Opinion Roundtable: Behind America’s Public School Battles
What this covers
Three public-school parents—Siva Raj, Letha Muhammad, and Tom Chavez—convene to examine the roots of present school conflicts and the character of parent activism reshaping American education. The conversation centers on a specific breach: the breakdown of institutional trust crystallized by Covid closures and remote learning, which exposed what these speakers argue was deprioritization of academic outcomes. Rather than a temporary reaction, they frame sustained parent engagement as a durable shift in how citizens now monitor institutions once trust fractures. The discussion moves across competing diagnoses of school failure—learning loss and its compounding effects, disparities in student discipline and college readiness, and questions about curriculum content—while acknowledging that parents across the political spectrum share more common ground than polarized headlines suggest.
The roundtable navigates tensions that resist easy resolution. Chavez argues for historically balanced curriculum and contends that heightened parent involvement, exemplified by the parents' rights movement in Virginia and the election of Glenn Youngkin, reflects beneficial democratic awakening. Muhammad pushes back on framing the breach of trust as new, noting Black communities have required intensive engagement for years to ensure fair treatment, and emphasizes curriculum representation as foundational to student thriving. Raj identifies structural problems—activist groups speaking for parents rather than parents themselves, board processes that exclude working families, and the absence of clear accountability for student outcomes—while cautioning against overpoliticization that serves political advancement over educational results. Disagreement runs across how to teach American history, what constitutes genuine diversity, and whether the education-industrial complex serves children or entrenched interests.
Three politically diverse public-school parents argue that the core purpose of school (academic preparation, discovery, and opportunity) has been undermined by a breakdown of trust between families and school institutions, and that durable parent activism is the response to schools deprioritizing student outcomes during and after Covid.
- Covid school closures and chaotic remote learning exposed that districts deprioritized education itself
- A breach of trust between parents and institutions is driving sustained parent engagement
- Parents across the political spectrum share more common ground on schooling than the polarized debate suggests
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Much of the current conflict stems from a breakdown of trust between the parent community and the institutions running public schools; this breach — crystallized during school closures — is what causes widespread parental anxiety and drives parents to scrutinize everything the institution does rather than delegating and trusting.
“a lot of the issue here, I think, is a lack of trust. There is a breakdown in trust between the parent community and the institutions that are running our public schools.”
Parent engagement is not a temporary blip but a lasting change reflecting an evolving practice of democracy: people no longer simply elect representatives and trust them to do the job; once that trust breaks — as it did during school closures — citizens become intensely engaged in monitoring everything institutions do.
“the way in which we practice democracy is changing, where we are not just electing someone and trusting that person will do the job. That trust is broken.”
Across the country, Black students are overwhelmingly the ones suspended, expelled, or referred to law enforcement, despite not behaving any worse than other students — they simply receive punishment in a different way, reflecting disparate treatment rather than disparate behavior.
“the disparity when it comes to who is suspended or expelled or referred to law enforcement from our schools, it’s overwhelmingly, across the country, Black students”
In San Francisco, the people speaking for parents are often not actually parents but political activist groups that claim to represent parents while really representing their own interests; this is enabled because school board seats function as a low-cost stepping stone to higher office, incentivizing performative politics over student outcomes.
“the people speaking for parents are not really parents. A lot of political activist groups that say they are speaking for us. But they don’t faithfully represent our views. They represent their interests.”
Reopening schools should have been treated as a five-alarm emergency because learning loss compounds over time, making it progressively harder for children to catch up the longer they are out of in-person instruction.
“We need to get children back into school and learning because learning loss compounds and it makes it difficult for children to catch up.”
Schools and families should operate as partners, building trust and creating space to interrogate difficult ideas together; in the author's experience, the schools where teachers and administrators were open to critical conversation about the good, the bad, and the not-so-good were precisely where her children thrived most, so a partnership model should be lifted up nationally to transform schools.
“schools and families should have a space for a partnership. For building trust. For even interrogating difficult ideas and thoughts.”
Teaching only the basics is insufficient if a child cannot see themselves anywhere in the curriculum; when all the images and stories are grounded in another culture or ethnic group, a student has no point of connection and struggles to thrive, so representation in the curriculum is a precondition for engagement and success.
“if I’m a child in a classroom who is being taught the basics... and I don’t see myself anywhere in that curriculum, how do I get to connect to that?”
Overpoliticization of education is contrary to doing the right thing for children and distorts perspective; a nonpartisan focus is needed because politicized leaders chase press attention and self-advancement instead of doing the unglamorous work required to run a public education system well and improve student outcomes.
“we see the overpoliticization of education as contrary to doing the right thing for our kids. In fact, it distorts the perspective.”
Prolonged distance learning during Covid caused serious academic and emotional harm: a previously high-achieving student dropped to the bottom of his class and became borderline depressed, in part because remote classes were demoralizing — students kept cameras off, leaving kids staring at blank screens while teachers lectured.
“he went from being an honor student to being rock bottom in terms of grades... he was at home, borderline depressed, barely getting out of bed. He had lost all the joy of learning”
Abolishing discriminatory laws does not immediately change conditions on the ground; the legacy of segregation and slavery still influences people's lives today, just as India's officially abolished caste system persists in rural areas — these influences are more pervasive and persistent than people often want to believe.
“just because we, with one stroke of the pen, said no to slavery or no to segregation in the ’60s... doesn’t mean that things immediately changed on the ground. The legacy of those institutions still exists”
Racism exists in the United States, but it does not define who the country is; an intellectually honest history teaches slavery, Jim Crow, the Civil War, and Reconstruction in full context — including slavery's existence elsewhere in the world and the progress made over 250 years — rather than presenting a one-sided narrative.
“I believe there is racism in our country. I’m Hispanic. I’ve experienced it. But I don’t believe that racism defines who we are.”
Parents should have a real say and have their opinions heard and acknowledged, but requiring every parent to agree to the coursework would make the job impossible — given a community's diversity it could take decades to decide what to teach — so schools must balance parental voice against the need to actually get the work done.
“if every parent has to agree to the coursework, then we’ll never get that job done. It may take us decades to even figure out what’s the right thing to teach.”
The public education system today lacks accountability for outcomes: no one is clearly answerable for children not getting a good education, and no one gets fired when students fail — so the central reform need is to make the system accountable for student results.
“What we don’t have today in the public education system is accountability for outcomes. Who is accountable for those kids not getting a good education? Who is going to get fired?”
Across thousands of parents from every part of San Francisco and different ethnic groups, people have far more in common than is appreciated, and common ground can be found even between political opposites — for example, broad agreement that history should be taught and taught accurately.
“We were able to find common ground between people who are polar opposites, from a political perspective.”
The current process of school engagement filters out parents without means, because participating in nine-hour board meetings or waiting hours to comment requires free time or the luxury of working from home — so a single parent working three jobs simply cannot participate, biasing the represented parent voice toward the privileged.
“the process of engagement filters out those without means. You have to have some time or have the luxury of being able to work from home to even be able to participate”
The breach of trust between families and schools is not new for Black parents, who have for many years had to be heavily engaged just to ensure their children are treated fairly and stay in the building; it is ironic that some parents are only now adopting the 'breach of trust' framing that Black communities have long lived with.
“a breach of trust for Black parents goes way back in the history of this country, in the ways in which racism has impacted Black communities and has shown up in our schools.”
Using Howard Zinn's 'A People's History' (via the Zinn Education Project) as the primary, non-syllabus teaching tool for high school history pushes a one-sided political ideology — the overarching theme that the United States is an irredeemable, oppressive regime founded to marginalize people of color — which is intellectually unbalanced and inappropriate as the go-to resource for teaching American history.
“the overarching theme in Zinn Ed is that the United States is an irredeemable, oppressive regime. It’s been founded to marginalize people of color. And it’s the go-to resource for teaching children American history.”
Leaders talking the language of social justice and equity have not solved San Francisco's persistent educational-outcome disparities — where 80 percent of students graduate but only 60 percent are actually college-ready — because they have not focused on the things necessary to run a public education system well, setting many kids up for failure.
“Eighty percent graduation, but only 60 percent are actually ready to go to college.”
What happened in Virginia — a blue state turning red over parents' concerns about school curriculum, electing Glenn Youngkin on parents'-rights issues — was similar to San Francisco, and is a good thing because it reflects beneficial increased parent involvement; moreover, much of the progressive ideology pushed into Illinois districts is mandated by state policy in Springfield, so politics has inevitably become part of education.
“Virginia was a blue state that turned red over parents’ concerns about what kids are learning in school and curriculum.”
Covid's silver lining is that parents became far more aware of what goes on in public education, awakening a 'sleeping giant' of lasting parent engagement; parents must now hold the nationwide 'education-industrial complex' accountable to produce results, because failing schools are a nationwide rather than local problem.
“If there is a silver lining to Covid, it is that parents have become more aware of what’s going on.”
Diversity in a school setting should mean not only diversity of skin color but also diversity of ideas and opinions; every student should feel free to express their views on difficult topics, but in many classrooms dissenting opinions are not appreciated, which undermines genuine inclusion.
“diversity in a school setting should not just be about diversity of skin color. It should be about the diversity of ideas and opinions as well.”
No nation's history is singular; schools should capture and reasonably represent the many different strands of a nation's history, because imposing a single narrative is counterproductive and prevents the diverse people who live in a nation from feeling represented in its story.
“no nation’s history is singular... capturing all of these different strands of history and being able to represent them reasonably well”
Because America defines itself as a melting pot, all its constituent groups have a right to be represented fairly and accurately in public education; the full historical truth — including slavery and Jim Crow — must be taught in its totality, not to demonize white people but because continuing a lie and erasing students' own histories does a disservice to Black and other students.
“It does a disservice to Black students and other students if we don’t share the full historical context of America. And not from a place of demonizing or witch hunting out folks”
The San Francisco school board deprioritized school reopening even though it was the top priority for the majority of parents, scheduling reopening last on nine-hour agendas so that hundreds of parents waited up to seven hours only to get brief late-night comment windows — evidence the board had deprioritized learning and education.
“we would have these nine-hour-long school board meetings where school reopening was literally the last item on the agenda. I remember waiting online for, like, seven hours once.”
School is fundamentally a place of discovery and transformation where young people are introduced to formal learning, connect with people from different backgrounds, and are given the space to imagine who they want to become in the world — opening up possibilities beyond their home and immediate community.
“it does create a space of discovering a new way... that actually could help a young person say, “Oh, well, I could do that, too.””
At a foundational level, school's purpose is to bridge the opportunity gap and give every child a chance at a successful life; a good education can be the difference between escaping extreme poverty and remaining trapped in it.
“without that education, I wouldn’t even be here talking to you guys. And for me, at the foundational level, what school is is this opportunity to bridge some of that gap, to give every kid a chance at a successful life.”
The primary, first-and-foremost role of the taxpayer-funded public education system is to teach children to read, write, speak, spell, and compute accurately and effectively, in order to prepare them for future success.
“the role of the taxpayer-funded public education system, first and foremost, is to teach children to read and write and speak and spell and compute accurately and effectively”
A diversity of school options — traditional, magnet, year-round, and modified-track schools — lets families match a child to their interests, as when a student interested in engineering could enroll in a magnet high school with an engineering focus to explore that field before graduating, producing an overwhelmingly positive experience.
“In our district, we have traditional schools, we have magnet schools, we have year-round schools and schools that are on modified tracks. So there is a diversity of options available to you.”
Exposure to a diverse student body is itself a valuable education about the world, motivating a family to move to a city like San Francisco so children can learn about the world while living in one place — though the joy of discovery and basic daily structure that school provides was severely disrupted for years by the pandemic.
“I did it because I wanted my kids to have the experience of having a diverse student body. And so he’s getting an education about the world while just living in this small pond right here.”