Stocks reacted negativelyJ but was it to rate hikes or the other Rs
What this covers
Jeff Snider and Steve Van Metre examine why stock markets have fallen sharply in 2022, challenging the widespread assumption that Federal Reserve rate hikes are the primary culprit. Snider argues instead that a worsening global recession and a deflationary shortage in the eurodollar system are the dominant forces, while rate hikes function mainly as a tool to manipulate inflation expectations and investor sentiment rather than to directly control prices or address supply shocks. The conversation traces how bond curves, futures markets, and falling commodity demand all signaled recession risk months before aggressive rate hikes began, and how the rising dollar—despite central banks worldwide raising rates—points to money shortage rather than policy tightening.
The discussion ranges across several concrete economic signals. FedEx shipping volumes have declined globally, with no recovery materializing even after China reopened. Companies face unexpected inventory gluts rather than the clearances they promised investors last quarter. US gasoline demand never recovered from its March 2022 spike downward, suggesting worsening economic conditions rather than improvement. Van Metre notes that roughly ninety percent of stock ownership concentrates among ten percent of people, making a stock crash's effect primarily psychological—it works through fear-driven consumption reduction rather than direct wealth loss. The speakers examine how the Fed Put created a self-fulfilling prophecy in 2020 when investors believed central banks would support markets, and how that belief reversed just as sharply. Central bank officials themselves, including Christine Lagarde, have acknowledged that rate hikes cannot fix energy prices or shipping blockages, inadvertently confirming that the tool targets psychology rather than the underlying economic problems.
Snider argues that the recent stock and market declines are driven primarily by a worsening global recession and a deflationary eurodollar dollar shortage, not by Fed rate hikes, which act mainly through short-term psychology rather than real economic control.
- Rate hikes work mainly by manipulating sentiment and inflation expectations, not by directly fixing prices or supply shocks
- Bond curves, futures, and falling commodity demand signaled recession long before aggressive rate hikes
- A rising dollar despite global rate hikes points to a deflationary money shortage, not policy tightening
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Rate hikes are not really about consumer prices; they are an attempt to manipulate psychology and inflation expectations, including by punishing the stock market so that robust stocks don't keep inflating inflation expectations, which is why the Fed hiked beyond what people expected.
“rate hikes are not about consumer prices this is all about psychology and what better way to manipulate psychology at least from the Orthodox perspective the ortho economic perspective than to hike rates Beyond any you know any what people had been thinking beforehand”
The supply shock was probably inevitably going to be transitory on a macroeconomic scale even if it lasts more than a year, because paying more for oil and shipping goods is economically unproductive over time and self-corrects through recession.
“the supply shock was probably inevitably going to be I'm going to use the word here transitory even if it takes more than a year that is still transitory on a macroeconomic scale”
Inflation can become transitory simply through the year-over-year comparison: prices (especially sticky ones like rents) don't need to fall, they just need to stop rising as fast, so as energy and other prices stop climbing the year-over-year inflation rate drops sharply.
“if you think about inflation from the year-over-year comp all that does is have to come back down and for that to happen prices just have to stop going up”
US gasoline demand spiked down in March when prices first surged and has never recovered even as prices fell sharply since mid-June; the decline reflects worsening conditions rather than improvement, illustrating how supply shocks redistribute economic activity unproductively and tend to end in recession.
“you saw gasoline go like this in March when prices spiked the first time and they have never come back even as gasoline prices have fallen since mid-June Fallen precipitously not because things are getting better but because they're getting worse”
Central bankers themselves acknowledge monetary policy cannot fix the actual problems; Christine Lagarde stated rate hikes cannot reduce energy prices, convince gas producers to lower prices, or unblock shipping and trucking, confirming hikes target inflation expectations rather than supply shocks.
“I cannot reduce the price of energy I cannot convince big players to reduce gas prices monetary policy is not going to bring down the price of energy”
The wealth effect and Fed psychological influence may operate in the short run, but the last 15 years show little durable wealth effect from rising stocks; the narrative persists mainly as a way to explain how QE supposedly works rather than how it actually does.
“the last 15 years certainly show that as much as there should have been a wealth effect from the stock market there really wasn't”
The dollar's sharp rise—even as central banks worldwide hike rates yet see their currencies crash and bleed reserves—signals a deflationary eurodollar money shortage rather than tightening from rate hikes, which combined with falling stocks and a potentially prolonged recession is a recipe for severe trouble.
“we know it's not rate hikes because other central banks around the world are hiking rates too and yet their currencies continue to crash they continue to bleed massive amounts of resources what we're really talking about is deflationary money”
Roughly 90% of the stock market is owned by 10% of people, so even driving the stock market to zero would not change the average American's day-to-day operations, which is why crashing stocks works mainly through fear-driven consumption reduction rather than direct wealth loss.
“I got around 90% of the markets owned by 10% of the people so if you think about the average American if you drove the stock market to zero it doesn't change their day-to-day operations”
Because conventional monetary policy is ineffective, the Fed (going back to Greenspan) relies on the wealth effect: making people feel richer or expect future wealth so they consume and borrow today, thereby driving the economy and creating inflation it otherwise cannot control.
“we could go back to Alan Greenspan who figured out that hey one day policy is pretty ineffective here we've been working this for a while it doesn't seem to do anything but we need inflation so how do you drive something that you don't have a lot of control over well simple if you could use the wealth effect”
The 'Fed put' belief that the central bank will support markets became a self-fulfilling prophecy in 2020 (reinforced by Powell's public statements), so when investors conclude Powell is no longer their friend, the same crowd piles out, producing a sentiment-driven selloff.
“everybody who've piled in the self-fulfilling prophecy in 2020 is now piling out because they no longer have Jay Powell to say I've got the market supported”
The prolonged stock decline since late 2021 reflects a combination of the Fed put reversing AND a worsening global economy, but as the Fed eventually stops and turns around, the selloff will increasingly be about recession risk rather than rate-hike risk.
“it'll be more about the recession than it is about the rate hikes and to me that's where you get into all the other markets that aren't stocks like you know Bond markets and curves that are sending just crazy crazy signals”
There is no correlation between the federal funds rate and the price of an individual share like Amazon; the Fed's influence on the stock market works through fear and sentiment rather than any direct mechanical link.
“obviously there's no correlation to the federal funds rate and the you know price of Amazon share I mean there's none you can try to find it it doesn't exist”
Bond curves, zeroed-out futures and related markets began predicting this recessionary end as far back as last year—months before aggressive rate hikes and even while the Fed was still merely talking about tapering—making them a leading indicator that the downturn was about recession risk rather than rate hikes.
“the bond curves zeroed out Futures all those things have predicted going back to last year which by the way was months and months and months not even just before aggressive rate hikes before the first well the Fed was still talking about tapering the markets were saying this was likely how it was going to end up”
FedEx reported declining shipping volumes not just in the US but globally, and its CEO noted that expected volume recovery when China reopened never materialized, with the stock getting hammered as evidence of a broader global demand and inventory problem.
“what did we hear from FedEx hey shipping volumes are down but wait a minute not just U.S shipping volume global Shipping volumes... we thought when China started to reopen the volumes would come back up and they didn't”
Companies that assured investors last quarter they would clear excess inventory are instead facing warehouses and incoming containers full of unsellable goods with no buyers, meaning the coming pain is inventory pain from a weak economy, not the rate-hike pain Powell describes.
“we've got too many warehouses full of stuff that we need to get rid of and you can't do that you know unless the economy really is as robust as you thought it would be you're gonna take some pain as Powell likes to say it's not rate hike pain it's inventory pain”
Fed decisions have become so predictable through forward guidance that one can essentially skip the meeting and just read what Wall Street Journal reporter Nick Timiraos writes the day before, since there is a high probability he has the outcome nailed.
“I just listen to Nick Timiraos Wall Street Journal whatever he writes about the day before and like oh if you said 75 basis points you might as well just turn off the news because there's a really high probability that he's got it nailed”
Governments deliberately manage recession psychology, as when the Reagan administration during a double-dip recession fudged data and projected a plentiful job market, which changed people's psychology so they went looking for jobs and the optimism became self-fulfilling.
“they started giving people the impression that the job market was plentiful and what happened the psychology worked people started thinking hey there's a lot of jobs out there I'll go look for one and the next thing you know it worked”
Bank reserves do not leak out into the real economy and cannot really be spent, a point made sarcastically through the running joke that the only way reserves get spent is via 'illegal bounties.'
“see they do leak out into the real economy they're just in the form of illegal bounties”