The Problems of Boys and Men in Today's America (with Richard Reeves)
What this covers
Richard Reeves and Russ Roberts examine what Reeves sees as a largely unrecognized crisis for boys and men across American education, labor markets, and family structure. Rather than framing this as residual sexism, Reeves attributes the deterioration to structural changes—earlier female developmental maturity, the collapse of institutional marriage, wage stagnation for non-college men, and educational systems that now reward executive functioning skills where girls have a natural advantage. The conversation treats this not as a zero-sum grievance but as a problem requiring systemic reform: stronger male presence in teaching, consideration of later school entry for boys, and cultural reinvention of Surplus Generator Masculinity—the idea that male purpose historically centered on providing more to one's community than one consumed.
The discussion ranges across demographic data, neuroscience, and historical precedent. Reeves documents that gender gaps in GPA have inverted and widened compared to pre-Title IX inequality, that suicide among men runs four times the female rate with young men's rates rising sharply, and that deaths of despair disproportionately affect men without college degrees. He argues that the Cultural Tipping Point in teaching—male representation falling below 30%—shifted classroom culture to favor female strengths just as it earlier helped women in STEM. The analysis of Mattering proves central: Reeves contends that male belonging has always been more socially constructed and fragile than female, requiring deliberate cultural work in an era when traditional economic marriage incentives have dissolved. Roberts pushes back on some claims with Longitudinal vs Cross-Sectional Data, questioning whether stagnation narratives misrepresent actual lifetime earnings. The conversation avoids the manosphere framing entirely, focusing instead on institutional remedies and positive-sum solutions.
Reeves argues that boys and men in America face a serious, under-recognized crisis across education, work, and family that stems largely from structural and cultural changes—not residual sexism—and that addressing it requires reforming systems and reinventing male 'mattering' rather than pathologizing or abandoning men, all without setting men against women.
- The education system now rewards earlier-developing female executive-function skills, leaving boys structurally disadvantaged
- Economic and family changes have left many men without a sense of being needed, contributing to suicide and overdose deaths
- Solutions (male teachers, redshirting boys, reinvented fatherhood) are positive-sum and need not reduce women's gains
Educational systems now structurally disadvantage boys by rewarding female-aligned executive-function skills over male strengths.
- By 2009 about 23% of K-12 boys had been diagnosed with a developmental disability—twice the rate of girls—and the surge in ADD medication is mostly boys; this represents an over-medicalization that tries to fix boys to fit a poorly designed school system rather than fixing the schools.
“the number for boys is 23%, which is twice the share of girls”
- It is a neuroscientific fact that the average 15-year-old boy is developmentally younger than the average 15-year-old girl—about a year behind especially in executive-function skills like organization, future orientation, and task completion—which is a natural disadvantage in a school system that rewards those skills.
“it's a neuroscientific fact that the average 15-year-old boy is younger, developmentally--especially in those skills--than the average 15-year-old girl”
- The rising stakes of homework, continuous assessment, and extracurriculars—originally a correction to a male-centric high-stakes exam system—have over-corrected, making the education system somewhat more female-friendly than male-friendly by rewarding behaviors aligned with girls' natural strengths.
“an unexpected or inadvertent consequence of that has been to, in a sense, over-correct and make the education system somewhat more female-friendly now than male-friendly”
- The big mistake in parenting boys, and in schools, is to treat a son like a malfunctioning daughter—holding up the female way of being as the default standard, which leads to a lack of empathy, compassion, and flexibility toward boys whose needs differ.
“the big mistake to make is to treat your son like a malfunctioning daughter or for schools to treat boys like malfunctioning girls”
- Boys lag girls substantially in GPA (the top 10% of students by GPA is two-thirds female, the bottom 10% two-thirds male) but there is essentially no gender gap on standardized tests like the SAT and ACT, suggesting the gap reflects executive-function and maturity skills rather than intelligence.
“the top 10% of students, measured by their GPA, break two-thirds female, one third male; and the bottom 10% of high school students by GPA is the other way around”
- There are huge differences in physical aggression (externalizing behavior) between boys and girls already at 18 months of age, which is too early and too large to be explained only by socialization—indicating a natural difference in physicality that should be regulated but not pathologized.
“on average boys are more physical; and they have more trouble paying attention”
The reversal of gender hierarchy in education and degree attainment is now wider than the original male advantage it replaced.
- There is now a large and growing gender gap in education across every advanced economy with boys and men behind girls and women, and on current trends there is little sign of reversal.
“there's a very large gender gap in education now, in every advanced economy--I'll talk mostly about the United States--but with boys and men behind”
- The gender gap in four-year college degree attainment is now slightly wider in favor of women (about 16 percentage points) than it was in favor of men (about 13 points) in 1972 when Title IX was passed—the inequality has reversed and is now wider than before.
“at that point, men were about 13 percentage points more likely to get a four-year college degree than women. Now women are about 16 percentage points more likely to get a college degree than men”
- The share of male K-12 teachers has fallen from about 33% in the 1980s to about 23% today and continues to decline year after year with essentially zero policy response, raising concerns about whether educational excellence is increasingly coded as female to boys.
“when he became a teacher in the 1980s, about 33% of K12 teachers were men. It's now down, as you said[?], to 23%; and continues to fall year after year”
- Evidence from women entering STEM suggests a cultural tipping point at roughly 30% representation: below that threshold a profession's culture skews toward the majority sex, and as the male share of teaching has fallen well below 30% the culture has tipped female—the same dynamic that helped women once they broke the 30% barrier, now working against men.
“it looks like it's about 30% from this evidence, right?, on women in STEM. It looks like if you have fewer than 30% of a institution or a culture or profession being male or female, then that's about the point where the culture will tip”
Male suicide and mental health crisis reflects deep uncertainty about being needed and valued in families, work, and community.
- Word analysis by researcher Fiona Shand of how men describe themselves before suicide attempts found the two most common words were 'useless' and 'worthless,' supporting the view that male suicide is the ultimate expression of feeling not needed and believing the world would be better off without them.
“the two words that men were most likely to use to describe themselves when they reached that point were 'useless' and 'worthless.'”
- A core driver of the male crisis is that so many men are uncertain they are needed or wanted in their families, communities, and workplaces, and being unneeded is literally fatal in many cases—men bench themselves while teams in lower-income areas shut down for lack of volunteer coaches.
“part of the crisis we're seeing now is so many men being uncertain that they're needed. Uncertain that they're wanted and needed in their communities and in our society”
- The United States loses about 40,000 men a year to suicide—four times the rate for women and comparable to the number of women lost to breast cancer—and since 2010 almost all the rise in male suicide has been among young men, whose rate has risen by a third even as middle-aged male rates flattened.
“we lose 40,000 men a year to deaths by suicide, which is four times as many as the number of women that we lose”
- Institutional forms like marriage provide structure that benefits men more than women: the suicide rate is eight times higher among divorced men than divorced women, and men's health and wages decline after divorce, showing men struggle more than women without the structure of traditional family.
“if you look at men and women post-divorce, it's eight times higher among divorced men than among divorced women”
The cultural meaning of manhood depends on feeling generative and needed, a fragile condition now undermined by women's economic independence and marital expectations.
- The traditional marital contract had two sides—the economic dependency of women on men, and the emotional dependency of men on women—and now that women's economic dependency has been removed, the previously hidden second side is revealed, creating a marriage-market mismatch as women are unwilling to marry 'idiots' to civilize them.
“we've unbundled the marital contract: And, one side of the marital contract was the economic dependency of women on men. The other side was the emotional dependency of men on women”
- There is an anthropological idea that mature masculinity means being a surplus generator—a man becomes a man when he generates more of something (meat, energy, money, time) than he needs for his own survival and gives it to family and community; this relational, generative masculinity is the historical norm, not the self-interested 'Lone Ranger' myth.
“the idea of mature masculinity being related to the idea of generating a surplus. You're a surplus generator. And so you become a man... when you generate more of something than you need for your own survival”
- Because we cannot put the genie of women's economic independence back in the bottle, fatherhood must be reinvented as an institution that matters in and of itself—the relationship between fathers and children can no longer be contingent on the relationship between fathers and mothers—even though a stable married relationship remains preferable.
“the relationship between fathers and children can no longer be contingent on the relationship between fathers and mothers”
- The sense of 'mattering' is more baked in for women because across human history most women reproduced, whereas only about 50% of men historically reproduced, so male mattering has always been more socially constructed, fragile, and contingent—making the cultural task of providing ways for men to feel needed especially important.
“only 50% of men have historically reproduced. And, the role of men in relation to the community and to the family has always been a bit more fragile, a bit more contingent”
Economic stagnation and labor-market decline hit men harder because women are upgrading skills faster to meet modern demands.
- Most men outside the top 25-30% of the distribution earn a little less today than men did in 1979, while women have seen wage increases across the board—and even if this stagnation can be explained economically (e.g., that fathers were 'overpaid' due to past rents), it does not help the man who feels it, making it a major cultural as well as economic fact.
“it's actually still the case that most men are earning a little bit less today than most men were in 1979. Women have seen an increase in wages across the board”
- There are fewer good paths in the labor market for low-skilled workers than in the previous generation, and this is hitting men harder than women because women are upgrading their human capital faster and more effectively to meet a world demanding more of it.
“it looks to me like women are upgrading their human capital for a world that's demanding more of it much faster and more effectively than men are and that's driving a lot of the gaps that we just discussed”
Gender gaps in educational and economic outcomes are far larger among low-income and Black populations and demand race-gender-specific analysis.
- Most of the gender gaps in education roughly double for kids from low-income (bottom third) backgrounds and double again for black kids, with black men and boys lagging dramatically behind black women and girls, so showing educational outcomes by race without breaking down by gender is now irresponsible.
“Basically all of the gaps that we've talked about so far, you can double them for kids from low-income backgrounds, say, bottom third of income distribution, and you can double them for black kids”
- Recent Chetty work shows upper-middle-class white children born in 1992 do even better than those born in 1978, while white men raised in low-income households are worse off than the previous generation, indicating widening class stratification that elites in segregated communities fail to notice.
“white men raised in low-income households are worse off than the previous generation of white men raised in low-income households”
- Out-of-wedlock births among college-educated women rose from 5% in 1990 to about 11% now, but for everyone else they are now above 50%—meaning for the non-college-educated two-thirds it is now slightly less common to have a child inside marriage than outside it, a dramatic class-divided transformation of family formation.
“the share of births outside wedlock, outside marriage, in 1990 that was 5%. Now it's 11%. So, it's doubled, but from a low base. For everybody else, it's now above 50%”
Taking boys' and men's problems seriously is positive-sum, not anti-feminist, and undercuts appeal of fringe manosphere figures.
- In the current transition phase men will have to adapt and move out of immaturity without women doing it for them—through other institutions and the help of the wider community—which is the central challenge for men in their 20s now that marriage comes much later.
“a better route forward is to actually help men find ways to become non-idiots... without women having to do it for them”
- Serious, mainstream work on boys' and men's issues cuts off the supply lines to fringe 'manosphere' figures: those figures are not wrong that boys and men face real problems, only wrong that the answer is to go backward or be anti-women, so legitimately tackling the problems undercuts their appeal.
“it's also how you cut off the supply lines to the nutters”
- Because boys are roughly a year behind girls developmentally, we should seriously consider starting boys in school a year later (redshirting) to level the playing field—something many affluent parents already do, and a practice that should be available to all parents.
“that's one of the reasons why I think we should be looking hard at things like starting boys in school a year later to try and level the playing field a little bit, which a lot of affluent parents are already doing”
- Working seriously on the problems of boys and men is positive-sum rather than zero-sum: a world of floundering men is unlikely to be a world of flourishing women, which is why a leading feminist like Melinda French Gates funds work on boys and men while still supporting work on women and girls.
“It is quite clear that a world of floundering men is unlikely to be a world of flourishing women”
- A Vanderbilt study shows that making standardized tests optional in college admissions skews undergraduate composition significantly more female—by about four percentage points—a larger effect than on any other variable including race, because standardized tests are the only admissions metric where boys hold their own against girls' advantages in GPA, extracurriculars, and recommendations.
“the main effect of taking standardized tests out of the admissions process, or making them optional, is to skew significantly further female in your undergraduate composition, by four percentage points”