What this covers

This is a conversation between Jay Hamilton of Milk Road and Michael Howell, who runs CrossBorder Capital and writes the Capital Wars Substack. Howell makes the case that liquidity, meaning balance-sheet capacity in the financial sector, matters more to markets than interest rates or conventional economic data. The mechanism he describes is a debt treadmill. Debt averages five to six years in maturity and must be rolled over continuously, which he ties to a roughly 65-month liquidity cycle. He also claims that financial crises are always refinancing crises, and that a stable debt-to-liquidity ratio requires liquidity to grow with debt, which he equates with monetary inflation. Several of these claims are flagged as contested.

The plumbing gets detailed treatment. Howell describes a financial system built on a pool of collateral, with repo markets as its "heartbeat" and central banks acting as dealers of last resort instead of lending through the discount window. He argues the collateral pool has drifted from Treasuries toward private credit and collateralized loan obligations through regulatory arbitrage, which makes the system more procyclical. He also introduces his own Fed liquidity measure, which strips out balance-sheet items that don't touch money markets. On the near term, he says current US conditions are flattered by the Treasury running down its Treasury General Account) during the debt ceiling period, and that this reverses in the second half of 2025.

The asset-level claims are where the conversation turns toward Bitcoin and gold. Howell says global liquidity is the largest systematic influence on Bitcoin in his weekly-data model since 2015. He pictures Bitcoin and gold moving together like a dog on a leash, correlated over the long run but able to diverge in the short run. Gold, in his account, is a purer liquidity play because it lacks Bitcoin's risk-appetite component. He also argues that the Shanghai Gold Exchange has displaced London as the dominant price-setter, consistently trading at a premium. Along the way he discusses China's debt-laden real assets and why central banks, after 2008, 2019 and 2020, cannot credibly abandon liquidity provision.

Sharpest takeaway

Howell argues that global liquidity, driven by the necessity to refinance accumulating debt, is the dominant force shaping asset markets, and that central banks will ultimately be forced to expand liquidity despite current policy rhetoric, creating a favorable environment for monetary inflation hedges like gold and Bitcoin.

  • Debt must be refinanced on a 5-6 year cycle; in a debt-driven economy, liquidity availability determines financial stability and asset prices
  • The debt-to-liquidity ratio predicts financial crises (high ratios) and asset bubbles (low ratios); current trajectory shows rising debt-liquidity ratios requiring increased liquidity injection
  • Central banks cannot realistically shrink balance sheets as stated policy claims; geopolitical and economic pressures will force them to expand liquidity, benefiting gold and Bitcoin

The claims · ranked77 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

The Shanghai Gold Exchange has become the dominant gold price-setter globally, overtaking the London market (dominant since the 19th century), consistently trading at a premium to London prices, indicating sustained structural Asian demand for gold.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“The Shanghai gold exchange has really come from nowhere to be the dominant market worldwide. Since the 19th century, the London gold market has really been the main price setter, but that is no longer true. Uh, the Shanghai exchange now trades at a consistent premium to London, showing there is an ongoing bid. uh for uh gold from Asia”

0.74

From 2000 to present, US federal government marketable debt increased almost 10-fold from $2.8 trillion to $28 trillion, while gold increased approximately 12 times in value and Bitcoin has increased even more, demonstrating that precious metals track debt expansion effectively.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Michael Howell

“just take a very very simple benchmark uh in from year 2000 to date uh the stock of uh US federal government debt marketable debt has increased by almost 10fold uh so you know it's now 28 trillion marketable debt that is um back in um back in year 2000 it was about 2.8 8 trillion. So we've seen a huge increase. But over that time span, the value of gold has gone up by about 12 times. So gold has easily matched that expansion in debt. And Bitcoin's gone up even more”

0.73

Debt has an average maturity of 5 to 6 years and must be continuously refinanced, which governs the global liquidity cycle frequency at approximately 65 months.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“it has a term and that term is probably on average about 5 to six years and it's that five to six year maturity term which really governs what we think of as the global equality cycle. Uh that cycle fluctuates with that uh that frequency”

0.69

The Shanghai Gold Exchange has grown from nothing to become the dominant gold market worldwide, displacing London which has been the main price setter since the 19th century, and the Shanghai exchange now trades at a consistent premium to London, indicating ongoing bid for gold from Asia.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“The Shanghai gold exchange has really come from nowhere to be the dominant market worldwide. Since the 19th century, the London gold market has really been the main price setter, but that is no longer true. Uh, the Shanghai exchange now trades at a consistent premium to London, showing there is an ongoing bid. uh for uh gold from Asia”

0.69

Real asset overvaluation is the bane of China because debt is held against those real assets; people fully realize that many of those real assets are worthless because of the debt burden they face.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“Real assets are really the uh the bane of the or the overvaluation of real assets. uh it's the bane of China not least because uh debt is uh held against that uh uh those real assets and uh you know people fully realize that a lot of that real those real assets are worthless because of the debt uh the debt burden they they face”

0.69

The Fed increasingly operates as dealer of last resort rather than through traditional discount window lending to regulated banks; the Fed must now act directly in markets to maintain repo market function and financial system plumbing.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“who oversees that is increasingly the Fed or central banks operating as what you might say is dealer of the last resort. they've got to act in markets now rather than going through the channels of normal discount window lending to uh regulated banks, high street banks”

0.69

Mandatory federal spending commitments (Medicare, Social Security, defense) will push up the federal deficit and increase the stock of debt over the long term, creating a requirement for ongoing liquidity expansion.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“the pressures on mandatory spending, mandatory fiscal spending, whether it be Medicare, Social Security, increased defense spending or whatever, what whatever uh is going to push up the federal deficit uh over the long term. It's going to increase the stock of debt and that debt basically needs to be um refinanced”

0.69

Central banks learned from 2008, 2019 repo crisis, and 2020 COVID emergency that they must be present in money markets and that QE is an essential part of their toolkit; therefore, they cannot abandon liquidity provision.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“we learned very clearly after 2008. We learned that again in 2019 with the repo crisis. We learned that again in the 2020 COVID emergency. So, you know, central banks have got to be there and QE uh is an essential part of their toolkit”

0.68

Modern economies are fundamentally debt-driven where economic growth increasingly depends on increments of debt fueling capital and consumer spending, with declining underlying productivity growth.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“economies being driven by debt more and more and more. There's less underlying productivity growth as many of us are sort of realizing um, over time.”

0.68

For financial stability, the debt-to-liquidity ratio must remain stable over time; as debt increases, liquidity must increase proportionally, which manifests as monetary inflation.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“Balance sheet capacity is my definition of liquidity or balance sheet capacity in the financial sector is a definition of liquidity and therefore that means that the debt liquidity ratio uh over time uh has got has got to remain stable for financial stability reasons and therefore as debt goes up liquidity goes up and if liquidity goes up that's monetary inflation”

0.68

The world financial system is structured around three key components: a pool of collateral at the core, repo markets as the 'heartbeat' connecting collateral to global liquidity, and central banks operating as dealers of last resort rather than using traditional discount window lending.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“at the heart of the system, right in the center of that diagram, uh is a pool of collateral. And between the pool of collateral and global liquidity is the repo markets. And the repo markets are basically a form of lending, securitized lending, uh that is really the creator of most credit in the world economy...the repo market is kind of the heart of the system or the heartbeat of the system and you need a functioning repo market”

0.68

The collateral pool has shifted from being skewed toward public debt instruments (US Treasuries) toward private debt instruments (collateralized loan obligations and other private credit) due to regulatory arbitrage, making the financial system more procyclical and vulnerable to crises.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“the collateral pool traditionally has been very skewed towards public debt instruments like US treasuries which were always deemed pristine collateral and they've started to shift increasingly into private debt instruments like collateralized loan obligations and that's been done for reasons of regulatory arbitrage because the bank or the treasury market or whatever has been more tightly regulated and so you get the seepage outside of the system”

0.68

Liquidity, defined as balance sheet capacity in the financial sector, is the single most important factor driving capital markets, more important than interest rates or traditional economic metrics.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“Well, I think without question, the most important factor is is liquidity. Um, and there's a whole host of reasons for that, but basically, uh, it really comes down fundamentally to the fact that we're living in a a debt driven world”

0.68

Bitcoin and gold are positively correlated over the long term but can negatively correlate in the short term, and this relationship is captured mathematically as an error correction model showing that Bitcoin and gold move together like a dog on a leash—sometimes the dog runs ahead, sometimes it lags behind, but they move in the same direction.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“Bitcoin and gold correlate positively and strongly over the long term, but they could negatively correlate in the short term. And that's exactly what's been going on lately...And that's pretty much what happens. But in the long term, um the the owner and the and the pet move in the same direction. Uh and that's pretty much what's going on there.”

0.68

Global liquidity is the dominant systematic influence on Bitcoin, accounting for a majority of the pie chart in a vector autoregression model analysis of weekly Bitcoin data since 2015, isolating systematic influences.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“there's a pie chart there which is basically a uh aical analysis of what goes into driving Bitcoin. This is looking at the systematic influences on Bitcoin. It basically is uh it derives from uh uh a vector auto regression model analysis of weekly data since 2015. It isolates systematic influences. It shows that global liquidity is the dominant slice of that pie.”

0.68

Without question, the most important factor in capital markets right now is liquidity, because we're living in a debt-driven world where economic growth increasingly rests on increments of debt fueling capital spending or consumer spending, with less underlying productivity growth.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“Well, I think without question, the most important factor is is liquidity. Um, and there's a whole host of reasons for that, but basically, uh, it really comes down fundamentally to the fact that we're living in a a debt driven world, uh, where economic growth increasingly rests on, um, increments of debt um, fueling whether it be capital spending or more particularly consumer spending, but economies being driven by debt more and more and more. There's less underlying productivity growth”

0.68

Debt has an average maturity term of 5 to 6 years, and this maturity window governs the global liquidity cycle, which fluctuates with that frequency and aligns with the average maturity of world debt.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“debt is not there permanently. Uh it has a term and that term is probably on average about 5 to six years and it's that five to six year maturity term which really governs what we think of as the global equality cycle. Uh that cycle fluctuates with that uh that frequency uh which pretty much you know aligns with the uh average maturity of world debt.”

0.68

The collateral pool has shifted from being skewed toward public debt instruments like US treasuries toward private debt instruments like collateralized loan obligations due to regulatory arbitrage, making the system more procyclical than ever before.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“the collateral pool traditionally has been very skewed towards public debt instruments like US treasuries which were always deemed pristine collateral and they've started to shift increasingly into private debt instruments like collateralized loan obligations and that's been done for reasons of regulatory arbitrage because the bank or the treasury market or whatever has been more tightly regulated and so you get the seepage outside of the system. And what that means is quite uh you know in straightforward terms is that the system is a lot more procyclical now than it really ever has been.”

0.68

Fed liquidity is a concept developed by Howell that looks at the active parts of the Fed balance sheet that actually create or withdraw liquidity, filtering out balance sheet items that don't affect money markets (like TGA drawdowns and reverse repo account increases).

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“Fed liquidity was a concept that we came up with a few years ago uh which is trying to look at the active parts of the Fed balance sheet and this really comes back to uh a lot of the work that was done at Salomon Brothers back in the 80s and 90s on Fed watching and it looks at the active parts of what the Fed balance sheet was is really doing. So in other words, the balance sheet per se is not necessarily all liquidity creating. Only certain elements of it actually add liquidity to money markets. Uh some of them withdraw liquidity uh such as the TGA will withdraw liquidity. The reverse repo account will withdraw liquidity”

0.68

Risk appetite sensitivity does not feature in the influences on gold, making gold a pure liquidity play unlike Bitcoin which has both a liquidity and risk-appetite component.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“By the way, that risk appetite element is not does not feature uh in the influences on gold. So gold is a pure liquidity play.”

0.68

The world financial system has a pool of collateral at its heart, and between the pool of collateral and global liquidity is the repo market, which is the creator of most credit in the world economy—approximately 80% of all lending is now collateral-based in some form.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“at the heart of the system, right in the center of that diagram, uh is a pool of collateral. And between the pool of collateral and global liquidity is the repo markets. And the repo markets are basically a form of lending, securitized lending, uh that is really the creator of most credit in the world economy. Something like 80% of all lending now is collateral based in some form.”

0.66

From 2000 to present, US federal government marketable debt increased from $2.8 trillion to $28 trillion (nearly 10-fold), while gold increased 12-fold in value and Bitcoin increased significantly more from a tiny base, demonstrating these assets historically tracked debt expansion.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Michael Howell

“in from year 2000 to date uh the stock of uh US federal government debt marketable debt has increased by almost 10fold uh so you know it's now 28 trillion marketable debt that is um back in um back in year 2000 it was about 2.8 8 trillion. So we've seen a huge increase. But over that time span, the value of gold has gone up by about 12 times. So gold has easily matched that expansion in debt. And Bitcoin's gone up even more, but clearly from a tiny base.”

0.65

Financial crises are always and everywhere debt refinancing crises that concern the inability to roll over huge piles of debt; the ultimate cause of all financial crises remains the lack of liquidity as compared to the tendency of modern credit systems to overaccumulate debt.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Howell

“the ultimate cause of all financial crisis always remains the lack of liquidity as compared to the tendency of modern credit systems to overaccumulate debt. Crisises are always and everywhere debt refinancing crisises. In other words, they concern the inability to roll over huge piles of debt.”

0.63

Current US liquidity conditions are artificially buoyant due to technical factors: the Fed is running down the Treasury General Account (TGA) to fund government spending during the debt ceiling period, temporarily injecting liquidity that will reverse in the second half of 2025 when the TGA must be rebuilt to target levels of $300-400 billion.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“US Fed liquidity has been quite buoyant of late but that's largely because of the debt ceiling and the fact that the Fed has run down uh the Treasury General accounts. So there's been uh liquidity which has been pumped into into markets uh temporarily uh to pay the government bill uh you know where they couldn't use fix the fixed income markets to do that. So that's a fairly artificial and short-lived uh feature.”

0.63

The tariff uncertainty is affecting US aggregate supply more than China's demand; it's easier and faster to change demand than to change supplier networks, meaning the US economy faces disruption risk that 'we can't really envision at the moment'.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“the tariff uncertainty is, you know, it's certainly affecting demand in China, but the real fact is it's affecting supply in the US economy. It's easier to change your your demand uh back uh than it is to change your supply, your suppliers, and that may mean that the US economy is disrupted um you know, in a way that we can't really envision at the moment.”

0.62

The only thing central banks can realistically do is expand liquidity to revive the system, which will result in monetary inflation, benefiting gold and Bitcoin in the medium term.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“the long-term picture is crystal clear here is that the only thing they can really or realistically do is to expand liquidity again to revive the system, which is monitor inflation, which basically lends itself to pushing out gold and bitcoin in the medium term.”

0.62

Tariff uncertainty is affecting demand in China, but the real issue is the impact on supply in the US economy—it's easier to change demand back than to change suppliers, and the US economy may be disrupted in ways that can't be easily foreseen.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“the tariff uncertainty is, you know, it's certainly affecting demand in China, but the real fact is it's affecting supply in the US economy. It's easier to change your your demand uh back uh than it is to change your supply, your suppliers, and that may mean that the US economy is disrupted um you know, in a way that we can't really envision at the moment.”

0.61

Gold has been purchased by Asian central banks, with the People's Bank of China buying gold again last month, and this is a long-term trend that is likely to persist.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“gold is being purchased uh by Asian central banks. People's Bank of China bought bought again last month. Uh and this is a long-term trend. In the short term, you know, what's going to happen to global liquidity?”

0.61

Financial crises are fundamentally debt-refinancing crises: the ultimate cause is lack of liquidity relative to accumulated debt, and crises manifest as the inability to roll over massive debt piles.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“the ultimate cause of all financial crisis always remains the lack of liquidity as compared to the tendency of modern credit systems to overaccumulate debt. Crisises are always and everywhere debt refinancing crisises. In other words, they concern the inability to roll over huge piles of debt.”

0.59

The Federal Reserve's stated policy of shrinking its balance sheet further is 'madness' because central bank balance sheet policy (keeping financial plumbing intact) is now essential to financial stability, as demonstrated by 2008, 2019 repo crisis, and 2020 COVID emergency.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“Federal Reserve is still talking about shrinking its balance sheet further which in my view is madness. Uh because uh basically balance sheet policy or concern over the financial plumbing is now a really key element of of central bank policy has to be uh they've got to keep the system intact and keep it flowing. Uh so that's that's you know something we learned very clearly after 2008. We learned that again in 2019 with the repo crisis. We learned that again in the 2020 COVID emergency.”

0.59

The Federal Reserve seems very stubborn about shrinking its balance sheet further, which Howell views as madness, because balance sheet policy and concern over financial plumbing is now a critical element of central bank policy that must keep the system intact and flowing.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“the Federal Reserve itself seems very stubborn um in terms of what it intends to do about its balance sheet. Federal Reserve is still talking about shrinking its balance sheet further which in my view is madness. Uh because uh basically balance sheet policy or concern over the financial plumbing is now a really key element of of central bank policy has to be uh they've got to keep the system intact and keep it flowing.”

0.57

The Federal Reserve's stated balance sheet policy (attempting to withdraw liquidity) is being revised upward by Treasury Borrowing Advisory Committee members, who expect the Fed to expand (not contract) its balance sheet, which Howell agrees is the realistic outcome even if not yet official policy.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“what I've shown in the little window there is a chart from the TBACK publication, the Treasury Borrowing Advisory Committee publication for Q4, which is basically illustrating what um TA Bank members are assuming happens to the Fed balance sheet uh over the medium term. And as you can see there, that looks remarkably different, very different again. Uh and that has to be the most realistic option out there. Now, I don't think this is really necessarily intended as a forecast, but it gives certainly a working assumption. That's what they're expecting will happen. That's what I expect to happen, but it's not happening yet.”

0.57

Investor risk appetite is the second largest systematic influence on Bitcoin at just over 20%, representing the correlation between Bitcoin and NASDAQ where Bitcoin gets further upside if risk appetite is increasing and a downdraft if risk appetite is decreasing.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“Then you've got investor risk appetite at just over 20%. Now what that really is in straightforward terms is to say well that's something like you know Bitcoin correlates with NASDAQ. So risk appetite is moving upwards. Bitcoin is going to get a further uh impetus if risk appetite is going down as it has done uh marketkedly you know since January 1 or since certainly since uh uh middle of the first quarter uh you get a big downdraft in uh in NASDAQ and Bitcoin.”

0.57

China's debt-to-liquidity ratio is elevated (above the mean), indicating too much debt relative to available liquidity; to reach equilibrium, the entire Chinese liquidity stock needs to expand by approximately 30%.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“the debt liquidity ratio of China contrary to what you're seeing on average in the world is actually elevated. In other words, there's too much debt relative to liquidity. uh the debt we know the story full well that China has taken on a huge amount of debt uh in terms of its uh economic growth in the last uh two decades the liquidity story has already been impaired by the fact that the Chinese authorities have been withdrawing liquidity because of the weakness in the Chinese yuan...our view was that to get out of the debt problems uh that China had they need to get that debt liquidity ratio at least back to an equilibrium level the dotted line which would require an expansion of liquidity of about 30%. So the entire Chinese liquidity stock has to go up by 30%”

0.57

China is opening the money taps pretty hard right now and there is deliberate devaluation of the Chinese yuan going on in the background, which is being reflected particularly in the gold market.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“you've got on the other side which we can dig into later. China is actually opening the money taps pretty hard right now. There's a lot of liquidity being thrown at the system by China. And you know it it's our view that there's a deliberate devaluation of the Chinese yuan going on in the background. Uh and that is being reflected in particular in the gold market”

0.56

Mandatory federal spending commitments (Medicare, Social Security, defense) will push the US federal deficit and debt stock higher over the long term, creating structural pressure for continued debt growth of 7-8% annually, exceeding GDP growth by 2-3 percentage points.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“the pressures on mandatory spending, mandatory fiscal spending, whether it be Medicare, Social Security, increased defense spending or whatever, what whatever uh is going to push up the federal deficit uh over the long term. It's going to increase the stock of debt and that debt basically needs to be um refinanced”

0.55

Bond markets are unlikely to provide positive real returns because yields would need to spike to 7-8% (matching nominal debt growth rates) to deliver acceptable real returns, but such rates would be 'disastrous for economic growth' and governments cannot permit this, making bonds unattractive.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“you don't want to get a lot of mileage out of fixed income markets unless [5:40] yields suddenly spike higher uh to that sort of 7 to 8% level. But that would be uh disastrous for economic growth. Uh and governments couldn't let that happen. So uh rule that one out. You don't want to be in bonds.”

0.55

Bond market volatility is currently elevated at approximately double normal levels (around 150 on volatility index vs. normal 70), signaling heightened systemic risk and approaching a 'danger zone' around 150+ where the system begins to break down.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Michael Howell

“the normal zone uh is shown as that gray shaded area and we've broken out of that very clearly and we're now in a heightened uh period of volatility and we're dancing around what I've illustrated there as a danger zone when you know the system starts to break down when it gets significantly above about 150. Now for ease of interpretation you can treat that 150 as being basically 15% uh annualized volatility in the bond markets”

0.55

The SOFR-Fed Funds spread is rising and frequently breaching its upper trend line, indicating growing refinancing difficulties in repo markets as the system overnight funding rate (SOFR) trades above Fed Funds targets.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Michael Howell

“that spread should be within the tram lines uh or somewhere near the lower tram line. uh it's basically been trading since the middle of last year towards the upper end of the trend line and has frequently breached that trend line uh which is showing that you've got refinancing difficulties because sofa rates uh system overnight funding rate is above fed funds targets”

0.55

Good quality equities and prime residential real estate are appropriate inflation hedges alongside gold and Bitcoin because they maintain purchasing power as liquidity expands, though they have not been the focal point of this analysis.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“So uh rule that one out. You don't want to be in bonds. You want to be in monetary hedge, monetary inflation hedges. That means gold, that means Bitcoin, that means prime residential real estate, that means good quality equities.”

0.52

The debt-to-liquidity ratio is a predictive indicator of financial instability: high ratios (above the mean) indicate refinancing crisis conditions, as evidenced by crises in 1997-1998, 2008-2009, and 2011-2012; low ratios (below the mean) indicate asset bubble conditions.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“if you get a very high debt liquidity ratio um such as occurred in 9798 or occurred during the time of the Leman crisis or the Euroan banking crisis what you find is that you get refinancing tensions and those refinancing tensions have their vent in the crisis. So every one of those past crises that occurred high levels of the debt liquidity ratio. So in other words refinancing is difficult. So that tries to make the case that every financial crisis is a refinancing crisis. And then if you look at the other side of that dotted line which is the mean value, what you find there is that uh you get um asset bubbles uh when liquidity is way above required uh liquidity for debt rollovers. So a very low debt liquidity ratio means you get an asset bubble.”

0.52

Central banks' use of liquidity as a policy tool after 2008 and COVID, combined with zero interest rates that encouraged borrowers to 'term out' debt to 5-6 year maturities, created a very low debt-liquidity ratio that drove asset bubbles and the 'everything bubble', with the debt maturity wave returning to the system in late 2025-2028.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“number one central banks used liquidity as a as a policy tool uh particularly after 2008 and certainly after COVID they injected lots of liquidity and the other factor was that zero interest rates which were employed uh again uh through these crisis periods encouraged uh many borrowers to term out their debt. Um so they pushed the debt they refinanced the debt and termed it out to basically five years five to six years on. So we're talking about late 2025 uh 26 27 maybe 28. Uh that window is when a lot of this debt is going to come back into the system to need refinancing”

0.51

The gold price in Chinese yuan has more than doubled from approximately 11,000 yuan per ounce (early 2023) to approximately 25,000 yuan per ounce (April 2025), indicating China is devaluing against real assets via the gold market.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Michael Howell

“back in um 2022, the beginning, sorry, beginning of 23, I think actually uh the gold price in yuan was about 11,000 yuan per ounce of gold. Uh it's currently uh around 25,000. So the yuan gold price has more than doubled over this period.”

0.51

China has been operating a 'stop-go' monetary policy driven by strength or weakness of the Chinese yuan: when the dollar strengthened in Q4 2024, China tightened liquidity; as the dollar weakened, China opened the money taps to inject significant liquidity.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“they've been operating a stopgo policy uh in terms of their monetary accommodation and that stopgo policy has really been dictated by strength or weakness in the Chinese UR. So when the dollar was very strong in the fourth quarter, they had to take a lot of liquidity out of the system. Now the dollar has weakened, they can put a lot more back”

0.51

The Fed will inevitably be forced to expand liquidity again to revive the economy, which will monitor inflation and lend itself to pushing out (i.e., causing to rise) gold and Bitcoin in the medium term.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“the only thing they can really or realistically do is to expand liquidity again to revive the system, which is monitor inflation, which basically lends itself to pushing out gold and bitcoin in the medium term.”

0.50

Bitcoin and gold have a positive long-term correlation but can negatively correlate in the short term, following an error correction model where one asset 'leads' (like a dog on a leash) and must eventually correct to realign.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“mathematically those two slices make up what is called uh mathematically at least an error correction model. What that error correction system is uh defining in straightforward terms is the fact that Bitcoin and gold correlate positively and strongly over the long term, but they could negatively correlate in the short term. And that's exactly what's been going on lately. So if you look at what happened in Q4, Bitcoin was very strong, gold was weak. Q1 gold was very strong, Bitcoin was weak. Uh and now you're sitting on reversal again. Bitcoin's catching up. So it's a little bit like, you know, um somebody, you know, uh leading uh having a dog on a leash and the dog runs off and you race after it and then you have to start pulling the dog uh when it decides it wants to go in another direction.”

0.50

The debt-to-liquidity ratio measures the effective amount of debt that needs to be refinanced each year, adjusted for flow and changing maturity, and is a critical indicator of financial stability.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“debt needs to be refinanced. And if you're refinancing debt, you need liquidity, balance sheet capacity, in other words, in the financial sector to do it. And the debt liquidity ratio is really something you need to pay attention to. Now, uh those that want to drill into this data, we do adjust the debt data for flow. So we're actually looking at the effective amount of debt that is being uh posted each year to be refinanced...It's normalized for that.”

0.49

China's debt-to-liquidity ratio is elevated (too much debt relative to liquidity), contrary to world average, and China needs to expand its entire liquidity stock by approximately 30% to reach equilibrium levels, which necessarily requires a weaker currency.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“the debt liquidity ratio of China contrary to what you're seeing on average in the world is actually elevated. In other words, there's too much debt relative to liquidity. uh the debt we know the story full well that China has taken on a huge amount of debt”

0.49

Current US Fed liquidity has been buoyant due to technical reasons: the debt ceiling and the Fed's rundown of the Treasury General Account have pumped liquidity into markets temporarily to pay government bills when they couldn't use fixed income markets.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“liquidity conditions right now are not too bad. Um I fully accept that although one's got to recognize that that's kind of coming through for technical reasons. Uh US Fed liquidity has been quite buoyant of late but that's largely because of the debt ceiling and the fact that the Fed has run down uh the Treasury General accounts. So there's been uh liquidity which has been pumped into into markets uh temporarily”

0.48

With monetary inflation running at 7-8% annually, investors should own assets that historically kept pace with debt expansion—gold, Bitcoin, prime residential real estate, and good quality equities—and should avoid fixed income unless yields rise to 7-8% (which is impossible without destroying economic growth).

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“you've got monetary inflation running at rates of 7 to 8% peranom, you've really got to ask which asset should I own which are going to basically keep pace. And I think the, you know, the short answer is the ones that have done well over the last 20 years, they're going to keep going. uh you don't want to get a lot of mileage out of fixed income markets unless yields suddenly spike higher uh to that sort of 7 to 8% level. But that would be uh disastrous for economic growth. Uh and governments couldn't let that happen. So uh rule that one out. You don't want to be in bonds. You want to be in monetary hedge, monetary inflation hedges. That means gold, that means Bitcoin, that means prime residential real estate, that means good quality equities.”

0.48

Very low debt-to-liquidity ratios (when liquidity is way above required liquidity for debt rollovers) produce asset bubbles, as exemplified by the recent cryptocurrency boom and everything bubble, which occurred during periods of very low ratios.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“you get um asset bubbles uh when liquidity is way above required uh liquidity for debt rollovers. So a very low debt liquidity ratio means you get an asset bubble. And you can see where we've just come out of uh the cryptocurrency boom or what you might get the everything bubble where you had a very very low ratio.”

0.48

Central banks used liquidity as a policy tool particularly after 2008 and COVID, and zero interest rates encouraged many borrowers to term out their debt to 5-6 years, meaning large amounts of this debt will need refinancing starting in late 2025 through 2028, which will absorb liquidity and cause the debt-to-liquidity ratio to rise.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“number one central banks used liquidity as a as a policy tool uh particularly after 2008 and certainly after COVID they injected lots of liquidity and the other factor was that zero interest rates which were employed uh again uh through these crisis periods encouraged uh many borrowers to term out their debt. Um so they pushed the debt they refinanced the debt and termed it out to basically five years five to six years on. So we're talking about late 2025 uh 26 27 maybe 28. Uh that window is when a lot of this debt is going to come back into the system to need refinancing and that will absorb liquidity”

0.48

The Treasury General Account will likely need to be rebuilt to its target levels of 3 to 400 billion above current levels in the second half of 2025, which will drain liquidity from money markets and create prospective liquidity shortage in US money markets.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“the TGA, the Treasury General account will have to be in all likelihood rebuilt to its target levels which probably sit something like 3 to 400 billion above where we are now”

0.47

According to vector autoregression analysis of Bitcoin since 2015, global liquidity is the dominant systematic influence on Bitcoin (largest pie slice), followed by investor risk appetite at just over 20%, with gold-Bitcoin correlation dynamics making up the remainder.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“It basically is uh it derives from uh uh a vector auto regression model analysis of weekly data since 2015. It isolates systematic influences. It shows that global liquidity is the dominant slice of that pie. Uh I mean clearly there are random elements which are coming on top but these are the systematic influences. Uh that would say that if liquidity is rising over the medium term that's that's a key element. Then you've got investor risk appetite at just over 20%.”

0.46

A recession in the global economy (or at minimum a very sharp slowdown in growth) is prospectively likely and will adversely affect credit markets, evidenced by credit spreads already widening, regardless of whether the US avoids recession entirely.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Michael Howell

“the prospect of recession in the US uh or more particularly let's say recession in the world economy in which the US will also be a casualty and that is something that ought not to be dismissed. It may not transpire that we actually get a recession but we're certainly getting a very sharp slowdown in growth and the even if we avoid the recession or skirt recession the fact is that that big growth slowdown uh is going to be something which affects the credit markets adversely and already you're starting to see credit spreads blowing up.”

0.45

In current conditions with uncertainty about credit markets and the economy, investors should avoid being too exposed to risk assets and keep their powder dry, but as soon as central banks start to ease liquidity, they should move back into risk assets.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“what do you want to do in terms of risk assets uh well my view is that yeah I wouldn't want to be too exposed to risk assets now because there is so much uncertainty about the credit markets and about uh the state of the economy and therefore I'd prefer to keep my powder dry. But as soon as the central banks start to ease liquidity, um what you would uh what you should be doing is moving back again.”

0.45

Assuming a stable yuan-dollar cross at 7.3 and a gold price target of 25,000-26,000 yuan per ounce (Howell's original target), the implied US dollar gold price is approximately $3,600, which the market has almost tested.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“if you triangulate these two numbers and you say well okay let's assume you stick at 7.3 yuan US dollar cross and and of course by the way there are capital controls which mean that it's not really a a true exchange rate paper the cross rate is not really a true exchange rate very much managed but human stays at 7.3 and you keep that 25 26,000 target for the gold price uh which is what we originally which we envisioned originally uh you get back to a level of uh US dollar gold of about 3,600 and that's we're not far away from that. Uh in fact we've almost tested that level.”

0.45

The SOFR-fed funds spread is showing signs of growing tensions in the repo market, trading toward the upper end of trend lines and frequently breaching them, indicating refinancing difficulties because SOFR rates are above fed funds targets.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“the sofa fed fund spread which is giving you an idea of growing tensions. Now the point is that that spread should be within the tram lines uh or somewhere near the lower tram line. uh it's basically been trading since the middle of last year towards the upper end of the trend line and has frequently breached that trend line uh which is showing that you've got refinancing difficulties”

0.43

The current 65-month liquidity cycle reading is approximately 50 and projects to peak at a lower level than the 2021-22 peak, due to slower world economic growth and lower liquidity demand, but the exact peak timing depends on whether central banks ease rather than tighten.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Michael Howell

“the current reading um is about 50 or there or thereabouts. U there's been a lot of volatility over the last uh few months. That volatility is caused entirely by China.”

0.43

Gold does not have investor risk appetite as a systematic influence (unlike Bitcoin), making it a 'pure liquidity play' that benefits from monetary expansion regardless of equity market sentiment.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Howell

“that risk appetite element is not does not feature uh in the influences on gold. So gold is a pure liquidity play.”

0.42

Howell doubts Bitcoin will reach all-time highs in this run, though he may be proven wrong; the risk of a pullback to the $70,000s is real but would likely be a mid-year or Q3 event depending on the depth of a US recession.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“Would you expect to see Bitcoin back down in the 70s or at all-time highs first? Well, I think the answer is uh I would I would doubt if you're going to get to all-time highs this run. Um I may be proved wrong what I would doubt. I think the risk of pull a pull back towards the 70,000s is real but I think that's much more uh I would venture a sort of midyear maybe Q33 event”

0.40

This is a trader market, not really an investment market right now, due to the volatility and uncertainty, but looking forward 12 months, investors can definitely buy on weakness.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“we think that uh this is a trader market, not really an investment market right now, but you know, if I look forward 12 months, u I think you can definitely buy on weakness.”

0.39

The projected liquidity cycle peak will come at a lower level than the peak seen in 2021-22, primarily because the COVID emergency caused absolute economic crash that required massive central bank liquidity injection, whereas a slowing economy doesn't need as much liquidity and throws it back to financial markets (double whammy effect).

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“our projections would uh suggest that it peaks at a lower level than the peak that we saw in 202122. Okay. Uh in the last cycle and there are reasons for that. Um but the main reason is that the world economy in that period the COVID emergency basically ab absolutely crashed and central banks had to come come in with elacrity and with size to actually inject all of liquidity back into the system and a very very slow economy basically uh doesn't need liquidity so it throws it back to financial markets. So you kind of got a double whammy.”

0.39

The Fed's stated policy of no QE in the near term will change; there are two possible explanations: either political considerations (Trump vs. Powell dynamic) or realistic expectations that the Fed will eventually be forced to expand despite current rhetoric.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“Do you think they will change their policy or what would they need to see in order to expand or do you think it's just inevitable and they're playing the political game and holding their their cards close to their chest right now? Well, I think if you look at I mean I I'll say two things...It basically shows that you know in the second half of this year the Federal Reserve is slated on current policies and uh announcements to actually withdraw liquidity from the system. That doesn't look realistic...That's what I expect to happen, but it's not happening yet. And it may be politics. I mean, why would JPAL now stand up and say he's going to expand liquidity? It certainly feels it feels very much like it's a Trump verse battle that's happening right now behind the scenes.”

0.39

There is a prospect of recession in the US or more broadly in the world economy in which the US will be affected, and even if avoided, a sharp growth slowdown will adversely affect credit markets, with credit spreads already starting to blow up.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“the other issue which is looming um is the prospect of recession in the US uh or more particularly let's say recession in the world economy in which the US will also be a casualty and that is something that ought not to be dismissed. It may not transpire that we actually get a recession but we're certainly getting a very sharp slowdown in growth and the even if we avoid the recession or skirt recession the fact is that that big growth slowdown uh is going to be something which affects the credit markets adversely and already you're starting to see credit spreads blowing up.”

0.39

Investors should not be exposed to risk assets now due to high uncertainty about credit markets and economic growth, but should 'keep powder dry' and move back into risk assets as soon as central banks start easing liquidity.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Michael Howell

“my view is that yeah I wouldn't want to be too exposed to risk assets now because there is so much uncertainty about the credit markets and about uh the state of the economy and therefore I'd prefer to keep my powder dry. But as soon as the central banks start to ease liquidity, um what you would uh what you should be doing is moving back again.”

0.39

Current market conditions are choppy and uncertain; Bitcoin is a 'trader market, not really an investment market right now,' with multiple near-term pullback risks, but buying weakness over a 12-month horizon is justified.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Michael Howell

“So, you've got a choppy market. And as we say, I mean, we think that uh this is a trader market, not really an investment market right now, but you know, if I look forward 12 months, u I think you can definitely buy on weakness.”

0.35

The liquidity cycle projection assumes a mild recession, slightly higher oil prices, a slightly weaker dollar (though the dollar remains fairly robust over a 2-3 year view, not radically weak), and elevated bond volatility that doesn't appear to be coming down.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“We've factored in uh a recession uh in the world economy uh a mild recession I'd have to say. We've factored in u an assumption that says that oil prices which are another u drag on liquidity basically drift up slightly. uh we've put in the fact that we uh we also assume that you've got a slightly weaker dollar but you got to remember that the dollar is still fairly robust over a two or three year view. though you know we're not looking at a radically weak dollar uh in looking forward. Uh and the other factor which sort of impinges on this is that bond volatility or the value of collateral which is another input into this system is actually elevated”

0.35

The main big positive for liquidity is the People's Bank of China's actions, and the main big question mark is the Federal Reserve, which on current policy is slated to withdraw liquidity in the second half of the year.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“the main big positive uh is the people's bank of China. The main big negative at the moment is the federal or the main big question mark is the Federal Reserve. But on paper, the Federal Reserve is slated to withdraw liquidity out of the system uh in the second half of the year.”

0.35

The current reading of the liquidity cycle is about 50 or thereabouts, with volatility over the last few months caused entirely by China's stopgo policy in monetary accommodation driven by currency strength or weakness.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“the current reading um is about 50 or there or thereabouts. U there's been a lot of volatility over the last uh few months. That volatility is caused entirely by China. So if you took China out of the data, there'd be a much smoother incline in that line. The reason that China has been uh volatile is that they've been operating a stopgo policy uh in terms of their monetary accommodation and that stopgo policy has really been dictated by strength or weakness in the Chinese UR.”

0.35

Bond market volatility has broken out of the normal zone (gray shaded area around 70 on the volatility index representing 7% annualized) and is now in a heightened period at levels around 150, approaching what Howell terms the danger zone when the system starts to break down.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Michael Howell

“the normal zone uh is shown as that gray shaded area and we've broken out of that very clearly and we're now in a heightened uh period of volatility and we're dancing around what I've illustrated there as a danger zone when you know the system starts to break down when it gets significantly above about 150. Now for ease of interpretation you can treat that 150 as being basically 15% uh annualized volatility in the bond markets”

0.34

Howell doubts Bitcoin will reach all-time highs in the current cycle, but expects a pullback toward the $70,000s is real and likely a mid-year or Q3 event depending on the depth of a potential US recession.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Michael Howell

“I think the answer is uh I would I would doubt if you're going to get to all-time highs this run. Um I may be proved wrong what I would doubt. I think the risk of pull a pull back towards the 70,000s is real but I think that's much more uh I would venture a sort of midyear maybe Q33 event depending on the depth of of US recession if it transpires.”

0.32

The second quarter of 2025 could see a continuing rebound in markets because markets became seriously oversold about a month prior, and one would expect a normal bounce that may continue.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Michael Howell

“it's not inconceivable that the second quarter could see a continuing rebound of markets. That that's possible. Um because they basically got into a situation uh about a month ago when they were seriously oversold. I think that that's fairly clear. So you would expect some reaction, some bounce and that that may continue.”

0.19

The second quarter may see a continuing market rebound because markets were oversold about a month prior to this interview, and some bounce is expectable from that oversold condition.

forecastestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Michael Howell

“it's not inconceivable that the second quarter could see a continuing rebound of markets. That that's possible. Um because they basically got into a situation uh about a month ago when they were seriously oversold. I think that that's fairly clear. So you would expect some reaction, some bounce and that that may continue.”

0.16

Jay Hamilton suggests that Fed policy obstinacy appears to be 'a Trump verse battle that's happening right now behind the scenes,' implying political constraints on Powell's ability to publicly announce balance sheet expansion.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jay Hamilton

“It certainly feels it feels very much like it's a Trump verse battle that's happening right now behind the scenes.”

0.13

The Milk Road Show is a daily crypto show where markets are so dry that tumbleweeds are holding cash on the sidelines, hosted by Jay Hamilton on X and YouTube.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jay Hamilton

“Good morning. Welcome to the Milk Road Show, the daily crypto show where markets are so dry even tumble weeds are holding cash on the sidelines. I'm your host Jay Hamilton”

0.13

Today's episode is Wednesday, April 30, 2025 (Howell's second appearance on Milk Road Show); Michael Howell is CEO of Crossber Capital, a global research firm focused on monitoring credit, liquidity, and capital flows in 90+ countries.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jay Hamilton

“It's Wednesday, April the 30th...We are very excited to be joined once again by Michael Howell, CEO of Crossber Capital, a global research firm focused on monitoring credit liquidity and capital flows in over 90 countries around the world”