
The Shocking Lessons Of History Everyone Has Forgotten - Niall Ferguson
What this covers
This is a conversation between Chris Williamson and the historian Niall Ferguson, built around a single question: how far can the past guide the present? Ferguson begins with the familiar line that history rhymes. He says it is not what Twain wrote, since Twain's image was a kaleidoscope whose pattern shifts while keeping some regularity. He then argues the line misleads in any case. The conversation moves from that point into what he calls bad lesson-learning, with the Iraq invasion as the main example. American planners assumed they would be welcomed as liberators, as in Paris in 1944, when the better lesson was that toppling a dictator and building a stable state is slow and expensive.
The middle of the episode covers a lot of ground. Empires receive a long treatment. The Nazi empire lasted little more than a decade and Rome about a thousand years, so no one can say whether decline takes years or centuries. Ferguson adds that empire was the normal political form in Africa and the Americas as well as in Europe. A long stretch on the printing press follows. He treats it as a decentralized technology that fed the Reformation, about 130 years of religious war, and a witch craze fed by bestselling guides to spotting witches. Other threads include Afghanistan's scientific past, the claim that monarchies are steadier than republics, and the moment in 1941 when Stalin might have been removed by his own colleagues.
Ferguson also takes aim at forecasting. He points to the Federal Reserve missing interest rates by about 500 basis points, the Congressional Budget Office's repeated debt errors, and Nobel-winning economists getting inflation wrong. He also describes the Bullshit Asymmetry Principle. The final stretch turns to American politics, recalling the nativist populism of Dennis Kearney and looking ahead to the 2024 election. One of the more contested claims is Ferguson's admission that choosing a historical analogy often comes down to picking whichever suits your purpose.
Ferguson argues that history is fundamentally unpredictable and non-cyclical due to technological change, natural disasters, and contingency, making simple pattern-matching analogies misleading and arguing instead for systematic comparative analysis across multiple historical cases to inform present decisions.
- The famous 'history doesn't repeat, it rhymes' quote is itself misattributed and inaccurate—Twain compared history to a kaleidoscope with shifting patterns, not a repeating cycle
- Technological innovations (nuclear weapons, the internet, the printing press) fundamentally break historical parallels and make past patterns non-predictive
- Even expert economists and institutions like the Federal Reserve are consistently wrong about economic predictions 12+ months out, showing that modeling historical processes fails regularly
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The quote 'history doesn't repeat itself but it often rhymes' is doubly inaccurate: first, it is not what Mark Twain actually said—Twain said history is like a kaleidoscope where the pattern shifts but has regularity—and second, history doesn't repeat itself in the predictable way people want it to.
“it wasn't what Mark Twain said people usually attribute it to Mark Twain of Huckleberry Finn Fame but actually twin didn't say that he said something much more complex about history being like a kaleidoscope remember those kaleidoscopes who used to have as kids and and the pattern shifts but there's a kind of regularity to it”
Thomas Blackmore/Blackburn was the first person to translate the original Bible from Latin into the common language in the UK and was quickly persecuted and killed, one of the reasons being that if you no longer need the priest as your conduit between yourself and God (if you have personal access), there is a massive loss of control for religious authorities.
“was um was it Thomas Blackmore Thomas Blackburn the first person to translate the original Bible from Latin into the common language in the UK and he was very quick he persecuted and killed and one of the reasons for that was that if you no longer need to have the priest as your conduit between yourself and God if you have a personal relationship there is a massive loss of control there a huge loss of control because they are no longer the vector the the middle bit of The Hourglass that you're getting squeezed through”
Afghanistan in 300-500 A.D. was a bastion of physics, mathematics, and other intellectual fields, showing a stark contrast to what it is today—this illustrates the radical non-linearity of history where once-advanced civilizations can experience complete transformation.
“I had this conversation the other day with a friend who was telling me about Afghanistan in the sort of maybe like three four five hundred A.D and that it was a Bastion of maybe physics and Mathematics and a few other places and we were discussing this sort of weirdness with history that we kind of know unless we do invent a time machine we know all of the things that we're going to know about history”
As the printing press spread throughout Europe from the late 15th century into the 16th century, it was a highly decentralized technology with no central control—printing presses sprung up all over Germany and Northern Europe, and religious reformers like Martin Luther used it to spread criticism of the Roman Catholic Church.
“as the printing press spread throughout Europe from the late 15th century into the 16th century it was a highly decentralized technology you really had no central control printing presses were springing up all over uh Germany and especially Northern Europe and initially religious reformers like Martin Luther said oh great now we can get the truth about the church”
Before long, people were publishing tracts about how to identify witches, with best-selling books designed to help identify witches among the population, which led to a witch craze—a widespread persecution wave against mostly innocent women that resulted in mass executions across parts of Europe, beyond Europe, and in the American colonies.
“before long there are people publishing tracts about how to identify witches you know how to spot a witch there's a whole best-selling book uh are designed to help you identify the witches who live amongst us and these tracts about witchcraft lead to the so-called witch craze a crazy uh persecution wave directed it perfectly innocent uh people mostly women that led to mass executions in all kinds of Parts uh of Europe and Beyond Europe and in the American colonies”
There was 130 years of religious warfare after the printing press began disseminating religious ideas—Catholics began publishing tracts saying Luther was a heretic and should be killed, leading to prolonged conflict.
“you have 130 years of religious Warfare after the printing press stops being used to disseminate religious ideas because not long before the Catholics are publishing their tracks saying that Luther's a heretic and he too should be killed”
One of the most interesting things learned about witch trials is that spectral evidence (essentially hysterical eyewitness testimony about a poltergeist in the room) was being used, sometimes for months or years, until the head magistrate/biggest authority figure questioned whether spectral evidence was actually valid.
“spectral evidence was one of the most interesting things I learned about when looking at the witch trials that um they were using this spectral evidence which was essentially like hysterical eyewitness testimony done done to a poltergeist in the room that said yes she is actually a witch and these things have been going on for months maybe even years and then they got in contact somehow with the head court or whatever the equivalent was there the biggest magistrate in America and they said this um we've been doing a lot of these cases based on spectral evidence that's um that's all right isn't it”
Dennis Kearney of the Californian Workers Party (late 19th century) had policies including border closure, keeping out immigrants (specifically Chinese immigrants), anti-elitism, and positioning himself as a common man without pretensions—a populist combination that has appeared in American politics before but is currently forgotten.
“there was a guy named Dennis Kearney who led something called the Californian Workers Party in the late 19th century and kearney's position was that we had to close the border and keep out building the immigrants he actually had built the wall as a slogan there's a cartoon showing a wall being built across San Francisco Harbor he was anti-chinese that was a big part of of cuny's appeal he was anti-elitist he was really uh somebody who kind of relished being a common man without any pretensions and all the policies that Kearney stood for including restriction of immigration and China bashing I mean that that has all been in American politics before but it's been forgotten”
Empires show massive discrepancy in duration: the Nazi Empire barely lasted more than a decade (or less than a decade if counting only from the reoccupation of the Rhineland), while the Roman Empire lasted about a thousand years, making it impossible to predict whether imperial decline takes years or centuries.
“when you sit down with all the empires that ever existed the first thing you realize is there's this massive discrepancy uh in duration that the Nazi Empire barely made it past a decade and in fact if you only start counting from the reoccupation of the Rhineland it's not even that and the Roman Empire is like a thousand years so Gibbon's great Decline and fall of the Roman Empire covers a millennium so you don't know I mean sure the empires rise and they have a good good kind of period of dominance and then they Decline and fall but is it going to happen in a few years or is it going to take a few centuries there's no way of knowing”
Monarchies tend to be more stable than republics because they have a personification of the state that is above partisan politics, whereas in republics everything is all-or-nothing bipartisan conflict.
“that's why monarchies turn out to be more stable than republics because you have a personification of uh of the state that is above partisan politics that in the Republic it's all uh or nothing bipartisan conflict”
History is not regular, cyclical, or predictable—it is actually pretty noisy, volatile, and unpredictable, which is what makes understanding it interesting and challenging.
“history is is not regular and cyclical and predictable it's actually pretty noisy and and and volatile and unpredictable and that's that's what makes my life interesting I I can't tell you with any certainty what's going to happen in the next seven days never mind the next 10 years”
There is a concept called the 'bullshit asymmetry principle' which states it takes far less energy to produce bullshit than it does to refute it, which is why the world is filled with unrefuted bullshit, especially on TV and probably on podcasts too.
“there's a concept called the [ __ ] asymmetry principle which is it takes far less energy to produce [ __ ] than it does to refute it therefore the world is filled with unrefuted [ __ ] and right especially TV especially on TV”
We can still understand historical figures like Thucydides and Shakespeare because they expressed the human condition around love, death, and power, which hasn't changed much despite radically altered lifespans and the nature of life due to technology—this is remarkable and worth studying.
“which is why we can understand Thucydides it's why we can understand Shakespeare uh The Human Condition particularly when it comes to Love and Death and power that hasn't really changed much even Although our lifespans are much longer than the people of thucydides time and the nature of life has radically altered... it's remarkable how amazing is that the people who were born thousands of years ago when life expectancy was in the 20s can express themselves in ways that we can understand”
Technological innovation that accelerates from the late 18th century (exponential growth in living standards from the Industrial Revolution, unintended consequences of labor-saving technology) makes historical patterns non-transferable—for example, nuclear weapons mean war in 2024 cannot be understood by learning from 1914.
“there's a critical difference that I've just hinted at which is that the there is this technological innovation that really starts to accelerate from the late 18th century and and makes the world different uh decade after decade... once you have nuclear weapons War can never be quite the same again uh and so you can't really perfectly learn from 1914 what to do in 2024 because in 1914 although they could they could risk a massive conventional War there wasn't the possibility of utter planetary destruction”
Disasters—both natural (volcanic eruptions, earthquakes, cataclysmic floods, plagues) and man-made (wars)—happen in a totally non-cyclical way with no pattern to their incidence, and this chaotic environment in which humans pursue power and love means there can be no cycle of history because the shocks are statistically unpatterned.
“disasters we may be kind of the same Homo sapiens as the ancient Athenians but we inhabit a planet where all kinds of random stuff happens and we can't control it uh the disasters that constantly punctuate history uh massive volcanic eruptions enormous earthquakes cataclysmic floods are plagues all that kind of natural stuff and then the man-made calamities as we like to call them like Wars these things happen in a totally non-cyclical way there's just no pattern to the incidence of large-scale uh organized violence uh there's no pattern to the incidence of of massive volcanic activity and that's why there's no cycle of History”
Most history is about empires, but not only Western European empires—Africans, Incas, and Aztecs also did empire, which was the standard form of historical polity everywhere, not only in Western Europe.
“most history is as I said earlier it's kind of Empires but in all kinds of strange places I mean let's not pretend it was only people in Western Europe who did Empire they were really late to the Empire game everybody else would be doing Empires for centuries including Africans including the Incas and the Aztecs Empire is actually the standard form of of historical uh polity and it's it's everywhere”
The truth is there's no real way to be sure which historical analogy is the right one—you just pick the one that suits your journalistic or political purpose, which is the 'terrible truth' of historical analogy.
“but if I'm being absolutely uh brutally honest uh there's there's no real way to be sure which analogy is the right one that that's that's the that's the terrible truth we don't know”
People like the idea that history repeats itself or echoes because it gives them a sense of control—it makes them believe they have a prediction engine that allows them to work out what's going to happen in the future if they read enough of the past.
“I think one of the reasons that people like and are comforted by the idea that history repeats itself or Echoes is it gives us a sense of control it it makes us believe that we have a prediction engine that we can if we read enough of the past we can accurately work out what's going to go on in the future”
Even now, the best-paid economists in the world on Wall Street and at the International Monetary Fund do a terribly bad job predicting what growth and inflation will be 12 months from now.
“the the people with the most Kudos at the international monetary fund uh they do a terribly bad job even of predicting what growth and inflation will be 12 months from now”
Stalin could have been arrested by his Politburo colleagues when Hitler invaded the Soviet Union—Stalin retreated to his dacha in panic expecting arrest, but his colleagues instead asked him to return to Moscow because they couldn't function without being terrorized by him, representing a moment that could have produced a completely different 20th century outcome.
“Stalin retreated to his Dutcher in a kind of state of panic and wondered when his colleagues in the Pollock Bureau would turn up and arrest him as he'd arrested many of his colleagues in the past they did turn up and he kind of expected them to put on the handcuffs and instead they kind of said please come back to Moscow we we can't actually function without uh being terrorized by you”
Nobel Prize-winning economists have been wrong again and again about major economic shocks over the last 20 years: from the 2008 financial crisis through the pandemic to the 2021-2022 inflation surge, with some eminent economists insisting on transitory inflation and repeatedly redefining the term.
“Nobel prize winning economists have been wrong again and again about our major economic shocks from the financial crisis that began uh in 2008 through to the pandemic there's still an ongoing debate about what caused uh the big inflation surge uh of uh 2021 2022 uh there were eminent economists Laden down with honors who were sure that the there would be a transitory inflation episode in the wake of the pandemic and the only way they've been able to stay uh stay true to that hypothesis is by changing the meaning of the word transitory over and over and over again”
Bad lesson-learning is exemplified by the United States deciding to invade Iraq believing it would be easy to establish democracy there because American troops would be welcomed as liberators like they were in Paris at the end of World War II—the correct lesson was that toppling a dictator and establishing a stable government is extremely difficult, expensive, and takes a long time.
“the United States deciding to invade Iraq uh and believing that it would be quite easy to establish democracy there because American troops would be welcomed in Baghdad like the liberators of Paris uh towards the end of World War II that was a terrible bad lesson of History uh the right lesson was it's extremely difficult if you topple a dictator to establish a stable government in the ruins of the dictators regime it can be done but it's really expensive and it takes ages”
The Federal Reserve employs really smart people with PhDs, and it's highly competitive to work there because people use it as a launching pad for lucrative hedge fund careers—yet they were wildly wrong about where interest rates would be, being about 500 basis points off in their projections two years ago.
“The Federal Reserve employs some really smart people they have phds it's really hard to get a job there uh it doesn't pay that well but once you've been at the fed you get hard by the hedge funds and you make tons of money so this is very competitive and they were so crazily wrong about where interest rates would be right now two years ago they were like 500 basis points off they were wildly wildly wrong and that was just over a two-year time Horizon”
In parts of Europe where the Reformation succeeded and literacy rates went up, economic growth was much higher over the succeeding 300 years, showing that net benefits of mass literacy exceeded the costs.
“Mass literacy had many good consequences I'm sure unquestionably that the benefits exceeded the costs of mass literacy we know they did because in in parts of Europe where the Reformation succeeded and literacy rates went up economic growth was much higher over the succeeding 300 years”
Political scientists, social scientists, and especially economists feel that if they can model the historical process, they will be able to project the future with some degree of certainty, but this has been a constantly disappointing exercise.
“political scientists and social scientists especially economists feel that if they can only model the historical process then they will be able to project the future with some uh degree of certainty and this is a constantly disappointing exercise but it doesn't stop them trying”
The Congressional Budget Office constantly tries to project what federal debt will be relative to US GDP on a highly regular basis, and it's always wrong—not just a bit wrong but wildly wrong—having underestimated the direction of debt consistently for 20+ years while continuing to publish projections that people discuss despite knowing they'll continue to be wrong.
“the Congressional budget office Congressional budget offers constantly tries to project what the federal debt will be in relation to U.S gross domestic product and it does this exercise on a highly regular basis and it's always wrong and not just a bit wrong it's kind of wildly wrong it's been it's underestimated the direction of the debt consistently for 20 plus years now and they'll keep publishing those projections and they'll keep being discussed and people will write op-eds about them and go on TV to talk about them but the truth is they'll continue to be wrong because there's something fundamentally flawed in the model”
The United States is nothing like interwar Europe—if you studied interwar Europe rigorously and time-traveled to 1920s Italy or 1930s Germany, you would be struck by how different it is from Trump's America (constant uniforms, pervasive militarization, etc.), yet people mainly know mid-20th century history and constantly compare everything to it.
“the United States is nothing like into war Europe I mean I've studied into war Europe if I had a time machine and you and I got into it and we went off to Italy in the 1920s or Germany in the 1930s we had a day there we'd be like this is totally different this is like this is crazy every other person is in a uniform I mean the thing about Donald Trump's America is that you hardly saw anybody in a uniform except occasionally there'd be somebody coming back from Afghanistan in an airport but this is the thing that I'm I'm constantly struck by if you study history rigorously you're you're constantly struck by how unlike the mid-20th century our time is and and yet people seem only to know about the mid-20th century”
Many people have lazily attributed fascist comparisons to Donald Trump (saying he's Mussolini or Hitler) out of prejudice, but these are bad analogies because a good populist analogy to Trump exists within American history via the 19th century Californian Workers Party leader Dennis Kearney.
“a lot of people lazily out of prejudice said oh he's a fascist he's Mussolini or he's Hitler and these were really bad analogies because you don't need to go to interwar Europe to find good analogies uh to understand Donald Trump there's a populist tradition in the United States that goes back to the 19th century there have been quite a few characters in American history like him with his ideas and his style who like well people you've never heard of there was a guy named Dennis Kearney who led something called the Californian Workers Party in the late 19th century”
No American populist has succeeded in becoming president until Trump, yet there have been earlier populists offering the combination of immigration restriction and elite bashing, showing that this is not a new political phenomenon but a recurring pattern.
“no populist until Trump has succeeded in getting to be president but we've had populists before offering that combination of immigration restriction and uh and Elite bashing and you didn't need to you didn't need to look for analogies in into war Europe”
Anti-bullshit positions don't go viral on Twitter—they're doomed not to spread—whereas bullshit spreads easily, which is why one will always be swamped by bullshit despite trying to counter it.
“the key to to anti-bull [ __ ] is that it is much less it doesn't go viral it just doesn't go I mean anti-bull [ __ ] it's it's it's just doomed not to go viral on Twitter and so you carry on doing your best but you will always be you will always be swamped by the [ __ ]”
Only Grover Cleveland has had two non-consecutive presidential terms in American history—if Trump were reelected, it would be the second time this has happened.
“it would be the second time in American history that somebody had two non-consecutive terms Grover Cleveland did it in the late 19th century”
The Roman Republic is a better analogy for the contemporary US than the Roman Empire—republican institutions historically have not been long-lived, with most republics in history having not lasted long, and political theorists from the ancient world, Renaissance, and Enlightenment would not be surprised by current processes of corruption and demagoguery.
“just to come back to my Roman point it's not really the Roman Empire that the United States is like it's the Roman Republic that it's like and Republican institutions historically have not been fantastically long-lived most republics in history have not been long-lived uh it's only relatively recently that we had long-lived republics and uh any political theorists from the ancient world or the Renaissance or the enlightenment would have said well republics tend not to last because at some point they either choose a tyranny or they descend into uh corruption and a demagogue comes to power all of the processes that we see at the moment at work would not surprise uh traditional political theorists”
Even in our contemporary lives, outcomes are determined by small contingencies—for instance, Ferguson's own life could be completely different if he were hit by a car crossing Park Avenue due to inattention, illustrating that this contingency principle applies to individual lives as well as historical events.
“and in my work and I've been doing this now for more decades than I like to count I constantly try to keep the reader aware there are these other paths that we could have gone down just as right now today our lives your life my life everybody who's listening's lives they could go in a completely different direction because of some disaster that strikes I get hit by a car Crossing Park Avenue and everything's different from that moment on just because I wasn't paying attention when I crossed the road that's the historical reality that we we have to keep reminding ourselves of”
The transition from 17th century Scotland (Afghanistan-like conditions) to 18th century Scotland (Enlightenment center with Adam Smith, Walter Scott) happened in the space of a few decades following the 1745 Jacobite Rising, with unclear mechanisms for how this transformation occurred—this represents one of the most interesting historical questions.
“and then and it's a very mysterious process but in the space of a few decades you go from the 1745 Jacobite Rising Civil War Carnage to the enlightenment to Scotland being one of the great centers of intellectual innovation of the late 18th century and uh you know Walter Scott writes a great novel perhaps the greatest historical novel Waverly really addressing this question how on Earth does Scotland go from being Afghanistan to being Athens in this really short space of time and I still think that's one of the most interesting questions”
American politics in the 19th century was a 'contact sport,' then there was a period of relative bipartisan gentlemanship in parts of the 20th century, and now politics has gone back to being a contact sport—returning to its original character.
“I think if one looks back at the 19th century American politics was a contact sport then it's gone back to being a contact sport after a period when there was a certain gentlemanly bipartisanship at least for periods of the 20th century and that that's gone and we're now back into the kind of contact sport that Dickens writes about when he visits the United States”
From a Republican vantage point, Democrats didn't accept the legitimacy of Trump's 2016 victory, though this fact is often forgotten—this tit-for-tat delegitimization started before January 6th, 2021.
“from a republican Vantage Point Democrats didn't expect accept the legitimacy of Trump's victory uh in 2016. although that's uh that's often forgotten there was a great uh wave of protest against uh Trump in his first year including if you remember the women's March”
The 17th century was a time when mercenaries were enormously powerful, exemplified by Wallenstein who was the protagonist of the Holy Roman Empire, and this period offers important lessons about the current moment.
“the 17th century was a time when mercenaries were enormously powerful there was a guy named Valenstein who was the progosian of the Holy Roman Empire we can learn a lot from that period”
The loss of the Library of Alexandria and the destruction of ancient texts during Islamic Crusades against heretical knowledge represents a catastrophic loss of historical information, and history would be radically different if all ancient Athenian and Roman texts had been lost (there would have been no Renaissance).
“just how different our world would be if the Library of Alexandria hadn't been burned if we hadn't lost a load of this stuff to some Islamic Crusades against some heretical knowledge as well or how different it would be if all of the ancient learning had been lost uh I mean that's a counter factual that I think a lot about because if all of the ancient Athenian and Roman texts had had been lost there would have been no Renaissance and it's hard to imagine quite how what we think of as Western Civilization would have been would have been possible”
There were times when the Russian Revolution could have been aborted, the Bolsheviks could have lost, or it could have led to World War III (as evidenced by the Cuban Missile Crisis being a contingent moment), meaning the history should be read as a series of forking paths with awareness of alternative futures rather than as a determined narrative.
“I think there were times when the Russian Revolution could have been aborted the Bolsheviks could have lost uh there were times when the Russian Revolution could have led all the way to World War III think of the Cuban Missile Crisis there are lots of different ways this story could have ended”
Recognizing that history has lots of contingency, chaos, and that even small decisions can have massive consequences while big decisions can have no consequences leads to better decision-making in the present because it avoids bad lesson-learning.
“if one recognizes that that's the lesson that there's lots of contingency and chaos and that even small decisions kind of massive consequences and big decisions can have no consequences learn that about the historical process will lead us I think to make better decisions in the present because it will get us away from what I would call bad lesson learning”
60% of Americans don't own a passport, which contributes to a lack of worldliness and myopia in America—this may also correlate with temporal myopia, where knowing only the last hundred years of history (especially only 1935-1945 of that) leads people to retrofit current events into a very small set of examples.
“that's got me thinking about this stat I learned UH 60 of Americans don't own a passport and when you live on a in a country which is essentially a continent and has you know 50 little countries all attached that will allow you to use your currency and speak your language and go and work there if you want to then I guess a bit of a justification is why would you need to um but the lack of worldliness I do think contributes to uh myopia um in America and I wonder whether there's almost like a a temporal myopia as well”
Orlando Figes' 'A People's Tragedy' frames the Russian Revolution as a tragedy, which lulls readers into thinking there could only be one outcome and that it was bound to produce a dysfunctional totalitarian regime that would last until the late 1980s—but this narrative framing obscures the contingency and alternative possibilities that existed.
“when you frame an historical episode as a tragedy the reader kind of knows what to expect it's not going to end well there'll probably be bodies all over the stage uh at some point towards the end so that's fair enough and it's a good history of the Russian revolution revolution one of the best in English but it it slightly lulls the reader into thinking that there could only really be one outcome one sequence of events that it was sort of bound to produce this dysfunctional totalitarian regime”
If Scotland could go from being like Afghanistan to being like Athens within a few decades, then it should be possible for 21st century Afghanistan to undergo a similar transformation, suggesting that today's conditions are not inevitable or unchangeable.
“if it's possible to to stop being Afghanistan kind of actually become a center of of not only intellectual Innovation but economic dynamism the Adam Smith Scotland I mean the Adam Smith Scotland is just a couple of decades after the Battle of Culloden uh you know that's to me one of the most amazing examples in history of total non-linearity total discontinuity radical upgrade from you know Civil War to Enlightenment if it's possible in 17th century Scotland 18th century Scotland then it should be possible in 21st century Afghanistan”
An ideal history curriculum would be much broader in chronological and geographical scope than is available in any school today, with one being better off knowing a little bit about everything rather than knowing everything about the rise of Hitler.
“I think if I were designing a curriculum for my 11 year old son I would attempt to make it much broader in its chronological and geographical scope than is available in any school today I would rather that he knew a little bit about everything uh than that he knew everything about the rise of Hitler”
If time machines existed as airbuses you could book to, everyone would want to go to 1933 to see Hitler come to power or to the 1920s to get drunk with Scott Fitzgerald, but the really valuable historical moment to visit would be the Peace of Westphalia in 1648 where they figured out how to stop the 30 years war.
“it'll it'll kind of give us a terrible feeling of of nausea and then we'll come come home or you know where else would people want to go if they were Time Travelers it's like let's go back to the let's go back to the swinging twenties and get drunk with Scott Fitzgerald to be like there'll be a bunch of destinations that would be really popular and I'd be that one guy on the little plane going to the Peace of West failure in 1648 it's like I think you should go to the piece of Westphalia in 1648 and find out how they stop the 30 years walk because we need something like that soon uh in the world today”
The probability of Trump coming back is much higher than most people realize because, just as people in 2015 struggled to imagine Trump being president the first time, people struggle again with cognitive barriers to giving a Trump comeback high probability.
“I think the probability of trump coming back is much higher than most people realize right now uh because just as in 2015 uh people struggled to imagine Trump uh being president the first time they struggle again uh with the kind of cognitive barriers to to giving that a high probability”
Despite history's inability to predict with confidence (even within 18 months), pattern recognition can reveal why Biden is a weak candidate and why Trump could win, demonstrating that history enables comparative pattern analysis even if not deterministic prediction.
“history is not really capable of giving you a crystal ball it doesn't allow you to say with any real confidence who win the next election even though it's less than 18 months away but if you start playing the game of pattern recognition you can start to see why Biden's a weak candidate why if he continues to seek re-election he could be a one-term president and why under those circumstances Donald Trump despite uh all that happened on January the 6th 2021 could get reelected”
Ferguson's ideal history course would be called 'Empires' and would systematically study all empires to understand them comprehensively, realizing they are everywhere but have varied durations, different business models, and mostly practice slavery to varying extents; such a course would require development of a better grand unified theory of empire than currently exists.
“my ideal history course is just called Empires it's just like all the empires let's try and understand them all let's realize they're basically everywhere they mostly do slavery to varying extents um they have very varied durations they have different business models but that's kind of what history is and there should be some much better Grand unified theory of of Empire than we have”
We know most of what we will ever know about history because we've captured the major source materials that survive, though there may be hidden texts and additional archaeological discoveries possible, but the bulk of recoverable historical knowledge has already been accessed.
“we kind of know unless we do invent a time machine we know all of the things that we're going to know about history there are maybe some texts somewhere that are hidden there are maybe some archaeological digs that can be done there are inferences that can be drawn but when we're looking at you know original Source material we've captured at least a large portion probably of what we're going to be able to capture so it's really it's really like going over a crime scene with very limited evidence”
People seem to only know mid-20th century history (Nazi Germany and WWII), and yet the 17th century is much more illuminating for understanding our time because it dealt with a new communication technology (the printing press) that drastically lowered the barrier to entry for disseminating information, comparable to the internet today.
“there is this uh extraordinary over emphasis on the mid-20th century as if that's the only history we should really bother knowing about I mean I studied part part of my career I spent studying that that period but but actually think that the 17th century is much more Illuminating if we want to understand our time because in the 16th and 17th century they had to contend with a new communication technology the printing press and it completely changed everything it's suddenly drastically lowered the barrier to entry you could you could get your thoughts out on on paper much more easily than on an illuminated manuscript we're living through a comparable period in which the public sphere has completely be transformed by technology”
Radical changes in the boundaries of knowledge should not be expected to have only good consequences—mass literacy had many good consequences but also costs, and we should be aware of the likely costs of drastic changes in the structure of the public sphere when thinking about the internet and artificial intelligence.
“one should not expect that kind of radical change in the boundaries of knowledge to have only good consequences Mass literacy had many good consequences I'm sure unquestionably that the benefits exceeded the costs of mass literacy we know they did because in in parts of Europe where the Reformation succeeded and literacy rates went up economic growth was much higher over the succeeding 300 years so net benefits were great but there were costs too to suddenly going from a basically illiterate Society to a illiterate one and I think in our thinking about the internet and this should also inform our understanding of artificial intelligence we need to be more aware of the likely costs of drastic changes in the structure of the public sphere”
Applied history involves being systematic and comprehensive in finding all possible historical analogies before jumping to a conclusion, with a mindset not of 'please confirm my prejudice' but of 'please get rid of my prejudice and teach me something new and interesting.'
“I think the lesson that I would take the reason that I call it applied history is that you've got to be kind of systematic you're really looking for analogies and you've got to make sure that you you kind of comprehensive that you try to find them all before jumping to the conclusion that you're tempted by and your mindset should be not oh please confirm me in my original Prejudice my mindset is always please get rid of my original Prejudice and teach me something new and interesting”
Historians writing popular history books face an expectation that they should be as readable as novels, which introduces a narrative structure and sense of inevitability that can mislead readers into thinking historical outcomes were predetermined rather than contingent.
“if you're writing a history book there is certainly an expectation that it should be ideally as readable as a novel”
Tourism often gives people an exaggerated sense of their own knowledge—people who travel to Scotland (for golf), Paris (for meals and shopping), and Florence think they know Europe, but if you only know Scotland through golf, you need to watch 'Trainspotting' multiple times as a corrective.
“the problem with tourism is that it often gives people the impression that they know more about the world than they do so uh there are very many Americans who do have passports and when they travel uh they go to Scotland to play golf uh and then they go uh to Paris to have uh fancy meals or do shopping and uh and then they'd probably go to Florence and then they come back with enormous an enormous sense of their own knowledge of Europe uh but if all you know about Scotland is golf uh you should watch the movie Trainspotting five times as a kind of corrective”
The temptation to draw analogies with past empires is quite hazardous because it's always possible to find a case that matches your preferred interpretation—Ferguson himself did this in a piece for The Economist before the US abandoned Afghanistan, comparing the US to Britain between the wars.
“it's always possible to find a case and say oh you see here we are we're just about where Britain was in pick a decade this is I've done this myself I did this for The Economist just before the US abandoned Afghanistan I wrote a piece of The Economist saying ah the US is beginning to look a bit like Britain between the wars kind of too much debt kind of overextended”
Historian Jeffrey West's framework of comparing empires to biodiversity (some giant like elephants, some tiny like mice) applies to history, treating empires as a weird menagerie with different sizes and characteristics.
“it's kind of strange it's strange it's a strange Menagerie this Zoo full of Empires some of them are giant like elephants some of that tiny like mice and that that's that's kind of Jeffrey West's take on the natural world I think it probably applies to the historical world too”
If Biden continues as the nominee all the way through, Trump could win, which would result in an extraordinary and dangerous time in American history because the left will refuse to acknowledge that result just as Trump refused to acknowledge his defeat, leading to severe political instability.
“I think if Biden's the nominee all the way through uh Trump could win and then we will have an extraordinary time in American history because the left will will refuse to acknowledge that result just as much as Trump refused to acknowledge his defeat and the Republic will become very politically unstable under those under those circumstances”
There was an obvious lesson about the internet to be learned from the printing press, but when Ferguson visited Silicon Valley around 2016, the utter optimism prevailed everywhere that the internet was awesome and all its consequences would be awesome, and it never occurred to tech entrepreneurs that there could be downsides to universal connection.
“I mean there was a pretty obvious lesson to be learned about the internet from the printing press but if you went to Silicon Valley as I did in 20 when did I move 2016 what really amazed me was the utter optimism that prevailed everywhere that the internet was awesome and all its consequences would be awesome and if everybody was connected that would be awesome and I mean I'm like but there could be some downsides to connecting everybody have you considered that like why but if you have an entire community of people who don't know any history at all and and that would never cross their minds”
A critical moment is arriving when many Americans think a double standard has been applied where Trump was targeted by the justice system while the Bidens were given different treatment—this is an important shift happening in American politics.
“the uh that's often forgotten there was a great uh wave of protest against uh Trump in his first year including if you remember the women's March uh the the great I think critical moment uh has arrived when many Americans think that a double standard has been applied that that Trump was targeted by the justice system and the bidens were given treat treatment that was quite different and that's a really important shift that's happening in American politics right now”
Joe Biden is losing his 'Amtrak Joe' regular-guy image because of his son's business dealings and his involvement with them, and the more this happens, the more people will say 'there's nothing to choose between them—they're all corrupt, all crooked.'
“Joe Biden is an extroably losing his Amtrak Joe regular guy image because of his son and his involvement with his son's business dealings and the more that happens the more people will say well there's nothing really to choose between them you can say what you like about Donald Trump but they're all corrupt they're all crooked”
Ferguson's 11-year-old son came across a video by Bill Wurtz called 'a complete history of the world' as a crazy musical animation that Ferguson believes is better than Yuval Noah Harari's work because it's funny and comprehensive, covering everything including the Phoenicians and Central Asian khanates.
“Thomas who is 11 came across a terrific uh video online which I think Bill wurtz did which is a complete history of the world as a kind of crazy musical animation it's really good uh it's better than Yuval Noah Harare because it's funny... it just does everything uh including the Phoenicians uh the Central Asian carnates”
Biden's presidency is unlikely to be a two-term presidency, similar to Gerald Ford, Jimmy Carter, and George H.W. Bush, who could only be one-term presidents—economics and polling substantiate that Biden is not in a strong position to get reelected.
“I think that uh the Biden presidency uh is kind of unlikely to be a two-term presidency uh in the same way that uh Gerald Ford and Jimmy Carter and George Bush Senior could only be one-term presidents I feel Joe Biden's a one-term president now in that case and by the way the economics and the polling all would substantiate the fact that he's not in a strong position to get reelected”
Unless Democrats panic and persuade Biden not to run early next year and parachute in Gavin Newsom, Trump likely won't be stopped—if Newsom is substituted for Biden, Americans will see an old guy versus a young, good-looking guy and choose the young guy regardless of policy differences.
“I'm kind of struggling to see what stops him now unless the Democrats panic and persuade Biden not to run early next year and parachute in Gavin Newsom I think if they do that Trump won't win because Americans will see an old guy and a young guy a young kind of good looking guy though I'm not sure how good looking but they're kind of going to choose the young guy uh regardless of the fact that he's left California a kind of wasteland”
The Republican nominee is quite likely to win, and that nominee is likely to be Donald Trump, who is far ahead of the competition and Ron DeSantis isn't really getting traction, putting the US in the position where a man indicted for trying to overturn the last election could be reelected.
“that means the Republican nominee is quite likely to win but the Republican nominee right now is quite likely to be Donald Trump uh he's far ahead of the competition Ron DeSantis isn't really getting much traction and and so we are in The Amazing situation that a man who has just been indicted of trying to overturn the last election and that's just one of the many criminal charges he faces right now uh could be re-elected”
The Trump second administration would be ruthlessly well-prepared for power in a way the first Trump Administration wasn't, suggesting greater institutional effectiveness and potentially more dangerous governance.
“the Trump second Trump Administration will be ruthlessly well prepared for power in a way that the first Trump Administration wasn't so yeah that's my kind of that's my crystal ball so far as I like it”
Arguments about double standards will count for a lot more in the 2024 election than arguments about whether the 2020 election was stolen—swing voters and independent voters will be persuaded by double-standard arguments, particularly in the small number of counties that actually determine elections through machine politics.
“I think those arguments about double standards uh will count for a lot much more than arguments about whether the 2020 election was stolen it's the sense that a double standard has been applied that will help Trump now as I said concluding reflection history is not really capable of giving you a crystal ball it doesn't allow you to say with any real confidence who win the next election even though it's less than 18 months away but if you start playing the game of pattern recognition you can start to see why Biden's a weak candidate why if he continues to seek re-election he could be a one-term president and why under those circumstances Donald Trump despite uh all that happened on January the 6th 2021 could get reelected”
The only kind of time travel we can do is by reading history or watching movies, but movies are actually worse than books because they further flatten and narrativize history, making it even less useful for understanding.
“we can sort of do time travel with books and and movies uh but I suspect it's a bit like tourism we all go to the same places and come back with an exaggerated sense of our own knowledge yeah but it's not only in the UK I mean there is this uh extraordinary over emphasis on the mid-20th century... we don't have them never have them I suspect and that means the only kind of time travel we can do is basically by reading history or we can go and see movies which are actually worse because you know you can go and see Oppenheimer but he'd be better off reading the book If you really want to understand what happened”
The Reformation was about enabling people to read scripture themselves in a language they understood rather than having it read to them in Latin, which was revolutionary because it changed the boundaries of knowledge distribution.
“that the Reformation was the idea that that people should be able to read scripture themselves in a language uh that they understood rather than having it read to them in Latin that was a revolutionary idea”
Most people in history have led unrecorded lives in non-literate agricultural societies, making it really hard to recapture the full human past; any curriculum will inevitably capture an unrepresentative sample that overrepresents the literate and urban.
“most of the people in history LED unrecorded lives in uh in non-literate agricultural societies and so with the best will in the world it's really hard to recapture the human past we're inevitably going to capture this really unrepresentative sample which over represents the the literate and the urban”
Ferguson would prefer to be safely sitting in England if Trump were reelected, as he expects things could 'get very nasty' in the US, possibly including kinetic violence.
“you know if Trump is is re-elected I shall I shall be quite glad to be sitting safely in England watching it from a distance I'm not sure I'd want to be here if that happened well that would get I think that could get very nasty I could get very nasty I'm kinetic nasty”
Ferguson is working with physicist Jeffrey West (author of 'Scale') in a 'pipe dream' collaboration to create an analysis of empires for physicists that would make all of history intelligible through a unified theoretical framework.
“I was I was in Santa Fe a couple of weeks ago at the Santa Fe Institute hanging out with my favorite physicist Jeffrey West who's a brilliant guy he did a book called scale that everybody should read and we have this kind of pipe dream that will join forces and and kind of do Empires sort of for physicists and then all of history will be intelligible”
Godwin's Law states that as an online discussion grows, the probability of a comparison to Nazis or Hitler approaches 100%, reflecting the fact that many people only know the history of Nazi Germany as their reference point.
“you are reading my mind I've got in front of me Godwin's law as an online discussion grows the probability of a comparison to Nazis our Hitler approaches 100”
Ferguson writes a column for Bloomberg Opinion that appears every two weeks where he drops his thoughts on current events.
“regular readers of my column which appears for Bloomberg opinion can hear my thoughts every two weeks when I when I drop a column there”
Ferguson's next major project will be Volume 2 of his biography of Henry Kissinger, which he is working on 'every waking hour except when doing podcasts.'
“Volume 2 of my biography of Henry Kissinger I'm working on that uh every waking hour except when I'm doing podcasts it's really good and uh and and that will be the next book that I I publish”
Ferguson has published a book called 'Doom: The Politics of Catastrophe' a couple of years ago that readers can access while waiting for the Kissinger biography volume 2.
“while you're waiting for that you can buy Doom the politics of catastrophe which was the book that I published most recently A couple of years ago now”