What this covers
James Rebanks, author of The Shepherd's Life, sits with Russ Roberts to discuss what it means to build identity and meaning through work bound to a specific place and community. Rebanks's family has farmed sheep in the same English village for at least four centuries, and his flocks carry DNA from Viking times. The conversation moves between the particular—techniques for orphaned lambs, how mountain farms historically recreated transhumance through chains of economic exchange—and the philosophical, exploring how belonging to a long line of people and place can be humbling rather than diminishing. Throughout, Rebanks argues that modern culture's emphasis on individual mobility and self-authorship systematically devalues this kind of rooted, physically meaningful work, and that work itself has become impoverished by the logic of industrial division of labor.
The discussion ranges across externalities, technology, and ecological harm. Rebanks illustrates how local optimization with systemic harm operates in farming—combines optimized to drop no grain destroyed the winter food sources for billions of birds and insects—and argues that modern society lacks any deliberative framework for saying no to technological change, contrasting this with Amish communities that weigh new tools against their social impact. The conversation becomes contentious around land-sparing theory, whether rewilding makes ethical sense in densely human-inhabited landscapes, and whether free-market economics, while elegant in theory, proves too simple for systems where nature is literally winning or losing based on policy choices. Roberts defends the extraordinary gains from specialization and warns against government overreach, while Rebanks argues current policy rhetoric about nature restoration rings hollow when combined with deregulation and trade deals that undercut farmers practicing conservation grazing. The core tension—between progress's undeniable material benefits and what gets destroyed in the process—remains unresolved.
Rebanks argues that the modern frame of the individual as a self-authoring blank slate misvalues rooted, place-bound, physically meaningful work; that work and belonging are the core sources of human meaning; and that economic and technological 'progress' applied indiscriminately to land destroys ecosystems and communities unless deliberately constrained.
- Belonging to a long chain of people and place is a source of meaning and humility that modern mobility and education devalue
- Work in farming is identity and purpose, not merely a disutility traded for consumption
- Free-market technological progress optimizes narrow tasks while ignoring ecological and social externalities, so some technologies deserve a deliberate 'no'
Specialization and division of labor create wealth, higher living standards, and medical innovation.
- Economists are not responsible for the Industrial Revolution but are good at understanding what sprang from it: the division of labor creates wealth and a higher standard of living, enabling longer life expectancy and medical innovation, so participating in specialization produces something extraordinary even if one is free to ignore it.
“The division of labor creates wealth. I think Smith is absolutely correct about that... if you don't ignore it and participate in that weird social milieu of specialization, you create something extraordinary, which is a higher standard of living. And that allows things like a longer life expectancy, medical innovation”
- In America the share of people working on farms fell from about 40% in 1900 to about 2% today (similarly around 2% in England), which is glorious because freeing those resources from farming allowed the creation of many other things—though Roberts concedes something was also lost in the process.
“In America, in 1900, 40% of the people worked on the farm and today it's 2%... there's something glorious about that, because all these other things could be created because we had to devote fewer resources than we did before to farming.”
Government should not mandate technology adoption; restraint through persuasion respects individual liberty better.
- Roberts agrees individuals and communities (like the Amish) should be able to limit or refuse technologies, but as a classical liberal he prefers to preach restraint to individuals and families rather than empower government, because governments tend to listen to billionaires more than to ordinary critics.
“the only disagreement we have over this is who should have the privilege of saying No... I would rather--as a classical liberal, I would rather preach to the individual and the family and not want the government to decide because they tend to listen to the billionaires more than listen to me.”
Mattering in one's community through virtue and wisdom is as valid as wealth, fame, and power.
- Per Adam Smith, man naturally desires not only to be loved but to be lovely, and there are two ways to be significant or to matter: to be rich, famous, and powerful, or to be wise and virtuous; Rebanks's grandfather mattered deeply in his small community through the second path despite the outside world judging him a nobody.
“Smith says, 'There's two ways to matter. There's two ways to be significant. One way is to be rich, famous and powerful, or one of those three. The other is to be wise and virtuous.'”