strategic blunder by failing like staying with a closed system”
Google turns millions of tiny transactions in which eyeballs flow through websites and are sold to advertisers into a market capitalization of about 200 billion dollars, which Hazlett calls remarkable.
“Google really almost without a serious rival now has figured out how to take millions of tiny transactions”
More than 90 percent of Google's revenues come from search, so its other applications are all dependent on the search engine.
“well over 90% of the the revenues are driven by search”
Calling Google post-capitalist does not hold up, because the more one knows about capitalism and Google, the more Google looks like a successful capitalist enterprise.
“the more you know about capitalism and I think the more you know about Google the more you see them as a vested capitalist enterprise”
People often hold irrational but socially meaningful attachments, such as rooting for the Los Angeles Dodgers despite disliking the owners, and these allegiances are a socially acceptable place to channel irrational tendencies.
“a good place though to squirrel away your neurotic tendencies oh right better there than your car purchase”
Apple's vertical coordination delivers value to developers, while Google has had to shape its own platform and give up some of the fully laissez-faire attitude, learning from Apple's experience.
“in many respects Google is learned of course from from from the Apple experience”
At Apple, designers rather than engineers drive product decisions, and John Sculley's account of meetings where designers' entry silences the room shows a different mindset from Microsoft's engineering-led meetings.
“when the designers walk into the room everybody goes silent because they're the most important people he says that the Microsoft meeting which he was in recently there's no designers”
Japanese vertical control worked particularly well because commute times are long, so many people want handsets to deliver entertainment and applications.
“it's in particularly in Japan where commute times are long on average”
Google is now the 800-pound gorilla that will likely face legal attempts to slow it down, although Apple's growing success may partially take the pressure off.
“I just assume as their market share and success continues to grow that they will be the subject of various legal attempts”
Enthusiasts take pride in their specialized knowledge of particular gadgets or software and use that knowledge to hang identity on the products they recommend, which is a very social activity.
“they want to take pride in the fact that they know those aspects and they want to tell you”
Apple sells the iPhone on only one of the four national US networks and holds an exclusive contract with AT&T, which critics argue denies customers the benefits of competition.
“Apple only markets its iPhone for use on one of the four competing networks national networks and it has an exclusive contract with AT&T”
Google's 'don't be evil' motto is an unrealistically high standard that invites mockery, and Andy Grove's jab that Hitler did not think he was evil either shows that good intentions are not a reliable guide to behavior.
“Andy Grove is mocked it saying well you know what he says Hitler didn't think he was evil either”
Steve Jobs and Google's leaders would not necessarily swap success: a leader's success is a function of personality, skills, and the competitive environment, so Hazlett rejects the idea that the leaders are interchangeable.
“they are functions of their personalities their skills and the competitive environment they're in”
Apple does not manufacture in the United States because it is too expensive, but it closely monitors its overseas suppliers, and its attention to packaging, such as box layout and manual orientation, reflects a deliberate design sensibility.
“Apple doesn't have a factory here in the United States where Apple employees manufacture their stuff but because that's too expensive but they will monitor that process from their suppliers”
Google is doing the right thing and bringing value to society, and the profits it earns are a positive outcome of the capitalist process.
“I think they are doing the right thing and I think they're bringing value to society”
Both Apple and Google face image problems: vendors complain Google squeezes them, prices rapaciously and makes traffic hard to generate unless you pay, while Apple controls aspects of its ecosystem; these costs are inevitable when companies try to make money.
“you do hear vendors complain that they squeeze them out that they price very rapaciously”
Apple's market value in October 2010 was the highest of any publicly traded company, about $280 billion versus roughly $220 billion for Microsoft and just under $200 billion for Google.
“just checking the market caps apples about 280 billion dollars as we talked today Microsoft little under 220 billion and Google a little under 200”
Hazlett's own 1985 purchase of a classic Mac was motivated by its aesthetic appeal relative to the IBM PC's green or white-on-black screen, and the Mac's 1984 Super Bowl commercial appealed to him.
“I found the green print on the black screen that was or the white print on the black screen that was the IBM machine very unaesthetic”