What this covers

Leon Kass, a longtime teacher of classical texts at the University of Chicago and now Dean of Faculty at Shalem College in Jerusalem, discusses Aristotle's account of human flourishing in conversation with EconTalk host Russ Roberts. Drawing on his essay from Leading a Worthy Life, Kass offers a close reading of the Nicomachean Ethics centered on how the good life emerges not from pleasure, honor, or wealth, but from the excellent activity of the soul. The conversation traces Aristotle's argument that eudaimonia—better rendered as flourishing than happiness—requires being fully at work expressing one's deepest capacities, and that character, built through habituation, makes a life beautiful and worthwhile in itself.

The discussion ranges across several dimensions of Aristotle's ethical vision. Kass distinguishes intellectual and moral virtues, explains how practical wisdom and character converge at their peak, and unpacks the concept of energeia—the Greek term for being fully engaged without impediment in any activity. A central and somewhat counterintuitive claim emerges: that Aristotle treats morality as a form of aesthetics, justifying the virtues not by their usefulness but by their beauty. The episode also addresses how Aristotle refutes relativism by displaying specimens of excellence—courage against cowardice and rashness—such that failure to see the superiority amounts to moral colorblindness. Throughout, Kass emphasizes that despite changing circumstances, the passions that enslave us remain constant, lending Aristotle's framework enduring practical value for understanding which lives are worth living.

Sharpest takeaway

Kass argues that Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics offers enduring truths about human flourishing: that the good life is not pleasure, honor, or money but excellent activity of the soul—and that character, cultivated through habituation, makes a life beautiful and worthwhile for its own sake.

  • Human flourishing (eudaimonia) is being at work expressing one's deepest capacities without impediment, not mere contentment
  • Moral virtues are acquired through practice/habituation and pursued for the sake of the beautiful, not for usefulness
  • Greatness and excellence of character can be appreciated and aspired to, and matter especially in public life and crisis

The argument · threads6 threads · 28 claims
0.80

Flourishing is an activity of the soul in excellent form, not a feeling or possession.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The Greek term energeia—coined by Aristotle—denotes being fully engaged as who you are in any activity (arts, learning, parenting, friendship), not work in the sense of toil or money-making; external rewards are secondary manifestations of success, while the activity itself is what fulfills those lucky enough to express themselves through it.

    “The word that we translate into English 'activity' is, in Greek, energeia. It's a word Aristotle made up in order to... say what he wanted to say.”

  • For Aristotle the human good is an activity of the soul in accordance with excellence: flourishing requires being at work using one's deepest powers, not merely possessing a capacity; a basketball player flourishes only during the game, and contentment follows upon and is colored by the activity rather than being separable from it.

    “the human good is an activity of the soul in accordance with excellence. And that means being at work: not just having a virtue and not exercising it”

  • Since 'useful' always points to being useful for something else, an infinite regress of instrumental justification requires some ultimate end that is for its own sake; Aristotle suggests life itself, and flourishing, is for itself—so meaningful and fulfilling activities are not always useful-for something beyond them, and a good account of one's time is one spent in activity meaningful in itself.

    “If everything is useful for something else, what is the ultimate useful-for, that's not useful for, but is for itself? Aristotle is trying to suggest that life is ultimately for itself, and it's to flourish in and for itself.”

  • The fullest activity occurs when one is at work without impediment—without distraction, self-consciousness, or felt obstacles—so that the activity and the agent are united; if you focus on the pleasure you don't get it, but if you give yourself over to the activity, the pleasure lights up in consciousness as it goes well.

    “this is what it really means to be at work fully yourself without impediment. And the pleasure just follows. If you're thinking about the pleasure, you don't get it. If you give yourself over to the activity, that activity lights itself up in consciousness as it's going swimmingly.”

  • Eudaimonia is better translated as 'flourishing' than 'happiness' because modern happiness reduces to contentment—a good feeling about oneself—whereas Aristotle's concept is the blossoming of the deepest aspects of our humanity in excellent form.

    “the human good is an activity of the soul in accordance with excellence. And that means being at work: not just having a virtue and not exercising it”

0.75

Virtue is acquired through habituation, practice, and good upbringing, not instruction.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • A habit is an 'acquired freedom': through habituation, praise, blame, reward, and punishment—as in toilet training—what once required struggle becomes effortless, so that one need not worry about the impediments that would otherwise block living well, freeing one to take command of one's own chariot.

    “the very first example of education to control your impulses, is toilet training... It's an acquired freedom: You don't have to worry about that stuff; you know what to do with it; you don't think about it.”

  • The virtues are acquired not by being told the right maxims but through practice: one becomes better at facing fears and uncertainties by repeatedly doing the difficult things, so that mastering inner impediments frees one to display care, courage, and thoughtfulness more fully over time.

    “you do it better now because one learns to do these things, as Aristotle says, by doing them. It's the practice of facing these fears, or these uncertainties, which is the only way one gets experience in overcoming them and being able to do better.”

  • Aristotle's ethics presupposes that readers have been brought up well, already grasping that the noble and just things are good; Kass came to doubt that contemporary students are in the same place as when he began teaching, leading him to question whether they need other texts and whether Aristotle leaves out things that matter.

    “Aristotle presupposes that we've all been brought up well. It's not so obvious to me that we are the same place as we were when I started teaching.”

  • Aristotle warns that young people are not fit students for ethics because they are led by their passions and lack experience; to be a good student one must already be well brought up and sense that the noble and just things are good, then learn why.

    “young people are not fit here, as for this subject: they're led by their passions, they don't have much experience. In order to be a good student of this class, this book, you got to be well brought up”

0.71

Character is the core of ethics, grounded in identifying and cultivating excellence over vice.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Aristotle uniquely never justifies the virtues of character by their usefulness to others—not even military courage by the safety of the city—but presents them as being for the sake of the beautiful or noble, treating the moral life as a species of aesthetics whose goal is to make oneself a beautiful human being, satisfying in itself rather than for what it leads to.

    “He never talks about their usefulness to anybody else, even in talking about courage, even military courage; he doesn't talk about its usefulness to the safety of the city. He'll talk about these moral virtues as being for the sake of the beautiful or the noble.”

  • The word 'ethics' derives from the Greek ethos meaning character, so ethics is technically about characters—better and worse, finer and less fine—rather than about right and wrong, benefits and harms, or duties and rights; Aristotle's book surprised Kass by being about character rather than a rational deductive ethics.

    “The word 'ethics,' by the way, comes from a Greek word ethos, which means character. Ethics, technically speaking, is about the characters: better and worse, finer, and less fine.”

  • Aristotle is the first to distinguish excellences of intellect (scientific excellence, artistic know-how, practical wisdom, philosophical wisdom) from virtues of character (courage, moderation, generosity, gentleness, friendliness, truthfulness, wit, greatness of soul), where the moral virtues govern the appetites and passions that could enslave us.

    “he makes a distinction--he's the first to distinguish these things--between the excellences of intellect... Scientific excellence, artistic know-how, practical wisdom, philosophical wisdom... But the virtues of character, or the moral virtues... courage, moderation, generosity, gentleness, friendliness, truthfulness, wit, and one of the big ones... greatness of soul”

  • Character counts more than intellectual brilliance—as C.S. Lewis said, he would rather play cards with a man skeptical about ethics but raised to believe a gentleman doesn't cheat than with one who could prove the existence of God but was raised by sharpers.

    “C.S. Lewis has a nice line: he would 'rather play cards with a man who was very skeptical about ethics, but was brought up to believe that a gentleman doesn't cheat, than by a guy who could give you the ontological proof of the existence of God, but was raised by sharpers.'”

  • Aristotle refutes the relativist claim that virtue is all relative by displaying polished specimens of the virtues alongside their excesses and deficiencies; if one cannot tell that courage is better than cowardice or rashness, or generosity better than miserliness or prodigality, one is the moral equivalent of red-green colorblind.

    “if you can't tell that courage is better than cowardice or rashness, or that moderation is better than being an ascetic or being a profligate... there's something the matter with you. You're the equivalent of morally red-green colorblind.”

  • Contrary to the claim that moral character is hidden behind closed doors, character shows in public life and in nearly every human encounter—in how someone treats a handicapped dinner guest, in a faculty meeting, in how one treats students, in whether one has the intellectual courage to stand up when everyone else goes along—if you know how to look for it and care about it.

    “Character shows in public life; and it's on the stage, even though people try to disguise it. But, character shows in all kinds of ways... in all human relations, if you know how to look for it, and if you care about it, you will see it.”

0.38

Intellectual and moral virtues converge and reinforce each other at their peak.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Though initially distinct, intellectual and moral virtues converge at their peak: you cannot do well in physics while drunk or on drugs (intellect needs some virtues of character), and you cannot be ethically excellent with only good intentions if your judgment is poor and imprudent (character needs practical wisdom).

    “the virtues of intellect need at least some virtues of character. You can't be drunk or on drugs all the time and do very well in physics. And, conversely, you can't really be ethically excellent in the best sense, if all you have are good intentions, but your judgment is terrible, and you're imprudent”

  • The motion of the Ethics leads the reader, through self-examination, to conclude that the truly best life is not that of the well-known citizen but the life of learning, thinking, and understanding—also pursued for its own sake—offering the distinct fulfillment that comes from understanding something.

    “the really best life is in fact, not the life of being a well-known citizen in town, but in fact, a life of learning and thinking and understanding of the sort that we're engaged in with his help in this book.”

0.34

Slow engagement with foundational texts and admiration of genuine excellence shape one's life.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The friendship of sharing thoughts and speeches may be the most durable kind of friendship because sharing such goods does not diminish one's own portion but may increase it, so partners grow together through conversation rather than depleting a finite resource.

    “the friendship of sharing thoughts and speeches might be the most durable kind of friendship, because you're having more, does not diminish mine, but in fact, might increase it, and we might grow together through conversations like this.”

  • Unlike Plato who wrote Socratic dialogues in others' names, Aristotle wrote treatises in his own name on nearly every conceivable subject—the history and parts of animals, logic, rhetoric, ethics, physics, metaphysics—undertaking to give an account of everything humanly thinkable.

    “Aristotle wrote what are thought to be treatises in his own name, on just about every conceivable subject... He really undertook to give an account of just about everything that was humanly thinkable.”

  • Reading slowly and spending time with the best foundational texts—rather than reading many books or contemporary articles—yields greater, more durable value; Kass attributes his life's work to having read very few books well, living with them and letting them inform him.

    “I haven't read very many books in my life well. But, I was lucky in what I picked. And I lived with them, and they've informed me. And I think I've shown a whole bunch of students that if you read slowly, and spend time with what's best, you won't be sorry.”

  • Being in touch with and admiring genuine greatness and excellence pays tribute to the appreciator as much as to the excellent one—as 'taste is to genius,' one Mozart produces many Mozart-lovers, and the capacity to appreciate excellence does a world of good to those who can appreciate it, lifting the whole tone of life.

    “to be in touch with greatness, to admire it, to really admire excellence, pays tribute also to the appreciator as much as it does to the ones who are excellent. It's like taste 'tis to genius. One Mozart, lots of Mozart lovers”

0.29

Human nature displays persistent passions and distinguishing ruling passions across lives.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • People are distinguished by the dominant ruling passion of their soul, revealing three or four basic lives: the life of pleasure/fun, the life of honor and recognition, the life of learning/understanding, and the life of money-making—though money cannot be the good life since it is only a means to other ends.

    “if you don't want to just listen to the opinions, but you look at how they live their lives and discern from the lives that they lead, what they think human flourishing is, it turns out that basically, there are three or four lives.”

  • Although circumstances and times change, certain fundamental features of human nature remain the same—the passions that enslave us from within (fear, lust, miserliness, anger) are permanent possibilities of human beings—so Aristotle's ethics still has practical value today.

    “times have changed, circumstances change, but there's certain fundamental things about human nature that might remain the same. The obstacles to living well, in terms of the passions that enslave us from within, are still with us.”

  • Even in democratic times, crises may arise requiring someone better than the ordinary; the example of Winston Churchill arriving just in time in May 1940 shows that the distinction between greatness and smallness is never irrelevant to who governs and leads, and teachers have a duty to show students that distinction so they are not lost when it becomes crucial.

    “in democratic times, there might come crises in which we might have a need for someone who is better than the ordinary. And I give them the example of Winston Churchill, happening to arrive just in time, in May of 1940.”