YouTube32m· Nov 2023· cataloged

Ami Ayalon: The Missing Israeli Endgame | Foreign Affairs Interview


What this covers

This Foreign Affairs interview pairs Dan Kurtz-Filen, who asks the questions, with Ami Ayalon, a former head of Israel's navy and of the Shin Bet, who began military service in 1963. It was recorded weeks into the war that followed October 7th. Ayalon's starting point is that Israel has no agreed picture of the day after. He cites a cabinet resolution not to discuss the question at all, and he says the decision holds a coalition together whose members disagree about the endgame, among them Ben-Gvir and Smotrich, who reject occupying Gaza, and ministers who oppose withdrawing from it.

The conversation then covers several areas. On security, Ayalon argues that October 7th exposed fences, walls, and technology as illusory and ended a theory of conflict management. He also argues that "decisive victory" means little against Hamas, which is an ideology and a terror organization, not a state. He claims Hamas has grown more popular over fifteen years because Palestinians see no future, and that it seeks to maximize civilian casualties to win support. Kurtz-Filen presses on whether destroying Hamas is even possible.

A second thread concerns Israeli democracy. Ayalon draws on Brian Jenkins's essay on incremental tyranny and compares the internment of Japanese Americans in World War II with Israel's present erosion of minority rights. His contrast is that America's war ended and Israel's will not. He also describes a growing rift among Israelis over whether Israel should remain a Jewish democracy.

The last part looks outward. Ayalon holds that neither the current Israeli government nor the weak Palestinian Authority can produce a two-state solution, so it must come from abroad. He points to US leadership, a regional role for Egypt and Saudi Arabia, and the risk of China gaining influence in the region. He also recalls the Yom Kippur War and the years it took to reach peace with Egypt.

Sharpest takeaway

Ami Ayalon argues that Israel's current military strategy in Gaza is fundamentally flawed without a defined political endgame, and that only a US-led regional coalition supporting a two-state solution can break the cycle of conflict that Netanyahu's management strategy has enabled.

  • Netanyahu's 15-year policy of dividing Palestinians and managing rather than solving the conflict collapsed on October 7th, revealing the failure of containment without political vision
  • Sending military forces to war without defining a political goal is irresponsible and unsustainable; democracy cannot survive indefinite warfare
  • Only the US can lead a regional coalition with Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and Jordan to fill the Gaza vacuum and impose a two-state solution that both Israelis and Palestinians will support

The claims · ranked46 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.79

An article by Brian Jenkins titled 'Incremental Tyranny' describes how democracy erodes step-by-step, 'bite by bite,' in small increments that seem individually acceptable but cumulatively dismantle democratic institutions.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“A friend of mine Bri Jenkins he I think he was the vice president of Rand Corporation in Santa Monica he wrote a very very important article during the 1990s I think that the title is incremental tyranny but step by step bite by bite democracy each in safe in in in small bites”

0.74

Israeli security was previously based on fences, walls, technology, and military power, but all of these were revealed as illusory by October 7th, necessitating a fundamentally different approach to security.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“until now you know we felt relatively safe um but our security was based on uh fences walls technology and military military power all of it collapsed all of it collapsed”

0.74

Netanyahu's cabinet formally resolved three weeks ago not to discuss or state any position on 'the day after,' deliberately avoiding political definition because coalition members disagree fundamentally on the endgame.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“everything is politics our cabinet uh decided three weeks ago um where that there they will not discuss they will not say anything it's a formal cabinet resolution they will not say anything on the day after so there is no political go”

0.73

Hamas is becoming increasingly popular among Palestinians over the past 15 years because Palestinians see no path to a better future and are fighting for national identity and dignity, not just economic improvement.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“during the last 15 years he is becoming more and more popular among Palestinians especially because Palestinians want to see a better future now if they will be able to get a better future not only as people but as a people they have fighting not only for better economy better education they are fighting in order to see themselves as a nation alongside Israel”

0.73

America interned Japanese citizens during World War II while their sons served in the Pacific, but America recovered its democratic character after the war ended because the war had a defined endpoint.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“America locked Japanese in camps during the second world war their sons served somewhere in the you know in the Pacific Ocean but after the war America became let's say a democracy again but this is an ongoing war in Terror it's not a war it is an ongoing battle with varied intensity”

0.73

A democracy cannot survive in an ongoing war, as founders like James Madison understood, and Israel today demonstrates this principle through erosion of rights, especially for minorities.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“when you know the founders of America if I remember medison said that a democracy will not survive in an ongoing War I believe that in a way this is what we see today in Israel”

0.71

It is irresponsible to send military forces to the battlefield without defining a clear political goal, which must be a description of 'the day after' the conflict ends.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“I think that uh it is irresponsible for us um to send uh our military our people to the battlefield without defining a political goal which is the description of the day later”

0.71

Netanyahu's 15-year policy of managing the conflict by dividing Palestinians (Hamas controlling Gaza, Fatah controlling the West Bank) while preventing both from strengthening was designed to avoid pressure for a two-state solution.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“he came with a policy that there is nobody to talk with nothing to talk about he did not invent it by the way but he created it as his former policy now in order to do it and to avoid pressure from the International Community uh the only way to do it is to empower Hamas in Gaza to make sure that Palestinians will be divided and Hamas will control Gaza and fat will control the West Bank”

0.71

Most Israelis now understand that the reality of ongoing conflict is inevitable and must be fought, but they do not understand that democracy cannot survive indefinite warfare, making a political solution essential for Israeli democracy's survival.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“more and more Israelis are saying okay this is the reality in which we live and we have to fight and they do not understand you know what we discussed earlier we cannot separate our concept and understanding of democracy from the concept of War because if we shall have to go fighting for Generations our democracy will not survive”

0.71

American domestic interest requires preventing Chinese domination of the Middle East, making US-led regional coalition building and support for two-state solution aligned with American geopolitical interests.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“the Israeli Palestinian conflict is a conflict between Israelis and Palestinians and I will tell Americans in the American Administration no more it is not only a conflict between Israelis and Palestinians it is a regional conflict and it is part of the global conflict because you have to understand China is here if China is your you know rival or enemy whatever you call it so China is here and if you will not create here this Coalition Regional Coalition and if you will not be the leader from outside don't send soldiers but be the leader of this Coalition if you will not do it China in few years will control this region if you want to lead the West this is what you have to do”

0.69

Hamas is not a state but a terror organization that will not surrender; therefore, the concept of 'decisive military victory on the battlefield' has no meaning in this conflict.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“Hamas is not a state uh is a a terror organization and nobody will rise a a white flag so the idea of decisive military victory in the battlefield has no meaning”

0.68

On October 7th, Israel lost control of intelligence and operational capability in Gaza and experienced a collapse of the entire strategic theory of conflict management, not merely a tactical security failure.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“what we saw on the 7th of October this is a collapse of the theory because um you know every two years three years we had to enter into Gaza in order to make sure that they will not you know increase their military power and we lost control and we didn't have the human human intelligence”

0.65

Israel and Palestine have conflicting narratives that each side experiences as justified: Israelis frame their security concerns, Palestinians frame their drive for freedom and end of occupation, but neither side can see the other's narrative.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“there are two conflicting narratives between Palestinians and us we shall tell you um as an Israeli will tell you all what we wanted to achieve was security and we gave them everything and instead we got you know violence in TI Etc and we are right on the other hand they will say we recognize the state of Israel along the lines of the international you know um resolutions um and um and we wanted to achieve our freedom end of occupation and all what we saw is more settlements more settlers more checkpoints more army units so so to we do not see their narrative they do not see ours”

0.65

A huge rift exists between Israelis regarding the future of Israel: fewer Israelis believe in Israel as a Jewish democracy, and more are willing to abandon democracy in favor of a Jewish state concept.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“there is a huge Rift between Israelis on the future of Israel uh less and less people believe in Israel as a Jewish democracy and more and more people are ready to give up the concept of democracy and um speaking on the idea of a Jewish state”

0.65

Israelis are afraid because their previous sense of security was illusory, and what they need now is someone trustworthy to lead them and show them a better reality than indefinite conflict.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“Israelis are afraid so what we need is someone to trust that will lead us and will show us a better reality”

0.65

The Israeli Palestinian conflict has become a regional and global conflict (not merely bilateral) with China's participation, making American leadership essential to prevent Chinese domination and control of the region.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“we used to see that the Israeli Palestinian conflict is a conflict between Israelis and Palestinians and I will tell Americans in the American Administration no more it is not only a conflict between Israelis and Palestinians it is a regional conflict and it is part of the global conflict because you have to understand China is here”

0.63

Ayalon's generation experienced the Yom Kippur War, the bloodiest war until October 7th, which was a major trauma, and it took 4 years of public engagement and 6 additional years of negotiation to achieve a peace agreement with Egypt.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“I belong to the generation of yum kipur War which was the bloodiest war until the 7th of October uh 23 and um and for Our Generation Um it was I think a major trauma and uh it took us four years to see s visiting our Parliament speaking to our CET members and in the ceset you know speaking to the Israeli people and two more years to sign a peace agreement with Egypt which was our largest enemy and this peace you know still exists”

0.62

The current situation in Israel is an 'ongoing war with varied intensity' that will not end, not a traditional war with a defined endpoint, making democracy survival impossible without a political settlement.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“it is an ongoing battle with varied intensity sometimes it is a higher intensity some but there will be no end to this war of a State against uh a ter organization especially in our case when we are fighting for religious national uh and uh and social Concepts”

0.62

If the objective is to destroy Hamas, this may be impossible because Hamas is an ideology and terror organization, not just a military force that can be defeated in conventional terms.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Dan Kurtz-Filen

“if the objective is to destroy Hamas how... is that is is that really possible”

0.61

Coalition members disagree fundamentally: Netanyahu and far-right ministers hold 'Jewish Supremacy' ideology and oppose withdrawal from Gaza, while Ben-Gvir and Smotrich do not accept occupation and control of Gaza, making any discussion of 'the day after' unsustainable.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“they do not agree uh the moment that they will start this debate uh the Coalition will fall apart uh Netanyahu will lose all his you know Messianic radical U fundamental Jewish Supremacy concept and um and within the cabinet uh gun and G isinot uh do not agree to uh you know going on with occupation and controlling Gaza”

0.61

The process to achieve a two-state solution will not come from Israel under the current government, nor from the Palestinians given the weak Palestinian Authority, but must come from abroad through US leadership.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“it will not come from Israel certainly not from this government it will not come from the Palestinians especially not with you know um the weak Palestinian Authority uh who believe in the concept of two states by the way uh it should come come from abroad uh America is the only superpower who can lead this process”

0.61

Hamas's strategy is to maximize Palestinian civilian casualties to gain support within Palestinian society (presenting this as fighting for freedom), support from the Muslim world and Arab states, and support from the international community.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“the idea is to bring us Israeli Ida to kill as many pal innocent Palestinians as possible in order to achieve support first of all within the Palestinian Society because they are paying in blood in order to achieve Freedom end of occupation etc etc second within the Muslim Community around us all the Arab states and the International Community and unfortunately um they are winning this war”

0.61

The Israeli government's cabinet will face coalition collapse if they begin discussing the day after, because fundamental disagreement on the endgame is the only thing holding the diverse coalition together through an agreement not to discuss it.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“the moment that they will start this debate uh the Coalition will fall apart”

0.60

The only viable political horizon for Israel and Palestine is a two-state solution for two peoples, which both sides have accepted as a framework despite disagreement on implementation details.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“for me the only viable political Horizon is the Horizon of two states for two people in Oso”

0.57

Netanyahu's cornerstone policy is to stay out of prison, and his ability to remain in power as prime minister despite facing trial is 'unbelievable nonsense.'

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“the Cornerstone Stone of his policy is to stay out of of prison and I I'm not joking uh it's uh it's unbelievable it's nonsense uh that he is still in power as a prime minister”

0.57

Netanyahu enabled Qatar to pay Hamas 1.2 to 1.4 billion dollars to ensure Hamas remained in power in Gaza, while simultaneously weakening the Palestinian Authority to prevent it from becoming a unified Palestinian leadership.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“he had to assist Hamas in many ways uh to allow them to come you know uh to to work in Israel and um and giving them you know or at least uh enabling Qatar uh to pay as far as I know more than 1.2 1.4 billion dollar and um and to make sure that will stay in power in Gaza”

0.55

Biden is viewed by Israelis as 'our grandfather' and is the only political figure in the world that Israel trusts, giving him unique power and leverage to impose a two-state solution as a condition of American support.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“Biden entered to a a leadership vacuum in Israel uh Israelis see him as our grandfather he's the only political person in the world that Israel is trust so he has the power he has all the Leverage to come to us and to tell us look I will support you but you have to understand that I will not act against the American interest”

0.55

Biden should tell Israel: 'I will support you, but I will not act against American interest or what I believe is your interest—which is to be safe, Jewish, and democratic, achievable only through a two-state solution.'

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“I will support you but you have to understand that I will not act against the American interest and I will not act against what I believe that it is your interest your interest is to see Israel safe Jewish and Democratic and you can achieve it only in a reality of two states”

0.52

Netanyahu does not take political or military risks, which is why he believes he can 'manage' the conflict indefinitely, but managing something requires not taking risks whereas solving something requires taking risks.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“he do not take risks not political risks and not risks in the battlefield he's very very careful and this is why he believes that you know he he can manage it because in order to solve something uh you have to take risks”

0.52

Hamas uses Palestinian civilians, including children, elderly, and women, as human shields as official strategy, and the current Israeli military casualties result from this deliberate policy by Hamas.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“Hamas is using its people civilians innocent people elderly women children as a human shield and all what we see today is um in a way um the results of this policy no it's not something new this is their official strategy”

0.52

Israeli generals are making greater efforts to avoid civilian casualties than in earlier battles, but hospitals are military installations in Gaza, making it impossible to defeat Hamas's military and political leadership without civilian casualties in a densely populated area.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“I know them personally and they are doing all what they can by the way even more than we did earlier or in former battles in order to avoid civilian casualties but you have to understand the hospitals are military installations and Gaza is probably most populated you know City or or or area on the world there is no other way to defeat the military wing of Hamas”

0.51

Israel cannot sustain a presence on the northern border with Hezbollah as long as civilians live on both sides of the fence, but this should be addressed through threatening military capability combined with political discussion with Lebanon about border lines.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“we cannot live when on the other side one side of the fence hisbah with all his military capability leaving and our civilians are leaving on the other side of the fence... but on the other hand yes okay hisbah is something different if you ask me we shall have to face his balah later but it should be always a combination of threatening and even using our Superior military capability but with a very very uh with with a with idea that our security concept should be based on military power and a political Cornerstone”

0.51

Israel should discuss border lines with Lebanon, not with the international community, because Hezbollah gains support in Lebanon by claiming parts of those areas belong to Lebanon, and historically these claims may be justified.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“I think that we should discuss with them with libanon not with the International Community as the exact line of the Border in the north uh because uh they are gaining a lot a lot of support in libano when they say parts of these areas belongs to libanon and as I understand the history they are right”

0.51

Saudi Arabia should lead a regional Sunni pragmatic coalition including Egypt, Jordan, and Morocco to fill the Gaza vacuum, not Israel, because they speak Arabic and will not be perceived as Crusaders by the Muslim world.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“Saudi Arabia will lead the regional Sunni pragmatic States Egypt Jordan probably uh Morocco to create this Regional Coalition they should F the vacuum in Gaza not us... they should speak Arabic because otherwise they will be presented by the Muslim world as Crusaders”

0.51

If a political horizon is created and people see a realistic path to peace even if it takes 10 years, the majority of Israelis and Palestinians will support it.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“I believe that it is achievable it will take years but if we shall ignite it if people will believe if people will see a political Horizon even if they will know that it will take 10 years I think that the support of the majority among Israelis and among Palestinians uh we'll be there”

0.47

Biden must show the goal clearly and assist Israel and Palestinians to move toward it, while all Middle Eastern players are watching and waiting for US leadership to create a regional coalition.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“he will have to show the goal and he will have to assist us to help us to go to us and the Palestinians now all the players in the Middle East are watching him and they're waiting”

0.47

Financial support for Gaza reconstruction should come from Saudi Arabia and the Emirates, not Qatar or Iran, to prevent Iranian influence and align with pro-pragmatic regional states.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“second they should money should come from Saudi Arabia and the Emirates not Qatar and not Iran”

0.45

The interviewer seeks to understand whether recent catastrophe of October 7th has shifted Israeli public opinion toward supporting a two-state solution and political processes that previously had declining support.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Dan Kurtz-Filen

“what would it take to get the Israeli public to see things the way the way you do do you see that understanding emerging from the catastrophe of these past weeks”

0.45

Netanyahu's vision is only to stay in power and manage the situation indefinitely; he is convinced that he does not need to solve the problem, just manage it, and believes that either change in circumstances or divine intervention will eventually resolve it.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“all what he Envision is to stay in power I said this is a Cornerstone of his policy and and he convinced us it is not for me to solve the problem uh I just have to manage it and sometime someone you know it will be solved with the help of God or with a change in the circumstances”

0.40

Outside observers sympathetic to Israeli objectives have difficulty explaining Israel's theory of victory in Gaza, suggesting the theory itself may be unclear or poorly articulated.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Dan Kurtz-Filen

“outside observers even though it's quite sympathetic to Israeli objectives have a hard time really explain that theory of Victory”

0.37

The Oslo Accords established parameters for a two-state solution that are broadly understood by both Israeli and Palestinian leadership, meaning the basic framework for agreement already exists.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“the goal of two states this is the great achievement of os we know if if ever we should achieve an agreement what what will be more or less the parameters this is the achievement of Oso”

0.37

Both Israeli and Palestinian leadership believe in the principle of two states but disagree on implementation: Israelis focus on security justifications while Palestinians focus on freedom and ending occupation.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“the weak Palestinian Authority uh who believe in the concept of two states by the way”

0.26

The debate between Israeli security establishment and political leadership about Hamas's nature and intentions has been ongoing at least since Netanyahu came to power 15 years ago.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“it's an ongoing debate um between um at least all the director of the shinette as far as I know uh and our political leaders um at least uh since Netanyahu came to power somewhere about 15 years ago”

0.26

Ayalon met with Netanyahu weekly for four and a half years (though Netanyahu was replaced after roughly two years), and based on these meetings, he understood Netanyahu's psychology and approach to governance.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ami Ayalon

“when I was director of shet under him as a prime minister um I met him every week at least once uh for almost four and a half years oh sorry I was four and a half but he was only two and something at that time because he was replaced by a Barack”

0.22

Netanyahu does not take political risks or military risks, preferring to 'go between the drops when it is raining,' and therefore will not plan to go to war against Hezbollah despite northern border tensions.

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Ami Ayalon

“he do not take risks not political risks and not risks in the battlefield he's very very careful and this is why... he will do everything in order to you know to go between the drops when it is raining um it doesn't work all the time uh but I I don't think that he plan uh to go to war against hisbah”

0.12

The situation and ground in Gaza will change significantly in coming days, suggesting both fluid military circumstances and potential for rapid escalation or negotiation.

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Dan Kurtz-Filen

“it's likely that the situation on the ground and Gaza will change quite a bit in the coming days”