YouTube18m· Sep 2024· cataloged

China slowdown, Gold/Oil ratio, AI/Robotics deflation v. debt-based system framework


What this covers

This is a single-speaker, 18-minute commentary by Luke Groman that moves from China's slowdown to oil, gold, AI, and U.S. fiscal mechanics. It opens with a historical analogy. The post-Napoleonic UK worked off a heavy debt load without default, depression, or debasement, through the Industrial Revolution, fossil fuels, new transport technology, and the repeal of the Corn Laws alongside early free trade. He notes the costs of that repeal, including deindustrialization and inequality. He also stresses that productivity gains on that scale rarely occur and must arrive at the right speed: too slow doesn't solve the problem, too fast creates unemployment.

The middle of the talk covers several distinct areas. On China, he reads the slowdown as a deliberate long-horizon strategy ("eat bitterness") to build credibility for the yuan, yuan-denominated commodity trade, and its bond market. As evidence he cites Chinese government yields nearly 200 basis points below Treasuries. He also floats the idea of a "pain contest" in which the U.S., with its 50 basis point cut, may have blinked first. On oil, he argues that shale production falls roughly 6% a month, so prices below $60-65 would send the rig count down and cede the market to Russia and Saudi Arabia. That makes him expect the Strategic Petroleum Reserve to be refilled around $65-70. He ties the gold-to-oil ratio to the dollar's geopolitical standing.

The closing sections turn contentious. He claims the S&P 500 effectively backs the Treasury market, because capital gains and taxable IRA distributions drive consumer spending. He argues that deflation from AI and robotics, with worries about 2026-2027 as a possible wage-pressure tipping point, cannot coexist with a debt-based system. He expects reactive UBI rather than proactive robot taxation, eventual central bank balance sheet growth to avert nominal default, and a positioning stance of staying unlevered and holding Bitcoin, gold, and industrial equities.

Sharpest takeaway

Groman argues that the U.S. faces a structural debt crisis resolvable only through a perfectly-timed productivity miracle, and that deflation from AI/robotics is mathematically incompatible with the debt-based monetary system, forcing eventual central bank balance sheet expansion and benefiting hard assets like Bitcoin and gold.

  • Deflation is fundamentally incompatible with debt-based monetary systems and will force central banks to expand balance sheets to prevent sovereign default
  • The S&P 500 de facto backs the Treasury market—stocks must rise 10-15% annually just to prevent fiscal deterioration, making equity performance inseparable from fiscal solvency
  • Historical precedent (post-Napoleonic UK) shows debt crises can be resolved without depression/default/debasement only via unprecedented productivity gains arriving at exactly the right speed

The claims · ranked36 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

The post-Napoleonic UK resolved its high debt levels through an unprecedented productivity miracle (Industrial Revolution, fossil fuel commercialization, transportation technology innovation) combined with repeal of the Corn Laws and early globalization/neoliberal free trade, avoiding debt default, depression, or currency debasement.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Luke Groman

“there is an example in history of that being able to be done via productivity miracle and it was in the post-napoleonic wars in the UK high levels of debt coming away from the Napoleonic Wars and the productivity Miracles were pretty much unprecedented in human history up into that point you had the Industrial Revolution you had the discovery and then rapid commercialization of fossil fuels you had transportation technology that was unprecedented uh moving from buggies and carriage horse horse and buggy to trains steam powered ships cars planes and then all of these things arrived really neither too slow nor too fast you also had the English not appreciate this isn't appreciated repeal the Corn Laws and effectively set up the first attempt or the first go-around of global ization and neoliberal free trade”

0.74

Deflation is fundamentally incompatible with debt-based monetary systems and will blow them up with mathematical certainty.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Luke Groman

“if we start from a first principle that I think governs this whole dynamic which is deflation is fundamentally incompatible with our debt-based monetary system deflation will blow it up mathematical certainty”

0.74

The Corn Laws repeal created negative effects including deindustrialization and wealth inequality, though it avoided debt default and depression for merchant classes.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Luke Groman

“you also had the English not appreciate this isn't appreciated repeal the Corn Laws and effectively set up the first attempt or the first go-around of global ization and neoliberal free trade where the the the British essentially offshored their workingclass jobs to lower cost countries around the Empire it created problems he it it it contributed to denen and wealth inequality um uh but no debt default and and no uh depression per se certainly not for the merchant classes”

0.70

Massive productivity increases needed to resolve debt crises 'don't happen that frequently in history.'

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Luke Groman

“it's extremely tricky and requires massive massive productivity increases that to be blunt don't happen that frequently in history”

0.69

Oil shale production declines at approximately 6% per month at a declining rate, meaning sustained low oil prices would cause rig count to fall sharply and shale production to roll over, similar to the 2020 pattern where production fell sharply and didn't return to 2019 levels until 2023.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“the nature of shale which declines at a 6% per month rate uh at a declining rate you can see what we saw in 2020 which was Shale production fell sharply when they laid rigs down and didn't come back to 2019 levels until 2023”

0.60

Chinese government bonds offer yields nearly 200 basis points below U.S. Treasury yields, indicating market confidence in Chinese credit despite stock market underperformance.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“their bond market 10-e treas treasury or 10e Chinese government bond yields are still nearly 200 basis points below 10year us treasuries”

0.56

Oil shale production will not remain at current levels if oil prices fall below $60-$65 per barrel.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“I've been told by multiple former highlevel energy execs that uh Shale production will not stay at current levels if oil goes too far below call it 65 or or 60”

0.54

Higher-ups in AI development are concerned about 2026-2027 as a potential tipping point when AI and robotics could begin to apply nonlinear downward pressure on wages.

factualhigh valuefringenovelty 3/4durability 1/4· Luke Groman

“I've seen or or heard reported that some of the higher ups in AI uh development development are very concerned about the 2026 2027 time time Horizon U maybe I don't know we watch that time Horizon”

0.53

China is pursuing a deliberate long-term strategy of building credibility for yuan-denominated commodities, their bond market system, and their currency through slower growth ('eat bitterness'), while their 10-year bond yields remain nearly 200 basis points below U.S. Treasury yields.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“they're trying to essentially grow their way out uh a little bit more slowly um trying to I think establish or or continue to win credibility uh that has been hard one credibility for Yuan denominated Commodities etc for their system and and for their bond market as much as we see in the western media that the Chinese stock market has done terrible and massively underperformed the S&P and it has their bond market 10-e treas treasury or 10e Chinese government bond yields are still nearly 200 basis points below 10year us treasuries”

0.53

China may be engaged in a 'pain contest' with the U.S., deliberately running their economy slowly to see which country yields first to policy stimulus, and recent U.S. 50 basis point rate cuts suggest the U.S. may be 'crying uncle first.'

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“why else might China be doing this ultimately are they engaging in a pain contest in other words running things slowly and seeing who cries Uncle first the us or China uh and if that's the case seems possible with 50 basis point cut today and and uh 50 basis point Cuts more coming that perhaps it's the US that's crying Uncle first”

0.52

China is engaging in a longer time horizon strategic approach with its slowdown, not responding to short-term cyclical pressures.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“I think China has their eye on a much longer time Horizon in terms of what they're trying to accomplish here”

0.52

The U.S. tends to move 'from Bubble to Bubble every two-year election year cycle' while China does not.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“they don't just kind of go from Bubble to Bubble every twoyear election year cycle like we do”

0.52

A debt crisis resolved through productivity miracle requires productivity gains to arrive at precisely the right speed—not too slow (won't solve crisis in time) and not too fast (will cause excessive unemployment and create more problems than solved).

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“I've talked about needing a productivity Miracle as a way out of the debt problems but I've also talked about that it needs to arrive on in Goldy likes Goldilocks like fashion in other words not too fast or not too slow arrives too slow it's not going to be in time arrives too fast drives too much unemployment and and creates more problems than it solves”

0.52

For Treasury valuations to become attractive relative to stocks, Treasury issuance and fiscal deficits would need to fall far enough that the deficit-to-GDP ratio declines significantly.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“if if you got the S&P high enough that receipts Rose enough that issuance fell enough treasury issuance fell enough that that the GDP and deficit the GDP were far lower then that discussion would change uh in regards to all those things”

0.52

Western politicians lack the wisdom and foresight necessary to implement proactive AI/robot taxation policy, making it more likely that large employment disruption will occur first, followed by reactive Universal Basic Income (UBI) policies for displaced workers.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“from an execution you know standpoint that requires a level of wisdom and foresight that to be blunt is sorely lacking um across most of the western politicians I see certainly especially given the money involved so I think it's much more likely that we get large disruption to employment markets uh from Ai and Robotics at some point and um then you get politicians trying to do Ubi on the back end Universal basic income on the back end for displaced workers”

0.52

The gold-to-oil ratio would only revert to historical 10-30 barrel range if the world returned to U.S. dominance (1990-2014/2018), requiring either Russia to cease selling oil outside the dollar, China to cease buying oil outside the dollar, or massive geopolitical upheaval of both countries.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“to me the big thing that would change it would be a shift back to the unipole world of 1990 through 2014 or 2018 depending on how you want to Define it uh if the US Energy uh you know dominance became extremely dominant we became I don't know 80% plus of global oil production I don't think that's going to happen but it's possible I suppose uh when you talk about shifting back to unipolar what we're really talking about is Russia stopping uh selling oil outside the dollar and China stopping buying oil outside the dollar short of uh coups or economic collapses of both of those countries leadership structures I find that highly unlikely”

0.52

Investors should not attempt to time the AI/robotics wage deflation inflection point but should instead remain unlevered, monitor trends for acceleration, and profit from the inevitable central bank balance sheet expansion through positions in Bitcoin, gold, and industrial equities.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“I would recommend the average investor play this the way I personally am playing this which is I'm not trying to get cute and time it I don't know when it's happening I can see the trend I'm watching for big changes in the trend or big accelerations in the trend if I don't see a reversal the trend's going to keep going and at some point it's going to accelerate I don't need to know when exactly that happens if I'm not levered so stay unlevered and ultimately in a debt-based system once we know that first principle deflation is fundamentally incompatible then it just becomes a matter of time if we're on lever until central banks have to start more fully reserving sovereign debt more fully reserving means growing their balance sheet to prevent the nominal default of Western sovereign debt that serves as collateral for everything else ultimately that's really good for Bitcoin that's really good for gold it's really good for industrial stocks equities more broadly”

0.52

Central banks will eventually need to more fully reserve sovereign debt by growing their balance sheets to prevent nominal default of Western sovereign debt, which serves as collateral for everything else in the financial system.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“ultimately in a debt-based system once we know that first principle deflation is fundamentally incompatible then it just becomes a matter of time if we're on lever until central banks have to start more fully reserving sovereign debt more fully reserving means growing their balance sheet to prevent the nominal default of Western sovereign debt that serves as collateral for everything else”

0.52

If oil prices fall to $60-$65 or below and shale production rolls over as a result, the U.S. would cede the global oil market to Russia and Saudi Arabia for 2-4 years, which is unacceptable geopolitically for the U.S.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“what that means geopolitically is you are going to seeed the oil Market globally to the Russians and the Saudis for the next 2 to three years maybe the next four years that that's a non-starter for the US in my opinion”

0.52

If the U.S. needs to run $2 trillion perpetual deficits but cannot finance them through bank/investor purchases, the Fed will either directly print money or use proxy methods (bank SLR exemptions) to print and finance deficits de facto, weakening the dollar and increasing inflation.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“so we want to run $2 trillion deficits in perpetuity uh where I either going to need to force our banks to buy it or our investors to buy it which will crowd out and slow growth and make the deficit worse or the fed's going to have to print money either directly or via proxy with US Banks SLR exemptions Etc uh and basically print the money and finance the deficit themselves de facto which should weaken the dollar increase inflation”

0.52

Higher percentages of gold in global international reserves would force the U.S. to print money to finance entitlements, defense, and interest payments, or else cut one or more of these items.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“it it would higher percentages of gold reserves would ultimately Force the US to print the money to finance entitlements and defense and interest or else cut one or more of those items”

0.52

China can sustain slowdown and even outright deflation for a period of time without an outright collapse of their financial system, unlike the U.S., where deflation triggered rapid policy responses.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“China clearly uh growth uh slowing or slow uh they are clearly having some issues in certain areas couple things within it that I I do not see a lot of discussion in Western Financial media about China's slowdown and economic difficulties the first uh noting that China can actually have sustained slowdown and even some outright deflation for a period of time uh without an outright collapse of their fin Financial system um that's not how it worked here um once we got into deflation you saw the authorities spring into action pretty quickly”

0.49

The S&P 500 de facto backs the U.S. Treasury market because net capital gains plus taxable IRA distributions alone are 200% of the growth in U.S. consumer spending, which is two-thirds of GDP.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“The S&P 500 de facto back the treasury market so it's a little bit of a chicken in the egg question so uh remember net capital gains plus taxable IRA distributions alone are 200% of the growth in US consumer spending which is 2third of GDP”

0.49

A 10-year Treasury at 3.6% would not be a better store of value than stocks until the S&P PE is significantly higher and/or Treasury issuance and fiscal deficits fall materially.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“I would have to see the PE on the S&P a lot higher before I would start thinking about thinking that that the treasury 10e treasury at 3.6% was a better value”

0.49

Given current debt-to-GDP ratios, the U.S. needs the S&P 500 to rise 10-15% annually just to prevent the fiscal situation from deteriorating, which is how the S&P 'de facto backs' the Treasury market.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“so ultimately I would have to see the PE on the S&P a lot higher before I would start thinking about thinking that that the treasury 10e treasury at 3.6% was a better value as long as debt the GDP is this High and set the GDP this High the US needs the S&P to rise by 10 to 15% plus every year just to keep the fiscal situation from really falling apart which is how the S&P de facto backs the treasury market”

0.49

A viable AI and robot value-added tax could theoretically offset employment disruption by taxing GPU semiconductors or robots and directing revenue into a fund for technology investment and job retraining.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“I don't know you could do some sort of GPU you know uh tax on on AI semiconductors or on robots that goes into a fund that then invests in the technology and other job retraining things like that conceptually something like that might work”

0.49

U.S. political leadership will likely refill the Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) at oil price levels around $65-$70 to support domestic shale economics and prevent market dominance by Russia and Saudi Arabia.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“I think you're going to get Harris or Biden or Trump saying hey we're going to refill the spr baby and bid it right back up to 70 because I think that's the level it needs to be at”

0.48

If stocks don't rise, U.S. consumer spending cannot rise, GDP cannot rise, and if stocks fall, weak GDP and consumer spending will occur, increasing Treasury supply via larger deficits and creating a problem for bond market stability.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“if stocks don't go up US GDP can't go up us consumer spending can't go up mathematically and GDP probably won't go up and if stocks fall you you're you're going to see weak GDP and you're going to see weak uh consumer spending and that's a problem uh because you're going to see treasury supplies up with the bigger deficit from the recession”

0.48

Global growth shortfalls cascade to U.S. growth shortfalls, which then worsen U.S. debt-to-GDP ratios, necessitating Fed rate cuts and stimulus regardless of the triggering factor.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“anytime Chinese growth isn't high enough Global growth is is n high enough anytime Global growth isn't high enough us growth isn't going to be high enough and anytime us growth is not high enough US debt to GDP is going to get much worse much faster uh and put bring bring the US fiscal problems we've been highlighting ad nauseum forward much more aggressively and necessitate Fed rate Cuts fed s uh us stimulus Etc”

0.48

If global international reserves revert to 1980 composition with 60% in gold and 20% in dollars, the U.S. will lose the ability to run perpetual $1 trillion trade deficits and will face negative mechanical effects on the dollar's value and purchasing power.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“ultimately uh the mechanics will negatively affect the US's ability to run deficits without tears they can still run deficits but it's going to show up in the value of the dollar”

0.47

If Doomberg is correct and oil can sustainably go to $50 while shale keeps growing, then Groman's thesis about oil pricing and geopolitics would be wrong.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“let's say doomberg right let's say oil goes to 50 it's not the case is not oil can't go to 50 the case is oil can't go to 50 and Shale keep growing and so if we get oil to 50 and Shale keeps growing I'm going to be wrong full stop”

0.39

If oil stays above $65, rig count will not fall sharply and shale production will not roll over; only below that price does the assumption of production decline become likely.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“so is it possible goes into the 60s sure uh is it going to last there long probably not but that'll be our test”

0.39

The gold-to-oil ratio has historically ranged between 10 and 30 barrels per ounce and is likely to rise in the future because the oil market is approximately 12-15 times larger than the gold market.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“to oil ratio spent much of the last 100 years in a range of one 10 barrels per ounce to 30 barrels per ounce you've talked about how going forward that ratio is likely to rise since the oil Market is call it 12 to 15 times the oil Market excuse me the gold market I agree”

0.39

As long as progress continues toward multi-currency oil pricing and oil's share of total energy BTUs (British thermal units) expended remains relatively steady, the gold-to-oil ratio will likely continue rising over time.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“as long as progress keeps making uh keeps being made on multicurrency oil pricing and as long as uh oil's share of BTUs expended remains relatively steady um I think we're probably going to continue to see the gold oil ratio rise over time”

0.24

Oil prices have not stayed below $70 for very long historically.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“I agree oil is abundant um I agree gas is abundant uh let's see oil so far has not stayed below 70 for very long”

0.21

China has 'been doing a very good job supporting their bond market' though not as successfully as the U.S.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“they've been doing a very good job supporting their bond market uh a less good job than we have”