What this covers
Tyler Cowen joins Russ Roberts on EconTalk to defend a surprising thesis about economics' greatest thinker: that crowning a GOAT requires a rare convergence of qualities almost no modern economist possesses. The candidate must command both Microeconomics and Macroeconomics, marry theory to empirics, anchor claims in historical fact, and resist being catastrophically wrong. Cowen argues that economics has undergone a fundamental shift from a field concerned with big ideas—growth, liberty, the viability of central planning—into one dominated by hypothesis-testing and statistical work. This transition has pushed genuine economic thinking toward blogs and podcasts, away from the academic profession itself.
The conversation moves through six finalists: Adam Smith, John Stuart Mill, Thomas Robert Malthus, Hayek, John Maynard Keynes, and Milton Friedman. Cowen credits Smith with first grasping Division of Labor, increasing returns, and competition—ideas so absorbed into modern thought that their originality goes unnoticed—yet faults him for missing marginalism and business cycles. Malthus emerges as subtler than his reputation, understanding trade-offs within the Malthusian Trap rather than preaching mere pessimism. Cowen praises Hayek's distinction between Law vs Legislation and his essay on Use of Knowledge / Decentralized Coordination, though he pushes back on Hayek's blanket dismissal of scientism. Friedman was ahead of the curve on fiat money but borrowed heavily from predecessors on monetarist theory, and his core claim about monetary aggregates has weakened since the 1980s. Marx fails to make even the semifinals for being too wrong on too much, while Keynes forced necessary rethinking but lacked rigor in microeconomic foundations.
Cowen argues that the title of greatest economist of all time requires a rare combination of breadth and depth, micro and macro, theory and empirics, lasting historical impact, and being mostly right—criteria almost no living economist meets because the profession has shifted from a discipline of ideas to one of empirical hypothesis-testing.
- GOAT status demands breadth and depth, both micro and macro, both theory and empirical work, historical import, and not being too wrong
- Economics has fundamentally shifted from a field carrying ideas to one of hypothesis-testing, and ideas migrated to blogs and podcasts
- The classical economists (Smith, Mill, Malthus) had a breadth that modern top economists lack
Smith's most important ideas—increasing returns through division of labor, competition's power, and public choice—are now so embedded in economics they go unattributed.
- Smith is huge because his most important insights—increasing returns and trade through division of labor being limited by the extent of the market, the power of competition, and the phenomenon of public choice—are so deeply embedded in modern economists that they underrate that Smith came up with them first.
“increasing returns and the power of trade to respond through the division of labor being limited by the extent of the market; the power of competition; the phenomenon of public choice. Just those three are so embedded in you, Tyler, that you underrate that he came up with them first, and they're huge.”
Dogmatic faith in competition's power can both inspire creative thinking and blind one to contrary evidence.
- A dogmatic belief in the power of competition, as Friedman displayed on school vouchers, has great value because it pushes one to consider new possibilities, but it makes one much more likely to dismiss contrary evidence rather than learn from it—for example by overemphasizing teacher incentives while underweighting culture and parental involvement.
“when evidence comes along that doesn't agree with it, you're much more likely if you're in that mindset to dismiss the evidence rather than try to learn something from it.”
Deep distinctions between law as evolved norms and legislation as formal enactment remain intellectually powerful.
- Hayek's distinction in Law, Legislation, and Liberty—reserving 'law' for norms and expectations of behavior versus 'legislation' enacted by formal governing bodies, with the understanding that not all legislation is enforceable and that norm-based law often dominates—is an incredibly deep idea, even though Hayek justified it poorly in the book.
“the distinction between law and legislation... that legislation is what is legislated by formal bodies of governance. But that law, he wanted to reserve that term for norms and expectations of behavior. And that distinction and the understanding that not all legislation is enforced or even enforceable, and that law, the norms that he talked about, would often dominate, is I think an incredibly deep idea.”
Interactive digital tools like ChatGPT integration can offer novel ways to engage with substantive intellectual work.
- Cowen's GOAT book is a tour de force in its breadth and depth, embedded inside a ChatGPT-4 option that lets one query the book in a different way than searching text.
“it's embedded inside a ChatGPT-4 option online with other options to come, so you can query the book in a different way than, say, searching it”