What this covers

Tiffany Jenkins, author of Strangers and Intimates, joins Russ Roberts to trace how the boundary between public and private life came to be, and why its recent collapse damages both spheres. The conversation moves through history, philosophy, media, and psychology to argue that Privacy as Historical Construction—built gradually across the Reformation, the Age of Enlightenment, and the Industrial era—is now collapsing in ways that impoverish intimacy and corrupt how we judge one another. Jenkins and Roberts examine how Treating Strangers as Intimates leads us to apply standards of judgment meant for our closest relationships to complete strangers we encounter online, a reversal that paradoxically makes us treat intimates more like strangers.

The discussion spans from Luther and the Protestant reformation's cultivation of inner conscience through John Stuart Mill and Harriet Taylor's case for experiments in living, to 19th-century legal philosophy and 1970s reality television. Jenkins details how toleration in 17th-century England accidentally created a space beyond state reach, how prosperity and the separation of household from economy carved out the private sphere, and how the Victorian era came to revere privacy so deeply that even political enemies defended a man's right against intercepted letters. The conversation turns sharp on modern life: how constant self-disclosure makes a person shallow, how Public Self vs Private Self is not hypocrisy but necessary health, and how Adam Smith's insight into the desire to be "lovely"—admired and respected—has transmuted into performative self-display. Jenkins argues that without the soil of privacy where one can grow unobserved, human flourishing becomes impossible.

Sharpest takeaway

Jenkins and Roberts argue that the modern collapse of the boundary between public and private life degrades both spheres: it impoverishes private intimacy, which depends on selective concealment, and it corrupts public life by applying judgment meant for private intimates to strangers we treat as cartoon characters.

  • Privacy is not natural but a historically constructed achievement (Reformation conscience, toleration, domestic architecture) worth defending
  • Intimacy requires exclusivity and concealment; sharing everything makes a person shallow and erodes the bonds of trust
  • Treating strangers as intimates leads us to treat intimates like strangers, and to judge private lives by public standards that no one can survive

The argument · threads4 threads · 49 claims
0.70

The drive for admiration has shifted from creation to self-display as technology enables constant attention-seeking.

2 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Adam Smith's insight that man desires not only to be loved but to be lovely—to be admired, respected, and praised—explains the modern drive for attention, and where civilization once channeled this into inventing, building, and creating, people increasingly seek it through self-display like posing in iconic places.

    “my favorite Adam Smith quote, "Man actually desires, not only to be loved, but to be lovely." And, we desperately want to be loved. And, by that he did not mean romantic love. He meant admired, respected, praised.”

  • Chronicling life via selfies is a contradiction if intended to capture real life, because what you actually capture is what you think your real life is supposed to look like; you become 'real' only when posing and inauthentic.

    “A selfie--chronicling your life via selfies--is a contradiction if you're thinking of it as being a way of capturing real life. Because, what you're really doing is capturing what you think your real life is supposed to look like.”

0.70

Privacy and private judgment are increasingly rare and precious in a world of pervasive surveillance and recording.

2 pointscentrality 5/5
  • In a world where so much is surveilled by our own choices, our technology, or governments, our fleeting unrecorded thoughts and private judgments—what happens inside the skull—are the last potential safe harbor of real privacy.

    “the idea that that's the last bastion of real privacy are my fleeting thoughts, my judgments, the things that make me laugh inside... the skull is kind of the last maybe safe harbor there.”

  • Fans feeling betrayed when a celebrity dies privately reflects an illusion of closeness; we are not actually close to celebrities and not entitled to witness their private moments, yet modern life produces this feeling of betrayal, which is alien to most of human history.

    “we do feel close sometimes to a celebrity, but it's an illusion. We're not close to them. And we're not entitled to witness their dying months or their dying moments unless they choose to share them.”

0.57

Literal fidelity to form cannot capture essence; private judgment systems depend on consequences and social context.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The intuition that a more literal translation is more accurate is totally false, even though it makes sense; the same applies to film adaptations that follow a book's plot exactly yet miss its heart and oddity.

    “They think that the more literal the translation, the more accurate it is. Which is totally false. But it makes sense. It's just wrong.”

  • Smith's loveliness feedback loop—wanting to be judged positively encourages good behavior, while bad behavior is judged—breaks down if bad behavior is always forgiven and never condemned; but the law and the state should treat you differently than your intimates, who can forgive because they know your weaknesses.

    “Smith argued that if you weren't lovely, people judged you; and the fact that you want to be judged positively encourages loveliness; and that's a built-in feedback loop to good behavior.”

  • The hallway with rooms off it was an innovation that created private space, and like the coffee house it was enabled by a rising standard of living, since a hallway is 'wasted' space and a coffee house is a luxury that requires wealth to afford.

    “you have to be wealthy to imagine creating a hallway. Because a hallway is wasted space and a coffee house is such a luxury.”

  • Roberts wants to begin the conversation by discussing the book's title.

    “I want to start with the title of the book.”

0.49

Extrovert-default culture stigmatizes introversion and the legitimate human need for privacy and concealment.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • We live in an extrovert's culture where the default exhortation is to join in, come out, share, and not conceal, and introverts who are constitutionally made to be more private are judged and treated as if something is wrong with them.

    “we live in an extrovert's culture; and introverts are judged... the default is: join in, and not stay home. Come out, don't stay inside. Share and don't conceal.”