
Why Conspiracy Theorists are Taking Over the World - Naomi Klein | Intelligence Squared
What this covers
This is a conversation between Naomi Klein and journalist Ruchira Sharma, built around Klein's book on her doppelgänger: the writer Naomi Wolf, with whom Klein is often confused. Klein uses the double as a way into what she calls Mirror World, where anti-vaxxers, wellness influencers and far-right propagandists overlap. She also uses it to ask how societies flip into uglier versions of themselves. Wolf appears as a case study: Klein says she has been deplatformed from liberal media but now reaches large audiences on Tucker Carlson's show and Steve Bannon's podcast. She also cites an NPR analysis that traced the "vaccine shedding" fertility myth partly to Wolf's tweets.
The middle of the talk is about why conspiracy theories work. Klein's claim is that they get the feelings right and the facts wrong. QAnon's adrenochrome story, for example, is read as a distorted version of a real worry about systems that drain children's futures. She contrasts cabal-thinking with the left's systemic analysis, recalling the old line about anti-Semitism as "the socialism of fools," and argues that conspiracy as distraction from systemic analysis serves elites. The more contested turn is her account of how the right fills gaps the left has left open. She points to Big Pharma and Big Tech, where the revolving door) keeps Democrats from criticizing the industries, and to Bannon's courting of white working-class men angry about offshored factories. She also argues that abusive habits on the left help right-wing recruiters.
The talk then widens. Klein draws on surveillance capitalism as an enclosure of the commons, with consent to terms of service extracted under duress. She says liberals accept phone tracking yet mock concerns about vaccine apps. She describes deliberate mirror infrastructure, such as alternative platforms and publishers. She also treats AI as a "mimicry machine" that produces digital doubles of people.
Klein argues that political mirroring and conspiracy theories proliferate because progressive movements have abandoned key issues and constituencies, allowing the right to exploit legitimate grievances through distorted narratives that 'get the feelings right' while 'getting the facts wrong.'
- Conspiracy theories thrive in the vacuum left by progressive abandonment of systemic critique and class analysis
- The right strategically targets constituencies and issues progressives have neglected, repackaging them with scapegoating solutions
- Liberal dismissal of these movements through humor and deplatforming actually widens the parallel 'mirror world' platform ecosystem
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Conspiracy theories succeed not because their factual content is accurate, but because they 'get the feelings right' while 'getting the facts wrong'—they accurately capture genuine grievances about inequality, impunity for elites, and injustice, but channel them into false narratives about cabals rather than systemic analysis.
“conspiracy theories these conspiracy theories because there are some real conspiracies in the world that's also important to remember um they get the facts wrong but they get the feelings right”
Conspiracy theories function as elite distraction mechanisms by directing attention away from systemic crises toward cabals and conspirators, making conspiracy theorists 'the best friends the elites could ever have' because they prevent systemic critique rather than enabling it.
“conspiracy theories I'd be interested in your take on it but I think you know a lot of what consp iracy theories do is distract our attention from systemic crises right and for that reason even though conspiracy theorists are always talking about the elites the elites they're they're the best friends the elites could ever have because they prevent us from speaking about they distract us from speaking about systems and they steer us towards the cabal right and that's always been the role that conspiracy has played for power”
Steve Bannon strategically identified abandoned constituencies and issues to build Trump's 2016 coalition—specifically white working-class men whose factories had been offshored and who were enraged about trade agreements, constituencies the Democratic party had neglected, and he filled that gap with Trumpism despite having no policy offers for their actual grievances.
“what Bannon did in6 16 when he was working for Donald Trump I mean arguably he still is but in 2016 you know he he was just looking at who had the Democratic party abandoned you know and he saw all these you know white workingclass men whose factories had been offshored and who were enraged about the trade agreements that they felt had screwed them and he was like this is a constituency that that that they've abandoned and we're going to we're going to speak to it”
Societies have a 'kind of evil twin version of themselves' and there is a real historical pattern of societies flipping and becoming 'much uglier more dangerous versions of themselves'—this is the deeper doppelgänger Klein fears beyond personal confusion with Naomi Wolf.
“ultimately I think what the book is about is the doppelganger that I most fear and that I think a lot of us fear which is which is the way whole societies have a kind of an evil twin version of themselves and the sort of the way we know societies can flip and become um much uglier more dangerous versions of themselves not to idealize our world right now but it can get worse um so yeah so it's about fascism is the short answer”
Conspiracy theories serve a function for people by providing simple narratives with evil villains and heroes to explain complex world events, and this function is particularly appealing in moments of systemic crisis (climate change, pandemic, AI destabilization) when people need a story to make sense of their world.
“conspiracies always surge in moments like this right where we need we need a story to explain our world and conspiracies are are are easy to understand theories yeah with evil evil characters right yeah villains and heroes and then a fight and a cause”
Leftists have a systematic theory that explains symptoms of inequality and suffering as logical outcomes of capitalist systems designed to maximize profit, not as conspiracies orchestrated by hidden elites, which is why anti-Semitic conspiracy theories have historically been called 'the socialism of fools'—because they substitute systemic analysis with cabal-thinking.
“leftists um you know have a theory of capital have a have a theory of um that that that that that much of these symptoms are not because of a plot behind the scenes but it's actually just a logical outcome of a system that is built to maximize profits and this is why you know anti-Semitism and anti-semitic conspiracy theories are often or you have long been referred to as the socialism of fools right because rather than seeing a system you imagine a cabal”
Surveillance capitalism, as described by Shoshana Zuboff, is an historic enclosure of previously unenclosed commons including human relationships—conversations between friends that previously couldn't be data-extracted are now commodified on platforms, and users have not provided genuine informed consent despite signing terms of service.
“this is is you know the the thesis of shashan zub's book um the the age of surveillance capitalism um that this is really an a historic enclosure of of you know what I mean the commons but also of just ourselves of of un previously unenclosed space like the relationship between friends right was not previously something that could be you know commoditized right”
Leaving constituencies unaddressed and abandoning people creates a predictable political dynamic: 'someone's going to come along and fill that space'—this is a warning about the necessity of the left engaging with real grievances to prevent authoritarian movements from monopolizing them.
“leaving leaving constituency abandoning people is is a problem because someone's going to come along and uh and fill fill that space”
Progressive intolerance and abusive culture on the left—how progressives treat people poorly—creates fertile recruitment ground for right-wing figures who position themselves as offering acceptance and belonging in contrast.
“I learned a lot and not just in the sense of oh they're such terrible people um I already thought that um I think what I learned more was about what liberals and leftists have abandoned that has created such fertile territory for the right to exploit including how we treat people poorly how we how we just the sort of um intolerance and and some of the abusive cultures on the left um that's also fertile territory to sort of position oneself as welcoming accepting”
The book explores doubling and doppelgangers as a device to understand political dynamics where societies mirror the people they disagree with—whatever one side is against, the other is for, and vice versa, creating a kind of political mirroring that is becoming increasingly clear in US politics.
“uses that as a device to understand some political Dynamics where um our world world is sort of doubling and we are mirroring um the people that we disagree with whatever they're against we're for whatever whatever they're for we're against it's really kind of becoming clear and clearer in US politics”
It is important to monitor and understand what right-wing figures like Steve Bannon and Tucker Carlson are doing and saying, despite the discomfort this causes, because they are 'crafting a political agenda out of our failures neglect and hypocrisies' and have demonstrated ability to shape political outcomes (Trump's election).
“I'm interested in the way they um just they play on the intolerance that is real on the left you know and say like oh no I'm willing to talk to somebody who I disagree with unlike those people you know um and they kind of Cosplay um uh acceptance and inclusion and belonging I use those words a lot it's really interesting”
It is less accurate to think about capitalism 'working' through three hidden people in a room (Rothschilds, etc.) than to recognize that capitalism operates through systemic incentives to maximize profit—the system does what it was designed to do without requiring a conscious conspiracy.
“it's better to think of three or four people in a room um maybe the Ross child or you know whatever the the the latest iteration of it is than it is to talk about capitalism and and and and the system doing what it was designed to do right”
The Democratic Party and UK mainstream politics maintain revolving doors between political leadership and pharmaceutical/tech corporate positions, indicating structural financial dependence on these industries.
“the mainstream Democratic party is fully in bed with you know the pharmaceutical companies and um and the big tech companies and there's an absolute revolving door um if you look at who their leadership is same same as the UK I was going to say we're not we're not that different”
Naomi Wolf became a major vector of COVID-era medical misinformation, particularly around the 'vaccine shedding' myth—NPR's data analysis traced significant portions of the narrative that women would become infertile from proximity to vaccinated people to Wolf's tweets.
“NPR did did did an investigation of like why it was that so many women were suddenly afraid that they were going to become infertile not if they got the co vaccine but even if they were around somebody who got the coid vaccine because it would shed on them and so they did this data analysis and found that that that a lot of that misinformation could be traced to a few key tweets by um other Naomi”
Liberals normalize serious privacy violations through smartphones—accepting ubiquitous phone monitoring as inevitable—then dismiss right-wing concerns about vaccine app monitoring as absurd, missing that this normalization of surveillance creates the emotional terrain on which conspiracy theories about monitoring and control take root.
“it's not funny that we think that our that that that we all just sort of take it for granted that our phones could be EAS dropping on us or that we're being tracked but we have normalized that right and so what happens when you normalize something that really shouldn't be normalized well it comes it it reemerges in in what I'm calling the mirror World in this strange way in this doppelganger way”
Progressive movements have failed to propose 'real solutions' to issues like Big Pharma, Big Tech, and corporate power that people are genuinely 'upset about'—instead, when these issues are taken up by the right, they're presented as 'fake populist solutions' that 'mostly you know involve just scapegoating.'
“these are potent issues people are upset about them and if if if we aren't speaking to them and if we aren't proposing real solutions then they will reappear in the mural world and there will be these sort of fake populace Solutions yeah that are not real solutions and that mostly you know involve just scapegoating”
The right wing positions itself as willing to critique 'Big Pharma' and 'Big Tech' precisely because mainstream progressives and the Democratic party largely refuse to, instead maintaining revolving-door relationships with pharmaceutical and tech industry leaders—this allows the right to occupy the anti-corporate space by default.
“they go on and on and on about about big big Pharma yeah um or big or big Tech um you know how M and and position themselves as being the ones who are taking on big Pharma who are willing to take on big Tech um that's only possible because you know at least in the US it's like basically just Bernie Sanders who's banging on um you know and a few few other members of the squad but the mainstream Democratic party is fully in bed with you know the pharmaceutical companies and um and the big tech companies and there's an absolute revolving door”
Naomi Klein has a doppelgänger in Naomi Wolf who is frequently confused with her by much of the world, but Wolf has been deplatformed from mainstream liberal media spaces and now appears on major right-wing platforms like Tucker Carlson (3 million viewers nightly) and Steve Bannon's podcast, making her far more visible in the 'mirror world' than mainstream liberal audiences realize.
“somebody who much of the world thinks is you um but is not you”
AI is functioning as a 'mimicry machine' that copies and recreates human culture, creating literal digital doubles of people, which is a form of mirror-world creation and represents a new kind of unsettling displacement where people feel replaced by AI versions of themselves.
“it looks at the way AI is creating doubles of our basically our whole culture it's sort of a mimicry machine um but by mirror World um I'm I guess I'm talking about conspiracy World um and my own doppelganger”
When people are deplatformed from liberal social media and platforms, there is a widespread perception among liberals that they have disappeared from the world because social media has trained us to mute and block people, leading us to treat them as 'dead'—but in reality, deplatformed figures often have much larger platforms than before.
“when people get deplatformed from from spaces that are you know more liberal um you know media spes spaces or platforms there's often the perception that they've kind of disappeared from planet Earth yeah um because because we don't see them anymore and I think social media trains us to mute and block and we're just like you're dead to me you know and so when when she was deplatformed pretty much everyone I knew thought she no longer needed to be paid attention to but because I was sort of on this Rabbit Hole journey I was I it really struck me that she had not been deplatformed in fact she had a much bigger platform than she um than she'd had in years”
The technology industry operates through extracting people's consent without genuine understanding—terms of service agreements are pages long and unread, but users must 'accept' them to proceed, so consent is extracted under duress because people need to access digital services.
“the whole Tech economy is like those terms of service agreements right that on for pages and pages and pages and then no one reads them and and it's an extract you know our consent is being extracted because we need to like get to the next to the other end of it like we have to get online we have to fill out a form I mean everything happens online now so we need to we need to get to the other side so we consent except it isn't real consent and we did not read it and we don't know what's in it”
QAnon and similar conspiracy theories about elites draining children of life force through adrenochrome are distorted versions of real concerns about economic systems that drain children's futures through environmental destruction, inequality, and depleted opportunities.
“you could make the argument that you know uh we live in a system that is draining um our children's futures um and so you know the way I put it in the book is conspiracy theories these conspiracy theories because there are some real conspiracies in the world that's also important to remember um they get the facts wrong but they get the feelings right”
Ideas and language important to the left (feminism, anti-fascism, free speech) have been appropriated and distorted in the mirror world to serve right-wing ends—the form is preserved while the content is twisted.
“there's also a way in which many of the ideas that are important to me as somebody who's been you know part of the left for many years um are being picked up in the mirror world and sort of turned into Twisted doppelganger versions of themselves including the the fight against fascism like all the language gets appropriated and kind of Twisted to use for ends that are really not the ends they're intended including free freedom of speech right because these are many of the people who are supporting book bands and um you know are very comfortable censoring um but they use the discourse of freedom of expression um you know for their own end”
There are deliberate, intentional efforts to create a mirror world with alternative infrastructure—mirror publishing houses, mirror currencies, mirror social media platforms (like Gettr as a mirror to Twitter, Umble or Parler as mirrors to YouTube)—and Steve Bannon explicitly discusses the need to build this separate infrastructure so 'they can't ever let them erase us again'.
“there's like mirror versions of everything in our world in the mirror world like if you get CAU get kicked off Twitter then you go to getter or you know if you get kicked off YouTube then you go to um Umble or parlor or you know you know and there's mirror publishing houses now and and um it's very deliberate you know Steve Bannon talks about how we need our own currency we need you know that we can't ever let them erase us again”
Philip Roth's novel Operation features a doppelgänger character whose damage is 'too ridiculous to take seriously and too serious to be ridiculous'—Klein returns to this phrase to describe the stakes of being confused with a doppelgänger who is spreading medical misinformation during a pandemic.
“I think that at that point I thought well this is you know there's a line that I returned to several times in the book from Philip Roth's operation where he says about his his his doppelganger who is Wrecking wreaking havoc um it's too ridiculous to take seriously and too serious to be ridiculous”
In December 2021, Steve Bannon invited RFK Jr. on his show and performed a ritual of welcome, telling him 'you have just been excommunicated from Liberal Society' but 'you will always get a fair hearing here', providing what appeared to be acceptance after rejection by liberal institutions.
“December 2021 Bannon had RFK on his show and gave him the entire show and just performed this you have just been excommunicated from Liberal Society the New York Times just took you down but you will always get a fair hearing here we're not like that”
The Naomi Klein who wrote No Logo in her youth was part of the broader third-wave feminist movement of the 1990s, which emerged during the Reagan-Thatcher era as a moment of renewal for feminist thought and activism after a lull in the 1980s.
“when I was in university she was um she was part of what was being called the third wave of feminism so you know I I was a teenager in the 80s it was a very kind of um lull period for Progressive politics feminism was sort of um it was still happening there was still kinds of great work being done but it was really outside the outside the glare of the media Spotlight I mean these were this was you know the years of Reagan and thater and then at the dawn of the 90s Along Comes Naomi wolf and a few others”
Naomi Wolf's book The Beauty Myth argued that second-wave feminism's gains (more women in universities and workplaces) were being countered by heightened beauty standards that forced women to spend enormous time and energy on appearance as 'professional beauties,' and the book documented a rise in anorexia and fitness obsession at that time.
“she had written this book called The Beauty myth um and it was um you know not that Innovative in terms of its analysis of uh you know the amount of time time in particular that that women were expending to meet a particular Beauty ideal she was making an argument that women's um the the successes of the second wave of feminism um that had uh made it so that more and more women were going into universities more and more women were going into the workplace were being pushed back by this heightened Beauty standard”
Everyone engages in 'various tactics of unseeing of distraction,' and conspiracy theories represent one prominent form of collectively abandoning systemic analysis in favor of scapegoating narratives.
“and I think we're all you know conspiracy theories I'd be interested in your take on it but I think you know a lot of what consp iracy theories do is distract our attention from systemic crises right and for that reason even though conspiracy theorists are always talking about the elites the elites they're they're the best friends the elites could ever have because they prevent us from speaking about they distract us from speaking about systems”
Being alive today is 'very destabilizing' due to multiple simultaneous crises: climate change, pandemic, AI/technology-induced replacement and alienation, and the collapse of narrative coherence.
“it's a pretty this it's another way in which being alive today is very destabilizing yeah um so is climate change um you know so is co and conspiracies always surge in moments like this”
RFK Jr. is serving as a 'chaos agent' and demoralizing the Democratic base through his 2024 presidential campaign, which he 'certainly' won't win mathematically, but his purpose appears to be weakening Democratic political will.
“RFK Jr you know is is is running to to uh be the Democratic nominees not going to win I don't see how that math could happen but he's certainly a Chaos Agent um and and he's certainly playing a role to demoralize the Democratic base um and they were already pretty demoralized”
Klein's previous book No Logo established her as a face of a 'new left' cultural critique in the 1990s, which created pressure to write with complete intellectual and moral certainty ('bulletproof') because she felt responsible for representing leftist politics.
“I had this like really great Fortune um as a young writer to have my first book kind of blow up and to have myself kind of turned into the face of this kind of new left at that time I think the every my writing afterwards was sort of carrying the weight of the left on my shoulders it got very very serious”
Writing the book involved vulnerability and examining her own mental health and impact on loved ones while investigating her doppelgänger, but this experience was liberating—it freed her from the weight of carrying leftist orthodoxy and allowed her to write with humor and playfulness after decades of writing with defensive seriousness.
“what was it like writing this um compared to your other works and you know expressing how much this took a toll on you getting confused for other Nomi but also going down the rabbit hole and throwing yourself into this investigation um because you mentioned you know the impact on loved ones and for your own mental health as well”
Wolf's analysis of beauty standards in The Beauty Myth, while capturing something real about women's experience of beauty pressure, was debatable and 'culturally contingent'—it wasn't a rigorous empirical analysis but rather an interpretation of contemporary cultural phenomena.
“and obviously that's debatable and and culturally contingent and so on um but there was there was no doubt that there was you know a rise in anorexia at that time”
The book 'Doppelganger' is a mix of memoir and cultural analysis, departing from Klein's previous works which were more conventionally structured as thesis-and-supporting-arguments.
“so it's a very different kind of book for me um I usually write pretty conventional non-fiction you know thesis argument argument thesis argument um this is more of a mix of of memoir and cultural analysis”