What this covers
Ian Leslie joins Russ Roberts to explore why curiosity has become scarce despite unprecedented access to information. The conversation centers on a counterintuitive claim: that curiosity is not an innate trait but a product of accumulated factual knowledge, and that the ability to Google answers actually weakens the very habit of mind it promises to liberate. Leslie argues that knowledge Enables Thinking—you cannot think critically about a subject you know nothing of, and early gaps in knowledge create a self-reinforcing disadvantage. The discussion moves across psychology, education, and economics to show how this compounding effect works and why it matters for everything from individual capability to democratic participation.
The conversation distinguishes between Puzzles vs Mysteries as sources of sustained curiosity, arguing that puzzles—once solved—lose their power to engage, while mysteries, which can never be fully resolved, fuel the deeper and more durable fascination that characterizes scientists and genuine inquirers. Leslie frames curiosity as fundamentally opposed to judgment, showing how adopting a curious stance toward people and problems builds understanding in ways that rushing to judgment cannot. The discussion also uses Trophic Cascade and Supply and Demand as analogies to demonstrate how Second-Order Thinking reveals the hidden costs of interventions and solutions that seem obvious at first glance. Throughout, Leslie connects these ideas to cities as engines of curiosity, the role of attachment and love in sustaining exploratory impulse, and why the cultivation of good questions—rather than answers—may be the deepest value a liberal education can provide.
Leslie argues curiosity is not innate cleverness but a virtuous cycle that depends on accumulated factual knowledge, so the modern belief that we can outsource knowledge to Google undermines the very curiosity it claims to free—and the deepest, most durable curiosity comes from treating fields as open-ended mysteries rather than solvable puzzles.
- Critical thinking requires prior factual knowledge stored in long-term memory; you cannot think well about a field you know nothing about.
- Knowledge compounds, so early gaps create a self-reinforcing 'cognitive rich get richer' effect.
- Mysteries (bottomless, never fully solved) sustain long-term curiosity in a way puzzles (solved and discarded) cannot.
Good thinking traces second- and higher-order consequences rather than settling on simple answers.
- Good economics is fundamentally about narrative and causal sequence rather than mathematics: it means remembering to ask 'and then what?'—tracing the second- and higher-order effects that a subsidy, tax, or price control sets into motion—which makes it a powerful tool for treating apparent puzzles as mysteries and imagining the chain of consequences that follows an intervention.
“one of them said, 'Good economics is remembering to ask: and then what?'... This is the first order effect of, say, a subsidy or a tax or a price control. But, then: and then what? What does that set into motion?”
- The TV series The Wire took the police procedural—a genre conventionally built on weekly puzzle-crimes that get solved—and turned it into a mystery, demonstrating that while police and politicians present urban crime as a puzzle with definite answers (arrest users, longer sentences), it is actually a multilayered, shifting, nuanced mystery, including the way it reveals adversaries as more alike and responsive to similar incentives than either side imagines.
“it took a genre, the police procedural, which is conventionally based on puzzles, in the form of crimes that are solved each week, and turned it into a mystery--the mystery of Baltimore's crime problem.”
- Removing wolves from Yellowstone counterintuitively reduced the beaver population—because more deer/elk meant fewer streamside willows and aspen, which beavers depend on—and reintroducing wolves reversed the chain; this trophic cascade is analogous to economic reasoning where a price control sets off a long, non-obvious chain of consequences that can be forecast even though the system's knobs cannot be moved easily.
“there's a connection between how many wolves are in the park and how many beaver... when Yellowstone reintroduced wolves... the elk population got a little smaller and the aspen and willows got a little taller and all of a sudden the beaver came back”
- The higher price of women's dry cleaning looks to some like a puzzle solved by discrimination, but treated as a mystery it raises a deeper question: if it were mere discrimination, a non-discriminating entrant could undercut competitors and win the market, so economics provides a tool for imagining alternative causal explanations rather than settling on the first tidy answer.
“why women's dry cleaning is more expensive than men's. For some people, that's a puzzle... it's because people who own dry cleaning places discriminate against women. But, for me, it's more of a mystery because if that were true... a woman who's not discriminating against her own kind could open up a dry cleaning store with lower prices and drive all the other ones out of business”
- Part of behavioral economics' appeal was that it initially introduced a more 'quantum,' less predictable element into human behavior (a mystery), but it then reverted to puzzle-thinking—treating people as irrational but fixable through nudges—revealing the persistent dual impulse in economics between treating phenomena as solvable puzzles and as nuanced mysteries.
“some of the appeal of behavioral economics... is it introduces a more quantum element into human behavior, a less predictable part. At first. Then it became back into the old, 'Oh, it's a puzzle. I'll just nudge them.'”
Knowledge and understanding develop through repeated contextual exposure, not single encounters.
- We do not learn what words or concepts mean by looking them up once in a dictionary; we acquire them by encountering them repeatedly in context through conversation and reading, which is why on-demand Googling, though useful for settling debates, does not embed knowledge in the brain the way contextual exposure does—especially in childhood.
“that's not the way we learn what a word means. We don't learn about what a word means by looking up it in the dictionary. We learn about it from hearing it a number of times in context, in conversation, in reading.”
- A great liberal arts education does more than teach you how to think; its deeper gift is teaching you what to think about—giving you the tools and the landscape to decide how to perceive the world and your fellow human beings.
“a great education doesn't teach you just how to think, which is sort of a cliche that might have some truth to it, but there's something even more important, which is it teaches you what to think about. It gives you the tools for you to decide what to think about.”
Outsider perspective combined with foundational knowledge enables fresh discovery and insight.
- Non-specialists can make great discoveries precisely because not being versed in a field's conventional channels leaves their thinking unfettered, allowing them to approach problems freshly—though this works only for the right kind of person who still has some base of knowledge, since a person with nothing to start from learns almost nothing.
“Kevin Kelly had the great disadvantage of--I think he never went to college. He also has the great advantage that he never went to college. His brain is unfettered in certain ways that other people's are constrained because he wasn't shoved into certain boxes”
Curiosity and examined engagement with ideas and the world matter, though not universally.
- Socrates held that the unexamined life is not worth living, though many people lead wonderful lives without being curious about themselves or the world.
“'the unexamined life is not worth living,' said Socrates; and I thought he was, and still think he was onto something. But, many people lead wonderful lives who are not curious”
- Both the host and guest admit to being 'curiosity snobs' who prefer the company of curious people.
“I think you're a curiosity snob, Ian. ... I do have a certain preference for curious people.”