Roosevelt Montás on Rescuing Socrates
What this covers
Roosevelt Montás joins Russ Roberts to discuss what liberal education actually is and why it matters for democratic life. The conversation draws on Montás's own journey—from a working-class background in the Dominican Republic through Columbia's Core Curriculum—to argue that liberal education is not primarily about acquiring knowledge or job skills. Instead, it cultivates self-reflective individuals capable of working out their own understanding of human flourishing. The core claim is structural: because each person must grapple with the Condition of Freedom and determine what a good life means, education aimed at free people must be fundamentally different from slave education—training designed to fit someone into a predetermined role. Yet modern universities have allowed the vocational function to dominate, nearly displacing liberal education entirely.
The conversation ranges across why ancient texts, despite their distance in time and culture, reveal a common humanity that contemporary works cannot; how Dialogic Learning through dialogue differs fundamentally from absorbing others' answers; and the problem posed by postmodern deconstruction in universities, which drains concepts like truth and virtue of content and leaves only power struggles. Montás argues that Tradition as Collective Intelligence provides immense value—a compressed distillation of what generations have found worth reading—even as he addresses the contested question of Chronological vs Contemporary Diversity in curriculum. He connects liberal education directly to defending against ideology and demagoguery in politics. The conversation also touches on concrete pedagogical moves: how faculty modeling, student feedback structures, and the instructor's role as skilled moderator rather than expert shape programs that actually work.
Montás argues that liberal education is not the transmission of knowledge or job skills but the cultivation of free, self-reflective individuals capable of working out the human good for themselves, and that it is essential to democratic self-governance and an antidote to ideology.
- Liberal education addresses the human condition of freedom—each person must work out their own conception of the good life
- Great Books work as occasions for dialogue, not as repositories of knowledge to be absorbed
- The dominance of the research paradigm and postmodernism in universities makes genuine liberal education nearly impossible
Liberal education happens through live dialogue and engagement with great texts, not solitary study or passive absorption of summaries and answers.
- Although Great Books can be read profitably alone, liberal education is fundamentally something that happens between people through dialogue, debate, and shared exploration—an insight Plato himself endorsed in the Phaedrus, where he condemns writing because a book only repeats itself and cannot answer questions, whereas philosophical development requires a live, responding interlocutor.
“liberal education, in my view, is something that happens between people. And, it's actually something that Plato would agree with. There's a little dialogue that Plato writes called the Phaedrus in which he condemns writing”
- What one gets from a novel is not knowledge of the novel but an aesthetic, moral, and discursive experience of going through it—which is why summarizing the plot cannot substitute for reading it; analogously, the liberal arts classroom is driven by grappling with the questions works raise, not by knowledge of the works.
“The thing that you get out of a novel is not knowledge of the novel. It's a certain experience--a certain aesthetic, moral, discussive immersion that you experience in reading the novel. That's why you can't just tell somebody the plot”
- When exploring a great text or an unanswerable question, what you learn from discovering an answer for yourself is fundamentally different from being told someone else's answer; the point of liberal education is not to arrive at answers to fundamental questions—we know no better than Plato what justice is—but to sharpen the capacity to ask, sit with, and debate them.
“what you learned from that experience is very different when you discovered for yourself than when someone tells you their answer”
- In a Great Books liberal arts curriculum, no single instructor can be an expert across the full range of texts, so the professor enters the classroom not as a field authority but as a skilled moderator and guide to discussion, which is structurally central to the program's identity.
“there is no individual who is an expert in the range of material that we teach. If you are a classics professor, you're going to have some expertise in the Greek and Roman classics, but you're going to be in the same boat as everybody else when we're doing the Hebrew Bible”
- The contemporary research university model—in which scholars develop very narrow, deep expertise and build their identity by reproducing it through training students and publishing—sits uncomfortably with liberal education, such that succeeding in the liberal arts classroom often requires unlearning the academic habits instilled in graduate school.
“this approach to the educational experience is going to sit uncomfortably in the thrust of the university, which is the model of the contemporary university as a research model, in which people develop very narrow expertise, very deep expertise”
Studying ancient and canonical texts reveals common humanity across time and culture while exposing the contingency of one's own native assumptions and language.
- Exposure to a foreign language and living in a foreign culture forces you to realize that your native language—which feels natural and reliable—is actually funky and unreliable, and the light this sheds on the experience of your own mind is priceless; therefore liberal education ought to include foreign language instruction, which American higher education is tragically losing.
“The light that that sheds on the experience of your own mind, it's priceless. And, it seems to me that a liberal education ought to include language instruction, foreign language instruction”
- Ancient texts written by people from a wholly different world, time, class, and culture allow us to recognize ourselves in them, revealing a substratum-level common humanity—the fundamental architecture of human experience—that contemporary works reflecting our own specific historicity cannot illuminate; this is also why reading across cultures (Lao Tzu, Confucius, the Bhagavad Gita) is valuable.
“we can see in those ancient texts--in those minds and writers from a different world, a different time, a different class, a different culture than our own--we can see what is fundamentally human”
- Attending to translation problems—the untranslatability of key terms like eudaimonia (better rendered as 'flourishing' than 'happiness') and comparison to cognate concepts like Nirvana—sheds light on the complexity and historical constructiveness of concepts, and this meta-awareness of the linguistic medium we live in is extraordinarily valuable in education.
“you can get at these very profound kind of truths about human experience by doing this kind of linguistic analysis that is conscious of translation problems”
- The belief that one can form oneself entirely on one's own—a blank slate writing one's own future—is itself a culturally-constructed ideal and an illusion; one cannot do it alone because the language one speaks and the cultural water one swims in were not self-made, and examining one's origins reveals things about oneself and one's culture otherwise invisible, including where the self-making impulse itself comes from.
“There is a--you can't do it on your own. The language that you speak, the water in which you swim, as you said, is not one that you made yourself, and you're constrained by that.”
- Freud's specific theories have been largely discredited and are virtually ignored in clinical psychology today, yet he remains enormously influential—even among people who have never read him—in the way we think about the mind, analogous to how Marx is discredited as a political force but pervades how the academy thinks about the world.
“Freud indeed has been discredited in large parts of his theories and claims that he made. And, virtually ignored in clinical psychology today directly, yet he's hugely influential even among people who've never read Freud.”
Liberal education cultivates deliberative capacity and self-governance required for democratic citizenship and immunity to ideological capture and demagoguery.
- Liberal education is the enemy and antidote to ideology—the uncritical adoption of accounts of truth in which people have the answer before the question arises, independent of the data; America's political crisis is in significant part a failure of liberal education at both the university and K-12 levels to immunize individuals against ideological polarization and demagoguery.
“Liberal education is the enemy and the antidote to ideology. That is, to the uncritical adoption of accounts of truth.”
- Liberal education is incompatible with authoritarian, non-democratic governance but absolutely critical for democracy, because the possibility of rule by the people hinges on people being equipped for autonomy and self-governance—which requires the deliberative and communicative capacity that liberal education cultivates—whereas contexts like the armed forces rightly function by following authority without raising questions.
“the possibility of rule by the people hinges--depends on--people being equipped for autonomy, for self-governance. And that is liberal education. Liberal education is education on how to be free, on how to manage freedom.”
- Higher education has a moral imperative to equip students with job skills, but in the contemporary world that vocational aspect has 'swallowed the whole,' crowding out the other responsibility of educating free individuals; the solution is liberal education for all—as a foundation on top of which any specialization (computer science, medicine, business) can be built—rather than promoting the liberal arts major specifically.
“The problem is that in the contemporary world, that aspect of liberal education has swallowed the whole. That is, that we have done that and forgotten about this other responsibility that we have, which is to educate free individuals.”
- The ancients distinguished a 'slave education'—training to do a job, accomplish tasks, and function in a hierarchical productive organization—from a 'free education' for the free person; modern people live in both registers, but the vocational has overwhelmed the free.
“There is an education that's about how to do a job, how to accomplish something, how to do what you're told... That's a kind of education that the ancients used to call a slave education. And, there's another aspect of education, that's a free education, for the free person.”
Liberal education pursues understanding of the human good through reasoned inquiry and debate, fundamentally incompatible with postmodern deconstruction and ideological certainty.
- The dominant paradigm in the humanities—postmodernist theory and deconstruction—empties categories like truth, the human good, and virtue of content, leaving only power and a vying for dominance; since liberal education requires a commitment to truth and the possibility of rational investigation into the good, this reigning intellectual climate makes genuine liberal education impossible even within humanities departments.
“you can't have liberal education absent some commitment to truth, and absent the possibility of rational investigation into truth, into the human good, into virtue. If these notions are emptied of content--as much postmodernist theory and deconstruction... does--if you empty those categories of meaning, the only thing you have left is power.”
- Beyond a modest threshold of economic goods, the questions that determine one's wellbeing are no longer a function of material goods but enter a different dimension related to the condition of freedom and the integration of conflicting inner desires into a whole life.
“that threshold, it's a very modest threshold beyond which the questions that determine your wellbeing are no longer a function of material goods, but enter some kind of different dimension and that have to do with this condition of freedom”
- Liberal education makes people better citizens of a democracy and better versions of themselves, but this should not be confused with the claim that liberally educated people are superior to others—the comparison is between a liberally educated you and a non-liberally-educated you, not between people.
“if you're a liberally-educated person, you would be a better you than a non-liberally-educated you. That is, that it makes you a better version of yourself.”
- The phrase 'liberal arts' is misunderstood; 'liberal' refers not to political liberalism but to the condition of freedom in which humans find themselves—the fact that the education is not subordinated to a specific craft or goal but addresses each person's need to work out for themselves what the human good is.
“the origin, the meaning, it just has to do with freedom--has to do with the condition of freedom in which we find ourselves as human beings, and in the fact that the education is not subordinated to some specific goal, some specific craft”
Conscious self-reflection expands interest in oneself and the world, and can occur outside academia among the illiterate and unschooled.
- A great benefit of liberal education is that conscious self-reflection imbues the world with interest—it becomes very hard to be bored because everything around you, including your own mind, is full of noteworthy, puzzling, and interesting things.
“One of the great benefits that a liberal education confers in you, is that it makes the world so, so interesting. It becomes very hard to be bored because everything around you, including your own mind is so full of noteworthy, puzzling, interesting things.”
- The same formative text produces opposite transformations in different readers depending on what they bring to it: St. Augustine made Montás less of a Christian but more of an intellectual, while making another philosopher who read him as a freshman convert to Catholicism—illustrating that the impact of Great Books is idiosyncratic to the reader and their life stage.
“What he did for me was not make me more of a Christian, like he would have liked, but rather it made me less of a Christian, but more of an intellectual. But, I know people for whom St. Augustine did the opposite.”
- The self-reflective exploration of the human good that liberal education promotes can be had outside academia and even without literacy—Montás knew illiterate people in rural Dominican Republic who were thoughtful, wise, deliberative thinkers exhibiting exactly the quality liberal education tries to foster.
“I knew a lot of people who were illiterate... and some of those people had what I would think of as a liberal education: People who were thoughtful, wise, deliberative kind of thinkers”
- Columbia's Core Curriculum, which celebrated its centennial in 2019, is the oldest program of its type—a set of required Great Books courses for all undergraduates, anchored by two year-long discussion seminars of about 20 students reading the Western canon from Homer through contemporary works.
“Columbia's Core Curriculum is the oldest thing of its type. In 2019 celebrated its centennial.”
- To train instructors to run discussion-based rather than lecture-based classes, the program models the desired behavior in weekly faculty meetings where a guest expert gives a short presentation followed by discussion, and uses end-of-semester student evaluations that explicitly rate the discussion-to-presentation balance to signal that this balance matters.
“we have faculty meetings every week in which we model that... in the end-of-semester evaluations, we ask the students to comment and to, kind of, rate the balance between discussion and presentation of the instructor.”
Traditions expressing collective generational intelligence and chronological diversity of thought are extraordinarily valuable starting points despite their historical gender imbalances.
- Because a person can read only a few thousand books in a lifetime, traditions are extraordinarily valuable: they express a collective intelligence of many generations who read thousands of books and made the selection of which endure, providing a great starting point even though one need not agree.
“Traditions collect a kind of--they express a kind of collective intelligence: a kind of generation after generation that have read thousands and thousands of books. And, they have made the selection for you.”
- The fact that ancient texts are written primarily by males is not exclusionary in the sense of deliberately selecting only male writers from the past; rather, the people who had access to the tools of intellectual creation were male for unjust reasons we now reject—and a full curriculum should value both contemporary diversity and chronological diversity (3,000 years of thought), accepting that emphasizing one trades against the other.
“The writers that are there in the past--the people that had access to the tools of intellectual creation--were male for all kinds of reasons: unjust reasons, reasons that we would not defend today”