YouTube26m· Apr 2026· cataloged

Why Carson Block Says AI and Passive Investing Could Break the Stock Market | WSJ’s Take On the Week


What this covers

This WSJ "Take On the Week" episode is a conversation between hosts Miriam Gottfried and Peter Rudegeair and Carson Block, the short seller who runs Muddy Waters Capital. It begins with why markets are hard for shorts right now. Block cites years of suppressed volatility after the Global Financial Crisis (GFC)), when low rates and swift policy responses to drawdowns signaled an economy too leveraged to tolerate dislocation. He also points to retail-coordinated squeezes such as GameStop and OpenDoor, and says his firm now watches social media and avoids setups where a squeeze looks to be building.

On AI, Block says the "bubble" question is the wrong one. Hyperscalers are well capitalized, he argues, unlike the dot-com era's borrowers, so the real issue is what AI does to jobs. His claims are bold and flagged as contested or fringe in the material: that Claude and ChatGPT now help code and test their successors, that the legal profession will be devastated, and that knowledge workers will see losses, with an unprecedented hit to the top of the earnings ladder.

The second half widens out. Block calls private credit opaque by design, citing loose private documentation, the risk of pledging the same loans repeatedly, payment-in-kind structures that echo pre-2008 incentives, and insurers whose holdings may not be investment grade. He explains why it is hard to short directly, so spillover plays through banks and insurers are the alternative. He then describes why his firm avoids overseas-listed Chinese companies, the limits of auditors against "control fraud," and his view that the legal "gray zone" matters more than outright fraud. He also weighs the SEC's proposal to end quarterly reporting and closes with a rare long position in Snowline Gold.

Sharpest takeaway

Carson Block argues that AI-driven job displacement of knowledge workers will trigger a financial market collapse within 3-5 years, creating opportunities for short sellers similar to 2008, while most investors remain distracted by geopolitical noise and underestimate systemic risks due to generational inexperience with market dislocations.

  • AI capability progression is exponential (Claude and ChatGPT now code/test their own successors), enabling replacement of 15% of knowledge workers (1 in 7 employees)
  • Passive investing fragility: when knowledge worker 401k contributions reverse due to job losses, forced selling will exceed available active capital, causing 1929-magnitude correction at 2020 speed
  • Two generations of investors since 2008 GFC lack risk appreciation; complacency in private credit (loose documentation, misaligned incentives) mirrors pre-2008 conditions

The claims · ranked43 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

Auditors do not prepare financial statements; management does, and an auditor's job is to ensure that the correct financial standards have been applied correctly, not to identify forged documents, so in cases of 'control fraud' where management is cooking books at the senior level, auditors cannot be expected to identify the fraud.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Carson Block

“I mean, look, first of all, what vast majority of investors don't understand is that auditors do not prepare financial statements. Management does. An auditor's job is to ensure that the correct financial standards have been applied, and they've been applied correctly. So, if you have a situation that's called a control fraud where management is cooking the books at the most senior level it's not literally it's not the auditor's job to sit there and identify forged documents.”

0.69

AI-driven job losses will trigger an 'AI-driven jobs apocalypse' where demand contraction from unemployed workers will feed upon itself, creating a self-reinforcing cycle of economic contraction.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“So, we're heading toward uh what I think will be, you know, an AI-driven kind of, you know, jobs [12:33] apocalypse. And then of course, once you get demand contracting because those people have lost their jobs, well, that's going to feed upon itself.”

0.69

Private credit is an opaque asset class by design, and there are serious concerns about it including loose documentation practices where documentation is private between parties and not publicly filed, creating real opportunity for fraud such as pledging the same loans multiple times (similar to the First Brand collateral fraud).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“There's some market practices there that are really loose in terms of documentation where um documentation is not publicly filed, it's private between parties, and offers real opportunity to forge documents so that you can pledge the same loans multiple times. So, that's similar to the First Brand situation, which is an auto parts [13:36] supplier that went bankrupt, and it got in trouble in part because it pledged the same collateral for different loans.”

0.69

It is difficult to short private credit effectively except through spillover effects to public markets (e.g., shorting banks or insurance companies that hold private credit), because private credit is not itself publicly traded and is difficult to bet against directly.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“But it sounds like it's a little bit hard to short or find an actionable way to Yeah, no, I I mean, you can't really bet against private credit except there's a spillover to public markets.”

0.69

Volatility in financial markets was artificially suppressed for many years following the 2008 GFC because interest rates were so low, and the policy response to any real market drawdown is swift and overwhelming, indicating that the economy is so leveraged that it cannot afford financial dislocations.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“coming out of the GFC, vol was artificially suppressed for many years. And >> rates were so low. >> Right, because interest rates were so low, and the it's clear and even that's the case still today that the policy response to any, you know, to any real [16:44] drawdown in the market is going to be swift and overwhelming. Like, we we are so leveraged as an economy that we just cannot afford to have financial, you know, financial dislocations.”

0.69

Muddy Waters Capital no longer focuses on overseas-listed Chinese companies because of regulatory enforcement difficulties; instead, the firm focused on China-based companies listed in the US, Canada, or Hong Kong due to the heads-I-win-tails-I-don't-lose incentive structure for fraudsters.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“Well, we don't spend a lot of time looking at [18:19] overseas-listed Chinese companies anymore. And just to to clarify what we did was we always focused China-based companies that were listed in the US or Canada or maybe even Hong Kong. And the reason was that especially with companies listed in the US or Canada it was for somebody sitting in China to defraud overseas investors, it was a heads I win, tails I don't lose proposition because the reality is, I mean, there've been hundreds of confirmed frauds from [18:51] China listed in the US. These companies went dark you know, took investor money. There's a complete inability of the US uh for the US to enforce against persons and entities in China. Because it's unpoliceable.”

0.69

Hundreds of confirmed frauds from China-listed US companies have gone dark taking investor money, and there is complete inability of the US to enforce against persons and entities in China, making it unpoliceable and consequence-free for Chinese fraudsters to defraud overseas investors.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“there've been hundreds of confirmed frauds from China listed in the US. These companies went dark you know, took investor money. There's a complete inability of the US uh for the US to enforce against persons and entities in China. Because it's unpoliceable.”

0.69

When private credit loans use payment-in-kind structures, the incentive structure mirrors the pre-2008 Global Financial Crisis environment where misaligned incentives between lenders and borrowers led to bad outcomes.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“the incentives are all screwed up. You know, just like we saw going into global financial crisis, when you have a misalignment of incentives you get bad outcomes.”

0.64

Retail Robinhood traders and coordinated meme stock squeezes (GameStop in January 2021, OpenDoor in 2024) have made short selling significantly more difficult and riskier by allowing retail investors to coordinate organized short squeezes.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Carson Block

“I think it's a complete distraction to what what is going on right now that's going to fundamentally change society and markets. Hi everyone. This is Miriam and I'm joined today by my colleague Peter Rudegair who is our hedge fund reporter here at the Wall Street Journal. >> And we have a special guest today. I'm very excited for this conversation. We are going to have a conversation with Carson Block. He is the founder of hedge [0:31] fund Muddy Waters Capital and research outfit Muddy Waters Research. Uh he is a short seller and short sellers of course are investors who bet against a company's stock and they look for companies that are overvalued facing disruption or involved in a potential fraud. Um welcome Carson. Thank you. Glad good to be here. So the big question that I have uh for you today is you know it seems like the past few years have been a tough market for short sellers. The market's been up into the interest rates have been low [1:02] and it's been very hard you know to kind of maintain probably a negative view on anything because the market just keeps going up and up. Some prominent short sellers like Jim Chanos and Nate Anderson have thrown in the towel. Um but that's picture seems to have been sort of muddied recently by you know the Fed's recent moves, geopolitical turmoil and AI's effect on stocks. Are we now entering a short sellers market? I think over the longer term here. Um I'm very concerned about um AI and what [1:35] AI does to jobs in the economy. So I think over the over several years and you know the the timeline is is a little bit squishy on this but I think over several years we're going to have a significant um a significant financial event uh dislocation where if you set up set yourself up right going into it I think it could be somewhat similar to the GFC in terms of how short sellers made um [2:07] significant returns during that period. So by GFC you mean the big financial crisis that happened in 2007-2008. >> Exactly. I mean it's you know little bit little consolation because um you know when we come out on the backside of that I think it'll be a it'll be a greatly reordered society after a lot of turbulence. So to me the one thing that really matters that is not getting enough discussion in terms of the the long-term picture is [2:38] AI. The short-term here you know I mean the Fed's probably going to ease but do we have inflation coming back? How long will the war in Iran last? To me those are unknowables. Um you know and when a lot of it depends on what you think this administration or this president is going to do I think trying to be a Trumpologist is is a sucker's bet. I mean I just explain to people look he's a volatility machine. You have to understand that. Like so that's the one that's the one [3:08] thing I feel good about with financial markets and this administration is expect the unexpected. Over the long-term I think AI is going to potentially really break the stock market because the combination of that and passive investing. How passive investing is set up all this fragility in the market. So I'm concerned about that. Fragility because people aren't paying attention to individual stocks anymore. Well the thing is you've had um so much so passive has kind of become [3:39] the market and when you look at how companies within the major indices so say the S&P 500 um when you look at what is driving those movements a lot of it is just passive flows and companies can turbocharge that with share buybacks. But when you see the dispersion you know such a small number of these companies are driving the mean of the index performance that's great on the way up but the thing is [4:09] if we get to a point where there are a lot of layoffs cuz a lot of these flows have come from target date funds contributions, 401k funds contributions. So if you get layoffs of knowledge workers well they stop contributing to 401ks there are not going to be you know new knowledge jobs created for them. They will take redemptions. You'll get to a point where there's net selling by the target date funds and combine that with people also selling from their taxable assets because they need to fund [4:42] they need to fund their lifestyles and there's not a lot of active money anymore there to catch the falling knife. When this breaks when you get those flows that to reverse we'll have a 1929 magnitude correction at 2020 speed. So that is you know that will be an issue. Um so you know look if you're short going into that obviously you could do okay. Don't get me wrong. I'm not rooting for that [5:13] because I don't want to live in this post AI world or AI world that I think we're going to but you know I'm not driving the bus on this. I'm just a passenger. So going to do my best to position the portfolio for you know my client and myself. Let me ask another thing that's made the market for shorting really tough last 5 years is the retail Robinhood trader right? Meme stocks from you know GameStop 5 years ago to OpenDoor last year you know they've squeezed a lot of [5:44] investors. How have you had to adjust your process you know just to account for that possibility? Well it's interesting because when GameStop happened um that was really the end of it. Um although it didn't seem like it at the time. You know one of uh my colleagues Andrew Left of Citron Research he he was the one publicly short GameStop and you know that huge squeeze that was organized on Reddit um caused him a lot of losses and then he said [6:15] okay I'm done with short selling and um turns out that you know that after that um these stocks were you know especially these really speculative companies they had a horrible year in 2021 after GameStop.”

0.63

Over several years, there will be a significant financial dislocation and event where AI's impact on the economy and jobs will create an opportunity for short sellers similar to returns made during the 2008 Global Financial Crisis.

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“I'm very concerned about um AI and what [1:35] AI does to jobs in the economy. So I think over the over several years and you know the the timeline is is a little bit squishy on this but I think over several years we're going to have a significant um a significant financial event uh dislocation where if you set up set yourself up right going into it I think it could be somewhat similar to the GFC in terms of how short sellers made um [2:07] significant returns during that period.”

0.62

AI will annihilate the legal profession as AI (especially Claude) gets better at legal document generation and litigation work, displacing lawyers at scale.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“big part of my business is litigation and, you know, I just can't wait to see it get rid of a lot of lawyers, I guess. It's going to annihilate that profession. And I'm a former lawyer, too, so.”

0.59

Current AI capability progression is no longer linear but exponential because the latest versions of Claude and ChatGPT are coded and tested by their predecessors, but now these versions code and test their successors, creating a self-reinforcing loop at an inflection point.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Carson Block

“Okay. First thing is keep in mind that AI right now, the progression in the capability of AI models is no longer linear. Okay, this version of Claude is a step up. Why? Because this version of Claude and ChatGPT were coded by their predecessors [11:02] and tested by their predecessors. These versions are coding and testing their successors, and that will continue to happen. So, we are at that inflection point where the capability goes exponential.”

0.55

Society has never before experienced large-scale job elimination at the top of the economic ladder (among high-paid knowledge workers with college degrees and loan obligations) rather than the bottom, and this unprecedented situation will have severe political and social ramifications.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“So, we haven't seen human society hasn't [12:03] seen that situation before where I mean, we've certainly eliminated jobs at the bottom of the economic ladder but eliminating them at the top in terms of your highest paid people, people who've taken out college loans had promises made to them. So, now this is where you start thinking about the political ramifications of this, and it's going to get you know, it's going to it's going to get bad. Like, it's going to get crazy.”

0.54

Over the long term, AI combined with passive investing structure creates market fragility that could break the stock market because passive investing concentrates flows into a small number of companies driving index performance, leaving no active capital to stabilize prices if those flows reverse.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“Over the long-term I think AI is going to potentially really break the stock market because the combination of that and passive investing. How passive investing is set up all this fragility in the market. So I'm concerned about that. Fragility because people aren't paying attention to individual stocks anymore.”

0.52

The question of whether markets are in an AI bubble is the wrong question; instead, one should focus on what AI will do to society, the economy, and markets—the real issue is the economic impact of AI on jobs and the economy, not whether valuations of AI companies are excessive.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“Well yeah. I mean uh I could pound the table and say that's the wrong question. You [laughter] know we got to talk about what is AI going to do to society, the economy, the markets etc.”

0.52

Two generations of investors have entered markets since the 2008 Global Financial Crisis, and they do not appreciate risk the way that investors who lived through the GFC, the internet bubble burst (early 2000s), or the Long-Term Capital Management crisis did, leading to underappreciation of risk in general and complacency.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“And look, one of the [14:07] things that's been a theme for me uh is that there've been probably two generations by my, you know, my way of counting, two generations of investors have entered the markets since the GFC. And so, I don't think they appreciate risk the way that you know, people who went through the GFC did or the internet bubble bursting a few years before that or Long-Term Capital before that or, you know, so, I think that there is an under-appreciation for risk in general that has led to this complacency.”

0.52

Block believes only 20-25% of things that Muddy Waters discusses publicly are actual frauds; the bigger problem is the 'gray zone' of intellectually fraudulent activity that is technically legal due to enough lawyers or AI systems creating plausible deniability through document generation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“For us as activist short sellers, like my firm, maybe only 20, 25% of the things that we discuss publicly do we think are actually frauds. I think the far bigger problem that the world has, uh, markets and, you know, just institutions and their credibility in general is the gray [21:57] zone. Doing things that are intellectually fraudulent, but yeah, you know, you have enough lawyers, you know, or soon it'll be enough Claude to, you know, create the documents and plausible deniability to get away with it. So, it's not necessarily illegal.”

0.52

Block believes there is an inverse correlation between interest rates and the level of dishonesty in society: lower interest rates enable more dishonesty because cheap money allows companies to borrow cheaply, use that capital to acquire other companies, and obfuscate organic growth, making it easy to paper over sins and create plausible narratives.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“So, I I believe that there's an inverse correlation in society between interest rates and the level of dishonesty. So, the lower interest rates go, the more dishonesty you get. When money is cheaper, companies can BS investors and then just buy other borrow cheaply, buy [22:30] stuff, and it becomes really difficult to sort out, like, well, what's, you know, what's organic growth and what's, you know, acquired. It papers cheap money can be used to paper over a lot of a lot of sins.”

0.52

Block believes within 3-5 years it is likely that 15% of knowledge workers will lose their jobs due to AI displacement, and this is realistic because teams of eight can already be reduced to one person plus AI at leading tech companies using the best AI tools.

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Carson Block

“But you're mostly thinking of that as tied to [10:29] AI-related job losses. I'm not saying this is likely but within 3 years. And if it's not 3 years, it's 4 years, it's 5 years. I would say that's likely. 15% of knowledge workers lose their jobs. Why? Okay. First thing is keep in mind that AI right now, the progression in the capability of AI models is no longer linear. Okay, this version of Claude is a step up. Why? Because this version of Claude and ChatGPT were coded by their predecessors [11:02] and tested by their predecessors. These versions are coding and testing their successors, and that will continue to happen. So, we are at that inflection point where the capability goes exponential. Even at the present capability of AI the leading users of AI in the economy are at the tech companies. And so, what you've seen is that a number of in with the best users of AI, they've been able to replace seven of their colleagues. [11:32] So, you've had teams of eight go to one plus AI.”

0.48

Muddy Waters Capital has adjusted its short-selling process to actively avoid situations where a compressed or compressing short squeeze spring is forming, including monitoring Twitter/social media for signs of coordinated retail action, in order to manage tail risk.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“So as short sellers we you know my firm we definitely try to avoid situations where it looks like there's a compressed or compressing spring. Now maybe we don't [7:18] always get it right but um that's you know I I mean risk management is first and foremost how this business of short selling works if you're going to stay in in the game.”

0.48

Unlike the internet stock bubble of late 1990s-early 2001, companies investing in AI (Microsoft, Google, Facebook) are very large, well-capitalized firms with manageable debt loads relative to cash flows, so even if AI investments are value-destructive, these companies will not go out of business from overinvestment.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“I don't buy the comparisons to the internet stock bubble of the late 90s that popped in March of 01 um in the sense that the companies that are investing in AI [8:22] are these incredibly large very well capitalized companies and for the most part um they have even with all the debt they're taking on these are very manageable debt loads relative to their cash flows. So are they potentially over investing? Will we look back and say well these were value destructive investments? Yeah it's possible but I mean these company Microsoft is not going out of business because of this. Google is not going out of business. Facebook is not going out of business.”

0.48

Positive volatility in markets from external shocks (geopolitical, commodity) is unhealthy if it is driven by political tweets or impulsive decisions rather than by fundamental information about business conditions.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“volatility in financial markets is healthy, but you know, maybe this is kind of an unhealthy form of vol because it's, you know, vol by tweet or, you know, I woke up this morning and decided this was a good idea.”

0.47

Block has lived in China for 6 years, is conversant in the language, had his own business in China, and co-authored 'Doing Business in China for Dummies,' providing him with deep context for understanding audit practices and enforcement challenges in China.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Carson Block

“It's unpoliceable. >> I lived in China for a total of 6 years. I've, you know, I used to be pretty good with the language. I've, you know, I had my had my own business in China. Um even co-authored uh Doing Business in China for Dummies back in the day.”

0.45

The short-term unknowns like whether inflation will return, how long the Iran war will last, and what this administration will do are less important than the long-term AI threat, making trying to be a 'Trumpologist' a sucker's bet; instead, one should expect the unexpected and understand the president as a volatility machine.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Carson Block

“The short-term here you know I mean the Fed's probably going to ease but do we have inflation coming back? How long will the war in Iran last? To me those are unknowables. Um you know and when a lot of it depends on what you think this administration or this president is going to do I think trying to be a Trumpologist is is a sucker's bet. I mean I just explain to people look he's a volatility machine. You have to understand that. Like so that's the one that's the one [3:08] thing I feel good about with financial markets and this administration is expect the unexpected.”

0.45

Insurance companies have stuffed their balance sheets with private credit holdings, and many insurance companies are at risk because it is unclear whether the private credit they hold is actually investment-grade, creating misaligned incentives where managers inflate NAVs to collect higher management fees.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Carson Block

“I've [14:40] done some work on insurance companies um recently, nothing that we felt was actionable, but you know, we have felt that insurance companies are you know, a number of insurance companies are at risk, and one of the things that they've stuffed their balance sheets with is private credit. And you know, is it really investment grade? I mean, you know, like quite possibly not.”

0.45

Default rates in private credit may spike to 6%, which is the level of high-yield default rates, but given the current opacity and PIK loan prevalence, default rates have not yet spiked, suggesting distress has been masked by loan restructuring practices.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Carson Block

“And I guess one of the other things that, you know, the the the bull side or the, you know, don't worry about it too much side would say is, "Well, look, default rates, [15:11] maybe they'll spike to 6%. You know, that's what high yield default rates are." And, you know, when the the credit cycle turns. But you know, default rates aren't there yet,”

0.45

Suppressed volatility leads to underpricing of risk and misallocation of capital, resulting in valueless assets (like Bitcoin) hitting high prices ($100,000), which is a sign of capital misallocation driven by volatility suppression.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Carson Block

“So, vol was artificially suppressed, and that leads to uh that leads to an under-pricing of risk, and that leads to misallocation of of assets. And so, when you see these you know, like valueless assets like, you know, Bitcoin take off and hit $100,000 of, you know, fake coin [17:17] or whatever it is. Like, that's just a sign that we have a misallocation of you know, of capital, and it's it's been driven, you know, I mean, good part of it's been driven by the suppression of volatility.”

0.45

An SEC proposal to eliminate quarterly reporting requirements in favor of semi-annual or annual reporting would not substantially harm short sellers; the effect evens out because while data comes less frequently, the longer reporting voids create periods where companies are not speaking, which can be exploited.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Carson Block

“I think net-net it evens out. We've publicly, you know, run campaigns against companies that are semi-annual reporters from other markets in the [20:24] world. Um, yeah, the crunchy data comes through less frequently, but on the other hand, there are these longer voids during which the company is not speaking. So, um, you know, so net-net, it I think that it evens out for us as activist short sellers.”

0.45

Between November and the interview, Block's views on market optimism have not changed; things might go up based on passive flows, but he doesn't have a clear view on AI disruption's initial effect on metals prices; over the long term, he expects QE forever and yield curve control forever, so financial assets will be inflated and metals like gold will be a good long-term position.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Carson Block

“Well, I mean, that was at a time when, you know, before I I had my concerns [24:04] about AI disruption. You know, in the, you know, between now and then, I I mean, I don't I you know, things will go up. I mean, based on flows. Um, you know, I can't I I don't have a view as to what AI disruption does, you know, initially to metals prices over the long term. I mean, look, I think the very long term is QE forever, yield curve control forever. Financial assets get inflated. Um, so, you know, metals like gold are probably, you know, great place to be over the [24:35] long term. And so, right now it's kind of funny because things have sold off. Our AI disruption basket is generally making money, but for the wrong reasons.”

0.41

Block's AI disruption investment basket is currently profitable but 'for the wrong reasons'—recent selloffs rather than the fundamental thesis of AI-driven job displacement playing out—suggesting the positions may be crowded or premature relative to the actual timing of disruption.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Carson Block

“And so, right now it's kind of funny because things have sold off. Our AI disruption basket is generally making money, but for the wrong reasons.”

0.41

Claude AI is now being used to structure sophisticated trades and investment strategies that would not have been possible pre-AI, indicating that AI systems are already capable of complex financial engineering.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Carson Block

“So, we basically went to Claude and we're like, how do we structure this? >> [laughter] >> So, Claude's helping you with with your investments now? It's incredible. So, yes, we've been able to structure some, I think, very sophisticated trades. And, you know, this is not stuff we'd be able to do, um, pre-AI.”

0.40

Most investors support reduced reporting frequency because they have not experienced material risk since COVID, when government intervention prevented losses and inflated financial assets.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Carson Block

“by number, uh, vast majority of American investors would support this because, you know, go back to these comments I made about two generations of investors entering the market since global financial crisis, the only time risk materialized was that brief moment during COVID before the government just came in and and saved everybody and everything and just sent financial assets like to the moon.”

0.34

Risk management is the most fundamental aspect of short selling; it is the primary discipline required to stay in the business long-term.

normativeestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Carson Block

“risk management is first and foremost how this business of short selling works if you're going to stay in in the game.”

0.29

Block acknowledges he is not 'rooting for' an AI-driven market collapse and financial crisis, clarifying that while he would profit from being short in such a scenario, he does not desire the post-AI world that would result because the societal consequences will be severe.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Carson Block

“So that is you know that will be an issue. Um so you know look if you're short going into that obviously you could do okay. Don't get me wrong. I'm not rooting for that [5:13] because I don't want to live in this post AI world or AI world that I think we're going to but you know I'm not driving the bus on this. I'm just a passenger.”

0.29

Block finds that pitching long positions is less stressful than pitching shorts because when you are long, 'the whole world is long back at you' and people smile, whereas when short, he is tense and worried about lawsuits, so the psychological appeal of going long is partially driven by the desire to be less tense.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Carson Block

“I'm fond of saying from the few times I've done public longs in my life that when you're long, the whole world is long back at [23:32] you. You know, it's it's like the smiles on people's faces as they came up to me, you know, as opposed I get off stage and I'm tense and >> [laughter] >> now I'm thinking like, man, like, you know, how long till the lawsuit hits, you know. Now I'm relaxed and I can enjoy talking.”

0.29

The GameStop squeeze in January 2021 was the end of aggressive retail-driven short squeezes, as subsequent speculative stocks had a poor year in 2021 and the phenomenon did not repeat at the same magnitude.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Carson Block

“Well it's interesting because when GameStop happened um that was really the end of it. Um although it didn't seem like it at the time. You know one of uh my colleagues Andrew Left of Citron Research he he was the one publicly short GameStop and you know that huge squeeze that was organized on Reddit um caused him a lot of losses and then he said okay I'm done with short selling and um turns out that you know that after that um these stocks were you know especially these really speculative companies they had a horrible year in 2021 after GameStop.”

0.29

Prominent short sellers like Jim Chanos and Nate Anderson have exited the short-selling business in recent years.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Miriam

“Some prominent short sellers like Jim Chanos and Nate Anderson have thrown in the towel.”

0.27

The past few years have been a tough market for short sellers because the market has been up and interest rates have been low, making it difficult to maintain a negative view on anything because the market just keeps going up.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Miriam

“the past few years have been a tough market for short sellers. The market's been up into the interest rates have been low [1:02] and it's been very hard you know to kind of maintain probably a negative view on anything because the market just keeps going up and up.”

0.19

The Fed is likely to ease monetary policy in the near term, but the direction of inflation and duration of geopolitical conflict are uncertain and unknowable.

forecastestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Carson Block

“I mean the Fed's probably going to ease but do we have inflation coming back? How long will the war in Iran last? To me those are unknowables.”

0.17

In November, Block pitched a long position in Snowline Gold (a junior gold miner) at an investment conference; Muddy Waters launched a junior mining fund in 2024 with a new team member who previously shorted a company with Block in 2017, and Snowline has been one of the fund's core holdings.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Carson Block

“Yeah, junior gold miner. Um, so, we we actually we have a resource, we have a junior mining funds that we [23:01] launched in 2024. Uh, we brought in somebody who's very talented, somebody we've known for some years, um, with with whom we, you know, we shorted a company publicly in 2017. So, um, yeah, he joined and Snowline's been one of our core holdings.”

0.17

Even though reduced reporting frequency would not harm short sellers, the SEC proposal is objectively bad for markets overall, appearing to be a solution in search of a problem.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Carson Block

“Is it good for markets? I mean, I think objectively you could say no, but, you know, I mean, it seems to me like it's a solution in search of a problem.”

0.17

The Muddy Waters hedge fund strategy will operate regardless of market conditions (risk-on or risk-off), but the strategies are positioned to benefit from market fragility and dislocations rather than from calm markets.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Carson Block

“the strategies that we run, we're going to run no matter what.”

0.17

CoreWeave is the most marginal player in the AI infrastructure space and is not a consequential company, so hyperscaler AI investment losses will not be driven by mid-tier vendor bankruptcies.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Carson Block

“the most marginal player in that space by a long shot is CoreWeave but um you know that that's not a consequential company.”