Give Away a Kidney? Are You Crazy? (with filmmaker Penny Lane)
What this covers
Penny Lane recounts her three-year journey toward donating a kidney to a stranger, a choice that felt plainly right to her yet provoked confusion and suspicion from nearly everyone around her. Speaking with Russ Roberts on EconTalk, she explores the gap between her own certainty and others' doubt—what it reveals about human motivation, the psychology of altruism, and why we recoil from acts of bodily sacrifice even when they save lives. The conversation moves between her personal experience and deeper territory: the limits of why we do what we do, the way do-gooder derogation protects people who feel judged by others' goodness, and the fact that disguise as moral heuristic drives much of the unease around transplantation itself.
Lane examines the institutional side as well—how transplant center screening disqualifies donors perceived as risky, how standards for acceptance vary arbitrarily between centers, and how about 90 percent of people who begin the altruistic donation process eventually withdraw. She notes the tyranny of the gift, a bioethics concept in which an obligation so large cannot be repaid, sometimes poisoning the relationship between donor and recipient. More philosophically, she and Roberts touch on decentering the self—the work religions ask of us—effective altruism, and drawing on Alan Paton, what it means to bear wounds from the things worth fighting for. Throughout, Lane grapples with a harder question: we cannot fully know our own reasons for doing good, and demanding that we do may itself be part of the suspicion that poisons altruistic acts.
Penny Lane argues that altruistic kidney donation to a stranger feels obviously good to the donor yet seems strange or suspect to others, and that this gap reveals deep truths about unknowable human motivation, the suspicion of do-gooders, and the sacrificial, quasi-religious meaning of giving from one's own body.
- We cannot fully know why we do altruistic acts, and demanding a 'right reason' is itself part of the suspicion around donation
- Negative reactions stem from disgust, the newness of the procedure, and 'do-gooder derogation'
- Giving an organ is a visceral bodily sacrifice that carries religious significance distinct from donating money
Altruistic kidney donation expresses a religious impulse rooted in recognizing human finitude and unimportance.
- The desire to give a kidney to a stranger is fundamentally a religious impulse—not in the organized sense but in recognizing one's own relative unimportance and finitude—because there is something glorious rather than degrading about diminishing oneself.
“your desire to give a kidney is fundamentally a religious impulse. Not in the organized sense, but in the sense of recognizing your relative unimportance.”
Kidney donation is remarkably brave and life-saving despite being relatively safe and rare, comparable to profound historical moral courage.
- Giving blood is similar to donating a kidney except blood regenerates, yet despite kidney donation being relatively safe many people find it far scarier than giving blood, and unlike donation no one feels justified expressing an ick factor about blood donation.
“People give blood, which is real similar to donating a kidney. The difference is you, your kidney doesn't grow back. You just have a backup.”
- Only hundreds of people a year make an altruistic kidney donation in the US, a number that is simultaneously tiny for a large country and remarkable in that any single person would do something so brave and life-saving, comparable to those who harbored Jews during the Holocaust.
“only hundreds of people a year make a altruistic donation. And, I can't decide whether that's a small number or a big number.”
A meaningful life requires wounds from things worth fighting for, revealing depth and complexity in ourselves and others.
- Drawing on Alan Paton, a meaningful life requires having wounds—physical or psychological—from the things worth fighting for, because the question 'Where are your wounds?' implies that something down here should have been worth fighting for.
“the angel or God says, 'Where are your wounds?'... And the response is, 'Wasn't there anything down there worth fighting for?'... you have a wound now that you'll carry the rest of your life, that says something that you thought was worth fighting for.”
- We routinely fail to remember how complex other human beings are, reducing them to a single trait like 'friendly' or 'smart,' even though we know about our own rich inner life; works that reveal another's complexity change how we see not only that person but remind us this is true of everyone we interact with.
“we don't remember how complicated people are... your film and what you just said forces the viewer to remember something profound about the human experience, which is: So much going on in there. I know that about myself, and yet I have trouble remembering that about the other people I see.”
Psychological mechanisms protect people from unbearable indebtedness, and true charity removes even the mild selfishness of being thanked.
- According to Maimonides, the highest level of charity is anonymous giving in which neither donor nor recipient knows the other, which strips away even the mild selfish component of being thanked.
“in Judaism, according to Maimonides, one of the great Jewish thinkers, the highest level of charity is when it's anonymous. That when neither person knows the other, neither the recipient nor the donor.”
- Parents feel very differently about their children than children feel about their parents; it would be unbearable to grow up fully internalizing what one's parents have done, so a protective mechanism prevents that crushing indebtedness, and parents themselves don't want children to feel so indebted they can't function.
“it would be, I guess, unbearable to grow up if you fully internalized what your parents have done for you. And, it's kind of a protective mechanism--because the parents don't want it”
- The phrase 'no-brainer,' used to mean an obviously good decision, literally also means the choice was not made by rational deliberation but felt compelled for reasons one can recite but may not be the real ones.
“the phrase 'no-brainer' is a great phrase because we use it to mean it seemed like an obviously good idea. But, I think if you think about it literally, it also means: I didn't use my head. It wasn't a rational decision.”