What this covers

This is a Foreign Affairs interview in which senior editor Eve Fairbanks questions the political scientists Steven Levitsky and Lucan Way about their essay on the American path to authoritarianism, a month into Trump's second term. They begin with the definition. Under competitive authoritarianism, opposition parties can still win elections, but the state is systematically turned against critics, so the contest is real and unfair. They argue this is now the dominant form of autocracy: close to 80% of authoritarian regimes hold multi-candidate executive elections, against almost none in the 1970s. They also say American observers were caught off guard because they were still thinking in Cold War terms.

The middle of the conversation sets out the playbook, drawn from Hungary, Turkey, India, Poland, and Venezuela under Hugo Chavez. Purging the independent bureaucracy comes first, because arrest, audit, regulatory, and contracting powers become tools against opponents once career officials no longer block them. The speakers note that first-term efforts to prosecute enemies stalled for just that reason. They also cover the standard claim that the state has been infiltrated, obedience in advance as Timothy Snyder uses the term, and the point that Trump announced much of this beforehand.

The later sections are more contested and more forward-looking. They discuss American history: the Jim Crow South as an 80-year authoritarian enclave, and Reconstruction-era violence as a precedent for political thuggery, which they connect to the January 6 pardons and rising threats against officials. They explain why they expect little Republican defection, citing the ruined careers of Liz Cheney and Adam Kinzinger. They also point to resistance that is easy to miss, such as lawsuits from 19 attorneys general. Their forecasts include a tilted but still competitive 2028 election, more vigilante violence once street-level opposition appears, and a harder argument among Democrats over how much hardball to play.

Sharpest takeaway

The United States is experiencing the early stages of competitive authoritarianism—a regime form where elections continue but the state apparatus is systematically weaponized against opposition—and Trump's second term, unlike his first, has the conditions and personnel to entrench this transformation irreversibly.

  • Trump now controls the Republican Party completely with loyalists replacing institutional checks that constrained him in 2016–2017
  • The blueprint for competitive authoritarianism—civil service purges, state weaponization, media co-optation, and vigilante intimidation—is already visible in Trump's first weeks and matches patterns from Hungary, Turkey, and Venezuela
  • Americans' historical amnesia about past authoritarian episodes (Reconstruction, Jim Crow, McCarthyism) and false complacency from Trump's first-term failure have left the public unprepared to recognize or resist the trajectory

The claims · ranked79 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Purging the civil service and replacing career bureaucrats with loyalists is the first and most important step in constructing competitive authoritarianism because government has enormous power to arrest, investigate, audit, contract, and regulate, which can be weaponized against opposition unless bureaucracies are insulated from political pressure.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Steven Litzky

“basically even in a country like the United States which is relatively less aair uh the government just has enormous power over people's lives it can sort of arrest you it can investigate you it audits you it cont tacts you um for businesses it's you know enormously important in terms of providing contracts in terms of of regulating vast sectors of the economy so leaders just have enormous power to attack opposition and undermine their ability to compete in democratic system which is why all modern democracies you know the United States in the late 19th and early 20th centuries developed a series of measures that basically restricted the ability of politicians to politicize the state kind of created an arms length relationship between many of the bureaucrats”

0.80

The independent civil service and bureaucracy are the most important impediment to creating an authoritarian regime, which is why populist leaders coming to power in Hungary, Turkey, and India have systematically attacked the independent bureaucracy as their first priority.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Steven Levitsky

“all modern democracies you know the United States in the late 19th and early 20th centuries developed a series of measures that basically restricted the ability of politicians to politicize the state kind of created an arms length relationship between many of the bureaucrats who make core decisions that are important for everyday lives like tax audit and partisanship and this was sort of basically what kept democracy intact for the last century and so this has begun to change and this is the most important impediment to kind of creating an authoritarian regime and this is why in countries like Hungary and and turkey and India populists have come to power and this has been they first to attack this sort of independent bureaucracy”

0.80

Competitive authoritarian regimes are characterized by multi-party elections and legal opposition that can win, but the state machinery is systematically weaponized against critics and rivals such that competition is real but not fair, tilting the playing field against opposition.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Steven Levitsky

“competitive authoritarian regimes are regimes that are actually competitive in the sense that there are multi-party elections there is uh the opposition is legal the opposition is above board and competes seriously for power uh and once in a while even wins... from a bit of a distance competitive author regimes may look Democratic but they're not Democratic because systematic weaponization and abuse of the state of the Machinery of government and its deployment against critics and Rivals tilts the playing field against the opposition”

0.80

All authoritarian leaders who purge and pack the state invariably almost without exception claim that the state has been somehow subverted or infiltrated by dangerous elements in order to justify their actions, which is a standard rhetorical move of authoritarianism rather than a factual claim.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Steven Levitsky

“you have to justify it and authoritarians when they weaponize the state invariably almost without exception claim that the state has been somehow subverted or infiltrated by dangerous elements of some sort right to give you an example I mean sort of Victor Orban in Hungary he came to power um again the second time in 2010 and immediately made the argument that the state was controlled by Communists from the 1980s which was just patently false but that was his sort of excuse for undertaking a major attack on the independent bureaucracy”

0.79

Competitive authoritarian regimes became much more widespread after the collapse of communism in the late 1980s because electoral legitimacy became the dominant global political norm, making it costly to rule without elections, so new autocracies have adopted the competitive authoritarian form rather than single-party rule or military dictatorship.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steven Levitsky

“there have been competitive authoritarian regimes at at other times in history but they became much much more widespread after the collapse of communism because beginning in the late 1980s and I would say even still today electoral regimes competitive elections are really the most globally legitimate political Arrangement... it's really costly to just shove aside elections entirely and Rule with a single party is in the Communist era or with the military like P or Franco”

0.75

The blueprint for competitive authoritarian transformation is not new or unpredictable—it is visible in the documented cases of Hungary (Orban), Turkey (Erdogan), India (Modi), and Poland, making Trump's actions foreseeable if one understood the regime form, yet most American observers were surprised because they remained locked in Cold War-era thinking about authoritarianism.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steven Litzky

“there is an established pattern you could look at what Orban what Ugo Chavez what erdogan did and and predict it but there's another reason why the establishment ought not to have been shocked in 2024 2025 Trump said he was going to do all of this and the Republican party has been clear has been Crystal Clear since 2020 2021 that it is willing to acques to if not support an authoritarian project”

0.75

Timothy Snyder calls the phenomenon of businesses and institutions preemptively aligning with Trump before pressure is even applied 'obedience in advance,' and this has already occurred with major corporations.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“Timothy Snyder calls this obedience in advance so even before Trump came to power they were already sort of lining up behind Trump”

0.74

Modern democracies, including the United States in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, developed institutional measures to restrict the ability of politicians to politicize the state and create an arms-length relationship between bureaucrats and partisan pressure, and this remains the core mechanism that preserved democracy for the last century but is now being dismantled.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Steven Litzky

“all modern democracies you know the United States in the late 19th and early 20th centuries developed a series of measures that basically restricted the ability of politicians to politicize the state kind of created an arms length relationship between many of the bureaucrats who make core decisions that are important for everyday lives like tax audit and partisanship and this was sort of basically what kept democracy intact for the last century and so this has begun to change and this is the most important impediment to kind of creating an authoritarian regime”

0.74

The United States did not experience full democracy until 1965 because the Jim Crow South was under single-party authoritarian rule for 80 years and law enforcement turned a blind eye to efforts to prevent Black citizens from voting, tilting the electoral playing field in favor of whites.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Steven Litzky

“there's not a full Democratic regime until 1965 in this country...the US South was under single party authoritarian rule for 80 years...law enforcement actors turned a blind eye to really serious efforts to prevent black citizens to vote and therefore tilted the Electoral playing field in their favor”

0.74

The government has enormous power over people's lives through arrest, investigation, audits, and business regulation, and this power creates opportunities for leaders to attack opposition and undermine their ability to compete in a democratic system.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Steven Levitsky

“the government just has enormous power over people's lives it can sort of arrest you it can investigate you it audits you it cont tacts you um for businesses it's you know enormously important in terms of providing contracts in terms of of regulating vast sectors of the economy so leaders just have enormous power to attack opposition and undermine their ability to compete in democratic system”

0.73

Competitive authoritarian regimes maintain elections and legal opposition but systematically weaponize the state apparatus against opponents, tilting the playing field against the opposition through abuse of power that is systematic enough to prevent fair competition.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Steven Litzky

“Competitive authoritarian regimes are regimes that are actually competitive in the sense that there are multi-party elections there is uh the opposition is legal the opposition is above board and competes seriously for power...from a bit of a distance competitive author regimes may look Democratic but they're not Democratic because systematic weaponization and abuse of the state of the Machinery of government and its deployment against critics and Rivals tilts the playing field against the opposition so competition is real but it's not fair”

0.69

To evaluate whether Democratic weaponization of the state occurred, one should look to reputable organizations like Freedom House that measure democracy and authoritarianism, not to partisan claims by Trump, Vance, or Republicans, because credible democracy monitors have not reported systematic state weaponization by Democratic administrations comparable to what's occurring now.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steven Litzky

“what I do is I Look to um Freedom House reports or other International organizations whose job it is to measure democracy and authoritarianism if they're not reporting that the Democrats weaponize the state and that both parties are assaulting Democratic institutions don't take J D Vance's word for it find a reputable organization or a reputable scholar of political regimes who claims that there was a weaponization of the State uh a systematic weaponization this a comparable weaponization of the State under previous Democratic administrations and then I'll then we can talk seriously”

0.68

Close to 80% of authoritarian regimes now have multi-candidate elections for the executive, compared to almost none in the 1970s when formal single-party rule was standard, making competitive authoritarianism the modal form of authoritarianism since the end of the Cold War.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steven Litzky

“You know in the 1970s almost all authoritarian regimes were kind of formal in the sense that there was no elections to the top executive There Was You Know formal single party Rule now close to 80% of acies of authoritarian regimes have some sort of multi-candidate Elections for the executive”

0.66

Political thuggery seems far-fetched in the contemporary US but is precisely what happened in the US South during and after Reconstruction, and given that the US already has a large armed extremist fringe, threats against politicians and judges have skyrocketed, and Trump pardoned almost all January 6th insurrectionists (giving them a 'huge wink'), this tactic could easily happen here and is quite terrifying.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Steven Litzky

“it seems far-fetched but it is precisely what happened in the US South during and after reconstruction and given that the US already has a large and armed extremist Fringe given that the level of threats against politicians and judges and prosecutors has already skyrocketed in recent years and particularly given the huge wink that Donald Trump gave by pardoning almost all of the January 6th insurrectionists that's something that we see in other competitive authoritarian regimes that I think could easily happen here and is is quite terrifying”

0.66

Trump explicitly told the American public before taking office that he would sue the press, weaponize the IRS and Justice Department against opponents, and pursue prosecutions of political enemies—yet the establishment and media were shocked when he began doing these things in early 2025.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Steven Levitsky

“Donald Trump promised to do with a partial exception of the Doge stuff promised to do every single one of the things that that he was doing lawsuits against the Press wielding the IRS and the justice department against the pronus he told us he was going to do this so how the establishment was shocked that this is going on quite frankly is beyond me”

0.66

Efforts to prosecute political enemies like John Kerry and Hillary Clinton were attempted in Trump's first term but 'never really saw the light of day' because career government officials blocked them before they could take shape.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lucan Way

“various efforts to um prosecute people like John KY and Hillary Clinton sort of never really saw the light of day in large part because career government officials basically Nick them before they could sort of take shape”

0.64

No democracy as rich or as old as U.S. democracy has ever broken down, and even dating the U.S. democratic system from 1965, it is over 50 years old—and no democracy over 50 years old has ever died—which creates false complacency about the prospects for democratic breakdown.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Levitsky

“this is unusual territory no democracy even remotely as rich or as old as US democracy ever broken down no democracy over the age of 50 has ever died ever and even if you take the birth date of us democracies 1965 were above 50 and so um old Rich democracies never die and that's another reason for complacency”

0.64

Every principled conservative who stood up for the rule of law, Constitution, and democracy since 2016—including Cheney and Kinzinger—has seen their immediate career prospects completely destroyed, creating a powerful disincentive for large-scale Republican defection.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Levitsky

“I just find it really hard to imagine there have been a lot of Danielle suon since 2016 there's been a drippage of principled conservatives who stood up for the rule of law and stood up for the Constitution stood up for democracy and as luk pointed out every single one of them has seen their uh at least their immediate career prospects completely destroyed”

0.64

There is significant opposition happening in the U.S. that many people don't fully appreciate, including 19 attorney generals who have filed suits against various Trump actions and DOGE-Musk activities, suggesting that the legal system is still functioning as a check on executive power.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Levitsky

“there's more opposition now going on than sort of many of us appreciate you know I think there a lot of it's being done through the legal system with the 19 um attorney generals who filed suit against the um various actions by Doge and musk”

0.63

There will be a more serious debate and self-criticism within the Democratic Party about how dirty they should play—whether to engage in hardball tactics, play rough, or even engage in authoritarian behavior against Trump—which is a very difficult set of questions that all opposition movements in competitive authoritarian regimes face.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Steven Litzky

“there will be a more serious debate and there is a more serious debate about how dirty should the Democrats play should they be willing to play hard ball against or or even engage in authoritarian Behavior against Trump that's a very very difficult set of questions but it's it is a set of questions that opposition's everywhere had to figure out okay you know what are do we cross these lines too do we take off the gloves do we cheat do we bend the rules do we play hard ball th those are a difficult set of choices that that the Democratic party has to make”

0.59

The Republican Party decided to nominate Trump for president again after he tried to overturn the 2020 election and block a peaceful transfer of power, signaling its willingness to acquiesce to or support an authoritarian project.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Steve Levitsky

“Donald Trump tried to overturn the results of the 2020 election and block a peaceful transfer of power and the Republican Party decided to nominate him for president again”

0.57

While some Republicans hope for an emerging intra-party opposition to Trump, this is unlikely because the career cost to people who oppose Trump is enormous—as seen in Cheney and Kinzinger who faced career destruction—and historically, large-scale defections from ruling coalitions in competitive authoritarian regimes require government unpopularity and sense that opposition would protect one's career, conditions not currently present.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Lucan Way

“the career cost to people doing this is just so enormous um you look at sort of Cheney and kininger and what they've had to go through these are two Republican courageously came out in opposition to Trump um it's just kind of hard to imagine that many uh would follow that path and I think it's basically if you look at other competitive authoritarian regime they've really had large scale defections or you know Mass defections from the ruling Coalition when the the government is incredibly unpopular when there's sort of the sense that there's a danger to one's career and sort of livelihood by sort of remaining loyal right and right now you know very far from that in the United States”

0.57

The Democratic Party is currently shell-shocked with little street-level opposition to the Trump Administration, and this lack of fierce opposition has partly kept violence down, but when opposition emerges, much more vigilante violence will likely occur.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Lucan Way

“we're sort of now almost in this per period uh we can talk about this the Democratic party is in some ways kind of Shell Shocked you know there really hasn't been opposition you know at least on the streets and as a result I think partly you know that's kind of kept violence down because there hasn't been kind of ferous opposition but when it does emerge I think we're going to see much more of this kind of vigilante violence”

0.57

By 2028, assuming Trump doesn't find a way to grant himself a third term, there will be a competitive election, but the playing field will be tilted by government use of carrots and sticks through economic and regulatory policy, voter intimidation, and election worker intimidation that may escalate beyond recent norms.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Litzky

“come 2028 presuming that Trump does not find a way to give himself a third term he can't redo the Constitution so he he can't run again it's a competitive election between Democrats and Republicans...the Trump ad Administration could make it clear that voter intimidation tactics maybe not quite as violent as the 1870s in the US South but voter intimidation tactics are are encouraged or allowed that that could change the vote and the other thing we don't know is just how much the government's use of carrots and sticks in in terms of Economic and Regulatory policy just how much of the private sector sector's arm the government's going to be able to twist”

0.57

Democratic Party leadership has been doing politics the same way their entire careers, with politicians like Schumer and Pelosi operating under established playbooks, but the rules of politics are changing on multiple dimensions including authoritarian tactics and media technology changes, requiring Democratic adaptation to 2020s political conditions.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Litzky

“politicians in both parties but particularly the Democratic party have been doing Politics the same way their whole life I mean maybe they learned how to tweet in the last decade but Schumer's been doing politics a long time Nancy Pelosi has been doing politics a long time the entire Democratic party's leadership knows one way of doing politics and politics are changing on a number of Dimensions some of some are authoritarian others just have to do with the changes in media technology the attention economy”

0.57

Timothy Snyder calls the business sector's alignment with Trump before he took office 'obedience in advance'—a preemptive capitulation where elites align with authoritarian power before being forced to do so, clearing the field for authoritarian consolidation.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“Timothy Snyder calls this and we quote this in the piece obedience in advance so even before Trump came to power they were already sort of lining up behind Trump”

0.57

One of the facets of authoritarian consolidation that is hard to see is the opposition that might have materialized in a less threatening environment but never did—young lawyers who decide not to run for office, citizens who decide not to join protests—this invisible opposition depletion is potentially worse than visible opposition to authoritarianism.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Eve Fairbanks

“the depletion of societal opposition to authoritarianism may be worse than it appears in any given time already we can observe when key political players sideline themselves when politicians retire when University presidents resign but it is harder to see the opposition that might have materialized in a less threatening environment but never did the young lawyers who decide not to run for office the countless citizens who decide not to join a protest”

0.56

Many social scientists who rely on historical data estimate there is a 0% chance of democratic breakdown in the United States, which is patently ridiculous and represents a stunning failure of political science to predict or even consider the possibility.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Lucan Way

“a lot of the social scientists who rely on historical data basically say there's a 0% chance of democratic breakdown in the United States which is just patently ridiculous I mean it is a really I think Steve and I have talked about this a lot this is really a kind of in many ways a stunning failure of political science”

0.56

Media companies in the United States are part of larger conglomerates with interests in aerospace and other sectors deeply affected by federal decision-making, making them incredibly vulnerable to pressure from Trump and creating incentives to cooperate with or capitulate to the Trump Administration rather than maintain independent journalism.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lucan Way

“the problem really comes down to the fact that in the sort of modern economy of the United States media companies are part of larger conglomerates that have interest in a wide variety of areas Aerospace Amazon and others that are deeply affected by federal decision-making as a result these companies are incredibly vulnerable to pressure by Trump”

0.56

When powerful figures like Jeff Bezos and Mark Zuckerberg capitulate and newspapers fold, the collective action problem in civil society becomes paralyzing—each individual has incentives to protect their own organization, but when everyone does this, the democratic movement overall is badly weakened.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Steven Levitsky

“when you see Jeff Bezos and Mark Zuckerberg getting on their knees and when you see newspapers folding and CEOs who you know know better politicians who you know no better surrendering it can be paralyzing it can be debilitating... there is this Collective action problem that we have is that each individual has each individual Civil Society leader every University president every CEO every editor every uh parent company of a major uh media outlet has to take care of their shareholders their University make sure that they don't face frivolous lawsuits that can be costly that they don't face investigations tax charges they've got to take care of themselves and their organizations and there's a strong tendency when you're worried about the bottom line when there are maybe billions of dollars at stake or a an endowment tax coming or a costly defamation suit coming or or an investigation coming there are strong incentives to just okay you know I'm going to take care of myself I'm just going to step to the sideline for a year or two but when everybody does that the Democracy movement overall Civil Society overall is badly weakened”

0.52

Opposition to authoritarianism faces powerful emotional forces pushing people toward the sideline: a mix of fear, exhaustion, resignation, and pragmatism where people have spent years fighting only to ask 'for what?' and where seeing powerful people like Jeff Bezos and Mark Zuckerberg capitulate makes continued struggle feel paralyzing and debilitating.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“there's a a mix of fear and exhaustion and resignation and in some cases just sheer pragmatism the different mixes for different people but there there are a number of forces a number of emotional forces pushing us toward the sideline you know in my case I feel like there there are many times each day I think to myself I spent eight years doing this and for for what Right For What and it it is exhausting and then to get to your point Eve when you see other people around you people who are more powerful wealthier better positioned better able to defend themselves than you are Jeff basos is in a much better position than I am um when I see Jeff Bezos and Mark Zuckerberg getting on their [Music] knees and when you see newspapers folding and CEOs who you know know better politicians who you know no better surrendering it can be paralyzing it can be debilitating”

0.52

Americans lack experience with modern authoritarianism and therefore operate with complacency similar to people who have never experienced measles or polio and therefore won't take vaccines—no one has experienced this kind of authoritarianism before so they figure it can't happen to them.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“it's similar to with vaccines right now there sort of a lot of the opposition to vaccines is a function that people have never experienced measles they've never experienced a lot of these polio and horrible diseases so they're kind of complacent and they're you know unwilling to take vaccines and I think it's because you know no one's experienced this kind of authoritarianism before that they sort of figure can't happen to them”

0.52

Political polarization and the rigidity of party identification in the US are protective factors because while Trump cannot rise to 80% approval like some authoritarian leaders, he also cannot drop to 15-20% as seen in other countries, creating a stable floor of roughly 50% support that makes complete regime capture more difficult.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eve Fairbanks

“one of the things that distinguishes the US maybe a little bit from some other some other competitive authoritarian regimes is the degree of political polarization and the sort of stasis of party identification and in one sense that's a bit protective you talk about how much much damage and how much change a person with an 80% approval rate riding in can do and you knowe that one of the potential sources of resilience in the United States is that Trump is I think hovering just below 50 and can't barely crack that number he doesn't have that level of support but on the other hand it seems very very difficult for him to drop to 20 15% as you see in some other places because of this just in incredible rigidity of this two-party system”

0.52

A core difference between the United States and places like Hungary and Turkey is that the US is a much more developed capitalist economy with wealth far more distributed across society, a much stronger legal system, and much stronger institutions, making it harder even for someone like Trump to successfully implement authoritarianism.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“one of the core differences between the United States in places like Hungary and turkey is that we're just a much more developed capitalist economy wealth is far more distributed across Society the legal system is much stronger the institutions are much stronger so really it's much harder for even someone like Trump who's you know died in the world autocrat and basically well to almost do anything to be successful so I think we have to distinguish between sort of his abuse of power versus the impact of that abusive of power”

0.52

The United States is likely trapped in Cold War-era thinking about authoritarianism, imagining only traditional dictatorships with repressive features and locked-up opposition, which prevents Americans from recognizing the emerging competitive authoritarian threat.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steven Levitsky

“even today I think we have the sense in the United States maybe we're a little bit behind in our way of thinking or a little stuck in the Cold War and we think of these dictatorships where opposition parties are locked up and that really have repressive features”

0.52

The Democratic Party must decide whether to play hardball against Trump, potentially crossing ethical lines or bending rules, though there is no clear answer to these difficult questions.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steven Levitsky

“there will be a more serious debate and there is a more serious debate about how dirty should the Democrats play should they be willing to play hard ball against or or even engage in authoritarian Behavior against Trump that's a very very difficult set of questions but it's it is a set of questions that opposition's everywhere had to figure out okay you know what are do we cross these lines too do we take off the gloves do we cheat do we bend the rules do we play hard ball th those are a difficult set of choices that that the Democratic party has to make and there's no clear answer”

0.52

The United States had elements of authoritarianism in its past—Nixon politicized the IRS in the 1970s, and the Jim Crow South was a system of competitive authoritarianism where law enforcement turned a blind eye to voter suppression—but the current period is fundamentally different because Trump faces no institutional constraints, whereas Nixon was forced to resign when Republicans in Congress signaled they would convict him on impeachment.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steven Levitsky

“the most obvious example is Richard Nixon in the 1970s but I also think it's really important to understand that we are in a completely different era than we were in the 197s you know Nixon resigned in 1974 because he knew that Republican would convict him after his impeachment by the house none of this is the case now Trump faces literally no restrictions on his activity there's really sort of no no checks on his power which is quite different from from what it's been in the past”

0.52

Americans have not experienced authoritarianism in the modern era, creating false complacency analogous to vaccine hesitancy among those who have never seen measles or polio—people figure that if they haven't experienced it, it can't happen to them.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“I also think it's similar to with vaccines right now there sort of a lot of the opposition to vaccines is a function that people have never experienced measles they've never experienced a lot of these polio and horrible diseases so they're kind of complacent and they're you know unwilling to take vaccines and I think it's because you know no one's experienced this kind of authoritarianism before that they sort of figure can't happen to them”

0.52

Competitive authoritarian regimes often employ football clubs and vigilante groups to beat up protesters while providing plausible deniability to the regime, and this pattern may explain why some Republicans opposed impeachment in 2021 despite its clear justification.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“competitive Authority regime sort of rely not just on the on the formal agents the police and the like but on sort of football clubs and other other kind of Vigilantes to sort of beat up protesters and provide a kind of a veneer of plausible deniability to the regime and this is kind of stuff that as Steve mentioned already kind of infects the system it's it's as we mentioned in the piece probably explains why some Republicans opposed impeachment after in 2021 when the the grounds for impeachment were just utterly obvious”

0.52

In the breakdown of competitive authoritarian regimes, defection from the ruling coalition often happens from within the ruling party, but this is only likely when the government becomes extremely unpopular; right now in the U.S., Trump is still highly popular within Republican ranks.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“I mean this is certainly if you look at the breakdown of competitive authoritarian regimes very often happens from within the ruling Coalition and I mean I certainly hope that's right I I'm I think both Steve and I can see why Steve is shaking his head quite skeptical that this is going to happen I mean the career cost to people doing this is just so enormous”

0.52

The United States has a much larger and more distributed capitalist economy, a much stronger legal system, and much stronger institutions than Hungary or Turkey, which makes it harder for even Trump, who is skilled at wielding authoritarian tools, to successfully impose authoritarianism.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“one of the core differences between the United States in places like Hungary and turkey is that we're just a much more developed capitalist economy wealth is far more distributed across Society the legal system is much stronger the institutions are much stronger so really it's much harder for even someone like Trump who's you know died in the world autocrat and basically well to almost do anything to be successful so I think we have to distinguish between sort of his abuse of power versus the impact of that abusive of power”

0.52

Settlements between ABC and CBS and Meta involving defamation suits are 'almost certainly' going to result in self-censorship by the media and mitigation of criticism of the Trump administration during this term, and represent a major concession by media in shrinking the space for free press.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“these are settlements made between ABC and very likely CBS also and also meta that are almost certainly going to result in kind of a a kind of self-censorship by the media and sort of mitigation of criticism of the Trump Administration during this term so I actually find that that is something that is already occurring right now these are settlements of defamation suits that the companies almost certainly would have won but because their parent companies had other economic interests at play that could be threatened by the Trump Administration they decided to settle which is a major concession by the media in terms of shrinking the space for free press”

0.52

Trump's pardon of almost all January 6th insurrectionists was a signal ('a huge wink') that vigilante political violence and intimidation will be tolerated and shielded from prosecution, consistent with the pattern of competitive authoritarian regimes.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steven Levitsky

“given that the US already has a large and armed extremist Fringe given that the level of threats against politicians and judges and prosecutors has already skyrocketed in recent years and particularly given the huge wink that Donald Trump gave by pardoning almost all of the January 6th insurrectionists that's something that we see in other competitive authoritarian regimes that I think could easily happen here”

0.52

Trump's first term differed fundamentally from his second because in 2016 he had no plan, no team, virtually no allies in the Republican Party, was forced to rely on establishment figures committed to democracy, and did not control the party—so his worst instincts were held in check by career government officials and mainstream Republicans.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“in the first term when Trump was first elected in 2016 you know really no one expected him to win he was himself quite surprised he had you know just undertaken a kind of hostile takeover of the Republican Party he had virtually no allies in the party and so he was basically forced to rely on many establishment figures who shared basic uh commitment to the democratic system and he also had no plan coming in he was you know was very ad hoc and as a result many of his kind of worst instincts were held in check various efforts to um prosecute people like John KY and Hillary Clinton sort of never really saw the light of day in large part because career government officials basically Nick them before they could sort of take shape”

0.52

Political scientists who rely on historical data largely predict a 0% chance of democratic breakdown in the United States, which represents a stunning failure of political science to predict or warn about the authoritarianism that has emerged.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“if you look at s a lot of the social scientists who rely on historical data basically say there's a 0% chance of democratic breakdown in the United States which is just patently ridiculous I mean it is a really I think Steve and I have talked about this a lot this is really a kind of in many ways a stunning failure of political science to to really not predict this at all”

0.50

Danielle Sauzon, an acting US attorney for the Southern District of New York and former clerk for Antonin Scalia, stepped down rather than follow an abnormal request to dismiss charges against the New York mayor as a quid pro quo, representing one of the rare instances of principled resistance to Trump administration pressure.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Eve Fairbanks

“let's take the resignation of Danielle suon the acting us attorney for the southern district of New York uh former clerk for Antonin Scalia she steep down rather than follow this very abnormal request to dismiss charges against the New York mayor as a quid pro quo”

0.49

The opposition will reach a better position when it becomes first acceptable and then eventually cool to stand up to Trump, and Litzky believes there's a good chance this will happen, suggesting that social norms around opposing Trump can shift if his failures mount.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Steven Litzky

“when it becomes first acceptable and second eventually cool to stand up to Trump will be in a better place and I I think that there's a good chance that that will happen”

0.49

The business sector's capitulation to Trump is not based on loyalty but on rational calculation of power, so if circumstances shift and Trump becomes weak or unpopular, business would abandon him just as quickly as it aligned with him.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Steven Litzky

“you saw this incredibly depressing great capitulation of much of the business sector almost immediately after Trump was elected these are not loyal people to Trump you know the minute they put their finger in the wind and things are blowing away from Trump I could easily imagine these people abandoning them just as quickly as as they went to him”

0.48

The Trump administration's second term is fundamentally different from the first because Trump now has complete control over the Republican Party with no internal dissent, whereas in 2016 he had undertaken a hostile takeover of a party where he had virtually no allies, forcing him to rely on establishment figures committed to democracy who constrained his worst instincts.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“In the first term when Trump was first elected in 2016 you know really no one expected him to win he was himself quite surprised he had you know just undertaken a kind of hostile takeover of the Republican Party he had virtually no allies in the party and so he was basically forced to rely on many establishment figures who shared basic uh commitment to the democratic system and he also had no plan coming in he was you know was very ad hoc and as a result many of his kind of worst instincts were held in check”

0.48

The sense that opposition to Trump is a career killer creates exhaustion and resignation among potential opponents, making it psychologically difficult to continue resistance even when one knows it is necessary.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steven Levitsky

“there there are a number of forces a number of emotional forces pushing us toward the sideline you know in my case I feel like there there are many times each day I think to myself I spent eight years doing this and for for for what Right For What and it it is exhausting”

0.48

There is an established playbook for competitive authoritarianism that Trump and other leaders have followed: one can look at what Orbán, Hugo Chávez, and Erdoğan did to predict what would happen in the U.S., but Trump explicitly told Americans he would do all of these things and the Republican Party made clear since 2020-2021 that it is willing to support an authoritarian project.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steven Levitsky

“there is an established pattern you could look at what Orban what Ugo Chavez what erdogan did and and predict it but there's another reason why the establishment ought not to have been shocked in 2024 2025 Trump said he was going to do all of this and the Republican party has been clear has been Crystal Clear since 2020 2021 that it is willing to acques to if not support an authoritarian project”

0.48

Unsexy bureaucrats are really on the front lines of preserving democracy today, as the independent bureaucracy has been the institutional barrier protecting democratic norms from politicization.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steven Levitsky

“these bureaucrats they sort of unsexy bureaucrats are really on the front lines of preserving democracy today”

0.48

Political thuggery—threats of violence, gangs, militias, and armed groups engaged in political intimidation on the ground to silence civil society and threaten politicians, shielded by the judiciary—is used in some competitive authoritarian regimes to consolidate power, and this occurred in the U.S. South during and after Reconstruction.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steven Levitsky

“one thing I worry a lot about and which you see not in all competitive authoritarian regimes but in some competitive authoritarian regimes is the use of political thuggery threats of violence gangs militias armed groups sometimes heavily armed sometimes not but the use of of political intimidation on the ground to silence Civil Society actors and to threaten politicians and they do it shielded by the Judiciary so they engage in illegal Behavior nowhere is it legal to you know go beat up opposition at at rallies but if the attorney general or the prosecutors or the justice department give you a wink then turn a are willing to turn a blind eye which often happens in competitive auor regimes then these guys get a certain free rank they get a blank check to engage in intimidation politics that seems far-fetched but it is precisely what happened in the US South during and after reconstruction”

0.47

In modern media, media companies are part of larger conglomerates with interests in sectors deeply affected by federal decision-making (e.g., aerospace), making them incredibly vulnerable to pressure from Trump, and this vulnerability has convinced many businesses to openly ally with the Trump administration in what has been called the 'great capitulation.'

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lucan Way

“in the sort of modern economy of the United States media companies are part of larger conglomerates that have interest in a wide variety of areas Aerospace Amazon and others that are deeply affected by federal decision-making as a result these companies are incredibly vulnerable to pressure by Trump right but more broadly the sort of you know the ways in which business can benefit from good relations with Trump have convinced a massive number of businesses to go in and sort of openly Ally with the Trump Administration Michelle goldber called this and we quote this in the piece the great capitulation”

0.47

A constitutional crisis and court resistance to Trump's actions represent a relatively better outcome than complete authoritarian consolidation, and some kind of resistance or constitutional conflict is actually an optimistic outcome in competitive authoritarianism.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steven Levitsky

“one thing um I think in in a sense a constitutional crisis is a relatively better outcome in the sense that if you see actual courts not accepting Trump's actions as legal I mean that is already kind of a healthy outcome it still may end up being that Trump I mean the thing that I worry more than I when we first wrote this article was that Trump could just decide to ignore the law at all and just sort of engage in this activity but I still think that some kind of resistance or some kind of constitutional crisis is actually to me an optimistic outcome in some ways”

0.46

American democracy will 'break down' during the second Trump Administration 'in the sense that it will cease to meet standard criteria for Liberal democracy,' though not through destruction of the Constitution or imprisonment of opposition, but rather through erosion of the procedures and norms that make elections fair.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Eve Fairbanks

“American democracy will likely break down during the second Trump Administration in the sense that it will cease to meet standard criteria for Liberal democracy...the breakdown of democracy in the United States will not give rise to a classic dictatorship in which elections are a Dam and opposition forces are locked up Trump will not be able to rewrite the Constitution but contemporary authoritarianism does not require the destruction of the Constitutional order”

0.45

Trump now governs with loyalists rather than skilled technocrats or mainstream Republican politicians, there are no adults in the room providing checks on his behavior, and the entire House of Representatives led by Republicans has abdicated its oversight responsibility.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Lucan Way

“Trump came in with no team and no plan the first time around in 2017 and he did not control the Republican party and so he governed with conservative technocrats and a more or less mainstream repu Conservative Republican politicians and they constrained him none of that is true anymore he completely owns the Republican Party there's no dissent there was no check from the Republican Party the entire house of representa ives led by Republicans has abdicated and stepped aside and Trump is governing with loyalists not with either skilled technocrats or republican politicians he's governing with loyalists there are no adults in the room”

0.45

The United States has a big and wealthy enough private sector and upper-middle class that it's unlikely the playing field will become non-competitive, but it's impossible to anticipate just how far intimidation and co-optation will go, leaving significant uncertainty about whether opposition will maintain sufficient resources to compete.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Litzky

“we're pretty sure the playing Field's going to tilt a little bit we're not sure how much my guess I'm still fairly optimistic that that we have a big and Wealthy enough private sector a big and Wealthy enough upper middle class that it's not going to make the election non-competitive but we it's it's impossible at least for me to anticipate just how far that level of intimidation and cooptation is going to go”

0.45

Authoritarian leaders including Trump, Musk, and Vance claim they are undoing Democratic weaponization of the state (specifically citing IRS weaponization by Obama), which is consistent with a standard authoritarian playbook where regime leaders justify purging and packing the state by claiming prior subversion.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eve Fairbanks

“there is a pervasive allegation by Trump himself and by musk and by Vance and by prominent American Republicans who are now in power that what they are doing in fact is undoing the Democrats weaponization of the state that it was the left it was the Democrats you know Barack Obama weaponized the IRS um there many allegations on this front”

0.45

Trump is now more popular within Republican ranks than anyone who opposes him, which means as long as that condition persists there will be no significant defection from the Republican Party.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steve Levitsky

“as long as Trump is the most popular Republican as long as he is more popular within Republican ranks than anyone who opposes him you're not going to see defection”

0.45

A constitutional crisis in which courts reject Trump's actions as illegal is a relatively better outcome than Trump simply ignoring the law, because court resistance represents a healthy check and sign that opposition institutions are functioning.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steve Levitsky

“I think in in a sense a constitutional crisis is a relatively better outcome in the sense that if you see actual courts not accepting Trump's actions as legal I mean that is already kind of a healthy outcome it still may end up being that Trump I mean the thing that I worry more than I when we first wrote this article was that Trump could just decide to ignore the law at all”

0.45

Trump and those in power are just very bad at governing and dealing with core problems that people care about like the economy and national security, so his firing of officials and disruption of agencies will almost certainly lead to catastrophic outcomes that will decrease his popularity and wake up the population, reviving outrage.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Lucan Way

“people like Trump are just very bad at governing and at dealing with sort of core problems that people care about like you know the economy and National Security or sort of or airplanes not running into each other and things like that so I think that his kind of fire hose of firing officials and stuff is almost certainly going to lead to you know a variety of catastrophic outcomes and decrease its popularity but also sort of I think kind of wake a lot of the population up in terms of Reviving their outrage”

0.45

The Overton window of acceptable Republican opinion has continued to shift in an authoritarian direction—Kash Patel, who would have been unthinkable as a major administration figure in early 2021, is now positioned to become FBI director.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Levitsky

“the overden window Contin continues to shift in an authoritarian direction right it was Unthinkable in early 2021 it was Unthinkable to allow cash Patel to take a major position in the administration now it looks like he's going to be FBI director”

0.45

Politicians in both parties, especially the Democratic leadership, have been doing politics the same way their whole life and may need to adapt to politics in the 2020s, including engagement in attention economy politics and podcast appearances.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Levitsky

“politicians in both parties but particularly the Democratic party have been doing Politics the same way their whole life... the entire Democratic party's leadership knows one way of doing politics and politics are changing on a number of Dimensions... Democrats do need to learn how to adapt to politics in the 2020s um you know they may have to engage in a little more uh attention economy politics they may have to get on Rogan a bit more whatever”

0.45

Despite cooptation and bullying of CEOs and wealthy Americans, there will likely remain a fair number willing to finance opposition candidates, and the US private sector is large and distributed enough that it may resist complete political control, making elections remain competitive even under authoritarianism.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Levitsky

“my expectation and I hope I'm right my expectation is despite the cooptation and the bullying of a large number of CEOs and and Wealthy Americans there will still be a fair number of wealthy Americans willing to finance Gavin new or Josh shapir or whomever the Democratic Party candidate is”

0.45

By 2028, assuming Trump does not find a way to give himself a third term, the 2028 election will depend on the extent of voter intimidation tactics and the degree to which the government's use of regulatory and economic pressure can distort the political playing field.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Levitsky

“it'll depend on on a number of things first of all will there be a a level of sort of Grassroots intimidation of Voters and election workers we could be in an environment where that remains relatively rare like in recent elections or that could be stepped up you know the Trump ad Administration could make it clear that voter intimidation tactics maybe not quite as violent as the 1870s in the US South but voter intimidation tactics are are encouraged or allowed that that could change the vote and the other thing we don't know is just how much the government's use of carrots and sticks in in terms of Economic and Regulatory policy just how much of the private sector sector's arm the government's going to be able to twist”

0.45

The Democratic Party is currently shell-shocked and there has been little opposition on the streets, which has kept violence down, but when fervent opposition does emerge, there will likely be much more vigilante violence.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Lucan Way

“the Democratic party is in some ways kind of Shell Shocked you know there really hasn't been opposition you know at least on the streets and as a result I think partly you know that's kind of kept violence down because there hasn't been kind of ferous opposition but when it does emerge I think we're going to see much more of this kind of vigilante violence”

0.44

No democracy remotely as rich or old as US democracy has ever broken down, no democracy over 50 years old has ever died, and even dating US democracy from 1965 places it above 50 years old, creating a false sense of complacency based on historical selection bias where observers assume old, rich democracies are immune to breakdown.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Steven Litzky

“no democracy even remotely as rich or as old as US democracy ever broken down no democracy over the age of 50 has ever died ever and even if you take the birth date of us democracies 1965 were above 50 and so um old Rich democracies never die and that's another reason for complacency”

0.43

When assessing claims that Democrats weaponized the state, one should defer to Freedom House reports or other established international organizations that measure democracy and authoritarianism rather than accepting partisan claims by Trump or JD Vance.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steven Levitsky

“what I do is I Look to um Freedom House reports or other International organizations whose job it is to measure democracy and authoritarianism if they're not reporting that the Democrats weaponize the state and that both parties are assaulting Democratic institutions don't take J D Vance's word for it find a reputable organization or a reputable scholar of political regimes who claims that there was a weaponization of the State uh a systematic weaponization this a comparable weaponization of the State under previous Democratic administrations and then I'll then we can talk seriously”

0.42

There is more opposition to Trump occurring than many appreciate, including 19 attorney generals filing suits against various Trump/Doge/Musk actions, and the legal process is still in early days, suggesting that legal mechanisms of resistance remain partly functional.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Lucan Way

“there's more opposition now going on than sort of many of us appreciate you know I think there a lot of it's being done through the legal system with the 19 um attorney generals who filed suit against the um various actions by Doge and musk still very early days I just want to emphasize that it's still very early days”

0.42

It will become first acceptable and eventually cool to stand up to Trump, at which point the U.S. will be in a better place, and there is a good chance this will happen given the current phase of vulnerability.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Levitsky

“we're at a phase right now where the only people willing to to stand up to Trump are Danielle casson and the uh Minister who spoke to Trump in DC about about Mercy but when it becomes first acceptable and second eventually cool to stand up to Trump will be in a better place and I I think that there's a good chance that that will happen”

0.42

The business sector made 'incredibly depressing' capitulations to Trump immediately after his election, but these businesses are not loyal to Trump—they were simply assessing which way the wind was blowing—and could abandon Trump just as quickly if the wind shifts.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Levitsky

“you saw this incredibly depressing great capitulation of much of the business sector almost immediately after Trump was elected these are not loyal people to Trump you know the minute they put their finger in the wind and things are blowing away from Trump I could easily imagine these people abandoning them just as quickly as as they went to him”

0.41

The Overton window has shifted in an authoritarian direction such that it was unthinkable in early 2021 to allow Kash Patel to take a major administration position, but now appears likely he will become FBI director, demonstrating how much the Republican Party has Trumpified.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Steve Levitsky

“the overden window Contin continues to shift in an authoritarian direction right it was Unthinkable in early 2021 it was Unthinkable to allow cash Patel to take a major position in the administration now it looks like he's going to be FBI director this is a party that has completely Trump ised”

0.39

Levitsky's optimism rests on the belief that Trump is bad at governing and dealing with core problems that people care about (economy, national security), so his governance failures will likely lead to catastrophic outcomes, decrease his popularity, and wake up the population to his authoritarianism.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steven Levitsky

“you know the legal process is kind of working itself out and and you know but it's also early days in terms of we haven't yet seen the full impact of Trump's behavior and I think that's where I think some of my biggest optimism comes in the fact that you know people like Trump are just very bad at governing and at dealing with sort of core problems that people care about like you know the economy and National Security or sort of or airplanes not running into each other and things like that so I think that his kind of fire hose of firing officials and stuff is almost certainly going to lead to you know a variety of catastrophic outcomes and decrease its popularity but also sort of I think kind of wake a lot of the population up in terms of Reviving their outrage um at this activity”

0.39

The appearance of 'optimism' in the Levitsky-Way essay is retrospectively too optimistic; they now believe the situation is 'much less confident' than their piece conveyed, particularly about whether core democratic system features will hold.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Lucan Way

“this piece was written you know a few weeks ago it feels to me very optimistic in some some ways if I had to rewrite it um I think both Steve and I are kind of much less confident in the sort of core features of the democratic system than we were”

0.38

Many people hope for Republican opposition to Trump to emerge over time, citing examples like Danielle Suon's resignation as acting U.S. Attorney for SDNY rather than dismiss charges against the New York mayor as a quid pro quo, suggesting Republicans will eventually break with Trump.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Eve Fairbanks

“a lot of people that I talked to seem to be putting a lot of Hope in the possibility of an emerging overtime Republican opposition... let's take the resignation of Danielle suon the acting us attorney for the southern district of New York uh former clerk for Antonin Scalia she steep down rather than follow this very abnormal request to dismiss charges against the New York mayor as a quid pro quo”

0.36

The piece was written a few weeks ago and feels optimistic in retrospect; both authors are much less confident in the core features of the democratic system than when they wrote it, suggesting their pessimism has increased as events have unfolded.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Lucan Way

“this piece was written you know a few weeks ago it feels to me very optimistic in some some ways if I had to rewrite it um I think both Steve and I are kind of much less confident in the sort of core features of the democratic system than we were”

0.26

The state apparatus is like a Titanic—a massive mechanism with tremendous inertial weight—that individual citizens would have difficulty swimming against; this metaphor captures why opposing authoritarianism feels futile to individuals facing a vast state power.

definitionspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eve Fairbanks

“the state is like a Titanic it's a gigantic mechanism that carries a tremendous weight against it and and the sense is that every individual would have a hard time swimming against that current”

0.13

The interviewer notes that the authors' essay provided 'granular predictions' born from 'deep comparative thinking' and offered a 'very different and deeper take' on the Trump presidency compared to other coverage.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Eve Fairbanks

“Stephen luk your peace had a granular pressions that I think was born of really deep comperative thinking and and offered a really really different and deeper take on a very extensively covered moment and future”