YouTube11m· Feb 2024· cataloged

What Makes Someone Vote Against Their Political Party? | Sarah Longwell | TED


What this covers

This is an 11-minute TED talk by political strategist Sarah Longwell, drawing on her focus-group and polling work with Republican and swing voters. She starts from a 2018 project in which she tried to show potential Republican primary challengers that voters wanted an alternative to Donald Trump and saw him as a threat to democracy. The research showed the reverse. Voters liked him and were unconcerned about his antidemocratic behavior, including praising dictators and using the White House to enrich his family. From there she turns to the psychology behind that indifference, citing anthropological claims that expulsion from the group is among the most traumatic things a person can face.

The middle of the talk covers what tribal instincts do in practice. Even Republicans who disliked Trump recoiled when critics from outside the tribe attacked him, which she describes as tribal defense mechanisms. The two parties also name opposite threats: Republicans point to a rigged 2020 election, Democrats to the Capitol attack and election denial. She then describes Republican Voters Against Trump, built on permission structures and trusted messengers. Its testimonials spoke about personal values rather than democracy, and once about 100 had been collected, unsolicited ones started arriving. She also notes that voters admitted how painful it was to vote for Democrats and did so anyway.

The later sections look at 2022 and at what to do next. Swing voters rejected Republicans as "extreme," especially on abortion, and not as threats to democracy. Longwell argues that voters' silence about democracy does not mean they don't value it, comparing it to air we breathe. She rejects telling people to put democracy over party. She calls for explaining better what liberal democracy is, including pluralism, free speech, and the rule of law. She also argues for winning elections margin by margin in the meantime, and she places the stakes beyond America, since democracy elsewhere depends on it holding here.

Sharpest takeaway

Longwell argues that American voters are primarily motivated by tribal belonging rather than democratic principles, so defending democracy requires building larger coalitions through trusted peer messengers rather than abstract appeals to democratic values.

  • Voters show immunity to antidemocratic behavior when it benefits their political tribe, prioritizing tribal membership over democratic norms
  • Republican Voters Against Trump succeeded by offering disaffected Republicans a new tribe to join, not by appealing to democracy
  • Swing voters in 2022 rejected Republicans as 'extreme' on specific issues (abortion) rather than as threats to democracy itself

The claims · ranked22 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.69

Many Republicans were initially reluctant to publicly state they wouldn't vote for Trump because they feared social consequences from neighbors, spouses, and family members, demonstrating that tribalism creates fear of going against one's tribe.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“People were nervous about saying they weren't going to vote for Trump publicly. They didn't want their neighbors to find out, they didn't want their spouse to find out, they didn't want their parents to find out, because that's what tribalism does, right? It makes us afraid to go against our tribe.”

0.69

Republicans and Democrats have fundamentally opposed definitions of the biggest threat to democracy: Republicans cite Democrats rigging the 2020 election, while Democrats cite Republicans attacking the Capitol and denying election results.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“Right now, if you talked to a Republican, and you said, 'What's the biggest threat to democracy?' they'd tell you, 'Democrats, because they rigged the 2020 election.' If you talked to a Democrat and said, 'What's the biggest threat to democracy?' they'd tell you it's Republicans, because they attacked the Capitol and denied the election results in 2020.”

0.68

Social scientists and anthropologists have established that there is nothing more traumatic for a human than getting kicked out of their tribe, because tribal instincts are hardwired into human survival mechanisms to prevent predation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Sarah Longwell

“social scientists, anthropologists, people who study people, they will tell us that there is nothing more traumatic for a human than getting kicked out of their tribe. We all want to fit in, we all crave community and belonging. We've had tribal instincts for as long as we've been around. Right? Humans have. It's hardwired in there, as part of our survival instincts, so we don't get eaten by lions or bears.”

0.55

American voters do not feel nearly as strong a connection to democracy as they do to their political team or partisan tribe, with most voters not thinking about democracy at all.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“I've listened to thousands of American voters, and I know that they don't feel nearly the connection to democracy that they do to their political team, their partisan tribe. In fact, in America, most voters don't think about democracy at all.”

0.52

In 2018, Longwell conducted polling and focus groups to demonstrate to potential Republican primary challengers that Republicans wanted an alternative to Trump and believed he was a threat to democracy, but the research revealed the opposite: voters liked Trump and were unconcerned about his antidemocratic behavior.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“I was running around, talking to a governor and some congressmen, some other people, and I was like, 'You've got to primary this guy.' But they all wanted to know one thing: if they ran a primary against Trump, could they win? So I started doing a bunch of polling and focus groups so I could go make the case, to these potential candidates, that, of course, Republicans wanted an alternative to Trump. Of course they thought that he was a threat to democracy. Of course they were up for putting democracy over party. Nope. Not at all. They liked Trump fine. They thought he was funny, they thought he was a good businessman, they liked it that he 'told it like it was' and that he wasn't a regular politician.”

0.52

Focus groups revealed that Republican voters do not care about Trump's antidemocratic behavior (praising dictators, hijacking foreign policy for personal political purposes, using the White House to enrich himself and his family) because Trump is a member of their tribe and therefore receives the benefit of the doubt.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“Trump praises dictators? OK. He hijacks American foreign policy for his own political purposes and gets impeached for it? They don't care. He uses the White House to enrich himself and his family? Not worried about it. Trump's a member of their tribe. Right? So he gets the benefit of the doubt.”

0.52

Even Republican voters who disliked Trump recoiled at direct attacks on him, especially when those attacks came from outside the tribe (from the deep state, the media, Democrats, or Never Trumpers), demonstrating that tribal defense mechanisms override individual disagreements with tribal members.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“Even Republican voters who didn't like Trump, even they still recoiled at direct attacks on him, especially if those attacks were coming from outside the tribe. Right? They're coming from ... 'the deep state, the media, Democrats -- Never Trumpers like me.'”

0.52

Disaffected Republicans did not trust institutions, experts, or even Republican politicians, so the one group they would trust were people like themselves—regular Republicans without special knowledge or expertise.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“The problem was they didn't trust anybody. They didn't trust institutions or experts, they didn't even trust Republican politicians. But then, we had a little bit of a breakthrough. So in the focus groups, we started showing people video testimonials. Little videos, just of regular people, Republicans, talking about why they couldn't vote for Trump, again, in 2020. And suddenly, people were listening. Because it turns out the one group they do trust ... is people like them. Right? Members of their tribe who don't claim any special knowledge or expertise.”

0.52

Republican Voters Against Trump testimonials focused on why people became Republicans in the first place, what their values were, and why those values meant they couldn't vote for Trump—not on democracy as an abstract principle.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“None of these testimonials mentioned democracy. Instead, they talked about why they became Republicans in the first place. What their values were. And why those values meant they couldn't vote for Donald Trump.”

0.52

Rather than stop talking about democracy, the imperative is to talk about democracy better by explaining what democracy is, why it's good, and why the components of liberal democracy (pluralism, free speech, the rule of law) underpin a free society.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“But this doesn't mean we should stop talking about democracy. On the contrary, we need to talk about democracy better. If we're going to ask people to put democracy over party, then we better explain to people what democracy is and why it's good. Why the things that make up a liberal democracy -- pluralism, free speech, the rule of law -- why those things underpin a free society and make us who we are.”

0.52

The fact that voters don't think much about democracy is actually the greatest opportunity for those defending democracy around the world, because it means there is a chance to rekindle the love of democracy for a new generation.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“The fact that voters don't think much about democracy is actually our greatest opportunity. It means that we have the chance, those of us who are trying to defend democracy around the world, it means that we have the chance to rekindle the love of democracy for a new generation.”

0.52

If defenders of democracy can successfully rekindle love of democracy for a new generation, they won't have to ask people to put democracy over party—the loyalty will be intrinsic.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“And if we can do that, we won't have to ask them to put democracy over party.”

0.52

Although Republican Voters Against Trump testimonials did not mention democracy as a principle, the voters who broke from their tribe and voted against Trump were objectively putting democracy over party by voting against a president who was a threat to democracy.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“But none of them said that they were doing it to put democracy over party. But that's exactly what they did, when they broke from their tribe and voted against a president who was a threat to democracy.”

0.52

Just because voters don't talk about democracy doesn't mean they don't understand and value democracy; rather, in America, democracy is like air we breathe—so ingrained in who we are that it's hard to see when it's under threat.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“Just because voters don't talk about democracy doesn't mean they don't understand and value democracy. It's just that, in America, democracy's like the air we breathe, right? It's just that thing we do here. And it's so ingrained in who we are that it's really hard to see when it's under threat.”

0.52

By telling a better story about democracy, Americans can create a better story about America where politics is not zero-sum (where 'I win means you lose'), because the big tribe of America predicated on democratic values is large and strong enough to hold all smaller tribes inside it.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“Because if we can tell a better story about democracy, we can tell a better story about America, where our politics isn't zero-sum, right? I win means you lose. Because the big tribe that is America, the big tribe that's predicated on our democratic values, that tribe is big enough and strong enough, expansive enough, to hold all the other little tribes inside of it, from your progressive Bernie Bros to your evangelical Christians to your basic lesbian Republicans.”

0.52

Staving off the dangerous version of the Republican Party cannot be accomplished by telling people to put democracy over party; instead, it requires winning elections by building a dominant political coalition using permission structures and trusted messengers, similar to how Republican Voters Against Trump was built.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“But we are not going to stave off this dangerous version of the Republican Party by telling people to put democracy over party. We're going to do it by winning elections. We're going to do it the same way we built Republican Voters Against Trump, by building a dominant political coalition using permission structures and trusted messengers.”

0.48

Republican Voters Against Trump testimonials talked extensively about how painful it would be to vote for Democrats, but people voted for Democrats anyway because alignment with their core values took precedence over partisan tribal identity.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“They also talked a lot about how painful it was going to be to vote for Democrats. They really didn't want to do that. But they did.”

0.47

Once Republican Voters Against Trump had collected 100 testimonials and launched publicly, more testimonials came flooding in unsolicited because disaffected Republicans discovered a new tribe to attach to that allowed them to feel safe and secure breaking from their original tribe.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“So we fought really hard, scrapped, for the first 100. But once we had the first 100, we knew we had a new tribe. We called it 'Republican Voters Against Trump.' People could maintain their Republican identity. So once we launched Republican Voters Against Trump, went public with it, all of a sudden, testimonials came flooding in, unsolicited, because there were lots of people who felt this way. They just needed a tribe to attach to, to feel safe, to feel secure.”

0.47

To defeat Trump in the general election, Longwell determined that the strategy required building permission structures that allow disaffected Republicans to break from their tribe and vote against Trump by using trusted messengers that disaffected Republicans would listen to.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“So we had to figure out how to beat Trump in the general election. And I knew that meant building the necessary permission structures to help disaffected Republicans break from their tribe and vote against Trump. That's how we were going to make the margins. And to do that, I knew we needed trusted messengers, right? Messengers that these folks trusted.”

0.45

In 2022, even after the Capitol attack and with Republican candidates running on platforms claiming the election was stolen, swing voters in focus groups did not talk about democracy as a threat, but instead said they didn't want to vote for Republicans because they were too extreme, especially on abortion.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Sarah Longwell

“Some Democrats talked about democracy, but swing voters, the ones that were going to make up the margins, they never talked about democracy in the focus groups. What they did talk about was that they didn't want to vote for Republicans because they were too extreme. Mainly on abortion. They didn't think they were a threat to democracy. They just thought they were nuts.”

0.29

Democracy cannot survive in other countries if it fails in America, so the stakes of defending American democracy are global.

causalestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Sarah Longwell

“If democracy can't hold in America, it's going to make it a lot harder for democracy to survive in other countries.”

0.19

Longwell focuses on winning the center-right margin, and notes that people across the coalition will have to fight for every margin in order to win elections now and thereby lay the groundwork for better democracy messaging in the long term.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Sarah Longwell

“I focus on the center-right, lots of people focus on other margins, but we're going to have to claw for every margin. Because if we can win right now, in the short term ... then in the long term, we can set about telling this better story about democracy.”