What this covers

This is episode 91 of Milkshakes Markets Madness, recorded as August closes and the US heads into a holiday weekend. Brent Johnson talks with Todd, a friend who manages money. The first half is market-focused. Equities snapped back hard after a three-week selloff tied to negative Fed headlines after Jackson Hole and a stronger yen following Bank of Japan rate hikes. From there Johnson looks ahead to a volatile stretch before the September 18th Fed meeting, and possibly into the election.

The market discussion rests on a few specific readings. Gold's first monthly close above $2,500 is set against Commitment of Traders data showing commercials more than 300,000 contracts net short, a level he compares only to the height of COVID. He also compares the chart to copper in mid-May, which looked nearly identical before copper fell 20-25%. He argues that extreme positioning tends to reverse, and that dollar sentiment, at its lowest since summer 2021, sets up a bounce that would pressure precious metals. He notes that "the milkshake is over" commentary peaked just as the dollar turned. He expects more equity downside, though he would prefer a hard selloff to a slow grind. A separate, more contested point concerns the widely shared chart of falling Chinese Treasury holdings, which he says reflects current market value) rather than sales. He cites a conversation with the Treasury Department and the correlation with bond prices as evidence.

The second half moves into politics. Johnson, who lives in Puerto Rico and does not vote, describes Donald Trump in terms of Churchill's remark that greatness and goodness rarely coexist in one person. He says he is no fan of Trump but sees a path to historical greatness. He also covers the endorsements from Robert Kennedy (RFK)) and Tulsi Gabbard, the Arlington Cemetery photo controversy, and Kamala Harris going about a month without a broadcast interview. He predicts increasingly negative campaigning, with neither side likely to accept a loss. He sees the first months after the election as a particular risk window.

Sharpest takeaway

Johnson argues that while markets have recovered strongly from August volatility, September will likely bring significant turbulence due to seasonal patterns and positioning extremes, particularly in precious metals where commercial banks are heavily short and sentiment has reached unsustainable levels.

  • Gold positioning at extremes with commercials over 300,000 contracts net short mirrors pre-reversal conditions seen in copper in May 2024, suggesting pullback risk despite bullish sentiment
  • September-October seasonality combined with election uncertainty and extreme dollar sentiment creates setup for volatility even as markets sit near all-time highs
  • Charts used to support bearish narratives (like Chinese Treasury holdings) often misrepresent market value changes as sales, requiring critical analysis of data sources

The claims · ranked34 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.81

The chart showing declining Chinese holdings of US Treasuries is widely misinterpreted as evidence of sales, but it actually reflects current market value of holdings, not face value; the Treasury Department confirmed this in direct conversations and the correlation between bond price and reported holdings proves this because sales-only data would show a straight line lower, not correlation with bond price movements.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Brent Johnson

“the chart that often is used to show that China is selling their treasury bonds does not reflect sales only sales are included in this but it also reflects a change in value of the bonds that China holds”

0.80

When analyzing financial data or charts, skepticism about reported conclusions is warranted because charts can misrepresent data through different measurement bases (face value vs. current market value, flows vs. stock changes), and verification through primary sources and logical reasoning is necessary to avoid being misled.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Brent Johnson

“when you see a chart if you see a chart and it says that it's face value you have to do your own little research to make sure that it actually is face value in other words don't read everything don't don't believe everything you read on the internet sometimes it takes a little bit more digging and a little bit of more of thinking about what you're looking at whether it Mak sense or not and if it doesn't make sense then dig even more”

0.71

Discussing Donald Trump creates polarized reactions where people either absolutely hate him or absolutely love him, similar to Bitcoin discourse, leaving little room for nuanced middle positions.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“this show is not meant to focus on Donald Trump and uh I I feel like Donald Trump is one of these guys if you don't absolutely hate him then everybody assumes that you love him it's kind of like Bitcoin if you don't absolutely love Bitcoin then everybody thinks you hate Bitcoin so it's a very polarizing issue”

0.69

September and October are traditionally difficult times for markets from a seasonality perspective, partly due to liquidity concerns and because historically large crises tend to occur in fall months.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“whenever we've been kind of big crisis it always seems to kind of happen in the fall”

0.68

A large segment of the US population, particularly in rural Midwest areas, wants Donald Trump to be president, despite the fact that in the past they would have been the last to support him due to changes in both the Republican and Democratic parties.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Brent Johnson

“there is no denying that a huge part of the population wants him to be president and I think it's really interesting especially for me because I grew up in a in in in you know the rural Midwest where you know quite frankly Trump has a lot of support and I know how people that live there think”

0.68

Commercial (bank) traders often lose money when they reach extreme short positions in commodity markets, as they are typically on the correct side of major moves and reversals that hurt them indicate structural imbalances.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“if the commercials would have to cover that would be extreme with gold at an all-time high that could send gold much much higher but typically what happens when you get to these extremes and what historically has happened is you get a reversal”

0.63

Gold closed above $2,500 for the first time in a monthly closing in history, representing a bullish signal, but positioning data from the Commitment of Traders report shows commercials (banks) are over 300,000 contracts net short—an extreme position comparable only to the height of COVID, suggesting historical reversal risk.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Brent Johnson

“gold um closed it's the month above 2500 I think that is the first close monthly closing above 2500 in history”

0.63

Dollar sentiment has reached its lowest level since summer 2021, with extreme bearish positioning creating conditions for a potential bounce, which would typically correspond with higher volatility and pressure on precious metals.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Brent Johnson

“the sentiment in the dollar is about as low this week as it was other than in the summer of 2021 it's about as low as it has been”

0.53

Johnson expects election cycle messaging to intensify over the next 2-3 months with increasingly negative attacks on both Trump and Harris from both sides, with little indication that either camp will accept a loss.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“as we lead into the election over the next two or three months um you know I think things are going to get increasingly volatile I think we're going to hear more uh stuff about how bad Trump is we're gonna hear more stuff about how great Trump is we're gonna hear more about how bad kamla is we're gonna hear more about how great she is and so you know what that leads to I I don't know but uh I have a hard time seeing how either side accepts the outcome of the election if it goes against them”

0.53

Markets rebounded very hard after the three-week selloff caused by negative FED headlines post-Jackson Hole and Japanese Yen strengthening from Bank of Japan rate hikes, indicating that while markets can move down, the bull is difficult to kill.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“we had a scare about three or four weeks ago um when we had kind of uh some negative headlines come out post the FED meeting Market sold off and it was kind of exacerbated by uh the Japanese Yen strengthening on the back of the bank of Japan raising interest rates and that caused about a two or three week kind of little mini selloff markets then very hardly rebounded or or rebounded very hard”

0.52

Johnson's Milkshake Theory, developed 4-6 years ago, is a framework designed to help understand the mechanics of the monetary system and how it may react in a debt crisis scenario.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“we do that through the lens of the dollar milkshake Theory uh which is something I came up with four five six years ago now to kind of help me understand and think through um the mechanics of the monetary system and how they may react if we were to enter a debt crisis”

0.50

The copper chart and positioning from mid-May 2024 looked almost identical to the gold COT chart currently, and Johnson warned of this parallel at the time; copper has since fallen 20-25%, suggesting similar reversals are typical when positioning reaches extremes.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“go back and look at the Copper chart and the copper positioning from the middle of May and back in the middle of May I sent out a tweet with the copper chart you know saying is it different this time or will history repeat showing the the copper CAU report from the middle of May looks almost identical to the gold CAU chart right now”

0.48

Both major parties commit similar ethical or rule-based violations in pursuit of electoral victory, meaning 'every sin committed by the Republicans is committed by the Democrats and every sin committed by the Democrats is committed by the Republicans'—a pattern likely to intensify as the election approaches.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“so to kind of to kind of see this start to blow up I think this is the start of it getting even more so I think this type of thing is probably going to increase”

0.45

Trump's character flaws prevent him from being considered a good person, which could limit his legacy, but those same character traits that enable 'greatness' in historical impact do not require goodness.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“so my point is is Trump has the qualities to give him the potential to go down in history as a great man the problem is I don't think he has the qualities to go down in history as a good good man and as as as Churchill said that's pretty rare anyway and so you know I think a lot of his character flaws um keep him from being considered a good person but it doesn't mean he can't if he gets into office achieve some great things”

0.45

Post-election is a particularly concerning period for election-related volatility, with the first couple months after the election potentially being a critical risk window.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Brent Johnson

“and especially probably you know the first couple months after the election okay that's it it's kind of a short uh short show this week but I wanted to get out there say hello to everybody”

0.41

The first two to three weeks of September leading into the Federal Reserve meeting on September 18th will likely be extremely volatile, with the possibility of movement in both directions, breaking the calm market conditions that prevailed at the end of August.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“I think September is going to be extremely volatile and I still think that that is the case so even though we finished August on somewhat of a high note and a very calm note uh you know the vix is back down to 15 I I don't expect that to last and I think the first two or three weeks of September heading up into the next fed meeting which will be September 18th could be extremely volatile”

0.41

Equities are expected to experience more downside over the next couple weeks and probably into the next couple months leading into the election, though a hard selloff would be preferable to a slow grind because it would likely present a good buying opportunity.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“I'm expecting uh more downside in the equity markets over the next couple weeks and probably into the next couple months I I would love to have a hard selloff because I think that would probably be a good buying opportunity”

0.41

Many market participants on Twitter and DMs were claiming that 'the milkshake is over,' the dollar will fall, and the US can do nothing about it, with Jerome Powell having 'thrown in the towel'—comments that peaked exactly when the dollar began to bounce, demonstrating sentiment-driven mean reversion.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“I got more comments this week you know people on Twitter or in my DM saying oh the milkshake is over the dollar is going to fall there's nothing that the US can do about it Jerome threw in the towel etc etc etc you know saying that now the dollar is going to to fall precipitously and listen Maybe that's possible I I can't rule that out but what I found was interesting is kind of at the height of all those the dollar then kind of bounced from the last couple days”

0.30

Brent Johnson is not a fan of Donald Trump personally and would not want his son to model himself after Trump, but this does not preclude Trump from having the opportunity to become a great president due to his following and historical impact potential.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“I am personally not a fan of Donald Trump I I would not choose for my son to model himself after Donald Trump and I'm going to tell you why but that doesn't change the fact that he has the opportunity to go down in history as a great president”

0.27

Trump attended a memorial service at Arlington National Cemetery for soldiers killed in the Afghanistan withdrawal, where campaign photos were taken, violating regulations against using Arlington Cemetery imagery for political purposes.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“he was at the it was for the memorial service for some of the soldiers that were killed in a in the withdrawal from Afghanistan and he was at Arlington National Cemetery and I didn't know this but apparently there's some rule that you cannot use pictures taken in Arlington Cemetery for political campaign pains and stuff”

0.27

Robert Kennedy (RFK) suspended his independent presidential campaign and endorsed Donald Trump, representing a notable shift of a traditionally Democratic figure to Trump's camp.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“RFK you know Robert Robert Kennedy um you know kind of suspended his campaign and then endorsed Trump and is going to support him now”

0.27

Tulsi Gabbard, who was not running for president in 2024, came out publicly to support Donald Trump.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“Tulsi gabard um wasn't running this year but she came out and supported Trump”

0.26

Johnson does not vote and lives in Puerto Rico, where he is not allowed to vote, stating this partly as explanation for why he maintains distance from direct electoral engagement despite discussing elections.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“I don't vote and you know even if I wanted to I'm I'm not allowed to vote from Puerto Rico”

0.21

Kamala Harris had not done a broadcast interview for approximately one month after Biden stepped out of the race and she secured the Democratic nomination, which is notably late in a presidential campaign cycle.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Brent Johnson

“KLA Harris has not done an interview um since uh you know getting the nomination and it's been like I don't know or since since Biden stepped out of the race and that's it's been like a month”

0.20

Johnson has met Kamala Harris personally multiple times when he lived in San Francisco, and some of his wife's friends knew her at social events.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“I've actually met KLA Harris a couple times my wife's met her a couple times when we lived in San Francisco some of our friends knew her and and so we would be at a couple different events when she was there”

0.19

Johnson is the founder/principal of Santiago Capital and has been hosting the 'Milkshakes, Markets and Madness' podcast for almost two years, recently changing format and sometimes doing solo commentary shows.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“my name is Brent Johnson I've got a firm called Santiago capital and we've been doing this show for almost two years now and as you know we've kind of recently changed the format and we've been switching it around a little bit and what you're going to get today is really just me talking”

0.19

His friend Todd has lost money in every September for the last 10 years, demonstrating that seasonality is a real phenomenon that traders should not ignore.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Todd (friend/money manager)

“he told me today he said we're going into September and I've lost I've lost money in every September for the last 10 years um so that's you know that's something else and he said listen seasonality is a real thing you got to be careful”

0.19

Kamala Harris has successfully navigated her political career to bring herself within striking distance of the presidency, meaning whatever one thinks of her, her maneuverability and political survival skills are notable.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“I have to say I'm I'm not a fan but you know she uh she has maneuvered herself throughout her career and she is you know within spitting distance of the White House so whatever you think of her um and whether you like her or you don't like her she could become the next president”

0.19

Bringing Tim Walz (male running mate) as Kamala Harris's companion for her first interview after a month of no interviews was a strategic misstep that undermined her brand as a potential first female president.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“she could potentially be the first woman president and that's a great thing you know it's a great thing to potentially have a woman be president I have no problem with a woman being president I thought it was really to me it it hurt her brand so to speak or or it hurt the the woman's movement that you know she she she brought Tim Waltz with her for the first interview like why why would you bring your male running mate when you are trying to become the first female uh president”

0.19

Markets can go down, which had not been visibly demonstrated in recent months before the July/August selloff, and this reminder of downside risk is important context for the current environment.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“we saw something that we hadn't seen for a while and that is that markets can actually go down um”

0.14

Gold was testing and declined from a peak near $2,525 earlier in the week, closing around $2,500, indicating profit-taking or pullback from intraweek highs.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Brent Johnson

“it was at 2525 a couple days ago and then had a not a hard sell off but a fairly strong selloff over the last couple days”

0.14

VIX (volatility index) has returned to 15, a calm level that Johnson does not expect to persist given multiple volatility catalysts in early September.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Brent Johnson

“so even though we finished August on somewhat of a high note and a very calm note uh you know the vix is back down to 15 I I don't expect that to last”

0.13

It was a slow week at the end of August with quiet markets, which motivated Johnson to record despite limited breaking news, to share his market thinking and outlook.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“because it was kind of a slow week it's the last week of August kind of the end of summer here markets for the most part were pretty quiet um so not a whole lot happened but I still wanted to get together and you know do a show and kind of tell you what I'm thinking”

0.13

Johnson predicts that in the 2024 election, he personally does not know if Trump will win, whereas he predicted Trump would win in 2016 (and he did) and predicted he would win in 2020 (and he didn't).

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Brent Johnson

“in 2016 I predicted he would win and he did um in 2020 I predicted he would win and he didn't and this year I just really don't know it won't surprise me at all if he does it won't surprise me if he doesn't”