What this covers

This is a 43-minute debate between Luke Groman and Don Luskin, moderated by Sprott's John Hathaway. Much of it is argued through history. Groman builds his case on the post-WWII deleveraging. The Fed and Treasury committed to yield-pegging in January 1942, the Fed's balance sheet grew roughly tenfold by 1951, and the debt-to-GDP ratio fell from about 110% to 55%. He credits inflation, with real rates bottoming near negative 13% in 1947–48 once rationing ended. Luskin answers with his own readings of the period. He points to the 1950 real growth of 13.3% arriving alongside 9% inflation, and he treats the war as a full restart of the global economy. Groman replies that the 1950 figure reflected specific policy circumstances, such as rebuilding Germany and Japan, the Cold War and the Berlin Airlift, and not a general productivity boom.

The second strand is the current plumbing of Treasury markets. Groman lists five episodes of dysfunction in four years, from the September 2019 repo spike to October 2023. He reads them as coordinated Fed–Treasury liquidity responses. Among his examples are Janet Yellen running down the Treasury General Account (TGA)) in 2022 and the Fed's par swaps on underwater Treasuries in March 2023. He expects the pattern to recur as deficits rise again. Luskin sets this against a contracting M2 money supply and invokes Milton Friedman's monetary theory to rule out a replay of the Arthur Burns 1970s.

The debate also turns contentious on method and on trade. Luskin attacks the Kenneth Rogoff and Reinhart debt-threshold work, and he argues that comparing debt (a balance-sheet item) to GDP (an income-statement item) is an accounting error. He adds that productivity is measured in the private sector and is unrelated to government debt. Groman concedes that the same flaw undermines the Warren Buffett market-cap-to-GDP metric. He also argues that the US lost a decades-long trade contest by offshoring through NAFTA and China's WTO entry, and that BRICS trade settlement creates a steady bid for gold.

Sharpest takeaway

Groman argues sustained inflation is politically necessary to manage US debt, requiring negative real rates maintained through Fed/Treasury coordination, while Luskin contends contractionary money supply will cause deflation unless growth solves the fiscal problem organically.

  • US debt-to-GDP at 120% requires negative real rates to be serviceable; positive 2% real rates trigger fiscal dominance and market dysfunction
  • M2 money supply has contracted year-over-year for first time since 1959, pointing to deflation absent policy intervention
  • Treasury market dysfunction episodes recur when fiscal deficits exceed balance sheet capacity, forcing coordinated Fed-Treasury liquidity injections

The claims · ranked52 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

The Federal Reserve's balance sheet expanded tenfold from 1942 to 1951, mostly during the war, when the Fed committed to buying all 10-year Treasuries at 2.5% and all 3-month Treasuries at 0.375% with no questions asked, effectively financing the largest public works program in history.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Luke Groman

“the FED came out and said we will buy every 10year treasury you issue at 2 a half% we will buy every 3-month treasury at 38% no question asked and the fed's balance sheet grew 10x from 1942 to 1951 and with most of that growth during the war”

0.80

Post-WWII US real interest rates bottomed at negative 13% in 1947–1948, while in defeated nations inflation ran far higher: Japan at negative 60%, Italy at negative 40%, and Australia at negative 30%, all above their nominal rates, because victorious nations could impose negative real rates to deleverage while losers could not.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Luke Groman

“us real rates bottomed in 47 or 48 atga 133% we were the winner of the war critically in Japan the loser of the war real rates bottomed attive 60 60% in Italy 40% in Australia who won 30% uh in other words inflation ran anywhere from 13% above rates to as high as 60% above rates in Japan in war ravaged countries”

0.74

Post-WWII US GDP was 110% debt-to-GDP, and the US deleveraged by having the Fed and Treasury 'get married' (commit to yield-pegging) in January 1942, allowing the Fed's balance sheet to grow 10x from 1942–1951, with most growth during the war, financing the largest public works project in history.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Luke Groman

“similarly post World War II us death the GDP was 110% What followed was a US deleveraging its balance sheet uh by virtue of the fed and treasury who got married in January of 1942 shortly after the Japanese bomb Pearl Harbor uh the FED came out and said we will buy every 10year treasury you issue at 2 a half% we will buy every 3-month treasury at 38% no question asked and the fed's balance sheet grew 10x from 1942 to 1951”

0.74

In September 2019, repo rates spiked to 8–10%, forcing the Fed to regrow its balance sheet at a time when few expected it; in March 2020, Treasury markets crashed (in Stan Druckenmiller's 40-year experience unprecedented), forcing the Fed to inject $600 billion per week in QE until stabilization.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Luke Groman

“the first one was in September 2019 when we saw repo ratees Spike to 8 to 10% the FED very quickly came in began regrowing their balance sheet at a period of time where no one thought they were going to do it except for us and a few others March of 2020 we saw the brief deflationary Spike around Co at the bottom of it treasury market crashed Stan dren Miller's words something he said in 40 years he had never seen treasury market crashed fed comes in 600 billion a week in QE”

0.69

Post-WWII rationing of goods kept inflation contained during the war, but when rationing ended inflation exploded, with US real rates bottoming at negative 13% in 1947–1948, which is why the US could deleverage so quickly from 110% to 55% debt-to-GDP by 1951.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“there was rationing of Goods in the war to contain inflation during the war but after the war rationing of goods went off and US inflation rates exploded us real rates bottomed in 47 or 48 atga 133% we were the winner of the war critically in Japan the loser of the war real rates bottomed attive 60 60%”

0.69

The Great Depression of the 1930s was solved by World War II, which was not only the greatest public works program ever conceived but a complete restart of the global economy with massive investments in new technologies (jet aircraft, etc.) that the world spent 20 years adopting.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Don Luskin

“its solution was World War II that was not only the greatest Public Works program ever conceived by the mind of man but it was a complete restart of the global economy a massive investment in new technologies which the world spent the next 20 years adopting so for instance jet aircraft were invented in World War II every combatant had them they were on the field in 1945”

0.69

Eisenhower's Interstate Highway System was government spending that drove massive productivity booms in the 1950s and beyond, suggesting that government spending on productive infrastructure can be growth-enhancing, and current energy investments may have similar effects.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“we had the heisen Hower highway system with government spending helped Drive massive productivity booms in the 50s and into the 60s and Beyond and I think that type of government spending if done if spent on the right productivity enhancing things and there's signs that some of that might be happening um some of the energy Investments we are making could prove to be driving productivity enhancement Lake Don is is is suggesting”

0.68

Five times in the past four years (September 2019 repo spike, March 2020 COVID crash, September 2022 pension fund crisis, March 2023 banking crisis, October 2023 Treasury dysfunction), Treasury market dysfunction has forced the Fed and Treasury to respond with coordinated liquidity provision—a pattern that will repeat when deficits rise.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“we have had for the past excuse me five times in the past four years anytime you get the deficit into not enough balance sheet capacity you get the US government crowding out Global dollar markets the dollar start to rise and we quickly get into a treasury market problem the first one was in September 2019 when we saw repo ratees Spike to 8 to 10% the FED very quickly came in began regrowing their balance sheet”

0.68

In March 2023, when the banking system was upside down in their Treasury holdings, the Fed engaged in what was effectively yield curve control for the US banking system by conducting swaps at par on Treasuries that were trading approximately 30% below par, supplying liquidity without explicit QE announcement.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“one q23 was the fourth instance where we saw the banking system get upside down in their treasuries and the FED could have said nope sell them at losses to supply money to supply deposit losses but the FED didn't the FED instead did what was effectively yield curve control for the US banking system and engaged in swaps at par on treasuries that were trading probably 30% below par”

0.68

Rogoff and Reinhardt's famous work on debt-to-GDP ratios was based partly on computational errors that they were forced to correct three years after publication, and comparing a balance sheet item (debt) to an income statement item (GDP) is a fundamental accounting error—like an economics teacher failing a student for the same mistake.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Don Luskin

“respected economists like rogo and Reinhardt talk about the debt to GDP ratio all the time their most famous work on it was based in part on some very important computational errors they were terribly embarrassed to have to correct three years after their book was published but nevertheless it's an insufficient metric to begin with if rogoff and Reinhardt were your econ 101 teacher they would actually flunk you for comparing a balance sheet item to an income statement item”

0.68

In September 2022, the Treasury did not tighten policy directly but instead Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen ran down the Treasury General Account (TGA) so fast that she more than offset the tightening impact of the Fed's QT and rate hikes, supplying liquidity to the system in a way that was politically deniable.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“after the FED started tightening the third instance of Treasury Market dysfunction uh was September 2022 very quickly it wasn't the fed this time we thought it would be the FED we were wrong uh it was treasury Yellen began running down the TGA uh so fast that she more than offset the tightening impact of the fed's QT and rate hikes”

0.68

The US debt-to-GDP ratio fell from 110% in 1945 to 55% by 1951 primarily through inflation that eroded the real value of debt, not through surplus budgets, because the Fed and Treasury were married (committed to yield-pegging) and allowed inflation to run to deleverage the balance sheet.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“by letting us real rates bottom at 13% the US debt to GDP went from 110% in 1945 to 55% by 1951 when there was something called the FED treasury Accord agreed to which effectively was fed and treasury treasury saying okay fed you are independent again War's over now you can run independent monetary policy”

0.68

The Warren Buffett metric (equity market cap divided by GDP) is invalid because it commits the same sin as debt-to-GDP: comparing a stock to a flow, and Groman's earlier reference to this metric in 2018 was flawed.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“but what what you're fine what Buffett's a great a great expert and you can use his name to get credibility but comparing the market cap of the S&P to GDP is just committing the same sin as committing Deb comparing debt to GDP that's an invalid thing to do”

0.68

BRICS nations are using gold as a neutral reserve settlement asset for intra-BRICS trade, and since BRICS oil imbalances are large and oil markets are 12–15 times the size of the physical gold market globally, there is a relentless bid for gold from BRICS trade settlement.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“the bricks are using gold as their neutral Reserve settlement asset for intra brick trade and the reality is is to the extent that is largely driven by Commodities those imbalances among trade are largely driven by Commodities and in particular oil the oil Market is some 12 to 15 times the size of the physical gold market globally”

0.68

The Federal Reserve in 2022 executed rate hikes while Treasury Secretary Yellen ran down the Treasury General Account to offset tightening, showing that Treasury-side policy tools can be used to supply liquidity independently of Fed policy.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“it was treasury Yellen began running down the TGA uh so fast that she more than offset the tightening impact of the fed's QT and rate hikes and she ran down the dollar and that supplied liquidity to the system”

0.63

The fiscal deficit has bottomed and is rising again on a trailing 12-month basis, which is a leading indicator for money supply expansion because the government must finance rising spending, and without sufficient balance sheet capacity the US Treasury and Fed will be forced to supply liquidity to prevent market dysfunction.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“the reason I don't think we're going to get a downward Trend in in GDP is I think ultimately when I look at what is happening with the fiscal deficit situation federal government spending it has bottomed and is already Rising again no and I think that's our leading indicator on what money supply is ultimately going to do and the reason I say that is because unless the government cuts that spending someone needs a finance that spending and the balance sheet isn't there”

0.62

The 1950 real GDP growth of 13.3% was not a general phenomenon but was driven by specific policy choices: post-war rebuilding of Germany and Japan, the onset of the Cold War, and the Berlin Airlift (specifically 1948), not a general productivity boom.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“well why did we have that growth I just said why we had that growth because Japan's industrial base was Destro and we were building it because we were in a new cold war with the Soviets we were rebuilding it we were rebu we were running the Buran airlift we were rebuilding Germany it was American Property”

0.62

The United States with debt-to-GDP at 120% plus requires sustained negative real interest rates to remain functional, meaning rates must stay below inflation, because positive 2% real rates would quickly trigger fiscal dominance that destabilizes Treasury markets.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“The US with debt the GDP at 120 plus% needs sustain negative real interest rates in other words rates need to be below inflation this was talked about in great detail actually last summer in a white paper on the St Louis fed website by Charles kyus he wrote in there that positive 2% re rates would quickly put the us into fiscal dominance almost immediately”

0.62

The US lost a 25-30 year economic and trade war against China and other competitors by offshoring its industrial base via NAFTA (to Mexico) and then via China WTO entry, in contrast to the post-WWII scenario where the US was the only intact industrial nation.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“I think Co was the last battle of what was a 30-year 25e trade War economic war and and we lost that war and the reason I know we lost that war is because in World War II the people that lost lost a good portion of their industrial base it had been bombed into Oblivion and then the United States had a boom as we basically rebuilt it for them particularly again Germany and Japan in contrast without bombing uh the United States via trade policy first via NAFTA where we sent the factories to Mexico and then via China into the WTO where we sent those factories to China the United States's industrial base this time at the end of this war quote unquote war is the one that has been severely impaired”

0.62

The reason Groman believes sustained negative real interest rates are necessary is his view that to sustain 120% debt-to-GDP either productivity must miracle (it hasn't) or the US must run sustained negative real interest rates, which means higher inflation and equities performing very well.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“ultimately the debt has to run to sustain 120% debt the GDP you either need a productivity Miracle or you are going to have to run sustained negative real interest rates which means higher inflation and then higher negative real or negative real interest rates are very good for equities to be clear I'm not being what I'm saying it's not dire for equities it's very good for equities just not good for bonds it's very very good for gold it's not great for the dollar”

0.62

Luskin's inflation model predicts that if money supply is contracting at 2% year-over-year (opposite to the 14% growth in December 1976), a resurgence of inflation like the 1976 Arthur Burns replay is impossible according to Milton Friedman's monetary theory.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Don Luskin

“you are not going to get an Arthur burn style 1976 style Resurgence of inflation like you got when the money supply was growing at 14% year-over-year which is what it was doing in December 1976 it is now Contracting by 2% a year so Resurgence of inflation impossible according to my model”

0.60

The global economy shut down for 3 months to a year during the pandemic, experiencing a 10% GDP contraction in 3 months—orders of magnitude worse than the Great Recession's 3.5% drop over a year and a half—making it a true depression comparable to the 1930s.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Don Luskin

“we had a an economic crisis in the pandemic where the entire global economy was shut down anywhere from 3 months to a year we had fluctuations in economic variables like GDP growth like unemployment the likes of which haven't haven't been seen since the 30s so you know I remember people were saying during the so-called Great Recession of 2008 and 2009 oh this is the worst thing since the depression uh yeah but you know almost ORD of magnitude different right so in the Great Recession over a year and over a year and a half we saw a three and a half% drop in GDP okay well we saw 10% J drop in GDP in three months during during the pandemic”

0.60

The 1950 real GDP growth of 13.3%—the single biggest real GDP year in American history—also occurred when inflation was at 9% (the height of post-war inflation), showing that inflation and strong real growth can occur simultaneously.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Don Luskin

“Look there were a couple High inflation years like 1949 and 1950 were but 1950 also has the distinction it has the distinction of being the height of post-war inflation at 9% but it's also the single biggest real GDP year in American history at 133%”

0.60

Productivity is real output divided by hours worked and has nothing to do with government debt; productivity statistics from the Department of Labor exclude government and focus on private sector, so one can have flat debt-to-GDP while having rising private sector productivity.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Don Luskin

“what what is the pro what is your calculation I mean the productivity say it again I'm going to use the same one that every Economist uses it's real output divided by hours worked real output divided by always work and what's in real output 25% of real output is US government spending and how does out that's that's not so you know by the way that's actually not true the productivity statistics provided by the Department of Labor are private sector they actually exclude government and if you look at it that way now I understand so when I say real uh when I say real GDP I mean real private output the private part of GDP that's the official way of doing it”

0.57

M2 money supply has experienced the first year-over-year outright decline in the history of data going back to 1959, which according to Milton Friedman's monetary theory will lead to deflation within 12 to 24 months unless the money supply reverses.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Don Luskin

“we're experiencing the first year-over-year outright decline in the M2 money supply in the history of the data that goes all the way back to 1959 now the world's a complicated place but if I had to cite a single simple rule for a complex world it would be Milton Friedman's famous dictate that inflation is everywhere and always a monetary phenomenon”

0.57

If debt is growing as fast as GDP (as shown by stable debt-to-GDP), then by definition there is no productivity increase because productivity excludes debt in its calculation (productivity = real output / hours worked).

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Don Luskin

“you say well we're getting the productivity but you just cited you said the debt to GDP is flat for the last three years if we were having a productivity boom per year prior point about post World War II the debt the GDP would have not stopped falling at 120 it would already be back to 110 or 100 or 90”

0.53

Federal Reserve policy has been at 5.375% (the highest rate in 17 years since July 2023 FOMC meeting), and markets are expecting the first rate cut in June 2024, with the Fed doing nothing to disabuse markets of this expectation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Don Luskin

“you know they've had the FED funds rate at 5 and 38 it's the highest uh rate in 17 years since the July fomc meeting and markets don't expect they're going to make the first cut until the June FMC meeting and they're not saying anything to disabuse the market of that in the meantime we're experiencing the first year-over-year outright decline in the M2 money supply”

0.52

A mortgage banker evaluates debt using debt-to-value and debt-to-equity ratios, not debt-to-income; therefore US debt should be compared to US equity (the present value of future taxing power), best estimated by the market cap of the S&P 500.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Don Luskin

“what you probably want to do is you want to compare balance sheet items to balance sheet items so that's what a mortgage Banker does when you're applying for for a jumbo mortgage he says what's the loan to value ratio what's the debt to equity ratio in the United States sure in dollar terms in nominal dollar terms federal debt is horrifying especially if you're a conservative like me who wants the federal government to be smaller so you know as a citizen I think it's just absolutely ridiculous it's horrible it's not to be born but as an economist I'm going to be like a mortgage Banker I'm going to say okay what's what's your debt to equity ratio here do I want to issue this jumbo mortgage to you well I don't know what's the equity of the United States well I guess its single most important item is the present value of its future taxing power well what's that well that's going to be very closely connected to the earnings power of the American economy in perpetuity present valued what's our best estimate of that the market cap of the S&P 500”

0.52

Groman computed a metric in 2018 where he subtracted federal debt from US equity market cap and compared the net equity to GDP, finding that equities weren't that expensive on an enterprise value basis, and this computation directly backs his view that sustained negative real interest rates are required.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“we wrote about that you know the the SNP to the debt right Don referred to is is you know popularly known as the Warren Buffet metric right the Warren Buffett metric is equity market cap divided by GDP and Warren Buffett has cited this famously and I agree with it right but but excuse me but what what what you're fine what Buffett's a great a great expert and you can use his name to get credibility but comparing the market cap of the S&P to GDP is just committing the same sin as committing Deb comparing debt to GDP that's an invalid thing to do even when you wrote about this in 2018 that if you subtract the debt from the equity at the top right the S&P the the global Equity or the US Equity market cap and then compare it to GDP you find that the debt and basically an Enterprise Val eida basis you end up finding that equities aren't that expensive is what we found in 2018”

0.52

The pandemic was a war—not man against man but all men together against an invisible invader—and produced technologies (work-from-home revolution, mRNA vaccines) and a warrior mentality that will drive growth for the next 20 years, similar to post-WWII recovery.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Don Luskin

“this was the best war ever because this wasn't man against man and we didn't destroy the world's physical plant like we did in World War II this was all men together working against an alien invisible Invader and when you come out of an experience like that not only are you armed with whole new ways of interacting with people interacting with your work new technologies you can use but you're a warrior man if you survived that you're going to mourn your dead and you're a warrior and you're going to act accordingly”

0.49

Reverse repo rundowns are already supplying liquidity interim, and ISDA (the banking lobby) recently wrote to the Fed, FDIC, and OCC requesting permanent exemptions to the Supplementary Leverage Ratio (SLR) rule for Treasury holdings—effectively yield curve control or QE executed through banks instead of the Fed.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“we've seen the rundown in reverse repo that's supplying liquidity in the interim Yellen has TGA that can be run down uh after that uh but we saw a couple weeks ago uh isda uh the two big def fail banking uh lobbyist effectively write a letter to the fed the FDIC and the OC C asking for permanent exemptions to the SLR uh rule for treasuries this is simply yield curve control or QE executed through the bank”

0.49

In October 2023, Treasury market dysfunction led Fed speakers to jawbone the dollar down in seven speeches over ten days with the same message ('the bond market has done our job for us'), and Treasury Secretary Yellen shifted issuance from long to short end to relieve pressure—another coordinated policy response.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“October of this of of just this past year where we again saw treasury market dysfunction we saw seven fed speakers in 10 days Jawbone the dollar down like they were reading from a himn the bond market has done our job for us the bond market has done our job for us they all said basically the same thing Yellen comes in shifts issu in from the long end to the front end”

0.49

Core CPI excluding owner's equivalent rent (the largest, laggiest, and statistically most invalid component of CPI) is already back to 2%, and course CPI is at 2.4%, both at or below the Fed's 2.5% target for months, with goods segments already showing year-over-year deflation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Don Luskin

“already CPI if you take out Oar owner's equivalent rent the largest part the laggiest part the statistically most invalid part if you take that out already CPI is back to 2% course CPI is back to 2.4 they've been there for months now expressed in CPI terms the fed's target is two and a half they've been below Target for the better part of a year large parts of CP especially the goods parts are already in downright year-over-year minus sign deflation”

0.48

The moderator (Hathaway) notes that US GDP is 25% government spending and asks whether the private sector is being eclipsed by government spending and the need to finance it, suggesting that robust private sector growth may not be enough if government spending is growing faster.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· John Hathaway (Moderator)

“which as I understand the stats and you guys are both more way above my pay grade in this that includes government activity uh GDP consists of I think one of you said 25% of it is is government so without government being 25% and maybe an increasing amount in future years you really don't get that GDP growth the private sector is maybe it's robust but uh it's being is it being eclipsed I guess this is the question I should ask is it is it being eclipsed by government uh spending”

0.48

Luskin has a point of agreement with Groman: the current situation is risky and fragile, and a shock (recession) could disrupt the 'so far so good' narrative, particularly if it causes policymakers to increase debt further to escape the downturn.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Don Luskin

“I I suspect a point of agreement is that we are in a at least a risky or fragile place where you know I'm I'm sort of staking it all on saying we can grow our way out of this but shocks can happen things things can happen where some event happens in the world where you know it's enough of a thing to put you in a recession for a while and so now you go for two or three or four quarters with Contracting or poor growth but the debt doesn't go away and you know the way politicians act nowadays if you're in that recession they're actually going to crank up the debt to get you out of the recession”

0.48

If Luke's premises are correct—that inflation is necessary to sustain US debt—combined with the reality of contracting money supply and deflationary pressures, the US faces a deflationary disaster and credit bust, which would be politically unpalatable and force the Fed into 'warp speed' monetary creation.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“I would certainly agree with the the logic of what you just said it would not only just be disinflation it would be deflation and a credit bust which I would think politically is totally unpalatable and I I expect that that would force the FED into warp speed as far as money creation”

0.48

Unless policymakers are willing to stand aside and allow Treasury market dysfunction AND treasury auction fails (which will never be allowed), money supply will expand because rising government spending requires financing and the Fed-Treasury complex will provide liquidity through multiple mechanisms.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“for it to be continued negative the FED and/or treasury have to stand aside and let the treasury market dysfunction and then not just dysfunction but you have to start allowing treasury auction fails which is just never going to be allowed in our country in my view”

0.48

Don Luskin's view focuses on institutional machinations (Fed, Treasury, ISDA) without mentioning private sector or real economic activity, presenting an interlocking series of lowercase-c conspiracy theories where powerful hidden agents pull the world's strings.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Don Luskin

“your view of the world at least the one that you just expressed is one where you think the only thing that matters that's worth mentioning are the machinations of these institutions and I didn't hear one single word in that narrative about anything going on in the private sector or the real economy and I'm I'm I'm going to use an expression here and I it's I guess it's inevitably a pejorative expression I can't quite come up with with another one but please accept when I say it I I don't mean it to sound pejorative you have a an interlocking series of what amount to lowercase C conspiracy theories”

0.48

If nominal GDP can be kept well above the rate of interest, the debt problem is solved over time, which is good for stocks (especially industrial stocks), commodities, and gold, but not great for the dollar and is consistent with inflation.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“ultimately uh in terms of our our choices the productivity gains depend on our choices but ultimately nominal GDP is nominal GDP and so if you can keep nominal GDP well above the rate of interest uh that takes care of the debt problem over time that is really good for uh stocks and particularly industrial stocks that's really good for gold it's really good for uh Commodities it's it's not great for the dollar and it's good for inflation”

0.45

On a trade-weighted basis (e.g., versus the Yen), the US dollar has been in the same range for the past 5–6 years, showing no signs of dollar crisis, and the dollar may even be too strong.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Don Luskin

“on a trade weighted basis if we were to look at it say versus the Yen Well you certainly don't need to worry about a dollar crisis except maybe the dollar is too strong but in the last five or six years while all this is playing out the Dollar's just been in kind of the same range it's it's generally been in for sure”

0.45

Federal debt-to-GDP peaked at a higher level in 2020 during the COVID stimulus period, but has since fallen back and stabilized at 118–121% for the past 3.5 years, suggesting that nominal GDP growth is keeping pace with debt growth and the ratio is now in equilibrium.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Don Luskin

“versus that Peak that it attained in 2020 it is now lower than that it immediately fell back to something like 120 and within a percentage Point debt to GDP has been something like 118 120 121 studing now for three and a half years now that can only be true if the debt is growing at approximately the same rate as the as the nominal economy”

0.45

Real GDP growth as measured by quarter-over-quarter changes since 1Q23 has been positive every quarter, though small enough that 'you'd need a magnifying glass to win your point,' suggesting growth exists but is modest.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Luke Groman

“and yet that the GDP isn't falling yes it is depends what it depends what you're it's not that's just wrong it's not Rising since 1 q23 gross to GDP Hasen every lower than it was four years ago well four years ago but since 1 q23 that the GDP is up every quarter it's it's it's you you say it's up it's up by such a tiny little amount you'd need a magnifying glass to win your point”

0.45

Rebuilding the US industrial base requires 'some version of industrial policy,' exactly why Trump started it and Biden has continued it, and both 2024 candidates are openly talking about varying degrees of industrial policy, which will be highly inflationary.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“you're going to have to basically uh do some version of industrial policy which is I think exactly why Trump started it in and Biden has continued it in 2020 and on uh and both candidates are openly talking about varying degrees of industrial policy to rebuild that as well”

0.45

Gold is trading at all-time highs in US dollars, and the market (via gold's price) is recognizing that the US cannot afford its debt at positive real rates and will require a return to negative real rates and inflationary policy.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“I think there's two reasons to this number one the market is recognizing the United States cannot afford its debt level on a sustained basis with positive real rates they're going to need to go back to negative real rates and an inflationary policy again so they're buying gold”

0.45

Gold's all-time highs disagree with Luskin's monetary model, as a global supercomputer of the smartest people in the world (via gold pricing) is showing different expectations than his model predicts, creating a disconnect he acknowledges.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Don Luskin

“but on the other hand gold the price of which is the output of a global supercomputer of the smartest people in the world coming up with their idea of where inflation's going well that supercomputer and my model don't agree right now so we'll see”

0.35

Treasury yields and Fed funds rates are now back to levels that were normal before the Great Financial Crisis and are no longer abnormal; the only abnormal thing is the debt-to-GDP ratio, but the debt-to-equity ratio is better.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Don Luskin

“we are not seeing things that are abnormal the only thing that's abnormal is the debt is the debt to GDP ratio the debt to equity ratio is better the quite the question really was do do you agree that using the S&P as a proxy for future earnings power is valid”

0.34

January and February 2024 inflation readings were slightly hotter than expected, which Luskin initially dismissed as anomalous, but now with two such readings, he is concerned they might signal an Arthur Burns 1976-style replay.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Don Luskin

“I do note that this move by gold to new alltime highs it's it's not exactly running away but you know it's obviously new all-time highs you know that's a thing you can't ignore that that is happening at a time when not so much the FED but I think you know ordinary Market participants are looking at the way inflation's been coming in this year in January and February and they're thinking well is this going to be a replay of 1976 where you know it's like Powell has been warning us for the last three years...here we are with a Contracting money supply so to me my going in Assumption is that the slightly hotter January and February inflation readings are anomalous they're kind of you know one offy uh I I guess there have been two of them now so so that that's not good”

0.34

If history is any guide, the US experiences recessions once in a while, making Luskin's contingency on no shocks a vulnerable assumption.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Don Luskin

“you know if history is any guide we do have recessions every once in a while let' admit that”

0.32

Corporate tax receipts are currently higher at a 22% tax rate than the Congressional Budget Office forecast they would be at a 28% rate in 2023, showing that the private sector is more productive and profitable than expected, supporting economic health.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Don Luskin

“if you're having a productivity boom you should be having a tax receipt boom which would lead to lower need for the federal you are having a tax receipt boom corporate tax corporate tax receipts right now are higher at a 22% corporate tax rate than the CBO forecast they would be in 2023 back when they thought the rate was going to be 28%”

0.32

The federal debt-to-S&P 500 market cap ratio is at the lowest in 15 years, which does not suggest the US is coming off the rails, and supports Luskin's view that the fiscal position is manageable.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Don Luskin

“the ratio of the federal debt to the market cap of the S&P 500 which represents the present value of all the earnings potential in the United States forever minus that this is market cap well that's about the lowest in 15 years so that's not coming off the rails”

0.22

Supporting a war with Russia in Ukraine does not drive long-term US productivity, in contrast to infrastructure spending, suggesting that not all government spending is created equal for growth purposes.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“supporting a war with Russia in Ukraine doesn't drive productivity in the long run so it it depends on our choices”

0.17

Luskin holds substantial gold positions and has done so for 40 years, believing in gold as insurance, but if someone offered him Venezuelan bolivars in exchange for his gold, he would refuse, suggesting gold's value is as insurance, not as a currency replacement.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Don Luskin

“can I just say that if anybody I I have quite a lot of gold I'm a Believer had it for 40 years if anyone comes and offer me Venezuelan boulevards for my gold not someone you're a smart guy”