What this covers

Noreena Hertz, an economist at University College London, discusses her book The Lonely Century with Russ Roberts on EconTalk. Hertz documents that loneliness has measurably risen since the 1970s and accelerated sharply since 2010, particularly among the young. She attributes this crisis to three main forces: the pervasiveness of social media, the erosion of in-person community infrastructure due to austerity, and the ascendancy of neoliberal capitalism under leaders like Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan, which she argues has reframed individuals as self-interested competitors rather than community members. Roberts offers a counterargument, proposing instead that the decline of family and religious institutions—institutions both Thatcher and Reagan championed—bear primary responsibility, and that government intervention is not the answer.

The conversation ranges across sociology, economics, and psychology to isolate what drives disconnection. Hertz points to mounting evidence: atrophying face-to-face skills among young people, the neuroscience of mirror neurons showing in-person interaction's superiority to screens, and a Stanford experiment where deleting Facebook reduced loneliness measurably. She explores the distinction between aloneness and loneliness—solitude chosen is not the same as connection refused—and proposes concrete remedies: deliberate cross-group activities like civic service, shared meals in workplaces, and the protection of third spaces like cafes and independent shops. Roberts counters that the concept of neoliberal capitalism lacks real evidence and that loneliness questionnaires measure something too subtle to quantify reliably. The debate hinges on whether structural economic systems or the decay of traditional belonging institutions best explain why so many feel unseen.

Sharpest takeaway

Hertz argues that rising loneliness in the developed world is a measurable, accelerating crisis driven by social media, declining in-person association, and the individualist 'neoliberal capitalism' ushered in by Thatcher and Reagan; Roberts counters that the cause is more likely the decline of family and religion and that bottom-up action, not government, is the remedy.

  • Loneliness has measurably risen since the 1970s and accelerated since 2010, especially among the young
  • Hertz blames social media, austerity-driven loss of community infrastructure, and a self-interested neoliberal mindset
  • Roberts attributes it instead to declining family and religion and rejects neoliberalism as a real or causal force

The argument · threads4 threads · 42 claims
0.85

Loneliness fundamentally reflects the collapse of family, religion, and local community spaces that once anchored belonging.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The slow decline of the traditional nuclear family in the West over the last 40 years -- which both Thatcher and Reagan valorized -- is a large and underappreciated part of why people are lonely, a factor Hertz mentions hardly at all in her book despite its importance to togetherness.

    “the death of the family, this traditional nuclear family in the West... the lack of the standard family structures that were common until the last 40 years, that's not so good for togetherness.”

  • Beyond libraries, ordinary commercial 'third spaces' -- McDonald's, cafes, hardware stores, barbershops, and other small businesses -- serve as important places where people interact and feel known, playing a real role in anchoring and nurturing communities.

    “he talks about how McDonald's is a way, in many communities, for people to interact with each other. And you talk about that in your book: that small businesses--we can think about cafes and hardware stores--there's all kinds of places where people get together”

  • While loss of family and religious connection is a huge part of the loneliness problem, government should not try to fix it by subsidizing family or religion -- subsidizing religion is bad for both religion and the country -- because the solution must come from the bottom up, from individuals practicing kindness, which is in our own hands.

    “I don't think government should be trying to fix it. I don't believe government should subsidize family, or ever subsidize religion. I'm now in a country where religion is subsidized. And, I think it's bad for religion, and it's bad for the country.”

  • Tribalism is the flip side of loneliness: humans crave belonging to a tribe, and where the natural tribes of physical neighbors, family, and religion are no longer available, people turn to other tribes such as political affiliations and sports fandom to feel connected.

    “tribalism--the tribal aspect of our humanity--is really the flip side of loneliness. We want to be with our tribe.”

0.64

The human need to belong to a tribe is so rooted in evolution that unmet belonging drives people toward divisive substitutes like political and sports tribalism.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • People seek substitute tribes, and Roberts suggests sports fandom is a healthier tribe to belong to than politics, though he acknowledges not everyone agrees with that judgment.

    “I often talk about the sports tribes. That's a common way that people feel connected to other people. I've suggested that sports is healthier than politics”

  • The human urge to belong to one's own tribe is so fundamental, rooted in an evolutionary history of being surrounded by one's tribe while fearing or fighting outsiders, that unless the primary need for a sense of belonging is satisfied, efforts to build bridges across tribes will struggle.

    “We spent most of our evolutionary history surrounded by our tribe and being either afraid of or fighting the people who aren't like us. So, it seems to me that that human urge to belong is so fundamental”

  • Much of the rise of populism -- Brexit and the Trump phenomenon -- stems from people who felt disconnected and no longer part of their country, whose narratives are now nearly irreconcilable with those on the other side, so government involvement in mediating belonging risks worsening the conflict if one side triumphs.

    “a lot of the rise in populism, as you said, is people who felt disconnected. And, they wanted to feel connected to their country again--whether it was Brexit or the Trump phenomenon in the United States.”

0.56

Social media companies structurally maximize engagement through design and data, exploiting human psychology for profit.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Social media companies make their money from advertising, and advertising revenue depends on how many people are on their screens and for how long, so their incentives are clearly aligned with maximizing engagement -- and they have the data to optimize for it.

    “they make their money on advertising. The money they make from advertising depends on how many people are on their screens and for how long.”

  • If you dislike Facebook, an alternative to regulation is to build a better, more child-friendly, less-addictive platform; though network effects make this hard because we care how many people we interact with, someone else could in principle create such a product.

    “he said: If you don't like Facebook, you find parts of it unpleasant or inadequate or whatever it is, build a better one. And, it's hard because there's a big network”

0.44

Claims about austerity, neoliberalism causing loneliness, and loneliness measurement lack empirical grounding and misdiagnose the real causes.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Governments in the 1980s and after liked to talk about austerity and belt-tightening but did not really do it; real government spending corrected for inflation is much larger and is flat or growing as a percentage of GDP across the West, so this is not really an austere era even if spending priorities shifted.

    “governments like to talk about austerity and belt-tightening, but they don't really do it. Governments are much, much bigger--certainly in absolute terms, corrected from inflation of course.”

  • Attempts to measure such a subtle, rich aspect of the human condition as loneliness should not be treated as truly scientific; 'sometimes' and 'often' are very different, and some degree of episodic loneliness is part of the inevitable human condition since we are isolated beings who long to connect.

    “I don't consider these attempts to measure this really subtle and rich problem or challenge to the human condition to be so scientific. We have gathered data on it. This is true. Sometimes and often are very different.”

  • Self-interest is as old as humanity and is not selfishness; Adam Smith never endorsed selfishness as a virtue, and there is no evidence Thatcher or Reagan promoted being a hustler over a helper; moreover we do not really live in a neoliberal world since government is bigger than ever, so the claim that neoliberal capitalism culturally caused loneliness lacks evidence.

    “I just don't see any reason to think that the cultural impact of neoliberal capitalism is real. I don't even think we live in a neoliberal capitalist world.”

  • For people who struggle with social cues -- and even those who are good at them -- audio-only or phone conversation can be a more intimate form of conversation than face-to-face or video, because neither party has to read or project body language or notice whether the other is paying attention.

    “I actually think sometimes phone, or just audio only, is actually a more intimate form of conversation for people who struggle with social cues and even people who are pretty good at them.”