Dwayne Betts on Beauty, Prison, and Redaction
What this covers
Dwayne Betts joins Russ Roberts to trace how a book of poetry slid under a cell door when he was sixteen in solitary confinement became the beginning of his transformation into a poet and lawyer. The conversation moves outward from that singular moment to examine the role of beauty—particularly books and literature—as a non-negotiable human need inside prisons, not a reformist tool aimed at reducing sentences or fixing the system, but rather an affirmation of dignity itself. Betts describes how the Freedom Reads Project, which places handcrafted wooden bookshelves on prison housing units, deliberately asserts that incarcerated people deserve beauty and deserve to see themselves and each other as more than their crimes.
The substance of their exchange ranges across how literature functions as history and psychology, preserving experiences that readers could not otherwise encounter; why a carefully curated 500-book collection serves as curation of opportunities rather than mere inventory; and how reading constitutes a transformative experience in the fullest sense—something that cannot be predicted or explained in advance. They discuss how redaction, inverted as an artistic technique in Betts's collaboration with artist Titus Kaphar, transforms dense legalese from class action lawsuit documents into poetry, and how the choice of beautiful hardwoods for shelves—rather than cheap veneer—forces everyone involved to confront the question of who deserves beauty. The conversation also touches on how correctional officers themselves experience their own form of confinement, and how shared access to books can make the boundary between inside and outside more porous for everyone.
Betts argues that beauty—especially via books—is not a luxury but a transformative human necessity that can fundamentally change the lived experience of incarcerated people, and that bringing curated beauty into prisons affirms human dignity independent of whether it reduces sentences or 'reforms' the system.
- Books and poetry transformed Betts from a 16-year-old in solitary into a poet and lawyer, showing literature's non-transactional power to remake a person
- Freedom Reads deliberately uses beautiful handcrafted wooden bookshelves placed on housing units to assert that incarcerated people deserve beauty and to build community
- Beauty exists in prison and reaching for it lets people see themselves and each other as more than their crimes
Books fundamentally change how people understand the world and themselves in ways arguments and facts alone cannot.
- Anyone who loves books recognizes that their relationship with books has never been transactional; the rewards books provide are unpredictable and carried with a person for a long time, which is what distinguishes the experience of a book from other things in the world.
“the stuff that happened from my engagement and interaction with books, it hasn't been transactional. And, I think that's what we share; but I think anybody who loves books recognizes that their relationship with the books has never been transactional.”
- Books are humanity's way of remaining present in the world even after we leave it: if a person is alive as long as someone is still telling their story, then books tell that story in perpetuity, making the lasting footprint of civilization a kind of permanence marked by the book.
“I think it's our only way of remaining present in the world, even when we leave. And if we say that you're alive as long as somebody is still telling your story, well, books are the way that that story gets told for perpetuity.”
- Poetry can preserve and transmit experiences that the people who lived them could not themselves record—because they might not have survived—so a poem can function as history and psychology, making a reader feel connected to others across time who shared their predicament.
“I read that poem and I knew the thing that the poet did was capture a story that the person who experienced it couldn't because the person who experienced it might not have survived.”
- Reading a book is one of the quintessential transformative experiences (in L.A. Paul's sense): nothing anyone tells you in advance can prepare you for the experience of reading it, because it is an opportunity to give yourself over to something deeply and meaningfully unexpected that you cannot predict before reading.
“I think that's what books are essentially, is an opportunity that we take each time we pick up a book to give ourselves over to something that's deeply, deeply, and meaningfully unexpected.”
- Books, especially fiction and poetry, are fundamentally better at changing people's minds and the way they see the world than arguments are, because a novel lets a reader carry an experience (like understanding the Holocaust) around with them emotionally in a way nonfiction or facts cannot.
“I also thought that books fundamentally are just so much better at changing people's minds and the way they see the world than arguments.”
Freedom Reads must saturate prisons with decentralized, beautifully made libraries to make reading a democratic norm, not a privilege.
- Freedom Reads has grown from an idea into 60 libraries across seven states in 19 prisons, plans 150 libraries this year, and has a moonshot goal of building 10,000 to 15,000 libraries to saturate the roughly 1,500 state prisons and make books and beauty a standard part of the lived experience of incarceration.
“At this point we've done 60 libraries across seven states in 19 prisons.”
- Placing libraries directly on prison housing units rather than relying on a central library avoids inequity, because central libraries are open only 8-to-5 (excluding people with full-time jobs) and cannot serve a thousand people with one room; saturating 60% of housing units makes reading a democratic, shared experience rather than a privilege for select groups.
“a lot of prisons do have libraries, but the libraries are open from eight to five. And, if you have a full-time job, then you don't go to the library. And, if you got a prison with, like, a thousand people and one library, it's impossible for all of those people to regularly go to the library anyway.”
- Even where prisons have libraries, people cannot discover great works like The Iliad or A Gentleman in Moscow if they've never heard of them, so a carefully curated 500-book collection is really a curation of opportunities—exposing readers to works they would otherwise never encounter.
“even when you go to the library where you get exposed to The Iliad ... If you've never heard of it, then how do you know about it? So, by us curating this 500-book collection, I think we basically are curating opportunities.”
- A curved, 44-inch-high bookshelf placed away from the wall (rather than a standard wall-mounted shelf) maximizes books in a small space, complies with prison sight-line and Prison Rape Elimination Act rules, and crucially creates community because six to seven people can browse at once while facing each other, rather than communing alone with books at a wall.
“by making it curved--the typical library has three bookshelves and around three bookshelves that's curved, 44 inches high, six to seven people could just browse at one time. And, what happens is when you're looking at those books, you're not just looking at the books, you're looking at the person across from you. And, it literally creates a space.”
Beauty in prison—through intentional design and curation—forces everyone to affirm that incarcerated people deserve dignity regardless of merit.
- Rather than focusing solely on criminal justice reform—shortening sentences or releasing people—it is valuable to fundamentally and radically change the lived experience of people inside prison by adding beauty to their lives, and a book can literally be the vehicle for that.
“What does it mean to actually fundamentally and radically change the lived experience of people inside? ... I'm not even advocating for criminal justice reform in my current work. What I'm saying is that you need another iota of beauty in your life and the vehicle for that literally can be a book.”
- Building the shelves from beautiful hardwoods (maple, walnut, oak, cherry) rather than cheap Ikea-style veneer is a deliberate choice because the wood lasts, contrasts with prison's steel and concrete, and—through the labor and care it requires—forces everyone involved to confront and affirm the question of who deserves a beautiful thing, asserting that incarcerated people deserve it because of how we want people to be treated, not because of their merit.
“Who is to say who is worthy of a beautiful thing? Who gets to decide that question?”
- If prison is like a glass and the incarcerated people like water, then books are like ice cubes—adding enough of them causes the water to overflow, meaning a sufficient saturation of books in prisons could fundamentally alter how everyone conceptualizes the space and the harm humans do to one another.
“I thought about the prison is like a glass and the people are like water. And, I thought of the books like ice cubes. And, if you add enough ice cubes to a glass of water, the water overflows.”
Writers and artists reshape what endures by choosing which stories and images to preserve and transmit across time.
- When you write about a person, you get to argue about what matters and make a case for the thing you want to persist; this is not erasing history—Betts deliberately ended his tribute to Michael K. Williams with an image of him dancing rather than his death by overdose, because the writer chooses which memory endures.
“when you write something, you get a chance to argue about what matters. And, it's not erasing history. It's making a case for the thing that you want to persist.”
- The mugshot format (a frontal view capturing most of the face) is designed to create stigma, but by pairing redacted court text with beautiful etched portraits in that same format, the Redaction project transforms the stigmatizing mugshot into something beautiful, doubling voice and image to push in the same direction.
“we turned the mugshot into a stigma because, when you see somebody, you say, 'That's a mugshot.' And, it was like: What if we did that but we made it beautiful and we did these portraits of people?”
- Redaction is conventionally used to obscure what is in a text, but in the Redaction poems Betts inverts the technique—redacting dense legalese from class-action court documents not to hide content but to reveal the salient human points buried within, turning legal minutiae into poetry.
“What if we redacted to get to just the salient points? And, we didn't redact to obscure what was in a text, but we redacted to reveal what was in a text?”
- Michael K. Williams's facial scar, acquired in a club fight, changed his career trajectory and made him distinct, because on screen the scar allowed him to be gentle in an unexpected and deeply moving way even though viewers expected a menacing figure.
“the scar allowed him to be gentle in an unexpected way, even though people would see the scar and expect to be confronting somebody that was menacing.”
Recognizing beauty requires active choice and attention; noticing it in prison connects incarcerated people to shared humanity beyond the hellish narrative.
- Recognizing beauty is remarkably a matter of choice: the phrase 'to pay attention' reveals that attention is the currency we give the world, and we get to choose which moments we deem remarkable, so noticing beauty (like finding a four-leaf clover) is an active decision rather than something that simply happens to us.
“even the phrase 'to pay attention': like, what is the sort of--that vehicle that you have to give the world? What is the money that you have to give the world? And, it's just your attention.”
- Despite the dominant narrative that prison is purely violent and hellish, it is filled mostly with people attempting to get by and reaching for beauty in every way they can, and recognizing these moments of beauty matters even though it is easy to forget them when emphasizing how horrific incarceration is.
“prison, like the streets we walk each day, isn't filled mostly with people attempting to get by. People who reach for beauty in every way they can.”
- A library project makes the wall separating prisoners from those on the outside far more porous—through shared books and visits—and this porousness is meaningful for everyone, allowing people inside and outside to be more connected to the world.
“The wall that separates prisoners from those on the outside becomes far more porous with a project like this. And, I think that's meaningful for all of us.”
Correctional officers suffer their own form of confinement, so libraries offer them radical light and help prisoners and guards see each other fully.
- Correctional officers experience their own form of incarceration—they are 'doing life eight hours at a time' under surveillance and distrust—and have higher rates of alcoholism, domestic violence, and stress than many professions, so providing them beauty (a library) is radical because it offers light in a dark place for the jailers too and lets prisoners and officers see each other as more than convict and jailer.
“correctional officers have a higher rate of alcoholism, higher rate of domestic violence, higher rate of stress than people in a lot of professions in this world.”
Learning poems by heart and reading fiction slowly create lasting, portable connection to literature that cramming and pure education policy miss.
- Learning poems by heart creates a geographical and historical connection to the work and lets you carry literature with you wherever you are, an undervalued gift; education wrongly forces cramming (reading Julius Caesar in three weeks) when slowly memorizing 20 lines over three weeks would yield far more lasting value.
“if you know it by heart, you can carry it around with you wherever you are.”
Betts ended up in prison at sixteen because the violence around him was easier to join than to resist, making the question of how permanent choices happen more baffling to him now.
- Betts ended up in prison at 16 not from being 'wild' but because, despite expecting to go to college, it was much easier to engage in the violence around him than to avoid it, and easier to imagine a momentary foothold in that world than to recognize it would permanently change how he and others saw himself.
“it was just much easier to engage in the violence that was around me than to avoid it. And, it was much easier to imagine that I could have a foothold in that world, even if just momentary, than to recognize that that thing would change the way I saw myself and the way others saw me for the rest of my life.”
- As Betts has aged, the excuses he once made for his younger self have waned, and the question of how he ended up in prison at 16 has become baffling rather than explicable—because at 42 with a 15-year-old he constantly meets people who could be him, making the old answers no longer make sense.
“now that I'm 42 and I got a 15-year-old, that question--how did you end up in prison at 16?--is one that I find baffling. Because I realize that the answers that I thought made sense no longer make sense.”
- At 16, Betts faced life in prison because carjacking carries a possible life sentence in Virginia, and he confessed immediately to drop some charges without even knowing how much time he would get.
“I stood in front of a judge, 16 years old, facing life in prison because carjacking carries life in Virginia.”