Sherry Turkle on Family, Artificial Intelligence, and the Empathy Diaries
What this covers
Sherry Turkle, MIT psychologist and author of The Empathy Diaries, speaks with Russ Roberts about her memoir and its central claims regarding technology, human relationships, and artificial intelligence. The conversation weaves together Turkle's personal history—her family's secrecy and how that shaped her into a keen observer—with broader arguments about what machines can and cannot do. Turkle contends that empathy is an active practice requiring effort, learning, and radical humility, rooted fundamentally in human vulnerability and presence. Against this stands her thesis about AI: no matter how much emergent intelligence a machine possesses, it cannot genuinely understand human experience because it has no body, was never born, and does not know mortality or touch. Machines can only pretend empathy.
The episode ranges across how technology shapes childhood development, the role of solitude versus loneliness in forming identity, the damage of family secrets versus the honesty of flawed relationships, and why friction-free design—an engineering ideal—is precisely wrong when applied to schools, businesses, and human relationships. Turkle argues that STEM fields lack frameworks from philosophy and the humanities to ask what their work is for, a gap she believes urgent. She discusses privacy as a political necessity for democracy, the particular loss when physical classrooms move virtual, and why genuine empathy between humans matters most in a divided nation. Throughout, the conversation insists that human values, not technical capability alone, should now shape technological development, and that the internet—still young—can be remade rather than passively accepted.
Turkle argues that empathy is an active, learned skill rooted in human vulnerability and presence, and that machines cannot genuinely provide it; the answer to our technological moment is to cultivate human empathy, solitude, and conversation rather than outsource them to pretending machines.
- AI can only pretend empathy because it lacks a body, mortality, and the experience of vulnerability
- Solitude is a prerequisite for self-knowledge, which is a prerequisite for genuine relationship and empathy
- Technology is still young and human values, not engineering ideals like friction-free design, must now shape it
Empathy is active practice requiring humility and listening, not machine simulation or passive feeling.
- Empathy is not a passive feeling of putting yourself in another's place and assuming you see it all; it is an active practice of radical humility that begins by admitting 'I don't know how this other person is feeling' and asking what one must do to find out—a skill that requires effort, learning, and practice.
“empathy is an active. It's an active thing. It's not just listening when it's your side and saying, 'Oh, I wonder how they're feeling.' It's listening on your side and saying, 'I don't know how they're feeling. How can I--what do I have to do to figure out how they're feeling?'”
- Because our country is divided and we need to understand people with deeply different opinions, we should be cultivating our own empathy through active listening and humility rather than chasing machine conversations that have no reason to possess empathy and will only get in our way; people are the only empathy app.
“More than ever in this country, we should be cultivating our empathy rather than chasing after something that--there's no reason that machines should have empathy and pretend empathy. We need our empathy more than ever.”
- No matter how much emergent intelligence, complexity, or 'society of mind' a machine has, it cannot genuinely understand human experience because it has no skin, was not born, never grew from vulnerability to less vulnerability, and does not know in its body what it is like to live without human touch; AI can only pretend appropriate empathic responses.
“no matter how much complexity and society of mind and emergence this machine has, it doesn't have skin. It wasn't born. It doesn't know about growing up from vulnerability to not vulnerability.”
- When Turkle tested the Replika chatbot during the pandemic by raising loneliness as her main problem, it responded that 'loneliness is warm and fuzzy,' demonstrating that such programs are not ready to address genuine human suffering and that there is no reason a program should know what human loneliness is like.
“I said, 'Well, what do you think about loneliness? That's my main problem.' Replika says, 'Loneliness is warm and fuzzy.'”
Solitude and the capacity to be alone are developmentally essential for self-knowledge and genuine relationships.
- Giving phones to young children stimulates them with the world in a way that denies them the time, space, and necessary solitude to figure out who they are, cutting off the developmental process by which they would learn to turn toward another person and give full attention.
“what phones do, particularly when you start to give them to young kids, is it cuts that process off. Because, in the very beginning, they're stimulated with the world in a way that doesn't give them time and space and that necessary solitude to really figure out who they are by themselves.”
- If you don't teach children to be alone, they will only know how to be lonely; the capacity for solitude—being content with oneself without stimulation or knowing who wants you—is what allows a person to develop self-knowledge, and without it people depend on others to tell them who they are and cannot form genuine mutual relationships.
“if you don't teach your children to be alone, they'll only know how to be lonely. It's worth just thinking about what that means. It comes originally from David Winnicott.”
- Rather than imposing arbitrary screen rules, parents should explain the reason to their children—that failing to learn to be alone will undermine the friendships they want—just as they justify homework, school, and healthy eating by their long-term payoff, and ultimately back it with parental authority.
“Take a minute to think about what's at stake, and tell your children what's at stake. That the reason you're doing this is that 'If you don't learn to just be able to be alone by yourself, you're really not going to be able to have the friendships you want.'”
Physical presence and human friction create understanding; removing them through technology diminishes learning and connection.
- Physical classrooms are a premium place for learning conversation, so moving students into virtual classrooms—even when cheaper—removes a most important venue for that skill, and even before COVID the rise of virtual blackboards and individual screen exercises had already sharply reduced the amount of talk among students who were physically together.
“if you take people out of classrooms and put them in virtual classrooms, you take away a premium place for learning conversation, a most important place for learning conversation.”
- Engineers value friction-free design as always good, but friction in human relationships is not bad—it is the moment of difference and spark that makes people understand each other, fall in love, or realize a company is onto something; applying the friction-free model to businesses, schools, and relationships is therefore always a mistake.
“one of scientists' highest values is that things should be friction-free... But, friction-free is not always good in human relationships. Friction in human relationships is what makes people understand each other”
Thought and feeling are inseparable, shaping both intellectual work and personal integrity.
- The Empathy Diaries is deliberately not a showcase of Turkle's own empathic qualities; its work depends on making the reader feel empathy for Turkle in her vulnerability, which is why she included painful, unflattering moments rather than self-congratulatory ones.
“The book isn't a show and tell of my empathy qualities. The book is my trying to write a book that can make you, that can evoke some empathy with me in my vulnerability.”
- When an Esquire profile noted the conspicuous absence of any mention of her father and implied she wore a mask despite professing that thought and feeling are one, Turkle decided the secret 'had to stop,' told her family the truth, and began the decades-long path to writing her memoir.
“I read that and I said, 'This has to stop.' And I called up my sister and brother and I told them the truth. I called up my stepfather and I said, 'This has to stop. I have to be able to speak the truth of who I am.'”
- Turkle's signature intellectual contribution is the thesis that thought and feeling are not separate but go together and must be won as one, a theme that runs through both her professional work and her decision to examine her own life.
“the theme of my work has always been that thought and feeling go together.”
- Living a daily lie about her name and parentage forced Turkle to see that next to any story claimed as true there might be another true story, training her to step outside narratives—an anthropological 'depaysement'—and turning a painful outsider status into the observational discipline that made her an ethnographer and social scientist.
“I turned this outsider status, which was so painful to me, into a kind of superpower because I taught myself the discipline of being an outsider to my own life to preserve my sanity--because I was lying every day about my name, about who I was, about who my father was.”
- Marvin Minsky argued that Bambi should never be shown to children because it teaches them that living caretakers are better than robot minders, when in the future children will bond with machines and should not be upset when living things die—a vision Turkle found chilling and from which she decisively parts ways.
“he's arguing that Bambi should never be shown to children because it'll give children the idea that you need to be a living thing, and that children shouldn't be upset when their mothers die because in the future children will be bonding with machines”
- Turkle unconsciously chose to study a psychoanalyst whose central theory was 'The Name-of-the-Father'—the very thing she was forbidden to have—which she takes as direct proof that unconscious drives shape the intellectual subjects we are drawn to.
“It was, like, total proof to the unconscious works, because the first thing I studied was a theorist who studies The Name-of-the-Father, the thing I wasn't allowed to have.”
- There is no such thing as the objectively 'best' culture or tradition; things give comfort precisely because they are yours, so the modern romance of being free to choose the best culture misses that what people actually miss is having their own.
“there's no such thing, really, as the best one. Things that give you comfort is because it's your one. And, not having your one is the thing that you miss.”
- Turkle's 1984 first book on computer culture and how computers change the way we think was a major success precisely because almost no one else was writing about people and computers at the time, making her work genuinely sui generis.
“I was the only person writing about those kinds of things... it was like sui generis. Not that many people were interested in the topic.”
Compassion for others' suffering and deprivation, not dismissal, is necessary for functioning democracy.
- The COVID experience demonstrated that tremendous technological innovation—a vaccine developed in days—is insufficient without social, political, cultural, and psychological understanding of communities and infrastructure; scientists standing alone with their miracle drug could not get it into people's arms, which required the full sweep of human and social-science knowledge.
“we've had an on-the-ground demo of how scientists standing alone, no matter how brilliant, could not do the job.”
- Many of the beliefs held by political opponents, even ones that seem crazy or based on magical thinking, are born out of tremendous deprivation, pain, and the sense of having no future, so a functioning polity requires compassion, active listening, and giving each other the benefit of the doubt rather than dismissal.
“I believe that a lot of their beliefs are borne out of tremendous deprivation... That doesn't mean I don't think they're crazy, but they're borne out of deprivation and pain, and not seeing any future”
- Science proves itself very dangerous when it fails to take into account the human question of what the science is for and why exactly we need it, because technical capability divorced from human purpose can do harm.
“science has proved itself, very, very dangerous when it didn't take the human question: is--what is the science for? why exactly do we need this? into account.”
- Just because we grew up with the Internet does not mean the Internet is all grown up; it is a world-historically new technology and there was no reason we should have gotten it right in its first twenty years, so rather than passively declaring the genie out of the bottle, now is the time to remake it according to human values.
“Just because we grew up with the Internet, it doesn't mean that the Internet is all grown up.”
Privacy and truth are foundational to human dignity, development, and political freedom.
- In Turkle's mother's generation, the idea that simply disappearing inconvenient people from a child's life was preferable to honestly addressing the truth was a common but very bad approach to raising children.
“the idea--very misguided idea--that nothing--just disappearing people--was preferable to addressing the truth, was very much abroad and a very bad way to go with children. But, it was common.”
- There is no democracy and no intimacy without privacy: if your data is scraped and you live in a surveillance society, you become afraid to speak up, and without people speaking up there can be no democracy—making privacy a political decision for human beings rather than a technical matter of friction-free programming.
“There's no democracy without privacy. There's no intimacy without privacy. If you scrape my data, I'm afraid to speak up. Without my speaking up, there's no democracy. You can't live in a surveillance society and expect it to be a democratic society.”
- An absent parent who is simply disappeared from a child's life is more psychologically damaging than the truth about a flawed parent, because absence leaves the child's mind free to imagine infinite possibility while having nothing real to ground them, removing the guardrails a growing child needs.
“your mind is free to imagine infinite freedom, infinite possibility, infinite, infinite, but you sort of have nothing. That absence allows for--that quote about 'no guardrails' is like you're unmoored when an adolescent, when a child growing up needs that sense of mooring.”