What this covers

This HBR IdeaCast episode is a 32-minute interview in which host Adi Ignatius questions McKinsey Global Managing Partner Bob Sternfels. It begins with the firm's public troubles over the past five years: its OxyContin and opioid work, bribery charges in South Africa, and conflict-of-interest accusations. Sternfels describes the reforms that followed, including a client selection framework, a rule that partner commitments go through risk professionals, and roughly $1 billion in modernized compliance, with leaders brought in from Apple and Walmart. He also says the firm's "profession, not a business" ethos cannot be enforced by culture alone. He defends working with hard-to-abate sectors, arguing the climate transition is impossible without them, and he acknowledges that critics disagree.

The conversation then turns to what AI does to the firm itself. Sternfels says McKinsey is moving from a fee-for-service model toward an outcomes-based model, in which it identifies business cases with clients and underwrites the financial results. He gives workforce figures: 3,000 AI agents alongside 40,000 humans eighteen months ago, about 20,000 agents now, and a projected one agent per person within another eighteen months. On the client side, he reports that CEOs worry about extracting enterprise-level value from AI, building institutional resilience, and escaping the matrixed structure McKinsey itself helped popularize. He puts at least half of AI success on organizational change rather than technology, and he describes the CFO-versus-CIO tension between being a fast follower and being a leader.

The last stretch covers talent. Sternfels says the firm's twenty-year hiring data showed that only one in six hires makes partner, and that it had over-indexed on perfect academic credentials. It now screens for resilience and learning agility. It is also exploring hiring for leadership, judgment (in consulting context)), and creative discontinuous thinking, which he says AI models lack.

Sharpest takeaway

McKinsey is undergoing a fundamental transformation from advisory-based fee-for-service consulting to outcomes-based partnership models, driven by AI capabilities, organizational learning from past ethical failures, and recognition that client value lies in solving increasingly complex problems rather than commoditized analysis.

  • AI is forcing McKinsey to shift from advisory to outcomes-based models where the firm underwrites results alongside clients
  • Organizational change, not technology alone, is the bottleneck in enterprise AI implementation
  • McKinsey's future competitive advantage lies in building leadership capability, judgment, and creative discontinuous thinking that AI cannot replicate

The claims · ranked29 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.68

McKinsey is pushing back against criticism that it should refuse to work with hard-to-abate sectors, arguing instead that climate transition is impossible without engaging those sectors—a position where the firm disagrees with critics and maintains it despite controversy.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“We got heavily criticized for our work and hard to abate sectors on their transition issues. And it was the old McKinsey's accelerating climate degradation, et cetera. And we pushed back and said, no, look, if you're going to be committed to climate transition, you have to work with the hardest to abate sectors. It's just naive to say that you're going to solve this problem without that.”

0.68

Faster organizations outperform slower organizations even when they make more mistakes, yet large enterprises have strong risk aversion that prevents them from adopting faster decision-making.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“One of the things that we've studied to death is faster organizations outperform slower organizations, even if they make more mistakes. And yet we're not wired to do that. There's such risk aversion in large enterprise.”

0.68

McKinsey has experienced significant public criticism over the past 5 years for work with OxyContin and the opioid crisis, bribery charges in South Africa, and conflict-of-interest accusations in the US and elsewhere, which prompted organizational soul-searching and systemic reforms.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Adi Ignatius

“You've also had your share of unwelcome publicity in recent years. And I'm talking about OxyContin, bribery charges in South Africa, conflict of interest accusations in the US and elsewhere.”

0.63

McKinsey's global operating model enables the firm to bring innovation from around the world to clients who may not have local access to cutting-edge practices in their geography or industry, providing competitive advantage through geographic and cross-sector intelligence.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“the clients that we serve don't want to understand what the leading edge innovation is in their particular country, they want to understand innovation around the world and perhaps even cross sector and that is part of our model.”

0.61

AI models lack judgment and truth—they are inference engines that require humans to impose parameters and truth values, making judgment-building a critical and durable skill in a post-AI world.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“The second is judgment. And you've seen time and time again-- these models don't-- there's not truth in the model. There's not judgment in the model. Humans need to impose those parameters.”

0.59

McKinsey is exploring hiring for three capabilities that AI models lack and that will remain valuable in a post-AI world: (1) leadership—the ability to set organizational aspirations and inspire people to stretch; (2) judgment—the capacity to impose values and parameters that models cannot provide; (3) creative discontinuous thinking—the ability to make non-linear conceptual leaps rather than linear problem-solving.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“One of them is, well, what do the models not do well? What are the models not do well? One, they don't aspire. They're not good at setting the right aspiration level. And so when you think about what great leaders do is they help an organization set the right-- ask, what should we aspire to? And so how do we start to look for and develop the skills of leadership?”

0.57

Clients with CEOs focused on growth will continue to demand McKinsey's services because they will always seek ways to double market cap; absent CEOs explicitly rejecting growth as an objective, there will always be more complicated strategic questions to solve.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Bob Sternfels

“They're going to pay us to find ways to double their market cap. And until we get to CEOs who say, I don't want to double my market cap, I think they'll always be a more complicated set of questions and opportunities out there.”

0.55

McKinsey is transitioning from pure advisory, fee-for-service consulting to outcomes-based models where the firm jointly identifies business cases with clients and underwrites the financial outcomes of those cases, aligning McKinsey's interests with client success.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“We're coming around to the conviction that we're migrating pretty quickly away from, let's call it, pure advisory work, which was a lot of the origins of our firm and a fee-for-service model, et cetera. And what's it moving to? It's moving to much more of an outcomes based model where we say, look, let's identify a joint business case together and we will underwrite the outcomes of that business case.”

0.55

Half or more of successful enterprise AI implementation depends on organizational change rather than technology implementation itself—including flattening org hierarchies, breaking down departmental silos, and redesigning workflows, which is harder and takes longer than most expected.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“what we're finding is half, if not more, of the secret sauce is organizational change as opposed to technology implementation. This is for large enterprise. And it's things like, well, what is your org look like after you're implementing these-- could you have, for example, a much flatter organization that cuts out a lot of middle layers and makes your organization faster?”

0.52

McKinsey has evaluated candidates in hiring to see how they perform in environments where they have no pattern recognition and must figure things out from first principles, as a test of learning agility.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“we purposely create an environment where you will-- no human in the world will have any pattern recognition in this environment. And we figure out how well do you do in an environment where you have no pattern recognition, you just have to go figure things out.”

0.52

McKinsey discovered through 20 years of historical data analysis that only 1 in 6 hires become partner, and that the firm had systematic biases in hiring toward perfect academic credentials rather than resilience, real-world teamwork experience, and learning agility—biases that do not predict partner success.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“we actually applied analytics on ourselves and took the last 20 years of data and said, what are the skills and characteristics that are most likely to make partner in McKinsey? Because it's not perfect, but it's a marker of success. Only 1 in 6 hires make partner. And it turned out we had some bias in our system.”

0.52

Organizations are not designed or incentivized to collaborate well across functions, departments, and value chains, despite evidence that cross-functional collaboration produces disproportionate gains in performance.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“I think increasingly we're seeing when people collaborate across the value chain, et cetera find disproportionate gain. And yet our organizations aren't geared to collaborate well. We're just not.”

0.52

Institutional resilience in uncertain environments requires organizations to simultaneously play offense and defense—maintaining enough buffer and cushion to withstand unexpected shocks while preserving capacity to take bold bets and strategic initiatives despite ongoing disruption.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“I need to play offense and defense at the same time. So I need defense that I need enough buffer, enough cushion to be able to withstand something that I don't see coming. But I also can't just play defense. I need some capacity to take some bold bets, even when I may be getting hit with exogenous shocks. Can I play offense and defense at the same time is my simple version of how do you build institutional resilience?”

0.52

The work McKinsey did 32 years ago (when Sternfels joined) is considered routine today and would not be undertaken by the firm, demonstrating how the scope of 'simple problems' expands over time as capabilities increase and clients internalize knowledge.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Bob Sternfels

“I'm now considered a dinosaur in our firm because I'm a little over 30 years with us. But the stuff that I did when I joined as an associate 32 years ago, we wouldn't consider even doing right now. Why? Because clients do that stuff themselves.”

0.51

McKinsey's core ethos is that it is a profession, not a business, meaning client interests should be prioritized over firm interests, but this ethos cannot be enforced without explicit compliance controls—suggesting that culture alone is insufficient to guarantee ethical standards.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Bob Sternfels

“the ethos internally is that we're a profession, not a business, meaning that we want to put our clients' interests ahead of ourselves. And the objective should be, are we doing distinctive work versus any kind of work? But without the right controls can't guarantee that.”

0.51

McKinsey pioneered the matrixed organization model in the 1950s through foundational thinking about global organization design, but the matrixed structure has become a bottleneck for modern enterprises due to slowness, complexity, and difficulty with resource reallocation and geopolitical decisions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“a lot of the seminal thinking actually comes from some stuff-- I'm going to date myself here, but I told you I was doing history-- a 1959 paper in HBR by [? Gil ?] [? Klee ?] was-- this was before he became a GMP. He was one of my predecessors. But it was about creating a global organization and it was the precursor thinking to the matrixed organization.”

0.48

McKinsey revised its hiring process to screen for resilience because the firm's core work is helping clients change, and team sports, retail work, or other real collaborative experiences build the human-to-human skills that consulting requires but the firm was not previously indexing.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“we weren't indexing enough on, had you had real experience, in a significant way, working with others? Fundamentally, we're about helping our clients change. And if you've worked-- if you've done a team sport or if you've worked in retail working your way through college, you've had to engage with others. And it's built a skill of human-to-human skill that we're now indexing a lot more on.”

0.48

McKinsey implemented institutional reforms in response to ethical failures, including: (1) establishing a robust client selection framework assessing country, topic, institution, individuals, and operating environment; (2) requiring partner commitments to go through risk professionals rather than unilateral partner decisions; (3) investing ~$1 billion in modernized compliance, bringing in Apple's head of internal audit and Walmart's head of compliance to establish new standards.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“what we learned is that we have to have a higher diligence around client selection. And we put in place a framework that is a really robust assessment now that looks across every aspect from the country, the topic, the institution, the individuals, and the operating environment to say, is this a client that we actually want to bring into the firm?”

0.47

CEOs across geographies and industries report three persistent management concerns: (1) how to extract enterprise-level value from AI and technology transformation; (2) how to build institutional resilience to handle continuous shocks and play offense and defense simultaneously; (3) how to redesign organizational structures beyond the matrixed model that has become a bottleneck.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bob Sternfels

“I'd be lying if one of the themes wasn't one of the ones that we talked about, which is, how do I get value from this technology? And what is everyone else doing because this is hard? And so I would put that as one of the themes of, how do I transform my enterprise through this revolution in technology that we're seeing right before our eyes? The second big theme is, how do I build more institutional resilience? Because I'm increasingly, I'm talking now in the guise of a CEO of the mind, that unfortunately, things will never go back to how they were. There's going to be a world of continuous shocks.”

0.47

CEOs express simultaneous beliefs about AI: enormous belief in the potential for productivity gains and growth opportunities, but also concerns from CFOs about spending money without seeing enterprise-level value yet, leading to debate between CFO (be a fast follower) and CIO (we'll be disrupted if we're not a leader) perspectives.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bob Sternfels

“I really hear in the truth room maybe two things. On the one hand, an enormous belief in the potential for this wave of technological change. And that's everything from enormous productivity gains in areas like customer care or back office processes but also to growth things.”

0.47

A unique moment exists for consultants to help clients 'reimagine themselves' leveraging AI technology, and consultants must simultaneously rewire themselves to enable that delivery, creating simultaneous client-facing and internal transformation.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bob Sternfels

“there's a unique moment to help all of our clients reimagine themselves leveraging this technology. And to be able to do that, we have to rewire ourselves to be able to deliver that.”

0.46

Leaders consistently fail to maintain a ruthless quest for new information and questioning, and overconfidence leads to organizational failure—suggesting humility and continuous learning are among the most important leadership practices.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Bob Sternfels

“One is this hunger and thirst to acquire new information. And whenever you get too confident-- too overconfident, I think change for the negative is going to come. And so how do you have this almost ruthless quest for let me continue to question new things and maybe also from all levels in the organization-- often the best ideas are embedded somewhere lower down.”

0.45

McKinsey's workforce composition is shifting rapidly: 18 months ago the firm had 40,000 humans and 3,000 AI agents; currently it has 40,000 humans and 20,000 agents; and Sternfels believes the firm will reach one agent per human in 18 months, with all employees enabled by at least one or more agents.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Bob Sternfels

“And I now update this almost every month. But my latest answer to you would be 60,000. But it's 40,000 humans and 20,000 agents. And a little over a year and a half ago that was 3,000 agents. And I originally thought it was going to take us to 2030 to get to one agent per human. I think we're going to be there in 18 months.”

0.45

McKinsey plans to increase outcomes-based revenue to become the majority of revenues by the time Sternfels finishes as global managing partner, moving beyond the current baseline of approximately one-third outcomes-based revenue.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bob Sternfels

“My hope is that crosses a majority of the revenues by the time I'm done being the global managing partner.”

0.45

McKinsey has generated over a million applications annually while hiring 8,000-10,000 people per year, meaning the firm filters out approximately 99% of applicants, with many of the brightest global talent included in the rejected pool.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bob Sternfels

“we got over a million applications a year and we hire anywhere between 8,000 and 10,000 people. And even the million aren't a normal distribution. There's some of the brightest minds in the world are applying.”

0.45

McKinsey invests over $1 billion annually in innovation and new thought across various institutes, with research like the McKinsey Global Institute producing novel thinking such as analyzing the global economy through an assets-and-liabilities balance sheet framework.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bob Sternfels

“we clearly invest a boatload in proprietary IP. We invest over $1 billion a year in innovation, new thought, new ideas. McKinsey Global Institute, for example, which is a bit of our independent research tank, but we've now created McKinsey Health Institute--”

0.43

McKinsey should maintain its identity as a 'leadership factory' that develops its employees into capable leaders regardless of tenure, with the expectation that individuals will have intensive, challenging experiences that make them better leaders whether they stay 2 years or 30 years.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“The part that it's continued to be known for is leadership factory of the world. And one of the things that's been very exciting is no matter how long folks stay with us, they tend to do pretty well wherever they go. And we produce more CEOs than any other institution in the world...do we make you a better leader no matter how long you're in McKinsey-- two years, 30 years. You leave McKinsey you better-- I hope that remains.”

0.32

There are increasing levels of scrutiny on institutions from media and governments, making some criticism inevitable and requiring organizations to develop discernment about which criticisms to remediate versus which to pushback on.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Bob Sternfels

“there's an increasing scrutiny on the side of media, governments for all institutions. And so one of the things that we learned through this process is there are some things that we're going to be criticized for that we're just going to push back on.”

0.26

McKinsey's growth has never been the firm's objective function—the firm does not track or publicize revenue growth metrics like a public company would, reflecting its private partnership structure and professional orientation rather than a business orientation.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Bob Sternfels

“growth has never been our objective function. And we're privately traded. We don't have quarterly earnings. You don't see McKinsey talking about, oh, we had revenue growth of this or that because the ethos internally is that we're a profession, not a business, meaning that we want to put our clients' interests ahead of ourselves.”