Weep, Shudder, Die: The Secret of Opera Revealed (with Dana Gioia)
What this covers
Dana Gioia, a poet and librettist, speaks with Russ Roberts about why opera moves us despite its foreign words and melodramatic plotting. Gioia argues that the libretto—the text itself—is opera's true emotional engine, and that great opera emerges not from solitary genius but from [catalytic creative collaboration](concept:Catalytic Collaboration) between composer and wordsmith. The conversation ranges from the mechanics of how words inspire melody to the historical evidence that a handful of creative teams account for over half the repertory's most-performed works. Central to Gioia's case is Tolstoy's theory of art as emotional transmission: the artist feels something extraordinary and encodes it so that a listener, even across language and centuries, can feel it too.
The discussion moves through operatic history and genealogy—Bellini and Verdi with their indispensable librettists, Rodgers reinventing himself with a new collaborator, the poet Boito psychologically manipulating the retired Verdi back to work—before turning contentious. Gioia contends that American twentieth-century opera withered because twelve-tone music became academic orthodoxy, forcing gifted composers toward cerebral atonality when audiences wanted excerptable song and emotional catharsis. He further argues that Bernstein and other modernists spoiled their own gifts by chasing respectability, whereas Sondheim's Broadway work—especially Sweeney Todd—represents the genuine operatic achievement of our era. Throughout, the pair weigh whether great melody is rarer and more precious than high modernism allows, and whether the future of opera-like work lies on Broadway rather than in opera houses.
Gioia argues that the libretto and the poetic word are the under-credited foundation of opera's emotional power, and that great opera (and musical theater) emerges from catalytic creative collaboration rather than lone genius.
- Over half the 100 most-performed operas were written by just seven creative teams, showing collaboration's outsized role
- Words come first because they inspire the composer and let singers communicate meaning even across language barriers
- Opera is fundamentally elaborate song, the oldest and most universal human art, which delivers emotional catharsis
Opera is unpopular but offers transformative emotional experience when approached with proper listening conditions and openness.
- Opera and poetry are not the most popular things among most Americans and many other people around the world.
“opera and poetry are not the most popular things among most Americans and many other people around the world.”
- People who think they dislike opera should try listening to a work like Madame Butterfly for twenty uninterrupted minutes, first in the dark with eyes closed and later while following a parallel-translation libretto, because for the right person at the right point in life the experience is magical.
“Put on Madame Butterfly... first listen to it in the dark. Just close your eyes... I used to listen with the libretto. I would follow along.”
Broadway attracts the greatest musical and lyrical talents, leaving opera with fewer enduring works in America and Britain.
- American and British opera will leave few works performed a century or two from now because the greatest musical and lyrical talents of this era go into musical theater rather than opera, since musical theater is more popular and lucrative while having norms not that different from opera.
“in 100 years or 200 years, there won't be very many American operas that are performed from our lifetime, or British operas... the great talents of this moment, today, go into musical theater rather than opera.”
- The Broadway songwriting team Adler and Ross wrote two hits, The Pajama Game and Damn Yankees, but never wrote another musical because Jerry Ross died of leukemia at 29; the talented surviving partner Adler never found another collaborator who could inspire him at that level.
“they never write another musical again... the reason is that Jerry Ross died... He's 29. And he dies, I think, of leukemia. And, his partner, Adler... never succeeds in finding a partner who can inspire him again, and at that level.”
- Wagner wrote his own words and may be the only long-time, ongoing, successful opera composer who did so; in American popular song the only comparable solo word-and-music talents are Cole Porter and Irving Berlin, while nearly everyone else worked in teams.
“Wagner wrote his own words. He might be the only truly long-time ongoing successful composer who was able to do that. In American popular song, there's really two. There's Cole Porter and Irving Berlin”
Art transmits emotion across time and space by allowing audiences to feel what the artist felt, connecting isolated human beings.
- Tolstoy's theory in What Is Art? defines art narrowly as the transmission of emotion: the artist feels something extraordinary and creates a work that allows the viewer, reader, or listener to feel the same thing, so that art is how a human being locked in their own selfhood connects across space and time, even after death, to give another the emotion the artist had.
“Art is when the artist feels something extraordinary and creates a song, poem, musical, opera, novel that allows the viewer, reader, listener to feel the same thing.”
Melody is a rare art requiring genuine talent, not sophistication; great composers vary in their capacity to write it.
- Writing an unforgettable, hummable melody is a rare and genuine art that cannot be reduced to a refusal of sophistication: Gershwin could write a great melody in ten minutes and again half an hour later, Verdi and Puccini could do it all day long, while Bernstein, by his own confession, wondered whether he simply could not write one.
“A great meloy is rare, and Verdi could do it all day long. Puccini could do it all day long. I think it's rare.”