What this covers
Stuntman and action designer Eric Jacobus joins host Russ Roberts to build a biological and historical account of human violence. The core argument traces violence to the mirror neuron system—the mechanism that lets us perceive and involuntarily mimic the intentions of others—and argues that tool-making alone separates human escalation from animal combat. Where animals resolve conflict through dominance displays, humans armed with hidden weapons face rational incentive to strike first, never knowing whether an opponent's hand conceals a rock, knife, or nothing. Civilization's institutions—duels, sport, ritual combat—exist not to eliminate this capacity but to contain it, funneling the Contagion of Violence into bounded channels rather than permitting open escalation into feud and tribal warfare.
The conversation moves across media, psychology, and history to map where violence surfaces and how stories amplify or defuse it. Jacobus explains how Intention Virtualization makes us anthropomorphize objects and absorb the emotions of fictional characters; how globalized media converges everyone's Intent Load onto distant crises, inflaming threat perception; and how the Scapegoat Mechanism lets audiences dump real-world fears onto screen villains. The Feud vs The Duel emerges as his organizing contrast—the duel's sealed, one-time resolution against the feud's recursive escalation—and he traces this logic into action cinema, professional wrestling, and the stylistic shift toward shaky-cam combat in the post-9/11 era. Discussion touches on Catharsis, the role of blood as a contagion signal in sport, comedy as controlled transgression, and the Veneer of Civilization that separates order from the violence he believes remains biologically present in all of us.
Jacobus argues that human violence is rooted in a biological mirror-neuron system that lets us 'virtualize' others' intentions, and that tool-making uniquely enables escalation; civilization's institutions (duels, ritualized sport, closed altercations) exist to contain a violent capacity we have not evolved past.
- Tool-making changes the game theory of conflict because an opponent may be hiding a weapon, making preemptive attack rational
- Mirror neurons cause us to virtualize and mimic intentions, explaining empathy, contagion of violence, and PTSD
- Closed altercations (duels, sport) suppress the feud's runaway escalation, which is humanity's recurring crisis
Mirror neurons fire both when performing and observing action, involuntarily virtualizing others' intentions and emotions regardless of conscious control.
- Mirror neurons explain why people cry at fictional characters' suffering or even at a cartoon car or robot 'dying'—the brain involuntarily virtualizes the intentions and pain of anything it perceives, hijacking emotional reactions beyond conscious control, which is also why comedy trailers insert footage of people laughing to induce laughter.
“Or when a cartoon car or robot dies, even, or an animal, or a tree. It goes beyond simply other people. Like I said, anything that you can virtualize, you're naturally going to have some kind of empathy for.”
- Because the mirror neuron system virtualizes intentions, humans anthropomorphize not just other people but objects, animals, trees, the sun, and even the Creator, ascribing intention to anything they perceive—which means even objects and locations can elicit empathy or fear.
“if you're trying to then understand the intention of whatever it is you're perceiving, then you tend to anthropomorphize it because that's the mirror neuron system that you have.”
- You learn to read others' intentions by performing the same action yourself; repeatedly throwing a punch in boxing builds the link between mirror neuron and motor system so that you can instantly read an opponent's punch from subtle cues like a hip move or blink—an instantaneous, non-conscious skill that armchair critics can never acquire.
“the way that you actually train yourself to understand the intents of others is by performing the same action yourself”
- Mirror neurons were discovered when researchers probing a macaque's motor cortex for the grasping neuron found that the same neuron fired both when the monkey grasped a banana and when the monkey merely watched a scientist grasp one, revealing that perceiving another's action triggers the observer's own motor system.
“one of the scientists picked up a banana himself; and then the same beep in the monkey's brain read--in generally the same area.”
Entertainment and narrative exploit mirror neurons to shape audience beliefs through catharsis, villainification, and proxy scapegoating rather than reasoned persuasion.
- The shaky-cam, hard-to-follow action style introduced by The Bourne Identity in 2002 succeeded because, coming on the heels of 9/11, it evoked a dangerous situation difficult to understand in the moment but reflected upon afterward—matching audiences' post-crisis virtualization and possibly helping compartmentalize collective PTSD, thereby becoming the industry's gold standard of 'evocative rather than showy' action.
“Bourne Identity was in 2002 and that was hot on the heels of a major catastrophic event in America, which was 9/11”
- Because audiences virtualize and empathize with heroes through narrative, the same mechanism that produces the cathartic 'hero's journey' can be exploited by cult leaders, hypnosis, and propaganda—for example a film blaming a poor man's suffering on a Jewish neighbor trains antisemitism via mirror neurons.
“you show that the fault is the Jewish guy next door--it's like, well, 'Wait a minute. Now you've now you've taught people to be antisemitic via mirror neurons.' This is also--it could be used very badly.”
- Action choreography is planned violence—choreography being planned movement—so to design compelling screen action one must understand real violence, then build an 'action code' specifying how performers move, how violent and cathartic the scene is, and how the camera and editing perceive it, all calibrated to the franchise's audience expectations.
“the thesis is choreography is planned movement, and action-choreography is planned violence. So, if we want to understand action, we need to understand violence.”
- The same audience can play God of War and watch Harry Potter yet hold incompatible expectations for each franchise's violence, so an effective action code must be calibrated to the specific franchise and demographic—Harry Potter violence will not work in God of War and vice versa.
“You shouldn't be putting Harry Potter violence into God of War. It's just not going to work even though it's the same people doing both, playing both.”
- Many recent series practice 'mean' violence by otherizing villains—giving them no cogent, steelmanned rationale—reflecting social-media culture's refusal to hear out the opposition, so that entertainment aims merely to produce a cathartic bloody experience and assimilate the audience to the producer's view rather than convert them by understanding the antagonist.
“it seems like a lot of these shows now, they want to otherize the villain... It's almost like they don't even have a reason for what they do. I think it's very mean what they do.”
- Fictional villains—like the WWE's foreign-archetype characters such as the Iron Sheik—function as proxy scapegoats onto whom audiences dump their current crisis 'intent load,' connecting a real-world villain in the viewer's brain to the screen villain, which is why we consume cathartic entertainment in higher volumes than ever.
“They sort of provide a proxy scapegoat in a way, where the current--whatever the current crisis might be, that this character is going to allow you to dump all of the intent load into this character”
- Great comedy works by making the hero the fall guy—as in Chaplin and Jackie Chan—so that comedy expels the outsider while the audience, laughing at the hero, also comes to understand what it is like to be laughed at, which is why the court jester held a permanent, well-paid position as an expellable outsider.
“comedy expels the outsider, which is why the court jester was always--he has a permanent position as an outsider that you can expel, and he's paid very well for it.”
Globalized media converges everyone's crisis attention simultaneously, overwhelming individual intent loads and creating markets for demagogues claiming solutions.
- Globalized media makes geographically distant events feel personally threatening—throwing a rock through a window in New Zealand makes Californians fear for their own windows—because global media causes everyone's 'intent loads' to converge on the same crisis, which is then overblown regardless of local relevance.
“if you throw a rock through a window in New Zealand, then suddenly people in California are afraid of their windows getting broken. And it's just global media tends to do that. It tends to make of our intent loads converge on the same crisis”
- When globalized media keeps people perpetually virtualizing looming crises, it creates a market opportunity for a 'new priesthood' of figures who claim to have the solution in exchange for rents, power, or attention—and if people are hungry enough for resolution they may hand power to a dangerous figure, signaling they have lost sight of who they are.
“it presents an interesting opportunity for a new priesthood to come out and say, 'Oh, I have the solution to that. Just pay me rents and I'll take care of it for you.'”
- To blunt an overactive mirror-neuron virtualizer inflamed by reactive, globalized social media, one should get off these platforms, which helps one sleep at night and avoid converging on overblown crises.
“I recommend if anybody's trying to blunt their virtualizer, to just get off of these things and that'll help you. It helps you sleep at night.”
Human violence uniquely escalates because tool-use makes weapon-possession unobservable, incentivizing preemptive strikes absent in non-tool-using animals.
- Intraspecific animal combat rarely ends in death because animals are physiologically outfitted to prevent dying at the hands of their own species, and even when capable, they tend to resolve fights through alpha/beta dominance rather than escalation to death.
“a dog can't kill a dog is because a dog is just sort of uniquely outfitted to prevent dying at the hands of another dog”
- Human violence escalates differently from animal violence because humans make tools: when a person hides their hand, an observer cannot know whether they hold a rock, knife, or nothing, so it becomes rational to assume they are armed and to strike first—a dynamic absent in animals who cannot impute weapon-possession to one another.
“if a human puts his hand behind his back, you don't know if he's got a rock, a knife or a CD that he wants to sell you. And it's all based on intention.”
- When one person kills another, the victim's relatives, empathizing most with the outrage, naturally seek revenge—and because it is safer to retaliate in numbers, three avengers become nine, escalating into tribal warfare and potentially world war, unless a closed system clearly bars further destruction.
“three fights--one and then his cousins come back with nine, and then now you have an escalation, now you have tribal warfare. And potentially world war.”
Closed, rule-bound systems like duels or sanctioned combat prevent escalation to death by sealing disputes and blocking retaliation spirals.
- A closed altercation has an external mediator or rules that suppress escalation and prevent fighting to the death (sparring, sanctioned sport fights), whereas an open altercation has no external constraint and can explode out of control—which is why societies attempt to impose global rules on combat and warfare.
“a closed altercation is going to have some kind of external suppression to keep things from escalating”
- The duel is preferable to the feud because it is an extremely closed system: it seals the matter through a one-time, norm-bound confrontation that the offended party cannot relitigate, preventing the runaway escalation of the feud—and historically dueling persisted in 1700s France despite Louis XIV's attempts to outlaw it, and even non-lethal sword duels ending in a wrist cut sufficed to settle disputes.
“the duel is a far-preferred system than the feud, because the feud can spiral out of control and the duel is just extremely closed.”
- The mere anticipation of possibly dying in a duel—even when no one actually dies and the fight ends in a minor cut—produces a profound effect that resolves the dispute, because confronting one's own non-invincibility makes the original grudge no longer worth pursuing.
“even though you may not die, even though there may not be a dead body at the end, the fact that you are anticipating possibly dying, that does something to you when you enter these equations.”
Blood signals contagious violence to humans through ancient neurological and cultural understanding, shaping both ritual cleansing and modern combat aesthetics.
- Before germ theory, plague and violence were treated as a single spiritual contagion using the same rituals, and through a mirror-neuron lens this makes sense: one can virtualize many people at once, so violence spreads through a crowd like an infection, which explains rituals requiring bloody weapons and bloodied people to be cleansed and set apart.
“you could almost say that germ theory is founded upon this idea. Because, before germ theory, the theory was that plague was a spiritual phenomenon”
- The sight of blood elicits a contagious response in humans because blood on a weapon or wound connotes violence, which the mind treats as contagious—explaining ancient practices of cleansing bloodied weapons and setting bloodied people apart—though these responses are sometimes ill-founded since not all blood signals violence.
“weapons that are soaked with blood have to be--they have to be cleansed before they go back into the vicinity of the tribe”
- Modern boxing rules suppress blood—a cut that a cutman cannot seal ends the fight—possibly tapping into an understanding that blood is contagious upon the crowd, whereas MMA permits blood yet does not appear to rile crowds more than boxing, suggesting blood may be insightful in one ritual format and cathartic in another.
“when somebody draws blood, the crowd goes, 'Wow!' But, what happens? You get the cutman on it, and if that cutman can't seal up that cut, what happens? The fight ends.”
- Children have an innate, untaught reaction to the sight of blood—no one tells them to freak out, yet they all somehow know—suggesting a deep-seated human understanding that blood means life and is not merely a mechanical chemical, consistent with anthropological practices of drinking enemies' blood to obtain their life force.
“nobody ever told that kid that if you see blood, you should freak out. No kid is... It's like they all know, somehow.”
Autism may involve concentrated mirror-neuron virtualization in a single domain of expertise, potentially linked to globalization of intent loads rather than genetics.
- Autism may not be a mirror-neuron malfunction but a mirror-neuron phenomenon in which the entire virtualizer is concentrated into a single domain of expertise, producing extraordinary mimicry (e.g., a blind autistic pianist with perfect pitch), with the core difficulty being the inability to shift that domain; Jacobus speculates autism is developmental rather than genetic, linked to the globalization of intent loads.
“autism might--it might be a mirror-neuron phenomenon where people with autism, they can dedicate their entire mirror-neuron virtualizer to one domain of expertise and perfect it.”
- Jacobus action-directed the Netflix Indian film The Man Who Feels No Pain and performed motion capture combat for God of War (2018) and God of War Ragnarok.
“I did motion capture for God of War, 2018--which means I put on a suit and performed combat movements for the character.”
- What appears to be a human thirst to watch death may not be a real urge but rather the mind still virtualizing a previous violent crisis and interpreting reality through that PTSD-like lens, since one cannot isolate a genuine appetite for death from this re-processing of prior trauma.
“what we might consider a thirst for violence might simply be us still virtualizing the previous crisis in our minds--the previous violent crisis--and trying to sort of interpret reality through that lens. Because that is a lens of PTSD.”