What this covers

Donald Shoup and host Russ Roberts examine how American parking policy creates widespread economic damage through mechanisms most drivers and policymakers do not recognize. The conversation centers on two interlocking problems: curb parking kept artificially cheap or free, and off-street parking requirements mandated on new construction. Shoup's core argument is that cities should instead charge market-clearing prices for street parking, dedicate the revenue to neighborhood improvements, and eliminate minimum parking mandates. Roberts raises practical objections about implementation and equity as they work through the logic and evidence.

The discussion spans several distinct territories. One thread examines the economics of bundling vs unbundling costs—how parking requirements hide their true price by folding it into housing, retail, and food costs, imposing charges on people too poor to own cars. Another explores land rent and why curb parking differs fundamentally from other priced goods: revenue collected is a pure transfer that funds public amenities without economic loss. Shoup traces specific harms: minimum parking requirements shrink affordable housing supply, distort development patterns, and create oversized surface lots that discourage foot traffic and vitality. He then presents cases—Old Pasadena, San Francisco's performance pricing system, and Los Angeles adaptive reuse—showing that reform removes artificial barriers and unlocks development. The discussion also covers surprising findings: variable pricing can benefit low-income drivers willing to walk; Tokyo's ruthless enforcement model works; and the political pathway requires showing local stakeholders tangible benefits, not abstract externality arguments.

Sharpest takeaway

Shoup argues that conventional American parking policy—free or underpriced curb parking plus mandated off-street parking minimums—imposes large hidden costs, and that cities should instead charge market-clearing prices for curb parking, spend that revenue locally, and abolish off-street parking requirements.

  • Curb parking revenue is land rent / a pure transfer payment, so charging for it funds neighborhood improvements without a real economic cost
  • Off-street parking minimums hide parking costs by bundling them into the price of everything, raising housing and retail prices
  • Real-world cases (Old Pasadena, San Francisco, LA adaptive reuse) show the reforms work

The argument · threads7 threads · 30 claims
0.85

Off-street parking requirements artificially constrain housing supply by mandating expensive spaces.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Developers will provide parking on their own because they know future residents and customers want it; they only build excess parking because of requirements. Since an underground parking space can cost $40,000–$50,000, an unbundled price would lead them to provide perhaps one space per dwelling rather than a planner-mandated two.

    “They know how much the parking spaces cost to build. An underground parking space could cost $40,000 or $50,000. At that price, maybe one parking space is enough for the dwelling unit if the parking isn't bundled in with the rent.”

  • After California state legislation preempted local bans and allowed homeowners by right to convert a garage into an apartment with no parking required (driveway suffices), the number of permits per year in Los Angeles increased seventeenfold—evidence the parking-related prohibitions had suppressed affordable housing supply.

    “Now every homeowner is allowed, by right, to convert a garage into an apartment with no parking spaces required... the number of permits per year has increased by 17 times.”

  • California single-family parking requirements demand two to four covered off-street spaces; the 'covered' rule (from LA's 1936 first requirement) existed so the space couldn't be converted to a garden or other use, which effectively dedicated garages to cars and blocked their legal conversion into small affordable apartments until the state forced cities to allow garage apartments without required parking.

    “they thought, if it was not covered, it could be converted to some other use, like a garden or a play area. So, if it were a garage, it would be dedicated to cars.”

  • Cities should remove off-street parking requirements, which mandate large amounts of parking for new buildings—e.g., a typical restaurant requirement of 10 spaces per 1,000 square feet, making the parking lot about eight times bigger than the restaurant—because these requirements are set by planners with no knowledge of actual parking costs.

    “the typical requirement is 10 parking spaces for every 1000 square feet of the restaurant area, which means in effect that the parking lot is about eight times bigger than the restaurant itself.”

  • When parking requirements are set per dwelling unit rather than by size or bedrooms, developers respond by building fewer but bigger and more expensive units to avoid the implicit per-unit tax, reducing the supply of small affordable apartments—an unintended, unnoticed effect.

    “if you have more units, you have to have more parking spaces. If you have bigger units, you don't have to add parking... the way the developers responded was to build fewer, but bigger and more expensive units.”

  • LA's adaptive reuse ordinance, which let any older office building be converted to housing without new parking, produced 57 historic-building conversions and roughly 8,000 apartments in eight years—proving that the required parking, not market forces, had been preventing those conversions.

    “in the next eight years, 57 historic buildings were converted into apartments... led to something like 8,000 apartments. And they all occurred simply because the city stopped requiring off-street parking.”

0.75

Curb parking charges should be variable and set to maintain one or two open spaces per block.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Curb parking is different from other market-clearing situations because the payment is land rent—a transfer payment. Whatever the driver pays comes right back out as spending on sidewalks, trees, or wifi, so unlike a gasoline price the entire charge is rent that can be reallocated to other uses.

    “curb parking payments are land rent. It's a transfer payment. Whatever the driver pays, comes right out the other side of the meter and fixes the sidewalks”

  • Cities should charge the lowest price for curb (on-street) parking that still leaves one or two open spaces on every block, so parking is well-used but always readily available when you arrive.

    “the right things to do are first to charge the right price for on-street parking, for curb parking. And, by 'right price,' I mean the lowest price the city could charge and still have one or two open spaces on every block.”

  • Variable, location-specific pricing helps lower-income drivers because where prices once were uniform (e.g., $2 everywhere), now a driver willing to walk two or three blocks can pay 50 cents/hour instead of $3/hour right in front of the destination—giving the time-rich, money-poor an option to save money by spending time.

    “If you're willing to walk two or three blocks, you can pay 50 cents an hour rather than $3 an hour right in front of where you're going... People who are short of money and are willing to spend some time walking, they could pay 50 cents an hour.”

  • San Francisco's demand-responsive curb pricing, started in 2011, nudged prices up or down by 25 cents every three months based on occupancy; after about three years prices settled, with the average declining about 4% (essentially flat). Morning prices fell—17% of meters dropped to 50 cents/hour—filling spaces and boosting early-opening businesses, while afternoon prices rose, only about six blocks reaching the $6/hour maximum.

    “by 25 cents an hour, every three months they would change the prices... it took about three years for the prices to settle down. And, after that, the average price declined by four percent”

0.61

Parking meter revenue reinvested in neighborhood amenities makes pricing politically viable and tangibly benefits residents.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • When Shoup pitched parking reform to Ventura restaurateurs, they were uninterested in benefits like reduced air pollution or carbon emissions and instead wanted the revenue and amenities—illustrating that the persuasive lever for stakeholders is local revenue, not externality reduction.

    “they looked at me as though I was the dumbest person on earth, and they said, 'No, we want the money. We want all the amenities you're talking about.'”

  • To make curb parking charges politically popular, cities should spend all the curb parking revenue on added public services in the metered area itself—cleaning and repairing sidewalks, planting street trees—so local stakeholders see a direct benefit.

    “to make that politically popular, I recommend spending all the curb parking revenue to pay for added public services on the metered streets--to pay for cleaning the sidewalks and repairing the sidewalks.”

  • In the Pasadena case, the biggest benefit was not opening up curb spaces but the spending of the revenue—fixing sidewalks, planting trees, cleaning alleys—which turned formerly valuable land that was being given away free into a funded source of neighborhood amenities.

    “it wasn't really the open spaces on the street that made the big difference. It was the money that made the difference. It was the spending that made the difference”

  • Old Pasadena, a declined Skid Row district, was revived when the city installed parking meters and sequestered the revenue to fix sidewalks, clean alleys, and bury overhead wires; the borrowed $5 million of improvements led sales tax revenue to double within five years, with about $1.5 million/year in meter income funding amenities for 15 blocks.

    “they borrowed--it was only five million dollars--they replaced all the sidewalks and cleaned all the alleys, and put the overhead wires underground. And, immediately the sales tax revenue doubled within the next five years.”

0.61

Parking requirements hide costs bundled into consumer prices while benefiting drivers over the poor.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The only real downside of charging for parking is that drivers must pay, and since everyone wants free parking the way to win reform is to show stakeholders a personal financial incentive—to 'show people the money'—rather than rely on externality arguments.

    “You have to show people they have a personal incentive to change the rules.”

  • Parking requirements hide the cost of parking so nobody realizes they are paying anything, but the cost does not disappear—it is bundled into the prices of everything we buy, so even people too poor to own a car pay higher grocery prices so richer drivers can park free.

    “Just because the driver doesn't pay for it doesn't mean the cost goes away. The cost is still there and it's bundled into the prices for everything we buy.”

  • Many who oppose charging for parking 'to protect poor people' are pushing poor people out front like human shields; the truly poorest do not own cars, and they benefit from the public services funded by meter revenue if they walk, bike, or take transit, while genuine concern for low-income drivers can be met with lifeline discounts as exist for utilities.

    “they're just pushing poor people out in front of them like human shields, saying, 'Don't charge for parking because it will hurt poor people,' when really what they mean is that, 'Don't charge for curb parking because I'll have to pay for it.'”

  • There are enormous, largely hidden subsidies for cars in the US—oil depletion allowances, minimum street widths, minimum off-street parking requirements—which have worked out perfectly for car manufacturers and have made the public itself the constituency demanding car subsidies.

    “there are enormous subsidies for cars that are largely hidden... We have become the people who are demanding the subsidies for cars.”

0.61

Removing parking requirements enables downtown density and vitality seen in successful older cities.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Despite initial skepticism from the planning profession, cities are removing off-street parking requirements—San Francisco, Berkeley, Buffalo, Hartford, Edmonton, Houston, Mexico City, Rio de Janeiro—and possibly all of California, indicating Shoup's recommended reforms are gaining real traction.

    “Cities are removing off-street parking requirements. San Francisco, Berkeley, Buffalo, Hartford, Connecticut... Houston has removed all street parking requirements. Mexico City, Rio de Janeiro.”

  • A new business without parking only harms neighbors by free-riding on street parking when curb parking is free and crowded; if curb parking is priced correctly, customers must pay to park and the spillover problem disappears, which is why older cities like San Francisco, Boston, and Georgetown thrive with many buildings that have no parking.

    “if we get the price of curb parking right, you can't expect the, 'Oh well, they can park on the street for nothing.' They'll have to pay for parking.”

  • The difference in vitality between downtown Los Angeles and San Francisco stems not from curb-parking policy but from off-street parking requirements: LA requires on-site parking for every building while San Francisco eliminated downtown requirements ~20 years ago and capped off-street parking at 7% of a building; LA requires as a minimum 50 times more off-street parking than San Francisco allows as a maximum.

    “LA requires, as a minimum, 50 times more off-street parking than San Francisco allows as the maximum.”

  • The places people most want to visit usually do not have large parking lots; big parking lots enable free parking but create places few people want to go.

    “The big parking lots enable us to park free, but they also create places that few people want to go.”

0.19

Tokyo's model of ruthless enforcement and market-priced spaces balances car ownership with pedestrian priority.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • Tokyo has the best parking policy: it prohibits on-street parking (ruthlessly enforced at night), so you cannot own a car without proving off-street parking, while requiring very low off-street parking and permitting small market-priced 'coin parking' lots, leaving streets largely pedestrian.

    “They prohibit on street parking... So, you cannot own a car without having off-street parking. And, they have very low off-street parking requirements.”

0.15

Parking reform emerged from neglected academic terrain and is now gaining real-world traction.

3 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Parking was long considered a boring, low-status academic topic—local government being the lowest-status level and parking its lowest concern—which is why it was neglected; Shoup describes himself as a 'bottom feeder' who found abundant unexamined material there.

    “What is the lowest-status thing in local government? Well, that would be parking. So, I've been a bottom feeder for about 50 years. But there was a lot of food down there”

  • Portland piloted paying a homeowner's cost of building a new backyard granny flat in exchange for the owner allowing the city to house a formerly homeless person there for five years with full social services—a model Shoup suggests could be scaled by agencies like the Veterans Administration to house homeless veterans.

    “they would pay the owner's cost of building it in exchange for if the owner allowed the city to house a formerly homeless person in it for five years.”

  • Ventura hired nine uniformed police cadets as parking meter 'ambassadors,' and their presence on the street cut the crime level roughly in half, an unexpected benefit beyond meter management.

    “it turned out that they hired nine of them, and it turned out that the presence of the uniformed officers on the street cut the crime level by half.”