What this covers

Bret Devereaux, a historian at the University of North Carolina, joins Russ Roberts to dismantle two foundational myths about the ancient world: that Rome was a culturally homogeneous empire that declined once it became diverse, and that Sparta was a fearsome military machine forged in discipline. Devereaux argues the opposite on both counts. Rome succeeded precisely because it was a multi-ethnic melting pot from its founding—a pragmatic, brutal state that integrated conquered peoples as soldiers and allies rather than subjects to be culturally remade. Sparta, by contrast, was a mediocre military power kept afloat by reputation and the enslaved labor of helots who vastly outnumbered the free Spartiates. The conversation excavates why these distortions matter: modern actors weaponize false histories of ancient migration and warrior culture to argue against diversity and for autocratic models of leadership.

The episode moves across several overlapping terrain. Devereaux traces Rome's practical genius—how absorbing diverse conquered peoples as auxilia created a deep well of soldiers that let Rome survive grinding conflicts like Hannibal's invasion and the 23-year Punic Wars. He addresses how the real Roman elite included North Africans and Libyans like Fronto and Apuleius, a diversity erased by modern television and film. On Sparta, he challenges both its military record—it won roughly half its battles—and the mythology of its agoge training system, which was conformity enforcement, not martial drill. Devereaux also engages source skepticism, explaining how ancient writers like Xenophon shaped Sparta's legend to flatter aristocratic oligarchy, and how preservation bias in what texts survived skews our entire picture of the ancient world. The argument lands on history as social memory: because modern states consciously model themselves on Rome and Greece, getting these histories wrong feeds present-day misconceptions about governance, manhood, and multi-ethnic states.

Sharpest takeaway

Devereaux argues that popular culture systematically distorts ancient Rome and Sparta—Rome was a brutal but pragmatic multi-ethnic melting pot whose success came from harnessing diversity, while Sparta was a mediocre military power propped up by slavery and good press—and that getting this history right matters because we use the past as a model for present action.

  • Rome's expansion succeeded because it co-opted diverse conquered peoples into its military rather than imposing cultural homogeneity
  • Sparta's reputation as an unstoppable warrior society is unsupported—it won about half its battles and its 'training' was a conformity-enforcing system, not military drill
  • Distorted histories get weaponized for modern political arguments about migration, masculinity, and governance

The argument · threads3 threads · 27 claims
0.71

Human nature includes a susceptibility to revering strong leaders that can manifest as dangerous authoritarianism.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • Beyond wanting to be special, there is a part of human nature—described by Adam Smith—that wants to look up to and be subservient to a strong, successful figure, even willing to suffer from that figure's actions; this willingness to believe a 'great man' will be one's savior is the most dangerous form, visible in the modern resurgence of respect for Stalin in Russia.

    “there's also a part of us that wants to be subservient to a very strong person. Adam Smith writes about this... our desire for--to look up to great people... that this, quote, "great man,"--and it's almost always a man--is going to be your savior.”

0.57

Historical inquiry must adapt its methods to the scarcity of evidence available from different time periods.

1 pointcentrality 3/5
  • The amount of historical evidence decreases the further back you go, so while a historian of the modern world must learn to sip from a firehose of evidence, the historian of the ancient world must learn to find water in the desert.

    “a historian of the modern world has to learn how to sip from a firehose of evidence, while the historian of the ancient world must learn how to find water in the desert.”

0.44

Roman civilization made substantial contributions worthy of historical examination and cultural recognition.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • There is a Monty Python skit from Life of Brian, 'What have the Romans ever done for us?', that humorously addresses Roman contributions.

    “there is a Monty Python skit about this from the Life of Brian... just Google 'What have the Romans ever done for us?'”